뺽ؼ
MISSILES AND SPACE VEHICLES
1999 5 No.5 1999



ģо(1)
顡
ժҪϵͳо˲ͬطʽ(¾ӹ̵¾ܼӹ̵¾ء·صȣģͼ˵ģͺԭʼеڶ಻ȷؼشӰ죬йɳۺͽ顣
ʡģͣ,ء
Research on Models for Ground Survivability Assessment of U.S. Ballistic Missiles
Wang JixiangChang Lan
(Beijing Institute of Astronautical System Engineering,Beijing,100076)
AbstractAssessment methods for ground survivability of U.S. ballistic missiles are summarized. Assessment models and computation results for ballistic missile survivability in various basing modes (including silo, superhard silo, dense pack harden silo, land mobile base, rail mobile base, etc.) are researched. Many uncertainties and their important effects in assessment models and original parameters of ballistic missile survivability are reviewed, and then some conclusions and recommendations are drawn from the above analyses.
Key WordsSurvivability, Model, Ballistic missile, Mobile missile, Missile base.
1š
ϵͳָǾܵз󾭹Ҫά޴һʱЧִзͨPSʾPSһִܹзĵٷ㡣
ϵͳĻطʽսʹԺвͬҲͬӰڶֻ࣬ںļ£򻯵ѧģͣԵгȻģͽ֤ҪĲȷصӰ죬ںĲΧڣ䡣
50ĩһֱעս⡣60˵Ԥϵͳ޼ʵɢõĶӹ̵¾ߵ¾ļӹ̶ȣѹ¾2.1 MPaߵMXӹ̾350 MPa70ǰ˸߾ȷֵ൯ͷ޼ʵ޼ʵӣǿ˶ԻطʽоģͺͷȷضӰ졢ܼءӹ̻䳵·ȷо
1988꣬վսģAFOTECƶʵʩ޶ĺMXڵ¾еԵ׶νУ
 aƺƻȷȷսģʽȷҪĺ˻жؼܺ͹ؼ豸жӰԱһжݵĻȡ;벻㣻ʵʩƻ׼ƺƻ
bʵʩƻսģʽϸս/˻ϸжҪۺϻжݶȱĿ취ͷලͲμ飻Ӱ죻ӹ̶ȱ/ӹ̶ȼල档
̴ϵͳսʹҪƻƻ/սƻʼϵͳĹܡԻԺͼӹ/ԡȻͨ顢桢Ӱ֮Ӱس̶ȣֹ񡢽ܡϰûӰ4ֽ1ݡ
ģֻеһڡҪвսģʽ顢ݿģݿȡ
վսԵУ̳кƹӦڷɻеĴ顣
վʵҸ˺ͼвµ/оվжѧʵҸǺв/оЩоЧӦӦ顢ݿսݿ2ݡ
1981꣬ɻϼЭˡͼ(CAD)רֻᣬŬʹ/оͬCAD/һ廯CADϣ2ݡ
1984꣬鱨ģDOD IAC/鱨ģSURV IAC1970ս鱨ģCD IC1981ķɻģݿ⣨ASMRϲɡģSURV IACΪоṩǺɱݣ3ݡ 
2ģ
2.1˱ըЧӦ
˱ըҪЧӦг˲ʱ䣨ӡߣ塢䡢ӡƬXߡ˸/ա΢ЩЧӦں˱ըͷռԼֱΪ50%35%˷͵5%10%ɴ˿ЧӦǿϵͳǿҪأ14ݡ
ЧӦѹͶѹ֡ѹǳѹѹѹѹȡں;౬ĵľʽ1

1
ʽСPѹMPa
YͷMt
R౬ľ루km
ʽ1ã
(2)
ѹǳӸ˶ѹĿĻˣҪɳѹļѹͶѹɵġԵ¾˵Ҫɱ˻ǳѹԵҪɱ˻1 Mt TNTĺ˵ͷʱΪѹ10 kt TNT˵ͷʱΪӺͦߺ˷䡣սϵͳ豸Աں˷䡢ȷͳ1,4,5ݡ
ӹ̵¾Ҫ˻ΪӰ뾶ܼصҪ˻ΪѹȺ͵ٶȣ6,7ݡ 
ͬطʽʱõͨóѹ˱׼16ݡ
1ֻطʽĳѹ˱׼

