ղѧ
JOURNAL OF AERONAUTICAL MATERIALS
1999ꡡ192ڡVol.19No.21999



ϲɰʴо
桡ʤ
ժҪ ˳ʴĻ豸˾ۺϲɰʴоſͳʴ˸ֳʴغͿʴͿԳʴܵӰ졣
ؼʣ ʴɰʴϲϣʴ
ͼţ TB323ױʶ룺A±ţ1005-5053(1999)02-0054-09
Review on sand erosion of composites
SHEN ZhenYANG Sheng-chunMargherita Clerico
(1.Aircraft Strength Research Institute,Xian710065China 2.Politecnico di Torino,Italy)
Abstract Some basic principles on erosion and erosion test devices are introduced. Survey on sand erosion and erosion mechanisms of composites is summarized. Factors influencing erosion rate and protective coating effects are discussed.
Key wirds: erosionsand erosioncompositeserosion rate

ʵʹùУܶܵ(Һ)ЮӵϮĥʴΪʴЮӵĳʴͨΪɰʴԺܶ๤Ӧ(ɻṹ)ɰʴǸص⡣Ǵ40ѿʼԳʴо1ݣ˴ڽʴоɹȥ20մɵĳʴܵ˼ĹעҲд׿ɹġ1970ԽԽȽۺϲϱںṹرǷɻṹۺϲϵĳʴΪһѿʼ˳2ݡ19844·ĳ¶װ(LDEF)19901»գڸװõĸϲϽṹ淢ԭӺͿռƬĳʴ3ݡǰϲѿʼֱҶ״֡ǰԵͷ⺭ȺսṹЩṹڽɳĮʹʱǷʴ⡣ͼһЩʴĻ;ۺϲϳʴоſԹԱο
1ʴĻ4
1.1ʴ(erosion)
ڹ塢ֳɷֵ塢Һ֮ĻеãϵĲʧĥʴΪʴ
1.2ĥʴ(abrasive erosion)
ӵ˶򼸺ƽеĳʴΪĥʴ
1.3ʴ(impingement erosion, impact erosion)
ӵ˶洹ֱĳʴΪʴ
1.4ʴ(erosion rate)
ʴǳĵλĥ(ʴ)ĥʴİ(򱻳ʴ)ϵ(λΪg/gmg/g)̬ͨʴ׶βá
1.5ʴ(volumetric erosion rate)
Ϊ˱ȽϲͬܶȲϵĳʴ迹ͨʴһðϵܶȥʴõ(λΪcm3/kg)
2ʴװ
ݳʴӰʴ(ʧ)ҪأѾƺ˼ֳʴװáFinnie51956˵һ̨ɰʴԿӵٶ(С76m/s)ͳǡԺTilly6,7ƺƳɰʴװáһǿɰʴװãɿӳʴʱ䡢ǡ¶ȺӦгϣFalexAir˾Air Jet Erosion Testerһࡣָϵĳʴ迹ڹ涨¶Բϵĳʴ迹򣬲׼ASTM D76-83 "Standard Particle for Conducting Erosion Tests by Solid Particle Impingement Using Gas Jets"ƺġװͨһ©ĥϣʴӣ͵УƵʺ©бٶȡͨѹٶȣٶӵٶȡͨʱ٣ȻϣͨתĳǶȣ8ݡTilly, G. P. ƵһɰʴתʽʴװáװõնС10-3رתۡװĶ˲һ(򳾰ɰĥ)ԾȷƵķʽʹǶת·ϡжӽмٵ鼼ٶȽϸ߼ֱ仯ܴ(ñ׼MIL-E-5007Cֱ仯ΧΪ01000̦)װÿԸʵģʴ
1975Grant G. ˣ10ݽ˷綴͵ɰʴװãڸ¶(µ)½гʴ顣Giros-ITE ˾Sand and Dust ChamberһࡣǸñ׼MIL-STD-810E Method 510.3 Sand  DustƺģװÿģδϷеķɻڵ¶ȱ仯ΧΪ10桫70档
3ۺϲɰʴо
3.1
üַоɰʴˣʧɨ羵۲ʴʹñֲڶȲǡͨʧɱȽϲͬϿɰʴӰɰʴأɨ羵ƬͱֲڶȲĽ״ʡЩпɰʴĻ͹׼򡣱1˲ͬϳʴ迹ıȽϣԿۺϲϵĿɰʴմɵĳʴ迹൱仯ΧܴڸϲϵѡȡȡҪ󣬲ͨĻϵɰʴԡΪ˽⣬ͨҪʹô߳ʴ迹Ϳĸϲϡ

