 ׺ 3-142
ԭĳຣʦѧѧ
ԭ
ԭںš200101
ԭҳš8186
  šJ1
  
ӡںš200107
    ԴϷ˵
Ӣı⡿An Analysis of the Assumption that Art Originates from PlayGAO Yu(College of Humanities of Zhejiang Normal Univer
sity Hangzhou 321004,China)
    
߼顿(1964- )УˣʦѧԺڶʿ㽭ʦѧԺʦ㽭ʦѧѧԺ㽭ݡ
321004
Ҫ¹Ϸɱ۵춨ԴϷ˵ۻϯϷۼԼȥǶϷ˵
񶨲ûлϷ˵ںˡǱϷ˵огɹȻûн⡣Ϸ˵Կ˷ѡ
ӢժҪKant's free essentialism about art and play formed the theoretical basis of the blay assumption that art originat
es from play. Schiller put forward play assumption originally but it was a very simple theory and our negation towards play a
ssumption in the past didn't shot its nudeus. Zhu Guang-qian's research about play assumption, although it was fruitful, didn
't solved the radical problem. Play assumption has its own incredible difficulty.
  ʡϷ˵/Դ/Play assumption/the origin of art/suspicion
    
    ͼţI022ױʶA±ţ1000-5102(2001)01-0081-06
    Դҵһ۵ǣԴıΪǰᣬжٹĶ壬жٹԴѧ˵
Ϸ˵ԴڡΪɻϷʡһĻԡԣϷ˵Ȼϯģۻȴڿ

    ڰֹսбȽϵʱ漰Ϸģ˵бֹգɵģֹҲԽ
ǰ·һϷǱһ飬ﵽһ㣬ǷĿģֹȴһͶǱ
Ͳ죨ʹࣩһ飬ֻͨЧ籨꣩ЩǱǿȵġ[1]ڿ¿ı
ĻϷıҲɵĻˣڱͨģΪˣԿ¡ʫɡϷֺ͡
ɫνоϷ[2]ϷΪɻǴģԸ˴ָоϵ㣺з·˵
õչһָоҲ泩򽡿ĸоָоڱ仯ϷеԴٳɽĸ
[3]
    оϷ⣬Ϊ˵ɱʲŰϷбȽϵġ˿ûԴϷ˼ʹ
ԺϷ˵ӰȻܴΪϷ˵ĸɾϷڱ϶ɵһ۵㡣
    ԴϷ˵ǵ¹ҡѧϯգϯġġԿ
