ֺ뻷
JOURNAL OF GEOLOGICAL HAZRDS AND ENVIRONMENT PRESERVATION
1999 10 3 vol.10 No.3 1999



˷϶Ϸо 
ǳɽȪ
ժҪں˷ϵʴùУ漰ҺӰؼ⡣ԹһоĽչ״һܺԽһо˷Χȫ
ؼʣȫϷˮӦأѧӦ
ͼţTL942+.1ױʶ룺A
A REVIEW OF RESEARCH ON THE COUPLED ANALYSIS OF
RADIOACTIVE WASTES BURIAL IN FRACTURED ROCK MASS
Liu YachenWu Yushan Liu Quansheng
(Institute of Rock and Soil Mechanics,The Chinese Academy of Sciences,Wuhan430071)
Abstract:The progress and the state of art of the research on the effect of three factors,namely thermalhydrological and mechanical effect,and the coupled problem are reviewed in the paper.Analytical methods for further researches are also made.
Key words:fully-coupled analysis;underground water flow;additional pressure;thermal loading;mechanical response of the rock mass
ں˷ϵ´ùУڷͬλ˥䣬˷Χҽʵ¶ߣӰ塢ˮʣҶӦˮҲҪãͬʱˮΪһֻأѧʺȶҪӰ죻һ棬Լеĸֲ(ϲ㡢϶)ֱȴˮҪá໥ϵ໥ԼʣЧӦġӺ˷ʴ˷ΧҸһʻУ¶ȳ(Thermal)(Hydrological)Ӧ(Mechanical)(ƣTHM)ʻеҪɲ֣ϵͳĽǶΧTHMϵͳ໥õıȻ19983£ʢвһ90104(gallon)ķԺ˷й©Ǻ˷ΧTHMʧƻˮѭӾĽˣź˷ϵʽʱҪ㹻ʵϣƶͬƷһҪָ϶ΧϵͳеˮӦصµ϶ѧӦں˷ϵİȫƣͬʱҲƶ˷϶ԵˮԴȾо⣬ʯͺȻȿɹУΪƺĿɷˮ͵λƣշĸֺоṩѧݣϣϷоǶģʽǨƻƼɵоӶٽѧ۵Ĺ㷺оʹѧ۸ܷӳʵʣʮҪ塣
˷ϵоҪ漰صӰ죬(Thermal)Һ(Hydrological)(Mechanical)Աֱؼ⿪չ˻оⷽоԵ
1漰صо
1.1˷ϵӰ
Mufti1(1971)ⲻ̬ͬʹСΧ¶ͬλ˥䳣֮ϵļ㷽Harkonen2ݡStephansson3ݡBeale4(1979)Hodgkinson57(19801983)ֱԸ߷Ź̻ĺ˷¶ȳ˽òͬļ㷽ָ̽¶ȳΧȵӦԼˮɣຣ89(19971998)̽еͷź˷ϵ´öΧҽ()¶ȳӰ죬ͬʱ˻ҽʵӦЧӦ
1.2˷ϵ϶Χڲͬµĵˮ
ռˮҪ֣رӴ(εò)Ǳˮ桪ˮͷãȶ¶ݶãʹ϶Էµ
Parts10(1966)ý̽ڶ׽ȶĹɣͬʱˮƽȶӰ죻Hodgkinson67(19801983)˺˷Χˮȶѧģͣü̽˶ɣˮƽȶӰ죻Wickens11(1984)Ԫģ˷ΧҵˮģʽͬʱǱˮ漰ȶãLowell12(1990)̽ȵԶƽ϶϶Ӱ죬Ϊã϶Ագ˶Abdallah13(1995)ɢԪ̽ڲˮȴԲͬˮµȶ⡣
1.3϶ΧҽԶҺӰӦ
(1) ϶ϵͳеͳԼ
ʵʵʹṹкдͬ򡢹ģ״ķԽṹ(ϲ㡢϶)ʹڹ̹ѧϳַǾʡԡĸ壻ͬʱֳΪˮҪͨʹ͸ԳʷǾȸԡΪоЩԣձøҰֳʵͳݣṹ缸Ըģ͵ķ
