뺽ؼ
MISSILES AND SPACE VEHICLES
1999 2ڡNo.2 1999



ϵͳԼ
ϵ
ժҪ˶ԸӿϵͳʵʩԵıҪԡԵĹ϶λɿȺ;߿ɿȡϵͳԭϵͳб⡣ҪһȽƵϵͳƼӦ
ʡ༼ɿԣԼ
Redundant Test and Measurement Technique
of Control System
Yan Dianqi
(Beijing Aerospace Automatic Control Institute,100854)
AbstractThe necessity of redundant test and measurement to complex control system, the reliability of fault location and decision of redundant test and measurement, and the principle and key techniques of redundant test and measurement system design are described. The design and application of a perfect redundant test and measurement system are briefly introduced at the end of the paper.
Key WordsRedundancy techniques, Reliability, Measuring technique.
1ϵͳԼıҪ
1.1Լϵͳ
һϵͳһͨвУܹͬʱȡϵĲԽݵķΪԷʵԷļΪԼϸظԵķʽȡϲݵĸ䱾ڡͬʱȡáͬ͡ʱȡá
ҪͬʱȡϵĲԽݣͱϵĶϵͳʵʹУЩϵͳΪϵͳϵͳΪһԷϵͳҪȫʩеķزҪɻԪɣԲȡֲ༼õ㹻ĿɿԣԱϵͳӴӡڲԲ֣þֲ෴Ƚѣϵͳ༼ȴȽʵ֡
һѿϵͳй״̬ơװλͲݲɼжȫ뷢عܵġԷϵͳΪϵͳֻǾݲɼ¼жȲԹܵĵ23ϵͳΪϵͳϵͳʵϣһػ򵼵ϵͳȸϵͳһϵͳ㹻ˡˣ粻ر˵ϵͳָ2ϵͳ
1.2ϵͳԼıҪԺԽ
ϵͳԵĻĿжһǵϵͳĹܼܲʱϵͳܹɿĿ϶жߣǵϵͳʱʱϵͳϼϵͳλȷڲȡһķʩҪɿ񣬶һϵͳ˵ԭ򣬲ԼʮֱҪġ
