ѧ
JOURNAL OF SOFTWARE
1999 10 8 Vol.10 No.8 1999



̶ֹ֧̽ģо
ΪԪ
ժҪӦӹ̽ģĽǶȿǶԹ̶֧,һ̶ֹ֧̽ģĿ.ĿĹ̶ģͽģ̶ֹ֧Ƶѡ̶ֹ֧̽ģ㷨.
ؼʡ̶,̽ģ.
ͼšTP311
Research on Metric-supported Software Process Modeling Methodology
SU Wei-min ZHU San-yuan
(Shanghai Development Center for Computer Software Technology Shanghai 200050)
Abstract In this paper, the authors suggest to think about the problem of process metric from the process modeling point of view, and discuss a methodology for metric-supported software process modeling, which includes a goal-oriented process metric modeling method, a descriptive mechanism for software process and an algorithm for metric-supported software process modeling.
Key wordsProcess measurement, software process modeling.
̸̹̺Ʒ֧ɣ1.,̵̹Ŀ,̽ģ͹̸ĽͳΪ̵̹оȵ.ͨ,̵ĸĽ·ʽе:(1) ģ;(2) ģʵΪ;(3) ڹʱ;(4) ̸Ľ;(5) ʵʩ̸Ľ.,(3)ǹ̸ĽĹؼ.һЧķǹ.Ŀǰ,о(Software Engineering Institute,SEI)һģ(capbility maturity model,CMM)Ϊ2汻㷺.е5Ϊ̲ϸĽĽʽĿ.19936,ʱ׼֯SPICEĿ,ּڿһı׼(Software Process Assessment,SPA).Ŀǰ,ñ׼Ĺݰѽ2ͶƱ.SPICEĿ䲼ļ3,δSPAһCMMΪġSEIʽ׼4.
Ȼ,SEISPAΪĹȴɱش:̹ڳ;ͬ˻ʽͬͬ;һЩҪĶûܼʱռȵ.ԭ,Ϊûһ׶õġһµ,뽨ģɵ.漰Ķ衰ڻ̵Ĺ,ʹҪʵʩĶΪ̵һ,ؽ淶Ĳ뷽,ӶSEIʽSPAڵ.Ǿһչ.
йؽģϵʼ90.PfleegerMcGowanʹһSADT(structured analysis and design technique)Ա㷢ֹе,͹̳ȶṩԽ5,6.LottRombachһַռݵĻɵģУ7.,McGowan˽ǵĻSADTķΪһֻģ͵(model process assessments,MBPA)8,÷̽ģĽ,ַһģ͡,ʹMBPAһϵͳ,ûнڳ.1993꿪ʼ,GQM(Goal-Question-Metric)ģͿʼõ.GQMģ80,ѧVictor BasisliһĿ꣨goal-oriented)ĹƷ͹̲ķ9,ʹòɡСɡ͸С,Ŀϸ󾫵ķ߱ǿԺͿɲ,õ˹㷺Ͽ.صĹDeBunjeSaundersͨGQMһEnty-Task-Exit,֤Ӧڵһ,Ӷȷ̺Ͳ10.BrchersǿڽĿĶһʱ̽ģҪã11,һģͻϴGQMƻķͲ轫Թ̵Ķ͸,Ӷһ˹̶Ŀɲ.
ѧߵоɹ,״Ӧӹ̽ģĽǶȿǶԶ֧,һ̶ֹ֧̽ģĿ,ԭ:ڹ̶һЩضĻȫ뵽ģ֮,ʹ֮Ϊ̸Ҳ̲еһ,лǹʱƫ,̵,жõִ,Ӷ̶֤ϵͳԺһ.
,ǽ͹̶ģͽģƵѡ񡢹̽ģչ.
1 ̶ģͽģGQM-D
1.1 GQM
йо,GQMо̶ʱѡ.
,Ŀ(Goal,G),Ȼ󽫸ĿϸΪڹ̻Ʒض(Question,Q),ЩԶ(Metric,M)ķʽõش.McCallFCM(Factor-Criterion-Metric),GQM֧ƷĶ,GQMڽGϸΪQ,MʱΪԱṩ뵽иϸڵĿռ,ڽй̶.
1.2 GQM-D
GQMָ˲Ĺ,ûԻǹڳ,ǲṩֹм.ܽص̵ص,GQMһϸ,ûָ.
ͨص㷢,еĶĶ,ʵʵ.һ̶,ȡùֹʱʵԵĶֵ,ڿڲ״̬ûж,޴ӷֹм,ṩ̸Ľ.,ĳһĿ꾭GQMϸõһMp:пԱĹЧ.ͨķùʽ

TWiΪiԱĹʱ;TBiΪiԱȴʱ;nΪԱĿ.ͳпԱĹʱ͵ȴʱ,ȻMpֵ.
õMpֵ:(1) еͳֵڹ֮̽õ,ʱĿ,κһԱѹTWTB,Mpֵ׼ȷֵû;(2) Mpֵս,Mpֵֵʱ,޴ӿ쾿ǹеһӰMpֵ,.ܽMpĶ뵽,ÿԱÿTWTB,õ̵мϢ,һλԱһܵһĿȻ,ӶӰЧʵ,̸Ľ.뵽̲,㹫ʽ¸ı.