   ʽ˱׼MPa 
¾1320
ӹ̵¾670
·ԽҰ0.21
·0.033*

*شֱķ
2.2¾ģ
ͨб׼ģ㡣ܵͷʱSSPSΪ

(3
ʽСSSPSʣ
RDͷ˰뾶km
CEPԲƫkm
ϮͷɿԵĵִPAnͷµĵ¾PSӦΪ

(4)
ڶ෢ͷͬʱһڵ¾ʱȵĵͷըݻٸĺͷЧӦЧӦɻЧӦɵʧPfִʱΪPA1-Pfʽ4н

(5)
ڶನιµΪι֮磬3ιµ¾Ϊ

(6)
׼ģͺͶSS-18/MX¾йزĲͬ裬ó/MX¾90öSS-18ͷһھµ2ǰöǱ䵯SLBMͷһھµ36ݡ
2/MX¾90öSS-18ͷһھµ

ۼмֹۼ
SS-18 CEPm90110125
SS-18 ͷMt0.50.50.5
/MX¾ǿȣMPa1316.520
SSPS0.126
SS-18ɿ908070
ٸ035
ٷֱ1514

3/MX¾90öǰǱ䵯ͷһھµ

ۼмֹۼ
SLBM CEPm120210300
SLBM ͷMt0.50.50.5
/MX¾ǿȣMPa13.316.520
SSPS23262
SLBMɿ908070
ٸ035
ٷֱ22257


2.3ӹ̵¾ģ
ӹ̵¾ָܾס˱ըκοѹĵ¾ӹ̶ȴﵽܿ350 MPa700 MPaĳѹݴ˶壬ӹ̵¾Ļ˰뾶RDڵӰ뾶Rʽ(3)ã

(7)
ͬĵͷ汬ըʱԳӹ̵¾ĵӰ뾶Rʽ(2)ʱP=700 MPaΪ0.5 MtĵͷR=78 mʽ7ͬCEPµSSPSͬͺ޼ʵICBMǱ䵯SLBM£ӹ̵¾ĵ4е±ըĵӰ뾶һͬͷ汬ըʱĵӰ뾶1.81.93صԳӹ̵¾вصĵӰ뾶ǱըȵĺűըȼӴѸ󡣱4м費ͬͺICBMSLBMĵ͵ͷɿԶΪ100%Ȼǲʵʵģ6ݡ
4ڲͬͺŵ£ӹ̵¾ĵ

ͷ
Ӱ뾶mCEP
m

Mt
ը
ը
ը
ը
SS-18 ICBM1202003803000.730.33
100.5661203000.960.90
δICBM
(MX)120200380900.040
27.1145280900.170
42.5110200900.360.03
100.566120900.690.27
δSLBM
(ꪢ򾫶)13.71202301200.500.08
21.3901701200.680.25
60.25541001200.870.62