 ػϵͳзн죬ͻᵼ·ʧܣʧǾ޴ġ˵ֵǻһ󱦹սˣϵͳԽоͷװУ۵ȣֻһһϵͳĴʶǸеġֻоһ;ҲܵõͬĽǲŸеȷˡֹûֶε£ֻò˹У͸ıطʽɣͻĸţɿǱȽϲġңڴݣҲ޷ٶȷҪǶϵͳɼڲԹУΪѸٿɿض״̬ܲϵͳжϺ;ߣҪһ2ϵͳӦܹϵͳвԵͬʱԱϵͳͬһϢʵʩݲɼԶжĽݡ£ݡ33׼ϵͳжߣ¼ƾߣ潫֤ľߣɿǺܸߵġ
ν33׼ָϵͳжĽݡϵͳжĽ뱻ֵϣƫڣʱΪò
зʱҪȷϵͳϲλҪŪԭڱϵͳڲϵͳΪˣûϵͳ£ͱظԷֹϣΪ˱ϲλԹߣͨǱϡ
ԪʧЧĳפ͹ϣͨ²ֹܹͨҪķ飬ҲŪϲλǺԣԽ϶ĸΪۣҪϵͳʱΪۡһЩ޵Ԫ˵ƽ̨ŷȣʱԳܵġ
ĳЩȶԭĳǱ״̬ķǳפ͹ϣôʹۣҲһֹܸҲ޷ȷϵԭͲλʹԹʱòСáʽĴظֹϣǸֲֻܸݷƶϵġԭ򡱻ڣȡԲǿνۺʩشĴۡȻһϵͳĸϵͳ˵ͬһɵԭȴͬһЩͨƶǿʶġһЩεԭȴһʶ£ʩопûδʶԭĴʩδʶԭϵҪԭʮΣյġ
£ԼԽԾԵʮͻˣΪԼͬظԣҲҪظԣϵͳвԲĹУȫʵʱزɼͬһݣӦݴжóݵġһ˹رǷǳפ͹ϣȥ൱ɿʵϵͳ϶λһΪϵͳϵͳԵĽһ£뱻ֵһ(ʱԭӦڱϵͳϵͳĲԽ뱻ֵһ(ƫڣϵͳĲԽ뱻ֵ(ʱΪԭϵͳϵͳĲԽ뱻ֵϵͳĲԽ뱻ֵʱΪԭӦϵͳϹ϶λ(¼ƶλԭҲΪ13׼
ʵ֤ԼʵϵͳĹ϶λرǶһϵͳķǳפ͹ϵĶλرҪã˵Ī
ϵͳ롢˲Ե㲢пеĲʱϵͳġ13λ׼϶λȻҲЧġϵͳĴͲǾ߱ġ13׼й϶λ൱ߵĿɿȡˣԼϵͳάԺͷпɿԾЧ
Ȼһ򵥵ĲԶһֱõĲԹǼ򵥿ɿģһѿ߾ˣһϵͳԼȻûбҪػ򵼵ϵͳĸӲԶȫͬĿۺԺܸߣжϵͳȫ(иϵͳμӡЩĿʱܳٶȼƵԡвԡܼԵȣĿػϵͳеزռԽԽıΪֻ߲ٶȣ̷׼ʱ䡣һЩǳפ͹ҪҲЩ͵Ĳ״̬зԼһ˹ϣرǷǳפ͹ϽѶλ̸ϿάޡΪ˸ֹϺͷϸĴ۾͸Ϊ޴ˣȫϵͳȫϵͳЭͬеۺԲ״̬ԽԽΪҪ״̬£ԼҲ͸Ҫ
2ϵͳʱľߺͶλĿɿԷ
ԷԽԣ˵˾ߺ͹϶λĿɿԡ˶?Ȩ⹤̷ʱ˽ġ½ͨйؿɿȶģ˵⡣
2.1һϵͳľߺͶλɿȶģ
Ϊ˶Աȷ۾ϵͳĲϵͳľ߿ɿȺͶλɿȵĶģ֮ǰ۵һϵͳľ߿ɿȺͶλɿȶģ⡣
2.1.1һϵͳľ߿ɿȶģ
һϵͳľ׼ǣԽ뱻ֵʱΪϵͳ롰33׼ƣɳΪ22׼ɿȱʽдΪ
P1j=1-1j(1)

ʽСP1jһϵͳ߿ɿȣ
1jһϵͳ߸ʡ
νߣָʵϲϸ񣬶ԵĽȴǺϸġָԱݺϸݽжȻóĽֽۡȥһжߡ
ɾߴ󣬱Ȼ3¼ͬʱ
a) ϵͳ˹ϣĳ䷢Ϊ1
b) ϵͳ˹(ݴж󣩣ܷӳʵʽ䷢Ϊ2
