ѧѧ
ACTASCIENTIAECIRCUMSTANTIAE
19986µ186ڿƼڿ
ߵȻרҵγ̽ṹͽѧʵʩȽо
½ǿ١ŸӾ
(Ͼѧѧ빤ϵȾԴоصʵңϾ210093)

ժҪ5ѧΪͷ价רҵĿγ̽ṹͽѧʵʩĻ״ҹ˱Ƚо.оγ̽ṹͽѧʵʩԲҪ9棺רҵĿꣻʽγ̵ãγϵṹѧƣĿγãʱӳ¹۵۵Ŀγ̣Ŀѧѧγã߿γ̣Դγ̺רҵѧʽ.ȽоΪ9Ϊҹ޶౾רҵͻѧҪĽ.ͬʱṩĳЩвοֵĿγʵ.
ؼʡߵȻγ̽ṹȽо.

COMPARATIVE STUDY ON ENVIRONMENTAL PROGRAMS (MAJORS) OF HIGHER ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION BETWEEN CHINA AND THE UNITED STATES

Yin Daqiang, Lu Genfa, Ding Shurong, Xu Ouyong
(State Key Laboratory of Pollution Control and Resource Reuse,Department of Environmental Science and Engineering, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210093)

ABSTRACTIn this paper,the present status of environmental programs (majors) concerning undergraduates and graduate students in US higher education was investigated, and compared with China.The comparative studies showed that there were lots of differences in setting up of environmental programs or majors between China and USA,and indicated that the setting up of environmental programs of majors in US higher education had some characteristics of follows:(1) there were many more environmental programs or majors set up at universities and colleges; (2) the ratio of environmental programs or majors concerning humanities and social sciences was higher; (3) some programs or majors concerning tranining of environmental teachers for popularized environmental education were set up; (4) much more attention was paid to the field of environmental health in setting up programs or majors; (5) the training of comprehensive personnel was more striking in US higher environmental education.Those mentioned above can provide the reference for decision makers in setting up environmental programs or majors and developing higher environmental education by the authorities of the Chinese government.
Keywordshigher environmental education,environmental programs or majors,comparative study.
ѡߵѧУ౾רҵод5ѧԻרҵγ̽ṹͽѧʵʩϴ9ҹԶԱȣΪоƶҹУרҵͽѧҪԼߵȻչսṩо.

1רҵĿĲ
ҹԱĿǿרҡ͡ר˲šҪҵרҵܡԿڡѧΨרҵ֪ʶȲΪӹȣ±ҵӦС.רҵھ.һ棬ӶѧȫĻʵڡ֪ʶ͡ˡУ߽Ϊ.ѧԱĿ꣬Ƚע߼ˣ籱ɴѧĹѧԺıѧλרҵ(ѧרҵΪ4ѧλרҵ֮һ)ǽ㷺Ļ빫רҵϣ1.רҵйרҵְҵԱΪԺоѧϰṩһʵĻʹѧȫ淢չ.νȫ淢չʵָΪһдѧĻ.רҵѧڻýǿרҵͬʱҲЩѧڻеӦáǿӦ.

2ʽγ
ԱӦעʽ.ָ֪ʶټʹ֪ʶõطõĶ.ʾ԰4棺һ˼ʣĻ(뾫Ļ)ҵʣ.ʽ4ȫ.21Ҫ˲Ǹʵġȫ淢չ˲.ԴѧʵĽһʮָӵϵͳ̣һ桢һַʤΣͨЭЧ.ϵпγһҪķ.ʢѧСۺϽƻ(General Education Program)ȽϾϵͳԣᴩһ꼶꼶ϵпγ̣4ܹϰ40ѧ֣ΪġѧƺͿѧ(ʵΪȻѧ)3ϵУ2.ִеѧơѧۡѧѧĻеҪѧְҵ(Ethics and Professionalismľ̵ְҵ)ְҵдȵȿγ̣Լǿѧʽ.
ŦԼѧѧɭѧԺоϵоרҵڡϵͲ֡γ(൱ҹ)60ѧУĿѧ6ѧ֣γ̰ѧѧ֡ϲȣѧԼѡ3.ҹĿγ绷ѧרҵ޿дѧ˼Ʒ¡ѧۡѧ10ѧ֣һЩѧУ͡͵ѡ.Ȼ֮γòͬĿͬǿѧĻʽ.ȻְҵʽҹרҵгӣγԶԶ.ſ˴ѧѧԺְҵʽγУְҵд(Professional Writing),ְҵ(Professional Skill),Ӱ׼ͱ(Environmental Impact Analysis Preparing and Documenting)4.ŦԼѧѧɭѧԺоϵĿγУдͼо(Library Research),ѧְҵд(Writing for Science Professionals),ְҵд(Writing for Environmental Professionals)ȣ3.ҹУ軷רҵӢһţⲻ϶ѧȫҪҹڼǿ˼ʺĻʽͬʱǿְҵʽ.

