 ׺ 1-3251
ԭĳо
ԭ
ԭںš199604
ԭҳš4-18
  šJ1
  
    
ӡںš199610
    ʷĳѧƸ
    
    Ӣѧ߿˼ˣKenneth ClarkѰζ⣺жʷԼȻܸĶ
죿·ǣΪҪгһԴӰ٣Leon Batista Albertiڣд꡶ۻ滭Ժֶ
˳ƵʷѧߣʵѺѣۢ٣ݡΪʷ̫רʷʵѼӶʧȴ˿ɶԣۢڣݡȻ׷ԭԶ
ֹڴˡ˵ɶԲԵıһ˼·йصĻôʷķ˼ȼӳʵ塣ʷ
ִĹ涨ԻѧƵһ򵥵ļϵѡ⣬һ̵Ĺ̡ʷδһ
˵Ŀɶйأһ׷󶴼͸˼ۣۢݡʷ˵ֻ㹻ֵʷʵǶ
ʶ˵Ҫɴ˰һָΪʤڴ˼֮ʷ岢ֻڳʾչֺ
ʹǵѰ˼ߵʣΪֻϲŸǺʷݵо
            һʷԺͻ
    Ӧ˵κһѧƶȻӦԣֻܺѧӦľ벢չʾеоҰ
ʷΪһѧƵʷ̫񲻹İٶ꣬ȴʱй͵򡣻ʷûԵô
˾ɥһʷԵڱ͵ѧѼһֹʶһ棬ĹǿרҵѡѾʹԸ
ѧƷչĻмȡ˵˼ѧάMartin WeinbergerһдԵӡ
˹¡жɣCharles de Tolnayġ׿޵ʱһʱܼĳЩиʵĶȫ
ȻִܾӦõԹŴоϡдʹվԭϼȫʹðͼŵڸԼ
ɭ͸µ˵ҲΣյġЩֲǴδʱǾͱ˶䴿ָŵһ
ֳªִ׾ﻯһЩ˴ìܣԵòʱ˵³鲻ʱǱ뵽ִۼƵƵѵʷ
ֻĵӰۢܣʵάķӦʲôļӡоոʱڵʷѧΪ˲
ѧ⣬ƺѧѧƵʷԽͶĽ䱸޷ܸ¶аǶࡤ
ȻҲܸѧ˵׷أRobert Liebert׫д׿޵ʷۢݣݡô˵ֱ죬
ʷоȡġԡӰҲǺ޵ġܰͶصйıı֯braidingղķѷͱԢԲ͵о
Լ¶Ȩֵ̽ѿʼʷĻϵͳУArthur Dantoжۣϲ(Guy Debordľ۸specta
cleԼأHayden Whiteʷѧ۵ȣȴǶĻۢޣݡڣʷȲѧƵǿ
עδеʶ˽޶ʱķչγµоʽҲͳ޷顣ֵע
ѧ֮ӰҪɢǴʷѧѧѧѧʷʷ෴СȻǺ
ʷѧ̬йصġѧʷѧΪǲؽ۵ַ棬һĺĻĻϵ
Կ졣֮£ʷʾԵڸеĻԣһ֮ϵ˳Ӧͬѧ
ƵǱ
    ʵϣֻҪԻعһʷγʷͲѼνʷһѧƴһʼں̶ܴһ
֮ԡ
    ȣҪЩ뼼صʷ⣬Ȼѧı֪ʶ۹Եñز١ȸʷļͣƷĹ
ԿѧᡤĪGiovanni Morelli,1816-1891Ϊλڶгѧʹ˹еģƷ
±Ŀͺͣ͵Ļڻϱжص˹Lorenzo CostaԼͿ
ĪͼGosimo TuraƷ֮Ͳûϸ΢ɱĲ죬ֻҪһĶ䡢ǿ׺
ȾͲƷĹ⡣νġĪĪܵҽѧѵеĽѧ֪ʶ
Щϸ΢֮ƷԣԵҲ˼¶صĵط磬ڲӡɻҵɫ
ʱʱɫʿѧķչǸ൱ҪĲϵйɫѧлնĹϵ⣬ͿǶҵ⣻
Ҫ˵Ӳ³˹аǶ࣬Ӷյ٤ԣߴ³˹͸ɵӾչ̣й͸ѧʷ֪ʶͻ˴
档ʷʼ涼ͨ͵·ٿȫʽ֪ʶѧʷоһֱر
    Σʷضʷ׶λԵԣһЩ൱Ҫĸѧơ磬¹ŵ塱
塱ʵ塱͡塱ѧʷ̸ĸ˶̻̽ʷ·ʮ塱͡ڡԴʷ
ַ塱ӡ塱͡Ұ塱ʼۢߣݡ
