йѧ
CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE
1998 18 4 No.4 Vol.18 1998
Ƽڿ

ˮ۷̽*
˳ݡ١Сΰ 人ҵѧϿѧ빤ϵ人 430070
ġժ۷LCAˮ๤ҵеӦáûӰָ׼AHPȨضԹˮ˽ΪϵͳLCAۣõ˹ˮ໷ۺָΪ6.7010-12,ˮ໷ܸƵĹؼЧ̼ԭĽҵȼռˮúĶߵĲܴӸϸˮĻܣֻǽȾˮҵҵתޡ
ؼʡLCAˮ
Studies on the life circle assessment of portland cement.Liu ShunniLin ZongshouZhang Xiaowei ( Department of Materials Science and Engineering,Wuhan University of Technology,Wuhan 430070).China Environmental Science.1998,18(4):328332
AbstractIn this article, the basic concept and framework for LCA(Life Circle Assessment) are described and the methodology of its application to portland cement is discussed. By normalizing environmental themes and utilizing AHP to quality weighting factors, LCA of portland cement is processed systematically and its comprehensive environmental index is 6.7010-12a.At last, the following conclusions are drawn: decreasing coal expense and increasing electricity expense can not improve environmental performance of cement, it just transfers the pollution from cement production to electricity production. The opportunities for improving environmental performance of cement are enhancing the efficiency of energy utilization, decreasing the amount of carbonate raw materials used and improving the industrial burning technology.
Key words:environmentLCAportland cement
ͳĻӰۺʽڵһ̼Ⱦʣ㻷ҪȾڲ̻ͬʼת޵õʵ䷴Ľ1ͨоΪ뻷໥صĻ⡣ΪۺͽЧߣLCAӦõоѸҵᣬ漰ҵƷյơۡƼƶ෽桲2Ϊ෢ƶҵչսԵѡָߡ3ĽLCAĻͷԹˮгLCAۡ
1LCAĻ
1.1LCAĻ
LCAۣLife Circle AssessmentڷLife Circle AnalysisɶΪϵͳ·ҡĹ۲ƷҵΪһϵͳ4
1.2LCAĻܼ
SETACLCAܡ56֪һLCAоĿ꼰ΧȷĿӰ۵ɡ
1.2.1оĿ꼰ΧȷȷоĻܣּ໥ϵ׶εĽмLCAսһȷ4ݡ4LCAоĿġLCAоʹߡLCAоLCAоı߽
1.2.2Ŀ(LCILife Circle Inventory))LCILCAչΪƵһ֣ͨɹͼռϵͳ߽ȷݴ4׶ɡ 
1.2.3Ӱ(IAImpact Assessment)һĻģͽLCI̵õĲƷڵĴתΪɱȽϵĻӰָĹ̡Ҫࡢָ껯Ȳ֡7
ࣺȾﰴӰûΪ9ࡲ4ԭģADPԴ(EDP)ЧӦ(GWP)ƻ(ODP)(ECA)ữ(AP)ཡ(HT)⻯ѧ(POCP)(NP)
ָ껯ݻӰ࣬һģͽLCIתΪӦĻӰָꡣΪڴָͨٻԻָռоΧӦָıʾ4(׼ָ)
òη89õĻӰָȨϵӰۺָ궨Ϊ׼ָiȨϵiӶóӰۡ
1.2.4ۡȷڸ׶ζԻӰ죬ƴʩӦۡ
2ˮLCA۷
ˮLCAһΪ֡LCAۣĳһˮ๤ҵϵͳۣȷˮĻλƶӦĻ߼ˮ๤ҵĿɳչսԾָ塣LCAۣȷˮ๤ҵϵͳۣΪˮĻܸơ¹պ¼ķչṩָ
ǵˮڵĲȷԣоԭϿˮͬʱһ׼Ļ칹LCA۵ڣ̼ͼ1ʾ
еĹҵϵͳȼϿɡȻڣɽΪϵͳϵͳݿLCA۵ĻҪ ˮLCA۵ĹؼݵļռˮʵͲݣйˮĹLCAۡ