ӱ4Կӹ̵¾ڸ߾ȡ±ըĵͷֻ2 Mtĸ߾ȹƵͷCEP75 mĩƵͷصͷŶԳӹ̵¾в
2.4ܼӹ̵¾ģͣ7 
80ΪMXⶨܼӹ̵¾طʹϮͷĻЧӦMX˷100öMX໥550 mܼõ¾ڣÿھӹ34.5 MPaѹǾס69 MPaѹܼ¾ϱԳʽڴԼ36 km2ڡ
ЧӦʱ˳ɷֳ3ࣺa˲ʱЧӦ10 s룬ͨ塢ŷ䣻b˲ʱЧӦӼԼ1 minȷ䡢ͦ÷䣻cЧӦ1 min20 minƬ
ܼ¾ؽΪٻЧӦ˲ʱЧӦ֮ǰЧӦ˥֮ͬʱϮͷǰ߿üʱ1 sеͷʵ֣谲νʵ֡νʱ20 min1νʵʩرը10 min1νʵʩߴ2 400 mĿбը1982꣬ʡѧԺ׵.Ŧ˹дܼؽսģʽף7ݡ
ʺϽܼ¾صĵͷΪرը25 Mtͷﵽ34.5 MPaѹĻ˰뾶ԼΪ790 mر25 Mtͷ3ֲͬĻ˷ʽaѹbĺԼ9.1 mϵסǣcٶʹֽ֧ṹƻʹƵϵͳ𻵡
ڻ˰뾶790 mܼ¾550 m1ö25 Mtͷܴݻ7ڡ8ھҲȷеĵͷͬȷеĵͷһҲܴݻ8ھоǰ4ֶܼ¾صĹʽ
a) 60ö25 Mtͷ׼20Ŀ꣬ÿĿ3öͷÿöĿĵͷɻ7ھɴݻ97%ܼ¾/MX
b½ͷ½ʱ𻵣½еͷ1 s⻥١
cصͷѹ͵Ӱ뾶Ӷ˻Ч
d20 min30 minνԼЧӦ33ö25 Mtͷ׼11Ŀ꣬νܴݻٴ󲿷ܼ¾/MX
ͬսģʽµԼܼ¾زսȶԣʹзΣʱʵʩȷԭ˻ط
2.5ģ
ʽͳ̻֡
2.5.1
װڼӹ̻䳵HMLĵҪֹʽһǵĻʽһĹƵͷסHMLĻ򣻶Ƿ׼ĿʽͷڷаĿλ׼Ŀ
a) ĻʽHML/٪嵼
HML/٪嵼еĻʽʱ䵥˸PKΪͷADͬAm֮ȣ

(8)
ʽСRDRmֱΪͷ˰뾶͵뾶
ʱSSPSΪ

(9)
ʽ4nͷµHML/Ķ෢PS

10
Բģͣͼ1ļιϵCEP=0µĻ֮ȣ

(11)