µԭΪݡ[4]ԣϯġϷ˵ʵǶԿµɱԴľ
    ϯΪϣˣִǷѵģѵֳ嶯Գ嶯ʳ嶯Գ嶯ʽ嶯Գ嶯
ĶҪռУҪܣƣǱģ״̬ȻˡԳ嶯ĶҪͷ
˼־֧䣬ģ״Եˡֳ嶯Զǿԣֱӽϡʹֳ嶯Խϣ˴
Ȼˣмһ䵱ʹ˽ԵĽʦ[5]ıʾ
ϷԣΪϷ˾ľãԡḡʹҰǵųȥӶʹҲܹ֪ذһд
ǵжУմǵȥˡӶʹ˱øСΰ;ḻ۵ʱһʵĶʧȥ
ԣΪСˣоʱһбȻĶԣΪˡ˵һ״̬У
ϷֻϷʹ˳Ϊȫˣʹ˵˫һӷӳһΪϷ嶯ߵ·ȥѰ
룬Ǿġ˵ףֻеȫϵˣϷֻеϷʱȫˡ[6]
    Ϸķ¶λãȻȻԶҲǵ󣬲ĶƲһ
ɵ΢⣬ʨڲΪȣûбҰսʱŲõľҪԼһ׳ĺ쳹ɳĮ
ĿУʢľܡ̫·ȥԵ֣öҲ϶
ĺ޿ɷϣЩɣǰɣǰĳضġĳڵҪɡ
ƶȱڹƶķḻ˵ʣڴ̼жϷһ仰Ϸھʣ
ûȻľҲϷϯճ֮ΪϷ͡˶Ϸ
    ˵ҲԼ˶ϷϷ󲻷ϵֻΪԺͲĿ֡Ϸ
ʽĸԤ˵ĶȵһʽʱԵϷշԾϷˡǣϷ
ϷԼϷӵͼ׶ε߼׶Ȼһչ̣Ϸ嶯̽мϲΪԳ嶯صϰ
ԺʹҰ󲻶ϵؽиԤʽⲿͨ˵סͥþߡװ˽ӽʱʽҲڿʼռ˱
ֻǸı˵Ҳı˵ġΪȡֶûйԾ赸ûһʽƱгΪ
ָֻܵҵһչʼ˽ģתΪ[7]
    ϯյġϷ˵ȻǼԼģûκǲɿʵ֤ϣֻϵģҲ֡
    Ӣѧ˹ڡѧԭڶھƪھ¡СУϯյľʣ˵µķӲµȶ
һʵάְ档µȶֻ֪ڶķչĽϸ߽׶ϣͲˡ
ﲻһûڽϸߵӪлһЩҪ·ʣԵϷʱǷҪ
ϷһַȻϰϷҪǣάĻûֱӵİϷߵĻ׷һ
ĹĿġͬһè׷ذϹŵŵʱ򣬳ϷĿ֮⣬ʲôҲò
    Ҫ˵ǣ˹ġϷ˵߼ֱӵϾкŵļ򵥽ܣԲۡӡȻ
ϷõٵϰϷ߸Լ壬õġ[8]˹Ϸϰʡ
ϣ³˹ġϰ˵˹۵ľ
    ¹ѧҹ³˹ȽϵͳоϷ⣬ڡϷ͡ϷרУͬ˹ۣϯ
ա˹ۣݸ³˹ϷǹʣıֵȫΪʵ֤СϷֱƣ
ǾݵϢϷһϢʹǵʣֻǸպʹǿ԰ϷָͯҲ
磬ǼʹʱϷǳƣֻҪһʼϷǾƣ͡Ϣ೤ʱ䣬Ҳʣ
ʣϷıҪֻǶ[9]
    ³˹ԸġȻϰ˵ΪϷĿĵĻʵ׼ϷĿľҪѹҪõĻ
Ԥϰ죬Ϸʽ涯졣СèϷֽţϰŮľżϰĸסϷѧϰ
ϷҲѧϰڡϷǸһձıܶĳļԤϰ[10]
    ڹ³˹Ϸ˵֪Ĵ¾Щ֪Ƿ۹Ϸ֮Ĺϵ³˹ɢ˵
ϷϷǷ𣿶ͯϷĳ˵Ϸʲôϵö֪
    Ϸ˵˱Ƚ϶࣬иͿ¡ʸĹ۵Դо˵ֵӵġ˵ʵʻ
֮ģϷĹʽϷĲ֮ͬΪʵʻһ׷һĿģϷʵʻȴ
ΪҲУֻǽעػıע޹ؽҪĿġҪһĿȻʵʻϷ
Ĺϵǿһּ򵥵ķһæֱʾʵʻʾϷԲȦʾ[11]
    ¡ʸΪǻþϷһʽϷŻþĳɷ֣ϷͬġΪÿһ
Ϸĳʽ֮Ӧ磬Ϸ֣֮ӾϷ֮װΣ˶Ϸ֮赸ϷϷ֮Ϸ磻ͼ
Ϸ֮滭żϷ֮ܣϷ֮뽨µϷ֮ʷʫȵȡ[12]
    ⣬˹кŵϷҲ˹˵ѧ۳׷ٵͯϷȥԽֻ
ĿҪձȥҵͼ͵ķǳʹҵ¼ĸԴҪӸձлȡ
С[13]Ϸ˱Ƚϣָǵͬ벻ͬûԴϵóʲôĽۡܵĽǡ
