ѧ
ACTA ZOOTAXONOMICA SINICA
1999 24 3 Vol.24 No.3 1999



оչ
š֣衡
ժҪǽάһҪ裬һƽĵģʽƥ.񡢲ԡģ͡͹()Ȼ.зͲԣĸģͽ˱ȽϣϸĿǰԾѧĸⷽĿǰڵĸ⹤߻򻷾˹ͱȽ.л򵥽ⷽȡõһЩչ.
ؼʡ⣬أ Ƭģʽƥ䣬OOAF
ͼšTP311.5
THE RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT OF SOFTWARE COMPREHENSION
LI Bi-Xin, ZHENG Guo-Ling, LI Xuan-Dong, ZHANG Yong-Xiang, and LIANG Jia
(Department of Computer Science & Technology, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210093)
(State Key Laboratory for Novel Software Technology, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210093)
AbstractSoftware comprehension is an important step of software maintenance, and it is regarded as an increasing pattern matching process from one level to another. First, in this paper, the-state-of-the-art and development directions of basic factors of software comprehension are systematically studied, i.e., concepts and models are compared, tasks and strategies are analyzed, objects are discussed, environments and tools are classifiedand all kinds of software comprehension methods are analyzed. Then, the progress made in object-oriented software comprehension is also discussed. Finally, some good conclusions are given, and future work is also presented. 
Key wordssoftware comprehension, basic factor, program slicing, concept analysis, pattern matching, OOAF
1ǰ
ĲʹúͿվ͸ӵͶг.άѳΪǰҵٵҪ.ȣڻδƳʵʿõȷϼͶʹú޸Ĵ󲻿ɱ⣻ΣĻûҪ󾭳Ҫ޸ʹ书ܺӦĿǰûдﵽĳ̶ȣú͸ûµҪ󣻵ģΪ˸ĽδάԺͿɿԣΪ˸δĸĽ춨õĻ.ˣάǵձע.Ͷʹú󣬶оƵĻͳά.άǷ⡢޸ġȷϵĹ.άĵһܷ׼ȷѸ١ȫǾάɰܵĹؼ.ͨһʩͷŪһǡʲô Լһ4ʶλٿۺϳ߼.оһɷΪ4ࣺ1о70ʼ,Ŀǰڼ.صǾϢʾʾڲϵĿӻ.ֳͼĹȣ2оʼ70ڣоҪ8090.صǴԴȡϢͨõݿУȻͨѯԶݿвѯ3оʼ80.صǲ֪ʶȼʶ4оʼ90оصǲģʽƥ䡢任ȼʶĸ߲׼㷨ݽṹ﷨ƥ.ĵ26ڷֱ񡢲ԡģ͡͹()ȵ״ͽչ7ڼ򵥵ؽⷽȡõһЩչ8ַͨķоܽƽĵģʽĵĽ.
2Ͳ
ڲͬĳ󼶱Ͻģ(mental model)ʵǽ(Ӧ)򵽳(ʵ)ӳ伯ͼ1.ķΧӴ뱾ģ͵ӦģͣĿΪ˱άչٹ.Ϊ4ʵּ:鵥ĳƽṹ򱻵͵رʾɳ﷨(AST)űͨԴı.ֹĶ˹Ʒȡ̬̬;ڽṹ:нṹϵȷʾɲ֮ϵ.򹤳̡ϢȡϢ󡢽ṹģƥ䡢ʶ緶ͽṹۼּṹȹ;۹ܼ:ṹΪ()֮Ĺϵ,ͬʱоɳĺ.ƻָΪģʽƥȹ;Ӧü:ضӦĸ.⡢ʶ𡢸ֵȹ.


ͼ1
ʹõķͲõ.ҪТԵϲ.ʵӳ伯(mappings),()()ɷ־ۼγɸ߲ĸϵͳ.Զ².Ӧʵӳ伯ммʾ.ĽȷϺ;Ḷܸ́õӦĿƵ⣬ڹʦר֪ʶ.ۻ.ԵϺԶ²ԵĽϣԵϺԶ²Եŵ㣬ԲͬӦýűпӦ.
3ģ
ǿϵͳϵΪģ͵Ĺ.άͷչһҪ60%90%ʱ.Ƶĸӻ.һϵͳʵǳϵͳĸ߲Ḷ̵́ĿƷģͣģͰʵĶ໥ϵ˳һЩ̫Ҫϸ.
