뺽ؼ
MISSILES AND SPACE VEHICLES
1999 6 No.6 1999



ģо(2)
顡
ժҪϵͳо˲ͬطʽ(¾ӹ̵¾ܼӹ̵¾ء·صȣģͼ˵ģͺԭʼеڶ಻ȷؼشӰ죬йɳۺͽ顣
ʡģͣ,ء
Research on Models for Ground Survivability Assessment of U.S. Ballistic Missiles
Wang JixiangChang Lan
(Beijing Institute of Astronautical System Engineering,Beijing,100076)
AbstractAssessment methods for ground survivability of U.S. ballistic missiles are summarized. Assessment models and computation results for ballistic missile survivability in various basing modes (including silo, superhard silo, dense pack harden silo, land mobile base, rail mobile base, etc.) are researched. Many uncertainties and their important effects in assessment models and original parameters of ballistic missile survivability are reviewed, and then some conclusions and recommendations are drawn from the above analyses.
Key WordsSurvivability, Model, Ballistic missile, Mobile missile, Missile base.
3湥ģ
 ڳֶεĶ浯ͷ-صƵըѲֲӵȣڳµ͸ÿһ־в͹սģʽСñ׼12ݹ涨зУ
a-вĶԿ
bԷģʽ̽⡢Сɱ˵ĸʡ
˾ñ׼涨аơƺڼõǱ׼ļ涨ķ򾭶׼Ƽ
ڳµһʾвͬ˱ܹ;סݡվƻAFR80-38аΪϵͳ;˹жԻҲ;ʧɹ涨Чܵ13ݡ
ˢ򵼵1977꿪ʼʵʩƻڵ¹˹㷺Ұսϰȡ˽ʵսµݡ½ΪˢǰҪȡܹʺͱ˸ʣǰȡڱ̽ʡ׼ʺ͵зĵִʣȡˢϵͳԡάԺͿٲԣͼ6ÿһӰضʱйأ14ݡ

ͼ6ˢǰӰ
ͼ6гϵͳڳʵļԹʽ

(18
ʽСPSʣ
Pd̽ʣ
Pt׼ʣ
PAִʣ
PK˸ʣ
PmfʧЧʣڹ̶˵Pmf=1
Kmϵͳάϵ
KSϵͳٲϵ
KW򻷾ϵ
4ȷصӰ
ڵģõľԭʼУŹеĲȷءЩȷؿɴԷΪ2415ݣ
a ܹսԲȷأ
Ӿɢ
Ӿ䣻
·䣻
䣻
Ȩ䣻
öԿӦ
öԿĿӦ
b ϵͳȷأ
սоо֮Ĺϵ
ͷ
ͷ/Ÿ߶ȣ
ɿԣ
ʣ
Ŀʣ
ָӡơͨŵЧԣ
ϵͳЧԡ
c ܹĿĲȷأ
˳ͺ˷ļӹ̶̳ȣ
Ŀλݵľȷ̶ȣ
ָӵֵԣ
C3Iϵͳԣ
صͳЧӦ

ЧӦ
ս
ٷӦ
оԺĲ³˹W.1979ICBMеĲȷؽϵͳоǷֱ˲ǱڵҪӰ죬óۣICBMĲȷأеĺδĻطʽӰ춼ǳ󡣳õǼ򻯵ļ㷽ڶ಻ȷصӰ졣ˣǰ˵ǵЩȷغսأɵóǶǵĽۣ80Ƕжٵ¾ܾסȷûжģ˶ԴݻǵĴ󲿷ֵҲûжա5
ΪȷЩȷصӰ죬ȰЩزICBMPsΪɷΪ4SSPK˸ʣPK෢˸ʣPAͷִĿʣFͷסɹĸʡڷ4ʱйصҪءSSPKʵ8ĺߡ˰뾶ĿԻӹ̶ȡѹڡ˦ҡCEPϵͳƫ󲿷ַֻĿӹ̶ȡͷоCEPͨķ©ͬICBMʵйصҪءЩȷصĺϵʮָӣԲ޷òʵȷԷֲˣ£õͲֵǽƵġ
SSPKĲȷԼС9СVNǾ任Ŀ꿹ѹǿȣKĿԳѹڵжȣ˦ҡǻ˾5,4ݡ
9˸ʵĲȷԣ5

 ȷԼ
ǰֵֵǰֵֵ
VN1.00.52.01.0
K0.50.251.00.5
˦0.050.050.10.1
5%10%10%20%
ߣ5%5%--
˰뾶5%5%10%10%
ԲƫCEP50252010
ϵͳƫ5025100.x24100.x24
ѧtɶ9944