1ͬϳʴ迹ıȽ
Table 1comparison of erosion resistance for different materials

MaterialsTest conditionsTest rigImpact angle 
for (dE/de)maxRef.
AlErodent:Al2O3(74130m)
Air speed40m/s
Sand speed14.3m/sAir blast40㡫6010
Stainless steelErodent:Al2O3(74130m)
Air speed40m/s
Sand speed14.3m/sAir blast45㡫4010
TiErodent:Al2O3(74130m)
Air speed40m/s
Sand speed14.3m/sAir blast60㡫2510
CeramicErodent:Al2O3(74m)
Air speed30m/sAir blast90511011
Carbon/polymerErodent:Al2O3(74130m)
Air speed40m/s
Sand speed14.3m/sAir blastBased on
composite system50100010



3.2ʴ
ף8,16ɨ羵۲˾ۺϲϵܳʴòۺϲϵĳʴͲĥʴм׶Σ⼸׶εֱΪ
(a) ܳ֬ϱʴʹά¶ڳʴɰ
(b) ɰάΧƲ֧ά֬ʴάᴩάƣά˶ϡ
(c) ɰʹά֬Ľ˿öά֬ķѿ
ɨ羵۲쵽ĳʴͼϲϵĳʴ˰֬ϵĳˢάĽһ鼰뿪ԭλά֬ϵĳˢάʽܣ֬ϵԼάճܵȣɲͬۺϲϳʴԵĲԭ
3.3Ӱʴʵ
ϲϵĳʴԱҪӵö࣬ڲͬĳʴ£ͬһָϲϿʾͬĳʴΪԳʴҲǴԳʴ
3.3.1ܡۺϲάͻɣĳʴȡάͼǿʽԼάͻĽܵȡף10,12,13ݶЩصӰϵͳоеһЩۡ
(1) ֬17,1921ݣ ͼ1-3˸־ۺ;ۺϲϵĳʴʣԿ֬(PEEKPPSTPI-һµԾǰ)ĳʴ迹Ҫȹ֬(֬BMIǰ)ϲõ֬ǵĳʴ迹(Ӹߵ)ΪPEEKPPSBMI(˫)PI(ǰ)ڳʴӵĳȳˢ֬壬֬ϵĳʴӰۺϲϳʴ迹Ҫءͨ֬ʾԳʴԣȹ֬ʾԳʴԡ

ͼ1ͬ֬ĳʴʡͼ2ԵϲϳʴʵӰ
Fig.1Erosion rate for differentFig.2Effect of matrix on erosion rate
resinsfor tape composites

(2) ά ڹ㷺ʹõάǿУʯīάͲάǴԵģʱĳʴ迹СKevlarάʴʱҪմ(ͼ4)
(3) ά ϲϵĳʴ迹άӶӣͼ5ʾάʹøϲϱȴ֬Ҫ࣬Ӷ临ϲϵĳʴҪ֬ĳʴʳڽϴĳʱ
(4) ǿʽ ֯︴ϲϵĳʴ迹ȵϲҪСöࡣԶάǿϲϣسάṩ˺ܸߵԣ뵥̵ʽȣзʽʹ²άṩǿ֧֡ͼ6ʾΪвͬǿʽʯīά/PPSϲϳʴʵıȽϡ

ͼ3Ի֯ϲϳʴʵӰ졡ͼ4άͶԸϲϳʴʵӰ
Fig.3Effect of matrix on erosion rateFig.4Effect of fiber type on erosion 
for woven compositesrate


ͼ5άԳʴʵӰ
Fig.5Effect of fiber contents on erosion rate

ͼ6άǿʽԳʴʵӰ
Fig.6Effect of fiber reinforcement type on erosion rate
3.3.2ʴ
(1) ϣ 衢ɰʯӢɰǹӳʴгõĳʴӣΣЩģⳡĳʴҪʹȻɰʯڲͬطȻɰʯʯӢɰĺܴʱҪӲͬĵɼȻɰʯ
(2) ٶȣ ۺϲϵĳʴʴٶȵĹϵմɣָϵ14
dE/devn
մɵֵָΧͨ23.5ۺϲԼΪ3.56.0
(3) С ۺϲϵĳʴʴӳߴӶӣͼ7ʾֱָϵ16
dE/deDn
(4) ʴάн() ͼ8˳ʴʴάн()ĹϵԵάʴƽʱʴĥʴҪʴֱʱصöࡣ
3.3.3άܡάճϺãά洦ľۺϲϣʴȽϵ(ͼ9)

ͼ7άԳʴʵӰ
Fig.7Effect of interface between fiber and matrix on erosion rate 

ͼ8ʴֱԳʴʵӰ
Fig.8Effect of diameter of erodents on erosion rate

ͼ9ӳάн,¶ԳʴʵӰ
Fig.9Effect of angle  between orientations of impact and fiber on erosion rate

