뺽ؼ
MISSILES AND SPACE VEHICLES
1999 5 No.5 1999



ԪɿԼڷչеҪ
ִ߰սսӵս͸߼սԪǸ߼ս͵սĺģǻӻԶܻĻɿԵõ˷ӡߴӻķ䡢ķлԵӲƷ󡢰뵼弼ķչԼִսҪ5˵ԪɿԼҪԡͬʱ˵ԪɿڹоصνԪɿԼӦڻйӦõԪɿԼľԼڵѣһЩ۵Ϳ
򽣲
1ԪɿԼԺ켼Ҫ
Ÿ¼ķչִеӻԶܻص㡣ӺսͿΣпԿִսսӵս͸߼սΪ߼ս͵սĺġ豸ԣ临ӳ̶ȲܸߣҷչٶȺܿ졣1940꣬ըϵĵ豸Ԫ2 000ִɻϵһ״Ԫ2 000ĵҲ൱ˡ
֪ϵͳԽӣɿԽϵͳӳ̶ȵߡгļӾ磬ɲɿƷľ޴󾭼ʧսѵԼᶯ˵ɿԹ̵ҪѾ͹Գ䷢չٶȺܿ졣
ԪΪ豸͵ϵͳĻɵԪɿѾõ˸߶ӣԪĿɿԼܷʹ켼һ̨ףܷ񱣳ֺҵչͷһ򿪹ʷгǺ켼Ĺؼ֮һ
1.1ԪĿɿǻķ֮һ
ʵֵԪĸ߿ɿǵӼչģҲǺҵչҪΪӦִ豸ϵͳĸӳ̶ڲߣҲڲࡣݿɿۣϵͳԪԽ,Ԫɿָ겻£ϵͳĿɿԽ͡Ϊ˱֤ĸ߿ɿԣߵԪĿɿԡһϵͳ15 000Ԫ Ϊȷϵͳ0.95ĿɿȣҪÿԪĿɿΪ0.999 998 7
һʮָӵϵͳɴԪɣһԪɿͿشʧﰲѾ100Σй8ηʧ8ηʧУ1ǰﰲ5ػڻĵϵͳɵģ7ζΪԪ϶ɵġ
1998819995£ʧ6Σǻը¹ʡһ1998826գ¶ڿάɺԼ80 sʱըûЯһͨǣʧΪ2.25Ԫʧԭĵϵͳϣе͵Ӳɻбʧȥơһ1998812գ4A40 s쳣ɵԱ2 sԻװãںϿձըαըʷʧص¹֮һɵľʧ޴öĴֵԼ3ԪЯһżǼֵΪ8ڡ10Ԫ199949մԤδԤ427ŵȻδԤ430մͨδԤ54յ¶ͨʧ4ʧܾʧԼ20Ԫ
˹1998910շ¹ʣЯ12֮ͨŹ˾ǵ춥-2ŻʧܣԭǶͻȻϵ¡
ڱʺΪɫ961996꣬˹ӺŻױǺɻﰲڷ⵽شйҲ⣬215գƵĳһŹͨɲãһͷײڷ䳡ɽϡУ818գͥʸĳŻִе11ηУǰ48 sػδܽԤ
߿ɿԷǳɹǶ˹ĺƽſռվ1999220Ϊֹ̫13꣬ԭΪ3ꡣӼĽǶȿվڷɿԴľ޴ʤͬʱҲ˾޴ľЧ档ںƽⲻƽ13135˹ҵԱڹվϹȺ󹲽1.65οѧ飬аɵ23ʿѧƻȡ˴ݼشʵüֵĳɹԱ̫ľΪгǼʷṩҽѧϡ
ɴ˿ɼߺõԪĿɿԣǻʹҪҲʹġ򵼵ϵͳĵ豸ɿԲߣڷʱ󣬵ϵͳֹϣɿʧ飬ᵼ¾޴ľʧͲκ
1.2лҪԪкܸߵĿɿ
лʮֶӵġɻ㲿УԪǱȽϴģʹȴǱȽϿ̵ġҪָܸߵ¡ȡߵѹ񶯳ٶȡȻӰ죬Զ԰뵼ɿԵҪҲԽԽߡԪݣĳԪʵ³ֹϵĿΪ1ôڷɻʹµĿΪ6.5ڻʹΪ80ʹĲͬԵԪʧЧҪҲͬõӻҪʧЧΪ100ء500أͨѶ豸ҪʧЧΪ20ء200أճڡڡڹҪʧЧʷֱΪ1أ10أ100ء
