ղѧ
JOURNAL OF AERONAUTICAL MATERIALS
1999ꡡ192ڡVol.19No.21999



ϽڸȻеӦѭµƣ
ʩݻƶά
ժҪϽӦƸµܵƣͺͬλȻеƣ顣ڵƣѡȡʵ¶Ϊ350500棬Ȼеƣѭ¶ȷΧΪ350-500档ݲɼĲӦӦӦѭƻԿ¶ȵı仯ԲƣܴӰ죬¶ѭӦѭʱ˵ĳ̶ȡѭߵķÿһƣоѭѭ󡣶ƻԼ΢۽ṹڸӦѭ£ϽƻǴϹ̡
ؼʣ ȻеƣͣϽ¶ѭӦѭ
ͼţTG146.142ױʶ룺 A±ţ 10055053(1999)020013-070
Fatigue behavior of molybdenum alloy under hightemperature
thermomechanical stress cycles
SHI Hui-jiKORN CPLUVINAGE G 
(1.Department of Engineering Mechanics,Tsinghua University,Beijing 100084,China'2.University of Metz,Metz 57045, France)
Abstract: High temperature isothermal mechanical fatigue and in-phase thermomechanical fatigue(TMF) tests in stress control were carried out on a molybdenum alloy.Two temperature levels of 350 and 500桡were applied to isothermal fatigue test and a temperature interval of 350-500 to TMF tests. The fatigue lives obtained in the in-phase TMF tests is lower than the ones obtained in the isothermal mechanical tests at the same stress amplitude.It appears that an additional damage produced gy the reaction of mechanical stress cycles and temperature cycles in TMF situation.Ratching pheomenon occurred during the tests with and increasing creep rate and it dependent on temperature and load amplitude. The observations of the microstructure of the damaged specimens demonstrated that the fracture was a brittle process under higher cyclic stress conditions.A simple model of lifetime prediction was it is based on   Woehler-Miner law. The lifetime prediction gives results corresponding to experimental data.
Key words: thermomechanical fatigue;molybdenum alloy;temperature cycles;stress control cyclesl
Ŀǰںպ򣬸¹̶Ͳ˸ߵҪڶУǿǿȺȳܡϽTZMһӦڸ¹еۺϽ1,2ݡ켼ĸĽ״ĲȻϽܸӵغʱҪýһݡ
๤̽ṹӦУܵеԼ¶ȱ仯ܵ͵ơ, ¶ȱ仯ڲڲкӦӦ佫Ӱṹʹ˲Ӧ˽µƣܣҸҪоϵķǵƣԡĿǰ๤̲ϵʣȻеƣõ˷չȻеƣУԼϵغѭеӦӦѭ¶ȵӹɣӦȻеƣ鼼ԶԲϵƣͺȳܽϵͳϸµо35ݡ
оϽڵºȻеѭ¸ƣܡƣ 350 500
¶½У¶ѭӦѭͬλȻеƣ¶ȷΧΪ350500
½СеΪӦƣӦΧΪ8001200MPaͨԼƻλ
ԺͱȽȻеƣͺ͵ƣͼѭӦ˸ƣ͵˻ƣƣ
˹㡣
1ʺ
ϽTZMһƷĸºϽԼ0.5%, 0.08%ﯺ0.01%0.04%̼ЩԪصļ빹ϸܺ;̼ֹܹڸ¾ĳϽĻѧɷֱֺܷɱ1ͱ2ƣͺȻеƣԼΪԲΣԼγȴ20mmֱΪ8mmƣǰԼ׹Էֹڻ
еӹ۴ʼ΢ƶƣ
1ϽTZMĻѧɷ֣wt%
Table 1Composition of the molybdenum alloy,wt%
MoTiZrCOHNFeNiSi
99.30.50.080.030.030.00050.00050.0050.0010.003


2Ͻ TZM ʪ
Table 2Physical properties of the molybdenum alloy
Temperature
/Thermal
conductivity
/(W/mm.K)Specificheat
/(J/g.K)Thermal
expansion
coefficient
/(1/K)0.2%yield
strength
/ MPaTensile
strength
/ MPaModulus of
elasticity
/ MPa 
200.1250.245.310-65906853.2105
5000.1150.255.610-63.0105
10000.1000.296.010-62.7105