3.4ԿʴͿо
ף18оֿʴͿãǷֱǣӲ۰(MIL-C-83286)Ծ۰(MIL-C-83231)͵(AF-C-VBW-15-15)ͼ10ʾΪвͬͿ㸴ϲڲͬɰʴµʧͿΪԳʴԣõĳʴ迹ͼ11ʾΪ벻ͿE-ά/֬ʯӢ/ǰʧԿͿ㸴ϲϵʧҪһоֻҪͿ㱣ʴ迹൱ãĥʴʱͿĳʴ迹߲ԣʱϲϵĳʴ迹Ƚϸߣʴص⡣


ͼ10ͬͿ㲣/֬ʧǵı仯
Fig.10Change of mass loss for glass/epoxy with different coatings vs impact angles

4ԽоĳЩ
(1) ۺϲڿռṹѵõ㷺Ӧãĳ迹ϲúԶΪֹһоδõչбҪһоԷֲϵĳʴԤģͣӦӶͳʴͿϺͿ㹤յо
(2) Ϊֹеĳʴ鶼óɰװúͼ죬ʴ츽ĺСΧӵٶ켸γߴ缰ĺڵӵٶι켣ʽֲʴṩϢֻϡڽṹͨҪԼϵٶȵķֲǾȵġԴ,ֻGrant,G.ˣ9Ƶķ綴ͳʴװúͶռǲһҪ󣬲ģʹеķӶӦƹװýеĳʴ顣

߼飺(1943-)УоԱ¸ϲ˺͸ϲϽṹ;/о
ߵλ桢ʤɻǿо710065
棺鹤ҵѧ
οף
1ݡSIEBEL E, BROCKSTEDT H C. Verschleissminderung. Maschinenbau,194120457
2ݡTSIANG T H. Survey of sand and rain erosion of composite materials. Journal 
of Composite Technology & Research, 1986,8(4)5458
3ݡTENNYSON R C, HANSEN J S, MABSON G E. MORISON W D, KLEIMAN J. Composite 
materials in space: results from the LDEF satellite, Proceedings of the 
Sixth CASI Conference on Astronautics, 1990
4ݡStandard practice for conducting erosion tests by solid particle impingement 
using gas jets, ASTM G7683
5ݡFINNIE I. An experimental study of erosion. Soc Exptl Stress Analysis, 
1959,17: 6570
6ݡTILLY G P. Sand erosion of metals and plastics: a brief review. Wear, 1969,
14: 241248
7ݡTILLY G P, SAGE W. The interaction of particle and material behaviour in 
erosion processes. Wear 1970,16: 447465
8ݡPOOL K V, DHARAN C K H, FINNIE I. Erosion wear of composite materials. Wear, 
1986,107: 112
9ݡGRANT G TABAKOFF W. Erosion prediction in turbomachinery resulting from 
environmental solid Particles. Journal of Aircraft, 1975,12(5):471478
10ݡTSIANG T H, Sand erosion of fiber composites: testing and evaluation, Test 
methods for design allowables for fibrous composites: 2nd Volume. ASTM STP 
1003, 1989, 5574
11ݡCLERICO M, GIROLETTI L, CUPPINI D, CATALDO G. NDT observation and analysis 
of crater-shaped damage. Proceedings of 14th World Conference on 
Non-Destructive Testing, New Delhi, India, December 813,1996
12ݡMIYAZAKI N, HAMAO T, Effect of interfacial strength on erosion behavior of 
FRPs. Journal of Composite Materials,1996,30(1)3550
13ݡMIYAZAKIN, TAKEDA N. Solid particle erosion of fiber reinforced plastics. 
Journal of Composite Materials,199327(1) 2131
14ݡROY M, VISHWANATHAN B, SUNDARARAJAN G The solid particle erosion of 
polymer matrix composites. Wear, 1994,171: 149161
15ݡMATHIAS P J, WU W, et al. Solid particle erosion of a graphite-fiber-
reinforced bismaleiimide polymer composite. Wear, 1989,135: 161169
16ݡZAHAVI J, SCHMITT G F. Solid particle erosion of reinforced composite 
materials. Wear, 1981,71:179190
17ݡKARASEK K R, GORETTA K C, et al. Erosion in bismaleimide polymers and 
bismaleimide-polymer composites. Journal of Materials Science Letters, 
1992,11: 11431144
18ݡZAHAVI J, SCHMITT G F. Solid particle erosion of polymeric coatings. Wear, 
1981,17:191210
19ݡPEARL L S. LU G X. Erosion of impacted notched holes in GFRP composites. 
Wear, 1994,176: 8188
20ݡBRANDSTADTER A, GORETTA K C, et al. Solid-particle erosion of bismaleimide 
polymers. Wear, 1991,147:155164
21ݡZAHAVI P.WU J,GORETTA K C, et al. Solid particle erosion of a graphite-
fiber-reinforced bismaleimide polymer composite. Wear, 1989,135: 161169
ոڣ 1999-04-16޶ڣ1999-05-10
