ѧ
JOURNAL OF SOFTWARE
2000Vol.11No.3P.346-362




ȫЭ߼֤
桡ԡ˶ʦӱ
ժҪǰĹ,ѶԵȫ(secure electronic transactions,SET)гȡƬν֤,ҲSETпܴڵ˳̽.ڴ˻,SETҵ̽ϸ߼֤,ͨʽ߼֤,SETЭдڵһЩ,νЩ˳̽.
ؼʡϢȫ,߼֤,,׷.
ͼšTP309
Logical Verification of Secure Electronic Transactions Protocol
CHEN Qing-fengBAI ShuoSUI Li-ying
(National Research Center for Intelligent Computers Beijing 100080)
CHEN Qing-fengZHANG Shi-chao
(Department of Mathemetics and Computer Science Guangxi Normal University Guilin 541005)
WANG Ju
(Institute of Software The Chinese Academy of Sciences Beijing 100080)
AbstractIn the previous work,some segments of secure electronic transactions (SET) are verified,and some potential problems in SET are also discussed.Based on these,all transactions in SET are strictly logically verified in this paper.Though this formal logic verification,certain problems are found to do exist in SET.Solutions to these problems are also discussed.
Key wordsInformation security,logical verification,accountability,traceable.
,ԽԽ֯͸ͨʻInternetͺͽϢ,Ҿͳֱ,ᾭõķչ,ڳ.ЩϴϢ,Ҷעͬһ⡪Ϣȫ.һ,˺ܶౣϢȫķʩ.
ĿǰϱȽейϢȫоԷΪ¼.ǱȽϴͳ,ѧֶζԼ㷨иĽ,ﵽҪĿ,ܡױƵ,ͬʱҲȽϳѶ,޷ͨǷֶλȡϢΪ.һЩҵ,һɺӵĻ.һЩ¿ƼӦ,ձĸ߿ƼоϢѧϵKenichi HAYASHI,Eiji OKAMOTOMasahiro MAMBO1ݸÿʹϰ,һģʽʶϵͳ,ͿԱϳÿ˵,ֻڷʿ,޷Ϣڴݹеİȫ.ʵҵLiWu ChangIra S.Moskowitz2ݲؼҪϢϢֵͨý绰ߡE-mailķʽ,һص,ʺͨ.һڽϱȽϹ㷺оAgent3,ͨһЩȫAgentԶϢ,н.Щŵ,ǶҪʹö,ڽҵ,ӳɱ֧,һ豸,ͻ޷صĺ.ȫЭĳ,һ̶Щ֮,Э鱾൱,Ƿиɻ,޷ƾֱ,˲ʽ߼֤4,5,ף6жNDL߼ܵչ,Ѿɹ֤˵ȫ(secure electronic transactions,SET)7еĲ.ܵĿ,ʽ߼֤ϽصڰȫЭ֤Ҫ.
ף6,8ݹĻϣڵ1жSETЭ֤̽.2ڳ֤̽зֵ.һڶԱĽܽ.
1 SETЭ߼֤
ף6ֻоSET3,չNDL߼ܶǽ߼֤.潫SETҵ̵5׶εȫ֤.
Ǹ:
3.Know(x,CertS(y))Know(x,Spb(y)).
֤:
(1) Know(x,CertS(y))
ǰ
(2) Know(x,Sign(CA,y,Spb(y)))
(1)۶
(3) Know(x,y,Spb(y),S(H(y,Spb(y)),Spv(CA)))
(2)۶
(4) Know(x,y,Spb(y))
(3)6-1
(5) Know(x,Spb(y))
(4)6-1
(5)Ϊ.

4.Know(x,CertK(y))Know(x,Kpb(y)).
֤ͬ3.
1.1 SETЭеĳֿע֤
֪:
P={Know(CA,CertS(CA)),Know(CA,CertK(CA)),Know(C,Acct(C)),Know(C,Spb(CARoot)),
Know(C,Kpb(CARoot))},
=Generate(C,InitReq)Send(C,CA,InitReq)Generate(CA,InitRes)
Send(CA,C,Sign(CA,InitRes))Send(CA,C,CertS(CA))Send(CA,C,CertK(CA))
Verify(C,CertS(CA),X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)Verify(C,CertK(CA),X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
Generate(C,RegFormReq)Generate(C,k1)Send(C,CA,E(RegFormReq,k1))
Send(C,CA,S(k1,Acct(C),Kpb(CA)))Generate(CA,RegForm)
Send(CA,C,CertS(CA))Send(CA,C,Sign(CA,RegForm))
Verify(C,CertS(CA),X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)Generate(C,Spb(C),Spv(C))
Generate(C,Filled-RegForm)Generate(C,CertReq)Generate(C,k2)
Generate(C,k3)Send(C,CA,E(Sign(C,CertReq,k2,Spb(C)),k3))
Send(C,CA,S(k3,Acct(C),Kpb(CA)))Legal(CA,CertReq)
Generate(CA,CertS(C))Generate(CA,CertRes)
Send(CA,C,E(Sign(CA,CertRes),k2))Send(CA,C,CertS(CA))
Send(CA,C,CertS(C))Verify(C,CertS(CA),X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
Verify(C,CertS(C),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot),
Q={Auth(C,X2,CA,Spb(CA)),Auth(C,X2,CA,Kpb(CA)),Auth(C,CA,InitRes),
Auth(C,X2,CA,Spb(CA)),Auth(C,CA,RegForm),
Auth(CA,C,CertReq,k2,Spb(C));Auth(C,X2,CA,Spb(CA)),
Auth(C,CA,C,Spb(C)),Auth(C,CA,CertRes)}.
