йѧ
CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE
1999ꡡ193ڡVol.19 No.3 1999



ɽȻɭ̬ϵͳӾüֵ
ѦԪĻ
ժҪʹгֵӰӹ̷ɱѷȶԳɽȻɭ̬ϵͳĹֵܼ˾.۽,ֵ̬ܼܵΪ176465.94Ԫ,лľֵ10777.43Ԫ,ˮԴֵ69741.2Ԫ,ʴļֵ2307.02Ԫ,̼ԼЧӦļֵ87716.6Ԫ,ֳַNPKֵּ4338.88Ԫ,SO2ͷβ溦ֵ1584.73Ԫ.
ؼʣȻɭ̬ϵͳԣӼֵɽ
ͼţX826.2 ױʶ룺A ±ţ1000- 6923(1999)03- 0247- 06
A valuation study on the indirect values of forest ecosystem in Changbaishan Mountain Biosphere Reserve of China.
XUE Da-yuan1, BAO Hao-sheng2, LI Wen-hua3 
(1.Nanjing Institute of Environmental Science, the State Environmental Protection Administration of China, Nanjing 210042,China2.The Research Center of Natural Resources, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210093, China3.Commission for Integrated Survey of Natural resources, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China). China Environmental Science. 1999, 19(3)247252
AbstractIn this paper, the market valuation method, shadow engineering method, opportunity cost method and substitute expense method are used to value the functions of the forest ecosystem of Changbaishan Mountain Biosphere Reserve. The valuation results reveal that the total ecological function value of the nature reserve in 1996 is estimated up to about 1,765 million yuan (Chinese RMB) per annum, of which, about 108 million yuan is of the output of standing trees, about 697 million yuan of water conservancy, about 23 million yuan of soil conservation to control erosion, about 877 million yuan of carbon fixation for reducing green house effect, about 43 million yuan of nutrient retention for N, P and K, and about 16 million yuan of SO2 degradation and control of diseases and pests.
Key wordsnature reserveforest ecosystembiodiversityindirect valueChangbaishan Mountain
ȻԴļӼֵΪȻ̬ѧܵķ,Ϊṩļ.ּӼֵȻбֵһҪɲ.ɽȻһɭ̬ϵͳΪҪȦ.196 465hm2,ֵ167 081hm2,ɭָ85,ҶΪԭʼɭ.̬Чоѧߵرע[1-3],ͼͨԳɽо,ʾּӼֵ.
1 ɭ̬ϵͳӼֵĺ
ɭ̬ϵͳӼֵɭֵֵ̬ܼ,ָɭ̬ϵͳӳĶࡢͻȫЧͷ.ɭ̬ϵͳϵͳЧ桢ϵͳЧ桢ϵͳ뻷ϵͳͳһۺЧ.ɭֵ̬Чֱûҵʽֳ,Ȼȴüӵķ.һɭ̬ϵͳ͵Ȼ˵,ӼֵҪڹáˮԴֹˮʧҰֲ̶CO2ͷٲ溦ȷ(ͼ1).