ͼ1ܼĻʽͼ
עϽHMLڻ
Բ֮Ӱ
ڴ˻˸ÿλڴݻHMLĵͷN

(12)
HMLĿѹǿP=0.2 MPaʽ2õ汬ըʱHMLĻ˰뾶

13
ݸ˹ЧӦеݣѸ߶ȱըĳ˰뾶ȵر˰뾶10%ң8ݡԣձʱHMLĻ˰뾶Ϊ

14
ʽ14ʽ12

15
ʽ15òͬͷѸ߶ȱըͬHML/ﵽ90%˸ٵͷ5ǵսʡɿԵأ˵ͷҪ
5Am=1 000 km2ʱͬͷHMLﵽ90%˸ٵͷ

ͷMtͷĿN
2010
525
174
0.5117
0.5186


ʵHML/٪ʱó˱ȱ5ֵһĵͷ絯ϸо˶ԻеĴ͵Ļʽں£ Բ41 400 km2ڵ500HML٪˵ǰԼ7 000ö1 Mtͷܴﵽ90%Ļ˸ʣƽÿHML/٪14ö1 Mtͷ9ݡɴÿ1 000 km21 Mtͷ169ö
b) ׼ĿʽHML
ÿһHMLоȷλ׼ֱӹǿеġҪȽ鱨/ͨϵͳܶHMLȷλڵڼĳһʱ̰ѴϢʵʱشеĵͷڷ׼Ŀ겢
վѧ1986ؿ޷ģHMLȽʱһģһApple MacintoshϱдеMBASICҪй
1ȷϮICBMķʱFLTTIM
2FLTTIMͻ鱨/Ŀ鱨/Ŀѭʱ䣬ȷϮյЧʱʱUPDTIMʱHMLλΪöָĵλãDGZ
3ݶÿHMLϮͷȷЧ׼ͼκÿöͷ׼㣻
4ȷϮͷըʱHMLλã
5CEPԵͷըλõӰ죻
6㳬ѹHMLӰ죻
7HMLĻ˸PK
PS=1-PKHMLÿαըʡPSܵڸPS֮HMLnαըۻʡ
ģ͵ÿжHML͸Ϯͷ֮ĶԿ˷档ģ͹3ܿ飺
aȷؼʱ䡣
1) ӷֱ̽ϮͷЧ鱨/Ŀ֮ʱTime 1
2) ֱ֮ʱ䣬ʱ䶨ΪTime 2
bģͷHMLTime 1Time 2ڼ˶ȷҪλã
1) ͷе㡣ֻ1öͷָ1HMLHMLTime 1ЧλΪͷ׼ĵ㣨DGZͷ׼һHMLHMLTime 1λôϮͷ辡ȫǵġȷԲ򡱵Բġκ£HMLTime 1λöϮͷĿ׼㡣
2) ڵͷʱHMLλá
cģĿλáըλú͸CEPӰõģͣȷÿαըHMLЧþ뷶Χݴ˷ΧѹĻˡЩPKֵ
ģͼ3ܿ鲿ֵͼͼ25

ͼ2ģͼ

ͼ3ģ͵1ͼ

ͼ4ģ͵2ͼ

ͼ5ģ͵3ͼ
עGround 695 Damage 695 ӳ
վѧԺAFITγ NE 695 ϵͳ
Ľ̲ݡDamage 695 
̬˺˸ʣ9ݡ
ԴģҪ9ЩǸݵֵȻоģ
a HMLܹʱսɢ״̬
b ԲۻЧӦڼѹЧӦʱHMLܴǰĳӰ죻
c Ҫ˻Ϊѹ
d HMLӻ״̬תȫӹ̼״̬ʱSETUPΪ2 min
e ̽ʱDETECT涨Ϊ1.5 min
f HMLɢƣ׼ٶСֱֵֵֵΪ19.3 km/h48.3 km/h61.1 km/h
g HMLӹ̿0.21 MPaѹ
h ϮͷΪ114ö趨Ϊ1 MtڱΪ1 585 mʱ˰뾶Ϊ1.95 km8ݣ
i ȽͷоȣCEPﵽ10 m
ڽģУֱģ֮󼰷ģڼ䣬ģϸ֤ȷϡģӳʽеԺ֤»㼯һ֤趨Χڣϸģĺԡ
ڶģ֤֮󣬻ģȷϣ׼Чģ͵׼ЧǰģͼͬʵϵͳȽϵĹ̡ʵϵͳݿʱӽ档׼ģЧĹ̰3
a һԺЧԶǿġʱҪһЩģͣ
b ֤ģ͵ļЧ
c ģ͵-תͬʵϵͳӦ-תжԱȡȱʵϵͳʱóóһ׽ݽжԱȣȷģ͵Ԥ
׼Чģڲͬѭʱ(CYCLE)͵ͷϵĻ׼㣬ƳԻ˸ʺѭʱΪݺͼó¹۲
a 鱨/ĿѭʱС2 minʱϮͷ٣PKƵ1
ΪϮͷܾùHMLλõ鱨ʱ׼Ŀ꣬ԷֹHMLƶ0.21 MPaѹӦĻ˰뾶⡣
2 min<CYCLE<15 minʱPKѸ½CYCLE>15 minʱPKƽ½
ΪʹPK=0.9һöͷHMLCYCLE<2.3 min5öͷCYCLE<3.5 min10öͷCYCLE<4.7 min
b ǵзƳһѭʱ6 minϵͳ޿еֱӾȷHMLķ
ôģͻоHMLٶȡӹ̶ȱ仯вϵͳCEPЧӦHMLʵӰ죨㻥ЧӦõļף9ݸ¼GУǣ
a HMLȽľȷλ׼ĵʱԾкܸߵΪٴﵽ0.9PKĵͷĿƳǳȽ鱨/Ŀϵͳ
b HMLPSҪȡɢ½ͨɢ41 400 km2924 000 km2PSܴ0.10.9
c HMLPSٶȺͼӹ̶ȵ߶ʶ
dоȷλ/ĿĵֱӹHMLʱԺԲƻٶPKӰ졣
e зCEP߲HMLPSشӰ10ݡԻ𵼵еĻЧҪȡڽĵЧǷֵ൯ͷоȵĸߵ͡òͬĵͷͬͶȡõЧͬ
ף9ûм٪/HMLǱ䵯SLBMʱPSһӦо⡣SLBMʱ̣һ15 minңѹ͵SLBM8 minҼɷɵĿ꣬HML3 min6 minʱ䡣
2.5.2̻
٪ HML̻ع250ÿHMLHMLɽӱ45 km/hƽٶȳ̡ tڣ̻뾶Rm=45/60t=0.75 tkm ΪAm=(0.75t)2=1.77t2  Amʽ12 ڻ˸ PK = 0.9ʱݻһHMLĵͷN

