 ׺ 2-812
ԭĳڴѧѧư
ԭںš200101
ԭҳš7379
  šJ1
  
ӡںš200106
    йȱʲô
Ӣı⡿The Three-fold Inadequacies of Contemporary China's Literary and Art CriticismWANG Xiao-hua(Teachers College,Shen
zhen Univ.,Shenzhen 518060,P.R.China)
    
߼顿(1962-)УˣڴѧڣʿϷ硢ĻѧоڴѧʦѧԺ㶫ڡ518060
ҪͨйԺִԵƬ⡢Ծ۵ƫϵԽӱܣָ3Ƿȱ
ҰԵĲȱֻнԭԵϵйߵľ
ӢժҪBy analyzing contemporary literary and art critics' one-sided misunderstanding of post-modernism,their preference
 for empirisist liberalism and their evasion of building a system,the present author points out their three inadequacies,i.e.
,the confinement of their literary vision,the fragmentariness of their critical rationality and the frailty of the crititical
 ontology.Only by setting up an original system,can a new elevation of the contemporary Chinese literary and art criticism be
 really attained.
  ʡ/й/Ұ///literary criticism/contemparary Chinese literary and
 art criticism/literary vision/literary rationality;literary ontology/structuralism
    
    ͼţI206.7ױʶ룺A±ţ1000-260X(2001)01-0073-07
    ǵйĻԾ͸ӰĲ֡Ȼֱоѧ书ȴڷ˼Уܽմ
ͬʱ˼ɡ⴫ͳʶ̬µľıйĻ֮δҪʹΪйصĻ
оҪ壬͸Ҫ侲ӵйʵˮ׼Ķֹ֮Ĺϵ
߷ʱ֮СȱйʹǳصģҲζضĳǷȱĴ3ӽ̽Ѱй
ǷȱԴ˱ڴ
    һԺִԵƬҰ
    ִִת20淽ʽĸӭӡ⡢ﻮڵеĺִǵ˵ĵʹ
ѧ硢ѧ硢ѧ罫ִԼҰ֮˸мۣйĺִĻп
