йѧ
CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE
1999ꡡ191 Vol.19 No.1 1999



úݵص̬ѩɽúΪ
١Ũϼšƽ
ժҪ̬ѧ̬ѧΪָ,ɽпúұݵص̬ѽо.˸ѹ滮ƶڲͬظѵĵģʽ,˴̬̬ÿ˫ѡźƸģʽ˼·ͷ.
ؼʣ̬ѣݵ
ͼţX24 ױʶ룺A ±ţ1000- 6923(1999)01- 0085- 06
The ecological reclamation of subsided land aroused by coal minea case study from Kailuan Coal Mine in Tangshan.
YAND Ju-rong ,TIAN Run-nong ,ZHAO Yu-xia,ZHANG Ping, LIU Hong (The State Key Laboratory of Environmental Simulating and Pollution Control, Institute of Environmental Sciences, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875,China). China Environmental Science.1999,19(1)8590
AbstractIn this article, ecology and ecological economy method are used to study the ecological reclamation of subsided land in Guye,Kailuan Coal Mine,Tangshan.The formulating of reclamation planning and the typical style fitted to different land type are introduced. The thought and method to select and improve the reclamation style from the respect of ecological rationality and ecological economic feasibility are put forward.
Key wordsecological reclamationenvironmental controlsubsided land
úĿɿϸҲƶͱ,ɴرݡˮ,Ȼ̬͵òܵƻ.ũ,ׯǨ,صϰſõķչ.Ϊ,ݵصĸü,ΪǹעĽ.,ҹڿɽص÷濪չһЩо,رڸֲָ,˸Ĺע[1,2].йĻ,Ӹѵ̬Ժ;ÿԵ˫ؽǶ,̽˲úݵ̬滮ƶ͸ģʽѡ.Կú硢ׯݵΪ,о.
1 ſ
úаĿʷ.شɽϲƽԭ,ů´ʪ󼾷ʹ½,ļ.꽵ˮ648.1mm.Դḻ,ʱΪ2650.2h,˪182d.ԳΪ,ʷ,΢,ʳֲ,ɽҪƷ֮һ,ǽ͸߲ƽԭũҵ.
λڷׯľﷶΧ,2739.4hm2,ݵ840 hm2,ˮ466.7hm2,ݲ373.3hm2,ƽ³,̻.ȳǱˮλʱ,ᵼ³ˮ.ݻˮڿˮڵĻˮɴ579.9m3,ˮȴ7.1m,ˮ25.5m.
