йѧ
CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE
1998 18 1 No.1 Vol.18 1998
Ƽڿ

ľֶΣ֤׺˰
ϡܡ(йѧоԺо,  100012)
ġժļǵǰĵȵ㻷⡣ȴӷþֶμǱ׳ŷŽ׺͹̼˰ķȽϡҹӦ徭ߵɽ顣
ؼʡ塡ֶΡ֤ס̼˰
Economic instruments for reducing greenhouse gases:tradable permit and carbon tax.Wang JinnanCao Dong(Chinese Research Academy of Environmental Sciences, Beijing 100012).China Environmental Science.1998,18(1):1620
AbstractReducing greenhouse gases (GHGs) is a hot point involved in global environmental issues . On the base of comparing the advantages with the disadvantages of economic instruments for reducing GHGs,this paper reviews deeply on these two economic instruments, tradable permit and carbon tax . Finally,it puts forward some policy suggestions for responding these internationally economic incentives for reducing GHGs.
Key words:reducing greenhouse gaseseconomic instrumentstradable permitcarbon tax
1992ԼԻ顱ڼ䣬Լ155ǩˡ仯ܹԼһԼǩԼʽͬȡ(GHG)ŷŵжǣԼûָӦȡִʩʵĿꡣΪˣһЩ֯ϹСú뷢չ̫֯֯1)͹Ѿɼ߷ֶΡǵֶУעĿǹ̼˰ŷֶ֤Ρ
1ֶεǱ
ͳϣ׼ֶһֱǽҪֶΡǣȫΧGHGķ׼ƶʵʩж༼ϰڹʲϾмĲԡ뷨׼ֶȽϣгķܸʺڽгЧӦĻ⡣
һ˵ЧۻߵΨһ׼ôгֶΣҪڷ׼ֶΡֶ֮͵ķôﵽȾˮƽΪŷˮƽṩһĲ̼ͼ¼ͬʱֶλܹʽ룬Ϊרʽŷֶķ÷䲻ƽ⡣ͨͬŷ߻֮Ⱦ߼òԽ󣬾ֶεľЧԽߡOECD2оþֶΪGHGɲ֣ȡüЧʸĽ롰һСŷҪȣʹȫĺ۾÷ôԼ50
þֶ߼GHGЧʣǣгʵ׼ȷԤ⣬ԣֶʵGHGĿȷԣҪСڷ׼ֶΡ⣬ֶγԲͬķʽӰŲͬľòţӶһǷƽ⡣ԣڷ׼ֶεĻʹþֶΡ
2ŷ֤ƶ
֤Դ90ƼƻӦ֤ƶȼGHGҪһضԭȷŷߵGHGŷȻ䷢֤һ˹֤гУЩGHGøߵŷ߿Щõ͵ŷ߹ŷ֤ܵGHGŷ򱣳ֲ䡣ƶڹʷΧǿеĻôGHGʵϾͳһֹóײƷó׵ڸGHGĳɱȽơ
2.1г͹г
νгָȫΧڣݹʹϵķԭӦŷ֤Ȼ֤֮סгǸڻùʷŷٰѸŷŷ֤ʽڵŷߣ֤ŷڹڽнסгģʽԣһЩרңDudekTietenberg3ͬùгһЩרңGrubbSebenius4ͬһгǣгȫģгΪгĳΣGHGгĲɷָɲ֡ҪGHGsŷ֤гôGHGĹŷ֤йعЭһɲ֡
2.2ͨѡ
ѧоӰů岻ȼŷŵCO2һCH4NOxȡGHGԴͻ㲻ԴҵͨȲţһũҵɭֺͺȡCO2ЧӦеĹ׽ϴ󣬵ֻѡCO2Ϊ֤׵ͨȻǲġԽͨĲͬѡ񣬽ڷҺͷչйҲľò졣
ǵŷݵĿɵԺŷż⼼⣬ѡCO2ΪһͳһĽͨǿеġ£ͨġȫůǱܡϵɱ׼CO2Ϊ߶ԸĴ̼ȣҪڽгʱͰGHGȥ