Ե塣ȻӭӺִԵĹУйֳ޷ͬԷ㯡ԥ䣺ִԺ
ִĻԣҵ߼ִڵıΡһδͬӸ˵
˵壬˵ãȻӭӱӭɥʧԼΪʲôйڽִʱƲ
ԭǣйں̶ܴϻִڻɵҰִԵģȻպִԵıʡ£
߶ںִԵ˵ͻֱתΪйҶԺִԵ˵ʹִִ֮ԣִ
ִԣ߼ϾʹԵĴ
    ִԾЩԽ˾йҵҰΪִԺĵ˱ĳԽ˵ִԵĺ
Ϊĵ壬ôִԾǶĳԽй֪ʶģִ;Уڷ
˵ĿϲУѧѧйʮе⣩Ȼ˱嵱⹹ͳĻʶ̬Ĺϵں
ִеĳԽ˱˵ȻİĵġĶ˵ִıʣΪִ
ִһֳԽԽ˱ĺ塣й֪ʶ֪ĺִߣº͸£Ҫ
˹ϵġȻǲȫģ岻Ƕ˶ԵģǶȻԵģԣ
ȻϵѳΪߵԵĺִߵĳԽĿꡣִ˶չΪ
άȣ(1)ˣϵĲϣΪġȨ֮Ӧͬһԡ塢䣯Ⱥڵ
ַ֮ԶԪġ廯ġƽȵ߼ִ巴£Ϊ趨뱻ߵĲƽȹϵ
ƽ滯Ƭɢļʽ(2)ȻĲϣ
塢ĶַƵ壬ӦΪڵػߣá˺ֵϵ桰ִ˵
ͳռѶ˵ĸرػ̬ĿΪһ塱[1]ԣΪִĺִ׷Ĺػػ
̬ػػͳһȻйΪĵҰָȫؽʾ˺ִԵĺִ˶
δйע⣬й̸ִʱظƽģʽƬɢʣĹػ̬
ػΪһֲʱ˵а黳
    ػ̬ػػʶȱйҰֻͣ˶Ȼ
ϡʹйһѾػ̬ػػʶıӶһմȱػ̬
ػػδҪҸн80Ϸ硶Ұˡоͱֳ˶Ĺػھܵע
ˣ˵˺ҰˡҰҰֲΪ֮ĸȻ磬ԣⲿƷѾԽ˴ͳĹػ
Ұ׷Ĺػػ̬ػػͳһǸнԽй֮ǺмͬʱĹ
ʶ̬ػʶˣҰˡй̬Ϸ硣ҲнԺϸ°ǺߣƷ
ֳػʶ̬ػʶػʶںǽܳһ޶ġźǣнĶ֮й
ԵģҰˡʱע۽ĸṹһϷʽ̨ʱյ
ɱ任е̬ʶҰҲڶıͳ¿ȵݵϣĶڵӰ̺
ʶδʶչʾضĻеڡ塱ʱѾʹǵˡˡ̬ˣǡ
ˡıͳ¿ľ޲ǶԶĻƬչʾֻĻҰȱ̬Ұδܽ˷ŵ̬
Ұȥ֡ʹǵĵӰʵѾӰȷ̬塱ʱӰעΪ
е̬壨类йսųЦĺӰƬֲƬƻƬʽ˶ˡ̬ϵͳˡ
˵Ĺע뾯ıͳ¿ȶйӰ˵Ƿȱ缸δἰ˵Ұ
޷ҰȻҲ޷ߡɴ˶ʧְְҲ⡣
    йΪƫǣѧѧ˼Ǿ˽Եĸ壬־ס𼶵ļ԰ϵͳУǡĻˡ
ˡ̬ˡˣԽ˷ĻﾳȥۺоȻˡ˱޶˼ȲҲʹ
йȻѧĻϣҲȨҪѧҰĻ磬絽̬ϵͳ̬ϵ塣
ֻоҰչй㹻ߵĸ߶Ͻй˸˵ǣ¾֮ѾȻʼ
ڽչҰĺִתۣ³Ԫֳﻮ̬ѧͼ̬ϵͳΪ廰ռϵ[2]й
Ҫ־
    Ծ۵ƫԵĲȱ
    岰й𽥳ΪйĻڹɣ20йнԵĻ˶2080Ժй֪
ʶ罥ɳĺǡ϶˵λϵȨѡԼҪΪ໥˴˶
ԼΪ˸˵⣬ûʲôɡ[3]ʥͼΪйͳĻ˵ǳ׵Ľ
أڵйĻǾԵĽͨͺⱻʥ˵ľͼ壬ȷ
λ͸ɵԣй֪ʶضʷﾳеĻԣҲڵй70
ĩ㿪ʼԷԾе壬Ӷʫı绤Ҹ廯дʽޣɺͽŶй
Ϊע䰮Ĵڡ
    Ȼںӵľϵ̽ơԼȨĸӹϵйǿ
ģǶΪĿϷ˼ȱ˼洫ͳй֪ʶӸеͷۡĶԣйʵ
ϲȡ˱Ѿ׵ĲԣԻر壨ڡ˼Ϊе壬Ӣʽľ۵塣عһ
70ĩǾͻִᷢҶŨľζ澭ϵ
ܸ˵֮š֮֡еģƵģ֮񡣶ھ۵ĲµԾ
ϵ֮ǰʮЧĲԣҵģҵڱҵĵ¾ȥ֤ʵ֤αĳ⡢ԭ򡢡塱
ǶҵĸԵֱӿ϶ҵľҵĸԺҵɣνܸҴϵ֮Уõģ
սʵΪҵĸоҵĵ¾ΪԳ߶ҶԵС۵йضĻﾳоʵ
ĽŹܡ˴ʷĿ۵ƷԭΪű̵֮ʵǽһʵΪ屾λ⴫ͳʶ̬ͬʱ
