Զѧ
ACTA AUTOMATICA SINICA
1997 23 1 Vol.23 No.1 1997



³Ʒо
նź
ժҪùṹ³ָ꣬ż.˷˲ƴٲżʵóֵ޽йϼ⣻˾ֵ鷨(MVT)ϵָ꣬ɴϵļߵϵͳĹϼ.
ؼʡ³ȣֵ飬Ȼȼ飬˲Եϵͳ.
DESIGN OF OPTIMAL ROBUST
ANALYTLCAL REDUNDANCY
YAN DONGZHANG HONGYUE
(Department of Automatic Control, Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Beijing 100083)
AbstractIn this paper, a new method of calculating parity vector is proposed. First, a performance criterion for robust fault detection is given. By using the theory of Generalized Eigenstructure, the criterion can be solved to obtain optimal redundancy relation for the system detection. An optimal isolation performance criterion and Mean Value Test method(MVT) is also proposed. The parity vector can be compensated by using non-linear filtering, and the parity vector compensation approach can reduce the influence of sensor errors such as input misalignments, scale factor errors, and biases, and allow to use a constant threshold. When only one sensor fails, both GLT and MVT method can detect and isolate the failure correctly; When more than two sensors fail simultaneously, GLT method can detect the failures,but can not isolate the failures. However, MVT method can not only detect failures but also isolate failures. 
Key words Optimal robust analytical redundancy, mean value test, general likelihood test, non-linear filtering, strapdown inertial navigation system.
1
żռ䷽ѱ㷺ڹϼ16.ף1Уżȡ.÷ֻڴضĶԳƽṹʱĹ϶ԼĹͬϼľԣ7ݣPotter㷨Ӧܵ.˶ԴİװṹûضҪµȡżķ÷˲ƴżв.˼ϵľֵ鷽.ͬʱֹϵʱȻȷ.
2³Ʒ
ԪnûдиӵЦǣΪ
m=H+.(1)
Уʵ״̬Hn3άĴξ.Hnаn᷽ķ.Ϸʱ̸ıΪ
m=H+Bbf+.(2)
kֹʱBĵkԽԪΪ1ԪΪ0.Ϊ˼ϣҪѡv
vH=0,(3)
v(n-3)nάͶӰ󣬴ʱż
p=vm=vBbf+vǣ(4)
pһ(n-3)άż.
ף1ȡżķֻڴýṹضĶԳԵʱ7
(5)
hi,hjʾHĵiУj.ܶĶԳԲ㣬ʹְװģʽڴ᲻׼̶ԼƫеҲʹضĶԳԱƻֱӰFDIܣԣ³ȵƷ.ν³ȹϵָ³ɵĲвϵͳ״̬ı仯УԹϵı仯ΪУ8.ɹʽ(4)֪ҪʹƵżϵͳ״̬ı仯УӦʹvHܵСͬʱΪܶԹУʹvBΪָ
(6)
ָ͵ıֵף8ͶӰȡ(6)ʽĽд
(7)
УǾHHT-BBTֵvTǶӦͨMATLABеĺ.(7)ʽСֵӦvTΪͶӰ󣬽Իżp=vm.
3ϼľֵ鷽
X1X2XnǴ̬ĸN(̣20)гȡһЦ20֪H0(̣0(8)ʽͳоֵ910.
(8)
Ըˮƽֲ̬ȡ.оΪ
(9)
żpµͳƼ飺
(10)
Цvvǵľֵkʾkʱ.ٰо((9))Զ(10)йϼ.ͨľֵ鷽ֻܼϣȴ޷ϣһµķϵķ.
(4)ʽ֪ʱ̵żľֵΪ
Ep=EvBbf+Ev=vBbf.(11)
kŴʱEp=v(k)bf(k),v(k),bf(k)ֱΪͶӰv͹bfĵkԪ.ֵӦʹv(k)bf(k)ܵĴָ£11ݣ
(12)
(12)ʽɴͶӰżkĲֵԵlг̶Ѿ趨ңԳk֮Ĵ.ekǵkԪΪ1ԪΪ0.
ȲȷһΪϴʱ򣬽kȡΪ12n,ʽnϵͶӰǷֱv1,v2,vnnͶӰֱȡnżǷֱp1,p2,pnͬʱnżйϼϷ.
(12)ʽճԵõ
(13)
JƫΪ0AlleTlH(HTH)-1HTel,Alk=eTlH(HTH)-1HTek,Akk=eTkH(HTH)-1HTek,Akl=eTkH(HTH)-1HTel,