2.3ʼŷȨ
ȫΧʵʩGHGŷ֤ףôĳʼŷȨʵϾǹGHGƲȨṹȷ乫ƽԽֱӰ쵽ᾭøˮƽı仯ʼŷȨ˵ʵʩ֤⡣ĿǰķԭҪ3ԭ򡣵1ǰ˿ڷ䡣ԭͬȻ뷢չȨһԭ2ԭǰʷη䣬ζڹȥGHGŷĹӦóеҪΣ3ǡ̳游ʽԭ򣬼ά״ŷȨеŷߡԭʵǡ˭ŷŶ˭һֲƽķ䡣ΧЩԭۣʵǷҺͷչйҹڼGHGĳͻ͵͡ΪˣһЩרңGrubbSebenius4˻ԭġϡԭ򣬼ְ˿ڷ䣬ְʷη䡣
2.4ŷŽ׵ʵʩල
ŷŽ׵ʵʩලڲõгģʽõǹгôһϵŷ֤׵Ĺ֯ǱҪģң֯мලǷŷ޶ЩΥŷ޶ĹҽСƲáȨǣҪֹЩƲá淢չйҵĻȨ
áϡгггϣһҼ͹ڲԽ֤ףһ棬Ϊ˽ͽ׳ɱҲ԰ѹгֳɿɸμгǣͬ漰ලƲ⡣
3̼˰
ν̼˰ʵϾǸݻʯȼе̼ŷŶ̼յһֲƷ˰˰ȷĻô̼˰һֱʹGHGŷⲿڲЧֶΡ˰߱ȽʺڽԻ⣨ȫůԣ̼˰ΪһֶΣҪ֤׸ױܡ
3.1̼˰ľ
Ŀǰ̼˰ѾһЩաЩҰ󡢷䡣̼˰˰ʼ1ЩҵֻŲ̼˰ž㹻Ĵ̼Чŷ塲5ǶԴ̼˰/Դ˰2000ѳԴ˰ߵÿͰ10Ԫ̼˰Ϊ5Ԫۺ϶̼Ϊ80Ԫ/t̼
1ֹҵĶ̼˰˰ʣ1995*
Table 1CO2 tax rates in several developed countries(1995)

˰˰ʣԪ/t̼
Ų56.5
Ȼ56.09
ʯͲŵ49.2
24.6
ؿ21.2
ú27.0
̿20.5
48.0
1994Ȼ43.9
ʹҺʯĽͨ47.2
ʹҺʯƷ48.2
ȼ48.8
ȼ44.1
ú49.8
17.5
ҵ8.7
˰5.8
˰3.3

ע*ԴJ. Ph. Barde(1996)
3.2̼˰͹̼˰
̼˰ĹЭ̶ȼ䷢ӵĹʷϵ̼˰ߣ6ģʽ71ڳʵĵ˰2ڳʵľЭĹ˰3ڳʵĹ˰4ڴ̼ĵ˰5ڴ̼ľЭĹ˰6ڴ̼Ĺ˰˵˰һڲĻ⣬ģʽ̼˰Ҫɹ֮֯Э͹ȻĹ̼˰ֱеĲ˰ϵ͹ڿܵ£ЭĹ̼˰͹̼˰ԳΪЭһ֡ЭĹ̼˰õϵֺ֧ʵʩĿԴһЩֹ̼˰ڿԳＯʽΪĿģˣ˰ҲԵЩ
3.3̼˰
Ŀǰܹ̼˰һʵߣԴչѾܶࡣڽĳЭĿ£ɸƶӦ̼˰ߡеоͱŷҵʵӦã̼˰ʱӦص㿼˰Χ˰˰Լ˰ʵ⡣
˰Χ۵ĽǷвЧӦ壨CO2CFCȣӦ˰ǵЩGHGã̼˰ӦеGHG塣ԭϣǿԶÿһGHGȷһȫůǱܡȨأȻɶ̼ŷա
˰ȷ漰⣺1ǷҪŷԴ̼ŷԴ̼˰2ҪգĸգʵϣŷŲŴһЩȨƵĲţԴͨũҵһЩţڲƷ۸ܵƣˣԲƷġΡ̼˰һѰ̼˰Ĵ̼ȫתƵΡӶʧȥ̼˰Ĳִ̼ЧԴƷġΡߣ̼˰ôʹЩڹҵܵӰ졣ӡȾ߸ѡԭǶȳŷԴ̼˰ǺġǣΪϵ̶ֳ֧ȺͿʵʩһЩŷǿȴԴܼͲţԲȡһЩ򲹳ʩ
ԴƷԴĲŵ̼˰ԣ̼˰˰Ȼֻö̼̼Ϊʹ̼˰𵽴̼ãʽǶЩⲿԵֱŷߣݲⶨŷաȻһϵͳϢ͹̼˰ǼƵġˣ̼˰˰ֻܲȼϵԴ˰СڴҶȼ˰ȼ˰ֻҪȼ˰ȼ˰ջЩͿԿʼ̼˰
̼˰˰ʵƣ漰⣺һ˰ӦȷںˮƽϣǶԲͬšƷʹߵ˰ǷӦ죿ǰߣ̼˰˰Ӧõڱ߼ʧúͱ߼ŷŽͷáȻĿǰϢֺ֧ͼ˰ȷ̫ܡ˰ʽЧش̼ŷţܳ־ȶṩ룻֮˰ʾܲЧش̼ŷţȴܳ־ȶṩ롣һ˵ĳֹЭɹ̼˰Ը׵ƶ˰̼˰ߡǷ˰ʣһܸӵģʣ⡣Ӿ̬Ч׼һ˰ǺʵģǣӶ̬Чڸʹ߻ŵĲͬò̼ͬ˰˰ʡͨȿԶЩԺСĲýϸߵ˰ʣҲԶЩԽϴĲýϸߵ˰ʣǣյѡҪȡЩŵı̶Ⱥʵ̼˰Ĺʻ
4ҹӦ
ĿǰڼGHGĳսУʵʩGHGŷŽ׻̼˰ߡҹѾǡ仯ܹԼǩԼˣЩ߽ҪӦΪӦʱӦرעǶҹ۾õĲͬӰ졣
4.1߶Ǳ
GHGŷŽ׻̼˰עǽг̼˰Ȼг̼˰ںߣĿǰֻһָģʽڹʷΧڻûκξGHGŷŽֵǳʼŷȨķ䡣ҹGHGı߼ʳɱԵڷңԣֻҪݡ˿ڡ͡Ρԭŷŷ֤ײһȻҹGHGĺ۾÷ãң߻ΪҹȡGHGʱṩ̸г롣ʵʩ֤ףGHGŷŽ˫棬Ҽŷúͽ׷öǡʽġGHGŷŽ׵ǱҪн׷øߡгලԼһȨάȡ
Զԣ̼˰ʵʩĿɲԽϺãһЩȡһЩ顣̼˰ͨ˰⸺Ӷ⵽ҵ;òŵķԣǣ̼˰߾вص㣬ԶԹһûһļ򲹳ʩô̼˰ЩԴܼͲŲĲӰ죬ʹЩڹóʧȥΪ˱йؾòŵĹʾֻڰѲгԴܼ͹ҵΪʵʼʱŻῼǸ˰ʵ̼˰ߡ