3γϵͽṹѧʵʩϵĲ
ҹбѧеȱǹ涨ıѧֶ࣬ѡѧ٣רҵγ٣ѧѡ.౾רҵγеһصרҵڶ࣬漰㣬ѧѡɶȴرָѡ޿κͱ޿Ҳͬʱſιѧѡ.1гŦԼѧѧɭѧԺоרҵγ̽ṹ3ݣӱ1Կרҵ޿он϶ѡޣ޷רҵκ͡ϵͲ֡γ̱޿(൱ҹĹ)Ҳнϴѡɶ.ڿγ̽ṹϼȷָݣעⱣ֤ҪĲֵĲͬѡԱѧϰƻ.ЩԵصһ淴ӳ˻ѧƺͻĸԺۺѧԣһҲӳгõڼ˲ص㣬ӳѧҼֵԼѧĽ˼.

4ۺϷͽ
γӦۺѧԵģӦʵʻ.ѧУγӦڻõۻϣص⻷ʵ.ѧӦһԾ˼ߺ֪ʶĲߣӦԹߺ֪ʶ˼Ľߣѧ֪ʶͼӦڶԻߡʵ5.ĽӦǶѧƵۺԷˣҪѧۺϷͽʵ.ѧγбȽѧۺϵطսķ(2).2гЩγ̶ͨʵںͿֳУҹѧʮȱγ.


1ѧ౾רҵͳƱ
Table 1 The statistical table of majors for environmental undergraduate students at universities in USA

רҵ(Majors)רҵѧרҵƵʣ%
1ѧ/ȻԴά
Environmental Science/Natural Resource Conservation256
54

2//
Environment/Economics/Politics1
0.2

3ͼ
Environmental Ethics and Technology1
0.2

4ѧ
Environmental Biology and Management1
0.2

5ߡ滮
Environmental Policy,Analysis and Planning1
0.2

6ѧ
Environmental Geology7
1.5

7ѧ
Environmental Biology10
2.1

8Ƽ
Environmental Control Technologies109
23

9ͼ
Environmental Graphic Design1
0.2

10
Environmental Design2
0.4

11о
Environmental Studies40
8.5


12Ⱥлѧ
Environmental,Population and Organisms Biology1
0.2

13
Environmental Health Engineering60
12.7

(ҽ)
14ľ
Environmental and Civil Engineering1
0.2

15ʦʽ
Environmental Teacher Education1
0.2

16ϵͳ
Environmental and Urban System1
0.2

17ѧ붾ѧ
Environmental Chemistry/Toxicology1
0.2

18̿ѧ
Environmental Engineering Sciences1
0.2

19ѧ
Environmental Health Sciences1
0.2

(ҽ)
20
Environmental Policy1
0.2

21
Environmental Analysis10.2

22
Environmental Health296.1

(ҽ)