Brooks ʹһֻԶ·ģͣ1.ģͼƽ׶߶ᷴӦڴ.˻ָЩ߲ͨм¹ٰӳ䵽.ģ͵ĹͨԶ¹ʵֵģһ̳ɹʹõʽ֤.ģ͵Ķһܵĸ߲Ҫ裬ʽ֧Ҫ.
Soloway  Ehrlich ǵģͣ2вԶµķڴ֪¿ɲģ.ӵе֪ʶʽ裬ԱϵͳֽܹڴʵֵѾ֪ϵͳȻֽÿϵͳֱȡʵּȶܵһ.ַģĿ͸ֵĲι.ýĿֽɸٰ֣ѸַֽӸ.һʹ3ֲͬĸ֣սԸ֣еԣԸֲ֣йأʵԸ֣ʵֲԸֵԵ.
Letovskyʶģͣ343Ҫɣ֪ʶ⡢ģͺͬչ.֪ʶаԱӵейسƹ淶֪ͨʶҲһЩҲǹ㷨ݽṹʵֺͱ׼ȳƷĹģͿ԰3ͬĳ֯ٹ˵㣺ò˳Ŀ;ʵֲ㣺òʾ˳Ͳ㣬Ϊʵݽṹ͹;ע㣺òѹ˵ÿĿʵֲеʵϵͬչɻڼĹʽĲѯ֪ʶ.3ͬͣwhy衱һѡĿģhow衱ƲʵһĿķwhat衱ʵ.
Pennington һֲͬĹ۵Եϵķ5.ԵϵķǴ뿪ʼģƵģʽ(Ϊ)ģʽļϺһʶ߳ϵģʽ.Penningtonģÿͬʽ⣬ģͺ龰ģ.ģǳṹĵͲģ.ʵϣάԱڴϤʱĳģǶԿһֵͳ.µĸӳĳģͨѴṹֿɸĽṹģ龰ģڳģ֮󿪷ģһ/ܵĳ󣬰Թܲ֯ʵĶ˵ҪӦ֪ʶرʾ.
Von MayrhauserVansʹһְǰ漸ģ͵ļģͣ67ݣͨ۲֪̻ԵϻԶ»ַϵĹ.ģͰ4Ҫɷݣģ͡龰ģ͡Զģͺ֪ʶ.ǰ3ǽѾܵģ.ϤʱģͿԶģͣԴȫϤʱԵģ.ͨԶµķʽƽ̣ϤĴ벿֣ҪתȥԵϵо.֪ʶ3ɷֵĹ춼Ǳ.ÿģ͵ĳɷ־ɴмʾԼмʾĲԹ.֪ʶںǰϢ֪ʶ.УµϢŵ֪ʶԱڽʹ.
ѧ1997ķֲ㹹ģͣڶϵͳĹܷ估໥ϵʶ.ģͰϵͳֳ7Σ֮Ĺǵģ㹦ܵʵֶǰ͸ģ͵7ηֱǢϵͳӦò㣻ڳͲ㣻Ͳ㣻ܻͲ㣻ݶȡ㣻Ͳ㣻ȡ.


ͼ2
4ⷽ
4.1̷
̷ù̵İ취гķ򹤳̡򹤳̡ٽṹùԼٹ̵ȣֱҪ.
(1) 򹤳̺򹤳
ͳ̾ǰһϵͳ߲ͶƵ߼ʵתʵֵḶ́򹤳̹. 򹤳̱ΪǲıϵͳĻֻһּ̣Ǳ任̣ͼ2.ͨ˹Ʒȷϡ˹Ʒ֮ϵķֲּ.Ϊ򹤳һ̣Ϣժȡϵͳȷɳɷֺ͸ɷ֮ĹϵϢһʽ߳󼶴ϵͳıʾ.ҲΪ򹤳һ3̣ռ֪ʶ֯Ϣͱʾ.оۻʵйصϢ.֪ʶݺϢϵݻĹ.ϢָĵĿѡĽϢ.һΪ򹤳̾Ƿϵͳȷĵǰɷֺͳɷ֮ԼȡϵͳϢĹ.Ϊ򹤳һ3̣ģͽ(model creating)ʹøģͻӦضģͣȡ(extraction)ʹúʵȡƴϵͳۼԭʼݣ۳(abstraction):ĳ,ϢĿ.˵һЩ:,ƻָ͸ֵ,ļ,,̬Ͷ̬,Դṹ,Ӱ,άԷ,ǨƷ, ,÷.