    ٴΣѧƵоչֱӻǼӵӰʷչ͸¡Ʃ磬ԼԺʼһµĻع
ѧ̬ȶԴϣļִʷѧɭ³ķRobert Rosenblum׫ġʮת
һں̶ܴϽĻʷʷͷǵ¹ʷѧҵоӶΪִʷоһַ
ѧ޲ءո˵Ķо෽涼ѧ۷ۢݡάҲѧɶѧ
ʷѧѧѧѧȷĽǹΪ֪ʵڵʷоϣʷо뿪˲
ѧѧۣۢݣ¹ѧEmanuel Loewyʷۣۢݣôȫ
һɢɳҲγκγ־õѧӰ졣ĲѷҲѧƣѧṹ塢³ķʫѧ
Լѧ˵ȡνʷطҲֵĻΪġѧ߻ָʷͳ
ɫսʹĿǰһѧƱбҪϵǣսԴʷĶۢ٢٣
    ģʷؿѾںΪʷԵлֵĶеģǡǡǾڶءΪѧе
֮ʷһʼʹҵѳ͵ѧﲻһص̬ȡֶԪĻڹΪʷ
Ҫѧߵ̽С
    ǻע⵽ʷα仯ͷչķ˼ҪһԪʶҲ˵һֳԽ۹Ӻ
ңⱾҪʷѧƣرѧ͸ӡԣһʷ۵壬ôбҪĿͶ
ʷѧ۲ն˹ӡ˹ƣLudwig von BertalanffyƤǽܡά˹˹
ȣγʷʡ˼Χ
    ʷֻԲʲôȻĶ෴ǶǻΪǰᣬΪõġʷӦǡִ
ѧƣάӻԶӰͼµȫ˼롣ʷѧ˵֡
ݺʷѧӦľ档ʷʷγɵĻԲһֿʹһݵĺơʷѧԽԽ
ȷʶʷеѾʼϢԵĻԣڣʷоѡרҵۡĹѰ
ۡһԵļΪйأоѾ͵ǰоĶԪԸ롣µоģ̬
˵ԼȷеĳѧƵﾳԵԽԽüޡκεʷѧ߶⣺ν綨ѱϸ˵ѧ֮Ĳ
ϵۢ٢ڣĳ˵ʷԺͻԹϵ⣬ζŶµоʽ˼̽󡣾粻ѧ
ܵһϣﵽΪʵۺϵԸҪһ£һۺܹΪΪĻ
ɹ֮һзḻԺͿԵṩһּȾ͸ּ汸ʷЧԵ߼ԸǸ
һ״øǿˣ뵱ڵΪ˴ﵽĳۺ϶Ϣصġ״
־ɵķĿǰڼѧҡͼѧҡĻʷʷѧԼۼƵƵϵѧִǲΪе
ؼִԼоֶζǡǡЩֶεγɱӶҲͲƲԵγµķʶڴĸо
ⲻҪ˳ر۵ľ״ϵһԣʹ˶ԣͻƣ˵۹ԾǨĿǰо龳
ʮۢ٢ۣݡ
    壬ʷԺͻ֮໥úͱ仯ӦǶεĺ廯ġҪΪڵоУʷѧ
ĸԻѾͬ󣬽ʷѧԿոʱڵѧʱκ˶ƽ
ӵһƬȫİõľۢ٢ܣݡǶּĲͻǶҪѰӦǡĻֻ
ȻʲôֳɵĶڸֹ׳ʵѧмԼȡĳֻڹ̶ճΪʷġԴͳʷ
ĹأпԶ˵ѧЭͬơ趨ʷܹԻϣһְ
ѧʷѧĻѧѧڵĲϵֲգ˵ڣƴʽĴպϣѭڣԶʹӳ
Ĺ켣Ӷϳʷ۹⼰ˣĳ̶ֳϣʷԵķǾ˹ζҲ
˵ʷеĳѧصӡ֤ʵѾеڸöʡ⣬лĻԾܺͼе
ķҲѺĵһĹɳɷ漰һ൱Ӷֶص̡ˣ֮Ԥ
ʷԺͻԵ̬ӦопʷԺͻԵ໥γɵ
            ʷоĶԺ͵
    νʷĶȻһֱȽϵ˵֮ʵָʷһֶѧ̬ȣһ漰е
ѧơʷĵԣָǽʷѧĳѧõӦͽǣԺ͵ֻϵ
ֲͬĵԵܺͼжԵ塣˵ʷĶԺ͵Լǲǹġ
    ԶԣʷĶѾ㷺漰ʷѧԼѧڲ֮Ļڹ̣Է
ǿѡĳ㹻͵оʵôõĶؽлǶܸ룬ʷжѧƵ
͸ʵϹһоѶȣǿἰǿⲼյʷۡڡʱ״ʷһоٵز
ʷеı仯󣬶۱ݵѧѧʷѧͬԴݱʷѧglottochronologyۣ
ⲼյʦۼҺӺѧ˵ֱѧѧƵĹӰ졣ڿⲼ֮ǰֶֻRiegle
ݱ۶̶Ȳͬشѭ۵ɫʡȻⲼȴһǰ˵·ӣ˽ȻʷĹ
