йѧ
CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE
1999ꡡ194ڡVol.19No.41999



ɳչָ(ϵ)ȷ̽
ܺ
ժҪͨĿǰеĿɳչָϵо,ָָϵ˿ɳںáṫƽԼӰõҪ.ɳչָ.ָꡢչָꡢЭָϵͳĿɳ;׼ֵοֵ÷ӳϵͳɳ״̬ĵֵԼӳ״ȫʱƽֵ.ͬʱ˲ɳԱ׼ֵɳ״̬Զ벻ɳ״̬ɳչ̵ȸ.ǿָҪ,ָָȶϵͳɳԵָʾ.
ؼʣָꣻɳָ׼ֵ
ͼţX32 ױʶ룺A ±ţ1000- 6923(1999)04- 0360- 05
A study on the approach of establishing indicator system for assessing sustainable development. 
ZHOU Hai-lin (The Commission of Integrated Survey of Natural Resources,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100101,China). China Environmental Science.1999,19(4)360 364
AbstractBased on the study of current indicator system of sustainable development, this paper points out that the current indicator systems ignore the important meaning of sustainability, social equity, environmental restriction and economical growth. It proposes that deviation method should be applied in calculating indicators for assessing sustainable development. In evaluating the state of one system or a sub-system, the indicators reflecting restriction, development and coordination of the system would be more representative. Regarding standard and reference values, the average of present human situation within one area,state or the whole world should be adopted. This paper also introduces such new concepts as standard value of unsustainabilitystate of unsustainability,state of far-away from unsustainability and state of ongoing to sustainability. It emphasizes on the importance of individul indicator in reflecting sustainability.
Key wordsindicatorstandard value of unsustainabilitydeviation method 
ĿǰԿɳչָָϵ[1,2]о,:еָϵUNDPָϵָͬϵйɳչָϵָꡢŷ˵ָꡢӢɳչָ.ƺûһָϵܹΪܻ򱻹Ϊǿɳչָϵ.ЩָǰOECDѹ״̬Ӧ[3,4],һѾ廯Ϳɲ,󶼰ȡؽ޸,ձ¼:(1)ɳչָĸ,еĿɳչָϵûȷ˵ȥ񾭼úָʵʲ,ɳչָϵӽ͵زһЩ񾭼úָ,ûȷָָĿɳչ˼ںɳԵϢ;(2) ǿɳչָϵ,ӵָԿɳչĽ,Եָ겻ȷĿ֤,׷ۺ,ԵָԿɳչ״ָ̬ʾ.Ŀǰϳʹõϵۺָпɳչˮƽɳչȵ.ۺָʹðŵָĿ,,ˮָ곬ˮ,ָͨGDP,ۺָɳչˮƽչȻܸ,ⲻϿɳչ˼ʵ;(3)ɳչָ׼ֵȷ.Ŀǰйؿɳչָ׼ֵȷĳַչ滮Ϊ,ӳĿɳչ̶Ȼˮƽ˵ֵܲΪ׼;(4)ǿԼ㷽Ե׷,ָĿɲԼݵĿɻ.Щ,ɳչָϵ,ȷӦļ㷽.
1 ɳչָں
1.1 ɳչ״̬Զʵ״̬
ɳչ״̬һ״̬,޷ȷɳչָ׼ֵ.ɳչ,ǶԷչĲɳۺ.ֻ޵ؽӽ,ﵽɳչ״̬;,ڿɳչָ׼ֵ.,Ͻ,ŷӳϵͳɳָ׼ֵ,,ˮȾһάˮȶ(ˮ̬ϵͳȶ)ĽȾŷŵľ.ϵͳɳ״ָ̬׼ֵ,ͨѧоȷ.ͨЩ׼ֵ(οֵ)ʵʲֵıȽ,Զ϶ϵͳǷ񲻿ɳԶ벻ɳơѾɳչ̵.
1.2 ɳչָϵӦַӳɳչ˼Ҫں
ҪںΪչĿɳԡԡṫƽԼչЭԵ;ĿǰָϵرЩؼ,ֻԭеĹ񾭼úָм򵥵һЩָͿƼԷչ׶ָ,ϣܷӳɳչ˼,ԶԶûзӳɳչʵ.ĿǰձþָꡢᷢչָꡢָꡢȻԴָꡢָӳ򡢹ҡطеȿɳչ״̬.Щַָӳ˿ɳչĸ,ܹӳ(Ȼá)״ġõĵָ겢ûرǿ.,Ӧѡ񲿷־ָΪϵͳָ,䰴ָꡢչָꡢЭָз,Ȼȷ䷴ӳɳԵָ׼ֵ.