ͼ3
(2) ٹ: ٹ(restructuring)ͬһصĳ󼶱ϰһֱʾתһֱʾϵͳⲿΪĹ.
(3) ù: ù(reuse engineering)ȷϵͳпõĲԼıһϵͳʹ֮ӿõĹ.ع: ָ,(ADT)ȷ,ݾ,ɷȷ,óɷֿ.
(4) ٹ: ٹ(software reengineering)Ǽ͸¸һϵͳһµʽؽĹ.عУ򹤳̣ʵ֣ụ̀ٹ̣Ľ,ºͿأʽתٽṹļģ黯ٿ.
4.2Ƭ
Ƭ(program slicing)Ǹݿһֳ.ڹȥ20УƬȡþ޴չⷽѾרŵ׿.ǸдԵļƬ߲ο.
(1) ƬִͳĳƬһƬǸݳ˳ѭѡṹгƬ.ԱùĳƬʶĴҲΪ.Ƭ̬ƬͶ̬Ƭ֣ǵĲ֮ͬǣ徲̬Ƭʱ迼ǳִ·(ɿĻ򲻿ɿ)̬ƬֻǴһ뵽ضִ·
(2) ޶ͳƬ޶ͳƬMark Harman Sebastian Danicic1997һֳƬ.봫ͳƬȣ޶ƬڱһͶӰͬʱ˳򣬻ʹκμ򻯵תЩתӳ䣬ˣڴͳƬĻǿ˼⣻
(3) ̼͹Ƭݹ̼ڷƬƬɼʶĹ̼ڵĿأҿóƬϢԱõظĽЧʣ磬Marry Jean HarroldNing Ci1998Ĺ̼Ƭ͵Ĵ25ݣ
(4) ƬƬѱӦõ1996Loren LarsenMarry Jean Harrold19ݰƬӦϵͳͼ͹ͼУʹö(رC++)ĵԣ⣬ԣ򹤳̺Ͷ׵Ķ.ͬ꣬Frank Tipˣ20״ƬC++ε㷨ʹöC++иӵĶ̳к̳лƵü.
4.3ʶ
ȻѰ൱ձ򹤳̻ҪѰ.άԱڸǿٹ̳֮ǰҵش룬ͨʺĳģʽĴ.ģʽһֽṹΪѰЩض﷨ṹĴ룬ѰЩִйصض̬صĴ.ΪλģʽҪһָӽʦģ͵Ѱ(һĳ)ֻƳΪʶ(plan recognition).ԴƬεĳʾ.ñȽϷʶһϵͳгֵʵ.̻Եģʽƥ.ʶĽ֮һʶ򵥴ƬΣڵԴ뾭ıһϵͳٴαʹ.ʵʡʱ䣬ӵĴСҪÿƷĸı䣬Ӷάе.ʶ£Զ.ҪʵֵһĿȷĸʵЩĿ꣬ȻЩֺԴģʽϵ.Ե.Դ뿪ʼʶԴƥĸ֣Щƶϳ߲Ŀ.ۻ.ԶºԵϽʹ.
4.4ֵ͸
ֵ(concept assignment)Ƿĸе⣬Ǹֵϵͳڲʵʵ.ڴʹöӦ﷨ģʽʶĸʶһֽȻλʦ˵ȤĴƬʱ(Ϊֱ﷨ʵӽڳƵģ)ֱóʵԵ.ѳֱʾӦòǼ򵥵سƬΣŵ㽫.һַǸֵ.һĵĸʵֵĸƥḶָ́ģʽƥʹάԱѰƬεĻ.ֵûնӦģʽƥ.һԴʶͨϵʶӦһĹ.ʶо׶ʹõñȽ϶࣬ԭ֪ʶռ(Ըֵʶ͹Լ)Լƥ̵ĸԵԶܵ.(concept analysis)κζ֮Ĺϵתһȫĸ.ͨоЩ񣬲øܹܳɹоʼϵԺͽṹı.Ϊ֮ĹϵʱɼһעͳߵĻ.