䵽԰һĵزһд죨ӾʱһĹ̡ƷǾ̬ķ񷶳Ĺ
أʷҲɴȻȱϵʱ׺ɵġʵʻУ仯ǳġʷ
ʷϵԿ졣رǿÿһƷһ˵˫һԴڡĿĵĽ⡱a purposeful soluti
onһ⡣һصȷǾͻͨڲͬȺ״ġʱСеġԭprime objects䡰
ơreplicationsԭĳֱԣmutantֲͬı仯ѧʽʽʷ
ͬⲼնʷʱԵϣͼܸӺز׿ޡ棨ElGreco͸ŵһЩԽüʷ
ʱڵĴʦǵƷܰФ񻭡羰ȿʷ⣬רĳضʱڻңͬʱҪݻٽ
롰ԭʼֽ֮ݣͨʷĻѧѧѧʷѧ֮ڹϵȻⲼ
յоܴӶѧƵĽǶȶʷ൱۵ǿĵطҲ١ȣͷۣô
ʷѧعƷͼɷĶĹоʧȶ֮ˣΣѰ֮Ĺ
ܴΪƷ⣻ٴΣ漰˸غڶѧƵıȽеԳ͹֣ضʷ˵
ζԶġȥұ˵⣬ʷԻַġ˵Ⲽնʷʱ
еı仯İǽͲࡣԣ˵ڽ˵⣻Ϊһ
ʱ״ȷһʷֵ̽ҪΪߵоȺӡͬʱⲼն͹о
ȨԵģҲֵôӷ۵ĽǶȼӡ
    ʷѧڹʷѧѧͬԴݱʷѧѧʷѧѧ˵ѧƵķͷֵۺ
ԻϣȥƱѧƹխרҵ޶һԣȻڲɵ״̬ǼеĳɹѾʾѧƵӽǶڸ
̶ȫӾǺζ߶ϣ÷Hans Sedlmayr͵أKurt Badtŵ˹ȶ
͹ʾʷĶԷΪոʷѧ߿˹̩գPaul Kristeller̸ŵ˹ʷоŵ
˹ӾĻһ֣һҲѧѧڽ˼άѧԼڸʷ׶еѧоһ
ؽġ塯Ŀǰ۽Ȼ⣬ֻҪŵ˹ѧ֧ҵδϣ
ġۢ٢ݣڱ˶ʷԵһ־
    ʵϣʹǴͳʷѧҲڷչѧƵĶԷйֵŬôѧ߿W. Eugene Kleinbauerָ
һͼ־ѧٵҪֳʶľ֪ʶҪƷļʽȫ˽ۢ٢
ݡҪѰʽȻ壬ʵʵľ飻ҪȷϺͲ͹Ժ壬ҪͬĵֺݵıԨԴ
Ӧ֪ʶ⡣ƷںȷϺͲͣҪһּǰٿȫʽ֪ʶʷĺڽ̵ϰףĳһʱ
̬ȣԼĶԣͼоʵζо߱ǾͨĻʷߡһʷĶ
һֺܸߵҪŵ˹ǳ̵ָͼѧߵӦͲ͹Ӿŵ׻ֹ
ЩӾŷӳĹۢ٢ߣݡһ仰˵һָΪҲΪѵͼѧо漰ӾűΪ㷺
͸ӵıӶƱظֵʷĶԡ
    ԶԣʷĳһѧƵƣҪݵö࣬ҲڶʷĶԵ˽⡣ڰ
˹Ŀǰʷо龰£һ滭רȴִδεݻ֣ߴо
רִᷢƪ귨ũļۢ٢ݡĳ˵ĿͶһѧƣѧ
ѧʷоһֱȻҪ󣬶Ҳȷʵбжķ֡
    ϿʷĳһѧƵں˵ڸԵʷѧУ˵ǷӳڶĳһҼƷĳһȺ
оϣΪһµӽӡ֤ʷķչܻдڽһоķֻۺϡǲһ̳
ʷκαѧƵϵֻǴҡƷȷҪʷĵ塣
    ѧӽǡ壬κʷоУһֱȻĲͶΪǲúĦͯ꾭
ͿܶĸĵԻ󲻽⣻˽ص꾫ˣͿܺƵƵֵĴﱳ
ʶ塣ܹͬ˽һЩǻʯεôͻǵͼīиĵʽ
ʷоУҿԡڴʽоУֵ̧ߵһеĻӢĵλϡ
ʵòһΪĹһֵֶο϶ѧʷоеãġָ
ʷı׼ȷԣԸ⡰ȲѧκĽЩܿ۵̸۵ֽʱеǰ
ٲһˡȻҲĺôӶſѧ߲治ﵽġʷоıԽֻ
ǰʱԳɹġرǵʷ϶˻¡׼ȷʱͱˡǡˬֻ֮ǿ
˼впܡѧȻȱֻΨѧвпѰһ㡣ۢ٢нζǿ
ʹ˼Ӧע⾫йоƩ磬ŵ˹ܿѧеʽ۵ʾƷ͵
ΪΣΪԢΣΪ׵Σ͵ۺͿ͹ǰ漰֪ʶԭ
