뺽ؼ
MISSILES AND SPACE VEHICLES
1999 3ڡNo.3 1999



Է뵼ϵͳķ

ժҪ˹Ϸоĸͷݶ̬ϵͳص㣬оΪ̬ܼͶ̬ܼ飬ص˻Ƶ׹ƵĶ̬һԼ鷽Ȼ˵ϵͳоľ˼ͷһ
ʡģ⣬+Ƶ׹ơ
Simulation Credibility Analysis Method
and Its Application to Missile System
Li Pengbo
(National Univ. of Defense TechnologyChangsha410073)
AbstractThe concepts and methods of foreign research on simulation credibility are introduced. On the basis of the characteristics of dynamic system simulation, its credibility analysis is divided into two parts: static consistence test and dynamic consistence test, and the method of dynamic consistence test by spectrum analysis is emphatically discussed. Then, specific methodology of the research on simulation credibility of missile system is analyzed, and a technology project is given.
Key WordsSimulation, Guided missile, Spectrum estimation.
1ǰ
漼һֱڵϵͳзҪáż缼ý弼ķչ漼ڷֶϵԲϴ£ԱǵĹע10漼ܵȷҵĸ߶ӣһֱѷ漼ΪؼƻصĿˡģ泫顱׼ˡģƻ齨ˡģ칫ҡµĽģͶսԡ1996ꡰƻУѧ뼼չ10ؼļƻaƽ̨b˼c)Ϣϵͳ뼼d泵뽢ͧe빤գfҽѧѧg豸սռ价hƽ̨i˻ϵͳj10ýģ漼Ϊߣָ֧ɰ졢顢ά֡սЧѵͼƻƷĽȹ1994ꡰģָй涨˹ߣмͶʴٽDODDepartment of Defense M&SModeling and SimulationߣMSϢģDODŽ֤ȷ϶VVA(Validation Verification and AccreditationߺDODŹMSӦõĹ̵ȡϿɿڷ漼ѲڼϵͳƣչչϵͳȫڡپƲΪһоֶΣǳרŵĹߺʽӺ֧֡
ѾӴͳġ顪顱ģ͡桪顪ת䣬ǽģͣη棬Ȼ飬ģ֮ͣΪ桢̡ͨһ̣ҪһܹȷϵͳʵŶȵģͣԤϵͳܡսЧܺսԣΪɰѵԱṩ֧֡ɼ漼ķչʹıΪܣʹϵͳװսʹöʵģʵ֡
ʣ漼ǵϵͳͺơװսʹԼĽƵҪֶΡϵͳǶʵϵͳʵķӳܷӳʵϵͳķûġŵǰȷķģͣҪѧģʵϵͳ̺ѧϵҲ˵ǿŵģԷϵͳпоϳΪ֤ȷ϶VVAҲӡ