1.3 ָϵҪǿָָʾ
ĳЩָ̬ϵͳȺָʾֲһĹ,ܷӳϵͳĳЩʵԱ仯Ǳڵķչ.,ӦȷԻ׶Եָʾָ,ԡˮȾŨȡԴıƶ˿˾άֻˮƽȶлҵȿɳչָʾԷӦָ.൥ָܹϵͳǷɳж.
1.4 ɳָı׼ֵοֵͼȷ
1.4.1 ı׼ֵ(ļֵ) ָܳܵĶȾάϵͳȶ,߳ԲȾ.Щ׼ֵ(οֵ)ͨѧ̬ѧѧȻоۺϸ,ܹȻ״̬ȷġѧġӳȻߵı׼ֵ.ȻԴɳõָ,͵ĳΪͱ׼ֵ,뻷ֵָ.
1.4.2 ׼ ָ͵ĻҪʱ֤׼Ҫ׼ƽˮ׼Լȥ(һ)ȽϵĲοֵ.
1.4.3 ÷չָ ָùȥݵֵΪοֵ,Ƿ;ͬʱԲõȫҵƽֵ(Ϊοֵ);ԸݵԾָ޶,Ȼʵֵ׼ֵ(οֵ)֮ĳ̶.
1.4.4 ᷢչȶָ ָṹȶʡơˮƽ,ԲõʱȫҵƽˮƽΪοֵ.
2 ļ
2.1 ֵָȷһ㷽
ĳһɳչָ(Ⱦŷ)ΪTn'
Tn'/I>=[(Tn- T0)/T0]100
(1)
ʽ:Tn'Ϊn(ʱ)ֵָ;TnΪnʵʲͳֵ;T0Ϊָ겻ɳԵı׼ֵ(οֵ).
n- 1(һȻο)Ƚ,Tnbʾ:
Tnb=(Tn'/T'n- 1)100= [(Tn- T0)/(Tn- 1- T0)]100%
(2)
ʽT'n- 1ʽ(1)ó,:
T' n- 1=[(Tn- 1- T0)/T0]100
Tn'Tnbɱʾӳɳչںĵֵָ,.
ͨ,Tnb 0(·Tnbʱ,ͬTn',Ϊ˼,ֻTnbһ),ʾھԲɳ״̬;0 Tnb1,ʾԶ벻ɳ״̬,ûɳչ;Tnb1,ʾɳչ.ǵеָȶͬ,Щָ(緢չָ),ЩָǸ(ָ),ҪֱԲָͬеж.
2.2 3ָȵļ
2.2.1 չָ(GDPϵϵ) Ҫ֮Ƚϵȷοֵ׼ֵ;ҲȡʱȫҵƽֵΪοֵ.ȵļ㷽ʽ(2)ʽ(3)ʾ.
Tnb=[(Tn- T0)/(Tb- T0)]100 
(3)
ʽ:TbΪָ굱ʱȫҵͳƽֵ; T0Ϊֵ(ά־áϵͳתֵ,GDPĵֵ,ʱȫ򡢹ҵֵ).
2.2.2 ָ(绷ȾָԴزʡ) ھԱ׼ֵ(Ȼ)Ա׼ֵ(ݵʱҪ),ȵļ㷽ʽ(1)(2),ʽеT0Ϊֵ˵ĻҪֵ(Ӿ).
2.2.3 Эָ(绷Ȼ򻷾ͶռGDPıʡƼͶ롢˿ʵ) žֵ(Ͷ)ֵ(ݵʱȫˮƽԼչܹﵽ״),ȿԲʽ(2)ʽ(3).ʽеTbΪʱȫƽֵ(ֵ);T0Ϊֵ,ֵ(绷ʽͶռGDPıʡƼ׶ȵ).
2.3 ȷۺֵָĲ
ѡ񼸸ϵͳչáչáЭõָ,ĳһʱԵӰϵͳĿɳչ,ͨЩָ,ȷжϵͳǷڿɳ򲻿ɳ״̬.֮һԵų׼,:(1)׼ֵοֵȽ,κһָȳСڻ,Tnb  0(- Tnb  0),Զ϶ϵͳ(򡢳Сҵ)ڲɳչ״̬,Ӧòȡʩ,Щɳ,ҿԸ为̶ֵ,Ƚ;(2)0  Tnb 1(0  - Tnb  1),ϵͳԶ벻ɳ״̬,ûɳչ,ʱԲòηָȨֵ,ۺֵָ,ȻбȽ(ϵͳĹȥʱ),ϵͳûнɳչ,ԶЩȽӽָӳӦøرĹע;ҲԸݵֵָȷȽ;(3)ָTnb  1(- Tnb 1),ϵͳ˿ɳչĹ,ʱҪбȽ,ɲòηۺֵָ,ϵͳȥбȽ.ڴ״̬ϵͳ,ǵĲ,ķ,ЩȽӽ1ָӳϵͳӦԷ.