ԴͷȡӪϷҲӦԴͷ֮һ
    кŵûооϷԼϷ֮ĹϵЪ˹³˹˵ϷͶĹ۵ʱ
ͶϷһ۵ġ֤߼кŵƺϷķֱӵãΪϷԴͶ
    ԴġϷ˵ȥַһֱȽ϶࣬Ҫ¼棺
    һʣ˵ܽΪʲôͶͯԼһᾫƣߵȥϷǹ³˹˹֮һ
    ڶʣ˵̫ͳǱ˵ʣ˵̾Ϳ԰׿ⲢΪΪ̫ͳһл
Ǿı֣ϷˣʵĹĪȻ[14]
    աϰ˵ʱھӦϷҰߡϿˣȻЩ
ȻҲϲֵϷһЩǶڸԼеע⡣[15]ҡĪԼڲǱȽϵ͵

    ģϷ˵ҲԵȱ㡣ͻΪƫڴѧѧϷ塣[16
]й۽˵ձĿ
    ǣΪЩԵľ۵˵ȷеǶûϷ˵ںˡϷ˵
˵ǿ½ϷڱͨһԼϯϷϷķ̡ϷԴģӦ
һ⡣
    ԣӽ˵оϷıԼӷѧоϷĹϵҪģǰ֤һĿ
оһܵľ棬Ǿ⡣
    ϷԼϷ֮ĹϵǱʮͽ˱Ƚоѧ1931꣩ʮ¡
ԴϷ̸͡1932꣩ĵھ¡߲ʧ֮ġϷоĽǣϷĸ
ҪƵ㣺һǶĿ͹ۻʵ֮硣ʱǶôģ£һҪմʵ
һҪʵǶ̬ȶǡšҵķֱʱȥġǶʵĿĵɻ
ɻҪƽ棬ѡޡޡҪûŵĿУŽʵĿơ[17]Ϸ
Ҫ㣺һԣϷȴԡϷûԣֻ˰͵󡮱֡
ԣҪһ󴫴ºϷƷƷҼȻҪƷ˼
ˣʹҲͬ͹֣㲻ܲоļɡ[18]ϷĹϵǱǣϷҪʵ
ĽзɻΪܻȤʹĿοǰԿ͹ۻΪ龳ν
֡ϷȱԣԣҪ񲻽ڡ֡ڡҪؼ룬ǰԭϷĺܴ
ĻĻȫԭֻҪбֱֻ֣ʽǿ˵嶯Ϸ嶯չģĻȴ
ϷĻ֮½һĹϷнɰȡҪɰ[19]
    ǱϷۣҵĿģ
    һǱ˵ġϷҪڶͯϷϷҪǴоͯԣɳϷʵ
ͯϷǣϷȻһԪиָϷͬϷǲͬģÿһϷķչ
̲ʾڵĶؽṹ
    жϷҰ˵ϷԭʼϷִͯϷȡԴо˵ЩϷȻǲͬġ
Ϸر˶ӡɵϷһ̶Ϸӳ˻ڶʱڵϷ״Ϸ൱ϯ˵ġϷ
˺ͶĹͬܡϷʿͨоִյóۡʣ˵͡ϰ˵ҪڶϷһ

    ԭʼ˵ȵϷԴомֵͶϷбȽϾͻϿԹճΪϷķ̡
ѰͯȥԶʧˡǲųִŲһ־ȵϷŴһתԿ
ŲϵĿͷǾζ˸ĻҺ鷳ԣҪõʲô϶ĽۣǼѵġҰ˵ϷϱȽ
֣ҲȽоǣѾϸ֤ģҰ˲ԭʼˣȻִԭʼϷҲΪ
ȵԭʼϷֻΪһֲο
    ִͯϷҰ˵ϷͬʡˣԴĽǶǱϷԼϷϵоǺ
޵ġ
    ڶǱڰϷбȽϵʱȻûרŶй淶ġָ˵ȴǷǳԵġ
ΪϷִбȽԱȷڱϾڶ̶ϾһԣԴо˵ǷǳҪģǱ
оҲһ̶ϴﵽĿģȻϷڱϾһԣʱȺϵô֮ԨԴϵ
Ҳǿܵģ֤˴ϷķѧǶȥоԴпԡ
    ǣӷѧǶ˵ִ϶ԴоȻи塣ִǴԭʼݱģԭʼִ
бʵԭʼִ߱ڰǵͣڲʱִ߱Ʒ
֮йԭʼ˵ڳ֮ΪԭʼĶǡǡϷԭʼϷ֮ĲԶԶС
ִϷ֮Ĳ𡭡ϷԭʼбȽϲо֮߼ϵԴоĹؼҪģǡ
ǡǱûȥġ
    ΪԭΪǱϷеıȽǼֲڵģȫģֻǰִĶͯϷ
ִ˱Ƚϣ˵ͬ㻹ǲͬ㣬һ޶ڵġ
    ģҲΪԭΪǱϷоǸгɹģн壬ԴϣûлҪ
ԲûϷԴ⡣ĿǣȻϷԴϷһܵļ衣Ҫ϶
ܷϾܵķϷӽĵطϷпɷݳܣٿݽĴεΣ