ǰ6ı׼ƫǸݱ·ѧtɶȷֲģ
߲ȷʹǰõ汬ը
ӱ9йԵĲVNKǰ¾Ե˽ȷУǰԴ˲ĲȷԼΪӦֵڵͷͻ˰뾶ǡ෴Դ˲ĲȷԼΪǰӦֵоȲܾȷǰÿһε飬ڹCEPϵͳƫĲȷʱΪǰӦֵһ롣
෢˸PKֻͨSSPK򵥵ۺ϶ɡϸȷĿӹ̶ƫȵͷĿ귽Ӱ졣ңЩӰ޷ֻѡü򵥺ϳɻ˸ʵķ
ͷִPAǰɿԺͻǰδ¾ʵʩȷļ裬ִʼΪֻɿԡɿеĲȷʹͷɿݲġ
Fһ۶൫ٵĲԻЧӦʵ˽⣬Ŀǰ̫١
ӰĲȷؿɷΪ3֣ƽֵĲȷԡδ֪ģ͡ΧĳһԤĲƽֵƽֵĲȷԴ١ȷȱپȷ鱨ݵȡδ֪ģͣ޷飬ֻͨоͷдԹơ
վϵͳ˾վʵҵķ˹.Sְ1986Ե½ṹеĲȷԽнģͷָ಻ȷأĺͷġȷصصǳȷ¼䣬ͬظдͳơȷص䲻̫ȷֻãƽֵƫûʵ塣󲿷ģеĲȷضǷġУĽȷģͣչзģΪȷصĽģͬȷģϣγɸƵ16ݡ
90ģеõһƹӦá1993վѧԺW.ģ߼ӦõУ17ݡͬ꣬˹.˹ģӦںɱFortran 77Scapݿ⡣16˻Ϊ룬ڼд˴ϢԿ˼ӹ̵ЧѱȽ˷18ݡ
5ۺͽ
a úļͼ򻯵ѧģͶг
Ӱڶ࣬вٲȷأֻںļ£ü򻯵ѧģͣԵгȻͷģͽ֤ԤƵĺΧڣ䡣ԲֲȷصӰ졣
b ýģ͵ع
ģ͵عвȷȷϵͳ񡢽սģʽӰ졢ؼ/豸ԡݿģݿȡӦռڽӽʵսµݣݺͷϡ
ģõļ͹ʽӦ򣬴ӶԷؽзվѧף9нܵģͳͲֵý
c ҪݳѹΪ˻С
õļģ;Ǹݺ˱ըѹΪҪ˻ģӹ̵¾ģǸݵӰ뾶ΪҪ˲ġȷͬطʽõĳѹ˱׼1ѿ˼ӹ̶ΪƻеҪָ꣬רűñ׼MIL-STD-1766B޼ʵϵͳ˼ӹ̶ȺƻҪ󡱣21ݡ
d ԾвսģʽС
ڳµӦ-вԿģʽԷСҪȡڱ̽ʡ׼ʡĵִʺͻ˸ʡϵͳٻٷӦάԺٲҲӰ졣
e оȷضҪӰ졣
ȷضԵӰǷǳģʹôڴƵĹ˫Ի˸ʺʶûġΪ벻ȷصӰ죬ȽȷزȻȷؽģģԷȷؽģͬģϣɸƵģ͡ڴ󲿷ֲȷΪȷأҪǿоʹƹģ/еӦá
f һʹз󹥻۵ϵͳ
ڲȷصӰ죬޷ȷ׼ȷָꡣվ٪սҪǣ㹻ܿвͼƻевҪ㹻ȷ塣ƣڲзö500ö٪/HML޷ȷȼ϶Ҫһʹз󹥻۵ϵͳ˴ʹеͼͳܲ𣬴Ӷ䷢22ݡ
ߵλ(ϵͳƲ100076)
ο
1Douglas Donald M. Introduction to the operational nuclear survivability assessment process. AD A 210 072,1988-04.
2Wallick Jerry. Aircraft design for S/V. In: Proceedings of a workshop in survivability and computer-aided design, sponsored by joint technical coordinating group on aircraft survivability. AD A 113 556, 1981-04-69:438476
3Vice J M. Survivability/vulnerability information analysis center (SURVIAC)-a tool for the aircraft survivability community. AIAA 862691.
4־ߵ. ½սԵ. , 1987-12.
5Bennett Bruce Wm. Uncertainty in ICBM survivability. 1979-10.
6Levi et al. The future of land-based strategic missiles. 1989.
7Joe Romm, Kosta Tsipis. Analysis of dense pack vulnerabilities. MIT1982-11.
8Glasstone Samuel, Dolan Philip. The effects of nuclear weapons, 1977.
9Gearhart David J, Merrow Scott F. Survivability of the hardened mobile launcher when attacked by a hypothetical rapidly retargetable ICBM system. ADA172 453, 1986-03.
10Report of the defense science board task force on SICBM modernization. ADA 173 675, 1986-03.
11MX garrison program executive summary. AD A 206 086.
12Survivability, aircraft, establishment and conduct of programs for. MIL-STD-2072 1977-08.
13Air Force survivability program management. AFR 80-38.
14Lund Fredrick H. ˢ򵼵ϵͳķչ. AIAA 84-1966.
15Schneider Barry R et al. Missiles for nineties ICBMs and strategic policy. 1984.
16Wong Felix S. Modeling and analysis of uncertainties in survivability and vulnerability assessment. ADA 167 630, 1986-03.
17Fleming Richard W. Vulnerability assessment using a fuzzy logic based method. ADA 274 075, 1993-12.
18Celmins Aivars. Nuclear-survivability cost analysis using fuzzy-set theory. AD A 273 951, 1993-11.
19½似ļ. йػоԺ191996-06.
20飬. о. 1996-12.
21Nuclear hardness and survivability program requirements for ICBM weapon systems. MIL-STD-1766B(USAF), 1994-09.
22GAO Report to Congress, ICBM modernization. AD A 173 154, 1986-09.
ոڣ1999-01-06