TWijΪiԱڵj̲Ĺʱ;TBijΪiԱڵj̲ȴʱ;mΪ̲Ŀ;nΪԱĿ.ͬʱµмֵ,
MPij=TWij/(TWij+TBij),
ΪiԱڵj̲ĿЧ.
Ϸ,GQM-D̶,GQMĽһϸ,ͼ1ʾ.

ͼ1GQM/SS
GQM-DGQMչҪ3.
1.2.1 Զķֽ*
йMpļʵMpڹ̲ķֽ.ɿ̵ЧʷֽΪÿ̲Ч,ӶֿԱڹмڵĹЧ.
ж͵ʵ,һеĶMпڶ͵ʵϵõֽ,MĹֽ̲⣨M.AƷֽ⣨M.PԴֽ⣨M.Rͽɫֽ⣨M.Jȵ.ʵʩķֽʱ,ܻݾԾʵʵзֽ,統ʵʩMĲƷֽʱ,ֻĵƷж,M.P.D,ҪڹڶM.P.Dĵи.
̵һM,ͬʱԶʵʵʩֽ,,ù̵ʵΪE1,E2,E3,
(1) ɽME1,E2˳ֽ,ʾȽME1ֽ,ٽME2ֽ,M.(E1/E2);
(2) ɽME1,E2зֽ,ʾMͬʱE1E2ʵʩֽ,M.(E1+E2);
(3) ɽMۺϷֽ,M.(E1+E2/E3),ʾMͬʱE1,E2ʵʩֽ,E2ֽٶE3ʵʩֽ.
ڹMp,ʵǶMp˹ʵ͡Ա(P.D)̲͡˳ֽ,Mp.(P.D/A).
1.2.2 ֲD
ڽжMĸַֽ,㷽ʽʹõݽµı仯.ֲDйصĶṩõĲݲ.
ڹMp,TWij,TBijMp.(P.D/A)ṩõ,,ͼ2ʾ.

ͼ2GQM/SSMpķֽ
Щ,ֱܾӵĲ,HNL:Ƕײ,,ݲ,ʱ,DMһµ.
1.2.3 ӶĽṹ
ʵʩһʱ,ĺһؼ,Զ弰Ƿһµһؼ,ֻһµĻ,ܱ֤ռݵ׼ȷԺһ.ԶнṹĿľǰжͶ,֤һ.涨ڹ淶Ľṹ.
1(GQM-D). GQM-DM-SetеÿһԪ.
Mi=(N,C,Q,T,D,F,V,M),
NΪ,Ψһ;CΪĳɱ;QΪ뱾صQi;TΪ뱾صĹ,ݴ洢ռ,ߵ;DΪ㱾;FΪļ㹫ʽ;VΪֵ;MΪʵͷֽʽУ.
2(FQM/SSC). GQM-DD-SetеÿһԪ.
Di=(N,M,De,T,C,P,S,V),
NΪ,Ψһ;MΪصĶ;DeΪĶ;TΪռʱ;CΪռ;PΪռ;SΪݴ洢;VΪ.˵.
(1) ɶ1Ͷ2֪,ʵʷеĻռ,еĶӦƵ;
(2) ,T,CǸԻָԵ,TWij.TݿΪÿ̲ʱ,Щ̲ʱҪɾģ;,߼Ͻ,TWij.Tȷݵռʱ.
1.2.4 GQM-DĶģͽģ
1.ȷĿ;
2.ĿҪﵽĿġ漰ĶʵϸķʽĿQ;
3.öķʽشϵ;
4.ʵʩķֽ;
5.Խṹķʽ.
:Ͻģ,SPAĹеġִΪĿĹ̶ģ.