ʵְ뵼߿ɿԣǺ칤̵ҪǹҪ
1.3ԵӲƷ󲻶ӣռ
ԵԪ󲻶ҪԭǵӲƷܹ߻װܣʹ̡ɿԡоȡӦʱ䡢ԺӦԵȷ涼к̶ܴȵߡ2ԭǣӲƷʹǰʿеΣתɸװеͨʹ״͵ʹڸԶľоսӶʹٱ˺ͨͨѶϵͳԼ豸ʵԶ۲ս3ԭǣ豸װܻԶִˮƽʹӳŹģСԸǿķչҲڷĵӲƷĿ֧ԭսܷԤһЩ»عرգõӲƷһЩ˾ϵȻڷչСǮϣ.˾˾˹ӹ˾ӲƷĴ˾ӲƷͳƣĳЩʽս˵ԪڼӡͨѶϵͳѾռɱһ룬ܷǳ׼ȷԶѰļƵը򵼵˵ʹõĵԪռ8097Ԥ⣬10ķԤ㽫8ϣܶ2320Ԫ10ڷĵӲƷĿ֧10,ӵ555Ԫ
ɴ˿ɼҪ߹ִˮƽԪɿǱص㼼֮һ
1.4뵼弼ĿٷչԪɿԴս
뵼ӼǷչһż˼Ծչ΢ʱԪرǼɵ·ķչ˵졣²Ʒ¹ղӿ֣ɶԽԽߣȻһ£ڵԪɿԼȴһս
1975Intel˾ʼ֮һ Moore MooreǾǼɵ·ļɶÿ24CPUļÿ18һ伯ɵľҲ120ķչ̣һ򡣼ɵ·ļɶ1960ꡫ1975꣬ÿ241010001975Ժ󣬻ÿ341040оƬϵ߿ÿ5С1 ĿǰɦmnmչCPUٶȴ40042 000ָsչΪ3ָs뵼弼nmӼչ˵뵼άṹԼnmΧĽṹߴ緽ӵЧӦǽ10ꡫ15ҪơЩչ˵ܵĲɲԼеĲģԣǿɿԼҪо¿⡣
1.5ִսҪ
ִս졢Ӹź͵Ӵݻ٣ԪǽеսĻԪںսڼ䣬˽һġоƬսʵʩɳĮ籩ж֮ǰΪԸսָϵͳɳսСȥ͸︽ɹĳ֡оƬʹսָϵͳҲй©ϢϣΪͻϮ֡оƬӦǵע⣬رоƬǽڵġ
ΣУԼҲǿĵӸʩ˽ҵĵѹƣʹͨѶжϡԼʹ˿߹΢õǿĵ壬ʹΧʮﷶΧڵе豸Ӳ𻵣ƻ޷޸ֵͷҲܲһɱáˣһҪǿԪ͵ϵͳĿɿо
2Ԫɿڹо
ԿɿԹǴ50ʼġʱıǣ1957̫ƽ޼ʵɹ󾪿֣ʹͶɿԼо60ɿԼõչ죬չһרҵ䱾ķͼݡͰ޼ƻԿɿԹķչ˺ܴƶá
2.1ߵԪɿ뵼Ƽƻ
Ҫս֮һơУΪ˸Ľ߼ɵ·ĿɿԣƶˡɿԱ֤ƻ͡Ԫ֤ƻⷽͶ˴ƷΪ200Ԫ40ԪߵԪɿԷ档1964ꡫ1966꣬ɵ·ʧЧʴ0.07%/kh0.000 8%/khɿ˽100ϵͳMTBFﵽ10 000 h1969ĿɿԳ˹涨ָꡣ⿴ǡɿԼƻ͡Ԫ֤ƻĳɾͣΪɿԹչһɹĵͣΪԺ
ɿԼƻӳһʵȻɿԼƻҪһͶʣܵľúǳɱ͡ڹֳƵʧЧԪϣδʵʩʩ֮ǰɱߣʵʩɿԼƻ2֮2ĳɱ90%ϣǳɹۡ
2.2ԪɿԼķչѧˮƽͬչ
ƿʼ1958꣬1970꣬ƻʵʩ12ꡣƻʵʩУݵʱѧչ˲ͬĿɿԷ1958꿪ʼ1963꿪ʼ1966꿪ʼõǷƵǵ1̨ɵ·ͺŵMTBFﵽ10 000 h˵ʱɿԵˮƽܲ˵ǿɿԼƻĹ͡
