 ׺ 2-459
ԭĳо
ԭ
ԭںš199501
ԭҳš128-149
  šJ1
  
    
ӡںš199506
    ѰΣ
    ʷѧһƳ
    
    
    ʮʷѧֵͷֲͬѧ˼Ľʷо䷴˼ҲʱдССĲͬӦ
һƺ˵ʷԵĵݽ죬ǾǣЩѾȷġͼ־ʽʱ
񡱡ʷ͡͡Ƕ֮⣬һЩԭҲԽԽ˾ռߵؽʷѧġл֮УƩ硰ı
߸˹塱ת塱ﾳʷѧ͡ѧȵȡ80šʷ֮ȷ
˼塢ṹ塢ѧ˵ŮȨ塢ѧ⹹ԼִҲ·ȻҪʷѧĸ
롣һζӦӢʷҹϣһֻۣʹǽصóۣӾѧѧ
ѧӦ׼ʷŮٶմͳѧƷۣʷѧĿѧһ֧˵
ߵġŮȷʵʷһȷ˶Ʒѧƣĳ˵൱רšҲʮ徲ţ˻
񹱲ϣԤδķչˡǣڹϣﲢûʲôصĶʵʷڵٵ͸
ԵսѶʹ˸һ˿׳ϢΪѭʽıͻƵ״̬Ϣ֮Сζǣʷķ˼
ڲչģڵعѧȵ㡣ڵѧƵ龳УʷıͲε̬൱ϷԵġ
ȻʹǵĿǰΪֹҲûһֿȫͨ¾ʷѧ۵ۻѧ˵ҪԽԽʷѧ߿ʼһĹ۸С
ʷΣʷ״̬ķ˼ѳΪɻرܵ
    ʷսʷΣ
    ѾǳϤڸһ۶ϣڽ̺ѧչΪңԶͻȻս
ǰȡ֮80һλ¹ѧ߱͡(HBelting)ҲƵ⡣Ȼ͡ķʽбںڸ
ûаߵ׼жһУ൱شӽۣرǶԵĹ۸УչоѶȣˡ
ʷǷսˡʡڡʷս᣿һеƪʾԵһ̵γʷ䷽۵ģ
ʽոʱ(Vasari)Ĵͳʷ˳ֵĻɣһֲָǱ͵ʵ
;Ҳڵʷоȱݵ顣Ӧðڹ̬ȵ龳ϼӣֳɸͳۢڡ
    ʵϣڱ֮͡ǰӢҵѧҲʶˡʷΣ1982꣬Уϻ(CAA)Ҫѧ֮һѧ
(Art J-ournal)ĶŵǡʷѧеΣ λѧרĲһⲢɴ˸ʷѧߵĹע
ӢԴͳʷѧ̵ĶԵԵΪһϣŵŵѷ(Norman Bryson)һдԵ
ָһ˸еʵʷо˵׼ɷֲҵιԱĳٶۣ
æ׼չĿ¼޷µľȥ׫дԵֹ֣ע浵˼滭ʲô߹ҹо
ĻʷһʷһʼڰоѧƸ뿪߹ĳָһĿȻԭ򣬱ʷר
ҵɵȫͣͲǰ״̬ͶԵȡͬʱҲ޷϶ֶ״̬ҪȷµĻôһԹ߽Ƕ
һձԵͣ״̬飬ڶ̶ܹתΪչͱ仯ΪܿЩ̶׿гЧıֻܳ
ӶֱӸıЩĹܷʽԿ϶ĵǣڹȥҵʱѧʷѧоѰַḻ
ɵı仯Ȼʷѧȴһ־ٲǰȻʷһרҵȥר
׫дչĿ¼ҲԴԴϵ࣬ЩȴѧƵľԽԽԶԻһеĲˡ벼ѷһ
ͬеӢѧҲڡ⡱ʷΣģԹϣͿ˼(Kenneth Clark)
һѧߵо辶Ըܡ
    ȷʵǲѸܵ80ʷһѧƱԳƵоڱˡʷս˵ʷΣ
˵ѧƷ˼ıһǿźŻ־˵ǽ·ʽʱ
    ôʷΣ˵Що׶˵أ˲ѷ̾ѧƵĵչ൱Ĥ֮⣬ΪҪ
ͳʷִʵ֤ѡоҰĹ޶ظ19͵ѧߵоƵǣʷƺҲһ
ֶκʵۻ̬ȣΪЩʵשʯһڽѧһΰʱóǣѧ߶
νġ֪һ롣Ȼʵ֤չ˼ȴпܵԺظԣΪѧоĽ
״粼ѷָȻ30ʱɴ¹֪ʶǿص춨һֱʷѧ׷о·ߣ
ͬʱǵʵ֤ѧоȴҲԾص־棺оΪ˽һ滭ʷҪѧѰ
򵵰֤ݣȴԶԻ滭Ĳ͡˵ͳʷķʱǡǡǷǲԵĢݡԲ滭ݲ
Ϊּͼ־Ҳ˳ƵľأǿԶһЩйŵ˹Ĺ۸У
    ͼ־ķƺǣϢʹѧһ꼶ĽԱܹûԵĳڡŵФеĹ
һǻʵԡ
    ĸּȤµĵҲƺһּȤԽԽˣѧ˵һִ
뼼ɡңΪǣͼ־Ƶû塣ߵȻͼ־ʷоȻ൱Ҫã
ʵŵ˹Сʷе֮ƣ˵ǴͳʷǴͳʷµʷ֮Ҫн
ǣʹŵ˹ҲͼѧһµġռΣձ̵Ǣࡣͬʱлɵ̬ԶҪģ
ʷ˵Ҳ⡣
    ΪʵǣʷڰվĻʵԻʵԵĵʱԵöЩġ񱴶͡ѧ߶ԴĶ࿮̾
ҼʹǶʷон϶໤ѧҲʱидӽ⹹ĽǶȼ֮ĻʷĻ20͵ʱ
˽ܡ⹹ĳزˣôʲôԭֲ״أ20͵дڷչ仯֮еԵ⣬
ڲ޶ҲйϵƩ磬Ľ綨ǾĺһɲĻôκԽԹĵͿ޷ˡ
Ȼ綨ĻʯԹΪʲôǵǾ̬ĺŵأ磬ߵҲǴͳܰݺͽ͵ġ
ѧ߰Ͷ䡶ͼ󡪡֡ıһµ߹ۣ֪һıһбһֵһġѧԡ壨
Ϊϵ۵ߵϢʣһɫɫдĶάռ䣬κдǰδеģǻͻıȡ
Ļĵƪġ˶Ҳ˵ӾıȻ߹۲ͷеض
ȫ֣ܵҲʾһоĻҪйعڵĹҲڽѧӰ̵ı仯ͳ
۹ۣڵܶԡԵڵҰܵ˸ΪرĹעͿ϶֮İоİ
õѭȥĹҪӺ۵Ļӡһ൱սԵĿ⡣
    һζΪʷΣ˵ǽֶо·ӵĲϵһĻôƬͽˡʵϣ
һ½ǶȻԿһֵĲ˵Ƿһѧߣ˵һѧġо
յ㣬һϢѹȣǻضķΧ־һоĸ߶ȡһѧһ濴˾ɵʷѧ۵ľ
ޣһҲкܳһ·Ҫߡ֮ѧߵĽƸǶԵģȲо״ֿⳬԽǰˡһЩΪص
ʷѧָһ۹Щѧۣѧʷļѧߡѷ
ѷ(Michael Phillipson)ѧسԳѧƵо֮⣬һѧ߼Ҫѧ룬ѧ
ۺٻصʷϡҲ˵ֵڴѧѧ۵ľѰҲպͼȡУȻܰ
ѧۺʷоڻһ⵱ȻҲһ淴ӳʷͬĿѧѧĵУǺĤ
صķʽ֪Դﵽˮ׼ѧ(Donald Presiozi)ζἰ(Henri Zerner)һָ