4.5ģʽƥ䷨
ģʽƥ(pattern matching)ڲͬĳ϶ԳĸģʽƥĹ.ʶ˹Ʒ֮Ĺϵһڲͬεıʵģʽƥ.ʶ𡢲˹Ʒ.ͨ򹤳ʦģʽʶϵͳһضıʾ.⼼µʽԴ룺ֲıԤıʻ־﷨űע﷨/ͼ֣緶͸ģ͵.ӳʽĸ﷨ӽĺΪʽͽṹԶ.ԲͬûͲͬĿ˵вͬεķ.û﷨͸ģʽƥ򹤳ⷽǿԳ. 
4.6
̬Ͷ̬: ̬(static program analysisִֻǸһЩģƶϳʽĹ.﷨ͼƺṹáӶȶȹ̣̬(dynamic program analysis)һϵͳзʱĹ.ʵ̬Ͷ̬ԡͼǼǺͻؽк·ǲԡڴƿ֧.
4.7ⷨ
(intelligent understanding)˹ܺרϵͳ.ĿǰѾ⹤¼:رģĻڹʴϵͳ,LASSIE;ڸĳʶ,Աͽ, GRASPR, PAT, PROUST, TALUS; ģϵͳDESIRE.
5Ľչ
ѾӴͳĽṹչڼѧ19995ڵһƪ̸⣬ֻ򵥵.
ͳҪ¼չģ
(1) ݽṹ⣻
(2) ڿƵ⣻
(3) ڹܵ⣻
(4) ļͻ֪ʶ⣻
(5) . 
ⷽһ¼棺ٻε⣻ڻڶϵ⣻ۻڶʽṹ⣻ܻڸ߲ϵͳ⣻ݻڶϵͳõ⣻޻ڷ̬Ե⣻ϸ⣻ö.
6⹤(PCTs)
⹤(PCTs)һʹĽṹܵḺ́׵̹.PCT񣺢ٹĸϵͳдĸӴ룻۲򹤳̷ָĳӳƣļĿǰڵĸӼ򣻢ռһӳ幹ϢͽṹϢ޻ȡһϵͳΪ㷨Ϣ.
ĿǰѾڵ⹤ߺܶ࣬ݹߵ;ɷֳмࣺ
(1) ڴPCTs
⹤ṩһĴϸϢ.ǵĿľǰԴ.๤ҪһӦóĽṹľ̬.Щ߸ĿĵĲֿͬɷΪ¼ࣺٻ֪ʶĳߣƳԱͽܵĹߣ۴Դг߽׺ĹߣܻʽĸʶʾƸĹߣʹøֿģʽƵܹԤԡͽ͵Ĺ.磬Ͼѧƿ⹤TAUS ܶPascalԴнṹ, TAUS˼Ǹݳṹ߼ṹѳ򻮷ֳɽСĳηֱ⣬ͨԳٻ˹ģִг򣬴ﵽԳ˽⣬ѳϸڵɳɸ߼ĳ.PROMPTERIBMձѧԺƵĻ֪ʶĴ⹤ߣܲдĳע.PROUSTYaleѧϵƵĹߣɳԱдPascal⣬һԼһķ㷨Ϊ룬Ȼҵʹ֮ܵƥ.ͨȱݵĴͬͼϵȱݵһ.G. Antoniol1996ƳǶĳɹCANTO(ͽṹ)һȫϵͳ⻷CANTOڲͬĳϼ˶ַ۵͹۲㣬ЩΰӾϸϢ㵽淶֮в.ûԸԼҪԴϢͨƸüʲôüʲô.
