йѧ
CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE
1999 195ڡVol.19 No.5 1999



־ˮоеӦ
衡
ժҪ־ָʾȾΣЧӦź.ɷΪ,һָʾкʵı¶;һָʾȾĶЧӦ.ֶ,־רһԡԤԺ͹㷺.ĽָʾˮȾҪ־.תøͽ򵰰ЧرˮелؽӰ.DNAӺｫлȾŴʱ,˳Ϊ̬ѧоȵ.л־ȱݺͲ,չ˸Ӧǰ.
ؼʣ־¶ЧӦˮ
ͼţX171.5 ױʶ룺A ±ţ1000- 6923(1999)05- 0421- 06
Application of biomarkers in aquatic environmental research.
WANG Hai-li, TAO Shu
(Department of Urban and Environmental Sciences, Peking University, Beijing 100871, China). China Environmental Science. 1999,19(5)421426
AbstractAs the biological responses that indicate deleterious effects of pollutants in the environment, biomarkers can be classified into two types, indicating the exposure of organisms to the contaminants and the toxic effects of the pollutants. Compared to other monitoring techniques, biomarkers possess the advantages of specificity, early warning and extensive applicability. Currently applied biomarkers in aquatic environments are introduced in this paper. Both biotransformation enzymes and metallothioneins are able to indicate the effects of organic pollutants and heavy metals on aquatic organisms. DNA adducts can serve as indicators for the relationship between organic pollution and genetic mutation. The disadvantages of biomarkers are also discussed and the future prospects are evaluated as well.
Key wordsbiomarkerexposureeffectsaquatic environment
ſƼĽ͹ҵķչ,ĻѧƼ,,ڳϵ,ؽ뻷.Щ뻷صѧƼ,ͳΪ(xenobiotics),ɷΪ¼:໷(PAHs);(PCBs);л;㻯;лסлȵ[1].ݹ,ĿǰдԼ10˹ϳɵĻѧƼ,ÿ1500ֵٶȵ.10%Ļвİȫ[2].,ڽŷŵ֮ǰ,ҪбҪķ(risk assessment).һĻѧⷽȻܶԻȾﺬж,ƾ޷ӳЩȾЧӦ[3].ʵڽеĶԻ(toxicity bioassay),ҲʵĽ綨,ȾʵʻеЧӦ.Ҫ˽ȾֳЧӦ.Ⱦﺬܵ,໥,ϵ,ҪԻӰ,ҪоȾڸָı仯[4,5].ڴ˱,־(biomarker)ڻоеӦܵ.Ľ־Ķ塢ƺ;,ˮоеӦ״Ҫ.
1 塢
־,ȽϾĶͨⶨҺϸ֯,ϸϽʾȾڻķӦָ[6].ʵ,־֯βϸ֯,ӦѧΪѧԼѧȸ[7].,־꾡;ȷӦͨҺ֯,ܹһֻֻѧȾı¶()ЧӦϸΪϵı仯[8].ͳ˵,־ǿɺȾı¶ЧӦﷴӦ[9].
ӹϿ,־ɷΪ,һָʾȾı¶,ȾķӦ,ָʾؽ¶ļĵ(򵰰,metallothioneins,MT).Ȼ־ﲻָʾȾĶЧӦ,оԻѧѼ⵽ĻеĲȶı¶[6].һָʾȾЧӦĽ״,ָʾDNA˵DNAӺ(DNA-adducts).ڻѧо,һ־иҪ.ǿɽȾﶾЧӦķӷӦ,ڴǰ,ȷȾڵõ֮໥Ӱ[9].