ͼ1ˮʾ
Fig.1 The flow diagram of cement production process
2.1ȷϵı߽
2.1.1оΪˮ࣬ԭϲʯʯճʯ࣬ˮϺģʯʯ1.3tճ0.3tʯ50kgǹҵá
2.1.2ܵλ1m3׼ˮƣԴӦùڡ1m3׼Ϊ270kgˮࡢ60kgɻҡ1850kgϡ
2.1.3ˮѭá
2.1.45t䡣ˮͻԭֱٶΪ5km30km
2.1.5豸ʩصĻȾ迼ǡ
2.2ˮLCI
LCIҪȷйϵͳĻݡϵͳĻݼ1
1еĵȾǰҹܺƽֵ0.424kgú/kWhۺΪֵ24244kJ/kgȼúCO2ԭú̶̼50%㣻ԭúҷ20%ƣϵͳNO2SO2ϵӦƽŷӡ10õеԭϿͬĵļƣδȾͬɵˮ̵Ļݣ2
1ˮ๫ϵͳ(kg)
Table 1Environment data of public system (kg)

ϵͳԴGJCO2COCxHyNOxSO2
(kwh)ú0.424kg0.9384.0E-57.2E-55.1E-31.12E-30.1023
0.0124GJ
(5t/km) 0.2L0.6730.0021.1E-34.7E-31.36E-4
0.00714GJ
ԭú(103kg)13.89kWh

2ˮڹ̵Ļ(kg)
Table 2The life circle environment data of portland cement(kg)

ܺCO2COCxHyNOxSO2
(kwh)ú(kg)
ԭϿ(103kg)13.89
ˮ(103kg)123.3204.4ȼú3741.15E-22.73E-21.5330.35440
ԭ511
(m3)2

 2еˮܺݼס11ȼúֵ22990kJ/kgƣ̶̼50%ƣˮԲ4%ƣݲο糧ȼúܺĻõĵԼΪ2kwh/m3, Ⱦδǡ
ñ12ݶˮ๦ܵλ(1m3)LCAܼ㣬3
3ˮLCAݻ
Table 3The collect of LCA data of portland cement

ԭȼϺĵ
(kwh)ú
(kg)
(L)CO2
(kg)CO
(kg)CxHy
(kg)NOx
(kg)SO2
(kg)
(kg)
ԭʯʯ351kg4.88
ճ81kg1.125
ʯ13.5 kg0.19
䡡 5km0.08910.38.9E-44.9E-42.1E-36.1E-5
ˮ
ˮ
270kg33.2955.192393.1E-37.4E-30.4140.09610.8
켯1850kg25.7
30km
(ˮɻҼ)2.6168.790.0260.0140.0635.3E-3
2180kg
2
ܼ67.1855.192.7052480.030.0230.480.1010.8
Դú55.19kg0.76763.82.7E-34.9E-30.357.6E-26.96
67.95ȡ34.77
ܼơ89.962.7053120.03270.02720.830.1817.8

עԴδȼ͵
2.3ˮIA
LCIݽˮԻӰз࣬Ӧָ껯,44δǹＰ۳òη(AHP)ָȨϵָͬҪԱȡ95
ɱ5ֵõӦжϾһԼϸõָȨϵ6
4ˮ໷Ӱࡢָ껯׼
Table 4Environment impact classificationindex and standardization of portland cement

ӰйȾﵱָָ׼ָ
(kg)(10-9a)(10-12a)
ADP
EDPԴ1GJ2.112GJ235GJ8.987
GWPCO21kgCO2311.937.7kg10128.273
ODP
ECA
APNOxSO21kgSO20.761286kg2.661
HTCONOxSO21kg0.8638576kg1.500
NPNOx1kgPO3-40.107974.8 kg1.443
POCPCxHy1kgϩ0.01013.74 kg2.701