Ϊ崴졢顢ṩ˼򵥶ʵõĲԡֶԸԾƳᴩڴҶ״̬ѧдʵѧѧ
ҵġ˽˻дСѡʵϱͳ͵ﾳȶ֧ţ(1)йԺʿʼߵı
۵ĵ·϶˼·׼СƳ羭˼ҵĺΪй(2)Ȱ
ˡͼʱ¸߼ʶ̬еľִйӵ龳д
Ϊˣ۵ųΪйй֪ʶδ
    Ȼ۵ڵйĻĽл壬йĲȱȴڶƳ͹Գپ
¾ޣ(1)ܾ˵֮ζѧаȱԶͼ飬Ļ壻(2)۽鵱ռ
ʵڣΪе⡢ֻۡ뾭ϵ壬˸徭ྭԣԭĳʵֻʹĻ
ƶ״̬־תΪйľޣй׷澭۵֮ʱ˻δʶ
һԴȡŷ޴½塢Եѿʽ˼Ϊĵ塢ǿΪԼ
Լһ֧ԽΪĿȱ顣Ӧ
˶Ը徭ͼ徭ļֵϵԽ롢Ľܳ⡰ߡӢ塱ʹռֵԶ
ĿꡱȾгԽķ룬תͬմеģʽƽΰ¡Ƭ̻¶Ⱦǵ
Եȱ˵ԵĲȱеΪԾġ¾֮ܳѿġ˼ʵ
˼롰ҵĵ¾֮һŹĸ壬뾭ۺɽȫԡȲ
ľּ֮˼Ȩԡ˼ҪڽĵλͬʱʹΪߣӵѿۡ
˼ڡĹпԿһжǿɻɵģΩڻɲɻɣ˼ԣֻС˼ǲɻɵģȻ˼
ǲɻɵģôԭϵ۵ĳֻǡ˼˼ǹߡǿΪԼй
й˶Ҫ壬Ϊֻо˲ĸ塣άȨ۵ĺġȨеġ
ֻ֮˼ĲʸҪΪߣͲܾܳ⾭֮ĴڣҪɸ塢ѧ˵ĻγԼ塢
ѧ˵һѧôֻǸߺߣҡԼ
߶ѧĸ塣ڸԾĸ֮䣬ŴĶԻԻɵıϼɵԼɵļǡ
ǡ񹲳ڶĸƽȶԻϵĹ¡֡йİʧ״̬
ȱĽͱ˷Ƿȱķ֮һǽ۵塣˵۵ͨ׶ͼ
жй֪ʶ֮·ô۵Ľʹ֮Ϊ߲εߡ۵
۵Ϊһ壬йͻ˷ԵĲȱ״̬ľ
    ϵԽӱ
    ߾ڸġͰͺսġ˼Үʫѧ⡷ԭСͨµϵ
ԼصҰΰҵĹͬУǶصķϵͳתΪǵӽ磬ڴӽж
йա͡߾д͵ʡ
    Ȼ20йδﵽ־硣ǿгһ˼Һҵ֣ȴ˵20йĻԼԭԵϵ
ʹʮءλʶͽĻʦҲԭԲǷȱԭԵȱʹ20й
ʼ޷Խع鴫ͳƶ״̬ڴͳϵȫԵִ˶Ѳйҵľ͹
ˣתִת͵ԶԶڸ˻ع鴫ͳĺΪйֵȡֳ20
80Ѹûйڵ磬ʹڵصĺΪĺﻯνĺֳﾳԴȫγɡӦ
˵20ϰҶʮءĻʦڴԼϵ壨Ȼң
˼ǵʱҪԴô20°ҶйĻֻдʵ⣨硰ɵ
͡Ըۡȣ󲿷ǰֻĳΪ١20°ҶйΪԾ20䣬
Ľֳֳǰǿ̬ƣ80ٸԸۡһȱֳĽģ90Ὠ
λڶԺֳﾳİȲʺ֮ۡйѾֳʵʵڵġѧΪ壬ѧΪ
״̬ĳЩΪ۵Ĺߡŵ˵пɥʧĵز
    ˵ǰʱйȱԭԵϵعĻ̬ĶӣôĻ̬ѴиƵ80-90ڣ
ֻ˵ʧְؽȱĺʹУӱԺΪϵԽ
ƶ֧ŴΪ(1)ڸĸǰйʶ̬ķĸǰйʶ̬ʷۡ
ʷۡʷĿΪںˣγһȫʽĽϵͬʱڱʷɺʷĿ涨ı򣬴˽ϵ
Ļ廯ĹܵȫԵľܳ⣬й֪ʶҲڶĻʹز˾ܳж־ܳȴΪ
κϵԽľܳⲢʹй֪ʶäĿ׷⹹壻(2)ִ崫йԺ䷴ϵ⹹ƬŶܳ⹹
һĻϵ֧ԮΪй֪ʶֱ׳ؾܳκϵԽĽڣ·ΩˣǸʱĵĺִˡȻ
Ļϣ(1)ɸĸǰʶ̬ĵʷۡʷۡʷĿϵʵҲǴģǰĻ
ҲŷĻ룩⹹֮÷µĿŵϵϵ۶Կϵ򣬽⹹ڳɹؽ˽⹹
֮ʱɥʧκ̬ľ԰(2)ִķϵ⹹ĲĻոԺ̫ϵв
ڸʽķϵĻڳأҪ⹹ָйĻԡġûеԭԵϵĻ弫
ٽԵĽ⹹ֻʹ֮ԣйĻǽǽ⹹ȻйĻҪ
ϵԵĽΪʲôܶй֪ʶȻԸɾܳϵԽأԭǴй֪ʶȱϵԽ
еĽԸԼʧ֮ʱ㿪ʼԸֽӱϵԽйȻԿй֪ʶӵ˸ȱݣгԽ
