о뷢չ
JOURNAL OF COMPUTER RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT
1999Vol.36No.7P.824-829



CORBAʵϵͳŻо
л塡˹Ⱥ
ժҪCORBAΪ֧칹ֲʽϵͳĿеĻƽ̨ڶõӦ.ǣഫͳCORBAʵϵͳܱȽϵͣ޷һЩҪϸߵӦϵͳҪ.ķ˴ͳCORBAʵϵͳϵṹо˽ʵָӳٵCORBAϵͳŻԣͬʱĻϵŻԶпѭCORBA 2.0淶ORBUSϵͳŻŻǰܽ˱Ƚϲ.
ؼʣCORBAŻGIOPIIOPCDR룬
ţTP301TP393
RESEARCH ON PERFORMANCE OPTIMIZATION
OF CORBA IMPLEMENTATION
XIE Jun-Qing
(Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Southeast University, Nanjing 210096)
CAI Min
(Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Southeast University, Nanjing 210096)
GU Guan-Qun
(Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Southeast University, Nanjing 210096)
AbstractCORBA has been used in many fields as an environment supporting the development and deployment of heterogeneous distributed systems. But most of the traditional CORBA implementations have low run-time performance and can not satisfy the requirements of time sensitive applications. This paper first analyses the structure of the traditional CORBA implementation, and then introduces some optimization strategies. Finally those strategies are used to improve run-time performance of the ORBUS system which is a CORBA 2.0 implementation system developed by the authors. Some tests are also taken and the results are presented.
Key wordsCORBA, performance optimization, GIOP, IIOP, CDR, compile, interpret
1
żķչӦչInternetϳΪûձֲͳΪµȵ.ڷֲʽ㻷У칹һʮԵص.칹ʵϢԴĹʮѵģһ׳ķֲܽΪֲʽӦĿı.1989ʼOMG֯һֱ֧칹ֲӦͼɵؼоͱ׼ƶ.ƶCORBA淶1칹ֲһõĽ2ݣĿǰõ˴Լ830ҳ̺ͻ֧.CORBAʵϵͳ֮ӿ֣򡢵򡢽ϢԼͨõ˹㷺Ӧ.
ǣһЩеķֲӦϵͳƵ㲥Ƶ鼰ʵʱϵͳѸٷչͳCORBAʵϵͳЩӦõ֧Ե൱.ȱڴͳCORBAʵֵܱȽϵ£޷ṩӳٵĴ֧.ڴ£оͲԹʼֽCORBAʵϵͳܷŻӶΪܵCORBAʵֵ춨õĻ.
2CORBAʵϵͳŻ
2.1CORBAʵϵͳṹ
ͬCORBAʵϵͳʵּϵṹϸϴźܴҲCORBA淶ֻϵͳԺΪʵֵľ.ȻͬCORBAϵͳĻɲͬģҴCORBAϵͳһͻĲͬϵͳƵ.ʹĳϵͳɲŻԶԲͬCORBAϵͳԶõ.
ڻCORBA淶ķֲʽӦϵͳͻԷĳʱȻɿͻ׮Stub߶̬ýӿڣDIIòIIOPЭͨݱʾCDRĸʽȻORBĽװIIOPıķ͸.ORBĽոIIOPĺȽĵĽ룬ȻɻBOAͷܹskeleton߶̬ܹӿڣDSIÿͻĲɵӦӦ.ִò֮ͨƵ;ͷͷֵݸͻ.ùͼ1ʾ.ͼеӰֱʾҪŻCORBAʵϵͳĻɲ׮̬ýӿڡܹ̬ܹӿԼIIOPЭʵ.ЩɲŻòͬļ⽫½.


ͼ1CORBAϵͳʵϵṹ
2.2Żо
CORBAʵϵͳŻԸŻĲͬ¿ԻΪ3IDLɴŻIIOPЭʵֵŻַƵŻ.УǰŻǽܵϵһģĳ̶ֳϣIDLɴŻҲΪIIOPЭʵֵŻһ.⣬ŻԻֻ漰CORBAʵֶϵͳŻû漰ֱ֧ĴĴЭ鼰ʵֵŻ.
2.2.1 IIOPЭʵֵŻ
Ϊ˴ﵽORB以ĿģCORBA 2.0淶жORBͨŵı׼ͨЭGIOP (general inter-ORB protocol)3ɣ١ݱʾCDRṩGIOPʾIDL͵ĸʽ׼IDLӳ䵽ͼĶԱ紫䣻ڡGIOPϢ.GIOPЭ鶨7Ϣʵֶ/ش𡢶λŵۡGIOPϢݻƵĶ.GIOPЭֻһֳЭ飬ʵʱӳ䵽ЭضϣĿǰCORBA 2.0淶GIOPTCP/IPЭDCEӳ.