֤:PQ
֤:
(1) Know(CA,CertS(CA))
ǰ
(2) Know(CA,CertK(CA))
ǰ
(3) Know(C,Acct(C))
ǰ
(4) Know(C,Spb(CARoot))
ǰ
(5) Know(C,Kpb(CARoot))
ǰ
(6) Generate(C,InitReq)
۶
(7) Know(C,InitReq)
(6)R-2
(8) Send(C,CA,InitReq)
۶
(9) Know(CA,InitReq)
(8)R-1
(10) Generate(CA,InitRes)
۶
(11) Know(CA,InitRes)
(10)R-2
(12) Know(CA,Spv(CA))
2-2
(13) Know(CA,S(H(InitRes),Spv(CA)))
(11)(12)4-2
(14) Know(CA,InitRes,S(H(InitRes),Spv(CA)))
(11)(13)6-1
(15) Know(CA,Sign(CA,InitRes))
(14)۶
(16) Send(CA,C,Sign(CA,InitRes))
۶
(17) Send(CA,C,CertS(CA))
۶
(18) Send(CA,C,CertK(CA))
۶
(19) Know(C,Sign(CA,InitRes))
(16)R-1
(20) Know(C,CertS(CA))
(17)R-1
(21) Know(C,CertK(CA))
(18)R-1
(22) Verify(C,CertS(CA),X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(4)(20)۶
/*ʧ,CûPKIҵCARoot,ֹֿͣע
X2ǷCertS(CA)һCA*/
(23) IsVerified(C,X2,CertS(CA))
(22)R-6
(24) Auth(C,X2,CA,Spb(CA))
(23)7-1
/* X2,...,Xn-1,CARootΪPKIĸ֤Ȩ*/
(25) Verify(C,CertK(CA),X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot) 
(4)(21)۶
/*ʧ,CûPKIҵCARoot,ֹֿͣע*/
(26) IsVerified(C,X2,CertK(CA))
(25)R-6
(27) Auth(C,X2,CA,Kpb(CA))
(26)7-2
/*X2,...,Xn-1,CARootΪPKIĸ֤Ȩ*/
(28) Know(C,Spb(CA))
(20)۶3
(29) Auth(C,CA,InitRes)
(19)(28)۶2
(30) Generate(C,RegFormReq)
۶
(31) Know(C,RegFormReq)
(30)[R-2]
(32) Generate(C,k1)
۶
(33) Know(C,k1)
(32)R-2
(34) Know(C,E(RegFormReq,k1))
(31)(33)1-1
(35) Know(C,k1,Acct(C))
(3)(34)6-1
(36) Know(C,Kpb(CA))
(21)۶4
(37) Know(C,S(k1,Acct(C),Kpb(CA)))
(35)(36)1-2
(38) Send(C,CA,E(RegFormReq,k1))
۶
(39) Send(C,CA,S(k1,Acct(C),Kpb(CA)))
۶
(40) Know(CA,E(RegFormReq,k1))
(38)R-1
(41) Know(CA,S(k1,Acct(C),Kpb(CA)))
(39)R-1
(42) Know(CA,k1,Acct(C))
(41)2-1ݣ3-2
(43) Know(CA,k1)
(42)6-1
(44) Know(CA,Acct(C))
(42)6-1
(45) Know(CA,RegFormReq)
(40)(43)3-1
(46) Generate(CA,RegForm)
۶
(47) Know(CA,RegForm)
(46)R-2
(48) Know(CA,H(RegForm))
(47)4-1
(49) Know(CA,S(H(Regform),Spv(CA)))
(47)(12)4-2
(50) Know(CA,Sign(CA,RegForm))
(47)(49)۶
(51) Send(CA,C,CertS(CA))
۶
(52) Send(CA,C,Sign(CA,RegForm))
۶
(53) Know(C,CertS(CA))
(51)R-1
(54) Know(C,Sign(CA,RegForm))
(52)R-1
(55) Verify(C,CertS(CA),X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(4)(53)۶
/*ʧ,CûPKIҵCARoot,ֹֿͣע*/
(56) IsVerified(C,X2,CertS(CA))
(55)R-6
(57) Auth(C,X2,CA,Spb(CA))
(56)7-1
(58) Know(C,Spb(CA))
(53)۶3
(59) Auth(C,CA,RegForm)
(54)(58)۶2
(60) Generate(C,Spb(C),Spv(C))
۶
(61) Know(C,Spb(C))
(60)R-2
(62) Know(C,Spv(C))
(60)R-2
(63) Generate(C,Filled-RegForm)
۶
/*ֿCעϢ/eg,ֿ˵,,ʵַԼһЩڻʶǷΪֿ˵Ϣ*/
(64) Generate(C,CertReq)
۶
/*CertReqаעRegFormϢ*/
(65) Know(C,CertReq)
(64)R-2
(66) Generate(C,k2)
۶
(67) Know(C,k2)
(66)R-2
(68) Know(C,CertReq,k2,Spb(C))
(65)(67)(61)6-1
(69) Know(C,S(H(CertReq,k2,Spb(C)),Spv(C)))
(68)(62)4-2
(70) Know(C,Sign(C,CertReq,k2,Spb(C)))
(68)(69)۶
(71) Generate(C,k3)
۶
(72) Know(C,k3)
(71)R-2
(73) Know(C,E(Sign(C,CertReq,k2,Spb(C)),k3)
(70)(72)1-1
(74) Know(C,k3,Acct(C))
(3)(72)6-1
(75) Know(C,S(k3,Acct(C),Kpb(CA)))
(74)(36)1-2
(76) Send(C,CA,E(Sign(C,CertReq,k2,Spb(C)),k3))
۶
(77) Send(C,CA,S(k3,Acct(C),Kpb(CA)))
۶
(78) Know(CA,E(Sign(C,CertReq,k2,Spb(C)),k3))
(76)R-1
(79) Know(CA,S(k3,Acct(C),Kpb(CA)))
(77)R-1
(80) Know(CA,k3,Acct(C))
(79)2-1ݣ3-2


(81) Know(CA,k3)
(80)6-1
(82) Know(CA,Acct(C))
(80)6-1
(83) Know(CA,Sign(C,CertReq,k2,Spb(C)))
(78)(81)3-1
(84) Know(CA,CertReq,k2,Spb(C))