1 ־ϵ*
Table 1 Hierarchy of biomarkers

֯Ч Ӧ־﹦ʱ߶
ӷЧӦָʾ¶s
ϸ/ϸϸЧӦָʾЧӦmin
֯/ͼЧӦ
ֳ,ָʾ̬ı仯h
Ⱥֳ½ĸļٽ׷ֳȺ˥Ŵ콵͡month
Ⱥָܵʾı仯a
̬ϵͳԵĽ͡

ע:* ȡ[10,11]
Ⱦ,ε֯,С,̬ϵͳ,иӦȾЧӦõ־,γϵ(1).һ˵,ϵ,ȸε͵ı־(ӡϸϸ֯)ӦԵ,־ⶨɱϸ;Եı־ΪķԼ̬ѧ[12].Ƚ϶,ϵеͲα־ṩضϢ,ܶԽʾȾı.־о༯ڷӻϸˮƽ,Щ־ѵõ㷺֤ʵ;ȺȺ̬ϵͳϵ־оĳʼ׶[13].Ⱦص΢־ı仯,һ̶Ͻʾĳ,ӹĽǶ,־شʩжȷ[14].
־ͻ3.
1.1 
ضлȾؽı¶,ض־.Щ־Ⱦ״߱(diagnostic).һ˽ӦķӷӦ,߲ε̬Σ,־ṩרһԵԤ(prognostic)[6].
1.2 Ԥ
Ⱦ֮е໥öʼڷˮƽ.־ĲǶȾﱩ¶ڷӦ,־Ⱦﱩ¶ͶЧӦھָʾ[15].
1.3 㷺
3 ΢۷ӵ̬ϵͳ,־ڸͬε֯Ⱦ֮ϵ;һ˵֮Ĺڷˮƽ,־,MTDNAӺ,ɹ㷺Ӧڸ[4,16];־ȿʵо,Ҳֳʵʼ.ȾĶԻ,ڽСķΧ,ƹ㵽Ұ.
2 ־
,־ڿȷȾ֮ѷ໥,ⶨȾЧӦ(sublethal effects).,־Ҫ7[6].
ܹ˽ЧԵȾʱͿռϵۻЧӦ,ѧ,԰ѳ.˲쳣״򹤳ЪŷŴ.
ȷȾ뱩¶ͷյĶӦϵ.ͨﷴӦ,ӻ˽ΣӰ,ϵ,ڴ¼ʱ巨Ҫ.
ӦڲͬͬӪ,ԽʾȾﲻͬı¶;,⽫ȷⷽȴ,ԲȡָԤͲȴʩṩѧ.
ԻȻӳضȾԶ,ѽʵҰ.Ӱ,绯ѧ̬/աȾʳϵĸԼõЧӦȵ,޷ڶвⶨ.Ӧ־Բֵؽ.
ڻ״лȥȾ,PAHsл׻,־ͬʱָʾĸ廯ʹлı¶ͶЧӦ.
ֻܹȾ֮䶾໥õۻЧӦ.
ͬ֯(ӷӵȺȺ)õһϵвⶨо,ͨ־Ķڱ仯пԤȾﳤڵ̬ЧӦ.
3 ָʾˮȾҪ־
3.1 ϸɫP4501A1 (Cytochrome P4501A1)
ﶼתø(biotransformation enzymes)ͽⶾø(detoxification enzymes),ɽ֬лתˮԵġױйĴл.øڵ֯,ˮ׵˵,к.ʵ³´лΪ׶.,ͨøԭøˮøˮø,ʷһ(ҪǻȻ);Ȼ,ø,ʹԴԵˮܷӽ(׸ġȩ).ͨлȾܽȴﵽⶾ,ЩлܱתɷǳԾĴл,ԾΣЧӦ[17].
ϸɫP4501A1һ΢ӵø,ڶлPAHsPCBs㻯תĵһ׶ηҪ[18].ڲ鶯,ʼ(Ah receptor)յ.еϸɫP4501A1о֤ʵ,״Ϳյ벸鶯еķǳ[19].ֲϸɫP4501A1ΪлȾ־ĸ.ͨⶨP4501A1ĳЩø,Զյм.Ŀǰõ7-һ±һø(7-ethoxyresorufin O-deethylase,EROD)ͱǻø(benzopyrene hydroxylase,BPH).