 ڷоǿǼǿģ͵ĹУҪϸļ׼͹淶Ƶ֯ͼලڼϲ̷ʵֶʵϵͳʵԷӳ̶ȡӦԴӣעǵʵһЩҪǿ漼оҪǿԵоڼƶͣܣڣʡԼѶҪ塣
2оĻ
ģͺͷ棨MS)ζȣCredibilityۣǷ̱زٵҪɲ֡ζȵĹ̳ΪŶConfidence AssessmentŶҪa) ģ͵֤ȷϣVVValidation and Verificationģ֤һ̣ȷģ͵ļʵǷ׼ȷرʾģͿ߶ϵͳĸģȷҲһ̣ԤӦõĽǶȷģͱʵϵͳ׼ȷ̶ȡb) 汾CMConfiguration Management϶(AccreditationģͰ汾һƶȣӦü͹ϵļලֶΣģ͵ĹдӦıȻ󣬼ģı仯Щ仯дıӦı档ģ϶һŲĳһģ͵ȨԾȨԻϿģĳһضĿġϹһͳΪģ֤ȷϺ϶
ϷԵĸͶʶоһ·
2.1ģͼ
ģУһӶ޵Ĺ漰ܶ൥λͲţӦ֯齨ģУĹȷλΣ֯Эûܵ֯ʩģУ鹤޷չġ
2.2ģ֤
ģ֤ԷģеģĿ֤ʵʵϵͳģ͵֮תȷģ򵥵˵Ǽ޴1994꣬Balciģ֤ĸַࡣԭϽ֤ڷֻ֤Ǹַʵüֵͬ
2.3ģȷϷ
ģȷϵĿǼģ͵ЧԡģЧһͨڸ¼ģͣԤڵӦĿǷһľҪʵ֡ģ;ǹģͽȷԵĶֵڸϵͳģͣҪ֤ȷԻõ侫ȣʮܵġģЧģͿԵĶʵӦĿġҪûйءģЧԵĶֵģͿŶʾϵͳģͿŶȵǺѵģֻܶͨ۵õģ͵ĿŶȡģЧһӦĿļӦʵԵġʱģͺʵʣοϵͳʵӦͬġʵ趨̶ܴȡӦĿġģ;ǷҪҲӦĿйء1994꣬SargentģȷϵķҪͼԷȷԷͳƼ鷨ЧԼȡ
2.4ı
ģͼıģıǸһĹ淶ģ͡VVAģı淶дģıģıԽģ̽пƵḶ́ΪģıģͿĹУͨдģıԼģ߶ģ͵ʶģ͵ĲȫԡȷԺͲһԣMSĹ淶̶ȡЩģӴݸӡڳҪλͬķģͣд淶ģıȿԹģԼģֿΪЭԱĲοϣģͿ̵Эͳһ
3оĶ
оֱӵķͬ½ĽͬŵĽԵԣĽȫϵͳıȽϣǷһԼһԵĳ̶ȡڶ̬ϵͳģ͵ļ飬̬ͨϵͳģͬĳʼµĶη棬ͬһģ¶ʱлͬһĶЩԻùֲԣȻŵĽһԼ顣ͷǷͬһ壬Ϳжģ͵Ŀԡԣϵͳ̬ܲܣͶ̬ܣУˣԼķ̬һԼͶ̬һԼ顣
31̬һԼ鷽
̬Ƿྲ̬ĳƵεյƫѰɱ˸ʵȣΪʵͨͳƷֵ׼ȷȣɢܼȣͬ£Ի÷ͷ̬һԼʵʾǼǷͬһ壬ɸݼ鷽ķֲΪFۣ
a ǲFȫδ֪ʱڴ£Kolmogorov-Smirnov飻С£WilcoxonȺͼ顢ȡڵ٣Ⱥͼ顣n1 n2ֱͬµķͷһ˵n1n2һϴ󣨴20һС20ȱȺͼĸʷֲôBootstrap⡣ʵϣXX1Xn1ϴ󣬶Y=Y1Yn2Сn2СʱBootstrapСY1Yn2ֲFy)Monte-Car1oFy)гFy)ΪֲY1Y2YNN1ΪWilcoxonXYǷΪݣԴXYԼ顣
b F̬裬F״ֻڸֵͷõĲͳƷ顢ơƶһԼ顣
1) ơ裨x1x2xnΪ̬Ṇ2һ̺ͦ2δֵ֪ͷ̵ֵ1001-)%䡣ĳһַ£̡Ŀԡ򻷾Żȣֻһη飬ظΡԷѰƣɷѰǷжϷĿԡ
2) 顣Ѽٶеλ÷ֲ̬裨x1x2xn1ͣy1y2yn2ֱзͷx2N121y2N222F̬巽һԣtֵ̬һԡ
32̬һԼ鷽
̬絼Ĺء̬ʡϵͳȹ̲仯ǸӵģһԼҲȽѡƵ׹Ʒж̬һԼ飬ȡ˽ϺõЧʵʷͷлõһϵвʱУҪ˽ʵϵͳģ̶ȣģ͵ĿŶȣǼʱеһԡʱͬһ壬˵ڸˮƽ£ͷĽһµġ
ͬķ£ʵΪһx(t)t=12NȫִظΣnyi(t)t=12Ni12nôԶʱy(t)ơ
ֵ(1)
(2)

