Զѧ
ACTA AUTOMATICA SINICA
2000Vol.26No.3P.347-355



PIDȽ
ΰžΡ
ժҪPIDǹ̿Ӧ㷺ĿƷ.PIDȽڴ˷õоɹԽķչչ.
ؼʡPIDƣӦ.
A SURVEY OF ADVANCED PID PARAMETER TUNING METHODS 
WANG WeiZHANG JingtaoCHAI Tianyou
Research Center of Automation, Northeastern University, Shenyang 110006
AbstractPID control is the most common control method used in process control. This paper surveys the advanced PID parameter tuning methods and the newest achievements in this subject, it also points out the directions of the future development.
Key wordsPID control, parameter tuning, adaptation.
1
PIDΪֹͨõĿƷ.·ø÷Сı.PIDĽڹҵ̿Ŀ1(ȫ̿õ84%ǴPIDĽͰ򳬹90%).ǽ֪PIDչ19151940ڼ.1940ȽƷƳPIDṹ򵥣ģ³Լڲŵ㣬Ա㷺Ӧұ𡢻Ṥͻеȹҵ̿.
PIDһЩ£24.AstromHagglund1988껹רPID5.ͬƷһʮPIDƵĲͼҲڲϷչУرǽԶPIDƵĲоڼҪ־Ϸµоɹ.Automatica614ݣIEEE Trans. on Control Syst. Tech.15,16ݣControl Eng. Practice4,17ݵ.ֵǣAstromHagglund1995ٴγˡPIDۡƼڶ棩18.
ZieglerNichols19PID༼ѾPIDֶԶ.ݷչ׶εĻ֣ɷΪPIDPIDձض֣ɷΪPIDPIDǰ߰доȵ㼰ѵ㣻ʽ֣ɷΪPIDPIDǰھPIDɷԸ-΢ͷϷʽɵķPID.
PIDƲȽͽķչ.
2PID
Astrom1988ƻ飨ACCġܿơ20ݵĴᱨ˽һҵеֿ˼롪ӦΪPIDƵķչ춨˻.ΪӦΪһоǱʦԶ.ģ21м˼룬Ϊʵȡ̶̬ԵķƷܾʱʹPIPIDƣӦ.ӦPIDӦ;ĲʹöӦоҪ.ĿǰڶУҪַʵʹҵӦýϺã20.һɸ˹ޣFoxboro˾ƳĻģʽʶĲ22,23ݣڹ򣩣һǻڼ̵練Ĳ5,24ݣģͣ.ǰҪӦFoxboroĵ·EXACTɢϵͳI/A SeriesPIDEܿ飬ԭBristolģʽʶڹ25ݣоܽģ26.ߵӦʵ϶6,27ݣڰƻ趨ǰӦȹ.ЩؼPIDʹãĽܣǱͳΪӦܿƼ18,27.
ӦҪ.֣ܱΪࣺģ͵ͻڹ18.ͷֱ෽Խ.
2.1ģ͵
ڻģ͵У̬ͨӦʵ顢ƼƵӦʵùģ.
Уʹ಻ͬ෽Դģ19.ģ28ݸչZ-NԾӦһֻ̬Ӧ.÷ֱӴӽԾӦлü򵥹ģͲPIDĲȨƽָ(ISE)С£ģͲ֪.̬ӦԭʼZ-NԾӦȶ.ģ29˻ڻضȣcross correlationöαеĻضʶλӦZ-NʽҪŵǿĻ.
ģ7ݻڶԲںСݺĹƣһڱջPID.PIDƵеŻ.ǵ͵ĿϵͳԣȼȺֵ.ֵPIDƵֵ£ȷPID.ַŵ³ԼԵֱͨѡ̶ԸźȽϵ.ȱǲӦ̵仯.