ʷѧƵĴʼˣī(Morelli)(Riegl)ֵֶȣǵ˼Ѿ˻һֺԵרҵ
ָظǣѧʼ̸ʷΣʱʷȦȴһ˺ĬȻϣκη˼
жǲֵĢᡣڣ͹۵˵еĶԴͳо·ӵӣ൱̣ҲǡơڡƩ磬
Nѷ䡶Ӿ滭һ൱˹ϣʷѧָһְĻ򵥻˵ġ֪塱(P
erceptualism)ǲѷڡӾ滭Ȿȴδܳʾ߳ϣ׵ϵͳԷ⡣ӢΪ
ʷѧ׫дġʷҲˡȻͼӵ˼άŮȨ塢ṹ塢˼塢ṹԼ
ȣĽǶӢʷо״һЩµ⣬Ӷͬϣ(KClark)70ڵγ
ĶԱȣǣ˲ޱǣռڸеļǹɲ꣬˰յʷӦеȫò[11]
ô˵ⱾѾζʮĹˣοʷŲʮѡ
    ʷķϢѧҪصö࣬оɹ˼𾯾Ķ
ѧѧԺʷѧҲǵĵطǰʷȻǽݷݷѧǵҪ⣬Ʃ
γǰ˵Ĵ뼼ɣЯĴĹϵƷα⣬ԨԴǺڵƷӰ˺Ʒ
ͼ־ԼΪʲôƺѭһִĳһ񣨻˶һ񣨻˶̣ȵȡǲ˵ûʲ
ô塣ǣʷоľһЩ⼰εظĻôƱػһխַյʷۡ
ô˵任һЩЩ˼άʽֻ޺Ʃ磬粼ѷƵΪʲôʷֹǣ
ʷѧߣרҵ·ӰضҼƷںλϵойұ˰ԼʷĺλԼͬ
ĽԵ̽أĳ˵߸͹ʾʷиӶ΢ĳͻƣȴʷоѾ[12]
    ȷʵʷΣ˵ȥʷһѧƱҪӸϴݻһѧгγɵһֽäĿİȫУıʷ
ѭؾɺ͹ַյоѧ֡˵νΣ˵ǡǡǰ̵ĽԶǵƻԡо
һ˼ıΣĿ꣬Ҳʾһֶ
    ڵʷڵʷ
    νڵʷߡڵʷ京嶼ǶԵġڵ۳֮ǰ˵ʷķΧרҵ
ȻġǣЩ뵱˼йȴֶЩΪרҵޣͼµĻ߸Ϊ۵о
Ұչʾʷʮɫɡ⡱ڡڡ⡱ˡ֮⣬ΪҪǣڵʷ͡ڵ
ʷֲͬоǰƫڴʷڲԣɵġĺݵʣ̽⣬ƫʷ
ⲿԣɵġĺʽʣ¡ҪȡڶֺչۣΪǰһ֡ڡ⡱綨ڻ
ʷѧķչн洦ɼ
    ѧ߲ޱ۵ظ̾ڽʷڲͬѧ۵ִ໥ų⣬Ժ͵;Ҳ[13]
һйءڵʷ͡ڵʷȷʵɼһߡƩ磬οʷо򻯼ֵ൱ŵĿ195
8꣬ʷѧϯLʸѧĳԱķΪʷѧҵġһ񡱣Ϊִѧע
ҪʷԽԽá60ԺӰ쳤ֱʷѧĹ㷺70νġʷѧΪһ
ֱزٵʱ֡ѧڶ(Lionel Trilling)ƤذĹ˵ǡĻеٵ
ǣ˹̹ɵ(David Stannard)ʷѧȴԺе۹ⶴʷѧľ޴ȱݡΪ¶аɶࡤ
ĴоӲϵ۵ԵġӲˡ磬ԮĵʱӼˡأӥһؼʣ
ʵD.S.Ŀɷ˹д1895аɶࡤĴУӦڡأӥӦǡ𰡱Ȼǡǡһ
չġȻ¶ԡأӥĹע⣬ΪڹŰУĸ׼أӥΪģ
أӥεİŮֵķmut͵еġĸס(mutter)ơ⣬ŵףڽףļأأӥҲĸ
׵ԭڴأӥһĸԵģڷĹſڷ硣һñ̻ԮΪȻʷ֤ݡ
ԲЩʥеˡɴˣ´󵨵ذйĸ޸аɶΪСأӥȷʵаɶ³ֵʥݵŮ
ͼУأӥ۵Уνġĸᡱǣڣأӥ뱾ͲĻôΪ
аɶеĳɾ벻ҵԿ׵ĿɿԾʹɻˡ֮⣬˹̹ɵ»ʷѧۻЧԡ߼
ԼĻ޵ȣһɣȫչʾеĽ̨[14]ɣ˹̹ɵµļ͸ٶ̵ģڲٵطȷʵڴ
ʷѧ˾ӡ
    ǿѧ˵ȷʵǰ޹˵ΪһʷʷָͨʶӶʷ̵żȻԡ
ԺԸӾ΢͹ֳĻôĹǲĨɱġʵϣȥֱɵһ棨ĳЩ¸
ľĻġ۹ںһ𣬽;ѧ֮ͨԺͻµľءνͨ
ԣָרҵֶԼԽѧʱڿԣڸߵĲϱѧƼоʾ̶ȡ
۲ͬѧһѧƣʷѧ֮ĻҲҪ򣬵ǣ飬ʷѧ
ϺƽӦ˹Ŀ࿴ģĳЩ޿áˣĳϣʷĹײԶ
ԶһʷѧĹףĳЩϹʷԵ塣
    Ҫᵽǵѧ߱ء(Peter Gay)йΪκʷУԶǲɻȱķ棬
ԵάԶҲʷоѧߵľ޹أ֮ˣάĲֻ쿪֪Ĵ͸ԡ
ʷγɵơڽʽͶϰ׺׼ȶǱ͹ͨҪ;֮λúԴжľ
ǵʽǺ临Ӻͳ죬Ȼϵеϵĳѹ֣еλ
ĳͶ䣬еҵĳʷѧеòֻ״̬Ƕ֪
һ˲֪ﱣ־ȻΪĸԴεģЩʾӾء鲻ԽҪĽһ
޿ɵֵĽۣѧר˽磬ⷽȨŵģѧ˲ʷԭе岿
֡ԾĻ͹֮Сˣʷѧδȫյַʽԣһʷض൱̶ҪΪʷ[15]ǻ
֮ʶѧҪʷ˼άʽȡը̬ȡĩ˽
ʷڲоĳɼأ1976꣬һϵݽἯ棬Ϊжʷԭ򡪡
Ƥ˹ɵﰲΪʷѧ塷ⲿУ۵ʷое
涨ԡȻѧľδһелȡ͹۵Ķôоʲôʼմ
һֶѵľأʹڶƷҲ⣬Ϊ϶ÿһ֪Ҳһˡeve
ry perception is already a theory)ѧɵѧҡѧԼ۹ʷڼʷʱձ
˵֤ݣġġԱɼȣ֮Ҳͻӵһܹȷо֮ľĻơ
ͬʱʷѧӦһʷѧҺѧҲ޹֮ͨѧ߰(James SAckerman)ʷѧ
ߡоЩٳƷ¼ʱôǵķЩо羺ѡսȵ¼ѧõķ죻Щ¼
ȫǹȥģԻٵͨסĶֳȷʵһʷµǶﱾоʱ
ͱһѧʷѧҡΪһ׿޴Ǻһ·»ǲĴ֮䣬йطս
׳֮䲢ԭϺͼϵĲ족˵κζʷ̽棺Ļպ͸Ȼ
ʷѧڶضҽоʱضĴšƩ磬˴֣ȻչպĻ򣬶ԸƤ
˹ѭĻյļ·ӣɵﰲҪӼյĻ̽ƽ֮ˣȫΪʷ
ԶʵҪḻ͸ӵöࡣϣʷомɽĶھоϵѧҲԶ