2.4 ׼ֵοֵȷ
ڲȷӳɳչ״̬ı׼ֵ,ֻѡ񲻿ɳԱ׼ֵοֵ,׼ֵӳϵͳȥĿǰȻ״̬,ӳϵͳչͷ,,οֵ׼ֵɳչ˼һ.һԻر趨״̬׼ֵ,ĿǰеָϵõĹ滮ֵұ׼,ۺ̫ǿ.,ڲֵָ(ֵֵ),ܷӳϵͳԶ벻ɳ״̬ĳ̶,ıɳչһ;ͬʱ,ǿ˿ɳչ˼Իرע.ͬչϵͳ(Զ벻ɳ״̬ϵͳɳչ̵ϵͳ)ԽбȽ,ϵͳҲǰȽ,Դϵͳе״.
ֵָ,ͨϸĿѧв,ӳϵͳȻ,׼ֵ൱ʱڽȶ,þ.չָ꼰ЭָοֵԲ÷ӳȫ򼰹ҵʱָƽ״ֵ,ʾȫ򼰹ҵʱʵ״,ֵָӵطӦȫԻڵĹƽ,һֵǿԼ.,ֵָļ()ں̶ܴϷӦ˿ɳչ˼ں.ڲָᷨ,ȷҪȻȨ;չָͨʡҸָƽ״ֵȽ,ֵָӳ˴߶ȵķչƽ,ɳչ˼ı;Эָӳϵͳ߱ĵԼȥŬ,ҪϵͳڲܹʱԲɳ״Ӧ,Ӻ͵ϵͳͶ.
2.5 򡢳Сطȿɳչ״̬
2.5.1 ɳ״̬ ɵָȷ,ֻҪһָȴڲɳ״ֵ̬Χ֮,ͿΪϵͳǲɳ.
2.5.2 Զ벻ɳ״̬ĳ̶ еָ0  Tnb  1(0  - Tnb  1)ʱ,ۺָԼԶ벻ɳ״̬ĳ̶.
2.5.3 ˿ɳչ̵ϵͳ еָTnb  1(- Tnb  1), еĵָȶڻ1,ʱ,ſԽۺֵָļ;òηۺָ,ɴ˿Եó(ϵͳϵͳȥ״ȵ)ɳչˮƽͳ̶.
ĿǰõǿɳչɳչƵĸ,ԵڶԿɳչ״̬ĿɴԻ״Եʶ;ʵ,ɳչ״̬Ŀɴԡ״ʶϵ.ԶûдﵽɳչĿ,ɳչ,˵Ϊõǰ,˵Ƕ෢չгִľԱ,ҪԲɳչ״̬Σ.Բòɳ״̬Զ벻ɳ״̬Լɳչ̸ܹ׼ȷطӳɳչ˼Ŀǰٵʵ.
3 
һϵͳпɳչ̬,һҪһġͳһָϵ,ʵָϵȷ,ڲͬϵͳȻᡢ״̬Ĳͬ,䲻ͬصȷһԵָ(ϵ);ϵͳչĲͬ׶вͬص,Ҫвָͬ,ͬһϵͳڲͬʱҪʹõָҲȫһ.ʵ,ڽжֵָ֮ǰ,ǿȶԵжϵͳ״̬,ѡʵָ,ϵͳʱءչغҪЭ,ѡؼԵļָ,ȼͷ,óϵͳ״̬Ҫ,ӦǽָָϵҪĿ.
߼飺ܺ(1965-),,Ϻ,йѧԺȻԴۺϿίԱоԱ,ҪԴ̬üɳչ۵о.ейѧԺ뼪ɭѧĿ̬ᾭ÷չо,ռϢϵͳٽ֦Դɳչо塱Ŀйɳչ̬оشĿ.д6,Ľ10ƪ.
ߵλйѧԺȻԴۺϿίԱ, 100101
οף
[1]UNDP. Indicators of sustainable development framework and methodologies [R]. New York: ISBN92-1-104470-7. 1996.
[2]ҶĻ, . Ϲɳչָϵ [J]. й˿ڡԴ뻷,1997,(3):83- 87.
[3]. ɳչ [M]. :йѧ,1997.
[4]ʦ. ɳչ͵ľ [M]. :㶫Ƽ,:й뵳У,1998.

ոڣ1998-08-13