AstromHagglundģ24һ̵ּ練÷ǻùٽϢķ֮һ.ͨڹķ·̵Խȷٽ.̽һ񵴣ٽ񵴵ķֵƵ.÷ɱȶ̵ȶջӦѹ㷺ӦڹҵPIDУ30.ģ31ݶģ24еķչ.ڸ÷УȲһ񵴣ʹÿϵͳڶϵͳȶҪƵʵ㴦񵴣Ȼ󷴸ƲʹջݺĳƵʵ㴦ķֵҪ.AstromHagg-lundĿȣڸ÷ѡƵʸʹÿƻ·бȺ߷ΧԣȣҸ÷Ƶʸĸ³Ըǿ.ҪȱڼƵʽϵͼƲ޸Ķϴڹ.
PIDھдͺʱĹ̿ܽϲҪҪĿٲȱ㣬ģ6ݻڼ̵練һ·ֱֿ㷨.ѡĽṹͺʱ䲹.ַʱPID㷨֮ڣټûнƣɢʱģֱȷʹöڷֵƵʵȫϢ׵ϵͳӦʣ㷨ڴʱ͵ϵͳͬʱӦ˲.ʵ÷ھʱ͵ĵͽϵͳЧϺãھнϴ󼫵ϵͳ.
ģ8һµļ̵練÷ɱʶھ̬ظµٽ飬һԶƫ˷ڼ̵ʵеľ̬ظŶٽٽڵĹɵ.ȻַҪڹ̬̾ԤȷϢ.ûй̬̾Ϣ÷Ҫ̵ʵԻþȷٽݺ͹̵ľ̬.ģ32һ־һƫͬʱٽ鼰̬̾¼̵.ַڼʹü̵練߹̱ʶ.ƫ¹ͼ̵Ļӣʹõٽ׼ȷĳ̶ֳ½.ģ9һµĸĽ̵練ڴھ̬ظµõ׼ȷٽϢ.ļ̵練Զı̵ȷԳƵĹ.÷Ҫڹ̬̾κ֪ʶ̬̾ٽϢһ̵ʵͬʱ.
ģ15һֻڼ̵缤ñضƵģ͵PIPIDУ׼ķ.÷ʹôͻļ̵Զڼ̵ԻùλͺΪ135Ƶʴ.ڶԳŻ33ݣͬʱ³ԣԣȡԣȡȣջԵŵ.÷ܲ޸ĵڹҵ̿ȥ񵴷ȺڵĲֵ׼ȷ½.
ģ15ݽ̵練ڴԶ.̵ʹڸ·ʱýΪֶʽҴ·ٶȿɼ̵練õ񵴣ȷ𵴣֪.ģ34һָĽļ̵練Իù̸ȷٽϢ.ʹźŴģ24ʹõźԼٸߴг.
÷ֵԣȺԣPIDʹϵͳõĿܺ³.ģ35һֻڼ̵練ԣPIDķ÷ͨڿƻ·вʱͱڹ̵ÿһ㷨ʵʱ֮ǰҵƵӦϵĲͬ㣬ֱĳЩԤ趨Ŀ(ջԣ)PIDڴʱ.㷨Ĺ֪ʶ٣ûֻջϵͳСԣȼ.ģ36һ÷ֵԣȺԣPIDķ÷ȶ.ģ37ݸһµĻڸԣȺͷֵԣȵPIDSPAM÷ýٵĶϢɶPIDв÷÷ΧϹ.Hoģ11һֻڸֵԣȵƵPIDڹ涨ϵͳ³Եͬʱϵͳ.Hoģ12ֵֽԣ(GPM)ʱŻƵŵϣһͬʱ³ԺŻҪPIDʽ.вʹƽ(ISE)ΪСŻ׼ISE-GPMʽPIDƵʵʱʽʽ򵥣ڹʵ.