GIOPЭ鵽TCP/IPЭӳΪIIOP(internet inter-ORB protocol)Э飬𲽳ΪInternetϵĶ󻥲Э.IIOPЭйݱʾϢʽȾGIOPȫֻͬǶϢͲֽ˾廯涨TCPGIOPϢ.
ڸ͵Ĳͷֵࡢ뼰͡նҪIIOPЭĴˣIIOPЭʵֱӹϵCORBAϵͳܺЧ.
1ӹŻ
IIOPЭֱӼTCP/IPЭ֮ϣÿͻشضͨһضTCP/IPд.ڴCORBAͻشTCP/IPӶԣ3 ÿͻ󶼽һTCP/IP.÷ʵֱȽϼ򵥣Ҫ¼κιϢǣڲϵؽͲTCP/IPӻķѴʱ䣬ˣַЧ͵ģ ÿһTCP/IP.÷˴ĽͲÿͬķĿͻ󶼹ͬһӣǣ˷ȽϴʱͬʱάֵTCP/IPܻᳬϵͳɶϵͳʧܣ ÿϵͳһTCP/IP.ʱͻ˶һضķϵͳٸֻһӣеĿͻ󶼹ӣˣЧߵ.ǣϵͳάһͻ/ϵͳӶӦԲҵõӦTCP/IP.
2ʾ㴦Ż
оͲԱ34ݣڴͳCORBAϵͳķֲʽӦó֮ԲߣҪIIOPЭıʾ㣨룩ЧʱȽϵ.IIOPЭʾ㴦Ż̬ú;̬öͬ.
ڶ̬£ͻ÷Ĳʱͻ׮ͷܹеĲࡢҪORBеCDR涯̬طòϢTypeCode.ڱòTypeCodeͬʱͨεɸò͵Ļ͵ı/ı/.ִԳΪ͡ıʾ㴦.
OMG IDLУָͣ繹ͺģ͵ȣɻ϶ɣҿ໥Ƕ.ǣеĸսΪֻ.ڸ͵Ĳı/ԣִеʱҪԷΪ֣ɸò͵ĸ͵ı/ִʱ䣻ڷòϢTypeCodeεø͵/ִʱ.Ȼĳ̶͵Ĳٲִֵʱǹ̶ģڲִֵʱڸ÷Ҫ̬طֵرʹñʾĴΪƿ.
ڴGokhaleVargheseͨЭŻ߸ָԭ򣬶IIOPЭıʾŻ5ݣ Գͳ㷨ŻڡԴ˷ѣۡר㷨ȡЧʲߵͨ㷨ܡȼ㲢泣ֵݡм״̬ԼӿԴķѴ㷨Ĳޡڲ֮䴫ŻϢߡCPUŻ.ЩָԭҪĿΪһͨЭŻĽһԣЩԭҲIIOPЭʾ㴦Ż.
ھ̬£ڿͻ/񽻻ĽӿڼʹõIDLļָӿÿĲͶڿͻ׮ͷܹǿ֪.ͿһЧʽϸߵIIOPЭʾ.÷Ļ˼ͨIDLڿͻ׮/ֱܹɲ͵Ļ͵ı/C++룬ڽв/ʱͿֱӵЩ/.ַԳΪ͡.
÷Ģڲִֵʱȡ͡Ҫ͵Ķ࣬ΪòֵĹIDLԱΪԵĹѾ.ǣУIDLɵĴĳȽ.ĳЩǶʽϵͳԣͻ˻˴ӽ޷ϵͳ.ˣھ̬õӦøݾַ֮ţ6ݣѱͽʹϣγɻϱ/ķ.
IDLԶɻ͵ͱ/Ҫ4Ҫ⣺
(1) Ϊĳɱ/Ĵӵĺķѣ
(2) Ϊɱ/Ĵܽʡʱ棻
(3) ÿʱõĸʣ
(4) һŻ㷨3ֵٶȻ볤ȵԼصͼΪһͱ/뷽ŷ.