ȣͼʷʷһ˼ʷءŵ˹ͼоʹڸֹϵоʱߵøԶڿռ
ø㣬ΪǣʹԴо̽ʶ޿ռ䡱ۢڢݡڱϾͺ;ѧɵּ
಻Զˡܵ˵Ϊչʾ˲ΪķḻԣֿھҰ֮ģĻ˵ɴ
ԲƵġ󡤸ΪѰ㹻ע⣬ֲͬ˵ֻͣ󡤸볣˵ϣȻ
ǲġеоѾʶҪݡ͵Ĳϣѧѧ߶󡤸ΪʲôҪ
ԼζĶطϣ꣱£ҹ󡤸߸ۢڢ٣Ժ󽻸һ
жļŮҪСĿƷԴˣѧѧʮֲͳԣΪֻһֲʮʵ
ֻĳЩʵĳɷ֣ҲûһֲʵŵģۢڢڣݡЩͣʹţҵΪʵһ
ʵƷҲӦǹһȻ󡤸ߵԲһ൱Ϸ˵ӣôйƷ
ҲӦػ磬аǶࡤΪʲôҪʥĸʥݺʥΪһĻܾͺͯ괴йأ
ԿѧȤԼʵĴϰҲ׷ͯ꾭֮ѧ˵˵͸йҵҪķ棬Ҳ
͹൱ضζķ档簢ŵ¡ΪˣGerstle Mackġһд˵δ
κξоĴǼ˵һ¡Ϊһһ¿ʵһԸΪڵ˵
壬Ϊǵ˸˽øޡ
    ڲƷ棬и˹Ŀ࿴Ϊ⵹˵ȫظıǶԹŵƷĿ⣬ܸ
һζʾƷԵĹעƩ磬ڣ̡˹̹ڣйءո˺
еĻ֮ԡľоһʮӵѧ԰бٳһµĴ˵о
ǽؽո˵ĳͼ֪ĳԡ˹̹رʹǶΪ֪ĶҪٿһλҪٿΡ
ڢۣݡʵϣ˹̹Ӱ컹ԽʷȦӣ磬о͵ʷѧҰķC. Bynumר׫дͺڵĻ
֮¡˹̹һģۢڢܣݷ֮ԡβں¿˹̹֮Ϊµոо
һߣΪΧơ֮ԡȤ˶ʷʵ۵ۡУһΪǶͼȷϱͨЩ
ȷʾ͵ʵԵı֤ݶۻһΪǶոʱڵǡвһҪʷʵȱ֮ͣͲǰ
ͨȶﵽӦ֤ȷʵԽĳǡĲϵóôҲͿͨո
ĻеƽĲ֤ĳһ⡣Ʃ磬˹̹оǷ֣ոʱڵѧǶԻ
ǿǡǡʹע⵽˻壩ǲѧıһζӾ⣬йĪΡСʵ
ϼƴƷԼȵľоҲľ߱ж塣֮ѧ˵ҲؿǶ
Ʒ⡣Ȼʷ;ĹϵһֱһĻ⡣䡶жٸ˵ãǲ
˹¡жɶ׿޵˹͢춥ķ·顣ھѧ˵һַչƵḶ́رĻ
ѧ֮Уʷ̶ȫʾ
    ΣֵעǿѧѧĹ̬ȡŵ˹ôѧʷϵֱٴ뿼ѧо
ܽһԱٴι֮Ϊһ֡л״̬Ķʵϣ̲ǰνӵģ໥͸ٴ
ۺΪѧоṩ˻ҿѧоҲΪٴĹṩ˻໥ӳ֤໥ûٴ죬
ѧоäĿͿնģûпѧоٴǻҵģʧ򡣵ǣ໥Ϊһϵͳһ
ʷĹṩ֤ݡۢڢݣݶʷǶѧĿпܻøӿѧҰзζдͬʱ
ͬص㴴Ʒͨһ־˵ķʽϵһʱ֮ͬĳһɻĳһʱڵƷΪơ
Ÿлֵ˳Ц֡ԽϰʽӡִֻʵʽӴ֮еϵһɶһ
ɵʵӰ졣Ȼ˹P. della FrancescaƷŰ滭֮䣻ɳضĵƷϣ֮䣻
Ф밣ķФ֮䣻׶Vermeerķ羰ֱӽӴͺ˵ķ羰֮䣬Զɷ
ġӦЩʵΣЩڹϵоʹǵʷԻعҰЩ֮ʷ
ʹ廯ۢڢޣȷʵѧʷʷоƺһʼͽԵ֡ʷѧϣϣ޶Ȼ
һԭʼĻеŨȤﺣǺɫ˹˵ķκȣʽ˽ǳȱ
ͬġʷĲݴҲѧйȤΪֻŷرԣѧ
෽չʷѧҰȣѧעκԹŴо̫ƽǵֵϵ壬Ϊ
ѧǰоĻعĳһһ̶ʷƫɷݣѷŷĻϵͳǰ
ųԼоҰ֮⣬Ϊѧڣ˶ԸĻһͬʵ̬ȣۢڢߣݡʵѧ԰
ǵо쵽ĻеԭʼҲܷǶĻʷںĸգƩڰ˹Ħ˵
壬ʽϵȵȡŮĽǶȿѧʷƫĳɷݣΪǰ߲ʷʱ
ԾذŮų⡣ѧ۹ԲݣΪĳ˵ԭʼһ
֮ǰˡ˶Michael Cardewڣǰеͼ塷һдȻб
һǰԵıʽҹڡ߼δֵһʼ۵ģʹ֮ļȴ