ģ˵
Gִ:ùʱԾʹһ,ÿȷ/ĹƷ,Ŀĳ̶.Ŀ:
漰ʵ:̲Ʒ
Q1ǷһɻɵḶ́Թ̲ʵ
M1.1̵Ĵڶȡ
D1Ƿʵʴڿ͹
Q2ǷִеĻԹ̲ʵ
M2.1ִжȡ
M2.1.aÿִ̲жȶԹ̲ķֽ
D2ÿ̲Ƿõʵִп͹
M2.1.jÿɫִжȶԽɫķֽ
D3ÿɫǷʵִԼĻ͹
Q3ÿǷ/ƷԲƷʵ
M3.1ƷĴڶȡ
M3.1.pÿмƷĴڶȶԲƷķֽ
D4ÿмƷǷڿ͹
Q4е/ƷǷﵽĿҪ󣿶ԲƷʵ
M4.1Ʒȡ
M4.1.pÿмƷȶԲƷķֽ
D5ÿмƷǷﵽйر׼Ҫ

MDĽṹ.
1.2.5 ̶ģ͵ȷ׼
ǰԶģ͵о֪,κһֶģ벻ˡ顱,Ҳ˵,ֶģô塱ָ˽ģĹ,õģͽڽģ˾ӽǵĲͬһĲ.жһģ͸,˵,ʵʩģ֤ǶģԱĵ.һֳõİ취齨ģר,һ̶ʹòĶģͺ,ԶԶ.ЩģڽһĿĶ֮ǰ,ӦжǷҪ.ǶԶģȷϹ.
νȷ׼,ǶӦڶͶĿ֮һЩضϵĹ涨.ף12,13ݶڶȷ׼,IEEE Std 1061-1992רһƼйȷ׼.Щ׼ԲƷ,ڶеĹ,ʹЩ׼Կڹ̶ȷ.ڹ̶ȷϵǴӶԲƷȷ׼ݻ,ȴ˹̶ȷϵġµĺ.
3(̶ģ). һ̶ģһ״ṹT(G,Q,M,D),G:ڵ,ʾĿ;Q:2,ʾGϸõ;M:3,ʾQشʵϵķֽ;D:4,ʾ֧Mļ.
ȷ׼1. ԣcorrelation.ĿMG֮Ƿǿ,Ա֤MԳΪGһӶֵ.
RΪMG֮ϵ,R2ʾMı仯Gı仯,ʽR2>aʱ,MG,ЦaΪһֵ.
ȷ׼2. һԣconsistency.ĿǱ֤GMһ,Ӷ֤MԳΪGһӶֵ.
GM֮ϵGһһֵ,G>c.cΪһֵ.
ȷ׼3. жdiscriminative power.ĿǽΪϸͲϸ񡱻򡰸͵ж,жǹ̸ĽʱҪ.һָĹֵGc,ӦٽֵMcܹзʽжеGֵ. 
Mi>McGi>Gc
Mi=McGi=Gc.
ȷ׼4. ԣtracking.ĿǿMǷ߱Gı仯,ӶжMֵǷԳΪGֵļӶֵ.ʱ,Mı仯Gı仯һ.ʱT1,T2,...,Tm,Ƶ.
M(Tj+1)>M(Tj)G(Tj+1)>G(Tj),
M(Tj+1)=M(Tj)G(Tj+1)=G(Tj),
M(Tj+1)<M(Tj)G(Tj+1)<G(Tj).
ȷ׼5. Ԥԣpredicability.Ŀжf(M)ǷҪľԤGֵ.f(M)ΪMõGԤֵ,f(M)һľȱƽGֱӶֵGa,ʱ,MпԤ.
ȷ׼6. ظԣrepeatability.ĿǱ֤һMһĳɹͨ˶ȷ,ȷŸöܹﵽĶĿ.
NisΪȷ׼iԹ̶Mʵʩȷϵĳɹ;NiΪȷ׼iԹ̶Mйģ͵ʵʵʩȷϵܴ;Nis/Ni>isisΪһϿɵĳɹֵʱ,M߱ظ.
6ȷ׼ǶκһҪ.ⲢζеĶҪͨеȷ׼.һڲͬ׼Ҫ¿ԱֳͬЧ.,һ׼,ȴһ׼.
ʵʵʩȷʱʹͳѧ.ƪ,ڴ˲.
2 ģ
Ϊ֧GQM-DĶ,ʹõģӦص:(1) ֱۡ;(2) Ӧ̵ļʵ:̲ɫƷԴԼ;(3) Ӧֹܱ֮ʱϵ.Ϊ,ѡSADTIDEF0ICAM DEFinitionΪƵĻ.
һ͵SADTIDEF0ģһͼ˵,ÿͼ66µķ,ڱʾ̲,ÿͼ3ʾ.