5ˮ໷ָҪԱ
Table 5Environment importance level of portland cement 

̬ҪEDPGWPHTAPPOCPNP
EDP124779
GWP1/213668
HT1/41/31456
AP 1/71/61/4135
POCP1/71/61/51/313
NP1/91/81/61/51/31

6ӰָȨϵ
Table 6The relative importance of every effect factor 

ָȨϵָȨϵ
EDP0.4138GWP0.2916
POCP0.1557HT0.0709
NP0.0434AP0.0246

עmax=6.471R.I=1.24C.I=0.0942C.R=0.0760.1

ݴˣˮĻۺָΪ׼ָiȨϵi=6.7010-12꣬ͬˮڸϵͳûۺָ꣬7
2.4ˮ໷
ӱ7ԿˮڻȾҪˮ켰׶ΣӰֱΪ68.06%26.17%ҪӰԴļCO2ŷµЧӦձ23LCIݿ֪CO2ҪԴʯʯԭϷֽ⡢糧ȼúˮúˣ̼ԭϵúģЧǸˮ๤ҵȾҪ;ˮ׶úĶߵĲܴӸϸˮĻܣǽȾˮҵҵתޡ
⣬NOxSO2ŷҲǻӰҪأҪԴȼȼգˣչµȼռҲǸˮ廷ܵҪֶ֮һ
7ˮڸ׶ۺָ꼰
Table 7The environment impact level and proportion at different production stages

̱׼ָȨϵ10-12aۺָ(%)
EDPGWPHTAPPOCDNP
ԭϿ0.0400.0400.6
ˮ2.4451.8480.11850.09570.03250.01774.557468.06
0.1760.1762.63
1.0530.4940.09850.07960.01190.01501.75226.17
ԭú0.0040.0040.06
䡡0.0690.01570.01390.06510.00280.16652.49
ܼ3.7182.4110.23270.18920.10950.03556.6959100

3
3.1ȫ۷ӿˮΪ뻷໥ۡͽ⣬ˮ๤ҵƷ֡¹պ豸оͿƻȷʮҪ塣
3.2ˮҪȾڵˮ׶ΣҪӰΪܺļЧӦˮ໷ܸƵĹؼЧ̼ԭĽҵȼռˮ׶úĶߵĲܴӸϸˮĻܣֻǽȾˮҵҵתޡ
3.3AHP㷨ɵõҹˮ໷ۺָΪ6.7010-12ꡣ
ο
1Michael LenoxJohn R Ehrenfeld.Design for environment: A new framework for strategic decisions.Total Quality Environmental management.1995,4(4)3751
2Mary Ann Curran.The history of LCA.In:Mary Ann Curran.Environmental life circle assesment.Cincinnati,Oh:The McGraw-Hill Companies,1996.1.11.3
3Thomas D Foust.Future perspective.In:Mary Ann Curran.Environmental life circle assesment.Cincinnati,Oh:The McGraw-Hill Companies,1996,18.118.15
4van den Berg N W, Dutilh C E.Beginning LCA: A detch guide to environmental life circle assesment.In:Mary Ann Curran.Environmental lite circle assessment.Cincinnati,Oh:The McGraw-Hill Companies,1996.17.117.41
5Terrie K BoguskiRobert G Hunt,James M Cholakis,et al.LCA Methodology.In:Mary Ann Curran.Environmental life circle assessment.CincinnatiOh: The McGraw-Hill Companies,1996.2.12.37
6Gabriel G Crognale.Environmental management: What ISO 14000 brings to table.Total Quality Environmental Management.19954(4)515
7Jrgen Giegrich.Valuation as a step in impact assessment: Methods and case study.In:Mary Ann Curran.Environmental life circle assesment.CincinnatiOh:The McGraw-Hill Companies,1996.13.113.14
8Agis VeroutisVital Aelion.Design for environment:An implementation framework.Total Quality Environmental Management.1996.5(4)5568
9Ӧᣬά.˳ѧ.廪ѧ磬1990.461466
10ˣ⣬񻪵.ҹSO2NOxŷǿȵֲʷ.йѧ1996,16(3)161165
11 Cabrera J G Woolley G R.Life cycle benefits of calcium silicate replacements.Waste Management,1996,16(1)215220
߼
˳ݡŮ19642Ϊ人ҵѧϿѧ빤ϵڡҪˮ໯ѧҵüϵо¯1996ȺʡƼһȽ35ƪ
ոڣ1997-10-20
*ʡȻѧĿ