(14)
kֹʱkֵżѧΪEpkEvkm=Evk=0ɴ˿ɼֻеkֹϣnвֻһвĲв(n-1)вͿֵͨйϣkĲвĽΪ޹.ڽйϷ֮ǰѾϵͳг˹ϣжûбĴ˹.
Ȼ޷ȷԴĻ˵˹ϣ趨ʱͶӰָΪ
(15)
ָĺΪ(15)ʽżk͵lĲֵ(15)ʽͿȷn(n-1)/2ͶӰõn(n-1)/2ż.
ƵḶ́ɶϴͬʱֹϵйϼ.
4żĲ
ף12ݺף13ݷֱÿ˲ƫƵķżв.żϵͳ״̬봫ķԺ˲ӦܵƣڲƫƷʱ㷨Ǻѱ֤.
ΪFDIܣ˷˲ƴżв.
ͨ̿Ա
m=(I+Hse)(H+Hme)أb+.(16)
Hn3άļξHseڴ̶nnάHme᲻׼n3άbn1άĴĳֵƫУn1άİ.Hseb,Ǳʽμף11.ϵͳİװģͱȽϸӣʽӦӾİװ.
ϵͳ״̬ѡȡΪ
(17)
Hsei,Hme(i,j),bi ֱʾHse, HmebԪأɴ˿ɼ(16)ǷԵ.
ϵͳ̿ԱʾΪ
x(k+1)=x(k)+g(k),(18)
Сg(k)=g1(k),g2(k),g3(k),0,,0Tgi(k)(i=1,2,3)Ǹ˹.
ͨԷ(16)(18)ɵĲ̺ϵͳ̽з˲Եõi,Hsej,Hme,bj(i=1,2,3,j=1,2n)ĹֵȻżвżʽΪ14
(19)
ӹʽ(19)֪,p*v.Ϸʱżʽp*vBbfvǣٶp*йϼ.
5Ӧ
ֱһɶΪݾȵذװʮ(ԳҪ󣬼ʽ(5))ݾȵذװ԰׶ı(ԳҪ)(伸ξμף11ݣ.
ʱװǦĦ(i),ĦjĦjľֵΪ0.018㣬̶HseiľֵΪ0.001ƫbiľֵ0.00004/s,gijЭΪ1.55E-11(/s)2ݷϵʱΪ1.25.
(a)ڲǴ£ֱPotter㷨뱾ĵ³㷨ȡżGLT鷨6(ԳҪ)ɼСϷֱΪ3.6e-53.6e-5,3.9e-5,2.7e-5,9e-6,3.9e-5(λǡ/s).
(b)ڲǴ£ֱPotter㷨뱾ĵ³㷨ȡżGLT鷨5(ԳҪ)GLTɼСϷֱΪ3.1e-5,2.3e-5,2.3e-5,2.5e-5,2.2e-6(λǡ/s)ֵ鷽ɼСϷֱΪ2.6e-5,2.4e-5,2.4e-5,2.6e-5,2.2e-6(λǡ/s).
ʽԿĵ³㷨ȡżľֵ鷨Potter㷨ȡżGLT鷨ɼСʮֽӽ.
(c) ڿǴ£GLT鷨ֵ鷨6ϼֱǣGLTɼСϷֱΪ3.1e-5,1.5e-5,1.6e-5,1.6e-5,1.9e-5,2.2e-5(λ /s)ֵ鷽ɼСϷֱΪ3.0e-5,6.0e-6,8.0e-6,1.9e-5,1.9e-6,6.0e-6(λ /s).
ɴ˿ֵ֪鷨ɼСϱGLT鷽ɼСҪС.
(d)ֻһϵʱGLT鷨ֵ鷨Լ͸.磬һŴгֹϵʱGLTĹϸ뺯DFIn,(n=1,2,6)ֱΪ3.36065e-10,1.73196e-10,6.81251e-11,1.25699e-10,2.59862e-11,1.06689e-11,GLTԽһŴ룬ֵ鷨߷ֱͼ1ͼ2ʾ.