1
23ѧ
Environmental Sciences
8
1.7

24

Architectural Environmental Design
1
0.2

25
ѧ
Environmental Economics
1
0.2

26

Environmental Management
4
0.8

27
ͷ
Environmental and Waste Administration
1
0.2

28

άͿɸȻԴ
Environmental Conservation and Renewable Natural Resource Management
2
0.4

29
ѧ
Environmental Sciences and Policy
1
0.2


30

Environmental Analysis and Policy
1
0.2

31
ѧ
Environmental Chemistry
5
1.0

32
ָ
Environmental Instruction
1
0.2

33
Ϊ
Environmental Policy and Behavior
1
0.2

34
ҵ
Environmental and Business Economics
1
0.2

35
ߡΪ
Environmental Policy,Institution and Behavior
1
0.2

36
ѧ뼼
Environmental Sciences and Technology
1
0.2

37
ѧ
Environmental Geosciences
1
0.2

38

Environmental Education
5
1.0

39
ʵ鼼
Environmental Laboratory Technology
1
0.2

40
()
Environmental Communication
1
0.2

41
޸к
Environmental Remediation and Hazardous Material
1
0.2

42
Ա
Environmental Techician
1
0.2


43
ѧ
Environmental Physical Sciences
1
0.2

44

Environmental Protection
1
0.2

45

Environmental Sampling and Analysis
1
0.2


1

רҵ(Majors)רҵѧרҵƵʣ%
46
ϵͳ
Environmental Systems Analysis
1
0.2

47

Environmental Technology and Society
1
0.2
48
԰ѧ
Environmental Horticulture
1
0.2

(ũ)
49/ѧ
Environmental/Marine Science
1
0.2



2.2ߵȽоרҵøſ
Petersonָϣ3,ǵ34ѧо(ʿ˶ʿ)רҵ(Program)øſͳƽ2.ӱ2Կ34ѧûоרҵ53֣34ѧǰ5רҵΪ̡ѧƺͻѧ빤̣ѧУֱ146544()Ƶʷֱ41%17.6%14.7%12%12%53רҵưũҽ͹44֣ռרҵ83%ѧ7֣ռ13%ڶ֮רҵл滮ͻо2֣Լռ4%.
234ѧоרҵͳƱ
Table 2 The statistical table of programs for environmental graduate students at 34 famous universities in USA

רҵ(Programs)רҵѧרҵƵʣ%
1
ְҵ
Environmental and Occupation Health
3
8.8

(ҽ)
2

Environmental Management and Policy
1
3

3

Environmental Engineering
14
41

4
ѧ
Environmental Toxicology
3
8.8

5

Environmental Health Engineering
2
6

(ҽ)
6
ľ뻷
Civil and Environmental Engineering
3
8.8

7

Environmental Monitoring
1
3

8
ˮԴ
Environmental Water Resource Management
1
3

9
Դ뻷о
Energy and Environmental Studies
1
3

10

Environmental Health
6
17.6

(ҽ)
11
ƹ
Environmental control Engineering
1
3

12
Σѧ
Biohazard Science
1
3

13
ѧѧ
Environmental Toxicology,Chemistry and Risk Assessment
1
3


2

רҵ(Majors)רҵѧרҵƵʣ%
14
о
Environmental Studies
2
6


15

Coastal Environmental Management
1
3

16
вѧ
Environmental Epidemiology
1
3

(ҽ)
17
¶ۺ͹
Environmental Exposure Assessment and Engineering
1
3

18
ѧ
Environmental Health Science
3
8.8

(ҽ)
19
̬ͻֲﲡѧ
Ecological and Environmental Plant Pathology
1
3

20
̬ѧͻѧ
Ecotoxicology and Environmental Chemistry13
21
ܿػ԰ѧ
Controlled Environmental Horticulture
1
3