1965꣬Walsh14ݵĶƪ̽϶ʯĿѹԺģӰ죻1969꣬JaegerCook15ݶԵؽ϶ʯѧʵӰ죻19741976 OConnell,Budiansky16Ǣ(the self-consistent method)϶йصӦֺۣ̽϶ʯЧģʯģ֮Ĺϵģ϶ܶȵĹϵͬʱ̽˱϶嵯ģ϶ܶȵĹϵ1976꣬Gregory17ݶԿ϶бĳҵĸģ仯ʵоȻˮͶȶԸģӰ죻1986꣬Oda35ݵĶƪĲõЧ׼򣬼Ӧԭ϶(crack tensor)϶ĸ(Բ)1995ܴ꣬18Ӧαܵԭ϶ĸԵԲ1997꣬üף19ܽǰоɹĻϣ̽ԶԸ̬ģӰ(϶)
(2) ¶ȶ϶ͨ϶ܶӰ
Molen20(1981)ʯӢ¶ȶѹԺͶϵӰ֣̽1987꣬ȫ2122϶ܶȿʯ˳̶ȣ1992꣬Germanovich23Ӧ͸ۣ϶Ⱥ϶ܶ仯ļ㹫ʽָ϶պϵĸBruhn24(1994)ڽе϶ˮѭ֣̽ģ϶ܶȵı仯ϵ͸ЧӦ϶Էձ仯ɣ¶ȴ300ʱ϶еˮѭɷӡϯ25(1998)Ի¶Ϊ-60600淶Χڽģʵ飬¶ߣģ½½
(3) ϶͸
Oda2627(19851987)Ӧ϶϶͸ܴ18(1995)Ӧ϶͸28(19961998)ϵˮѧר⽲ϵͳܽоɹˮѧģ͡ˮȷŽţ29(1997)ѧۣо϶͸ϵˮѹӦĹϵBrown30(1998)ӦOdaģͣӳ϶ͨ˵ıʽ˼Ӧ͸ԵӰ졣
(4) ϶͸¶ȵĹϵ
Morrow31(1981)ģ˷ϻ飬ⶨԴ¶ȱ200310棬ѹΪ1020 MPaΧѹΪ3060 MPaµ͸ʣ͸¶ȶ½ԭΪǻеĿɷڸܽӣܽ½£Moore32(1983)Morrowͬ¶ݶͨˮŵĻѧӦԣԽLowell33(1993)ģͣ̽϶ˮϵͳ¶Ӱɷ(SiO2)ܽȱ仯ʯȵӦӰ죬Ҳ˵ɷܽˮѹйϵMartin34(1997)һչLowell33(1993)ģͣʹøģֵģʵʵмµ϶ȱ仯ϵʽΪ

ʽУb,bmΪ϶뿪ȡƽ϶뿪ȣrΪʯϵvΪɱȣΪUΪճϵcSiO2ΪSiO2ŨȣTfΪ¶ȣTΪֲ¶ʼ¶֮
2HMTHMо
ѧϴHMTHMģͣЧģ͡϶ģ͡˫ؽģ͡ѧЩоͬϼ㷽ҪеЧɢ
2.1HM
Oda35(1986)õЧģͽ̡Һʵ⣬ģͷ˲ӦͼӦã϶͸ܵ϶ӦԵϹϵڣ3637(1996)ԼбҲʵ֣̽ΪڲͬӦ϶ڼбʹȼ٣ӵı仯鿡38(1998)ӦµĽӴ϶оֽ̽Ӵ϶ڴӦˮͷµɣܴ18(1995)оͬʱʹýͳȷREVĽ⣻ʢ39(1998)ϵͳ϶Ӧоһ϶Ӧо϶ӦϷ
2.2THM
Ժ˷ΧTHMϹ̵о90䡢ձӢϽΪDECOVALEX40ݵĹʺоĿڶȡҺϹ̽ۺʵо
(1) ģ϶THM÷Ӧõķ
 ɢ ֱӱʾÿTHMԵĲ档
 Ч һ־Ȼġ־THMԵĵЧʣʾеҿͲ档
(2) THMϹ̵
THMϹ̼ͼͼ1

ͼ1THMϹ̼ͼ
Fig.1THM coupled analysis process
ͼ1иͬ˵
-aΪ¶йصĹԱ仯-bΪշӦ䣻-aΪйصԱ仯-bΪڲɢΪ¶йصԱ仯ΪȶΪѹԹѧʵӰ죻Ϊ϶Ⱥ͸ʵı仯
(3) DECOVALEXʺĿTHMϹ̵о
ɢоСУINERISENSMPС飬õķΪɢԪ޵ԪЧоСУձKPHСͷCEA/DMTС顣
a. ɢ˷õĿƷǣƽ̡ⷽͲѧ̣Լˮ̡
INERISСUDECTHM϶⡣UDECص㣬ȫģTHMϹ̡ԣTHMϹ̼ͼеĢ-a-a-bñˡ
ENSMPСöά޵ԪTHM϶⡣ͬ޷Ǣ-a-a-bܵá
b. Ч˷ѧԭ˶ɵغ㷽̡
KPHСOda϶ģͣԪTHM϶⡣˷ȽȫؿTHMϹ̡
CEA/DMTСڵReussģͣSnowģͣͬԪTHM϶⡣˷ûпǢ-a-a-bܣݵá
(4) ַģ
üٶͨ϶Ϊ׼(BMT1)ģⷽбȽϣȺ棬ַģǺϣ棬ȴ𣬵һԭ϶ȳʷ¡
3
Ժ˷ϵʴõо֣ˮṹѧӦҪɺ˷Ϸͬλ˥շģշˮѧӦǺ˷ⰲȫƱ뿼ǵءˣڷˮѧӦʱЧӦڵˮоУӦҪˮ˶ѧӦоУӦҪȵӦԼӰ(ͨ϶ȱ仯)Ϸ£
3.1 ʵʩ
(1) ܽǰ˶THMؼϵĻϣȷоĵо弰䲻μصԣȻĵ͸Ļ(Ȼ)ȷͣѡо;ͷصǵˮصѧӦ