κʷԭҲ˵ÿһʷ¼кü֣ĳֱӵĻӵģڵĻ˽˵ģ¶Ļڵģȵȣ
ǶɵԤ൱޶ġһʹʷоζˡˣκεһԭ̽󶼲Ƕʷ
̽øµĻ˵ʷԭǡؾġԣʷҪʷֿһĹպͷ
ô˵ǶʷжӡΪȻоһʷʵУ֪Ͷʵԣ
ôһٶǰɵԤڽɻζģѧ𽥵ػᱻȷΪֿѧеŮףǡͨ
;[16]ʷ(psychohistory)оδֶܳȫؽѧȫֶΣԲ⡣֮£
ѧɵʷоʱԳ൱ơԭǲֻǶסĺͱ̬Ķͼĳһѧ֧ܹǺ
ͳ̬ĺͱ̬ȫ󣬱磬˵˳ƷչʱҲ̽˵澳չȵȡ
    ӦϣʷʶĹ֮ȲͬڴͳʷѧƫŰʷ̽ѧ
ѧĺ󱳾ϣһɵרֵ൱쾡£ͬʱҲͼѰΪڵԭ򣬼ͨ
ֱӿӴ̬Ʃ磬ܻʾһЩѰζͨɿǷǳйԵˣ
ڲͬǣʵȴڵʱĻ龳෴ɵﰲȻΪ20ڵʱ
ߣȻʵʷҸϸĸԺʮִֹԸȡ֮ʷеĺ΢ڸоҰ֮С
ӦָǣΪһҲӡ󣺾߶оζȻĶǿھĸо
ƺδַܽ᳹ʮֵң˵δЩʮעо㹻ľ롣ѧ߼ָ
ѸоּȤʵﵽηһĻٻ˲һʧУΪȻѧӦеĴ͸û߶
Ƥ˹ɵﰲʷϳ͹ʾԭ߶ԸûʲôͬʱԺй˼
[17]ʵԼҲѾʶʷԵġоеϵҲ
ͼѡһѧߵġʷобֵΪԡ
    ѧ롤ǲ(Suzi Gablik)ᡣġеĽһר۵ڵʷ͡
ʷ֮ĶŹϵָʷ۹⿴ķһ;Ѵˡڵػڵز
Ӱչܣһ⡣Ʃ磬ֶֺ(Riegl)Ϊѭڷչ
ɵչʾ߼ͬһģѧɵʷңܱ뷢չϵп졣
ѼǲΪֵֶʷѧġָӾ֪ԣаڹɷչʷ
ӵӰ档ֶΪӾֻĽʾԾͬӾʽ-ʾӦ
ʷѧߵĻͬʱǲҲǿʷʹȥѰҸΪͬʱҲΪ⣬Ʃ18
͵ķ羰20͵ξ(dreampaintings)Ķ֮ͬһʵʷѧӦȥоһڶصԵ
ΪǱͳ֪ģʽλõͼ󣻵ǣЩѧߣ繱ϣȴڰͼ󣨻
ͬԴԡԻںĹԡԴˣǲ׷ʵĹԴںδ磬Ϊʲô15ͿʱͻȻ
ʼðε(recessional)ƽ(planimetric)ķʽ֯ռأʲôضʱϵһ𣿡
壬ҪӲشЩ⣬ֻǾеġǲһ϶Ųоԣһ
رעڴ˵֪ķչһǶʷй켣ͼ֤չĻģʽʷĻıǨԭ
ǲֵԭ򣩡ǲָκ֪ṹڻ˵ͼʽǽͼʽ鹹磬仰˵ͼʽ
һн飬ʵ֪Լڴ˻ɵй֪ʶ֪ṹʹǻ鹹
֪Ҳʶ̣ߡƤǽܵ˵ҲѭһķչģʽҪض˼άʽ
˵ͼʽķչʹǿһԵĽǵ־һֿ͹ۻĽ򣬶ķչҲǴһ
ԻȱֻĽ׶תֻϵĽ׶εġȻĿ͹ʲǻ֮ΪҡǽԵ
ѰЩ桪йⲿ֪ʶʵһʶ˵֪ĽѾʶ˵֪
ܳһĽṹһһ˵ȵʵԵĽ׶ʱ߲ϵķֻҲ֮ɴˣ
Ҳвʵ塣ζǣķչҲһƵİڵĶڵĶ𲽼ԷĹ̡һ˵
֮ȱֻĽ׶ڱȽϷֻĽ׶ΡƤǽǰĲֻġҡ֮ķ룬ʹóʼ׶ʱ
ʶȫݶͬһƽиĹۣͶҲͳֻԵ档һ˵֪չʷ֮ͬϵ
˵֪ĳʼ׶һδȫҲδȫֿĽ׶εĻĩķչһǣ
ڸʵڵĿ͹Եģ⻯ǣ߼һԵģڻһ׶Σ˸עڿ͹۵ġ߼ϵкϵ
һʷ˶ͨضġ¼Ტ۵ġ͹ԡʷķʱȷˡ
ǵǣ֪ܶڻ滭е¾дЧ֣ĩͨʲô;һֲ״̬һָ߼״
̬չҴﵽȽϳֵĿ͹أĿǰǿҵǣƤǽչ̺ʷĽ൱Ǻϣͬ˳ӦĽ
ƽͼʽչԵ˶ֵעǣǲԼƤǽ֪׶ѧ˵⣬һʷΪ
ʱޡ(megaperiods)ָڿռģʽȷҪģΪģʽģʽ֮ĳתˡʱޡŲơ
ͼʾǱɶʷķչƤǽ֪ܵ׶˵֮Ĺϵ൱ӡ[18]һֺ۵ĽǶȿʷϵ
ЩʱָǷԵĴͳǼȱʾĳ֪ģʽսҲһģʽĿˣչضᣭĻתȷĳ
ʷԵӡҪǣȻһʵĹգӦýһоݡǣǲ˳ϣƤǽ֪ܵչ
˵ʵҲĻ⡣Ƥǽܱȷرʾ
    Ȼչ׶ҿһʵЩ׶ڲͬвͬĺ壻ڴڲͬǵȷԳ̶Ȼ˵
ȷƫصĳ̶Ҳͬһ׶οʺеķչĻĩɻġҼȲȷҲܷ
ǵĴڡֻвϵּͨȷһϵеĹϺͶӦȵоܶᣬػδɡ[19]ǲ
꣺ķչһֽ״̬͸֯ԣ򸴺ԣļ˵ͬĲԻֵʵʽ
ͻƩ
    ͼ  {ͼ}
    ʵ˵һдʵִع飬Ĺģ൱ޣ˲δϸıʷĺйض
εĸȷе˵ָڻĳ֪ʽĽһȷġıȻԡȻձԵ򲢲ųԵı仯Ϊǹ˼
ĿԣķչһĳһضĻΧʹĳһ׶βֳȽԵǣϣķչʽ
ոʱڵķչʽƽԣǶͻȻͣٶδﵽһȫչ͸ϵУһ
ɵ͵ߣдʵı仯֣ŷִ֤ġȱݵΪʲôƼ򵥶ʵȴ
ĳϱ־һߵĸԵԾڴˣʷѧ߿϶ʽΣƷʽϸӶ㣻
ԶκһոʱڵĻ滭Ҫ򵥵ö࣬ʵǸӸӻˡӻָΪִʽ (modern pa
radigm)ɵĽɴӾϵͳȽ϶ԣոʱڵķʽڵһġյ߼ϵ͸ӡÿһ
滭һһεԼͬķʽظ֣ÿһƷϸһϵеִֹʽĿԡ
ԺͶֵڳıûʲô壬ֻ໥ϵвŻĳζԣķֺϷʽԵؽҪˣ
ַֺϷʽѺʵ֪Զĳ˵ʷһʽнųĽǸ߶Ի̬
Ǽ͵ĴִġҲ޵ֶչʾ޵Ǳ[20]
    ǲ˵ʷѧȻĺôȲȫֶֺԷԷʽ־(Kunstwollen)ĸ
ʷԷչ̣Ҳ񹱲ϣڲںڸ˵ľһּˣִڹܵķ
׷ķ׷ΪʲôӶʵų˺ʷչ̵ڿ[21]ʷѧ