ͼT={t1,t2,,tn}볤ȼC={c1,c2,,cn}ʱ伯S={s1,s2,,snƵʼF={f1,f2,,fn}citiӦıͽӵĴ볤ȣsitiʹñͽʡʱ䣬fitiʱʹõƵʣͨԤȹƻʵͳƵõһ¿ΪƵͬ.CmaxӵĴ볤ȵֵŻʽ£
ٶӵĴ볤ȵϽΪCmaxҪѡһͽ͵ļϣʹӵĴ볤ȲϽ磬ʡʱ࣬滮⣺

xi{0,1}xi=1ʱʾtiı/뷽ʽΪͣxi=0ʱΪ.
Ȼ滮ѱ֤һNPȫ⣬xiȡֵֻ01ڸ⣬һЩϺõıƽ㷨.
һʱ临ΪO(n.logn)Ľ㷨£
(1) ki=si.fi/ciÿtiӦki
(2) i1ntikiֵӴСtjǸ򣬼j<j+11jnʱkj>kj+1
(3) ڸУȡǰmʹãtjӦxiΪ1xiΪ0.
ͨ滮⣬ȷIDLļЩҪɱͽ.ֻTypeCodeͨCDR涯̬ؽб/.ͿԱȽؽIIOPЭıʾ㴦.
2.2.2 ַƵŻ
ͳCORBAʵϵͳIONA˾Orbixϵͳڷ˶ԽյĿͻзַʱ÷ֲδķʽȣBOAݿͻеĿ˳ңȻڲҵķļܹskeletonУĿĲƽ˳ңַȽϣִиĿĴ룬оķ.ֲַַķʽ漰˳ҵḶ́˵ķԼֵ֧ĲϴʱϵͳĿǳ.仰˵ǷϵͳĿչԱȽϲ.
ַƵŻҪǲHashһƴ˳һƣ7.ַHashһֿԷΪࣺ ֱĿҼƲʩHashҵķʽԣַҹȻǷֲνеģ ĿҼƲҽһHashңʱԼܹķֲβҹ̵Ľ޽ƣγһβҵķʽ.÷ʽڷ˵ķԼֵ֧ĲϴԣִЧߵ.ȻHashȷ൱ѵ.
3ORBUSϵͳŻԷ
3.1ORBUSϵͳ
CIMSĲй̼ɿܹؼǹҡش󹥹ĿĿͨCORBA 2.0淶ҵܣʵֲͬܣеܡܺ;Ӫܣ֮ĲͬӦϵͳϢ͹̵ļɣԴﵽܲеؽвƷĿƺ.ORBUSϵͳǿƵѭCORBA 2.0淶һʵ֣ҵܵĺĲɿתҪ֧.
ORBUSϵͳĿǰ֧Solaris 2.5Windows NT 4.0ϵͳֵ֧ıΪC++.ORBUSϵͳORBϵͳIDL/C++ͽӿڲֿҪ.ORBϵͳCORBA 2.0淶еORBġDIIIIOPȵݣIDL/C++IDLӳ䡢׮ͼֵܹ.
3.2ORBUSϵͳŻ
ORBUSϵͳԭȵıĴƲSunSoft˾IIOP.SunSoftIIOPһѵIIOPЭĲοʵ֣ftp://ftp.omg.org/pub/interopC++ԱƵģṩѭCORBA 2.0淶ORBĴܣǲIDLӿڲֿĻ.SunSoftIIOPοʵֲˡ͡ıʾʽҪĿΪĳ֧ǶʽϵͳЧʲߣ5.ȻORBUSϵͳҪ֧־̬÷ʽһǿIDL/C++ˣŻORBUSϵͳ¸дIDLɱĲ֣SunSoftĽ棬γˡ͡ıʾʽ.
ͬʱԭȵORBUSϵͳʵΪ˷㣬˶ÿͻ󶼽һTCP/IPӵķڿͻȽܼ£ܴܽܵӰ.ˣŻORBUSϵͳöÿϵͳһTCP/IPӵӹ.
ORBUSϵͳŻǰԼCORBAƷIONA˾OrbixϵͳܽжԱȲ.ָܺҪ
(1) throughput:ָͨλʱͨʵ䵥ĴСһbpsΪλ.CORBAϵͳԣָҪָͻ̵ʵ֮䣬λʱñʽʾĸ߲Ӧƽĵʾ㼰¸Э.Ǻʾ㴦ܵҪָ.
(2) ӳ٣latency:ӳٶCORBAϵͳԣҪָӿͻʼÿͻ˴ĲʼͻյòֵΪֹƽʱ䣬Ҫȥ񷽶ʵִвʱ.