(83)۶
(85) Know(CA,CertReq)
(84)6-1
(86) Know(CA,k2)
(84)6-1
(87) Know(CA,Spb(C))
(84)6-1
(88) Auth(CA,C,CertReq,k2,Spb(C))
(83)(87)۶2
(89) Legal(CA,CertReq)
۶
/*CAóֿ֪Acct(C)CertReqעϢCertReqĺϷ*/
(90) Generate(CA,CertS(C))
۶
(91) Know(CA,CertS(C))
(90)R-2
(92) Generate(CA,CertRes)
۶
(93) Know(CA,CertRes)
(92)۶
(94) Know(CA,S(H(CertRes),Spv(CA)))
(93)2-2ݣ4-2
(95) Know(CA,Sign(CA,CertRes))
(93)(94)۶
(96) Know(CA,E(Sign(CA,CertRes),k2))
(86)(95)1-1
(97) Send(CA,C,E(Sign(CA,CertRes),k2))
۶
(98) Send(CA,C,CertS(CA))
۶
(99) Send(CA,C,CertS(C))
۶
(100) Know(C,E(Sign(CA,CertRes),k2))
(97)R-1
(101) Know(C,CertS(CA))
(98)R-1
(102) Know(C,CertS(C))
(99)R-1
(103) Verify(C,CertS(CA),X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(4)(101)۶
/*ʧ,CûPKIҵCARoot,ֹֿͣע*/ 
(104) IsVerified(C,X2,CertS(CA))
(103)R-6
(105) Auth(C,X2,CA,Spb(CA))
(104)7-1
(106) Verify(C,CertS(C),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(4)(102)۶
/*ʧ,CûPKIҵCARoot,ֹֿͣע*/
(107) IsVerified(C,CA,CertS(C))
(106)R-6
(108) Auth(C,CA,C,Spb(C))
(107)7-1
(109) Know(C,Sign(CA,CertRes))
(67)(100)3-1
(110) Know(C,Spb(CA))
(102)۶3
(111) Auth(C,CA,CertRes)
(109)(110)۶2
(112) ֿ˴洢֤CertS(C)ԼCAĻشеϢ,Ժĵ
1.2 SETЭе̼ע֤
֪:
P={Know(CA,CertS(CA)),Know(CA,CertK(CA)),Know(M,Acct(M)),Know(M,Spb(CARoot))},
=Generate(M,InitReq)Send(M,CA,InitReq)Generate(CA,RegForm)
Send(CA,M,Sign(CA,RegForm))Send(CA,M,CertS(CA))Send(CA,M,CertK(CA))
Verify(M,CertS(CA),X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
Verify(M,CertK(CA),X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)Generate(M,Spb(M),Spv(M))
Generate(M,Kpb(M),Kpv(M))Generate(M,Filled-RegForm)
Generate(M,CertReq)Generate(M,k1)
Send(M,CA,E(Sign(M,CertReq,Spb(M),Kpb(M)),k1))
Send(M,CA,S(Acct(M),k1,Spb(CA)))Legal(CA,CerReq)
Generate(CA,CertS(M))Generate(CA,CertK(M))Generate(CA,CertRes)
Send(CA,M,Sign(CA,CertRes))Send(CA,M,CertS(M))Send(CA,M,CertK(M))
Send(CA,M,CertS(CA))Verify(M,CertS(CA),X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
Verify(M,CertK(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
Verify(M,CertS(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot),
Q={Auth(M,X2,CA,Spb(CA)),Auth(M,CA,RegForm);
Auth(CA,M,CertReq,Spb(M),Kpb(M));Auth(M,CA,M,Spb(M)),
Auth(M,CA,M,Kpb(M)),Auth(M,X2,CA,Spb(CA)),Auth(M,CA,CertRes)}.
֤:PQ
֤:
(1) Know(CA,CertS(CA))
ǰ
(2) Know(CA,CertK(CA))
ǰ
(3) Know(M,Acct(M))
ǰ
(4) Know(M,Spb(CARoot))
ǰ
(5) Generate(M,InitReq)
۶
(6) Know(M,InitReq)
(5)R-2
(7) Send(M,CA,InitReq)
۶
(8) Know(CA,InitReq)
(7)R-1
(9) Generate(CA,RegForm)
۶
(10) Know(CA,RegForm)
(9)R-2
(11) Know(CA,S(H(RegForm),Spv(CA)))
(10)2-2ݣ4-2
(12) Know(CA,Sign(CA,RegForm))
(10)(11)۶
(13) Send(CA,M,Sign(CA,RegForm))
۶
(14) Send(CA,M,CertS(CA))
۶
(15) Send(CA,M,CertK(CA))
۶
(16) Know(M,Sign(CA,RegForm))
(13)R-1
(17) Know(M,CertS(CA))
(14)R-1
(18) Know(M,CertK(CA))
(15)R-1
(19) Verify(M,CerS(CA),X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(17)(4)۶
/*ʧ,MûPKIҵCARoot,ֹ̼ͣע*/
(20) IsVerified(M,X2,CertS(CA))
(19)R-6
(21) Auth(M,X2,CA,Spb(CA))
(20)7-1
(22) Verify(M,CerK(CA),X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(18)(4)۶
(23) IsVerified(M,X2,CertK(CA))
(22)R-6
(24) Auth(M,X2,CA,Kpb(CA))
(23)7-1
(25) Know(M,Spb(CA))
(17)۶3
(26) Auth(M,CA,RegForm)
(16)(25)۶2