2.2ڹ
ڻڹУûùʵģͣоĲֶĹ.ڹģ͵ķһʹ̬Ӧ趨ֵıظŵϢ۲ⱻع̵ԣƫ趨ֵڹ.Ϊһڹ̣ҪӦԽ.ͨʹõϵͳȶԵĳ˥ȣԼƻ·Ӧٶȵʱ䳣Ƶ.þͬӦüٻӵӦĹȽףȷӦ.ˣڹӦ.ģ͵ȣڹڴظźʹ趨ֵ仯ķͬǰ߱Ƚ趨ֵ仯18.
BristolһֻģʽʶPID23.ͼܿģ38ݣñջϵͳӦһԱԶĿ־ٵΪ״̬ԴΪͨõ.УһPID۲̵ĽԾӦű仯Ӧߵ.÷ŵӦü򵥣Ҫû趨ģͽ״εϢҪԤУԾԶ.ҪȱҪʽ򣬴Ӷϵĸ.⣬÷ϵͳҸšСλ̬Լϵܽϲ.
ģ16һֻƵʶĻڹ.÷ڣ̲жıջ,ʹƵʶӱջϵͳõйƳ̵ĿƵӦ.˼ûκζ̬֪ʶ⣬÷ؽм̵򿪻ԾӦ.÷ʹԼӦƵӦԻñջڵԸߵ.ʶԶִУҼʵ.
2.3ܱȽϼӦ
ģ39ݸPIDܱȽ.ֱõ·PIDSatt Controlļ̵練ԶУFoxboro EXACTԵڿԼһĽZ-NԭPID(ڻضʵ).ڹ̷Ϳģ³ļһԹ.̬ӦĻƽĶڱȽ趨ֵ仯̬ظżµӦ.ʱҲܱȽо.1PIDʹ.
1PID

Ʒʹ÷
Foxboro EXACT(760/761)ʹýԾӦԼģʽʶӦֱƶϹ.
Alfa Laval Automation ECA400ʹü̵ͻģ͵Ӧ.
Honeywell UDC 6000ʹýԾӦڹӦ.
Yokogawa SLPC-181,281ʹýԾӦģ͵Ӧ.

3PID
ڶ£УԺ;PIDṹļϵTanttu40PeltomaaKoivo41ݵĹ.ģ40ݸȷԻع黬ƽDARMAģĿ.ڸ÷УPIDͨƲƲԵ.ģ42Ҳһ㷨ϵͳĽԾӦͨʹõƱʶõ.ǣַÿڶҪ棬ⲻ߼.
ģ3ݸڶPIDܽᣬЩҪһƵʷΧʵֶ.һMIMOPI/PIDûרϵͳģ43и.ȻЩֶʱ.⣬ҲҪϾȷĶ̶̬ģͣ˲.
ΪʹPIDģ4447ݽ̵չڶPID.ģ44ͨĵ·̵練IRFʵ飬˷ɢPIDϵͳȶͨPI/PIDʵķӵԱ.ģ45һֽ˳·ջ̵SRF.ģ4647ͨɷɢPIDлõķɢ̵練DRF22㷨.
ɢ̵練DRFһıջԣĵ̵練IRF˳̵練SRFΪֱջ.ջڿǰ߸̴ٵĸŲʹģЧ5.DRFЧʶ̵໥ãʹƳΪܣIRFSRFֱӼ̵໥.ģ46,47ʹõDRFֻһ·PIDˣھк໥õĹ.
ģ13ԾϵĶ̣һȫ϶ĶPIDӦ÷ɢ̵練DRFķ.÷ͨɢܽϲʹȶľ໥õĹ.оDRFµĶ񵴣磬һȶmṃƵԽϴļ̵ֵ仯¼ֲ䣩mɢ̵練ʵ飬ʵУƵʱ˴˽ӽԱڸƵʴƹƵӦ󣻽һڼ̵ƫԱһ̬ԶPIDڽǰ¸һµƷ̣PIDֱͨƵʼƵʴⷽȷ.