ʷѧķǾ̽ʷĸʵģֻдйطչĵомȡ˼ӪܻһԦ
ܸǲ˵ѧ൱Ŷʾ˳ѧоĳԣͬʱҲΪΪ΢۵ϽչĶ
⣬Ȼ̶ҵءȣӸǲʱޡĽվʽݵĹ̡һ
1911Ժĸ߶ƳбֵΪȷ˵ͨԪصͼ
ʵģƾڻ﷨λƴķһְѲͬԪϡճʹ֮໥ķʹ滭
һνӽԵ״̬ߵһϵеɷƴ滭ṩĳķ˹˵ת﷨
׶Σ˹ (Juan Gris)ȫ״ɫʺƽ棬ɴɻϳɶʵָ棨Сϳɡ֮ƣ[22
]ֵǣǲƶϵĻ塣ִһֽתڵ﷨緽ΡԲΡ
塢ıκεһȻ﷨Ԫɡľ䡱(kernal sentence)ͲϹϵΪͼ(iconic)ϵͳ
ڻͶ󣨼ֿķţ֮ĹִġΪӵϵͳеķ򴫴ﾳ(context)
仯ϢеصԽԽ߼ĳˮƽƤǽԵԵĺͿѧ˼άҪͼ
ִͬҲͦԸӾͳʽʵıʡǸˡ˹̹(Frank Stella)Լɪ򡤰˹
(Josef Albers)ĳظ˾ɵ͸ӻþ壬ǰոʱڵȿռеĶάռΪһ壬ʹ֮
µȸС˵ڹŵִ֮仹һ߼ԣֻ߲εĸƾתͶʵ[23]
ԿɶԸǲ˵֤һ⣺ڳ֪׶֮δչճֺ֣ġ׶ۡ
߼пڸԶͼġ˼ά״̬Ȼ˵ĻǷȻҪ⵽һ⹹ˣҲ˵
ԼڵɣΪһѧġԵ״̬ȫȻغϣͲӵеĶӡǡ˵ִ
ڲ֮ͬǡǡԶбҪȥΪԣҵǣܸǲα⣬۶ϻǺ뵽ڸߵ
ۡǲܲʷĺĻʲɡΣ׶̺ۡʷ۳߶ȻҲ⡣Ʃ磬ڸ
˵ոǰͯһδ߼㣻ոʱڵ뵽˾߼꣬
ֻгڹִҲչȫҲ˵ȹϵǷиɻֻҪϸļֵ̬ȾͲ
ˡΪʵǼȺѷҵˮƽҲûڼֵ۵ϰִҵĴԵ֮ϡ
ĳ˵ʱǡǡǺ󼰵һַȻеźǣǺѴӸǲ˵мִֶܵǰ
ݻ߱Ƚϱ֤̬ȡȻ֤ΪʲôòƼ򵥵ִʵһָΪ߼ĸ״̬Ƕ
һֳԽô˵ǲ˸ṩһػʷӡһ൱۶ʷ̣һ
ȴɻʷ۹ۡ⵽ǶһɵĽֻһµչеĽ
ںһϡıϾһȫµоҰʷѧдδֹ̽һԶĿ⣬ȱһ
µġʵԵоԱġ
    ʷڽ̵ĹעоȻڸ͸ǲ˵оڷŮѧ߿˿(julia Kristeva)Ƕ
ʮ͵оⷽоһӡڿ˿޿ǽ׷ұڴжʵ
ʵҲ̽ΰѹеĳ嶯ݻΪɫ뻭Ĺ̡Ʃ磬ڿеɫʵԼȷ滭
ʷϵĶصλʱṩ൱̵ӽǡʷ˵ڻ滭гӱܵĳ嶯ɫʣǴһеĳ
ɫɫԽòƽɫ仯ͼСõıڻУɫرעĿɫ[24]ʵϰĳЩʶ
Եת[25]ֽǶȿʷı仯һ¡⣬ط(Sidney BlattEthels Blatt)ġеĳԺͱ
ԡֵģʽķչŵ(Linda Nochlin)Կδ֮ߵĻױĻױ׷Լ
˹̹(Leo Steinberg)ġոִеĻ֮ԡȣ̶Ȳͬ̽ʷڷ档ڽѧӽ
оϴʷʹģǾٲʤˡ˼ǣΪʲô˱͵ںͺڣǶڷչ߼Ȥ
ǶʷĴͳоģʽһԾѧƱصȻӣʣԴѧʷܻԶδﵽ
׶Σ״̬Ҳ˵оչľ޴ԡͬʱҲԿĿǰʷоɹ
ѧɹδͳֳֵΪѧ˵Ƥǽܵķʶ۵ȱϾѧһѧƵһ֣ң
ѧоɹҲǱȽ޵ġעǣѧʷĿͷԶ˶ԡڵġġĻ
ĺʶ̬ģĲպͰգ䶴ۿ۸֮е顣˵ʷġԡ͡ԡֻ
Եģǵƫغ໥ڲһо⣬Ҹǹԭ⡣ķᵽѵ¹
ھĲϼԽʣͿȫڸǻŤһɵʷ塣ҵǣɴͳε¹ʱŽȤζķģ
ܵ񶾵֫⣬֫Դڱ뾫񲡻ߵĻ滭ϰ۲á1937꣬ڳġչ
ϣϣŵ¡Ͽ˹Ϳ˵Ʒ뾫񲡻ߵƷһУԴ֤ǰߵƷǾ˻ĲӦΧ[26]Ȼ
ķ൱˵ӡѧʷоľԲǸԵ⡣ѧ³(William Rubin)Ͳ˺
ʽĹϵоָݸѧɵԲ˵չشѰԭڵƺ
Ϊ˸ݸѧ˼ѰעţЩעʱԶԲ˵ĴʽƷΪ۵ġƩ60Ͳɭ(Bryan Ro
bertson)ΪݸѧӰ죬ŮиԲ1934꣩һǴݸĸȨƵĽеõеģݸ
ΪĸȨ[27]ǣмûֻµ̬ҲûͷӡڰͷεŮɪ(Wysuch)ͺɭ
(Henderson)ɴԳΪʷעĲݸ۸ΪҲƵƵͨŮѰһ
жܸĸסһ־ѵļ󣺺ܼ壬ԼΧɧġѱܵϸֲ԰׵
·һıտ־塭ǣǺվסŵġ³ָѲƫοǾѵı
滭ֶΣΪֶεĺҲޡɺͱϼȻ˰ʱõַұϼԲ˵Ӱ
Ǻġνܼıտ־Ĺϵ˵ΪֻһѣǱϼ볬ʵ
صƷѵβʼ50ŦԼеĲƷҲˡԣЩ˵ǾѵĲڲ
ϸ԰׵ߣ޷ΪͻͼǿԺͱԶ[28]оٵӻкܶࡣӦǾǣİ
ͣƺһֲԾڰѶͳ뾫񼲻صԣΰѡڻо͡ڻ
νأ˵֮֮[29]Զ׼ʷ̽Ѱкܳһ·Ҫߣ
һ˵оԣһоյǰ;
    ʷ
    ʷ(New Art History)ŷѧһ൱ʱֵȷָʲôԴԺδȷ˵Ӽе
׿ʷΪе̼ԵԷζӢѧ˹(ALRees)Ͳ(Borzello)ܵ
ʷһ繫ʹ1982꣬ʱһ־(Block)һѧԺ֯Ϊʷѧ飬֮
ʺʾʹǶԴЩȷĸоɻ󲻽⡣Ҫʲôǡʷо¡ĳƪĲǲ
滭ƷλеŮ󣬻ĳݵĽߺʥĸ۵ĹǷԸĸĽ̻ڽ̻滭Ϊ֮ģô롰
ʷ಻Զˡѡʷһʷѧɣ罫йŮȨ塢˼塢ṹ塢