(27) Generate(M,Spb(M),Spv(M))
۶
(28) Generate(M,Kpb(M),Kpv(M))
۶
(29) Know(M,Spb(M))
(27)R-2
(30) Know(M,Spv(M))
(27)R-2
(31) Know(M,Kpb(M))
(28)R-2
(32) Know(M,Kpv(M))
(28)R-2
(33) Generate(M,Filled-RegForm)
۶
/*̼עϢ(eg,,ַ,֤)*/
(34) Generate(M,CertReq)
۶
/*CertReqаעRegFormϢ*/
(35) Know(M,CertReq)
(34)R-2
(36) Know(M,CertReq,Spb(M),Kpb(M))
(29)(31)(35)6-1
(37) Know(M,S(H(CertReq,Spb(M),Kpb(M)),Spv(M)))
(36)(29)4-2
(38) Know(M,Sign(M,CertReq,Spb(M),Kpb(M)))
(36)(37)۶
(39) Generate(M,k1)
۶
(40) Know(M,k1)
(39)R-2
(41) Know(M,E(Sign(M,CertReq,Spb(M),Kpb(M)),k1))
(38)(40)1-1
(42) Know(M,Acct(M),k1)
(3)(40)6-1
(43) Know(M,E(Acct(M),k1,Spb(CA)))
(42)(25)1-1
(44) Send(M,CA,E(Sign(M,CertReq,Spb(M),Kpb(M)),k1))
۶
(45) Send(M,CA,S(Acct(M),k1,Spb(CA)))
۶
(46) Know(CA,E(Sign(M,CertReq,Spb(M),Kpb(M)),k1))
(44)R-1
(47) Know(CA,S(Acct(M),k1,Spb(CA)))
(45)R-1
(48) Know(CA,Acct(M),k1)
(47)2-2ݣ3-2
(49) Know(CA,Acct(M))
(48)6-1
(50) Know(CA,k1)
(48)6-1
(51) Know(CA,Sign(M,CertReq,Spb(M),Kpb(M)))
(46)(50)3-1
(52) Know(CA,CertReq,Spb(M),Kpb(M))
(51)۶
(53) Know(CA,Spb(M))
(52)6-1
(54) Auth(M,CA,CertReq,Spb(M),Kpb(M))
(51)(53)۶2
(55) Know(CA,CertReq)
(52)6-1
(56) Legal(CA,CerReq)
۶
/*CA֪̼ҵϢCertReqעĺϷ.Ϸ,CAֹ̼ע*/
(57) Generate(CA,CertS(M))
۶
(58) Generate(CA,CertK(M))
۶
(59) Know(CA,CertS(M))
(57)R-2
(60) Know(CA,CertK(M))
(58)R-2


(61) Generate(CA,CertRes)
۶
(62) Know(CA,CertRes)
(61)R-2
(63) Know(CA,S(H(CertRes),Spv(CA)))
(62)2-2ݣ4-2
(64) Know(CA,Sign(CA,CertRes))
(62)(63)۶
(65) Send(CA,M,Sign(CA,CertRes))
۶
(66) Send(CA,M,CertS(M))
۶
(67) Send(CA,M,CertK(M))
۶
(68) Send(CA,M,CertS(CA))
۶
(69) Know(M,Sign(CA,CertRes))
(65)R-1
(70) Know(M,CertS(M))
(66)R-1
(71) Know(M,CertK(M))
(67)R-1
(72) Know(M,CertS(CA))
(68)R-1
(73) Verify(M,CertS(CA),X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(3)(72)۶
/*ʧ,MûPKIҵCARoot,ֹ̼ͣע*/
(74) Isverified(M,X2,CertS(CA))
(73)R-6
(75) Auth(M,X2,CA,Spb(CA))
(74)7-1
(76) Verify(M,CertS(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(3)(70)۶
/*ʧ,MûPKIҵCARoot,ֹ̼ͣע*/
(77) Isverified(M,CA,CertS(M))
(76)R-6
(78) Auth(M,CA,M,Spb(M))
(77)7-1
(79) Verify(M,CertK(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(3)(71)۶
/*ʧ,MûPKIҵCARoot,ֹ̼ͣע*/
(80) Isverified(M,CA,CertK(M))
(76)R-6
(81) Auth(M,CA,M,Kpb(M))
(80)7-2
(82) Know(M,Spb(CA))
(72)۶3
(83) Auth(M,CA,CertRes)
(69)(82)۶2
(84) ̼Ҵ洢֤CertS(M),CertK(M)ԼCAӦеϢ,Ժĵ
1.3 SETЭеĹ֤
֪:
P={Know(M,CertS(M)),Know(M,CertK(P)),Know(C,Acct(C)),
Know(C,CertS(C)),Know(C,Spb(CARoot)),Know(M,Spb(CARoot))},
=Generate(C,InitReq)Send(C,M,InitReq)Generate(M,InitRes)
Send(M,C,Sign(M,InitReq))Send(M,C,CertS(M))Send(M,C,CertK(P))
Verify(C,CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)Verify(C,CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
Generate(C,OI)Generate(C,PI)Generate(C,k1)
Send(C,M,E(PI,H(OI),So(C,H(OI),H(PI)),k1))
Send(C,M,S(Acct(C),k1,Kpb(P)))
Send(C,M,OI,H(PI),So(C,H(OI),H(PI)))
Send(C,M,CertS(C))Verify(M,CertS(C),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
Generate(M,PurchRes)Send(M,C,Sign(M,PurchRes))Send(M,C,CertS(M))
Verify(C,CertS(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot),
Q={Auth(C,CA,M,Spb(M)),Auth(C,CA,P,Spb(P)),Auth(C,M,InitReq),
Auth(M,CA,C,Spb(C)),Auth(M,C,H(OI),H(PI));Auth(C,CA,M,Spb(M)),
Auth(C,CA,PurchRes)}.