a ֱͳƷԶֱͳƣŴx(t)Ŵڣܼ裬Ϊͷж̬һԡǹӦõķ㡢ֱֻۡͬ仯ΧϵͳĽṹȡϵͳܸӵ£ⲻʧΪһЧķ
b ɷͷĹ۲еõУһԴ¼У1) еĸַ͵оƽһƽTheilʽϵȵȣ2) еĸʷֲƵԣ3) ĴԣҪԷģԤʱ
c) Ƶ׷ʱеĹƵзһͳƷֲҪʱбƽȵġйеĲʱУһǷƽȵģ븴ҪͬĴž߱һԼĻ
Ϊ˵õƽȻʱУĻͱ׼
(3)
(4)

ʽСűʾ
ΪƽʱУù׽һԼ顣ͳͼ׹ȻнΪȷķֲڷֱʵ͡׷ƫе⡣׹ƷֱʸߣԶʱ򡢵ȵźнϺõľȣֲǽƵģҲǿеġ
׹ƶ׵ĳֲͳ
(5)

ʽ(5)Ľṩ˼S1(i)=S2(i)Ļ˼Ľǣ-Z2DZ2ݣУΪˮƽÿƵʵ㶼Ҫļ顣ÿƵʵ㶼ܼ飬ʱݵġ
赼õһʱxtt=12N׵ĹΪx1()=Ϊ1巽
Ϊn໥ʱyi(t)t=12Ni12n׵ĹƵƽֵΪΪn巽̬ľֵ
Ϊ

ˮƽ֮£ܾH0
6

ͬÿƵʵii=12mҪļ顣ƵʵĹ׶һ£ʱһµġڹϣһעǹ׽ǿƵʵƵ׵һԡ
d˲ʱ׹Ʒǰ潲׹Լ鶼ƽʱеģǰĴһõƽȻˣбҪƽԼ飬̽ƽȻ
۸Ҷ׹ƻ׹ƣֻƽźŵķʹʵӦУϵͳǷƽȵʱУһҪƽȻЩźǴﲻƽȻҪģʱƵʵźšĽʱҶSTFTһȨźŵFourier任ĿȺ̣ܶźںСʱƽȵġSTFTһԴﵽֱʵҪ˲ʱ׷֮һWigner DistributionWD⣬ܸźһʱ̵Ƶʳɷ֡رʺڴʱƵʵķƽźšźx(t)y(t)ĻWD任Ϊ
(7)

ѧΪݱףWigner-Villeףʽ壺
(8)

ʽ(7)(8)еĪʾ
Ƶ׷еϵͳģ͵֤ڹѾõӦáΪƵ׷ڹ飬һֶķҿŶȽϸߣӦܵ˹㷺ĹעƵķܶ࣬縵Ҷ׹ơ׹ơ׹ƵȣлʱƵ˲ʱ׹ƺݱ׹ƵȡǵĹƾȣֱʣͷֲԶһķҲһӦõķΧܵҲв
4ϵͳķԷ
ռϵͳܵҪݣҲǼģͿԵҪݡԣڵƹУҪøϢԴԷ顢ͷϵͳϢзȽϺۺϣԼģǷȷǷš
ϵͳȫַģͷǳӣֵģ໥ϡ໥Ӱ졣ģΪһм飬ֵܷĸֵģҪУ顣ֵܽģͣģֿͣм飬׷ҪУǵģ͵ĸ֣ĸģ͡ңⵯ¼˷иϵͳĲۺңļ¼ݣЩϢԶԵѧģͽмУ顣̵ңĿλáٶȵȣλáٶȡ̬ǡٶƫָͶƫǡٶȡصȲݲеλáٶȵݣϵͳңݣȫġֵģϵͳѧģͣӶϵͳѧģ͡
ϵͳģ͵ļ飬ϵͳзݣôͨӦķݽһԼ飬жϵͳģ͵Ŀԡϵͳģ͵ûзݣҪ÷мõϵͳģ͵һµģ;߱˼ģ͵ĻӦһµģģ͵õ֤ͼ1һ򣬿÷ԸģͽУ顣巽ǣĹ̲Ϊϵͳģ͵룬ĽϵͳʵʷȽϣͼ2ʾͼеϵͳݺݾΪݡݣϵͳģͷӳʵϵͳݣϵͳģûзӳʵϵͳҪģͽУ飬ֱϵͳģͿΪֹ