ͼ1 ɭ̬Чʾ
Fig.1 Sketch map for ecological benefits of forests
2ɽɭ̬ϵͳļӼֵ
2.1 л
ɭ̬ϵͳлҪľĲ,һɭ,ľҪֱӼֵ,Ȼڽֹľ,һ㲻γľгƷ,лƷԻľʽ,Ϊɭ̬ϵͳӼֵɲ,ֵڻľ.
2.2 ˮԴ뱣
ɭֺˮԴļֵҪЧˮ,ˮʺ͵ھ.ɭ̬ϵͳĴ,ɽ׺ɭ¾ߴ86,ֱӾռ14,ˮھԶͬڽˮ[4].ͬʱ,ɭЧؼСʴ.
2.3 ̶CO2ͷO2
ɭеʽҪCO2O2Ľ,ɭ̶ֹٴеCO2,ͬʱṩӴе.ɽȻ16hm2ɭ,άֵеCO2O2Ķ̬ƽ⡢ЧӦž޴Ĳ.
2.4 Ӫѭֻ
ɭ̬ϵͳѭֺ֮֡.,ֽ֮ҪĹ,ѭҪ⡢֦Ҷ֮.
2.5 Ⱦβ溦
ɭܹն򡢷⡢к,н͹⻯ѧȾ;ʵ.ɽɭֶԸйҵΧȾ⼰һ.ͨ뻷ĸ̬ϵ,Чطɭֲ溦.
3ɭ̬ϵͳӼֵ۷
3.1 ľ۷
ҪָɭֵĻľ,侭üֵʹгֵ,㷽ǸȻڸֵַԸַȻֵ꾻,õֵַλ꾻(m3),Դ˾ֱľּ(Ԫ/m3)˶õַľֵ.
3.2 ˮԴֵ
ɽɭֺˮԴļֵ꺭ˮԴ(m3)ÿˮļ۸.ǰߵĹƿͨɭ꾶õ.ٶ꾶ɭֺˮԴ,򳤰ɽɭֺˮԴóɽ꾶 (mm/a)ɭ.:
ƽ=ƽˮƽɢ
ˮۿӰӹ̼۸,19881991ȫˮ⽨Ͷʲÿ1 m3ͶɱΪ0.67Ԫ.
3.3 ֵ
ɭֱļֵʴɥʧľʧ.
3.3.1 ʴļ ɲֵغֵصʴ.ձѧͨʵ,ɽֵغֵصʴΪ0.01:10.0(mm/a),ɽֵغֵصʴΪ0.10:50(mm/a).ڳɽΪɽͻɽ,ձγ,ɲձʴƽֵ30 mm/a.ô˲Գɽɭ,ֵµʴ.
3.3.2 صʧ ʴ,ƽ0.6mΪɭ,ûɱطʧȥ꾭üֵ (ȫҵ282.17Ԫ/hm2).
3.3.3 ɥʧ ʴ,һʧɥʧлʺ͵ס,ʹгϼ۸ʧľüֵ(ƽʼ۸2549Ԫ/t, 1990겻).ʵ۸,δлʼֵ.
3.4 ̶CO2ͷO2ֵ
ݱڸֵַλֲ꾻,ַÿ굥λ̶CO2.̶CO2뵥λCO2̶ļ۸,õ̶CO2ܾüֵ.ͷO2̶CO2Ϊͬһ,ΪظȥO2ֵ.
3.4.1 CO2̶ļ ֲ÷ʽ,ֲʱ,6772̫,264 g CO2108 gˮ,180 gǺ193 g O2,Ȼ180 gתΪ162 gֲ.ֲÿ1 gҪ1.63 g CO2.
3.4.2 λCO2̶ļ۸ ̶CO2ֵķҪ̼˰ʷֳɱ.һЩʹ̼˰CO2ŷ,Ų˰Ϊ227Ԫ/tC;CO2˰ʴԼ150Ԫ/tC;1990˰ʽΪ15Ԫ/tC.ѧʹ˰[1,2].
ҲʹֳɱɭֹCֵ.Titus[3]о,ֳɱΪ38Ԫ/tC.Myers[5]Ϊ,ÿ̼ծȨΪ130Ԫ/hm2.ҹ˹ӪɼľβɡҶɡͩȵĳɱ,̶1tCɱΪ250Ԫ[6].
3.5 Ӫѭֵ
ҪֳַNPKֵļֵ.ֲ꾻,ⶨNPKԪصı, ַһдյ,ٲⶨÿ黹.
ֳִֵַַַ֣֣黹֣ˮϴ
ֻۼֵַλֳּ۸(NPK)
3.6 Ⱦｵͷβ溦ֵ
ɭ̬ϵͳSO2ľ,ʹõλɭSO2ƽֵԱɭ,õÿ걣ɭSO2,ٸݽȾλSO2Ͷʳɱ,SO2ֵܼ.ʹñɭֲ溦ĵλڲ溦Σ̬Ч.
3.7 ɭ̬ϵͳܼӼֵ
Ӽֵ1,ܼӾüֵڸֵܼ֮.:
ܼӼֵ = ľֵ + ˮԴֵ + ֵ + ̶CO2ֵ + ֻۼֵ + Ⱦｵֵ + ڲ溦Σļֵ(1).
4 Ӿüֵ
4.1 ɭֵ
ֲҪľĵ,,Ҫɭľļֵ.ȫҪֱ׼ľּ[1]ͼʡַ־׼,ñÿľ324227.62m3,ֵܼ11487.04Ԫ.ȥÿ꿳ľĵۼֵ,1996꾻ֵΪ10777.43Ԫ.
1 ӹֵܼ
Table 1 Categories and valuation methods for indirect functional values
Ӽֵ͹ָʾ۷;