Ȼеƣɻеѭ¶ѭӹɡеѭҺѹŷʵ֣¶ѭڱںĵƷ¯ʵ֡ӦĲɸ߾ȸӦʵֵģΪ˱µӰ죬尲װڼ¯࣬ϵͷΪШεʯӢ¯壬гԼϡȵżϵͳӦϵͳպϻ·ͨԶͿӦ¶ѭķȡƵʺλϵ
ΪоϵƣͺȻеƣʣ飺350500µƣͣ¶ȱ仯ΧΪ350500ͬλȻеƣ͡¶ȺӦ仯ΪΣÿΪ1minϽǴԲϣʵӦƣ飬еڵӦ½Сڵƣͣѡȡ80010001200MPaӦΧȻеƣͣѡȡ80090010001200MPaӦΧȻеƣУ¶ѭӦѭͬƵʺͬλģӦӦ¶ȣѹӦӦ¶ȡУе豸ɼԶɣеҲԶ¼
2
2.1ƣ
ͼ1ӦΧѭƻĹϵƣߣSNߣ350500ƣ֮䣬ƣûԵĲ˵ϽϱĸѭǿȡȻȻеƣĽͬӦΧ£Ȼеƣ͵ֵƣ͵¶ȵı仯ʹԼĽγ¶ݶȣ˸ӦӦ䡣

ͼ1ƣͺȻеƣߡͼ2Ӧƣѭʾͼ
Fig.1Experimental S-N curves of Fig.2Schematic showing of the creep
isothermal and thermomechanical fatiguein stress control fatiguephenomenon

2.2ѭ
ео۲쵽ѭͼ2ʾڴУ俪ʼѹӦ䷽չﵽƣ210ʱ䷽תӦ䷽ֱԼѡʴӿʼһֱ״̬ѭǺӦǿȺ¶صģѭӦΧԽѭԽأͬѭӦΧ¶ԽߣѭԽԡ
2.3ӦӦӦ
¼УԵõƣӦ-ӦӦҪĽڱ3WT5BXұʾӦΧŪp ʾӦ䣬Wp ʾӦܶȣѭڵWT5BZNfʾѭƻ
ֵעǣǵƣͻȻеƣ飬ڵһѭֻкСӦ(0.01%)غжؼǵԵġȻӦѭӣԼǰﵽˮƽ800MPa鳬0.36%1200MPa鳬1.0%Ӧı仯˲ӦѭܡӦܶȵı仯ǺӦƵģڵһѭߺխѭӣԽԽ
3Ҫ
Table 3Main results of isothermal and thermomechanical fatigue tests
Type of
testsSpecimen
number Stress
range /MPap at
halftime /%p before
fracture/%p at
halftime
/MJm-3p before
fracture
/MJm-3Nf
/Cycles
350
Isothermal
FatigueTZM01
TZM02
TZM03800
1000
12000.28
0.35
0.550.40
0.72
1.051.74
2.51
3.742.64
5.92
8.666600
380
36
500
Isothermal
FatigueTZM04
TZM05
TZM06800
1000
12000.24
0.33
0.600.42
0.75
1.251.30
2.38
4.352.78
6.14
10.856020
410
26
350-500
Thermo-
mechanical
FatigueTZM07
TZM08
TZM09
TZM10800
900
1000
12000.26
0.31
0.34
0.780.36
0.52
0.58
1.501.38
2.04
2.42
5.121.86
3.22
3.90
12.605250
810
140
18

24
ԲͬӦˮƽ飬Լõɨ羵˹۲졣ڽϵӦѭ£800MPaΪԶСԼռ10󲿷ΪԶڽϸߵӦѭ£ڶ漸ҲԶ򣬶ϿʾΪȫԶѡͼ31000MPaȻеƣͶϿڵͼ3aϿ״̬ͼ3bΪֲŴ󲿷֣ϿڵòΪԶѡڶϿϣԷ΢ƣѭӦԽߣĽϳ΢Խࡣ΢۽ṹĹ۲Կ΢չΪ翪ʽڶҵѻļǷǾ״̬ġƵչɾչʹԽﹹɵġ

