ղѧ
JOURNAL OF AERONAUTICAL MATERIALS
1999ꡡ191ڡVol.19No.11999



Ͳλϻ͹ƣӰ
лϰ԰
ժҪ Ͳλϻ͹ƣҪӰء5͹֯ٽᾧ̶кܴĲ͹֯ٽᾧ̶ȵķɢԵƣķɢԡһķ͹֯ٽᾧ̶ȵķɢģʱԭʼСαͬɵġ⣬͹ױڱļӹȱҲǽ͹ƣһҪء
ؼʣ ͹ ƣͶѣ ٽᾧ 
ͼţV275.1ױʶ룺A±ţ1005-5053199901-0045-06

An analysis on effective factors to fatigue lives
of pull rod linking lugs of tube-shaped cases
XIE Ming-liXI Nian-shengZHAO Ai-guo
(Institute of Aeronautical Materials Beijing 100095 China)
Abstract: The cause of the diversity of fatigue lives of linking lugs of five tube-shaped cases was investigated by microfractography and metallography techniques. The recrystallization degrees of microstructure of lugs are much different. It is the diversity of recrystallization degrees that results in that of fatigue lives of lugs. The diversity of the recrystallization degrees may be resulted from the difference in deformation magnitude and original grain size of materials in die forging. In addition, another important factor of decreasing lives of lugs is machining defects in hole wall surfaces of lugs.
Key words: lug; fatigue fracture; recrystallization; grain size

ͲλϻֱͻֱĹؼ4͹ͨ4͹ĸغɡÿ͹ڿ׼϶һߵĳףΪ1Cr17Ni3װǰڽӺͿ̩680ȻװճӲ̻ʱɶ͹ĳڡΪȷͲλϻʹ͹ƣ顣оͲλϻ͹ƣ͹ƣҪӰؼƣɢԴԭ
1
1.1ϼƣ
41ëLC9CSϣ÷7075T73ģͼӹɡͲλϻĹչΪϡϡ͡뾫͡͡ȴּӹȴӹ洦װΡ4ڲͬΣԭϹͬ1ɪ150mmֱģͣ2ź3ɪ130mmΪ180mmϺٽģͣ4ɪ180mmֱģͳ͡MTS810ϽУΪ-ƣ飨ӦR0.1ö༶أӦֵΪ28.054.0kNƵΪ1530Hz
͹ƣ鵱ϸͼ1ʾ1ź2͹ؽǶΪ35.65㣬3ź4͹ؽǶΪ42.91㡣ͼݿԿ1ƣܽϺҷɢС2͹ƣ3ź4͹ƣɢԽϴ

ͼ1͹غ44kNĵӦR0.1
Fig.1Equivalent lives of lugs of tested cases under the maximum load of
44kN(Stress ratio R=0.1)
1.2Ͽںۼ
Ͳλϻòͼ2ɶ͹Уһһ͹ƻ͹Ŀ涼ֱڼط͹ԶС洦ȿѡ͹봫ĽӴҪֲ͹ڲ1/2ȷΧ1/2ȷΧ޽Ӵۡ
͹ƴ򿪣۹۲͹ϿڣϿƽ̹ϸܣΪ͵ĸƣͶѡ
1.3Ͽ΢۹۲
͹Ͽڽɨ羵۲졣͹ϿƾԴڿױڲඥǻؿױ12mm2ױڼӹֲڣڴĿ׶дĿ׶ߴ糬30m2͹ϿھԴڿױڿ׶(ͼ3)42ź4ŶϿҲԴڱȱݣ͹ϿԴδִĿ׶͵ڶҲδȱݡ
1.4͹ͱ߷
δѵ4-3Ŷ϶̵4-2Ŷͱ߼飬òֲϺã͹ֲ
1.5֯
͹ϿλøȡԿĥƽͺ֯ױڸ֯ͼ4ʾ֯ͼ5ʾ͹֯δȹδдִڶڶ״̶ֲȸ͹֯𣬵𲢲ܴ󡣸֯ҪھСٽᾧ̶ϡ1͹ڱڸ֯ΪϸСȣֲн϶ϸСٽᾧٽᾧ̶Ƚϸߣ2š33-3ٽᾧ̶ȽϸߣΪϸС⣬֯Ϊִٽᾧ̶Ƚϵ͡4ٽᾧ̶ȸͣƺտʼٽᾧڻظ׶ΣдڴϸСǾ(ͼ5d򡢺֯Ϊִĵᾧ֯δԡִִٽᾧ֯ȫٽᾧڱ¼ʱٽᾧγɵġ

ͼ2Ͳλϻòͼ32-2ϿԴ׶ò
Fig.2Configuration of theFig.3Appeartubeance of the hole at the
 tubeshaped caseoriginal area of the fracture surface of lug2-2

1.6Ӳȼ
Ը͹вӲȼ飬ڱ1ɱɼ1ż͹Ӳֵͣ4żߣ2ź3żУǵٽᾧ̶ġ
2
ÿ͹غԼΪ1000mm2ʩӵѭغΪ54kN͹ӦΪ54MPaԶСϽƣͼަҪ-10.3Ҫb150.0MPa͹Ӧþкܸߵƣ