õǴģɿ֤ʵʧЧʺʵʧЧʷڵľ䷽ҪǶԪдģ飬ͳƳԪʧЧʡġԪ֤ƻһֿɿԷơʧЧģʽһֳɱ͡Чʸߵϵͳ飬빤ϵľʩϣԼԪɿԵĸĽȡЧȱǲȷعԪʧЧʡǸüƻԼɵ·ɿԵķչ˺ܴӰ죬վչġ1968ƶ΢ѧ׼883ʱܵ˸ÿɿԼƻָ˼Ӱ죬رɸѡ֣883еõ˽һչΪɵ·ƶĵ1ñ׼һֱھƷб㷺á
͵ķչɿԼƵͬʱҲάԡԡȫԡԵȼĲͷչŸķչ1980ʽ䷢˵1ɿԼάָ5000.40ɿԼάԡ1985վʵʩRM 2000жƻ˵2000ɿԼάˮƽһ豸MTBFﵽ20 000 hĿꡣѾѿɿԹΪϵͳƹ̵Ҫɲ֣ǿɿԺάܡáͬҪɵ·ĿٷչѵԪɿԹһ½׶Ρ
2.3õԪɿɱ׼ϵ֤
80֮;ҵ֯϶˱仯ΪȷԪɿԷӣϵͳսãȣƶһϵеĵԪľü׼֤õӲƷɿԣݵӼķչϲ䡢ơΣץõԪѡãƶԪѡĿ¼Ű뵼칤յĳߣֿչϸӦ֤֤˾õԪѡõĿɿԡ3ھõԪĲɹǿ淶Ĺ֤ɹ
ŷվȻڱ׼ϵһЩ𣬵ھõԪĹ϶֮ͨƶɹѡáɸѡһϵк׼֤ԪɿԵġ
ǿͳһʹԪĿɿԹϵͳƶȻǵԪɿԹ̵ı֤
2.4ǿԪɿԼĻо
(NASA)ŷվ(ESA)ӵԪɿԼĻ裬罨ԪɿҡЩкƵֶΣ˿չɿɸѡ⣬չܶɿԼĻоЩоʧЧɿۼɿ鼰ͳƼȣʹɿԼ㺽췢չҪ
3Ԫɿڹڵо
3.1ԵԪĿɿԷǳ
йƼҵǿйԼչ׳ģںҵĴУΪߵԪĿɿԣ֤װƶˡרŸĸ￪ź͹ڵӹҵķչ1989꿪ʼ᳹꣬ƶ˵Ԫйؾñ׼͹淶ͨȡɼػ͵ķչҪá
3.2ǿ˵ԪɿԵĹ
Ϊ˸õԪĿɿԹ߿ɿԼֶΣǿװԪƺͼϣչ˿ɿɸѡͬʱǿ³աDPAʧЧȹȷװԪĿɿԡƶһϵйʩЩʩ߲ƷͿɿҪãرǼǿ˵ԪġͳһԪѡáɹơա顢ɸѡʧЧ7ؼڲȡͳһʩΪҵ׼ȡЧװԪĿɿԣװԪʧЧʣΪ֤ɹ˹ס1998ףϵл13ηɹ
3.3˺Ԫɿ
Ϊ˼ǿԪɿԵļԪɿġΪԪɿԵļеλɿľ߱˻ԪɿɸѡļֶΣԽпɿɸѡԺƷԵԪɿԵҪ󣬽иֻеͻ顣ͨɸѡDPAɿĻ൱ݺ;飬һ֧һɿ۵ļ飬֧ܹӦͺĿɿԵҪмֶοչοɿԿо
4ԪɿԼоٵ
4.1ԪɿˮƽŲ
ԪˮƽڹĲƷڲ״»ƷһԡȶԲҲڿɿ⣬ڳֵʧЧģʽڵͲε⡣ԪʧЧĲƷڽϴĲࡣˣԪĿɿԹضԶ
4.2ԪɿԹδͺϵͳƹ
ԪĿɿԿƵһ㶼װ֮ǰҪǶԵԪпɿɸѡͼ⡣ֹʹԪɿԹһ顢©ӦȵĶѭأԱҪڴDPAϸɸѡ̭ʸߺʧЧԪһЩԹϣûмڽߵԪɿһϡ
ŷվֶѿɿԹΪϵͳƵҪɲ֣ͺͬУ򵼵ƳھƶˡԪ֤ƻɿԼƻڳβõļɵ·пɿ飬ȡɹʹϵͳɿ˺ܴߡ
ͺƹУץ塢ϵͳ͹⼸רҵ֮⣬ԪɿԼҲӦͬСԪĿɿԿƵӦǰƣԴͷץ𣬼ѡáѡҡѹƷ֡ɿ顢ȼץʹЩôۻԤʩԴͷͷãǴڲȴʩ״̬Ҫ¼ԭ򣺵1·ļɶԽԽߣɿԲԺҪһ̡2ϵͳõ¼漰һЩ͵·ֶοûм羫ȷƵ߼õĵ·3ӦṩõԪһЩɿݡǻԭͺϵͳƳڣӦƶԪɿԱ֤ƻͶչĿɿԱϹڻ׶βмֶ֤ɿԡ򣬿ɿԱһջû˭ܶϵͳõ¼ĿɿԸ
