Ϣ
Information and Control
1999ꡡ281ڡVol.28No.11999



ӾҪؽ


ժҪ ͨCVGIP־1994֯ļӾй3DؽսĻع˺ͷó ӾҪؽһҲؽ
ؼʡӾ3DؽĿ壬Ӿ
RECONSTRUCTION IS NOT NECESSARY FOR COMPUTER VISION
WANG Tianzhen
(Digital Image Processing Laboratory ,Wuhan Automotive Polytechni cal University,430070)
AbstractIn the paper,base on the review of the debate(199 4,CVGIP) about reconstruction and purpose,in computer vision theory,author c oncludes:reconstruction is not necessary for computer vision,and also is impossi ble without any inference and constrain in general situation.
Key wordscomputer vision reconstructionrepresentation, pur posism, active vision

1
ӾǵԾҲѧƣ3DؽMarrΪ׵ļӾ 70ΪӾľĿ1ݣ 3DؽָǸݴһ һͼػָ3D״λ[4]ͨüӾϵͳѣ80 Ӿ۽ Ӿ״Ŀģ뷽ʵӦչ˼Ҷۣ㼯ؽϣϣMaryland)ѧӾоʵҵY.AloimonosΪ׵Ŀ ѧɣӾӾݶûһɹͨϵͳֵʵ3 Dؽ[19]ΪʶҪؽĿѧӾϵͳ ݻΪݣʽݵĻãԶԵķʽȥȥþȷʽ⣮ĿڼӾ˺ܴ飬19911994̶,Ȩ־CVGIPIU֯δ[26],[1720]һЩѧ ѧĸ߶˵Ӿؽ޹(Aloimonos)ޱ(representation) ӾBrooks MIT),ؽıEdelman)дӸϷ3Dؽ εĴ˼Ӿĸ⣮ϵĽɽĿΪCVһ ɣһЩ-ӾҪҪ3Dؽд һ֣̽Ľݶ1994۵Ļع˷оؽ⣬ԡӾ Ҫ3DؽԼCVоĿ 
294CVGIP֯սؽĿ
ӾҮ³ѧϵM.J.TarrͼϵM.J.Black 1994CV GIPIUˡԻӾбõļݻĹ۵㡱A Computational and E volutionary Perspective on the Role of Representation in Vision[2]һ, ˼ӾйĿؽĵڶսĻشƪԻ9ƪ TarrBlackԼԻشĻشר۹11ƪ£սTarrBlack ȷָģ˵ĿĶ3DؽǵӾѧйط ·ߵۣʹǷʽĸıҲǷϵĴת䣮նؽ̬ȣμսѧ ߿ԷΪɣ
һɣTarrBlackǲؽǿеģҲҪñоһӾΪĿӾӱǽ⣬ӾݵĻôӶǺǰ;.
ǽؽĿļ򵥵رΪǴʵģͣģ罻 ΪȻĿǰؽ屻Ϊ޳ɹʵȻΪؽǿеģؽȰӾҲӾϵͳǴݻͼ֤һ 
ǳ3DؽΪĿĵӾокܶⶼǲ̬ģûи޷ģΪӦüʵʲǼھ㣮ǴѧҵݣָȻС̽Ӿ٣˺Գ֪ӾϢӹȫͬģӤıȥѧϰ,ȥչǵ֪ʶһ һ򣬶ͶϢӹͨRepresentation ʱɱʾ ֵģǻɼôƣĿô ̣
ָȥAIֻCVһӴݲŵӹȫϲ²ָãΪӦøıΪݵĻǽĺܺ÷ʽΪĿ塱Ϊӱǽ⣬ǹ̹۵㣮
Tarr BlackʾǺ AloimonosԼ Brooksһ޳ݻĹ۵㣬Ϊ൱еĸ֪ԵȣǴһķ书ܽĽҽһ裬ӾҲǴȻѡĽָĿġȻʹγɹףʹݻѣؽñʹͼؽһܺõ֤ ûͼҲߣҪ֮һã