ͼ4͹֯
a1-1(b2-2c3-1d4-3eF-1
Fig.4Longitudinal metallographic microstructure of lugs of tested cases
(a) lug 1-1(b) lug 2-2(c) lug 3-1(d) lug 4-3(e) lug F-1


ͼ5͹֯
a1-1b3-1c3-3d4-3
Fig.5Transverse metallographic microstructure of lugs of tested cases
(a) lug 1-1;(b) lug 3-1; (c) lug 3-3; (d) lug 4-3

1͹Ӳȼ kgf/mm2
Table 1Brinell hardness of lugs kgf/mm2

Number
of tested
casesLug 1Lug 2Lug 3Lug 4
Tested
numberAverage
valueTested
numberAverage
valueTested
numberAverage
valueTested
numberAverage
value
1148,149,150149146,148,151148.3148,147,150148.3
2148,149,157151.3157,156,154155.6147,150,152149.7
3154,154,156154.7151,152,148150.3151,151,150150.7
4155,155,155155152,155,159155.3160,158,157158.3155,157,157156.3
F (foreign
case)151,151,152151.3



ʵ͹ǲȵġ͹봫ĽӴغҪֲ͹ڲ1/2ȷΧ1/2ȷΧ޽ӴۣòֲػغС͹ĳؽṹġм֧һ͹غ·Σ֧ԽԶԽ󡣴Ĳʹغ·ֲδĩغɼСС֧㸽λغˣ֧͹ڲ฽ӦֲԪ1ݣѭغΪ44kNʱ֧͹ڲֲӦɴ200MPaѳϽƣͼޣټһЩӦУӹȱݡȣӰ죬ֲӦ󳬹ƣͼ޶ƣͶѵķ
ǰ5͹֯ٽᾧ̶ȴںܴ졣ڲϵƣܶԲ֯СΪУ֯ٽᾧ̶ȵĲֱӵ²ƣܵĲͬо24ݣٽᾧ֯ƣܵӰһɷΪ41 ٽᾧ̶ȸʱ60侧ΪϸСȣƣܽϺã2 ٽᾧ̶ƫʱ10%20ȣٽᾧľǳϸСδٽᾧľΪִϸʡ״Χƴִδٽᾧƣܽϲ3 δٽᾧٽᾧ̶ȺܵͣǱ֯ڱнϸߵǿȣҲнϺõƣܣ4 ȫٽᾧ֯˾γɴִĵᾧƣִ󽵵͡ΪƣҪȡƣκٽᾧ̶ȽϸʱΪϸС϶࣬ȡϴЧ谭ƣκ˽׶εľ滬ƣӻִפ뼷γɣӶƣκִʱھ٣γɴִĻפٽƣκĽ÷41żٽᾧ̶Ƚϸߣӽڵһƣϸߣ2ż3żٽᾧ̶Ƚϵͣڵڶܲȣƣܾͽϲ3żе3-3нϸߵٽᾧ̶ȣƣӦߣδѣ4ٽᾧ̶Ⱥܵͣڵ3ƣҲϺã4-14-3ƣϸߣ4-24-4ƣܵƣԴȱݣƣκԵʣΪ4дִĵᾧƣܺܲ
ȱݵĴڻᵼ²ֲӦУٽƣƵӶ󽵵ƣ24͹ϿƾԴ͹ڿױ׶׶ĴڴٽƣƵ24͹ƣձƫ͵һҪԭ
ٽᾧ̱Ƚϸӣαα¶ȡԭʼСԼ˻¶ȡ˻ʱȾӰ쵽ٽᾧķ̶ȺٽᾧĴСαԽα¶ԽͣԭʼԽϸСٽᾧľҲԽϸСҪǿһԭʼСٽᾧӰ죬ΪӰױӡ4ģ͹ղµĲ:2״ֵ̬ĺδֵģ2αСɪ150mmģͺɪ180mmģ͡칤ղĲ4֯ٽᾧ̶Ȳͬ4ڰֱģͣԭʼϴ֣ģͱС͵ٽᾧ̶ȣϻڻظ׶Σ2ź3ڰϾ֣ԭʼСģͱСٽᾧ̶Խϵͣ1δ֣ģͱܴٽᾧ̶Ƚϸߡɼ4֯ٽᾧ̶ȲͬģʱԭʼСԼģͱͬɵġ
3ᡡ
15͹֯ٽᾧ̶ȴڱȽԵĲ죬ǵƣɢԴҪء
2͹ױڱڵȱǵƣ͵Ҫ֮һ
3֯ٽᾧ̶ȲͬģʱԭʼСԼģαͬɵġ
4Ӧϸģ͹ղرҪעԲԭʼȵĿƣԱòȫٽᾧĲȴִ֯
߼飺 л(1967-) У ˶ʿ ʦ
ߵλղоԺ 100095
ο:
1XI N S,Xi M L,et al.An investigation on fatigue life scatter of Al-5.6Zn-2.5Mg-
1.6Cu lugs in cases.Engineering Failure Analysis,1999,Accepted
2ݰпɽ J D.ϵĶ.ؿ,ٿƵ. ҵ磬
1985.321324
3ݶؽ  .ϽƷ֯. ,л. ұҵ
磬1984.287288
4壬. ͲĴ֡ϸƣܶԱо. չռ1997(6)3738
ոڣ 1998-09-28