2 ָ·뷽
̬ѧ̬ѧΪָ,ʵʩ̬ѷ.ݿܸŵĳ̶ȡȷѷ;Ⱥɻֲָ;иϵͳ,޸ĸģʽ̬Ч.
۸ѾЧʱ,ѧ˼,Ͷ߼ȫǶ,ֱ˲Ч;Ч,ȫ۲ͬģʽ.忼ǵм븴ѵ̬Ч桢ǰԴֵı仯˸ѲЧг۸ȷʽʱֵ.оҪ6:Ӧۺָú󿪲ɵ̬Ӱۺ.ѡȡ͡״˿״Ⱦȴ̬״18ָָ,̬ƻĳ̶Ⱥ͵ȼȷݵصĿɻָ.
Դ෨ݵظѵԷ,ȷũ֡ȸѷ,Ϊƶ滮ṩ.
ģۺ۷ˮű.
Ƶ͸ģʽ̬ṹͼ,(NΪ)롢̬ͨЧ[3,4].
ԸѺˮũеҪȾʽм,ˮCODpHֵܽؽͷ,ũеؽ.
̬÷ѡȡͶʻڡֵ(ֵ;þֵ)ֵʡڲʵָ[5].
ֵ(ӳĿڼڻĶָ̬)ļ㹫ʽΪ
 (1)
ʽУFNPVΪֵ;CIΪֽC0 Ϊֽ;(CI- C0) t ΪtľֽnΪ(ĿЧ);icΪ׼.
þֵӳĿԹ񾭼׵Ķָ̬꣩ļ㹫ʽΪ
 (2)
ʽУENPVΪþֵCIΪͶ;C0Ϊò(CI- C0)tΪtľþ;isΪ.
ֵʵļ㹫ʽ
ֵ FNPVRFNPV/Ip (3)
þֵ ENPVRENPV/Ip (4)
ʽ:IpΪͶʵֵ.
ڲʵļ㹫ʽ
 (5)
ڲʴڻڻ׼( ic )ʱ,ɽܣ
ڲʵļ㹫ʽΪ
 (6)
ڲʴڻ( is )ʱ,Ŀɽ.
гص:Ը漰ĻⲿЧ,ӰӼ۸,гֵʷг÷.
3 
3.1 滮ƶ
3.1.1 õָ̬E1Ϊ75,չиų̶ȷּ,ܡضȡ,Իָǰԭò,̬ؽ,ȷȡԸѷ,ƻΪµԴ,ڸԷĻ,пؽ.
3.1.2 ,㸴ˮ汣Ϊ15.3%,ˮ466.7hm2,Ϊ17%,Դˮ汣,ʵΧ,Χ,ԼٸʽͶͺֺĲ.
3.1.3 ݵظ۽, 2739.4hm2,ũֱ֡Ϊ373.3246466.7hm2,Լռ1/3.õ39.5hm2.ؿԭϽи.
3.1.4 ȡ´ʩ˲ͬѷݵؽиѣˮй,ھ,ˮ㡢зأв,ǳ,ۺֳ;Զ̬ݵؼСͲũи,߲˱;ֵؼرµֲؽ뱣;ʯݿ,콨õ;ʵʩԽũ·¹ܵˮվΪݵĹ߹.
3.2 ̬ģʽ
ݸԷ,ѡ3˲ͬݵصĵ̬ģʽо,ȶݵصۺֳģʽ(ۺֳ)ȶݵʯݿӸģʽ(ʯ)̬ݵؿƶ߲ģʽ(߲˱).
3.2.1 ģʽ̬̼ص ۺֳϷׯȶ.лˮˮ濪ھ,ڳǳݿ,ؾƽ,߽ǵֲũ,γɼι㡢ѭģʽ.ÿλʩ, øֽԿ. ͨ.
ʯｨڷׯ.ʯͽݿ,ƽ,ֲũ.乤صǲʯĩкͼ,ʯкʹ;ͨȵĶԱ,ȷΪ500mmȫ渴Ĳ;ֲֲ,ɸѡֲյݡɨ㡢ɳݡͩɽ󻱡뻱ľ.
߲˱ģʽԸׯ,ǶԶ̬ݵؽΡԭũ,ĸѹ.ΪӦر̬仯,ȡƽ,ˮũҵʩ,˿ɲװʽּ˫ĤͿƶʽɻС,Ϊֽ,ʺڶ̬ݵʹ.
3.2.2 ͸ģʽ̬Է 3ֵ̬ģʽҪָķ1.ӱ1Կ,3ָģʽ̬ϻ,ԻϺõ߲˱Ϊͻ.Ͷȸߴ5.10,ԼΪƽˮƽ5.ЧҲϸ,Ϊ1.95,ԼΪƽˮƽ4.ϵͳͶṹ.زͶȽϸ,ƽ״̬,Nӯ.ģʽδƻĶ̬ݵƹ.
1 3ָģʽ(N)Ⱦ״
Table 1 The materiel flow,materiel flow rate (nitrogen) and environmental condition in pilot run
 Ŀۺֳʯ߲˱
ǰ״ȶݵ
̻,ҵʯ
ݿӵر޻ˮĶ̬ݵ
hm211.7310.005.33
Ͷ0.361.045.10
0.27%0.02%1.95%
زͶ0.930.550.78
ϵͳڵԸ23.0%7.6%12.2%
ˮ״ûδȾδȾ
״FAsPbCdƫFAsPbCdƫ
ũ״FAsPbCdƫ,߲гAsƫ