ģ48һάĻDRFķɢPID㷨.㷨׶Σٱʶл·ٽһٽƵʵٽ㣻ڸý׶Σü̵绷ڴеĿˣл·вͬڵ񵴣ÿ񵴶Ӧڹ̵ٽ㣻ͨı̵ȷͬĵ㣻һ̣ù̿ٽ㣬ͬʱֹ̱ͿƱķֵԤȸķΧ֮ڣڽZ-N19ݻR-ZN2149ݣٽPID÷ŵǣںѡٽ֪̬棬ڱջʽ£ͨڱʶٽͬʱȷ.
ģ14ݸһPIDṹĶԵڿ.ԶPIDṹʹڹҵӦ.㷨һ¯΢ϵͳ.Ըù¯¶ȿƽʵоʵʩԵPIDҪѡûĶʽ󣬸̲ʹͼηĹ̶PIDԤ.õܸϺõĿЧ.
4PID
ԾPIDԸӵķϵͳҪģ50һ÷ĽPIDӦԺ³Եķ.һµķԽṹ-΢51µĻҪأӦЩҪصġϡʽĽPIDƳһͷPID.ĻҪزûֱȡ-ȡΪźžԴõ΢ֺͻ.ԿɽáPIDһʣͿΪPID.лַPIDһ־ʽ.
ģ52÷ԸĽPIDĳɹСԸ-΢PIDȽṹϵͳġʱ߶ȡġӦԡ³ԡȸԼЩṹ͸Ӧ÷.ָƲͬҪĿֻϵͳġʱ߶ȡp.˵Ϊ˽пƣһȥʶģֻͣҪʵعƳϵͳġʱ߶ȡpͿ.ܿض䡰ʱ߶ȡǱȽ׵.⣬ǿáʱ߶ȡpƳѧϰѧϰ.оѧϰ˵ѧϰ̣򵥶Ч.оԿ÷ԡȡ΢źţ쾭PIDΪоܿṩһµ;.
ģ53״νģ50ķPID㷨ɹӦڵ¯ɢϵͳԿƼ¯Ĺʣ¯ºͺ¹̽ʵʱ.ӦýPIDȴͳPID³ԸǿΪһо̷Կṩܺõķ.
5
PID㷨ΪֹͨõĿƲ.಻ͬķȷʵĿ.ЩڸԡԼʹõĹ֪ʶ.һõӦûںؿԵԣظ˥Ч̱仯³ԣ趨ֵ仯ӦģͣҪ.Ҫ򵥡ֱۡõķҪٵϢܹʵ.ҲҪЩҪϢܸϺܵĽϸӵķ.
ĿǰPIDоӦ״¼潫ǽһʱоʵص.
ٶڵ뵥ضҪоԲȶ򱻿ع̴ڽϴµPIDʹڳʼź³ܷһǿʹĹϢϼ򵥵ĲܽϺõ.
ڶڶضҪоԾϵĶ̵ĶPIDһƷɢ̵練ܼϢʹ.
PIDƼдһоӦƻ趨лϣʹԶϹܡ17רҾ֪ʶֱ߼רϵͳ˼ͷԭPID˼뼰иĽԤơģƺPIDϣ54ݣһ߿ϵͳܣPIDƷչļǰ;ķ.
ҽܳѧ(69825106).
ΰ19551982ҵڶѧԿϵ1988ڶѧҵԶרҵѧʿѧλ19901992ŲƼѧ²ʿо19981999Ӣţѧ·о.ΪѧԶоĺ͹ұԶ()ΣʿʦڹҪڿ͹ҪѧϷ50ƪҽίƼȽΣ1998ҽܳѧһ.ҪоΪӦơԤơܿƵ.
žΡ19721993ҵѧԺԶϵ19981ڶѧϢѧԺѧ˶ʿѧλΪѧԶоĲʿо.оΪPIDܿơϵͳģƵ.
ӡ1947ΪѧԶоĺ͹ұԶ()Ρڡʿʦ.оΪӦơܿơϵͳģƵ.
