йѧ
CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE
1998 18 3 No.3 Vol.18 1998
Ƽڿ

еĲȷ*
֡Σϴѧоɳ 410082)
Gordon G.H.Huang(Faculty of Engineering, University of Regina, Canada s4s 0A2)
ġժ˻еĲȷķ༰Ӱ,˶ȷ4ַ, ݺֵģⷨ䷨Ͷطٲȷ;Ŀ滮ǲع鷨عר
ؼʡ ȷԡۡ
Research of the uncertainty in environmental risk assessment. Zeng Guangming, Zhong Zhenglin, Zeng Beiwei(Environmental Protection Research Institute, Hunan University, Changsha 410082) Gordon G.H.Huang(Faculty of Engineering, University of Regina, Canada s4s 0A2).China Environmental Science.1998,18(3):252255
AbstractIn this paper, the classification and impact factors of the uncertainty in the Environmental Risk Assessment (ERA) are introduced. Four methods for quantitative analysis of uncertainty, i.e. transfer function method, numerical value simulation method, confidence interval method and second order matrix method, are expounded. At last , the approaches for lessening uncertainty, i.e. multiple objective programming, nonparametric approach, regression analysis and expert opinion approach are put forward. 
Key words:uncertaintyrisk assessmentquantitative analysis
ǰ꣬һֱΪѧԺԺʿԺԺʿFrank Press 鲢ٳɵĹʼȻֺ10꣨19902000)岻󡣲Ԥԣڿʼ5ڣǽֻ۲ݣ֪ӦЩʲô5꣬ǽֻܽǰ5겻֪Щʲô1ʵˣڻշ, ܶ໷ѧۺʵȡ˳ɾ͡116 뻷ֺصоԴȱۺͷ⡲15ͨԻղȷĳ̽ͼⷽЩ
1ȷԷ༰Ӱ
1.1ȷԷ
ȷԡһΪ϶ԡȷ֪ԺͿɱԡȷԹ㷺شȻУͻ۶ԣȷԵıҲ൱ձġ磬ĳһĳŷˮǷᵼ¸úˮʳʱ,۹ͨһˮģԤ⣬ڲȷʵᷢ¼ʵϳǷᷢȴȻʵϣúˮʡˮԼϵڲͬļڶǱ仯ĻвȷԣӶˮҲǱ仯ĻвȷԡOve.Ditlevsen7ȷԷΪ3֣ȷԡΪͬԻֳһĲ죻ͳƲȷԡй۲⣬ֻܻ޵ԴΪȥıԱͳƵĲȷԣģͲȷԡڽģгҪиŻͳ󼰼裬ͿܻһЩӰأģͿܽԭ͵һͬģ;вȷԡ
Suter8еĲȷԷΪ࣬һǿýȷĲȷԡ磬ڻУĳһ¼ķ(жѧʵй©)ԣǿͨضķ(Fault Tree Analysis11Ԥ䷢ĸʼӰ̶ȡһ಻ȷʶľޣԷĳЩ󡢻Ͳ׼ȷڽмĳһжʵĶԶĽΣӰʱѡжʵ飬ʵƵ࣬ƵĹУʱ10ȫӣ100ȫӣȻΪжʶ彡Σı׼ֵ˵ʵУߣܵнΣӰȴࡣƵĹиһİȫӣȷе˵жڵķӦ彡Ӱ켰Ӱ̶ǲģҲ޷׼ȷؼڵһ಻ȷԣֿɽһΪࣺȻ籾еĲȷ;ڷշĹĲȷ(ģͲȷԡȷԵ)Ȼ仯ĲȷԡУģ͵Ĳȷְʽ󼰱߽òĲȷ; ȷ԰кƵĲȷԡ
ͳѧĽǶȷҲɷΪ֣Ȼе¡ڼĳһڣDOֵΪ70%֮úDOֵϿΪǳģھĳһμУDOֵһ꣬DO ֵ仯ĲȷԣҲͳƹɱһֲȷԼΪ1ĲһǱȻ¼Ϊ0¼һǲɷ¼;żȻԭĲȷԡ䱾ͳƹ֮⣬֮޷ͳƷֲг仯ɼĲȷ⣬ܻڼĹм߱ʵ鼼Լһϵڵ޷ͳƹأӶɼĲȷԡ
1.2ȷӰ
ȷԱһʮָӵȻӰҲʮָӡȷֺʶЩӰоȷĹؼͻ
Haimes,LeomEiselΪӰ첻ȷԵؿɷΪࡲ710۲ֵڲԼȻء÷չĸԶԲȷһӰ죻˿÷չˮ仯һɲȷԵҪԭBenjaminCornellӰ첻ȷԵԭΪ3ࡲ11Ȼ籾еĲȷԣͳĲȷԣΪڲƵޣⲻ˻ĲȷԣģĲȷԣѡѧģͿܽԭ͵һͬԴڲȷӰ졣
ֹܽ۵㣬ԽӰ벻ȷԵҪԭΪ3㡣
1.2.1Ĳȷԡ˿ڱǨ÷չĲȷԣʵֲ֤ȷĽһչӾ磬ڽеϿӶԳȺķֲֵǨԼ̬ϵͳӰ൱̶ϻһƬհףðӶδ̬ӰĲȷǲԶġ