(2) ڷԵPCTs
ѧ򹤳̷ܴɾͣܽԺʿΪ׿ġ񹤳̡ߣC++ԣ̬Դ룬EERenhanced entity-relationshipΪC++ģͲȡϢϢݿУ󣬰ղͬû֯ϢûC++.ԴOODĵROSEĵΪûһȡṩ.ù3ɣϢȡϢû.ĴǵJohannes SametingerһC++άߣù߰C++ļֳһСĳƬ,磬ඨƬʵƬƬȣַͨԱC++дĳ.WashingtonѧDavid GraveڹͼĲ㷨,øÿʵϤĺ͵㷨Щ㷨CecilJavaдеȹģĳзʱ𵽺ܺõЧͬʱ˷˹̼Ժͺʱڸӵ.Gen++һC++ķһC++߿ɱʵҵPrem DevanbuLaura Eavesͬģʵֹͨ﷨ѯGENOA/GENIICfront 3.0϶.ĿǰC++Ѿʵ಻ͬĹߣԱɲͬ.磬C++һ̳вΣԱ֮亯ͼΪһഴһȱʡ?ʹñ棻C++ıpublicԱĿĿıȣĹ캯ǷǱ˵ģ鹹캯ǷûбģûκγԱӦü.Taegyun KimGyusang ShinԴ1994꿪ʼһֳΪOODesignerCASEߣù߾֧OMT3ģͣԴıһͼм֮һԣάģ͵Ϣֿ⣬C++ԼC++򹤳̴ȹܣ24.
(3) ٹ졢ٹ̡򹤳̡ù̵PCTs
๤ܺܺõع̵ĸ.άԱܹǴһĵͼȡ߼Ϣ.ʹǴӸֹ߳(Ķ̽ͨģʽƥ)аѳ.ͬʱ򹤳̹ߺͼȴ˹ܵԶ׳ӿɶ(ͬڶ֤ʽһ).֮򹤳̹ǰԶġĺͿɶģʹֹġĺͲɶĴĶȸ֮ҲͬԶġǽĺͨǲɶԶ.磬ǼѧԺ D.F.Jerdingָ10ݣʵ֡޸ĺٹһϵͳҪԳִʱĽ⣬ΪҪѰʶ𡢿ӻͷĳִʱķԿ⶯̬Ϊ߷ֳִʱĽűԶ̽г.һʶЩģʽķ.÷֧ƻָ֤ٹ̣÷ȿҲڹʽ.
(4) ڳطPCTs
Aaron B. Binkley Stephen R.Schachض(CDM)35ݼͨءṹغݼﵽĿ.һֳɹCDMԤ֪ʱʧܺʹͬάʱܹѰ.Ҫ4еõ֣һCOBOLעϵͳʱݶһCıߵάݶһC++ЭϵͳάݶһJavaĵļ豸άݵĶ.
(5) ͼμͿӻPCTs
øָͼΡͶһ.磬(CHG)е̳йϵӶͼ(SOG)̬ʶʵиӶ󡢲ѯȣԴÿͼ(CFG)֮ͳڲɷ֮Ŀƹϵͼ(DFG)֮ͳڲɷ֮ϵͳͼ(SDG)Ϳͼ(CDG)ϵͳиϵȵ.磬Danny B. LangeYuichi Nakamura 199514ݽǵĻProgram ExplorerһC++ĳӻù߰еĶ̬Ϣ();̬Ϣ()г⣬ȡ˹CIA++GraphLogŵĻϿɹ.вˮƽѡʹֱѡϾ̬ϢͶ̬ϢļʹöC++ⷽ㡢ݡЧ.
(6) óƬPCTs
磬Wisconsin Ƭversion 1.1һֶ֧Cϵͳ.ƬǰƬƬ3ֹܣܹûöһʲô.ƬͲͼͳͼһɣͷC﷨һǰƣҲתƬмʾ.
⣬øPCTs26ݡöPCTs35ݵȵȣPCTs9ݡPCTs26ݵȵȣƪﲻ.
7OOAF
ڿһֻCHGķĿܡOOAF.OOAFĿǰ¹ܣ
(1) ·ȼ()ʶӶ
(2) ·(Ӷ)пɼȷ
(3) ȷĿɼCHGɼͼ(VM0-CHG)
(4) WM-CHGĻϼ̳м͸дȷд߽磻
(5) 麯ͼ(VFCG).
OOAFܽṹ¼ɣ
(1) ʷ﷨.C++/JavaԴĴʷ﷨ȷԣ
(2) CHG.Դʷ﷨ȷC++/JavaԴCHGͼ.CHGC++/JavaУ
(3) C++/Java.÷4ɣ
 ӶʶʶĶӶ
 ȷȷ()ɼ
 ̳(д)ÿļ̳м͸дȷ÷ĸд߽磻
 VM-CHGVM-CHGVM-CHG뵽VFCG.
(4) VFCGü̳(д)VM-CHGļ̳мдVM-CHGȹVFCG麯õйϢ.ȻOOAFĿǰֻһܽķ̬Ŀܣ𲽼ɶͷƬӻȼԽһOOAFĹ.