֤:PQ
֤:
(1) Know(M,CertS(M))
ǰ
(2) Know(M,CertK(P))
ǰ
(3) Know(C,Acct(C))
ǰ
(4) Know(C,CertS(C))
ǰ
(5) Generate(C,InitReq)
۶
(6) Know(C,InitReq)
(5)R-2
(7) Send(C,M,InitReq)
۶
(8) Know(M,InitReq)
(7)R-1
(9) Generate(M,InitRes)
۶
(10) Know(M,InitReq)
(9)R-2
(11) Know(M,S(H(InitReq),Spv(M)))
(10)2-2ݣ4-2
(12) Know(M,Sign(M,InitReq))
(10)(11)۶
(13) Send(M,C,Sign(M,InitReq))
۶
(14) Send(M,C,CertS(M))
۶
(15) Send(M,C,CertK(P))
۶
(16) Know(C,Sign(M,InitReq))
(13)R-1
(17) Know(C,CertS(M))
(14)R-1
(18) Know(C,CertK(P))
(15)R-1
(19) Know(C,Spb(CARoot))
ǰ
(20) Verify(C,CertS(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(17)(19)۶
/*ʧ,CûPKIҵCARoot,ֹֿ*/ 
(21) IsVerified(C,CA,CertS(M))
(20)R-6
(22) Auth(C,CA,M,Spb(M))
(21)7-1
(23) Verify(C,CertK(P),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(18)(19)۶
/*ʧ,CûPKIҵCARoot,ֹֿ*/
(24) IsVerified(C,CA,CertK(P))
(23)R-6
(25) Auth(C,CA,P,Spb(P))
(24)7-1
(26) Know(C,Spb(M))
(17)۶3
(27) Auth(C,M,InitReq)
(26)(16)۶2
(28) Generate(C,OI)
۶
(29) Generate(C,PI)
۶
(30) Know(C,OI)
(28)R-2
(31) Know(C,PI)
(29)R-2
(32) Know(C,H(OI))
(30)4-1
(33) Know(C,H(PI))
(31)4-1
(34) Know(C,H(OI),H(PI))
(32)(33)4-1
(35) Know(C,H(H(OI),H(PI)))
(34)4-1
(36) Know(C,S(H(H(OI),H(PI)),Spv(C)))
(34)2-2ݣ4-2
(37) Know(C,So(C,H(OI),H(PI)))
(36)۶
(38) Generate(C,k1)
۶
(39) Know(C,k1)
(38)R-2
(40) Know(C,PI,H(OI),So(C,H(OI),H(PI)))
(31)(32)(37)6-1
(41) Know(C,E(PI,H(OI),So(C,H(OI),H(PI)),k1))
(39)(40)1-1
(42) Know(C,Acct(C),k1)
(3)(39)4-1
(43) Know(C,Kpb(P))
(18)۶4
(44) Know(C,S(Acct(C),k1,Kpb(P)))
(43)(42)1-2
(45) Know(C,OI,H(PI),So(C,H(OI),H(PI)))
(30)(33)(37)4-1
(46) Send(C,M,E(PI,H(OI),So(C,H(OI),H(PI)),k1))
۶
(47) Send(C,M,S(Acct(C),k1,Kpb(P)))
۶
(48) Send(C,M,OI,H(PI),So(C,H(OI),H(PI)))
۶
(49) Send(C,M,CertS(C))
۶
(50) Know(M,E(PI,H(OI),So(C,H(OI),H(PI)),k1))
(46)R-1
(51) Know(M,S(Acct(C),k1,Kpb(P)))
(47)R-1
(52) Know(M,OI,H(PI),So(C,H(OI),H(PI)))
(48)R-1
(53) Know(M,CertS(C))
(49)R-1
(54) Know(M,Spb(CARoot))
ǰ
(55) Verify(M,CertS(C),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(53)(54)۶
/*ʧ,MûPKIҵCARoot,ֹ̼*/
(56) IsVerified(M,CA,CertS(C))
(55)R-6
(57) Auth(M,CA,C,Spb(C))
(56)7-1
(58) Know(M,OI)
(52)6-1
(59) Know(M,H(PI))
(52)6-1
(60) Know(M,So(C,H(OI),H(PI)))
(52)6-1
(61) Know(M,H(OI))
(58)4-1
(62) Know(M,H(OI),H(PI))
(59)(61)4-1
(63) Know(M,Spb(C))
(53)R-6
(64) Auth(M,C,H(OI),H(PI))
(60)(63)۶1
(65) ̼M(ָPIύP֤)
(66) Generate(M,PurchRes)
۶
(67) Know(M,PurchRes)
(66)R-2
(68) Know(M,S(H(PurchRes),Spv(M)))
(67)2-2ݣ4-2
(69) Know(M,Sign(M,PurchRes))
(67)(68)۶
(70) Send(M,C,Sign(M,PurchRes))
۶
(71) Send(M,C,CertS(M))
۶
(72) Know(C,Sign(M,PurchRes))
(70)R-1
(73) Know(C,CertS(M))
(71)R-1
(74) ̼M֤,ȻҵҪ(e.g.ֿCͻ)
(75) Verify(C,CertS(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(73)2-5ݣ۶
/*ʧ,CûPKIҵCARoot,ֹֿ*/
(76) IsVerified(C,CA,CertS(M))
(75)R-6
(77) Auth(C,CA,M,Spb(M))
(76)7-1
(78) Know(C,Spb(M))
(73)۶3
(79) Auth(C,M,PurchRes)
(72)(78)۶2
(80) ֿC洢شPurchRes

1.4 SETЭеĸ֤֤
֪:
P={Know(P,Kpb(P)),Know(P,Spb(P)),Know(M,Kpb(P)),Know(P,Spb(CARoot)),
Know(M,Spb(CARoot)),Know(P,Acct(C)),Know(P,CertS(P)),Know(M,CertS(C)),
Know(M,CertS(M)),Know(M,CertK(M)),
Know(M,E(PI,H(OI),SO(C,H(OI),H(PI)),k1)),
Know(M,S(Acct(C),k1,Kpb(P)))},
=Generate(M,AuthReq)Generate(M,k2)Send(M,P,E(Sign(M,AuthReq),k2))
Send(M,P,S(k2,Kpb(P)))Send(M,P,E(PI,H(OI),So(C,H(OI),H(PI)),k1))
Send(M,P,S(Acct(C),k1,Kpb(P)))Send(M,P,CertS(C))Send(M,P,CertS(M))
Send(M,P,CertK(M))Verify(P,CertS(C),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
Verify(P,CertS(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
Verify(P,CertK(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)Generate(P,AuthRes)
Generate(P,k3)Generate(P,CapToken)Send(P,M,S(k3,Acct(C),Kpb(M)))
Send(P,M,E(Sign(P,AuthRes),k3))Send(P,M,S(k4,Acct(C),Kpb(P)))
Send(P,M,E(Sign(P,CapToken),k4))Send(P,M,CertS(P))
Verify(M,CertS(P),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot),
Q={Auth(P,M,AuthReq),Auth(P,CA,C,Spb(C)),Auth(P,CA,M,Spb(M)),
Auth(P,CA,M,Kpb(M)),Auth(P,C,H(OI),H(PI)),
Auth(M,CA,P,Spb(P)),Auth(M,P,AuthRes)}.
