йѧ
CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE
1998 18 4 No.4 Vol.18 1998
Ƽڿ

ȡ﷨ӷˮñȽ
ԪΡ̡ޱࡡĸƽ(廪ѧѧϵ 100084)
ġժӼýǶȶȡ﷨ӷˮ˱ȽϡͶʼֵ봦ŨȵĹϵʽŨС265mg/Lʱȡ﷨洦ĲͬͶϴڲ𣻵Ũȴ265mg/Lʱ۴Ϊ٣ȡͶʼС﷨ͶʡڴϴŨȽϸߵķˮȡܻýϴľֵ(NPV)շʱӯƽŨΪ1000mg/LڴŨȣȡΪӯĿ
ؼʡȡ﷨ӷˮñȽ
A comparative study on technical economy for the treatment of wastewater containing phenol between complexation extraction process and biological process.Dai YouyuanSun WeiCai WeiYang YiyanQu Fuping(Department of Chemical Engineering, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084).China Environmental Science.1998,18(4):293297
AbstractIn this papera comparative study on the treatment of wastewater containing phenol is reported from a view point of technical economy between complexation extraction process and biological process. Some equations between investment or net present value(NPV) and water quantity and concentration are built. The results are as followswhen phenol concentration is less than 265mg/L, there is difference in investment between complexation extraction process and biological treatment process with different treatment quantity;when the concentration is larger than 265mg/L, no matter what the treatment quantity is, the investment of complexation extraction process is always less than that of biological treatment process. For the wastewater with great quantity and high concentration, a larger NPV will be obtained if complexation extraction process is used.The concentration for equilibrium of profit and loss is 1000mg/L with phenol recovery,while the concentration is larger than 1000mg/L, the complexation extraction process becomes a profit project.
Key words:complexation extraction processbiological treatment process, wastewater containing phenolcomparison of technical economy
ӷˮһȾϹ㡢Խϴؽ账Ĺҵˮ1ͳ﷨ںӷˮзҪãԴŨȿɶáͣʱ䳤ȥʵ͵ȱ㡣ȡһֻڿϷӦȡлķ뼼2÷ӦڹҵӷˮĴʵһȡʹҺзӺŷš3ΪӷˮĴµ;ͼӼýǶȣȡ﷨ӷˮбȽϣﵽΪ߷ѡṩֵ֧Ŀġ
1ȡӷˮ
廪ѧоİϼӦ豸ڵĳ׺ӷˮΪ䴦ӷˮĹͼ1ʾ

ͼ1ȡӷˮʾ
Fig.1Schematic diagram of complexation extraction 
process for wastewater containing phenol
2﷨ӷˮ
ԴͳĻ෨Ϊ﷨ĻˮŨȸﴦŨȡ4100mg/LʱóˮϡʹҪͼ2ʾ

ͼ2﷨ӷˮʾ
Fig.2Schematic diagram of biological treatment 
process for wastewater containing phenol
3ָ
ӷúЧǶȳ˶ͶʷЧ۷5Щֱڲͬ⡣ѡ˶ָ̬ꡪֵ(NPV)ָǽͬʱʽ뻻ͬһʱϵĵЧֵصǿΪͬıȽṩͬȿɱȵĻͶߺ;ʽʱֵýʽ߾ЧҪ塣NPV㹫ʽ£

ʽУnΪĿ輰ޣiΪʣtΪݣCI-COΪt귢ľֽCIΪCOΪ
4㷽
ԻĿص㣬ڼֽʱҪ˷ͶʺзáȡͶʣҪȡϵķúáߡǱȷãзҪܼдʧ˹ѵɣ㷽μס6﷨ͶʣҪ˳ءءءŨءˮ豸ˮááķ豸ķãзҪ˶˹ѵȣ㷽μס7
5ֵļ(NPV)
ȡ﷨ֱʽ(1)м㣬nȡ10꣬iȡ12%ȡڲշʱCI Ϊ0շʱΪӻռֵCOڵ0꼴ΪͶʣ110Ϊзã﷨CI ʼΪ0
6
6.1Ũȶȡ﷨ͶӰȽ
Ũȶȡ﷨ͶʵӰֱͼ3ͼ4ʾ

ͼ3ȡͶ洦Ũȱ仯
Fig.3Investment vs quantity and concentration 
for complexation extraction process 

ͼ4﷨Ͷ洦Ũȱ仯
Fig.4Investment vs quantity and concentration
for biological treatment process 
ͼ3ͼ4ַ֪Ͷʶ洦ŨȵȡͶܴӰϴŨȵӰС﷨ͶܴŨȵӰ춼ϴ߽ΪӰͶʵء߲ͨöֺϱȽϣóַͶ봦ŨȵŹϵʽ
ȡ:
y=1.0918Q0.7051e2.874910-4C(R=0.9971)
﷨:
y=6.868210-4QC+4.590710-4Q+4.010110-3C+11.9819(R=0.9987)
ʽУCΪӷˮŨ(mg/L)QΪӷˮ(t/d)
ʽɿȡͶ洦ݺϵŨָϵ﷨Ͷ洦ŨȵԹϵ
ַͶȣɵã
1.0918Q0.7051e2.874910-4C=6.868210-4QC
+4.590710-4Q+4.010110-3C+11.9819
ʽַͶʵֵͼ5ʾͶʵֵߵΪֵIΪȡͶС﷨ͶʣIIΪ﷨ͶСȡͶʡ