8
Ϸֱءо״½չ˱ȽȫķоΪ
(1) ⷽһضĳĳεģٻڻм⣬벻ͷ뼼ڻԴ⣬򹤳̡ٹ̡ٽṹù̵ȼۻ﷨⡢ֶΡƬȼ͵Ĵܻڳ⣬ģʽƥ䡢ʶ𡢸ֵ͸ȶǽ弶ͷ.
(2) һƽģʽƥ̣ٳ.г﷨ģʽƥ;ڸʶ.гģʽƥ;۸ֵ.Ӧ(նû)ģʽƥ.
ͬʱͳȡõһЩչǹ麯ͼ(VFCG)36 ķ(OOAF)Ϊ̬麯ģͻṩһֿеĽ.
ȻWoods SYang Qiangʽ֤һNP-hard30ݣǴӲͬĽǶȣͬĲνȻǿȡýչ.ʵ֤άⲻز٣淢ľ޴.ķעػۼ﷨.ԣΪģʽƥ䡢ʶȷԺҪ.ͬʱھ㼼ķչƣþ㼼гҲһֽȡķ.
ĿõʡӦûĿ(ĿBJ97036)
߼飺ţУ1969ʿоҪоΪ.֣У1937ڣʿʦҪоΪ̡.У1965ʿڣҪоΪʵʱϵͳ.裬У1975˶ʿоҪоΪͳ.ѣŮ1974˶ʿооͬ.
ߵλš֣衡ѡϾѧ¼صʵҡϾ210093Ͼѧѧ뼼ϵϾ210093
ο
1Brooks R. Towards a theory of the comprehension of computer programs. Int'l Journal of Man-Machines Studies, 1983, 83(18): 543554
2Soloway E, Ehrlich K. Empirical studies of programming knowledge. IEEE Trans on Software Engineering, 1984, SE-10(5): 595609
3Letovsky S, Soloway E. Cognitive processes in software comprehension. In: Soloway E, Iyengareds S eds. Empirical Studies of Programmer: First Workshop. Norwood. NJ: Alex Publisher, 1986. 5879
4Letovsky S, Soloway E. Delocalized plans and software comprehension, IEEE Software, 1986, 56(5): 4149
5Pennington N. Comprehension strategies in programming. In: Olsen G M, Sheppard S, Soloway E eds. Empirical Studies of Programmers: Second Workshop. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publisher, 1987. 100113
6von Mayrhauser, Vans A M. From software comprehension to tools requirements for an industrial environment. In: Proc of 2nd Workshop on Software Comprehension. Capri, Italy: IEEE Computer Society Press, 1993. 7886
7von Mayrhauser, Vans A M. Comprehension processes during large scale maintenance. In: Proc of 16th Int' l Conf on Software Engineering. Sorrento, Italy: IEEE Computer Society Press, 1994. 3948
8von Mayrhauser, Vans A M. Software comprehension during software maintenance and evolution. Computer, 1995, 55(8): 4455
9Robert O'Callahan et al. Lackwit: A program understanding tool based on type inference. In: Proceedings of 19th Int'l Conf on Software Engineering, Boston, 1997. 1723
10Jerding D F et al. Visualizing interactions in program execution. In: Proceedings of 19th International Conf on Software Engineering, Boston, 1997. 1723
11David Grove et al. Call graph construction in object-oriented language. ACM SIGPLAN Notices, 1997, 32(10): 108124
12Margaretha W P. Analyzing the measurability in object-oriented designs. In: OOPSLA'97 Conf Proceedings, Las Vegas, Nevada, 1997. 2233
13Greg Defouw et al. Fast interprocedural class analysis. In: Proceedings of POPL'98, San Diego, CA, 1998
14Danny B Lange, Yuichi Nakamura. Program explorer: A program visualizer for C++. USENIX Association, Conf on Object-Oriented Technologies (CONTS), Berkeley, Calif, 1995, 2629
15Danny B Lange, Yuichi Nakamura. Object-oriented program tracing and visualization. IBM Research, Tokyo Research Laboratory, Research Report: RT0111, 1996
16Danny B Lange, Yuichi Nakamura. Interactive visualization of design patterns can help in framework understanding. In: Proceedings of the ACM Conf on Object-Oriented Programming Systems, Languages, and Applications (OOPSLA '95). New York: ACM Press, 1995
17Yucihi Nakamura, Danny Lange. Object-oriented visualization to help program understanding. Transactions of Institute of Electronics, Information and Communication Engineers (IEICE), 1996, (10)
18Darren C Atkinson, William G Griswold. The design of whole-program analysis tools. In: The Proceedings of the 18th Int' l Conf on Software Engineering (ICSE-18), Berlin, 1996. 2529