ʵµʵ,PAHsPCBs±ͻеȾԭ͡ȡҺƯţƤֽҺ,յεP4501A1[18,20].ϸɫP4501A1ΪлȾ־,ѾӦҰֳо.ол,ϸɫP4501A1Ⱦﺬ֮ڽԵļӦ(dose-response)ϵ[4,18,21-23].ļӦϵ,EROD㷺ӦõһԭǸòⶨԼΪƷ,ʵֺƹ.ĿǰERODļѾʵԶ[24,25].
ˮ׵,ˮ޼׵ӵøо.ݹ۲,лȾ۵Ľ˵[26].ǵERODһϵ,뼹׵,жP4501A1յĸݾԵòȷ[5].
3.2 򵰰
ڶн򵰰(MT)Ĵ.MTǷϵ(6-7 kDa),װĵ,ͨװĲлɽ.MTɵԴؽCuZn,ֹŨȹ߲,ͬĻCdHgؽӽⶾ,ɻڵ[27].CdCuZnCoNiؽܼMTת¼,MTΪ¶־.MTûд߻,ֻͨⶨж.Ҫķųӽɫ׵ķMT׷,ԭչײⶨؽ;ⶨMTԱǵCd֮Ľȡ;׷򴼵ĺ;߻ѧmRNA.
MTѾڶڵõо.ϸͻʵ,۲⵽еMTZnCuCdȽյ,һ̷ת¼׶[28].ڵMTˮ֯еؽ֮.Ⱦˮ,ĸࡢȲλMTϸ[29].P4501A1ͬ,ˮ޼׵һ,¶CdCuHgZnؽʱ,ܺԵؼ⵽MTı仯[30].޼׵ڵMTڵĲͬ,ǵķϴ,ԼΪ12.5kDa,װ,ʰ϶,еĻз.,MTΪؽ¶־,ˮ൱㷺÷Χ.
3.3 DNAӺ
ĳЩлȾ,PAHsùص,л׵ӵĲ,͵ʽ,γɹۼӺ.DNAӺγʵաлʹ޸̵ۺϽ,Ĳͻĳֺγ,ǻѧĳʼ׶.DNAӺʺΪˮлȾﱩ¶ЧӦ־[6,31].ⶨҪӫⷨ;ضӺĵ¡Ͷ¡߲ⶨ;32PǷ;GC/MS.Ŀǰõ32PǷ.÷ľ岽ȽDNAˮ,ĺͼӺֱγɸԵĵ,ͨøѧȡķӺŨ,32P;Ǻĺᾭɫ׷,ⶨзԵƬ,ӶDNAӺﶨ.˷ȿɴﵽ1010мһӺ.
ʵ֤,Աźͷ㰷ı¶γɵDNAӺܹܺõָʾЩлȾ״[32,33].ƵĽͽ嶯Ҳõ֤ʵ[34].йˮĶҰо,ˮDNAӺȾ֮żӦϵ[35,36].
DNAӺָʾǻеȾŴʵӰ.չ־о,˽кʵŴ,ڴӱڻвµĽȺ̬仯,л.,־ŴѧоΪ̬ѧһ·[12,37,38].
4 
־ȾŹؼԵָʾ,Ӧÿ䱾ҲȱݺͲ,ͻ3.
4.1 ֽ׶,־ĲⶨȽ,൱.
4.2 Щ־Բ.һֱ־ӦȾЧӦ򻷾еȻвı־.
4.3 ־ָʾʵʻµı¶ЧӦʱ,Ȳ.,־Ϊ۵ֶβܵ,Ҳ޷ȫȡ,ӦóΪȾۺϼϵһЧɲ,һϵȻӦѧⷽ.
־ھź,ӳӽһ(continuum)ȷλ.Ȼ,ȾΣǰ־״,ƶԤԵĹʩ,ʱỷȾ𺦶Ҫ.־̬Ӧǰ.
ĿҽܳĿ(49525102)
߼飺(1971-),,ɽ,ѧ뻷ѧϵʿ,Ҫ»ѧо.17ƪ.