ȳʹΪձϵĽһ塣Ȼֽ׼ȷԴ߼ѧ֮£ǣԶ߼ĵطۢ
ݻ仰˵ԭʼνĻ̬ʱΪֳֵĳ壬Ӷպ͹ֺеĺǱڵ
Ӧ塣ģʷѧĻֻǶʷǰĹעǲģΪʹִҲ׵ҵ
ѧĿ⡣磬߸Լֱ֮ŷҪˣЩδֻԴй
ʱþ³ļʹţԭʼ˵дĳֿ»Ծŷͣ
ڲṤʱͼһԼĻ滭ԣμ¬İԶܵʥȻı
ۢڢݡͬ˹ʣDerainϣζKirchner󡤸ߺҲԭʼǧ˿ƵϵȻԲͬĻ
ʷбȽоҲѧ۹лǳʷйԴҲƱѧбȻĹ
    λʼ壨ʷοʼģӦʷĵһ⡣ѧΪ㣬Դ
ΪʲôԭʼҪڶѨͿ棿˭Ҳ޷֮ؼԻش⣬ȻͼΪ׼Ĳ²ȴһԭʼ
ĳҪ׶εĲȼ磬ǼΪصģҿġ磬İ
ѨеıڻһôпЩĹͼȺͱȷԣ߲δܹңȻ
в쳶϶ڻ滭оȻΪȻɵĿԽʱַϡۢۢݰ
ŵ¡Ҳй˵Ĺ۸УʯʱĻ滭иӶֽļҲ˵ˣЩƷҵĶѵصɵ
ǰ֮൱ɹ۵һѧϰʵγԼҵײ㡭ʦͶֹר
ҵĴۢۢ٣ͷϲֵĺܶපѨڻ޿ɷϵرˣʷǰԲɼдǰʹһ
ЩͼĵƷԣеʷѧ߸Ըķչضı仯ǡ
ԽʱͿռضʱֹԵÿšڶԭʼں䴦ʷǰ׶ζԵõֱɡ񷢾
ٶԭʼ˶ѨڳǧĻ滭ӾֵԲͬʷǰ嶼ʮҪġȻӹԪǰԪǰ
ûʲô꾡ɿּ¼ʲ֤ǣԭʼĺʽȴֵ⣬Ʃ磬ΪʲôԷ
ʮдʵľ޴ĶͼΪʲô˱ȴ򻯳״ͼΪҲѵǣΪʲôԭʼҪڶѨͿЩ
أԭʼʾ㹻ʷкУƺûһʮֿ˵ۿԲؽһʷҲ
ѧƩ磬ԭʼ滭еĴ󵨶ϷԵı鲻Խʱġǡαʹǣ͡
ϵƺӦǽƲԭʼ˶ڱֵȤʮֲȡ磬һָΪеΪԭʼ˵Щ滭Ϊ
ȡĶޡ¶̬Ϊ˻ȡһѹ˵Ϊ˸οǵĻ顪νġȻ
ȻʺڽͽִĻΪѧҷԶŶѨ޹Ǿ󲿷Сģʯʱ˿ʳùЩС
ԣǡôΪʲôжǾ޴Ĳ鶯ף樥١ҰţҰȣΪʲô˵ͼ
ʵ֮һֲȵ˵ǣЩڻԽеһʶϮ鶯ͬʱѧҲע⵽
ԶŵĶѨڻʷǰˣ˺ͶͯĽӡȻ׷ݵ˾ԶôΪʲôЩȴȻʾ
ˣںѳЩԭʼıڻԭʼ˵ʽһ֣Ҳ˵ǾԵĹܡȻ
δǣЩСĽıڻôܻͺȺʽϢϢأһֲ²ǣЩͼͼڳ
ĳһֶĳһضĲ塣ǣھĶѨֻȿļ־޴Ĳ鶯ƺֲһһ
Ĳ塣ǣ֮иΪԲĽͣЩﻭֱָԺŮԣǶԷĸ̡ȻȻһֵĲ룬Ϊ
ȷеҵӦ֤ݡһΪ⣬ΪЩڻֻװѣΪװԣڲͬ
̬װμڡǣע⵽ԭʼ滭·ΧеĸȾͲǼ򵥵صͬʽװˣΪ
ʲôͼ˵ͼдʵ̶бˣۢۢڣݡȻԲȷ˵ԭʼ壬һȴ
о϶Ѩ滭ضԭʼĻ൱̶شζźǣʷѧϵԵõ̶ȵʵͲ
Ծʯʱͼĺ˶ٲ룬һЩʷ̲ĴδشͼʷԴ⡣
    бҪἰѧѧʷ̹ͨΪʷ쵽ηһڵоǣ
ǿεֱӹĴ켰ܣôоͿΪڵġԹϣͲѷΪͲ
ȷһ㡣ڹϣġһУ˺ܵǰҵͼӰ죬ǰǴЩͼ֪γ
ضͼʽԴȷ֪ʽǣҪκʵԵĽֱĳ̶ֳŲͼʽǣγ
ͼʽıȻơԴˣѷڡӾͻ滭һ顣ָʷ˶γɵĻĩֻ֮ڵ
زѰļֵˡظŵڡݡеһխ۵㣺ȥоȻᣩ
ȥ׽ǰңԴлȡͼʽڴ˻ϸʷµĹסǣȴһԵĲһ̶ض
龳龳κεͼʽٵĻ൱Ƭġԣ˵ǲǰʷĺεĹ涨
龳¼Կ죬ζܷסҪʵ⡣
    ʷεķϵӣ֮Ŀ⣬ΪȷʵӾʶ̬ϵġеѧ