19Loren Larsen, Marry Jean Harrold. Slicing object-oriented software. In: The Proceedings of the 18th Int' l Conf on Software Engineering (ICSE-18), Berlin, 1996. 2529
20Frank Tip et al. Slicing class hierarchies in C++. In: The Proceedings of the 11th Annual ACM Conf on Object-Oriented Programming, System, Language, and Applications (OOPSLA'96), ACM SIGPLAN Noteces. New York: ACM Press, 1996
21Mark Harman, Sebastian Danicic. Amorphous program slicing. In: The Proceedings of IWPC'97, Dearborn, 1997. 2830
22Danny B Lange, Yuichi Nakamura. Object-oriented program tracing and visualization. IEEE Computer Society, 1997, 6370
23Ramalingam G, Srinivasan H. A member lookup algorithm for C++. In: Proceedings of The 1997 ACM SIGPLAN Conf on Object-Oriented Programming Systems, Language & Application (OOPSLA'97), Las Vegas, 1997. 1830
24Taegyun Kim, Gyusang Shin. Restructuring OOdesigner: A CASE tool for OMT. In: The Proceedings of the 20th Int' l Conf on Software Engineering (ICSE-20), Kyoto, 1998. 1925
25Marry Jean Harrold, Ning Ci. Reuse-driven interprocedural slicing. In: The Proceedings of the 20th Int' l Conf on Software Engineering (ICSE-20), Kyoto, 1998. 1925
26Snelting G. Concept AnalysisA new framework for program understanding. In: Proc ACM SIGPLAN/SIGSOFT Workshop on Program Analysis for Software Tools and Engineering (PASTE), Montreal, 1998. 110
27Canfora G, Mancini L, Tortorella M. A workbench for program comprehension during software maintenance. In: Aniello Cimitile ed. In: Proceedings of 4th Workshop on Program Comprehension (IWPC'96), Los Alamitos, Califonia: IEEE Computer Society Press, 1996. 3039
28Crimitile A, Lucia A De. Identifying objects in Legacy system. In: Aniello Crimitile ed. Proceedings of 5th Workshop on Program Comprehension (IWPC'97), Los Alamitos, California: IEEE Computer Society Press, 1997. 5061
29Keller R. Pattern visualization of software comprehension. In: Aniello Crimitile ed. Proceedings of 6th Workshop on Program Comprehension. Los Alamitos, California: IEEE Computer Society Press, 1998. 8096
30Woods S, Yang Qiang. The program understanding problem: Analysis of a heuristic approach. In: The Proceedings of the 18th Int' l Conf on Software Engineering (ICSE-18), Berlin, 1996. 2529
31Christian Lindig, Gregor Snelting. Assessing modular structure of legacy code based on mathematical concept analysis. In: The Proceedings of the 19th Int' l Conf on Software Engineering (ICSE-19), Boston, 1997. 1723
32Gregor Snelting, Frank Tip. Reengineering class hierarchies using concept analysis. E-mail: Snelting@ips.cs.tu-bs.de
33Prem Devanbu, Laura Eaves. GEN++ An analyzer generator for C++ programs. E-mail: Prem@research.att.com
34Antoniol G et al. Program understanding and maintenance with the CANTO environment. E-mail: antoniol@irst.itc.it
35Binkley Aaron B, Stephen R Schach. Validation of the coupling dependency metric as a predictor of run-time failures and maintenance measures. In: Proceedings of the 1998 International Conference on Software Engineering, Kyoto, 1998. 452455
36ţƷ壬֣. һھ̬йVFCGķ.Ͼѧѧ.
(Li Bixin, Wang Yunfeng, Zhang Guoliang. An approach for constructing VFCG in statically-typed object-oriented language. Journal of Nanjing University, to appear)
յڣ1999-01-21
ĸڣ1999-04-07