3.3Ի
ORBUSϵͳOrbixϵͳܲһ̨Sun Ultra IվCPUƵ143MHzڴ64MBϽеģùվĲϵͳΪSolaris 2.5.1.ʵҵ绷Ϊ10MBps̫Ϊ˲ʹΪƿ޷ȷӳĴͻͷSun Ultar IվУ֮òϵͳڵTCP/IPػػloopbackʽбĴ.
typedef sequence<short>shortSeq;
typedef sequence<long>longSeq;
typedef sequence<float>floatSeq;
typedef sequence<double>doubleSeq;
typedef sequence<string>stringSeq;
typedef sequence<char>charSeq;
struct PerfStruct {
short shortVal; long longVal; float floatVal;
double doubleVal; char charVal; string stringVal;
};
typedef sequence<PerfStruct>structSeq;
interface TestReqReply {
long test prim args(in short shortVal, in long longVal,,out char outChar, out string outString);
long test struct args(in PerfStruct structVal, inout PerfStruct inoutStruct, out PerfStruct outStruct);
long test prim seq(in shortSeq shortVal, in longSeq longVal,, out charSeq outChar, out stringSeq outString);
long test struct seq(in structSeq structVal, inout structSeq inoutStruct, out structSeq outStruct);};
ԵIDLļжһTestReqReplyӿڼ4ԲֱڲԲΪ͡ṹ͡͵ͺͽṹ͵ʱCORBAʵϵͳ.
3.4Խ
ͼ2˻͡ṹ͡кͽṹеĲԽ.ԵĽ˲ˡ͡ʾ㴦ʽԼÿϵͳһTCP/IPӵӹ֮CORBAϵͳݴ˽ϴߣӽƷIONA˾Orbix 2.2MT for Solaris.


ͼС112ֱʾ(ִдг)(5050)(20050)(50100)(200100)(50400)(200400)
ͼ2(a) ͣ(b) ṹͣ(c) к(d)ṹеĲԽ
4
оCORBAϵͳŻҪָCORBAϵͳʵּŻCORBAʵϵͳŻԴCORBA淶ǴЭGIOP/IIOPȣĻֽУ磬ڸܵĴЭ飨XTPЭ飩֮ϽCORBAϵͳĵĴ.⣬ĿǰʵʱCORBAϵͳоѾΪȵ㣬ܵCORBAоʵҲʵʱCORBAϵͳǰͻ.
Ŀõҡش󹥹ĿĿ863-511-9704-002.
߼飺л壬У1972ʿҪоΪֲ칹缯.
У1976˶ʿоҪоΪֲ.
˹ȺУ1940йԺԺʿڣʿʦҪоΪߡܼ硢Э鹤̡CIMSֲ.
ߵλл壨ҽίϢ֧żʵ,ϴѧơѧ빤ϵϾ210096
ҽίϢ֧żʵ,ϴѧѧ빤ϵϾ210096
˹ȺҽίϢ֧żʵ,ϴѧơѧ빤ϵϾ210096
οף
1Object Management Group. The Common Object Request Broker: Architecture and Specification, Revision 2.0, 1995
2Vinoski S. CORBA: Integrating diverse applications within distributed heterogeneous environments. IEEE Communication Magazine, 1997, 14(2): 4655
3Gokhale A, Schmidt D C. Measuring the performance of communication middleware on high speed networks. In: Proceedings of SIGCOMM '96, 1996. 306317
4Gokhale A, Schmidt D C. The performance of the CORBA dynamic invocation interface and dynamic skeleton interface over high speed ATM networks. In: Proceedings of GLOBECOM'96, 1996. 5556
5Gokhale A, Schmidt D C. Optimizing the Performance of the CORBA Internet Inter-ORB Protocol over ATM. Washington University, Tech Rep: #WUCS-97-10, 1997. http://www.cs.wustl.edu/cs/techreports/1997/WUCS-97-10.ps.gz
6Hoschka P, Huitema C. Automatic generation of optimized code for marshalling routines. In: IETP TC6/WG6.5 International Working Conference on Uppler Layer Protocols, Architectures and Applications, 1994. 131146
7Gokhale A, Schmidt D C, Moyer S. Evaluating the Performance of Demultiplexing Strategies for Real Time CORBA. In: Proceedings of GLOBECOM'97, 1997. http://www.cs.wustl.edu/schmidt/GLOBECOM-97.ps.gz
ոڣ1998-09-28
޸ڣ1999-01-10