ʶ̬˸ԭ֧ѡУڶؼģ(1)ĻʱڽԼȱ
ʿ¡ʫѧʽĴ߼ǧй֪ʶӵ߼ûʵߣ߼Ե۽
ճ̵ǡġʱڣġв100ʱ䣬ֳҺͲڴ߼ʶ̬أй֪ʶӴ
ݵؽϵԽʱʵٵÿйִ֪ʶӵ߼ȻԻʵԵߣ߼й֪ʶ
ӵļǷȱʵʵĽУй֪ʶӲڴһ򼸸ԭ۳ϵҪôԭʼ˼άԵķ෨
нԺۺһеƪܳǸϵǽеĶǮġ̸
¼ֳʽĽ޷ԭԵϵֻܳΪ֪ʶĳйݡ(2)ǽϵԽںռнеģִ
߼δֳֵɺ֪ʶϵԽıԸԴִɱǺĻ
ĻԻĲִϵʵʹãִȱ˴ͳԣڽṹϷ˸ĸɴγ
ȫµռ䡣˵ͳﲻʺϴ߼ô˽ṹִٴ⡣ԣִ
ʺԭԵϵִ֪ʶδִܽĿԿռֵسֳִڴ˴ͳԺȱ
ѧϷǵִϵԽµľԭȱִܣûϷ˵
ɵǳʱ޷һֺһԵı㺬ͱ߼۽
ָµԭԵϵԣִ֪ʶӦԺﻳʶӦκνӱԺΪϵԽ
    ԺΪϵȫܵģִѾͨͬԵתɽṹµ߼ĿԿռ䣬ǿ
ŵϵͳˣֻҪ֪ʶͨϷϷֺԭ壬ú֡ʡӰ΢
ı۹ϵµԵ壬ôԭԵִϵһܹɣ彫ǿ[4]Ҫ
ҲҪΪߡߡߣҪΪҡͨµϵú﷢⣬Ļδ͵Ľ򣬲
Լصķ֡ɴ˹ҵߣΪĻĹʥˣĪɡ
    ʾĵ3ǷȱԴִĻԭԵĲ㣬ЩǷȱֻںԭԵϵʱ
ԽֽĳɹִִˣˣǵййĻΨһ
ϣִ֪ʶδִΪϵԽԺﷸְҪͨϵĽΪԼִ
ϣɲ׳
    ոڣ2000-12-04
οס
    [1]ңִ[M]磬199822-23
    Griffin,D.R.Spirituality and Society:Postmodern Visions[M].Beijing:Central Edition and Translation Press,1998.22-23.(in C
hinese translation).
    [2]˼̬ѧִǰհ[N]ձ2000-04-25
    WANG Ke-jian.Eco-Literature-and-Art Studies:Contemporaryiness and Foresight[N].Literature and Art Daily,2000-04-25.(in Ch
inese).
    [3]ᡤ¡[M]йѧ磬199711
    Jasay,A.D.The Restatement of Liberalism[M].Beijing:China Social Sciences Academy Publishing House,1997.11.(in Chinese tra
nslation).
    [4]ִȱϷ[J]̽1998,(5)
    WANG Xiao-hua.Modern Chinese Lacking in Deep-structure Linguistic Games[J].Academic Explorafion and Contention,1998,(5).(
in Chinese).
 