(2) ˷϶ΧTHMϿƷ飬˶غ㷽̡
(3) ڶϣıʽ(ɡȰ(Biot)廢˶ɡҶȴ)THMѧģ͡
3.2ȡķ
(1) ֿˮѭص㣬ʵѡȡ϶THMϷ϶ģͺ϶ѧģ͡ڴ϶ʱ϶ȱ仯ӦǸӦ͡϶ѧɷֵȱ仯صӰ죻ʯģ仯ʱӦԭ϶˺ͱˮصӰ졣
(2) Ҫȫ˽THMأTHMϹǡ£
-a ã϶嵯¶(϶ܶ)Լϵ¶ȵĹϵ
-b ãӳBiotĹ廢˶С
-a ãѧȴеõ֣غʾιеȺɢ
-b ãҪ(ˮ̰)
 ãӦ¶ȵĹϵ
 ãڴпǴаܶȿ¶ȵĺ
 ã̫ɳЧӦԭ
 ã϶ȱ仯غ㷽еõ֣϶THM͸ʱʽTHMϵģýڴʽеõ֣ĺֱӷӳTHMϷĳɰܣⷽ
3.3˷ȫϷдڸε̽
˷ϵ϶ȫϷһϵͳ̣轨ڸɿۺͼ֮ϡ(ҪǷ)֮ѿչ˹㷺ĺоĿǰҹѿʼоϣ̽רҡڡԱעһ⡣
߼飺ǳУ33ꡣʿо1995ҵ人ˮѧˮϵ˶ʿѧλзʯԺо
ߵλйѧԺ人ѧо人430071
ο
1ݡMufti,I R. Geothermal aspects of radioactive waste disposal into the subsurfaceJ.Journal of Geophysical Research, 1971.11,76(35):85688585.
2ݡHarkonen,H,et al..Temperature distribution and thermally induced stresses in a highlevel waste.In underground disposal of radioactive wastesJ.IAEA,Vienna,1979,2:149158.
3ݡStephansson,O,et al..Modelling of temperature fields and deformations for radioactive waste repositories in hard rock.In underground disposal of radioactive wastesJ.IAEA,Vienna,1979,2:121133.
4ݡBeale,H,et al..Thermal aspects of radioactive waste disposal in hard rock.In underground disposal of radioactive wastesJ.IAEA,Vienna,1979,2:137158.
5ݡHodgkinson,D P,et al..Initial assessment of the thermal stresses around a radioactive waste depository in hard rockJ.Annals of nuclear Energy,1980,7:541552.
6ݡHodgkinson,D P,et al..A mathematical model for hydrothermal convection around a radioactive waste depository in hard rockJ.Annals of nuclear Energy,1980,7:313334.
7ݡHodgkinson,D P,et al..Thermal aspects of radioactive wastes burial in hard rockJ.Progress in nuclear Energy,1983,11(2):183218.
8ݡຣ .ҽдеͷź˷ϵӦJ.ֺ뻷1998.69(2)4548.
9ݡຣ .еͷź˷ϵ´öΧҽ()¶ȳӰJ.ֺ뻷1997.128(4)5458.