ͼ3SADT(IDEF0)ʾһ̲
ÿ̲ԷֽΪһSADTIDEF0ͼ˵,ù̲ϸ.
SADT(IDEF0),һռ͵Ĺ̲ԱʾΪͼ4.,ûбעļͷʾù̲̲ʱϵ.ļͷù̲ʱƫ,ȥļͷù̲ʱƫǰ.Ըù̲չͼɱʾڸռľռ,ռ洢.

ͼ4SADT(IDEF0)ʾһռ̲
ͼ5һƹм̲TWij֮SADT(IDEF0)ͼ.

ͼ5ռ̲ṹƹ
3 ̶ֹ֧̽ģ㷨
ͨ,һGQM-D,ÿνһĿϸΪɸ뵽ڲĶ,Щ,ڶЩаTռʱ;Cռ;Pռȶγռ̲ʮҪϢ,Ϊڹдռ̲ṩ˳׼;۵ģ֤˶ռ̲֧.
,Ǹ̶ֹ֧̽ģ㷨.
㷨1. һ̶ֹ֧Ĺģ.
:ĿG,P;
:ֶ֧G ģGP-SADT;
㷨:
Begin
1.2.4ģͽģ,GΪĿĶģԼM-SetD-Set;
SADT챻ĹPͼP-SADT;
GP-SADT=P-SADT;
For each di in D-set
Begin
di.C,di.P,di.NγһռAi;
diAi˵;
di.TAi뵽GP-SADTʺλ;
End
End
M-Set={Mp},D-Set={TWij,TBij}ʱ,㷨1,Ҳɵõͼ5ʾġƹ̡.
4  
һ̶ֹ֧̽ģ,̶ģͽģGQM-DSADT(IDEF0)̶ֹ֧̽ģ㷨.ŵֹ֧ڲĶ,ṩм,Ϊ̸ĽṩؼĵһϢ.롰SEIʽ,Ը÷ΪеĹṩݸ,ŷ,ڹĸĽ.ǽڽоһһ,SEIĹΪĿGQM-Dܡ̶ռƵ,ӭҾһͬ.
עоõҡ塱ƼĿ.
*ʵʲ,ҲڶQķֽ,.Щı仯ʾ,˿ɽЩ""Ϊ,Ⲣ,ֻо.
ͨѶϵ:Ϊ,Ϻ200050,Ϻ
߼飺Ϊ,Ů,1967,ʿ,оԱ,ҪоΪ,֤.
Ԫ,1936,оԱ,ʿʦ,ҪоΪ,֤.
ߵλϺġϺ200050
ο
1Ϊ,Ƽ,Ԫ.̸̹ܵо.Ӧ,1999,16(2):17
(Su Wei-min, Huang Jia-qi, Zhu San-yuan. An investigation for the conception framework of software process engineering. Computer Applications and Software, 1999,16(2):17)
2Paulk M C, Curtis B et al. Capability Maturity Model for Software. Ver1.1 SEI, CMU/SEI-93-TR-93, 1993
3ISO/IEC/JTC1/SC7/WG10/N111-N119. Software Process Assessment (Part1-Part9), 1996
4Bollinger Terry B, McGowan Clement. A critical look at software capability evaluations. IEEE Software, 1991,8(7):2541
5Pfleeger S L. Lessen learned in building a corporate metrics program. IEEE Software, 1993,10(5):6771
6Pfleeger S L, McGowan C. Software metrics in the process maturity framework. Journal of System and Software, 1990,12(12):255261
7Lott C M, Rombach H D. Measurement-based guidance of software projects using explicit project plans. Information and Software Technology, 1993,35(6,7):407419
8McGowan C L, Bohner S A. Model based process assessments. In: IEEE Computer Society ed. Proceedings of the 15th International Conference on Software Engineering. Los Alarnitors, CA: IEEE Computer Society Press, 1993. 202211
9Basili V R, Caldiera G, Rombach H D. Goal question metric paradigm. In: Marciniak J J ed. Encyclopedia of Software Engineering. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1994. 528532
10DeBunje T, Saunders A. Combining process models and metrics in practice. In: Schafer W ed. Proceedings of the 4th European Workshop on Software Process Technology. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1995. 4953
11Brchers C. Differding, Gnter Threin. The role of software process modeling in planning industrial measurement programs. In: IEEE Computer Society ed. Proceedings of the METRIC'96. Los Alarnitors, CA: IEEE Computer Society Press, 1996. 7184
12IEEE Std 1061-1992. IEEE Standard for a Software Quality Metrics Methodology, 1992
13Methodology for Validating Software Metrics. In: Marciniak J J ed. Encyclopedia of software engineering. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1994. 528532
1998-03-18յԭ,1998-10-20յ޸ĸ