Ƶո˵ĳϾ⡣ɡ̩ԼGeorge Batailleȣѹκ
йעӣgazeĻȾѧ⡣ÿһ۾ȥע˶ضȨصˣĳ˵ضӿ
lookingӦضȨı֣ҵĲйأҲͬһ߽Ȩϵһ˼ǣʽ۷
ʷֵֶۣġʷԭǰ֮ѧѧʩչֵĵط
    編ѧ߹¼ἰʮӢΨѧʷУ˼ѧ˵ʷΨ壩
õ൱ӡF. AntalƤޡ˹أAlick Westָ£Francis KlingenderʣMilton Brown
Christopher caudwellԼɭGeorge Thompsonȣ̶ȲͬذѧѧᴩʷľоУ
һֶʷоеʽۣۢۢݡڳĲͣѧ۹Ҳ˹Ŀ࿴ĽƤ
׫дġıʡһľ൱̵˰ͶAlfred Barrġͳеʽ۵Ķ֮ۢ
ܣݡˣŮѧ߿ƿ޷ظǼذѳĳɹĻϵսϵһָһʼ
ͱˣֻҪһִݵĹչƻܺزеκ塣ҵĴǲɵģ
Ҳϱãѳ忴ǡɵȻԽԤϵķΧˡѳǡ߸
ġȻ棬εĿϵҲǲȡģۢۢݣݡоǱʶĲϽʾе
Ļ塣Ʃѧ£Edward Saidڱо˶֮󣬻һ̽Ļεڵ۹ʽ
ʵָ֪жں˼׼¾Уۢۢޣݡʷѧѧ֮ȷ
ռ䣬¿
            ʷĿԺѡ
    ڵѧƳУʷĿѾԵԽԽˡⲻζŶԪо̬ƣҲʾѧƱԲͬо
ǵͬǶεġƥǡķѧԣʣˣŮнȻͬ
۶ϣЩ۶ֿµӶγһоѭơĳ˵ʷĿһΪ˷
ʷеıҪ̵档ʷԽǾпԣԽпĿռ䡣˵ʷĿǿ
ҲΪġǣڣʷоĿԾҪȡʷҪı߽缴ѡԡ񰢶˹ڱʷѧ
ʱѹǲû˼ءʳȫھӡԭԶ׼ͬѧƺͲѾ̫ˣǣ
һ棬ֲԹеģʽȥרҵ⡣ۢۢߣҲ˵ʷĿԺѡ֮仹һڵ
ԼϵԵؿʷѡĻʲҪ̶͹ЩʣʷսĿ塣Ҫ
һɵ뼴ʷĿԻѧƵѧҰζڽѧѧ֮Ĳ졣ʵϣȷѧ֮Ĳ
Ҫ˿Ѱѧѧ֮Ĺࡣĳѧڲ͹Ĳ桢պͻǿʷĿԵͬʱ
ǻҪ˼⣺ӦòȡʲôԱ֤ʷĳѧоЧԣԵĲͣҲԵ룿ΪѧƵо
ȻسΪһĶ෴ʷӦеȱ㹻Ļôѧѧ֮Ľֶε
ֲпܵ޵ķʸȻʷĿԺѡԶֻʷĽͱأǶ֮һ
ƽ̬ԾʶĻҲεľ档еѧʮйʷ۵̽Լ
ѧṹ塢⹹塢ѧۺͲѧͼġϸƷclose readingѾԽԽ
ˣǶڸֲͬ໥õķ֮չԷ˼ȴǸ硣һԶ˴ͳľʷͼ־
һȱһַͼĹͬձļֵۡԣʵ龳ǣͬʷоȴûг
һָΪձ̵ۢۢݡҲǵᵽʷѧ߿ԴӱѧѧĶǲܿ
ƫΪġʷ⣬ͻһѧơ˵ո𲽵ʷѧߣо
˵ѧߣƺʱǰѧ߶ԷıԼѧвעĿĻֵϽ硣ȫ
ǿģΪȷвôⲢδʷʧȥұǵΣաʷĶ֮Ļۢۢ
ǿǡǡģʷѡԵһֽ
    ʷѡһҪ¼ԿĻǾͻ֣ᷢʷĶԵ컹ǵԵ룬Ӧ൱
ڵ޶оĳġȣʷľΪͿɣ¶䡶ּͣͼʷԲ͡
һָʷѧþۺͷʮֱҪģȴǲģǽֻͣǣ͵
ˡִ˲ƣʷھǱصġʶ֮µʱпܺԸΪԵĸ˺Ļ壬һ
ʷѧǾ̵ʾġͬʱоҲġ֮Ϊ
󲢷ǱȱȽǣǶԴͳĶйĹŵ滭ϵͳӦ൱Ѷȡ⣬
еķ򲻽֮ӣҲɢǶʵĳע˵ʷھþͲܲ
ѡͱͨΣѧоӣҲԷ֣ʷѧĹҲ뽨ڶʵϡѧ
ĵĻԼ󣬶󲢲ռرͻĵλ֮ѧע壬Ϊ