ԼѧѧȸȽͳֱصʷоɵֳһۺϸ[30]ȷʵ൱˼
¹ЮʷоһµġʤͬʱҲɫʵľء
    ӦϣʷԴͳĻͳʷоĻ൱̵ġǲԵرȽһߵĻ졣
о˼·ʷһйطαϡ󡢸ơԼҼͼѧơǣ
ڣһѧӦеű쾭ĶڴҵǰķǾԵù棬Ҳ͵
ѧƵķչһֲԾľ롣ڴͳʷ˵ƵоĿ꣬ⲢûʲôоĿȷԽԽ
ζôоͿʼۿˡ֪ʷѧǴֶֺ˿ʼġǵԭǣ
ʽоġ20µ(Edgar Wind)ŵ˹쵼ʽоҪעĻʷ
Ҫ塣ǣ30ɴͳεĵ¹ѧ߶Ծȷ͹֪ʶ׷ȴʹʷоѧҲյƩ
ǻٵųѧʷоеĵλԽԽƫڶʵͲϵѼСӦ˵70ʼʷ͸Ϊ
ϵԿ죬ٶʾԽԽעĿ塣˽(T.J.Clark)ǿӦðʷһֳֹ˼
ʵʷ磬о19ͻ滭ʱͲܲᵱʱ(1848-1851)״̬ӿ1848Ĵ
֮ԵóζĶȻΪҪǣʷּڳͳоҰľԣҲעط۵
ͼǶʲôԼΪʲôȵߵȤҲ˵ҪʹʷһƽǵС
оʷĹȻѰضĺһĿȻĶķͲȻǶµʧȴȤȱ
㹻ǿҵĿôд˼ˡʷԳƾ60ʼѧƻԾ״ķӦ˵൱۵ģ
ʷĶȻζʮ㡣עҲ۹ڰʥͰ֮ᡣǿ
һЩȽϵ͵⣺ôΪģĵλĿģΪʲôֵоģԼʷѧ
͹֪ʶۣȵȡ͡Ʒʡŵ⣬˵ǱųоߵҰ֮⣬˵ǹעĽ㣻
ЩѧҸºʶ̬Ȩơ׼۵ȣζ͸¶ʷѧߵ˼Ȥͷ
˶᱾ʵȫע⣬һѧر۵ü۵̽֡һ̶Ȳͬش˼塢
ѧŷ޴½ѧŮȨ۵ȴȡоϵʾһ̽ʷĺ⣬
ֲ϶ģضʲôϵȵȡʵĿΪˡ⹹ϰΪͲ˼
ĹرйƷҴԱ¶Ĺ׼ʱ޹صĹԼ΢߳
˼·ȵȣʵϣġ⹹ʹǶԿ˼˵ǱƳĵӽ¼ӦеĻ
ɣڸУƵƵǿĹ۵㣻Ÿ˵һ塣
    ԶʷʹͳʷоӦǶġͳ˼·ȻкữΣգʷҲ
ǿữʵͬʱƫֹ֮涨ԡԣǿߵƽзչֱӦ֮塣ǣ
ڣٵĿǰΪֹ߹ͨ¡еѧƵѹϣ͵һȻ顣
    ǰߴӢת򵱴ѧҪ̨֮һôǿԸܵ˵о龳ЩӢҵѧ
ϵʷоǰЩɳ֮ΪĶȻ˵ԿǿҵᵽڷʷоҲǱ
ĶռϷ磨ӵҲչĿ¼֮ĲϣǣѧߵȻԿɱ档ȣѧеҪ˶
о൱ŨȤȤʲôʽǲǵоռҪλãڡжί˹
ȵġŮ롶֮ҡĲڡֻжԺɶ򡶷ʹڡ֣̽ȫ˸ܵһ
ͳʷоζͬͶضԺ滭ķ(Archimboldo)ķ(Cy Twombly)Ҳʾ
λѧҶԻ滭ǶôзȨҵͶشıתӾͼʱ˼·õ˽һ죬һ˼·
һī⣬ɷ(Yves Bonnefoy)Ҳ˸еλѧʫѧʫѧӾʫѧ֮Ǻ
࣬Ӧ֡ҲζķɫһжɭȻķҰȻѧڷһֱռĵλãҲ
ΪΣǰղΣڷѧУȻʷֿٺӢѧιĶ
ȡѷָһֻѹȥǹȥʱǾ޷ᰬػǶϵ֡ͳˣµȥ
ָǶԹȥΰ̵ĽȻеʷоǿ޶ڡضʱڿܷʷо
ʹӵʱĴﾳҲں̶ܴϺʷĵԣʵĵơʷ
ַڷѧȴԡں̶ܴҪ鹦ǶԷʷĹϵеԾ⡣40𣬴
塢ѧرǽṹͺṹ˼볱еʷѧߣҪȫΧۺķȻǲ̫ܵġ
Σѧߵʷĵ̽ʶصѧ߱Ӣʷѧ߸ΪҰӵ˼·ѧʷ
޴ѧʷʷȣǾڷѧߵʷֵñȽϳ֡
    Ȼ˵ͳʷоȱʷŵĹעǾͲ̫ƽˡ磬߶ѧԵͼѧ(embl
em)ĸȵĽϢϢأ60ڣ÷ҮƤ(Meyer Schapiro)ҲרĲӾķѧ⡣Ȼֹϵд
[31]ͬʱ뷨ѧȽϣӢѧе(archival)Ը(hermeneutic)ءҲˣ
ɨ跨ġʷʱ˽뵱ѧлϵԵΪҪ
    ѧߵĹ趨һ˼ʷĹ켣ڻһʵ֤֪ʶĹӲͬ˼Ӿͼ
ʶӷѧĽǶȰȻҲǷѧߵרǾΪƳ粼ѧɵĴ֮һ¿޷˹(Jan Mukarovsky
)30ĵ8ѧΪΪѧʵҪݡָʶǼ˽˻ĸʶ
ҲԽԽرڼʶġźݱҪˡΪһгԽ˸ʶ
ֻԴڷŵһʵҲĳЩѧƵֻͬڴߵ״̬ͬκ
Ʒڹ۷Ӧ˵һʶ״̬ĳЩԵĺʱԵĶʹĳֲɱԺͲɽ
ԣĩƷּڹͨߵĸԺڵȺԡκڹһӡɻʱ״̬һ֡ɻ
״̬ǴྶͥģȻжһֿ͹۵ķѧʣһ仰˵ͬһͬһࣩƷ۷ӦȻ
ĳֹͨԡ˵νƷͲֻǡ㡱ķţġ廯ﾳѧΡڽ̺;õ
ﾳӶҲܸӳһضġʱ
    ǻڶŵıȻϵĶ⣬ͶġΪ硷һж17͵ĺ滭˱Ĳ͡
вյ(Saenredam)ȴرζ԰롰ִ֮СȲФҲ
Ψ൱һ˵ĽڲһֱȻżߵûҪԶƺûһܰ޸б
ô쾡¡滭ĿǵַбҲͬںóֶԡ־ã(horror vacui)ı֣
رлĵƷ͸¶һǵ˵ʴӸлҪĪĿС˵յԺ滭Ĺŵ
൱صģҲһȻ⡱ٰ۹Ͷ17͵ĺ滭ĩչʾǰһ˼
صġ滻ڽգƩʥĸʹĵλøˣĽҲѡǿ(Capp
elle)Ƿáά(Van de Venne)ĺǶлĳڶ̨ά(Essaias Van de Velde)
˺ӡ糵ܿܿϢϢأͷüõĶɿڡĶɴȣڵ͵ĺﻭЩ˴˲ָߵ͵
Ʒ͸ΪĺۼùԺõӡ׵ġ˵硣ں滭Уÿһﶼһ
ֶȫΨ۵ʤע˼ǣٺﻭ˲ȷʡ緲˹ش(Van Ostade)µũ