ۺֳԭΪƻصǲʡ༶ѭõԭ.,ֳδ,ũֲҲС.ʹ,ģʽʾ̬.Ͷȴ0.36.ڵ0.51%ƽˮƽ,ڴڽ,ƫ͵,ֵѲ.رϵͳĵԸ3ģʽߵ,ɴ23.3.ڵֲҵС,֮,ʡδ,ֲҵϵͳĵԴҪ,л޻ıΪ0.3.ֲҵƫ͡ߵӰ,Ҫϵͳ⹩,ϰϵͳ̬Чʵ.
3ָģʽ,ʯĹ,Ϊ0.02%,زͶȼԸҲϵ.˶ӵ½,㱡,ֺ,ˮ.ڴ˻,ϵͳתЧ,ѽӽһˮƽ,нϴ󿪷Ǳ.ҪũвֽԪس.
3.2.3 ͸ģʽ̬÷ 3ָģʽ̬÷2.ӱ2Կ,ۺֳģʽõĲЧ,Ͷ롢߲.20Ŀڡ1995ּۼ,ڲʿɴ33.2%,12,ÿԪͶ(1995ֵ)ɴ2704.60Ԫ(ֵ),Ǻܿɹ۵.Ͷʽϸ(ÿͶ38.4Ԫ),4.94.֮ģʽ̬ϻ,ԻԲӰ,ʵʩɼػ⵱ũƷĹӦ,ṩҵ,лӰ.ɼ,ģʽֵƹ.
2 3ָģʽ̬÷
Table 2 Ecological economic analysis of three reclamation style
 Ŀۺֳʯ߲˱
ͶʣԪ38.404.76޹Ͷ
루Ԫ34.651.0711.08
棨Ԫ152.900.7556.38
Ͷʻڣ꣩4.9419.22- 
ڲʣ33.207.08* 10.67**- 
Ͷ1.472.142.03
7%ԪͶʾ棨Ԫ350284- 
͸Ͷ롢߲Ͷ롢ͲͶ롢߲
ҪͶʲͼ
Բʶȷչ,ũӪַžӪ̬ƹ

ע* ڲ ** ڲ
ģʽֲҵ̫,϶ϵͳ⹩.ڲ񾭼ýṹ,ռɱ90,ɶгĹ.ͨڲʶϼ۸ȷ(3)Կ,ڸóƷнϺõĲ,ϳɱ(۸)30²,ڲƷ۸񲻱,ֻҪϼ۸()ǲ30,ĿӮ,˵ϼ۸ı䶯һ(ʵǲƷ۸½ɱӰ,䵯Եڴֵ).ϼ۸Ƿ40%,侭Ч潫½.Ȼг, ּ۸,ɴ˵ۺֳϼ۸кܴ.һȱ,۸Ƿ,Ӱֳת,߿ʹ̱.
3 ۺֳĲڲʶϼ۸
()ȷ()
Table 3 Sensitivity analysis of financial internal profit rateto feed price(or quantity) in multiple-producing farm(%)
FIRRFIRR
-2044.901027.32
-1038.972021.57
-536.033015.83
-234.284010.04
-133.07504.11
033.12

,ۺֳĲڲʶԲƷ()۸ȷ(4)ϼ۸ȷ,ֳڲʶ۸ı䶯.
4 ۺֳڲʶ۸䶯ȷ(%)
Table 4 Sensitivity analysis of financial internal profit
rate to pork price in multiple-producing farm(%)
FIRRFIRR
-803.90-3021.73
-707.46-2025.44
-6010.99-1029.23
-5014.53033.12
-4018.101037.12