ֻоеһСֶѡѧĹ۵оĳЩִʷʱʱĳֱҪĳ߶ȣҲ
еѧָ߸Ӧÿԭʼ̬Ļ֮ĹѧоҪּȤڣƺȱ
ġȻ߸ϣ֮Լڣ֮ǰ̫ƽĵĻʹʷϵִԭʼ֮
ϣ뷨ֳصĹϵô߸еϣͱ滯ˡĳϣ߸Щ˵벨
Ļйأ˵һԶеķڸ߽֮ѣۢܢݡԶо߸ѧĽǶǱ
ģͬʱԶԶ᲻ԾʮָĤĲ͡󣬶ʷеѧѧҲƵ⡣һ棬ѧ
ѧܺʷһ棬Ҳ͵󡣾ѧѧʷ͹һֺ۵
ʷԾϾȫ൱ʷﾳѧоٶĳһ˻ײضƷĽɻᳫ
ζڹԼĳǾԵ൱ˡͬʱƫѧѧĲпܺһʵ棬
ľӡĳʺַһġ֮ġĽδ̵ͬŲƵǵƷϣ˵ŲƵ
ҵƷˡʵϣ¼ѧͼʷй᳹ѧʱѾԾƫΡ
дЧӦ޷ǹͼʶ̬ʱܵ졣ʷ岻ݴǵϵķʽ
⡭ζŴʲôߡΪʲôһƷģΨ뱻Ψȡ
֮˭ʲôʱΪʲôΪһƷģۢܢ٣ݵȻǿԴӡΪʲôΪضƷġķ
ĶǹȥĻֽܶʶ̬ģˡɣǿԼͽ
֮⣬ƷеѧʶѧѧоųоҲǶԺ߱
ε̬ȵģۢܢڣݡԣӦǿǣֻȷʷѧѧ㹻ֵϵʱصоŻá
򣬳ѧƵĺȱѡԵġԶ׼ʷĿԺʷѡ֮ȡһֺ˵ƽ⣬һ
⣬ͬʱҲһ⡣
    ŵǣܳѧƵĽѧƵۺ϶ȻʷѧƵĸǱȻѧŵ
ǿԶԣʷһָĻôǰѳѧΪɻȱʵˡȻʷԣ
ѧƵļֵϿɲ¶һĴоһ̶ϱֳѧеķͲƵص㡪ʷѧ
ѧоѧѧΪӡѧƶʷΰҵļֵڹȥǺһ൱ȷĹǶģ
ʲôʷģʲôֲʷĹ֮£йʷӾĻʷоڣѧѧ
֮ǿЩǡʷѧƵİԣԼγһָеԵйʷĹѧƼͨ
ʷӰ졣Щ˷ܵоǿ첢ʷۻˮ׼ǻͻ֤ˡ
뵽˳иλӰо˶Ϳɣ¶ӡ˹͡¡·סԡʡԼ˼Ĺ
粼ѷͣ͡ǡ˵ȡֳѧƵоӰѧ֮оرЩӾĻµʷѧҺѧо
в˷졣ۢܢۣݺδʷоչͬһ볬ѧƵĸˮݵķպͱص״̬ϵһ𡣻
ʷĳѧƸάֺ͸ĽһԶҲ޷رܵ⡣ʷڣҲĻڡ
      ȻƺЩءʵʷӾתΪıдͲԵĻͺرڱ
ʷ޲СʼRoberto Longhiѧ׷УǺ͸˹ʱıһҲѧƷ
ľܡܹͬLa ForgueӰйءϧʼyơμWEugene Kleinba
uer and Thomas P.Slavens:Research Guide to theHistory of Western Art,p.9, American Library Association,1982.ڰ٣Ҳ
ѧָйʮ͵оȻȱʷμDavid Carrier: The Aesthete in the City: The Philosophy and Pra
cticeof American Abstract Painting in the 1980s,p.20, Pennsy lvania State University Press, 1994.
      See Kenneth Clark: Art History and Criticism as Literature, Moments of Vision, London,1981.