ӼĹ۵TarrȶԹо˻ع˺չǳϹоڲ ΪʹõѧߣΪMarkovۿܽЩ Լ˶ָʱʱֵϵͳŤ˶Ϊо ۲쵽ģʽŤΪѧĽǶȹУ
ڶĿѧɣֳΪѧɣΪAloimonosĿѧΪ3DؽĿ̫ߣ̫Ҫþ⣮AloimonosΪ ѧôб¹۵㣺(1)Ӿʶ̣롢͡ѡؽ ޹ (2)Ŀġ桢ӾҲǹҵӾΪĿһµ ͼݻõĹΪһĿĵģ뱻ǰ ȥͼݵĻãΪһӾֻһ룬ӾĿ,ĿľΪ ĿӾӾӾϵͳϵĿġԡͬĸĿ ⣬Իشν⣬ָݵķʹףʹ ףһһĿ(3)Ϊӹ̿ δ֪һ̣ȷ⣬ҪһҪӸ(4)ָMarr ʵWarrington ĹFarahʵȴó˲ͬĽۣAloimonos ƪȷӾʶ̣롢͡ѡؽ޹أ ڼӾоǵһΣ൱Ҫ壮
ɹ۵Ŀؽ֮䣬ȽϷɢ󲿷ּ޳оһӾһӾ ΪӾоĳԶĿ꣬ͬĿӾоȥӦдʵ⣮ ɫWeizmannѧѧԺѧϵS.Edelman[25] ,ڼӾоûؽıкBrooks˵ûбӾM arrûĿĵؽSRIM.A.Fischler[27]漰Զγɸ üϢαҲ˼
S.EdelmanǴѧĸ߶Ȳμ۵ģΪûؽı󡱣Reply: Representa tion Without ReconstrutionһУΪTarr Blackһʼ͵ؽCVиһı󣬶CVڹȥ15ģؽıᷨ׷ݵʿ£ĮΪʵļθƣʵĹ۵㣬ؽıһֿѡCVʵ֤ؽļ̫ѣؽľֻа׳ղ⣮к֤ܶ˵֪ؽ費һ£ӦÿоĹ۵㣺һܱеһֻҪȻĶܱ𣬲ʿ½ؽӾо̽ĻͿԹһڵı ı㹻ḻ弰ıЩԪ
Edelmanʵ˵ؽ޹أһǳα꿨󣮹ȥؽۼؾؽȥ౻СĤư߸󣬲ʹŷѧһصҰĶ̬Ľ˴ȫòؽһõƤMTĳϸܸı˶жϵʵʵ˵һMTϸĻʵϹ˴̼˶һ󣬵ؽͣǵӾ񾭿ѧһЩʵʾΪſռֱ絽ʶֱӴͼгȡҪؽGibson ŵֱӸ֪ȫĽʱûؽıкBrooks˵û ӾMarrûĿĵؽǱȽϺģݴѧR.Jain[23]ָ ѧGibsonģCVѧѧУΪһõCVӦüȲϵؽҲǷĿߣһߣйصģͱȥ⾫ȷ⣮
һӾ̲ĵߣ˹أRochestѧBrown[24]ΪһӾȫģʹ罻棬̽֡ؽĿġһĹϵָؽ¶ϵĹڽʱȴ˸ָ߲Ȥ˵Tarr BlackӦáĿġƥսǵΪһŰֽӦû÷չݻķʽȥѧϰȥ̡ӣѡ֪Ʋ⣮
ô׶ࣨTorontoѧϵJ.k.Tsotsos[26] Ϊ˫ Tarr BlackAloimonosBrooks,BallardMarr)õѧݴ󲿷Ѿʱ µѧʵָвڶĹģ飮
SRIM.A.Fischler\ָͳѧеĸָCVȷ ĸûбձܣӾдڵ˫⣨ʯͷϻ˵ӾоϲָǲٵģΪװǵӦоԽĿ꣬ҲǻӾĻλ
CVGIPIU`94۶ԼӾչ൱ҪģȻĽֻʽɡĿġѧɣԼӾǷҪؽûȷĽۣӾ۽ͨȷ˼ӾǼӾǷҪؽȴջ
3Ӿ׺ؽûйϵ
Ӿؽûйϵ?Ϊ˻شȴӳʶԵʵ𣺵һؽʶʵʶҶ֪ʱԲʱ䣬ʱʱʱƸסʱȺǻ,Ȼڰ޺ŵǰû˵浽ʲôģ˵ؽˣ׶Ҳʶ˵ʶӾҪؽڶʵǶԱʶһκ̵ᣮӢй˲֪ ̨ĲԱпǶȱ仯ᳬ 15ȣֻҪ󣬾֪Ӣй󲿷˶ ûмȫ󣬲֪Ǹǰݣ棬˵ؽ ȷļȥۻعǰڲɷãҿһŮԱ Ͳһһ汨ڣԱͦãûӢ һͷ˸ţϳʵɼ˵Ӿɲ2DͶӰͼ ʶ壬ؽ
ٴѧǶȿ⣮Salzman30ݱõ΢̼޺Ԫܸı޺ע˶жϣʹжϷָԪ˶ƫ÷򣩣˵ϸķѾγ˶(Coherent Visual m otion)ı󣮵޷ؽ͵ģؽҪ֮һ 3һ϶µƻȡϢ˫Ӳԭ[31]пӱ3DؽӲڿռ֪ ʲôã18ӢѧҲдһӾۡ[32] Ϊռ֪ӾͶӡ֮侭ϵĽִѧ϶һ[33]89ѧϰʱϸ۲һһ̨׶ʱ babysitterҷܽкɳĶʯɳСԲˮ һЩĺָȥĨƽɳеˮͬٶʯһú£ָȥˮ.ʱҹ׶ûУ֪ѧݵģøµèＰӰʵ˵ƤȷǶؼγɵ[34] ׶ӲȱӲؽӱµ⣮ܹƽϵķݣ˵ľ룬ǺܹյƲʺͷɻľ룬Ϊûо飮ɼ۴һоǶҲˣӾؽʲôϵӾȷʶ̣롢͡ѡ
4ӾҪ3Dؽ