ߵλѧ뻷ѧϵ, 100871
οף
[1]Sheehan D. Environmental biochemistry [J]. The Biochemist, 1994(June/July): 34- 37.
[2]Steinberg C E W,Geyer H J,Kettrup AAF, et al. Evaluation of xenobiotic effects by ecological techniques [J]. Chemosphere, 1994, 28: 357- 374.
[3]L pez-Barea J,Pueyo C. Mutagen content and metabolic activation of promutagens by molluscs as biomarkers of marine pollution [J]. Mutation Research, 1998, 399: 3- 15.
[4]Haux C,L F?rlin. Biochemical methods for detecting effects of contaminants on fish [J]. AMBIO, 1988, 17: 376- 380.
[5]Livingstone D R. Towards a specific index of impact by organic pollution for marine invertebrates [J]. Comp. Biochem. Physiol., 1991, 100C: 151- 155.
[6]McCarthy J F,Shugart L R (Eds.) Biomarkers of environmental contamination [M]. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, 1990.
[7]Widdows J,Donkin P. Role of physiological energetics in ecotoxicology [J]. Comp. Biochem. Physiol., 1991,100C:69- 75.
[8]Depledge M H,Aagaard A, Gy?rk?s P. Assessment of trace metal toxicity using molecular, physiological and behavioural biomarkers [J]. Mar. Pollut. Bull., 1995, 31: 19- 27.
[9]Walker, C H. Biochemical biomarkers in ecotoxicologyCsome recent developments [J]. Sci. Total Environ., 1995,171:189- 195.
[10]Depledge M H. Conceptual paradigms in marine ecotoxicology [A]. In: Proceedings of the 12th Baltic Marine Biologists Symposium [C].Fredensborg,Denmark: Olsen & Olsen, 1993, 47- 52.
[11]Bickham W,Smolen M J. Somatic and heritable effects of environmental genotoxins and the emergence of evolutionary toxicology [J]. Environ. Health Perspect., 1994, 102 (suppl.12): 25- 28.
[12]Evenden A J,Depledge M H. Genetic susceptibility in ecosystems:The challenge for ecotoxicology [J]. Environ. Health Perspect., 1997, 105(suppl. 4): 849- 854.
[13]Peakall D B. Biomarkers: the way forward in environmental assessment [J]. Toxicol. Ecotoxicol. News, 1994,1:55- 60.
[14]Livingstone D R. Biotechnology and pollution monitoring: use of molecular biomarkers in the aquatic environment [J]. J. Chem. Tech. Biotechnol., 1993, 57: 195- 211.
[15]Moore M N,Simpson M G. Molecular and cellular pathology in environmental impact assessment [J]. Aquat. Toxicol., 1992, 22: 313- 322.
[16]Chipman J K,Marsh J W. Bio-techniques for the detection of genetic toxicity in the aquatic environment [J]. J. Biotechnol., 1991, 17: 199- 208.
[17]Buhler D R,Williams D E. The role of biotransformation in the toxicity of chemicals [J]. Aquat. Toxicol.,1988,11:19- 28.
[18]Goksyr A,F?rlin L. The cytochrome P450 system in fish, aquatic toxicology and environmental monitoring [J]. Aquat. Toxicol., 1992, 22: 287- 312.
[19]Stegeman J J,Lech J J. Cytochrome P450 monooxygenase systems in aquatic species: carcinogen metabolism and biomarkers for carcinogen and pollutant exposure [J]. Environ. Health Perspect., 1991, 90: 101- 109.
[20]Collier T K,Varanasi U. Hepatic activities of xenobiotic metabolizing enzymes and biliary levels of xenobiotics in English sole (Parophrys vetulus) exposed to environmental contaminants [J]. Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol., 1991,20: 462- 473.
[21]Stegeman J J,Kloeper-Sams P J,Farrington J W. Monooxygenase induction and chlorobiphenyls in the deep-sea fish Coryphaenoides armatus [J]. Science, 1986, 231: 1287- 1289.