      Ƚ϶ԣʮйءʷ͸ֳζȻ˼ڹۻıֲɬɴҲ
˼ʷԵ⡣
      See Jack Spector: The State of Psychoanalytic Research in ArtHistory, Art Bulletin,No.4,1988.
    ݢ٢ܢڢۢۢ  See William Hood: The State of Research in ItalianRenaissance Art, Art Bulletin,June 1987.
      See David Carrier: Preface, Poussin's Paintings: A Study in Art-Historical Methodology,Pennsylvania state University 
Press,1993.
    ߢ٢  See W. Eugene Kleinbauer: Introduction,Modern Perspectivesin Western Art History,University of Toronto Press,1989
.
      See Henri Zerner: Foreword, Form and Meaning, by Robert Klein,New York,1979.
      ϣʮʱ˹Ϊʷľоһͨǣ˴ѧego psychology
δעµĺڹ
      ǹϣʦġϣеȻۡThe Rendering of Nature in Early Greek Artһֲ
δͼʽ̬䡪ͼ󡱣ʼչϣġͼʽʦġ䡪ͼԨԴ
ϵ
    ٢  See Michael Ann Holly: Vision and Revision in the History ofArt, Theory Between the Disciplines,ed.Martin Kreiswirt
h et al,The University of Michigan Press,1990.
    ٢ڢۢ  See Barbara Stafford: The Eighteenth Century:Towards anInterdisciplinary Model,Art Bulletin,March 1988.
    ٢  See Elizabeth Cropper and Charles Dempsey:The State of Research in Italian Painting of the Seventeenth Century, Art
 Bulletin, No.4,1987.
    ٢  See Art Bulletin,XLIV,p.67,1962.
    ٢  йƷԭԺͺ޸Ϊ֪ⷽʶͼѧоӰ졣Ƕڵġ˯ά˹ԭص
ⲻʮ͵ıҵݣҲִֵ⼼һ֤ʵġɳʥĸִ˹һ
ıϵԲƲⲢǳԴʦ˵ֱʣΪӡϸڻᵼ²ǡеĲͶаڶԭ⡣
    ٢  Svetlana Alpers: Is Art History? Value and Explanation in Arts,ed. Salim Kemal et al, Cambridge University Press,19
92.
    ٢  Heinrich Wolfflin:Klein Schriften,p.45,Basel:Schwabe,1949; see Rudolf Arnheim: Art History and Psychology, To the R
escue of Art, University of California Press,1992.
    ڢ  μ׸Ƕŷࣺѧѧۡڣҳй湫˾ꡣ
    ڢ  󡤸ߵġԻһУĲҶǻھȡԵʡ
    ڢ  See William Mckinley Runyan: Why Did Van Gogh Cut off His Ear? The Problem of Alternative Explanation in Psychobiog
raphy,Psychohistory:Readings in the Method of Psychology,Psychohistory and History,ed.Geoffrey Cocks and Travis L. Crosby, Ya
le University Press,1987.
    ڢ  See Renaissance Quarterly, XXXIX,pp. 399-439.
    ڢ  ˶ŵ˹ʷڣҳ磬ꡣ
    ڢ  תԡ׸Ƕŷࣺѧѧۡڣҳԭ
    ڢ  See Louisa Buck and Philip Dodd: Relative Values, Or What'sArt Worth? London,1991.
    ڢ  See Michael Greenhalgh and Vicent Megaw: Art in Society: Studies in Style, Culture,and Aesthetics, London, 1978.
    ڢ  μԼִ塷ڣҳ磬ꡣ
    ۢ  Quoted in John E.Pfeiffer:The Creative Explosion,p.23, Corne
    University Press, 1982.
    ۢ٢ۢ  Arnold Hauser: The Social History of Art, Vol.I,p.17,p.5, London,1951.
    ۢ  See Nicos Hadjinicolaou:Preface, Art History and Class Struggle,trans.Louise Asmal,Pluto Press,1978.
    ۢ  See Meyer Schapiro: Nature of Abstract Art, Marxist Quarterly,pp. 77-98,1937.
    ۢ  See Eva Cockcroft: Abstract ExpressionismWeapon of the Cold War, Artforum, June 1974.
    ۢ  See Phil Baker's review, Books 6.14, Sunday Times, 6 Feb.1994.
    ۢ  Svetlana and Paul Alpers: Ut Pictura Noesis? Criticism in Literary Studies and Art History; New Directions in Liter
ary History, ed.Ralph Cohen, London,1974.
    ܢ  See Louisa Buck and Philip: Relative Values, Or What's Art Worth,pp.121-2.
    ܢ  See Nicos Hadjinicalaou: Art History and Class Struggle,pp.182-3,p.11.
    ܢ  See Stephen Addiss and Mary Erickson: Art History and Education,p.55, University of Illinois Press,1993.
    ܢ  Celeste Brusati's review, Art Bulletin, 1995.3.
    ֿδעͣ
    ԭΪ¼ţ
    ԭΪӶ
    
    
    
 