c) ϵͳϵЧ뱻ϵͳϵЧպϻΪ䷢Ϊ33¼ͬʱĸʾǦ1j
1j123
Ϊֻۦ1=2=3=ʱ
1j=3
ʽ1
P1j=1-3(2)

P=1-ãڦã1ԣ3áP1jP
ɼһϵͳľ߿ɿȸڲϵͳĿɿȣҲڱϵͳĿɿȣߵĸϵͳϵĸʱȽΪС
2.1.2һϵͳĶλɿ
ڵһϵͳĶλɿȣ12Ѿ˵ˣԷֲʱָԭĸϵͳ£϶λһֻӲһһ泯ϵĸʾΪ0.5ˣһϵͳĶλɿΪ
P100.5(3)

ʽСP10һϵͳĶλɿȡ
2.2ϵͳʱϵͳľ߿ɿȺͶλɿȶģ
2.2.1߿ɿȶģ
ϵͳʱ33׼ߣ跢ߵĸΪ2jʵϾи¼ͬʱĸʣ
a) ϵͳйϣʹʵϲϸ䷢Ϊ1
b) ϵͳϣȷزñֵ䷢Ϊ2
c) ϵͳĹЧ뱻ϵͳĹЧǡûΪ䷢Ϊ3
d) ϵͳ϶ȷزʵֵ䷢Ϊ4
e) ϵͳϺ뱻ϵͳϺǡûΪ䷢ĸΪ5ǣ
2j=12345
1=2=3=4=5=ã
(4)

ʽСP2jϵͳĲϵͳľ߿ɿȡ
ɼϵͳĲϵͳ߿ɿҪڵһϵͳľ߿ɿȡߵĸϵͳĹϸΪСã0.1ʱɿҪ9
P1j=1-3=0.999
P2j=1-5=0.999 99
2.2.2ϵͳĲϵͳλɿȶģ
ϵͳĲϵͳĶλɿģͬԴӷλ¼ĸʦ2dõ2dиͬʱĶ¼ĸ֮ͣ
aж¼ͬʱʱλ
1) ϵͳĹϵ±ʵϲϸΪ1
2) ϵͳĹϲزʵֵΪ2
3) ϵͳЧͱϵͳĹЧǡ뻥ಹΪ3
4) ϵͳ޹ϣȷز˱ʵֵΪPϵͳĿɿȣ
£1 3׼й϶λȻذѹԭĲλϵͳȻǴĶλ
bж¼ͬʱʱҲλ
1) ϵͳϣʹʵֵϸΪ1
2) ϵͳ˹ϣȷزʵֵΪ4
3) ϵͳĹЧ뱻ϵͳЧǡΪಹΪ5
4) ϵͳ޹ϣȷز˱ʵֵΪPϵͳĿɿȣ
£13׼λͻΪԭĲλϵͳλ
cж¼ͬʱʱַλ
1) ϵͳ޹ϣ䱻ǺϸģΪPϵͳĿɿȣ
2) ϵͳ˹ϣȷزʵֵΪ2
3) ϵͳ˹ϣȷزʵֵΪ4
4) ϵͳĹЧϵͳĹЧͬߵĲԽΪ6
ڴ£13׼򣬻Ὣϲλ󶨵ϵͳ
3ֻҪһַͻᷢλ֮ǻĹϵλĸʦ2dӦΪ3¼֮ͣΪۼ򵥣3¼෴ݵģ
2d123P145P246P
Ȼ1=2==6=ãʽ

2d=3P3
P2d=1-2d=1-3P3(5)

ʽСP2dϵͳĲϵͳλɿȡ
ȡP=0.9ã0.1ʱʽ5ɵ
P2d0.997 3
ɼϵͳʱ϶λɿ൱ߵġ˵Ӿ߿ɿȽϣԼЧʮͻĻôӹ϶λĿɿȽϣԼЧͷǳͻǲԼص㣬ȡģʾ˼Խԡ
3ϵͳƵһԭ
ϵͳƣһӦѭԭ
3.1
ϵͳƣעԡνԣָϵͳԣӲӦȫķ·ԪȷҪϵͳͬɲͬƵλеϵͳƺڱֶ֤һЧʩ