[22]Goksyr A.,Larsen H E,Husy A M. Application of a cytochrome P-450 1A1-ELISA in environmental monitoring and toxicological testing of fish [J]. Comp. Biochem. Physiol., 1991, 100C: 157- 160.
[23]Lange U, Jedamski J, Siebers D, et al. Ethoxyresorufin O-deethylase and cytochrome P450 in the liver of dab (Limanda limanda (L.)) from the central and southern North Sea [J]. Mar. Pollut. Bull., 1992, 24: 446- 451.
[24]Goksyr A A. Semi-quantitative cytochrome P4501A1 ELISA: a simple method for studying the monooxygenase induction response in environmental monitoring and ecotoxicological testing of fish [J]. Sci. Total Environ., 1992, 101: 255- 262.
[25]Eggens M L,Galgani F. Ethoxyresorufin O-deethylase (EROD) activity in flatfish: fast determination with a fluorescence plate-reader [J]. Mar. Environ. Res., 1992, 33: 213- 221.
[26]Porte C,Sole M,Albaiges J, et al. Responses of mixed-function oxygenase and antioxidase enzyme system of Mytilus sp. to organic pollution [J]. Comp. Biochem. Physiol., 1991, 100C: 183- 186.
[27]Kille P,Kay J,Leaver M, et al. Induction of piscine metallothionein as a primary response to heavy metal pollutants: applicability of new sensitive molecular probes [J]. Aquat. Toxicol., 1992, 22: 279- 286.
[28]Hogstrand C,Haux C. Metallothionein as an indicator of heavy-metal exposure in two subtropical fish species [J]. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol., 1990, 138: 69- 84.
[29]Overnell J,Abdullah M I. Metallothionein and metal levels in flounder Platichthys flesus from four field sites and in flounder dosed with water brone copper [J]. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser., 1988, 46:71- 74.
[30]Livingstone D R,Pipe R K. Mussels and environmental contaminants: bioaccumulation and physiological aspects [M]. In: E. Gosling (Eds.) The Mussel Mytilus: Ecology, Physiology, Genetics and Culture, Developments in Aquaculture and Fisheries Science, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1992, 25:425- 464.
[31]Dunn B P. Carcinogen adducts as an indicator for the public health risks of consuming carcinogen-exposed fish and shellfish [J]. Environ. Health Perspect., 1991, 90: 111- 116.
[32]Thomas P. Molecular and biochemical responses of fish to stressors and their potential use in environmental monitoring [A]. In: S.M. Adams (Eds.) Biological Indicators in Fish, Amer. Fish [C]. Soc. Symp. 8, 1990, 9- 28.
[33]Stein J E,Reichert W L,Nishimot M, et al. Overview of studies on liver carcinogenesis in English sole from Puget Sound; evidence for a xenobiotic chemical etiology II: biochemical studies [J]. Sci. Total Environ., 1990, 94: 51- 69.
[34]James M O,Altman A H,Li CLT, et al. Dose-andtime-dependent formation of benzo[a]pyrene metabolite DNA adducts in spiny lobster, Panulirus argus [J]. Mar. Environ. Res., 1992, 34: 299- 302.
[35]Garg A,Krca S,Kurelec B, et al. Endogenous DNA modification in aquatic organisms and their probable biological significance [J]. Comp. Biochem. Physiol., 1992, 102B: 825- 832.
[36]Stein J E,Reichert W L,Varanasi U. Molecular epizootiology: assessment of exposure to genotoxic compounds in teleosts [J]. Environ. Health Perspect., 1994, 102(suppl.12): 19- 23.
[37]Depledge M H. The ecotoxicological significance of genotoxicity in marine invertebrates [J]. Mutation Res.,1998, 399:109 - 122.
[38]Walker C H. The use of biomarkers to measure the interactive effects of chemicals [J]. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf., 1998, 40: 65- 70.
ոڣ1999-01-25