ͼ1÷֤ϵͳģ͵Ļ˼·һ


ͼ2÷Уϵͳַģ͵Ļ˼·
Ҫ˵ǣȿȫ̵ҲǸߵС̵ȡģ͵֤ͨݵ֤ŵģȱҲͨϵͳĵ֤ϵͳ÷ϵͳģ͵Լ顣
ڷңҪԤſΪĲֵͨϵͳģӦķΪʱԼ飬Ӷϵͳַģ͡ʱҪʱƵķжһԡʱ򷽷еķƵȡƵҪĻͱ׼ΪʱƽȻҪƽԼ顣ƽȵʱͨƵ׷ǵԡԭǶͬģµʱƵԡƵ׵ĹƷǰнܣʹõ׹Ʒ
5ģеĿԷ
ݵģص㣬ԼģԷķҪ󣬸µĿԷ
a ȡݣң⡢ң⡢Ϊ̲λáٶȡ̬ǡͼٶƫָͶƫǡĽٶȡصȵȡȡƫLiHii=12nȫ̵ߵС̵ȷ顣
b ýзȫַģ͡ģͷֽϸΪϵͳģͣȷϵͳģ͵ӿڹϵ
c ģ顣ģĹ̲õģ͵Щ̬Ӧķ̲Ϊʱ
d) ҪϵͳģͣзңݣֱӶм飻߱ңݣͨģͼõԵõӦʱ
e ʱͿʱƵķͱȽϡʱһԼǣԤ޳ҰֵȻĻͱ׼ͳƷ
f ƽȵʱзֱ׹ơףʽ6ÿƵʵϹ׵һԡ
g) һ£Ϊڸˮƽ£ģǿŵġײһ£ģҪУ顣
h ģͶǿŵģȫϵͳģǿŵģԽģУõƫLjHjj=12m
i) ƫLiHii=12nеƫLjHjj=12mо̬һԼ顣
j Զ̬һԺ;̬һԼ鶼ɺ󣬼ɸһˮƽ£кͷĽһµģɶԵƵȽм
ллľʦԶооԱʦİָ
ߵλ:(ѧѧɳ410073)
ο
[1]Balci O. Validationverificationand testing techniques throughout the life cycle of a simulation studyProc. of WSC94Winter Simulation Conference1994.
[2]Balderson K AWeathers J T. Comparison of frequency response and perturbation methods to extract linear models from a nonlinear simulation. AD-A284115 1994.
[3]Bonner M SGingras D R. Status of a comprehensive validation of the Navy's FA-18A aerodynamics mode1. AIAA-96-3529-CP,1996.
[4]Gravitz R MWaite W F. Validation methodologies for complexhybridHWIL 6DOF missile simulationsa structured approach. Proc. of WSC881988.
[5]Morton W C. Simulation validation experiencepatriot guidance system, 1983.
[6]Patricia Sanders. Test and evaluation to the modernization challenge.Internethhtpwww.acq.osd.miltespeechessanderschallenge.html.
[7]Poolla KKhargonekar P. A time-domain approach to model validation. IEEE transA.C3951994.
[8]Sargent R G. Verification and validation of simulation models. Proc. of WSC'941994.
[9]Smith R S. Model validation for robust controlan experimental process control application. Automatica 199531(11).
[10]л. Ӧ˲ʱ׹Ʒ֤ըŵַģ. Ƽѧѧ1998201.
[11]л. Ƶ׷ڷоеӦ. ϵͳѧ1998103.
[12]̺. 漼ڵȷеӦ. ս1998(2.
[13]ɣ쳤. ָƵϵͳѧŶ. ϵͳӼ19892.
[14]. սԵȷзģ͵Уо. 棬1993341.
[15]κ. ׹Ƽڵϵͳģ֤еӦ. ϵͳѧ199793.
[16]. Ƶؿģ. 뺽ؼ1995(5.
[17]׹. ʱм׷. ѧ磬1988.
[18]Ž𻱣̺. ͳѧ. Ƽѧ磬1995.
[19]Ž𻱣Ȼ. Զ̻ȷ. Ƽѧ磬1996.
[20]ʹ. ִźŴ. 廪ѧ磬1995.
[21]֣. ˲ʱ׹ۼӦ. . 1993.
ոڣ1998-10-05