֤:PQ
֤:
(1) Know(P,CertS(P))
ǰ
(2) Know(M,Kpb(P))
ǰ
(3) Know(M,E(PI,H(OI),So(C,H(OI),H(PI)),k1))
ǰ
(4) Know(M,S(Acct(C),k1,Kpb(P)))
ǰ
(5) Know(M,CertS(C))
ǰ
(6) Know(M,CertS(M))
ǰ
(7) Know(M,CertK(C))
ǰ
(8) Generate(M,AuthReq)
۶
(9) Know(M,AuthReq)
(8)R-2
(10) Know(M,S(H(AuthReq),Spv(M)))
(9)(2-2)4-2
(11) Know(M,Sign(M,AuthReq))
(9)(10)۶
(12) Generate(M,k2)
۶
(13) Know(M,k2)
(12)R-2
(14) Know(M,E(Sign(M,AuthReq),k2))
(11)(13)1-1
(15) Know(M,S(k2,Kpb(p)))
(2)(13)1-2
(16) Send(M,P,E(Sign(M,AuthReq),k2))
۶
(17) Send(M,P,S(k2,Kpb(P)))
۶
(18) Send(M,P,E(PI,H(OI),So(C,H(OI),H(PI)),k1))
۶
(19) Send(M,P,S(Acct(C),k1,Kpb(P)))
۶
(20) Send(M,P,CertS(C))
۶
(21) Send(M,P,CertS(M))
۶
(22) Send(M,P,CertK(M))
۶
(23) Know(P,E(Sign(M,AuthReq),k2))
(16)R-1
(24) Know(P,S(k2,Kpb(P)))
(17)R-2
(25) Know(P,E(PI,H(OI),So(C,H(OI),H(PI)),k1))
(18)R-1
(26) Know(P,S(Acct(C),k1,Kpb(P)))
(19)R-1
(27) Know(P,CertS(C))
(20)R-1
(28) Know(P,CertS(M))
(21)R-1
(29) Know(P,CertK(M))
(22)R-1
(30) Know(P,k2)
(24)2-1ݣ3-2
(31) Know(P,Sign(M,AuthReq))
(23)(30)R-1
(32) Know(P,Spb(M))
(28)۶3
(33) Auth(P,M,AuthReq)
(31)(32)۶2
(34) Verify(P,CertS(C),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(27)2-5ݣ۶
/*ʧ,PûPKIҵCARoot,򸶷ֹ֤*/ 
(35) IsVerified(P,CA,CertS(C))
(34)R-6
(36) Auth(P,CA,C,Spb(C))
(35)7-1
(37) Verify(P,CertS(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(28)2-5ݣ۶
/*ʧ,PûPKIҵCARoot,򸶷ֹ֤*/ 
(38) IsVerified(P,CA,CertS(M))
(37)R-6
(39) Auth(P,CA,M,Spb(M))
(38)7-1
(40) Verify(P,CertK(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(29)2-5ݣ۶
/*ʧ,PûPKIҵCARoot,򸶷ֹ֤*/ 
(41) IsVerified(P,CA,CertK(M))
(40)R-6
(42) Auth(P,CA,M,Kpb(M))
(41)7-1
(43) Know(P,Acct(C),k1)
(26)2-1ݣ3-2
(44) Know(P,Acct(C))
(43)4-1
(45) Know(P,k1)
(43)6-1
(46) Know(P,PI,H(OI),So(C,H(OI),H(PI)))
(25)(45)3-1
(47) Know(P,PI)
(46)6-1
(48) Know(P,H(OI))
(46)6-1
(49) Know(P,So(C,H(OI),H(PI)))
(46)6-1
(50) Know(P,H(PI))
(47)4-1
(51) Know(P,H(OI),H(PI))
(48)(50)4-1
(52) Know(P,Spb(C))
(27)۶3
(53) Auth(P,C,H(OI),H(PI))
(52)(49)(51)۶1
(54) Pȷ̼M֤AuthReqֿCĸָPI֮һ¡
(55) P֤AuthReqֿͨ˵Ľڻ
(56) Generate(P,AuthRes)
۶
(57) Know(P,AuthRes)
(56)R-2
(58) Know(P,S(H(AuthRes),Spv(P)))
(57)2-2ݣ4-2
(59) Know(P,Sign(P,AuthRes))
(57)(58)۶
(60) Generate(P,k3)
۶
(61) Know(P,k3)
(60)R-2
(62) Know(P,E(Sign(P,AuthRes),k3))
(59)(61)1-1
(63) Know(P,S(k3,Kpb(M)))
(32)(61)1-2
(64) Know(P,S(k3,Acct(C),Kpb(M)))
(32)(44)(61)1-2
(65) Generate(P,CapToken)
۶
(66) Know(P,CapToken)
(65)R-2
(67) Know(P,S(H(Captoken),Spv(P)))
(66)2-2ݣ4-2
(68) Know(P,Sign(P,Captoken))
(66)(67)۶
(69) Generate(P,k4)
۶
(70) Know(P,k4)
(69)R-2
(71) Know(P,E(Sign(P,CapToken),k4))
(68)(70)1-1
(72) Know(P,S(k4,Acct(C),Kpb(P)))
(70)(44)2-4ݣ1-2
(73) Send(P,M,S(k3,Acct(C),Kpb(M)))
۶
(74) Send(P,M,E(Sign(P,AuthRes),k3))
۶
(75) Send(P,M,S(k4,Acct(C),Kpb(P)))
۶
(76) Send(P,M,E(Sign(P,CapToken),k4))
۶
(77) Send(P,M,CertS(P))
۶
(78) Know(M,S(k3,Acct(C),Kpb(M)))
(73)R-1
(79) Know(M,E(Sign(P,AuthRes),k3))
74)R-1
(80) Know(M,S(k4,Acct(C),Kpb(P)))
(75)R-1
(81) Know(M,E(Sign(P,CapToken),k4))
(76)R-1
(82) Know(M,CertS(P))
(77)R-1
(83) Verify(M,CertS(P),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(82)2-5ݣ۶
/*ʧ,MûPKIҵCARoot,ֹ̼֤*/ 
(84) IsVerified(M,CA,CertS(P))
(83)R-5
(85) Auth(M,CA,P,Spb(P))
(84)7-1
(86) Know(M,k3,Acct(C))
(78)2-1ݣ3-2
(87) Know(M,k3)
(87)6-1
(88) Know(M,Sign(P,AuthRes))
(79)(86)3-1
(89) Know(M,Spb(P))
(82)۶3
(90) Auth(M,P,AuthRes)
(88)(89)۶2
(91) ̼MΪĻô洢ܵĻCapTokenŷ⡱
(92) ̼Mɹ

1.5 SETЭеĸѻ֤
֪:
P={Know(M,S(k4,Acct(C),Kpb(P))),Know(M,E(Sign(P,CapToken),k4)),
Know(M,CertS(M)),Know(M,CertK(M)),Know(M,Kpb(P)),
Know(P,CertS(P)),Know(M,Spb(P))},
=Generate(M,CapReq)Send(M,P,S(k5,Kpb(P)))
Send(M,P,E(Sign(M,CapReq),k5))Send(M,P,S(k4,Acct(C),Kpb(P)))
Send(M,P,E(Sign(P,CapToken),k4)))Send(M,P,CertS(M))
Send(M,P,CertK(M)Verify(P,CertS(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
Verify(P,CertK(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)Generate(P,CapRes)
Generate(P,k6)Send(P,M,S(k6,Kpb(M)))Send(P,M,E(Sign(P,CapRes),k6))
Send(P,M,CertS(P))Verify(M,CertS(P),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot),
Q={Auth(P,CA,M,Spb(M)),Auth(P,CA,M,Kpb(M)),Auth(M,CA,P,Spb(P)),
Auth(M,P,CapRes)}.