Ϸĵط[20]ڲϺͷƣֻǲֵشﵽĿ꣬ԴоؼġϷпݳ
ԼݽĴεΡ⣬ûоҲ޴оȻҲһЩĽ硰ĳξϷϷ֮оͺд
͵[21]ԼܵĽֻۣЩ⣬ûгֵʵ֤Ϻ֤
    ͱִϷоñȽӰǵ¹ѧҡѧ٤Ĭġ뷽˺ܶƪ
Ϸ⣬ΪϷһϷȻ˵ҪǣҪӿºϯʹ
õȥʾϷ˵ϷĳңڴˣǲŽϷɴ˳ǾͿ
ȥѰϷĹ涨ϷĶģϷһִﵽеıʹⲻϷ
ϷĿģʿ˵ɡšġҪǣϷͶһֶصʥ
[22]ϷϷߵұ֡ϷʵϾͱڱϣϷĴڷʽұ֣ұȻ
һд壬ϷĳֽܳϾұ֡Ϸġ塯ʵϲĿĵʵ֮У˵Ϸ
еΪʵϾһֱϷϷұ־Ϸͨζĳֶĳֶ·ﵽ
еұ֡Ϸʼһֱֻ˵ϷڱֻзϷ񡣡һ㿴Ϸû
Ϊĳ˶֣Ҳ˵ûָߣܾ䱾ϷǱֻϷϷбġ[23]
    ٤ĬĽѧܿµ˼Ӱ죬ʵڿµġıʼϷĻϷġµı
˵ϷǾжģشıʻϷıʣǸϷʵȥоϷɳ
Ϸǡǡı߼Ͼ˵ϷĽṹĽṹͬһģϷ򵥡廯Կ֮ȣ
٤Ĭ˵ġ֤˴ϷȥоԴĿԡ
    ٤ĬϷ۶ԴоĵطġתۡתָĳЩһΪ
һĶĶΪתɵĶͳĴڣִڣʱĴھͲٴˡ˵
תָ˵ϷسΪתֻͨתϷӮĹԣϷͱΪ봴ͬһ
ܱ⡣[24]
    ٤ĬġϷۡرҪǣ䱾ѶԵʣȻĶϸã弰߼Բ
ˣԲи͹ɣۣٹԺлһѧϰо
    ԴϷ˵ǵĿģ
    һ˵Ϸ˵кܼʵɡΪҪĻ֮һҲԴһȫĻ
ԴһĻԶŸֻУĻϷڽṹϻڸϹ
ϣϷž˵ƣʱǡǡȺ˳ˣͼпǴϷġǲܿ϶Դ
ϷĳЩĳЩԴϷȴǺѷϵġΪʲôڵر֣ϷнͣΪϷ
һҪ䡰ٶԡ
    Ϸ˵ĻأûʲôµĻ˵ǵҪһǶȵġ
    ڶΪԴϷ˵ͨģ٣ϷĽǶȥоԴʧΪһҪ;Ϸ˵
ΪֹнԵĳɹϯչϷϷתǱϷıȽԼ٤Ĭġתۡǣ
ΪЩɹǳġ򵥵ġûжϷоûֲָͬϷԼǶãûжϷ̵
˶ϷıʵĸǲȫġҲûжĹԼϷ׶ĹϵоǵоУΪ
ͳĸֵġԣϷʲôģһԵϷԵϷתģʲôģȵȣⶼ
ȱоˣĳ˵ΪֹĹϷ˵Ĺ۵㶼ֻǼ˵۵ģȱʵ֤Ҳǡǡʱң
ԶѧѧȱݺΪĲϱҪ֤ЩԶʵ֤Ϸ˵Զܵõо
    ոڣ2000-05-15
οס
    [1][2][3]Ǳѧʷ²[M]ѧ磬1979.
    [4][6][7]ϣϯգ[M]ѧ磬1985.
    [5]뱾[M]ѧ磬1985.
    [8][9]кŵûеַţ[M]顤֪꣬1964.
    [10][14][17][19][20]Ǳѧ[A]Ǳѧļһ[C]ϺϺճ磬1982.
    [11]Դ[M]ӡݣ1984.
    [12]ңԴ[M]йѧ磬1982.
    [13][15]˹ѧ[M]йѧ磬1987.
    [16]˸ǣǰʷǰо[M]ϣɽճ磬1987.
    [18][21]Ǳ̸[A]Ǳѧһ[C]ϺϺճ磬1982.
    [22][23][24]HG٤Ĭ뷽[M]磮1987.
 