ΰѧԶоġ110006E-mail:wangw@mail.neu.edu.cn
žΣѧԶоġ110006
ӣѧԶоġ110006
ο
1ݡӢ.PID.ƥ鱨饤֥ꡪ6,,1992
2ݡ».ӦPID.Ϣ,1988,17(5):4150
3ݡKoivo H N, Tanttu J T.Tuning of PID controllers:survey of SISO and MIMO techniques.In: Preprints of IFAC International Symp.on Intelligent Tuning and Adaptive Control,Session 1,Singapore,1991
4ݡAstrom K J, Hagglund T,Hang C C,Ho W K.Automatic tuning and adaptation for PID controllersA survey.Control Eng.Practice,1993,1(4):699714
5ݡAstrom K J, Hagglund T.Automatic Tuning of PID Controllers.Research Triangle Park,North Carolina:Instrument Society of America,1988
6ݡAstrom K J,Hagglund T,Wallenborg A.Automatic tuning of digital controllers with applications to HVAC plants.Automatica,1993,29(5):13331343
7ݡSchei T S.Automatic tuning of PID controllers based on transfer function estimation.Automatica,1994,30(12):19831989
8ݡHang C C,Astrom K J, Ho W K.Relay auto-tuning in the presence of static load disturbance.Automatica,1993,29(2):563564
9ݡPark J H,Sung S W, Lee I B.Improved relay autotuning with static load disturbance.Automatica,1997,33(4):711715
10ݡVoda A A, Landau L D.A method for the auto-calibration of PID controllers.Automatica,1995,31(1):4153
11ݡHo W K,Hang C C, Cao L S.Tuning of PID controllers based on gain and phase margin specification.Automatica,1995,31:497502
12ݡHo W K,Lim K W,Xu W.Optimal gain and phase margin tuning for PID controllers.Automatica,1998,34(8):10091014
13ݡWang Q G,Zou B,Lee T H,Bi Q.Autotuning of multivariable PID controllers from decentralized relay feedback.Automatica,1997,33(3):319330
14ݡYusof R,Omatu S, Khalid M.Self-tuning PID control:a multivariable derivation and application.Automatica,1994,30(12):19751981
15ݡHang C C,Loh A P, Vasnani V U.Relay feedback auto-tuning of cascade controllers.IEEE Trans.on Control Syst.Tech.,1994,2(1):4245
16ݡMcCormack A S, Godfrey K R.Rule-based auto-tuning based on frequency domain identification.IEEE Trans. on Control Syst.Tech.,1998,6(1):4361
17ݡHo W K,Hang C C,Wojsznis W, Tao Q H.Frequency domain approach to self-tuning PID control.Control Eng.Practice,1996,4(6):807813
18ݡAstrom K J, Hagglund T.PID Controllers:Theory,Design,and Tuning,2nd Edition.Research Triangle Park,North Carolina:Instrument Society of America,1995
19ݡZiegler J G, Nichols N B.Optimum settings for automatic controllers.Trans.ASME,1942,64:759768
20ݡAstrom K J. Toward intelligent control. IEEE Control Systems Magazine,1989(April):6064
21ݡAstrom K J,Hang C C,Persson P, Ho W K.Towards intelligent PID control.Automatica,1992,28(1):19
22ݡKraus T W, Myron T J.Self-tuning PID controller uses pattern recognition approach.Control Engineering,1984(June):106111
23ݡBristol E H.Pattern recognition:An alternative to parameter identification in adaptive control.Automatica,1977,13:197202
24ݡAstrom K J, Hagglund T.Automatic tuning of simple regulators with specifications on phase and amplitude margins.Automatica,1984,20:645651
25ݡBristol E H.A simple adaptive system for industrial control. Instrumentation Technology,1967(June)
26ݡCallaghan P J,Lee P L,Newell R B.Evaluation of Foxboro controller.Process Control Engineering,1986(May):3840
27ݡHagglund T, Astrom K J.Industrial adaptive controllers based on frequency response techniques.Automatica,1991,27(4):599609
28ݡNishikawa Y,Sannomiya N,Ohta T, Tanaka H.A method for auto-tuning of PID control parameters.Automatica,1984,20: 321332
29ݡHang C C, Sin K K.An on-line auto-tuning method based on cross-correlation.IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 1991,38(6):428437
30ݡMorris H M.How adaptive are adaptive process controllers?Control Engineering,1987,34(3):96100
31ݡSchei T S.A method for closed loop automatic tuning of PID controllers.Automatica,1992,28:587591
32ݡShen S H,Wu J S, Yu C C.Use of based-relay feedback for system identification.AIChE J.,1996,42:11741180
33ݡKessler C.Das symmetrische optimum.Regelungstetechnik,1958,6(11):395400
34ݡSung S W, Park J H, Lee I.Modified relay feedback method.Ind.Engng Chem.Res.,1995,34:41334135
35ݡLeva A.PID autotuning algorithm based on relay feedback.In:Proc.IEE,Pt D,1993,140(5):328-338.