֤:PQ
֤:
(1) Know(M,S(k4,Acct(C),Kpb(P)))
ǰ
(2) Know(M,E(Sign(P,CapToken),k4))
ǰ
(3) Know(M,CertS(M))
ǰ
(4) Know(M,CertK(M))
ǰ
(5) Know(M,Kpb(P))
ǰ
(6) Know(P,CertS(P))
ǰ
(7) Know(M,Spb(P))
ǰ
(8) Generate(M,CapReq)
۶
(9) Know(M,CapReq)
(8)R-2
(10) Know(M,S(CapReq,Spv(M)))
(9)2-2ݣ4-2
(11) Know(M,Sign(M,CapReq))
(9)(10)۶
(12) Generate(M,k5)
۶
(13) Know(M,k5)
(12)R-2
(14) Know(M,E(Sign(M,CapReq),k5))
(11)(13)1-1
(15) Know(M,S(k5,Kpb(P)))
(5)(13)1-2
(16) Send(M,P,S(k5,Kpb(P)))
۶
(17) Send(M,P,E(Sign(M,CapReq),k5))
۶
(18) Send(M,P,S(k4,Acct(C),Kpb(P)))
۶
(19) Send(M,P,E(Sign(P,CapToken),k4)))
۶
(20) Send(M,P,CertS(M))
۶
(21) Send(M,P,CertK(M))
۶
(22) Know(P,S(k5,Kpb(P)))
(16)R-1
(23) Know(P,E(Sign(M,CapReq),k5))
(17)R-1
(24) Know(P,S(k4,Acct(C),Kpb(P)))
(18)R-1
(25) Know(P,E(Sign(P,CapToken),k4))
(19)R-1
(26) Know(P,CertS(M))
(20)R-1
(27) Know(P,CertK(M))
(21)R-1
(28) Verify(P,CertS(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(26)2-5ݣ۶
/*ʧ,PûPKIҵCARoot,򸶷ؾܾ*/
(29) ISVerified(P,CA,CertS(M))
(28)R-6
(30) Auth(P,CA,M,Spb(M))
(29)7-1
(31) Verify(P,CertK(M),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(27)2-5ݣ۶
/*ʧ,PûPKIҵCARoot,򸶷ؾܾ*/
(32) ISVerified(P,CA,CertK(M))
(31)R-6
(33) Auth(P,CA,M,Kpb(M))
(32)7-2
(34) Know(P,Spb(M))
(26)۶3
(35) Know(P,Kpb(M))
(27)۶4
(36) Know(P,k5)
(22)2-1ݣ3-2
(37) Know(P,Sign(M,CapReq))
(23)(36)3-1
(38) Auth(P,M,CapReq)
(34)(37)۶2
(39) Know(P,k4,Acct(C))
(24)2-1ݣ3-2
(40) Know(P,k4)
(39)4-1
(41) Know(P,Acct(C))
(39)6-1
(42) Know(P,Sign(P,CapToken))
(25)(40)3-1
(43) Pȷ̼MĻCapReqͻCapToken֮һԡ
(44) PֿͨCĽڻͻ
(45) Generate(P,CapRes)
۶
(46) Know(P,CapRes)
(45)R-2
(47) Know(P,S(H(CapRes),Spv(P)))
(46)2-2ݣ4-2
(48) Know(P,Sign(P,CapRes))
(46)(47)۶
(49) Generate(P,k6)
۶
(50) Know(P,k6)
(49)R-2
(51) Know(P,E(Sign(P,CapRes),k6))
(48)(50)1-1
(52) Know(P,S(k6,Kpb(M)))
(35)(50)1-2
(53) Send(P,M,S(k6,Kpb(M)))
۶
(54) Send(P,M,E(Sign(P,CapRes),k6))
۶
(55) Send(P,M,CertS(P))
۶
(56) Know(M,S(k6,Kpb(M)))
(53)R-1
(57) Know(M,E(Sign(P,CapRes),k6))
(54)R-1
(58) Know(M,CertS(P))
(55)R-1
(59) Verify(M,CertyS(P),CA,X2,...,Xn-1,CARoot)
(58)2-5ݣ۶
/*ʧ,MûPKIҵCARoot,̼Mܾø*/
(60) IsVerified(P,CA,CertS(P))
(59)R-6
(61) Auth(M,CA,P,Spb(P))
(60)7-1
(62) Know(M,k6)
(56)2-1ݣ3-2
(63) Know(M,Sign(P,CapRes))
(57)(62)3-1
(64) Know(M,Spb(P))
(58)۶3
(65) Auth(M,P,CapRes)
(63)(64)۶2
(66) ̼M洢ûش,ʹ߻õĸһ¡
ף1չNDL߼ܶSETĸҵ̽ȫ֤.֤̿ԿNDL֤ȫЭİȫϵҪ.ͨһЩӵĹ̳ɼ򵥵߼,SETϸ֤.ҲӦÿ,֤м뷽ǺϷû,ųǷǷûй¶ϢĿ,ԴûӦķʩ,һ,Ҫ׷ʱ,Ե,ܾе.ȡʲôķ״Ҫ.