Ҫǿһµͼе3DͶӰؽ[35]ͼӾеؽ ͬĸ3DͶӰؽָX-ߡ-ߡͳֶΣ3D аһֱʵҪȡһͶӰ¹3Dͼ磬ҽ ѧеļϲࣨCTȣ3DͶӰؽ㷺ڷҽѧ΢ ѧ3D CADͼؽУȡ˼ĳɹȷʵеģֵ о Ӿе3DؽǽӾɳ̵[31] ݴһһͼػָ3D״λã ѧ綼ʶǸ̬⣬ûһƼ룬ûȷģ ֿ꣬һȥȷ۲㵽ľ뵱Ȼ⣬ һͼûȥؽǲܵģֻйڻľ硢쾰ؽɹĵıδ˵һȻ˵ӾֻǸĤϵͶӰȥʶ壬ǳ̵㣬ӾҲȫҪؽ
ӾԿһӾñϢ˺ͶоϢӹ Ӥñѧϰ˻ʹùߣӦӻ һӬҪԭ򣬹ʼӾоûؽıкBrooks˵ ûбӾMarrûĿĵؽӦһܺõİ취ûؽı ôأĸϸγɵģ1994һЭͬʽӾģͣԪȺĿ۵ĵͬʱͬĶĤϵͼ洢롢ͼ͸оǼǡ2Dͼʶ𣻲֪źн[16,38]3DʶӲ2Dģ⣬ʵ 
һ¶ĿͬϵĿĿþ ʹӾн⣬ӳԶȷӱǽ⣮ӿѧʷԷ֣ĳЩѧȷʵӾол˺ôоΪѧķչ˺ܴףǴӸгȡһɵķǾúշAdhocԸ⣬ ܶоʱһ
AloimonosָӾʶ̣롢͡ѡؽ޹أS.EdelmanʾؽԽûκã ǶΪӾҪؽԼʮоͬǵĹ۵㣮 ˵ӾҪؽһҲؽҪҲﲻĿ꣬ӾͻӷõļнųΪĿǰҳһе·
߼:䣬54꣬ڣоΪӾͼ㷨˹ܡģʽʶ磮
ߵλ人ҵѧͼо人430070
ο
1 Marr DӾۣѧ磬1988
2 ȣӦгɳŵļӾģʽʶ˹ܣ1992,5(4:266271
3 ӾҪӦãģʽʶ˹ܣ1992,54:272276
4 £ӾҪʵĹģʽʶ˹ܣ1992,54261
265
5 ٣Ӿۣģʽʶ˹ܣ1992,54:276278
6 ۣԾӾӦãģʽʶ˹ܣ1992,5 4:279286
7 ֻ䣮ӾƼο199516(4):6570
8 Li hungwenKender JScanning the Issue Computer Vision,Proc. of IEEE,1988
(8).859861
9 Ĵ,ԬڣӾоչչͨѧ199314(4):5 664
10ʽܵ. ͼ,㽭ѧ,1990
11Ballad H, et alComputer Vision,Printice-Hall,1982
12ȣģ񾭼,ѧ,1992
13¸.,оӾѧĺΪ;,ﻯѧչ,1980,(1) 2126
14Rosenfeld AzirelComputer Vision:Basic Principle,Proc.of IEEE,1988,76 (8):863
868
15䣮Ӿģһ人״ѧԺѧ199610(3):2934
16䣮ӾģоĻعչ 人ҵѧѧѧ1996 18 (1):712
17Jain Ramesh C. Binford Thomas O. Dialogue Ignorance,Myopia and Naivete in 
Computer Vision System, CVGIPIU,1991,53(1)112117
18Snyder M.A. Reply A Commentary on the Paper by Jain and Binford,CVGIPIU,
1991,53(1),118119
19Aloimonos YA Rosenfeldreply A Response to " Ignorance Myopia, and Naviete 
in Computer Vision Systems" by R.C.Jain and T.O.Binford, CVGIP IU,1991,53(1):
120124
20Huang T S. Reply Computer Vision Needs More Experiments and Applications,CV GIP:
IU,1991,53(1:125126
21Tarr Michael J. & Black Michael.J. Dialogue :A Computational and Evolutionary 
Perspective on the Role of Representation in Vision, CVGIPIU,1994,60(1:6573
22Aloimonos YReply What I Have Learned,CVGIPIU,1994,60(174 85
23Jain,Ramesh Reply Expensive Vision,CVGIPIU,1994,60(1:8688 
24Brown,Christopher M. Reply Toward General Vision,CVGIPIU,1994,60(1:8991
25Edlman, Shimon Reply: Representation Without Reconstrution,CVGIPIU,1994,60
(1):9294
26Tsotsos John K. Reply There is no One Way tolook at Vision,CVGIPIU,1994,60
(1):9597
27Fischler Martin A ,ReplyThe Modeling and Representation of Visual information,
CVGIPIU,1994,60(1:9899
28Tarr Michael.J. & Black Michael.J. Dialogue : Response to Replies Reconstruction
and Purpose, CVGIPIU,1994,60(1:113118
29lewin,RogerBirth of a Human Robot, New Scientist, 1994
30Salzman C D. Cortical Microstimulation Influences Perceptual Jugements of Motion
Direction,Nature,1990,346(12):174177
31£Ӿѧ磬1993
32߾ѧʷ1982
33ʦѧϵѧʦѧ磬1984
34Fagiolini M.etal.Functional Postnatal Development of the Rat Primary Visual 
Cortex and the Role of Visual Experience: Dark Rearing and Monocular 
Deprivation,Vision Research,1994,34(6):709720
35ٿȣͼӦãҵ磬1985
36Stephen W K. 룬ѧԪԣѧ磮1991
37֣ܿ. Ӿģ͵о뷢չϢƣ199726 (2112116
38Wang TianzhenThe Plate Pallelral retrieval Hypothesis for Visual percepti on 
of Chinese Character, Proc. of The Third Int. Conf. on Automation,Robot,and 
Computer Vision, Singapore 1994, 2:915919
ոڣ1998-06-16