36ݡHo W K,Hang C C, Cao L S.Tuning of PID controllers based on gain and phase margin specifications.InProceedings 12th IFAC World Congress,Sydney,Australia,1993,5:267270
37ݡӣŹ.ڸԣȺͷֵԣPID·.Զѧ199723(2)167172
38ݡHang C C, Chin D. Reduced order process modelling in self-tuning control.Automatica,1991,27(3):529534
39ݡHang C C, Sin K K.A comparative performance study of PID auto-tuners.IEEE Control System Magazine,1991:4147
40ݡTanttu J T.A comparative study of three multivariable self tuning controllers.Tampere,Finland:Tampere University of Technology Publication,1987,44
41ݡPeltomaa A, Koivo H N.Tuning of multivariable discrete time PI controller or unknown systems.Int.J.Control,1983,38:735745
42ݡJones A H, Porter B.Design of adaptive digital set-point tracking PID controllers incorporating recursive step response matrix identifiers for multivariable plant.IEEE Trans.Autom.Control,1987,AC-32:459463
43ݡLieslehto J,Tanttu J T, Koivo H N.An expert system for multivariable controller design.Automatica,1993,29:953968
44ݡLuyben W L.A simple method for tuning SISO controllers in a multivariable system.Ind.Engng. Chem.Proc.Des.Dev.,1986,25:654660
45ݡLoh A P,Hang C C,Quek C K, Vasnani V U.Autotuning of multiloop proportional-integral controllers using relay feedback.Ind.Engng. Chem.Res.,1993,32:11021107
46ݡPalmor Z J,Halevi Y, Krasney N.Automatic tuning of decentralized PID controllers for TITO processes.InProc.of 12th IFAC World Congress,Sydney,1993:311314
47ݡZhuang M, Atherton D P.PID controller design for a TITO system.In:Proc.IEE,Pt D,1994,141:111120
48ݡHalevi Y,Palmor Z J, Efrati T.Automatic tuning of decentralized PID controllers for MIMO process.J.Proc.Cont.,1997,7(2):119128
49ݡHang C C,Astrom K J, Ho W K.Refinements of the Ziegler-Nichols tuning formula.In:Proc.IEE,Pt D,1991,138(2):111118
50ݡ.PID.Զѧ,1994,20(4):487490
51ݡ,ΰ.Ը-΢.ϵͳѧѧ,1994(3)
52ݡ.÷ԸĽPID.Ϣ,1995,24(6):356364
53ݡ˳,,֣ﱦ,֣Ԫ,,FDA1һ˳.PID㷨ڵ¯ɢϵͳеӦ.Զѧ,1995,21(6):675681
54ݡž,ΰ,ܡ.һܿƷ300MW¿ϵͳеӦо.йѧ,1999,19(3):610
ոڡ1998-09-26
޸ڡ1999-04-20