10ݡPrats,M.The effect of horizontal fluid flow on thermally induced convection currents in porous mediumsJ.Journal of Geophysical Research,1966.10,71(20):48354838.
11ݡWickens,L M.Finite-element modelling of groundwater flow in hard rock regions containing a heat-emitting radioactive waste depositoryJ.Ann.nucl.Energy,1984,11(1/2):1525.
12ݡLowell,R P. Thermoelasticity and the formation of black smokersJ.Geophysical Research Letters,1990.5,17(6):709712.
13ݡAbdallah,G,et al..Thermal convection of fluid in fractured mediaJ.Int.J.Rock Mech.Min.Sci & Geomech.Abstr.,1995,32(5):481490.
14ݡWalsh,J B.The effect of cracks on the uniaxial elastic compression of rocksJ.Journal of Geophysical Research,1965.1,70(2):399411.
15ݡӢJ C Ү·N G W  ,пԺѧ.ʯѧM.ѧ磬1981.
16ݡBudiansky,B.et al..Elastic moduli of a cracked solidJ. Int.J. Solids Structures.1976,12:8197.
17ݡGregory,A R.Fluid saturation effects on dynamic elastic properties of sedimentary rocksJ.Geophysics,1976.10,41(5):895921.
18ݡܴ.϶ӦϷоD.人ˮѧʿѧλģ1995.
19ݡü.ʯּʯѧķоM.ʳ磬1997.11.
20ݡ Molen,V I.The shift of the - transition temperature of quartz associated with the thermal expansion of granite at high pressureJ.Techonphysics,1981,73(1):323342.
21ݡȫ.ȿ˶ԻұμƻԵӰJ.ѧѧ1987.1119(6)550556.
22ݡȫ .΢϶ͻҵĿǿȣJ.ѧѧ1987.719(4)366373.
23ݡGermanovich,L N,et al..Percolation theory,Thermoelasticity,and discrete hydrothermal venting in the earths crustJ.Science,1992.3,255:15641567.
24ݡBruhn,R L,et al..Fracturing and hydrothermal alteration in normal fault zonesJ.Pure Appl.Geophys.,1994,142(3/4):609644.
25ݡϯ .¶ȶʯģͲٵӰJ.ʯѧ빤ѧ1998.1117()802807.
26ݡOda M .Permeability tensor for discontinuous rock massesJ.Geotechnique,1985,35(4):483495.
27ݡOda M,et al..Numerical experiments on permeability tensor and its application to jointed granite at Strip a Mine,SwedenJ.Journal of Geophysical Research,1987.6,92(B8):80378048.
28ݡ.ˮѧ(һ)()J.ˮĵʹ̵ʣ19961998.
29ݡŽ .϶ԵоJ.ú̿ѧ1997.1022(5)481485.
30ݡBrown,S R,et al..Fluid permeability of deformable fracture networksJ.Journal of Geophysical Research,1998.2,103(B2):24892500.
31ݡMorrow,C,et al..Permeability of Granite in a temperature gradientJ.Journal of Geophysical Research,1981.4,86(B4):30023008.
32ݡMoore,D E,et al..Chemical reactions accompanying fluid flow through granite held in a temperature gradientJ.Geochimic et cosmochimica Acta,1983,47:445453.
33ݡLowell,R P, et al..Silica precipitation in fractures and the evolution of permeability in hydrothermal upflow zonesJ.Science,1993,260(9):192194.
34ݡMartin,J T,et al..On thermoelasticity and silcica precipitation in hydrothermal systems:Numerical modelling of laboratory experimentsJ.Journal of Geophysical Research,1997.6,102(B6):1209512107.
35ݡOda , M.An equivalent continuum model for coupled stress and fliud flow analysis in jointed rock massesJ.Water Resources Research,1986.11,22(13):18451856.
36ݡ .͸ϵӦ䡢ӦĹϵJ.廪ѧѧ199636(1)107112.
37ݡ .϶ˮԵʵоJ.廪ѧѧ199636(1)102106.
38ݡ鿡 .Ӧ϶ԵоJ.ѧԺԺ1998.615(3)3539.
39ݡʢ .϶ӦоJ.ѧ1998.619(2)9298.
40ݡDECOVALEX-An International Co-Operative Research Processes for Safety Analysis of Radioactive Waste RepositoriesJ.Int.J.Rock Mech.Sci.& Abstr.,1995,32(5):389398.