ˮԴ

̶CO2
Ӫѭ
Ⱦｵ
β溦ľĻľ
ɭˮ
ʴ
ЧӦ
ղ
SO2
ڲ溦Σгֵ
Ӱӹ̷
ɱ
гֵ
гֵ
ɱ
ѷ
гֵַ꾻ʡľ۸
꾶λˮˮ⽨ɱ
ʴλֵ;ʧгʼ۸
CO2̶̼˰/ֳɱ
NPKʼ۸
SO2λSO2Ĺ̳ɱ
ɭⵥλɭÿڷβ溦ĳɱ

4.2 ˮԴֵ
ɽվƽӪվͶ׺ˮվͬθ߶ȵصƽ꽵ˮֱΪ1332.9814.1726.3mm,õƽˮΪ957.8mm.ݷ[4]о,ɽȪɭ̬ϵͳƽɢˮԼռƽˮ35,ϵΪ0.65.:
R(꾶)꽵ˮϵ=957.80.65 623 (mm)
R(꾶)=λ꾶ɽȻɭ623167081104091.46(m3)
ˮԴֵܼ꾶λˮĿݳɱ104091.46(m3) 0.67 (Ԫ/m3) 69741.28 Ԫ
4.3 ֵ
4.3.1 ֵؼʴļֵ üֵ ҵƽЧ棽(ʴ/aƽ)ҵƽЧ棽(ֵֵصʴֵ/ƽ)ҵƽЧ棽30 (mm/a)167081(hm2)0.6 (m)282.17 (Ԫ/ hm2.a) 235.73 (Ԫ/a)
4.3.2 ֵؼNPKʧļֵ ɽ[7]ֲⶨ,ɽȻҶ콻ֵ060cmЧNPKֱԼΪ276375868 kg / hm2,ɼֵطֱΪ237.8625.48163.22 kg/hm2,ƽ060cmNPKΪ972.69 kg/ hm2.
ʧֵλNPK۸ 8354.05 (hm2/a)972.69 (kg / hm2)2549 (Ԫ/t)2071.29(Ԫ/a)
,ֵܼΪ֮,:235.73 + 2071.29 = 2307.02Ԫ
4.4 ̶CO2ļֵ
ʹ̼˰ʺֳɱַ,ǰʹ̼˰, 150Ԫ/tC,Ϊ1245Ԫ/tC;ʹйֳɱ(ɱ)250Ԫ/tC.̼˰ʷÿCֵΪ146179.8Ԫ;ֳɱΪ29253.4Ԫ.ַƽֵΪ87716.6Ԫ(2).
4.5 Ӫѭֵ
ӪѭֵҪֳֵַļֵ,ȡɭλɭֳԼ۸.Ϊ㷽,ɽɭֽƵطΪҶ콻ֺͺɼ,ݲⶨ꾻ֳ[7],ɽȻɭ̬ϵͳֳΪ17021.895 t,ƽʼ۸2549Ԫ/tֵֻܼΪ4338.88Ԫ/a (3).
2ɽȻɭ̶ֹCO2ֵ
Table 2 Value for CO2 fixation of forest in Changbaishan Reserve



ֲꡡ׼(t/hm2. a)桡(hm2)(t/a)̶CO2 (t/a)ۺϴC(t/a)CЧ(Ԫ)
̼˰ (1245Ԫ/tC)ֳɱ (250Ԫ/tC)
Ҷ20.1965835.9961329228.72166642.7591323.273619.714783.1
ɼ13.4580295.8651079979.31760366.2480441.659815.012011.0
Ǹɽ5.156018.63130995.9550523.413788.91716.7344.7
ɽ2.38392.924935.161524.3416.051.810.4
Ҷ9.509523.18990470.30147466.640246.85010.71006.2
ɽ14.197591.00107716.29175577.647918.95965.91198.0
 ơ169657.582639325.54302100.81174135.4146179.829253.4