Ŀ壬ͯǼȼҲ治ԱΨ̬С֮ѡ²ũҲйı֡
Ļ̲һע̬ȣֻйФţġͼڡʸĺ͸߶дʵ͡Ե
̬numen൱ͬġ塱ŮԵǸԵģжڵ塣֮Էѧ۹⿴17͵ĺ滭
Էʤ㺭塣
    ΪṹѧҶί˹ȵ֮ҡķҲǲɶõʷ봫ͳ߲ͬ²ȥ
ͼĺ壬زͼ֮ӾλùϵԼҺ͹ߵӾӦϵȡڸ¿ʹòƱĿռ
λú߷ҲġšϵÿһϸڲǶôز۶ɵļֵ续еĻҵעӡб
ǹߵļϻݵȾͰżḻδԡԺԡ
    ˵ѧǵصȣĩҵоԵøΪϸ¡·ס(Louis Marin)ɣ
ǵˡľտƺǶһӾĶ۵ʾκΡ⡱ֵĻ裬
ĽҲ⣬ǵˡһ֤ѧѧĳЩоɷЧֲʷ
һѧͨ龳£йءͼıоܼдһ۵ĸصġиԵ棩֮ĶţͬʱΪ
Ļ滭еġṹġضġͼıϵͳҲһĲ졣˵һĶԼû򱣳ֵʵλ
漰棺һνġ(competence)ĽṹͼġھĻ滭
ܵϢ֮γɵģ߽еضƷΪӾͼԼͼеһӶѣν
á(performance)Ϊض˼Ļ滭Ʒ˼ƷܻһиصĶ⣨Ȼһг˼
Ǻ˵ģΰЭҪؼⷽ棬ɣġǵˡرܹӳѧע
ϵͳԣȷе˵
    ͼɣǵˡеġԻϵ
    ͼ  {ͼ}
    A=ߵ
    B=ŵ
    C=ұߵ
    D=Ů
    ֱ߼ͷ=̬
    ߼ͷ=ע
    д֣滭֪ɣֺӾͼһ壬еġEt in Arcadia Egoǻκζ˼
һȤ㡣Ӧעǣڻ滭ĶⲻͬڶѧıĶ⣬Ϊ߿ƾԼעӲϵشԽռ
ܹͼɫԼɫķֲʲô޶ԣעҲԶȶѧıʱעҪɵö࣬עԻ滭Ŀռ䣨
ΪӡĻ滭Լڷλȣ˵עֿռɵĹµʱ䡰߼˵
һķҪš֮˫ءӹϵĻôġԵĻ滭УΪŵͼڷָ
ĸֱ֮ӷáھĶУǲŸɭйؽʹܵĸ͡Ϣաָ桪
ȣѡǵˡͼʾͼ˵ͼġԻϵ[32]ɴˣɽһ˼л滭йص
⣬ռṹͼָĹϵ滭еģıͼͬȵȡ⣬Ҳɷڶ1
4ͻ滭еʱԺͷʱԵľоѧʷڡѧ(Michel Serres)ԸֳӵŮˡĻṹ͹ͼص
ϸ·ȣ޲һ¶ĿĸܣʹǸȷʷĿռ[33]
    ȽԵʵǣŷġʷǷѧожɧͷѧ߱(Mieke Bal)
ƾѧ߲ѷĳƪۡѧʷԴ൱ȫֺ̽ܽᡣʷеķѧѧƵһʱ
ı־ΪڱϿķѧһ̵Ļ۵ĲǴͳʷǷȱġ˼ǣ
ʷоԡӲα⣨һֱ۲ݵ۲ʡ󡤸ߺ͹˹ƷȻΪڡоǵ˵
ʵ֤ʵģ˵ǲʵģҪǶԷļͣо߱Ҳе㾪ȵ飬ҴαԲòδ
ʵ֤۵ıҪɺȻҪڶѧƱչϣǱڵؾгѧʵķѧķչʱ֤ʷѧƸº
չľ޴[34]
    õǣԡʷرеļ֮⣩ȻʮǿҵġƩ磬ͳʷѧرʷ
߶ԡʵ֤ۡΪе޵ķʸͬʱҲΪʷоʵĿǰϳͳоɹ
ƺڸȻʷȴΪվھɵĹ⡣ʷԿ׵ºʵ֤
˵ָضĸˣ˵ӦǶһռλ˼άƵĸʷоֻһָΪҰ
Ȼζ[35]
    ˼ǣԡʷҵǡǡеķѧҿ˹Ƥ(Donald Kuspit)ġͳ
ʷѧӾıԹνдķӦ˹ƤָΪʲôԶʷԳѧƹ۲ִΪʲôʷ
ӽṹṹĽǶƷΪʲôʷԸƷһ֡ıз˵Щʹ⹹
ġĽԼѽΪʲôʷԸ롰ѧԵĿռ䡱( paraliteraryspace)Щⶼ
ԭġʷҪάԼĶԣȥӡ֤ѧѧҵʱǡǡҪѻ滭û֮У
˵滭ǻ֡ʹܹеȡѧۣҲմлԭ۵Ķǿʽ棬ͶҪһ
۾ȵȣܽһµĻͳʷоһЩֵעļٶЩٶ춨վвɻ
ԭԵĹ(1)Ӿһڵĸ߹Ʒʣɴ˾ͳ˿׸(Murray Krieger)ġ
֮ϡȻѧΪĻԭȴڷӾƷԣ(2)ӾѧƷӽԿΪǰ߸
ʵСд̼ԣܻߵȶ༤顣ˣӦðѧֿһͬʣ(3)ߡѧߺעߵΪ
ҵĴ֮ġǣġѧƵоȴһְͬһͼּȷ
оĴԡ봫ͳʷѧ߲ͬʷѧ˵ң˵ЩΪ˼ҵңƩ
ǶУͺرżˡ͵ɵĶ[36]
    ˹Ƥصì֮ȣ˵ĵһּٶ͵ڶ㣣ǰһǿǹյġ˼ĺƷԣһ
ȴǡǡ෴ƫڸйٵġĺͷġΣǿͳʷӵɻٶʱƵƵڸµѧ˵
ȻⱾνĴͳʷġԡִԼҲòϣڴͳʷоһ
һҪоͷһָеЩڲ۵΢Դ塣ٴΣӾź͡ı
ְͬӾѧͬʵ£Ҳδ뻹ԭʲôϵǡǡ෴ǰӾΪŻıʱ
ǻԭ˹ƤӾع鵽һԴͷǽӾһֺĻ龳Ӷ
̵塣һ£ͳʷûͼѧҰֻƶʲôزأ󣬰оȷΪһִ
ĻСӡ塱֮ӡǿֻʷоΪ˵ûԵĶԣ
ִʷԾڷӡ˼άΤտ(ReneWelleck)ɵĿϵ֪
ֻʫһ鹹硣ԵʶʶΪĿġ[37]һϿ˼ң
ĳ־زûʲôɷġʵϣоЧԻδľԣ̵ܲ˼άһζƫڶ
顢Ϻͼͻǲġ
    ȻʷķѧоǡʷȫòʵϡʷҲʲôͳһоɣڲҲ
ΪͬӽǣṹȻвͬ[38]ԣоչһضʱڵҼ
ƷøΪḻͲͣһ塢ĿҲ֮γʷоĸҪ󣺻ҼƷ
ʷʵ֮۷ɼҪйʼյĹ淶ԣҪͨоǡлﵽϵЧӦʹ˶ԣʷоֻ
ҪԶоһҪ۵Ԫʶվһָ˼άϷ˼оԾҲֻ۸