4.3ԿɿûиӦеӺͽһ
ԪɿԷԤǽڴݵоϵġĵԪʹúʧЧʵʩͳһ֮󣬽˴DPAͼɸѡЩɿݵĻۺͷһڹ̣ҪͶʽ𣬵ԿɿԹ̲ȴǾ޴ġǳӿɿݵķʹãɿģͣҽӦڱѡĿ¼ͽпѧĿɿԤơ
4.4ԪɿԼнϴ
Ԫж೤䴢ʧЧǶ٣ЩضԵԪӰ죬Ӱ췽ʽʲôЩ⻹ûȷĽۣЩоԺƷϵͳŷǳҪ壬ҶԪпɿˮƽҲҪ
4.5ȱһЩҪĿɿԼֶ
ɿ۷ƷɿԵıҪֶΣƽ׶ͨĽɿб¶ʹƷﵽԤĿɿָꣻڶͽ׶ͨɿȫ濼˲ƷĿɿָꣻȶ׶ͨɿ֤˽ȶ̶ȡ
⣬ͨɿ飬˽ԪڲͬӦµʧЧģʽʧЧԭҳڣȡӦʩԴﵽߵԪɿˮƽĿġ
ɿûйصĿɿ飬NASAҲԼĿɿңJPLйغõԪĿɿɸѡԪرǼɵ·չܿ죬ʵ豸費Ͷʲ뵼弼ķչӦˣӦӵԪɿĵĽ裬ɿʵͼֶΣʹԪķչˮƽػҪӦ
5ӦӺͼǿõԪɿԼо
ڵԪɿһֱǺͺͻıڣǿԪĿɿо
a) ȻԪϸߣǣȼԿƣرǸߵȼ·ܵĽˡӳԶʵսĽǶȳΪ˱֤δսڲ֮أӦڵԪΪ
b) Ϊ˱֤ԪװҪԪɿԼΪһרҵͺƼƻƶÿͺӦġԪɿԱ֤ƻ͡Ԫ֤ƻЩƻԪɿĸоʵʩ2չͺصԪɿопɿԡʹÿɿԡɿԵݣڳֵҪйأɿԿƵǰơ3ǿԪɿĵĻ裬ƼֶΣ÷ɿԵļ֧á
c) ˸ԪɿԹ֮⣬Ӧǿ豸ɿԹչӦļɿ顣ڷ199819996ʧԭʱָԭ֮һ̵⣻ԭ֮²ƷƹйģģͣٶʵӲɵġɴ˿ɼ豸ҲӦйر׼ӦĲƷ飬׽豸ĿʧЧӵءȫԵȿɿ⣬ͺŵɿԡ
d) ھȷƵ棬ҲӦչйԼȫλϵͳļŷѾʶһԣڷչԼȫλϵͳйҲӦ
һϵͳֻ̣ԪԭϺŵӻ̶ȵߣӦĳɹ飬ԪĿɿԹͺƹУԪɿԹӦΪһרҵ塢ϵͳ͹ͬУܴӸϽϵͳɿԱ⣬ʹƷơơʹáάȸ׶ζȫܿأͺŲƷĿɿԡ
ߵλ(йػоԺԪɿԼ)
ο
1 Borofsky.CQAP for microminiature electronic components for Min.. 3rd Sym. on Physics of Failure ,1964.
2 Nowak. Reliability of IC for Minuteman. Sym. on Reliability, 1966.
3 Hausrath. Cost improvement as a result of reliability efforts on Minuteman  IC. Sym. on Reliability, 1967.
4Ź.䣺մӺζ.й챨.
5.ġоƬս.й걨.
ոڣ1999-01-20