1.6 ֤߼Prologʵ
߼Ƶ漰ĶǷź͹,Ҫ,ô,ʱϾһ˷.߼ڻ֤ص,Ǳ˻NDL߼ܵPrologȫЭ֤ϵͳ,ϵͳΪNDLĹ͹,ûԸӵҪǰ,ﵽ֤ȫЭǷ©Ŀ.
2 k out of n
2.1 k out of nĶ
k out of nĺָ,Эִйn뷽,ÿ뷽֪ԼȨ޷ΧڵϢ.,ֻ֪޵Ϣ,˭޷óԼȨ޵ҵ,SETĸǰȫɿ.,kһ,֪ܴյһγһġԿס,ͿԷǷȡҵ.
ڻ,׷ǵķʱ,κһԵ.ΪֻԼ֪ĺϷġ޵Ϣ,޷֪ЩԼȨ޷Χҵܵ.漰һҪ,ڵӽʵ֡ɷ͡׷١ְȫϻ,Ӷֹķ.
ע,k out of nRSA,DES㷨İȫǿ,㷨ѧϸڵǰ½۵.
2.2 SETв뷽
Issuer(з):һڻ,иѿ,ȷֿʺ.֤˰ѿƷƺ͵طΪ֤񸶷.
Acquirer(÷):һڻ,ȷ̼ҵʻ,ѿ֤͸.
Cardholder(ֿ):ĸѿIssuer,SET֤ڳֿ̼ҽ׵Ĺ,ѿĿϢֿɿ.
Merchant(̼):ṩҪƷҪ󸶷ѵķ,ܸܽѿ̼ұAcquirerйϵ.
Payment Gateway():Acquirer̼ҸϢ(ӳֿ˵õĸָ)ָ豸.
Third Parties():IssuerAcquirersʱѡѸѿҵ.
2.3 Գֿע׶εķ
Message C:Spv(C),Spb(C),k1,k2,k3,Acct(C),
Message CA:Spv(CA),Spb(C),k1,k2,k3,Acct(C).
ͨý׶θ뷽֪Ϣķϱ߶߼֤Կֿ˵ʻϢֿܷ֤ע׶εİȫԵĹؼ.ʻϢǷй¶ĽǶȳ,ȫֿɷΪ3:
.CԿSpv(C),k1,k2k3,ûй¶ʻϢ.
.CCAй¶ʻϢ,ûиԿ.
.CԿ,й¶ʻϢ.
1,ΪԿѾı,CԵ˵ûCA֤.2,ΪCCAй¶Ϣ,߶Գɹðֿ˴CAúϷǩԿ֤,Ҫ׷,CCAԵ,ָԷй¶Ϣ.ڵ3,1Ψһ֮ͬڣҲðC뵽Ϸǩ֤.,һ,ý׶εİȫԶ޷,ôΪܹ֤еİȫ,SETбܹ֤ᵽġԺ͸뷽ġ׷١ְȫƵʵʩ.
3 
϶SETЭȫ߼֤,˵NDLҪ,֤ҲSETȷʵ©.֤ʹSET֤÷ǳ,ͬʱҲΪPrologģ̵֤춨˻.ĵصǸSET̵֤.ֻǼ򵥵ؾͶԡֿעᡱ׶νеָˡk out of nĴ.ǽĿԸз,ʵʵĽҵпܻᷢ,ͨʵ֡͡׷١ְȫSETеϢȫ.ǽԺĹжSETЭдڵġk out of nϸ.
оõ863߿ƼĿ(No.863-306-ZD-10-02).߳,1971,ʦ,ҪоΪϢȫ,.,1950,ʿ,оԱ,ҪоΪ߼,.˶,1956,ʿ,оԱ,ʿʦ,ҪоΪ˹,ѧ,Internet/IntranetӦ.ʦ,1962,ʿ,,ҪоΪ˹,ݿ⼼.ӱ,Ů,1973,˶ʿ,ҪоΪInternet/IntranetӦ,.
ͨѶϵ:˶, 100080,ܼо
ߵλ:(ܼо  100080)
(ʦѧѧѧϵ  541005)
(йѧԺо  100080)
˶(ܼо  100080)
ʦ(ʦѧѧѧϵ  541005)
ӱ(ܼо  100080)
ο
1Kenichi HAYASHI,Eiji OKAMOTO,Masabiro MAMBO.Proposal of user identification scheme using mouse.In:Han Yong-fei,Okamoto Tatsuaki,Qing Si-han eds.Proceedings of the ICICS'97.LNCS 1334,Berlin:Springer-Verlag,1997.424434
2Chang Li-wu,Moskowitz T S.Critical analysis of security in voice hiding techniques.In:Han Yong-fei,Okamoto Tatsuaki,Qing Si-han eds.Proceedings of the ICICS'97.LNCS 1334,Berlin:Springer-Verlag,1997.203216
3Van der Merwe Jaco,Von Solms S H.Electronic commerce with secure intelligent trade agents.In:Han Yong-fei,Okamoto Tatsuaki,Qing Si-han eds.Proceedings of the ICICS'97.LNCS 1334,Berlin:Springer-Verlag,1997.452462
4Kailar R.Accountability in electronic commerce protocols.Information and Communications,1996,22(5):313328
5Kailar R,Gligor V.On belief evolution in authentication protocols.In:Proceedings of the 4th IEEE Computer Security Foundations Workshop.Los Alamitors,CA:IEEE Computer Society Press,1991
6Chen Qing-feng,Bai Shuo,Wang Ju et al.The secure electronic transactions protocol and its logical verification with non-monotomic dynamic logic.Journal of Software,2000,11(2):240250
,˶,Ե.ȫЭ鼰ǵ̬߼֤.ѧ,2000,11(2):240250)
7SET Secure Electronic Transaction Specification,Book 1:Business Description.Version 1.0,1997
8Bai Shuo,Sui Li-ying,Chen Qing-feng et al .The verification logic for secure protocols.Journal of Software,2000,11(2):213221
˶,ӱ,.ȫЭ֤߼.ѧ,2000,11(2):213221
1998-04-03յԭ,1999-03-22յ޸ĸ