ʵʵо˼вϳʵͷչ
    
    ʷΣ˵еζϾǹ֮ʮѧΧʷѧǰ뷽۵֣̽
̶˸ѧƱƷʣҲʹԳƵʷоһɻĿǰʷоͳбҪķ˼ձĹ
ʶΪҪһѧƵڡΣǾ֮ͣҪ൱ʱպŬô˵ᳫԾʶôǿ
Ҳġѧ߿(David Carrier)ʹȥմߵƷ粩
Ʒά޸ȣ䱾Ҳһ۲͡ΪԲ˵ڹ᳹䱣Ʒּʱ뿼ǵҶƷ
ʵȻеΪѵ飺Ǳ뱣Ʒԭ״Ȼܽԭ⡣ôܴﵽĿ
أƩ磬֪1523㴴ˡͿ˹밮ɡƷԼ470ʷҪ̽
ʵ壬ָֹܲ۵㣺
    (1)һɫƽ棬ǻ¶ʧɫġΪ˱ĶǾʾУ
    (2)һۻ¶仯Ϊ˱ĶǾһıĿȥµĺ
⼸޿ɻرܵĽֲͬйƷıʱһѧľˡʵϣҲѾٳʵ
(Otto Kurz)ƫص(1)ֹ۵㡣滭ƷԶĹ󡱡һķţ˥΢ķţ෴
ǰ⿴һʶǵͼҪƵģӦɫѡ񡣡[39]ϣҲΪȻ
˵׼Ƿԭ⣬ȴô˵ȷ֪ǡǡǣûԢڸӷḻ΢໥õ
֮[40]ǣԴҲ෴һʱҪЯ(patrons)ңΪʲôҪƷңԶδ
ʲôأʹȷȷʵʵƷδӣĩߵȤζأ˵ȵȡʵһԼ
ŵƷδΪ˿ı仯ĩȻѱ֤ǷܹȻزƷԭ⡣Ʃ磬ոʱ
ڵƷضģǱǨ벩֮ǵ֪ʽҲ֮ıˡĽʵЩͬʱĽ
ԭͬЩŴƷ޸˵Ƕԡԭأ˵ǲ̵¼Ϊһл
ʹߵĶ˸ģ˵ĽܿǶԹߵƭ֮ܶܶࡣƷıߡ޸ߣǼִ
ѼЭضǰϵ[41]˵Ʒı޸ˣĩʷȻǸӸӺͶˡ
죬ʷҪرܵѧƵ巢չƺ̫ʵˡʷѧ˹(Mark Roskill)ڲ޼ָʷ
ǰչһ;ǲϵظע뵱˼ͼֵʷѧ߶ԹȥֵĹ۵ڵֳõζ
[42]
    ţʷѧоΣʶĴ߻£ۻ׷õһؿԼ˵䲻ʵʵ
Σĳ⣬ʹǷ˼״ǵʷо߳µռ䣻дʷ
͹ʷй磨ѧɣԼվʲôĲչȽʷҰȵȡκʱΣжȿնֹۻΪնȻ
Եõ״̬öࡣҲǵʷѧ״ǵʾ
      ϣʷѧż񡷣Ϻ磬1989ꡣ
      See Hans Belting:The End of the History of Art?Universityof Chicago Press,1987.
      Norman Bryson: Vision and Painting: The logic of the Gaze,N-ew Haven,1983,Xi.
    [30][31]  See A.L.Rees and Frances Borzello ed.The New Art H-istory, London,1988,Introduction; pp.82-89.
      μ׾롲ɪ.F.дʷ19911ڡ
      M.Holly:Panofsky and the Foundation of Art History,CornellUniversity Press,1984,P.184.
      HZerner:I'Art in Faire de L'histoire vol.2, ed. J. LeGoff and P.Nora,Crallimard,1974,P.188.
    [11]  See Donald Preziosi: Rethinking Art History, Yale U-niversity press,1989,p.112;pp.1-2;p.119;p.186.
    [12]  See Norman Bryson: Preface to Chinese Edition of Traditionand Desire(forthcoming).
    [13][17]  See Donald Kuspit Conflicting Logics:Twentieth CenturyStudies at the,Crossroads,Art Bulletin,March 1987.
    [14]  See David E.Stannard:Shrinking History:OnFreud and Fail-ure of Psychohistory,Oxford University Press,1982.
    [15]  Peter Gay:Freud for Historians,New York 1985,PP.18-19.
    [16]  Friedrich Nietzsche: Beyond Good and EVil,Part One,Aphor-ism 23.