ע:׼ĻȵĲⶨ[8];ֲ͵йѧԺ̬λվͳ,Ҷаľ
3ɽȻɭ̬ϵͳֻۼֵ
Table 3 Values for nutrient accumulation of the forest in the Changbaishan Reserve
ַ֡(hm2)ַ־(t/a)(t/a)ֵܼ(Ԫ/a)
NPK
Ҷ콻88968.8162952.875293.5971291.8274538.2991156.812
ɼ80295.8657868.192990.0483625.35812483.5983182.069
ϼ169264.68110821.0651283.6454917.18517021.8954338.881

4.6 Ⱦｵͼٲ溦ֵ
4.6.1 Ⱦｵֵ ݡйԹо桷,ÿ1 t SO2ͶʳɱΪ600Ԫ,ݴɭSO2Ч.
SO2Ч棽ɭλɭSO2λSO2ɱ 167081 (hm2)152.13 (kg/hm2.a)600(Ԫ/t)1525.08(Ԫ/a)
4.6.2 ɭֲ溦μֵҵͳݱ,19941995ȫڷɭֲ溦󺦵ܷ÷ֱΪ26185.9Ԫ33409.3Ԫ.1995ηü,ƽֵطηΪ3.57Ԫ/hm2.
溦μֵɭληѣ167081(hm2)3.57(Ԫ/hm2.a)59.65(Ԫ/a)
Ⱦ벡溦ֵܼ1525.0859.651584.73(Ԫ/a)
4.7 Ӽֵ
ɽȻܵļӼֵΪֵ̬ܼ֮,:
ܼӼֵ ľֵˮԴֵֵCֵֵּSO2ͷβ溦ֵ10777.43(Ԫ)69741.28(Ԫ)2307.02(Ԫ)87716.6(Ԫ)4338.88(Ԫ)1584.73(Ԫ)176465.94Ԫ
5ᡡ
мֵֻ̬ܼǳɽȻɭ̬ϵͳ̬ܼӼֵһ,͵ļӼֵڼĸԺͼϵ,Ҳǲܺӵ.,ɽȻĴƬԭʼɭֶΧũҵС;ٽȺŴȶԺͱ,ŷḻŴ;ṩҰϢ.ɼɭ̬ϵͳļ̬ʮָ,һ,ڷ̫,ȫЧ,дڽһо.
߼飺ѦԪ(1955-),,ս,ʿ,ڰĴʿѧϵ²ʿо.ҪԱȻо.ESCAPUNDPƸΪԹѯר.֡塱塱ҿƼרͶ粿ίشĿ,ҺͲƼ5(4Ϊһ).ר9,60ƪ.
ߵλѦԪһܾϾѧо, Ͼ210042ڰĴʿѧϵ²ʿо(Postdoctoral Research Fellow,Department of Economics,The University of Queensland,Brisbane Qld 4072,Australia)
ϾѧȻԴо, Ͼ210093
ĻйѧԺȻԴۺϿίԱ, 100101
οף
[1]Anderson D. Carbon fixing from an economic perspective [R]. Forestry Commissions First Economics Research Conference, York University.1990.
[2]Pearce D W. Assessing the returns of economy and to society from investments in forestry [A].Whiteman A (ed.). Forestry Expansion [C].Forestry Commission, Edinburgh, 1990.
[3]Titus D B.Using tropical forestry to fix atmospheric carbon dioxide [J].Ambio.,1992,19(5):230- 236.
[4], .ɽɭ̬ϵͳˮˮƽ[A].ɭ̬ϵͳо[C].6.:йҵ, 1992.240- 247.
[5]Myers Norman. The greenhouse effect: a tropical forestry response [J]. Biomass, 1990, 18:73- 78.
[6]ѦԪ. ԾüֵɽȻо[M]. :йѧ. 1997.
[7]ɽ,,Ƽ. ´Ҷ콻ֵѭ[J]. ̬ѧ, 1995, 15, suppl.(B): 47- 53.
[8]Ļ,ö . ɽҪ̬ϵͳо [A].ɭ̬ϵͳо [C].2.:йҵ, 1981. 34- 50.
ոڣ1998-09-04