1.2.2ȻĲȷԡˮġ¡ˮ򡢷١շȻĲȷԣرһЩȻֺ¼쫷硢ԼˮĲȷԡ
1.2.3ʶ͹ľԡʹöԷһЩһЩȷԺģԣ־Ծ¼棺ԸӵĻϵͳҪϵȱ˽; ģͲʵ; ۹һЩҪļ;ڲĻȡкͶδ֪ƵеĲȷԡ
֮۹еĲȷǿ͹۴ڵġ۹ڲȷ·ҲԶ׼ģĹؼȷȥʶȷʶȷԵĴڲֺͨʵ;Ӱ죬ͷеķնȡ
2ȷ
ĿǰȷԵĶٻ򻹲졣ͨйزȷоɹз͹ɣϵۣܽԲȷĶ
2.1ݺ
ۣɸʼĲȷԴСηĲȷҪ۸ǹķۡ
2.2ֵģⷨ
ĳЩӵģͣ䲻ȷԵԴǼѵģMonteCarlo11ȽϷشģеĲȷ⡣Barnth Ouseȡ15MonteCarloģ⼼оɵһֶƵ̬ϵͳеĲȷ⣬Ϻõؽһ̵ĲȷתΪĳЧӦĲȷ״̬ӶĳһжЧӦˮƽķտһֱӶԺԴƹ̲ĲȷԺȷ
2.3䷨
޵ĽǶȣͳƷֲۣоֵĲȷԡ
2.4׾ط 
Աǰ׾ȡ̩ռǰ1ǰ2һζ׾෽Ͷζ׾طĲȷԡڻģȾķֲf(x)ʾf(x)ԭĹϵдȾŨȵĸ׾-׾ءһ׾ؼ׾ء׾رʾŷȾһ׾رʾȾŨȷֲĵλã׾رʾȾŨȷֲķŨȷɢɢ̶ȣݶ׾ص̩ռչоȾŨȷֲĲȷԡ
ڷоУ۲һַȷԣĿĶڴӱʶҵЧ;ȡЧĴʩٺĿǰȻٲȷķͻвȷҪ4֡
2.4.1عӦûعЧеϣϲɵĲȷԡĿǰõķҪǲعģҪProbitģ͡Logitģ͡Weibullģ͵ȡ16
2.4.2ǲع鷨عУ(xy)ķֲδ֪ʱE(yx=x)һַʱE(yx=x)ֻһԵҪ󣬶ٶκѧʽֱӴʵͳȥо⣬ģͼʵشѡģ͵ĹɵĲȷԣӶʹ㡣ס2۹ۺˮʷģͱǲõķǲع鷽
2.4.3Ŀ滮ڻеĲȷöĿ滮ҪǽƷˮƽ벻ȷԸŻΪͬĿ꺯ɶĿ滮۽з⡣
2.4.4ר۵սԻ彡Ӱ죬ѧҺͶѧҾֲͬʱȻ෴ҪԭڻѧʹõǽƵȾģͣѧʹõǶѧģͣģͣǸеѧƱ֪ʶͬԼʹϵȻȣ˶۽ӰͬۺϿרҵڼڷ۹еĲȷԡ
3
ڿ͹ĸ, Լʶ͹ľ, ΪȷԵغ, ʵвġȷġ֮ȷձڵģֱӰ컷۽ĿɿԼڶ̶ǿɿġǿԲȷоʵӦϣڻ۹չ
ο
1David Alexander.Book reviews about natural hazards by bryant and environmental hazards:assessing risk and reducing disaster by Smith. Progress in Physical Geography. 1993, 17(4): 504506
2,׿.ƷںۺˮԤеӦ. , 1997,15(2): 4144
3,ƽ.оչ. ѧչ, 1996, 4(6): 1721
4,ƽ. ڻеӦ.ϴѧѧ, 1997, 24(1): 3338
5ͨ,ά. ֺĻԭ̽.ѧ, 1996, 17(5): 7678
6ǿ.Σۺ͹. йѧ, 1991,11(4): 279283
7ѧ. ˮģͣʿġ.人人ˮѧԺ1988
8Suter G W.Treatment of risk in environmental impact assessment. Environmental Management, 1987, 11(3): 295303
9.ѧƷ¶ĽΣ. ⻷ѧ,1990, 1(4): 812
10Yacov Y Haimes.Integrated risk and uncertainty assessment in water resources within a multiobjective.Journal of Hydrology, 1984, 68(2): 222234
11Benjamin J RCornell C A. Probability: Statistics and decision for civil engineers. New York : Mograw-Hill, 1970. 7092
12Ӣ,ܺ鷨.̬۷.йѧ, 1991, 11(6): 465468
13William D Rowe.Evaluation methods for environmental standards. Florida: CRC Press, 1983. 3033
14Morgan M G, Max Herion.Uncertainty in risk assessment. Environ. Sci.Technol., 1985, 19(8): 662667
15Barnthouse L W.User's manual for ecological risk assessment. New York: ORNL-6251 Press, 1986. 5769
16.жѧƷĽ۸.л̬, 1993, 6(4): 4347
߼ 
,1962 12ʿڡʿʦ κϴѧоκʡѧѧḱ³Ҫ»еۡ·¼¹оְȻѧ𼰹ʺĿڵ18 ⡣гɹʡƼȽ1ʡƼȽ2ר1,80ƪ
ո:1997-04-08
* Ȼѧ(49201015)ҽίѧعԱͻе˲Ż(97251206)Ŀ