ǵGHGŷŽ׺̼˰ߣҹGHGǱڵףˣڽϵͳо֮ǰƫѡԷӦʱڱ״̬
4.2GHGŷŽ׵Ӧ
ۻЧӦеԡԣŷ֤һʮʺϵߡԹᳫGHGŷŽƶȣҹӦֺע⣺1ʼŷȨ밴˿ڡ͡ʷΡԭ䣻2GHGŷúȾЭͬЧӦ3涨δŷʱӦҹھGHGŷ󣻣4ŷŽڹгΧʽױ뾭׼5ֹڲŷȨܹ¢Ϲг6ʵʩල棬ֹһȨԷøҹľ÷չȨ
4.3̼˰ߵӦ
Ŀǰܹ־֮䣬һڲ̼˰ߣǣ̼˰Ϊʱ硣ԣֻ߹̼˰ĵ·ǰѾָ̼˰ҪӰӰԴܼ;òŵĹʾƶʵʩµóסŤӶԴܼ幤ҵķչΪˣ飺1ѡ̼˰ߣӦѡ˰ʵġԳＯʽΪĵ̼˰2̼˰ߵӦ˰ƣԴ˰ĸϣԹؼҵŵļͲʩ3ѡ̼͵Ĺ̼˰ôջӦѡԴƷġΡߣ4̼˰ȿ԰Ʒ˰ʽҲɰCO2ŷ˰ʽգߵĹԸЩ5Ϊ˼ؼҵŵľøݸŵԴ۸ԺԴЧˮƽѡ˰Ǻʵģ6԰̼˰Ϊ˰øʽרͶԴЧʡGHGŷŵԴ㹤Ŀֲ֣ԼйصĿѧоȣ7ںԶڵ̼˰ߣӦöԡСŷԴGHG˰ԷɢԴCO2ȼΪ8Ƿ޳뾭ЭĹ̼˰̼˰Ҫȡڹ̼˰ʽٷǷڷչйҵGHGš
4.4ǿߵоƶ
ΪGHGĴʩŷ֤׺̼˰оЧʣõƼ߷Ŀǰҹڸоڿհ״̬Ϊˣţ1֯йоרҳ仯ר飻2йع֯оϵ3оͬGHGŷȨͲ̼ͬ˰߶ҹĺ۾Ӱ죻4ƶGHGŷ֤ߺͽڵĹ̼˰ߣ5ڵڶֲ˰ĸڼ䣬̼˰ߣӹ졣
ο
1APEC, APEC Economic Outlook, 1996
2OECD,International Economic Instruments and Climate Change,Paris 1993
3Dudek J D and Tietenberg, T. Monitoring and Enforcing Greenhouse Gas Trading in OECD: Climate Change: Designing a Tradable Permit System. Paris 1992
4Grubb M J and Sebenius J K.Participation, Allocation and Adaptability in International Tradable Emission Permit System for GHGs Control in OECD Climate Change: Designing a Tradable Permit System. Paris 1992
5Delbeke Jos.Carbon Taxes: The European Community Proposal, in OECDThe Economics of Climate Change.Paris 1994
6Barde J Ph. Economic Instruments for Environmental Protection: Experience in OECD Countries. Prepared for the OECD/NEPA Workshop on the Use of Economic Instruments in the Environmental Policy in China.Beijing 1996
7Godard, Olivier.Several Possible Tax Regimes. in OECD: International Economic Instruments and Climate Change.Paris 1994
߼
ϡУ19637廪ѧϵ˶ʿѧλйѧоԺооԱҪ»áоĿǰֻмԮĿйշƶʵʩо͡йҵȾƾѧоԼ塱ؿ⡰21͵йоĽ40ƪר371סרСѧ**ߡг빤ҵȾΡ͡շѧ
ոڣ1997-01-10