    [18][19][20][21][22][23]  See Suzi Gablik:Progress in Art,NewYork,1976,P.43;P.43;PP.143-50;PP.45-46;PP.46-47.
    [24]  л¶ĿɫռͥǶаɫγĶԱȣ˹ıڻҲʵϰղ
Ҷ(Johannes Purkinje)ԭڻ谵Ĺ²̵ɫʱȲɫʸơˣճ֮ǰɫʾɫʡ
    [25]  See Julia Kristeva: Giotto's Joy, Galligram,ed. Norman Br-yson, Cambridge University Press,1988.
    [26]  See Rudolf Arnheim;TheArtistry of Psychotics,AmericanScientist, January-February 1986,P.51.
    [27]  See Jackson Pollock,New York,1960,P.72,P.91,PP.139-40.
    [28] See William Rubin: Pollock as Jungian Illustrator:The Lim-its of Psychological Criticism,Art in America,November 197
9.
    [29]  See M.Merleau-porty: Sense and Nonsense.Northwestern Un-iversity Press,1964,P.55.
    [32]  Ʃ磬ұվŵ˸ŮĳӾϢҵָŹŵͬ飬ĿǶŮ˵ģһѯ
˼ʲôʲô
    [33]  See Norman Bryson (ed) Calligram:Essays in NewArt Historyfrom France,Cambridge University Press,1988,Preface.
    [34]  See Mieke Bal and N.Bryson:Semiotics and Art History,Art Bulletin,1991,No.2.
    [35]  See Keva Wolf,Francis A. Dowley, Mieke Bal and N.Bryson:Some Thoughtson Semiosics and Art HistoryArt Bulletin.No.3.
1992.
    [36]  See Donald Kuspit: TraditionalArt HistorysComplaintsAg-ainst the Linguistic Analysis of Visual Art,The Journal of A
estheti-cs and Art Criticism,1987,No.3.
    [37]  ΤտˣָĴճ1987꣬11ҳ
    [38]  ڡʷУ˺ܶ಻ͬר
    [39]  Otto Kurz: Varnishes, Tinted Varnishes,and Patina,Burlington Magzine,104(1962),p.58.
    [40]  E.H.Gombrich:Dark Varnishes:Variations on a Theme from Pl-iny,Burlington Magzine,104(1962),p.54.
    [41]  See David Carrier:Principles of Art History Writing,PartOne,Pennsylvania State University press,1991.
    [42]  Mark Roskill:What Is ArtHistory,the Universityof Mass-achusetts press,1988,P.181.
    
    
    
 