ֻбϵͳĶԣܱͬһֹػͬʱϵͳϵͳʹϵͳϵ¼жʡǶ¼ڵ2Ŀɿģ͵ĻҲͲˡڿɿԷͺѷˡ룬һϵͳͬͬͬӲͬƵλͬϵͳȻʹϵͳͬʱͬʵĹϸʱԵĸߡ£ϵͳߺͶλɿ˻ǽˣʱǺжϵġˣϵͳϵͳ뱣޶ȵĶԡ
3.2߿ɿ
ڽɿģʱΪ˼򵥣ϵͳϵͳĿɿͬġʵУϵͳҪÿɿԸߵķΪˣѡõķ򵥡졢ʵ֡׿ɿܸӣ豸ֲܶ࣬죬пĹʺܸߣʹܵĿɿ߲½Ūɳ׾ΧڣԷһ㾫Ҫ󣬶ﵽ߿ɿ
3.3
ϵͳܵƣӦֿǵϵͳĻԡ¼ĻӡʾĻģʾʾĻȵȡڱҲϵͳ˴˱ָߵĶԵһ档߻ԣҲ˾ߵĿɿԻλĿɿԣͬʱҲ˲ϵͳ幦ܡ
4ϵͳʱļؼ
ᵽ4ԭҲǼ⣬ʼע᳹Ǿļؼ⡣ҪʹϵͳܹʵϵͳԵͬʱͬһݽвɼӰԵĿɿԣرǵһϵͳ˹ʱҲӰһϵͳ3ؼ⡣
4.1ʵ¼ȡӿ˫ϵͳ
Ҫʵϵͳͬʱɼͬһݣй¼ȡӿڱĳַʽʵֲֻܱ֤ϵͳͬʱ¼ȡͬһݡǿκ÷ʱķʽݵķϵͳӿ·ʵΥҪġΪΥͬʱɼͬһݵԭ
4.2ϵͳϵͳͬ
ʽĽӿֻṩϢͨ·Ҫʵϵͳͬʱɼͬһݣϵͳͬ⣬ؼͬʱ¼ȡļΪʵ˽ӿڲʽͬʱ͡ʵѾõ
ɼԺĴʶȹϵͳҪС
ϵͳͬ⣬ӲҲֹּƻϵͳĶԣֹϵͳĳһֲġĹʽ򣬾Υ˶ԭ򣬾ͻήͿɿԡⷽ棬ͨʵͬн϶ԽԣʵҲȽס
4.3ЧϵͳӿӲĹϹ
νϹָϵͳֹϺ󣬲ΣϵͳΣϵͳ磬ϵͳӿڳ˶·ģʽϣջϵͳӿڻ˥ϵͳźšϵͳһϣ˱ϵͳߵϵͳҲɲ󣬾ͽϹֹԭΪԭ
ֹԭ򣬾ʵƻ˶ԭ򡣹ԭԽ࣬ɿԾԽͣϵͳ󣬿ɿԽϵһϵͳˣǽˣȨ⡣
ķǣԲӿڵӲʧЧģʽΣȷ(FMECAÿγɹԭĹģʽȡЧֹʩһϵͳϵͳϸȫؽСȻҪÿģʽȫԭʱǼΪѵġǣҪ͹ԭǿġ磬·ģʽӣ·ϲȡʩ֮󣨵ȻҪ֤ϵͳ֮ƥЭԣͿԽ䷢ĸʽΪСΪֻԪͬʱ·γɹԭ
5ϵͳʵ

ͼ1ϵͳʵԭͼ
Ϊʵ¶ͼ1ʾϵͳķԼӦмҪܡ
5.1
ϵͳϸع᳹ϵͳƵ3ԭ
ݱʣϵͳ󲿷ɣж塢ʱ䡢ָԲĲԻУ鹦ܣؼԪԺͷõļϵͳһ廯ơӲʱָӿںͼͨѶӿл·(ӿ)棬ϵͳƵҪһ廯γ˼˵ԪԺ֧ȫϵͳԵӦϵͳ
ӿл·Ĺǵϵͳڷǰ϶ֲά޻Ľ£ԽԭϵͳĵأͨѶļӿлϵͳĵأͨѶӿڣͬʱжϵͳļӿڡ״̬£ϵͳɶԼʵʩװУͲԵȶϵͳķֶϣγһӦ״̬ڲϵ£ɷһֹܶ߷ɿԾش塣
ӿлװõĵ2ǣϵͳһԭ򣨾ܷĸѶСڹϷΪĳҪʱжӿڡԭıôʩֻڷǰĽ»Ϊ֤ĳַλʱʹá
ʱʱָӿڲֱӲķʽָڽͨϿʱġЧӦĹܡͬʱϵͳƵҪڸ·ӿоӦֵ൱ָѹֵֵӿܹӦʱָζŸʱָѹֵֵޣǺϸġΪ˼ϵͳڲʹٶȷìܣʹòPCΪϵͳķʵ֣˳ɱ˿ɿԡ