ͼ31000MPaȻеƣԼϿòͼ
(a)Ͽ״̬;(b)ֲڵĴԶ̬
Fig.3The SEM image on the fracture surface of 1000 TMF test 
(a)Total fracture and (b)brittle fracture in detail
3ƣģ
еƣԤģУڵƣͣȻеƣ򣬳ģͲڴǽһ򵥵ԤģͣڹӦƵºͺȻеƣڴģУ¶ȱ仯˵ԿǡWoehler-Minerʽÿһѭ˿ԱʾΪӦmaxƽӦĺ[6-8]
(1)
ʽЦuǿ;l()M()ƽӦĺ,ɷֱʾΪ:
(2)
˴loƣͼޣbƽӦӰϵʽ(1)ǵϵºMoƣͼޡۻ¶йءǵʵУⲿغɲƽӦСΪ㣬˹ʽ1ԼΪ
(3)
ڵƣͼ,Moͦ¿Ϊ¶ȵĺ.Ϊƣƻܴ,ɶʽ,赱N=0D=0ԼN=NfD=1:
(4)
ȻеƣͼУҪС¶ȱ仯ĸӦÿһѭ˲ӦmaxƽӦĺ¶Tmax¶ѭΧTй,ɱʾΪ:
(5)
ΪõȽϼ򵥵ģ,Ϊʽ(1)(3)ʽȻеƣ͵,=0ʱд:
(6)
ڹʽMoͦ¶Ⱥ¶ȷΧĺ.ϵMoԴӵƣ͵нƵõ,ڵЧ¶TeʱĵƣȻеƣͲͬ.ϽȻеƣ͹,ѭӵ,ϵ±ʾΪ¶ѭصĺ:
(7)
ʽ(7)¶ȵĵλþ¶ȱʾ,ϵȡѭͻеѭλϵ.ͬƣͼ,Թʽ(6),N=0D=0ԼN=NfD=1:
(8)
˴(Nf)TMFȻеƣƻܴΡ
4гʵݺͼıȽ,(Nf)exp.ʾʵƣ,(Nf)cal.ʾƣ.ģ;һʵüֵ
Isothermal Fatigue at 350
M0=1120,=8.20Isothermal Fatigue at 350
M0=1160,=8.05Isothermal Fatigue at 350
M0=1140,=7.53
max
/MPa(Nf)exp.
/cycles(Nf)cal.
/cyclesmax
/MPa(Nf)exp.
/cycles(Nf)cal.
/cyclesmax
/MPa(Nf)exp.
/cycles(Nf)cal
/cycles
400660080304006020659040052503320
-------450810872
500380480500410438500140250
600363460026253001816

4
ӦΧߴs00wtPaϣΪӦƵƣ顣ǿȺͼǿȣi200MPaӦΧУӦкѹӦѺܽӽϵǿȼޣѭƻΪ2040Ǻġ
΢۽ṹ۲ڽϵ͵ӦΧt800MPaƣڿԷΪ׶ΣȡչԼϣֱӦϿϱ濪ѣԶѺʹԶѡڽϸߵӦΧֻ׶ΣʹԶJѭӦˮƽԽߣϵƻԽߵĴԡ
ڱоУȻеƣ¶ȱ仯ΧǺܴ󣬽150棬Ȼ¶ȵĵƣȣȻеƣͲصˡ¶ȱ仯£¶ȵƣݽи¹ƣһõصĽΪ˸˽ºͷǵƣ͵ʣӦһȡϽƣͺͶݣ͵ӦΧ͸¶ȱ仯Χ
5
ϽӦƵܵƣͺȻеƣĽõ½ۣ
1350500ƣ֮䣬ƣûԵĲͬӦΧȻеƣ͵ڵƣʾ¶ȵı仯Բϲ˽һЧӦӦƣУѭѭѭӦΧ¶ȱ仯Χйء
2ڵƣͻȻеƣУӦɵһѭǳСֱֵһѭﵽԼ0.4%1.5%,Ӧѭ,ʾѭ.ϳܵѭӦˮƽԽ,ԽʾߵĴ.ͬӦΧ,Ȼеƣ͵ֵƣ͵.ԽļģͿ¶ȱ仯Ӱ,ʵݡ
ע:ĿȻѧĿ(59571037)
߼飺ʩݻ(1951-)Уʿѧ͹רҵ
ߵλʩݻ廪ѧѧϵ 100084
ƶά:Universite of Metz, Metz 57045, France
οף
[1]CALDERON H A, KOSTORZ G.Mater Sci Eng,1993,A160:189199
[2]JAKOBEIT W,PFEIFFER J P, WLRICH G.Nuclear Technology, 1984,66:195
[3]SEHITOGLU H,KARASEK M. J Eng Mater Tech ASME,1986,108:192198
[4]KRAFT S,ZAUTER R, MUGHRABI H. Fatigue Fract Eng Mater Struct,1993,16:237253
[5]SHI H J,WANG Z G,SU H H. Scripta Materialia,1996,35:11071113
[6]LANDGRAF R W.Fundamentals of fatigue characterizations of metals,SAE(1982)1118
[7]SOCIE D F,MORROW J.Risk and failure Analysis for improved performance and 
reliability,Burke JJ,Weiss V,Plenum Lishing Corp,1980:141194
[8]LEMAITRE J,CHABOCHE J L.Mcanique des Matriaux. BORDAS,Pars,1985:361367
ոڣ1999-03-12޶ڣ1999-04-02