ͼ1һֹʱֵ鷽Ϸ()


ͼ2һֹʱֵ鷽Ϸ()
ͼ1ͼ2Կʽ(12)еvkkϴһ£żвΪ޹ϣ򣬼Ϊй.
(e)ͬʱϵʱGLT鷨ֻܼϣֵ鷨ԽȷĹϼ.磬һźĺŴͬʱֹϵʱGLTĹϸ뺯DFIn, (n=1,26)ֱΪ9.64598e-11, 7.56961e-13, 1.93368e-10, 7.01055e-11, 3.11012e-12, 2.41300e-10, GLTϵĹ򣬽Ŵ.ֵ鷽Ϸ߷ֱͼ3ͼ4


ͼ1ֹʱֵ鷽Ϸ()


ͼ2ֹʱֵ鷽Ϸ()
ͼ3ͼ4ɼʽ(15)Уѡk,lϴһ£Ϊ޹ϣ֮Ϊй.
6
³㷨ȡżľֵ鷨Potter㷨ȡżGLTⷽԹϵļиߵ.ϴͬʱֹϵʱGLTֻܽйϼ⣬ľֵ鷨ȿԼҲԸ.ԣ³ƷȴͳPotter㷨ȡżGLT鷽иߵĹӦüֵ.
߼飺նУ196612ʡУ1995ڱպѧԶϵʿѧλ廪ѧϵ²ʿо.ҪоִۼӦá˹ܼдϵͳģϵͳʶ״̬Ʒݴ΢/׼ӦãѷĶʮƪ.
źᡡ鼰Ƭ1995211.
ߵλպѧԶϵ301ҡ100083
ο
1ݡPotter I E, Sunman M C.Thresholdless redundancy management with arrays of skewed instruments.Integrity in Electronic Flight Control Systems. AGARDOGRAPH-224,1977,15-11 to 1525.
2ݡDesai M, Ray A.A fault detection and isolation methodology. Proc. 20th Conf. on Decision and Control, 1981, 13631369
3ݡChow E Y Willsky A S.Analytical redundance and the design of robust failure detection systems.IEEE Trans. Aut.Control, 1984,AC-29:603614
4ݡLou X C, Willsky A S, Verghese G L. Optimally robust redundancy relations for failure detection in uncertain systems. Automatica, 1986, 22:333344.
5ݡChen Jie, Zhang Hongyue. Parity vector approach for detecting failures in dynamic systems, Int. J. Systems Sci., 1990, 21(4):765770.
6ݡԹ飬.ߵɿԵż.Ϣƣ1992(2)2632
7ݡ½ܣźᣬԹ.ȴϵͳдýṹżŻ.ѧ199011(3)175182
8ݡź.ȷϵͳ³ȵŻ.ߣ19949(2)141145.
9ݡYan Dong, Zhang Hongyue. Mean value test for FDI in redundant sensor configurations, american automatic control conference, USA, June 2123, 1995.
10ݡZhang Hongyue, Yan Dong. Optimal design of robust analytical redundancy for a redundant strapdown Inertial navigation system, IFAC Intelligent Autonomous Control in Aerospace, Beijing,280285.
11ݡն.Ƶϵͳ״̬Ʒݴо۲ʿѧλģ.պѧ1995.6871.
12ݡHall S R, Motyka P,Gai E, Deyst J J.In-flight parity vector compensation for FDI. IEEE Trans. aerosp. electron. syst., 1983,AES-19:(5)668675.
13ݡźź.ĽݴԵϵͳѧ199011(1)4752.
14ݡYan Dong, Zhang Hongyue. Parity vector compensation using non-linear filtering. IFAC Workshop on Safety, Reliability and Applications of Emerging Intelligent Control Technologies, 1994,HongKong, 177181.
ոڡ1994-10-17