һֲԲݷ࣬ݴͷʶУأԵҪ֡ؼĵԪԷԼһ廯ͳһǣʹרΪӵӲرӲ豸١һӲɼؼƵλе񣬴Ӹϱ֤·ơԪѡ͡Ƶȸ涼ϵͳźܺõĶԡ
ϵͳĵ2̬ϵͳ³˿ϵͳܲԴϵͳҪƵġû˿ϵͳģϵͳҪܲΪѹģʽڷйҲ仯ʽеġԴȫƣֻһ仯Ϊ0ģ仯ģߵӸϷⲿֲĲԣǶԸݵĲԣҲӦð״һЩĲԣɹ̲ΡϵͳЩģȴֻܽиݵĲԡݻԭͿɿԭһֵĻ豸ѡ¼豸˸߿ɿı¼Ⱥ
ͼ1еģӿڵĹҪǽźתΪֱźšͽεԴѹźžͨ任ɱ¼ǿɼ¼ֱźŵġֱѹźžȡֱӲķʽ
5.2ʵϵͳĹ
ʵϵͳȻ豸٣ܺǿƵϵͳĸֲϵͳܼ״̬£Ƶϵͳڵ͹ػݡʱ򣨺ػʱݡʱָݡݡƽ̨ٶȼݵݽвɼʶжڷʱͨϵͳϵͳװķݽУڱʱɵһϵͳ״̬µװУ飬֤װеķݵȷԡģԲֿԶ˿ϵͳ33ܲƵϵͳ·źšʱϵͳ·ʱźšϵͳ3ĵѹ˿ϵͳ׼ŵѹԼ5м¼
⣬ڱ״̬£ϵͳеֶ豸ϣԿϵͳƹܽм飬ݾڵһϵͳ״̬£ɡҲʱһһϵͳ״ֶ̬ԶϵĲԷϵͳӦԵɷ
ʵϣֱ״̬ҲӦõԣЧͬڱ䡣ЧӦ񣬶ӦڲʱĿɹϷ붨λ񣬿ɸʵҪѡĿ״̬Ǳϵͳ⹦ܡ
5.3ʵϵͳӦ
ϵͳʵӦʾҪúЧ
ݡ13λ׼ٶﲻϣʱ䳤⣨һַǳѸֵķǳפ͹ϣһζλ飬֤λȷҲܼзʱָźûзĹϣһζλ洫£֤µĽӵͷĽӵ䲻һ£ûоϵͳ飬˶λʡʱ豸
עǣڵЧյ豸ʱϵͳղʱָϵͳݡ13λ׼򣬳λȻϵͳйϡû⣬λλϵͳйʹʵϲϸϵͳйʹ֮ܿ͹۵زʵֵϵͳЧӦ뱻ϵͳЧӦϵͳ˹ϲʵֵѾ֤һ֮ȥ֤ǰ3ʱȫϡǳε⡪Чʱָ迹Чʱָ˥úСֻ8 Vźţʹϵͳ¼ȡϵͳʱָӿֵòҪ󣬱Ҫֵͺܶ࣬ڱ˥˵źֵֻ6 VżƽϵͳԿ¼ȡЧӦΪʹϵͳΪϸ
һ˵һҪ⣬ǲԼݡ13λ׼λһͨΪǲԼк棬ʵһ⹦ܣֹܿԷ⡣ΪûϵͳûУͷֲһ⣬ҪڱϵͳͲϵͳŹϻ½вԷ䣬УǺΣյġ
ӦøϵͳʹصĲԽжͽŵķװУ鹤˹ΪȫԶá33׼򣬿ɿݡ
֮ϵͳʵӦУѾɹβԷ붨λУδѾھߺͶλʾ˾޴ãܵǵӡ֤ԼһֵýһơչӦõҪ̼
ߵλϵ(Զо100854)
ο
[1]Ƚ¡. ػԷ乤ѧ. , 1989-05.
[2]Nancey R Mann, Ray E Schafer, Nozer D Singrur Walla. Methods for statistical analysis of relibility and life data. John Wiley & Sons Inc, 1974.
ոڣ1998-06-05