16
ʽ14ʽ16ã
17
ʽ 17 ڲͬʱtHMLΪYĵͷĻʽʱﵽ0.9PKٵͷN250NΪ250HML̻ٵͷ6
6ͬͷĻʽ250̻tӵHMLⷿﵽ0.9PKٵͷ
tminYMt250 N
22018
544
1130
0.5206
0.25328
620159
5400
11 170
0.51 857
0.252 948
820282
5711
12 080
0.53 301
0.255 241
1220635
51 600
14 680
0.57 429
0.2511 792

ӱ62 minʱ䲻Ա֤棬HMLڵз11Ĺֻ6 minϳ̻HMLĵзĵͷ
áۡӵرʾͶʾսȶԡָһĻ˸ʴݻ1öͷٹͷ༴ùͷ뱻ݻٵͷ֮ȡԽ󣬱ʾԽǿսȶԽߡ蹥HMLSS-18ͷΪ5 MtɿΪ90%˸90%̻HMLĹۼ79ݡ
7R=90%5 Mtͷ0.9PKHMLĹ

̻HMLʱ4 min0
ʱ8 min2.2
ʱ16 min8
HMLƽʱ10 000 km22.1
Ԥʱ20 000 km24.2
Ԥ4 min5.2
Ԥ8 min6.2
Ԥ16 min7.7


2.6·ģ
·ÿгöMXȷе·г0.5 MtͷʱѱµĻ˰뾶ͿѹǿȣҪȡгṹиǻڳķλ8
8·г0.5 MtͷʱĻ˰뾶Ϳѹǿ

 ÷˰뾶kmѹǿȣMPa
иǻӲ5.50.0340.041
Ӳ3.10.0820.103
иǻβ1.90.1370.172
β1.30.2750.345


վҪصгܿشֱ·ĳѹ0.034 MPaһö0.4 Mt0.5 Mtĵͷ汬ըĻ˰뾶ʽ2ֱΪ3.10 km3.34 kmѱߵӰ죬˰뾶1.1ֱΪ3.41 km3.68 kmڵͷоCEPӰ죬ھ·ߴֱ1.4 kmըʱֻܴݻ23.5 km=7 km·ϵгվ0.5 MtͷѸ߶ϱըڴԼ7 kmΧڵ·ߣ0.034 MPaϵĳѹһö0.4 MtͷѸ߶ϱըƻ4.5 km·ϵг
гƽʱΪ50 km/h100 km/hз̽гλõʱټICBMʱ乲Լ1.5 h2 hΪȷĻʽһгȡóɹͱ빥г1.5 hʻ·̣75 km150 kmҪ(75150)4.5=(1733)ö0.4 Mtͷ(75150)7=1122ö0.5 Mtͷǵгڽ㴦ǰУλȷгɢٶ265 km/hĵͷࡣɴ˼򵥹Ľٵͷ·9,11ݡ()
ߵλ(ϵͳƲ100076)
ոڣ1999-01-06