ʯģʽ̬÷,صļֵ,ڸǰΪ¶ʯݿ,üֵ,ҶΧвӰ,ʿΪصļֵΪֵ.ֵɲӰʧ,ͨɱȷѺ󻷾õ,˹ֲСĸơٷɳ,ЩЧǰ2.6.
ɱ2ɼ,ģʽ̬ڲΪ10.67,ģʽʹΧ;ԲӰΪ˹ֲũ,̬Ч.ڳ,ڼʽʱֵ,ʹ20겻κ˰,ڲҲֻ7.08,Ե1995дһ(7.47%).Ը(Ͷ)˵,ʽϢȽиָѸΪ.3ิģʽ,߲˱صľЧ(2).ڲôҺͷ߲˵ֲ,ʹ߲ǰ,ԻýϸߵĲ.ɴ748919.6Ԫ,˾9396Ԫ,ͶҲϸ(2.03),Ͷ롢߲ģʽ,ֵƹ.λڶ̬,Ӫݹɺͷչ,ȡҪķʩ.
3.2.4 ̬ÿз˫޸ġƵ͸ģʽ ķ,ۺֳʯģʽĽ֮.ۺֳµ:ֲҵ,ϵֲҵˮֲˮ,ʹֳҵϴﵽ20,ϵͳṩ;ֲҵлϵͶ(ʺ),ʹֲҵϵͳȫϵͳṩ.ʹռֲҵϵͳͶܵ2/3.޸ĺ̬̬Чʼ5.н׶εָ,̬Чʺ;ЧʶõԸ.
5 Żۺֳ̬ЧʵĶԱ
Table 5 Compare of ecological economic efficiency 
in pilot run and after modified in 
multiple-producing farm
 ĿŻƺ
Ͷ0.50.36
0.350.265
زͶ1.020.93
Ըʣ34.923
ڲʣ3833.2
Ͷʻڣa4.054.94
Ͷ2.31.47

ָǸģʽȻЧ,ͶҲϸ,,ģʽ˹.ǰʯģʽڵҪũʵ͡ؾ״ũһЩԪغ.Щ,¸: ߲˹Ϲֲ,뻱ơݱֲֲ, ʹռֲ80ȫ.ɽ͸ѵĳɱ(˹),ұؽũȾ.뻱ոõ6Ľ,Կ,ģʽ̬Լ̬ÿԾ.Ը̬ΪҪĿ,ֲ뻱ʹ̬Ը,Ҳ;Ч涼ԭзʽ,ܽвƷӹ(ֹ֯),侭Ч潫.
6 ŻʯģʽڵĶԱ
Table 6 Compare of waste-rock-land style pilot run
and after modified
 ĿŻƺ
Ͷ1.921.04
ʣ0.20.02
زͶ0.670.55
Ըʣ36.27.6
ڲʣ11.027.08
Ͷʻڣ꣩13.9119.22
Ͷ2.752.14
ڲʣ14.0610.67
Ͷʾ3.743.34

ע80뻱
4 
úݵظͶʽϴᾭû.ҹɼƻгת׶,ʹѳַᡢá̬Ч,ʹгӹ,Ӧ߼ͷԴо.Ϊѧ˼뵽ѵľ÷,븴ѵ̬ЧʮֱҪ,ɴʹ׷ΪԶڴ̬ΪĿЭһ.
лɽؾ֡ɽйұؾֵͥ޽áŹܡ޹⻪йũҵѧԺĽͬ־ĺ֧ڴ˱ʾл.
߼飺(1939-),Ů,ӱ,ʦѧѧо,Ҫ»̬ѧѧͿй.еؽֲȾΣֲؽܻȶо.ҡʡƼ5.60ƪ.
ߵλ(ʦѧѧо, ģȾƹصʵ,  100875
οף
[1],ո.صĻָо [J].̬ѧ,1995,5(3):339-343.
[2]ף.ƽԭúۺϿ [J].ȻԴо,1993,(2):10-13.
[3]¬,.ũҵ̬ϵͳѭϵͳ [J].̬ѧ־,1990,9(3):38-41.
[4].Ӫ̬ũҵϵͳ˹ܲͶȵļ㡢о [J].ũ̬,1989,(1):15-19.
[5].ʵûѧ [M].:廪ѧ,1992.
ոڣ1998-06-25