ͼ5ȡ﷨Ͷʵֵ
Fig.5Investment isogram of complexation extraction
process and biological treatment process
ͼ5ɿͶʵֵдŨȵ󣬵ŨС265mg/LʱַͬͶϵĲ𣬵Ũȴ265mg/Lʱ۴ĴСȡͶʼС﷨Ͷʡһ˵СŨȸߣѡȡͶʡŨȵͣѡ﷨Ͷʡ
6.2Ũȶȡ﷨NPVӰȽ
ŨȶȡշӼշʱNPVӰֱͼ6ͼ7ʾŨȶ﷨NPVӰͼ8ʾ

ͼ6ȡNPV洦Ũ
仯(շ)
Fig.6NPV vs quantity and concentration for complexation 
extraction process(no phenol recovery) 

ͼ7ȡNPV洦Ũ
仯(շ)
Fig.7NPV vs quantity and concentration for complexation 
extraction process(with phenol recovery) 

ͼ8﷨NPV洦Ũȱ仯
Fig.8NPV vs quantity and concentration 
for biological treatment process 
ͼ6֪շʱȡNPVΪֵŨԽNPVԽСӰNPVءͼ7֪ڻշ£5NPVŨԼΪ1000mg/Lʱһ㣬˵NPVԼΪ0õľΪӯƽ㡣ŨС1000mg/LʱNPVΪֵĿӮŨȴ1000mg/LʱNPVΪֵĿӮԽNPVԽӮԽࡣɼȡշӹɿΪӯٽŨΪ1000mg/LŨȾΪӰNPVءͼ8֪﷨NPVΪֵŨԽNPVԽСӰNPVء
ͨߵĶֺϱȽϣóNPV봦ŨȵŹϵʽ
ȡ(շ):
y=-1.150410-8CQ-3.558910-5CQ-1.5222Q-1.536910-6C+3.157410-3C-7.0979(R=0.9999)
ȡ(շ):
y=1.832810-3QC-1.4697Q-7.458610-3C-15.8693(R=0.9999)
﷨:
y=-4.027910-4QC-1.5287Q-6.040510-3C+2.0691(R=0.9996)
3ʽԿȡշӣNPVĸ봦ԹϵŨȾжκϵշӣNPV洦ŨȵԹϵ﷨NPV洦ŨȵԹϵַNPVȣͬɵַNPVֵͼ9ͼ10ʾNPVֵߵΪֵIΪȡNPV﷨NPVIIΪ﷨NPVȡNPV

ͼ9ȡ(շ)﷨NPVֵ
Fig.9NPV isogram of complexation extraction 
process (no phenol recovery) and 
biological treatment process
ͼ9ͼ10ɿNPVֵϴŨȵӶ߼Сص㡣һ˵ڴŨȸߵķˮIѡȡȡܻýϴNPVڴСŨȵ͵ķˮIIѡȡ﷨ܻýϴNPV

ͼ10ȡ(շ)﷨NPVֵ
Fig.10NPV isogram of complexation extraction 
process (with phenol recovery) and
biological treatment process
7С
7.1ӰȡͶʵΪӰ﷨ͶʵΪŨȡ
7.2շʱӰȡNPVΪշʱһӯƽ㣬ӦŨΪ1000mg/LŨȾΪӰNPVء﷨ŨΪӰNPVء
7.3Ͷʵֵ߱СŨȽϸߣѡȡͶʽʡϴŨȽϵͣѡ﷨ͶʽʡŨȴ265 mg/Lʱ۴Ϊ٣ȡͶʼС﷨Ͷʡ
7.4NPVֵ߱ڴϴŨȽϸߵķˮȡܻýϸߵNPVڴϵ͡ŨȽϵ͵ķˮ﷨ܻýϴNPV
ο
1ŷлҵ.ӷˮĴ. : ѧҵ, 1983. 125
2King C J. Handbook of separation process technology. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1987. 760774
3࣬õ. ȡҵӷˮ. ѧ,1995, 16(2): 3538
4ռٵ. ˮ. : 廪ѧ, 1991. 165
5. ѧ. Ϻ: ͬôѧ, 1992. 4354
6ԪΡ̡ޱ. ȡӷˮ÷.ѧ1998,19(5)610
7Խܵȱ. ֲᡪˮȾξ. : ߵȽ, 1996. 14341441
߼
ԪУ194511ڣʿʦ廪ѧѧϵΣһ廪ѧоԺԺҪ»ѧ̺ͻĽѧͿйصҺҺȡ̵¹պ·оȺе4ȻѧشĿҿƼɹصƹĿȡҵӷˮίҵо⡣10ҿƼȽ1ʡƼ4ͨɹ10꾭Ч泬ԪĿƼɹ6ϱר2140ƪ
ո:1997-09-01
* ҡ塱ƼĿ(96-909-05-01-03)