(ũ)
22
ϵͳѧ
Enviroonmental System Engineering
1
3

23
ѧ
Environmental Geophysics
1
3

24
ͱȽѧ
Environmental and Comparative Physiology
1
3

25
ѧ
Environmental Science
5
14.7

26

Environmental Quality Engineering
1
3

27
ѧ
Environmental Quality Sciences
1
3

28

Environmental Design
4
12

29
뻷
Sanitary and Environmental Engineering
1
3

(ҽ)
30
ۺͷ
Environmental Design Theories and Methods
1
3

31
滮
Environmental Planning
1
3


32
ˮԴͻ
Water Resource and Environmental Engineering
1
3

33
ѧ͹
Environmental Sciences and Engineering
4
12

34
͹ҵѧ
Environmental and Industrial Hygienics
1
3

(ҽ)
35
ְҵҽѧ
Environmental and Occupation Medicine
1
3

(ҽ)
36
ѧ͹
Environmental Hygiene Science and Engineering
1
3

(ҽ)
37
ж
Environmental Justice
1
3


2

רҵ(Majors)רҵѧרҵƵʣ%
38
ȽԴͻ
Comparative Energy and Environmental Policy
1
3

39

Դͷչξѧ
Political Economy of Energy,Environment and Development
1
3

40
԰ѧ
Environmental Horticulture
1
3

(ũ)
41
ũҵͻѧ
Argriculture and Environmental Science
1
3

(ũ)
42
̬ѧͻѧ
Ecology and Environmental Science
1
3

43

Environmental Education
1
3

44
󡪺ӿڡѧ
MarineEstuarineEnvironmental Science
1
3

45
мѧͻ滮
Urban Technology and Environmental Planning
1
3

46
ȻԴͻ
Natural Resource and Environmental
1
3

47
໷ѧ
Human Environmental Science
1
3

48
໷ѧϢ
Human Environmental Science Communication
1
3

49

Environmental Policy
1
3

50
ά
Environmental Conservation
1
3

51
ΣԹ
Hazardous Solid Waste
1
3

52
/Դ
Environmental/Resource Engineering
1
3

53
ѧ
Environmental Biology
1
3



3Աоͷ
3.1ߵȽרҵࡢҶԪ
ͳ(1ͱ2)3215ѧ(ѧԺ)ѧʿѧλ౾רҵ49֣34ѧоרҵ53֡רҵڶ࣬漰ѧ㷺ʾ˶Ԫص.ҹбĿ¼(1993)漰רҵ11֣11ݣ£
̡ࣺ⡢ũҵ뻷̣
ࣺѧ̬ѧѧԴȻԴ
ũҵࣺũҵ
ҽѧࣺҽѧ
еרҵΪ滮
1996軷ѧԴרҵ(԰).
Ǵרҵõרҵ漰ѧƵĹȣҹԶԶ.ߵȻרҵֶԪصĸߵȽͽ.һƹңеĽΪطȨƣʵʩ͹ߵȽҵҪǸݣγݡطͬ.ҪǹͶʣƶо¼ͷַ鱨ϣʵʩȫָͷ.һ˵ԸߵѧУûֱӵĹϽȨֻݹƶĽͨԸߵȽʩӰ죬мӿ.Ľ£ĸߵȽγ˶εĽṹ༴˽УμƸУƸУоԴѧ.ĽǿѧУͶϣְҵѵϣ˴ѧУתҵ.ߵѧУ˲˲͵гõԼ͵أ5.ˣơṹͷ£ڻѧĸ߶ȷչԼںԻӣԻ˲ӶڸߵѧУ˲רҵóڶͶԪص.ͬӳʮڣڵʱϢѧѸٷչķչһϢʱ˲ļӣѧרҵѸ.Ϣѧѧ19821983ȱ19721973ȣʮ䱾ѧ469%˶ʿ152%5.һӸֵ˵гöԸߵѧУ˲ŵԼ͵أͬʱҲӳѧƵչ͹ѧƵ.
ҹ൱ʱ(1961196619761985)ߵȽǿȨУжͳһ.1963626й롢ԺڼǿߵѧУͳһ쵼ּľ(вݰ)Եصõ֣˵СͳһҹߵȽƵĻ.ȷ涨Ҫ֮һ׼Уרҵã涨УĽѧƻͽѧٵƶԭ֯ƶָԽѧƻͽ.80ҹƵĸĸҹĸ߶ȼͳһĸУƱ׶汩¶1985527գˡйڽƸĸľָǰߵȽƸĸĹؼǸıԸУܵùĹƣڹͳһĽͼƻָ£ߵѧУİѧȨרҵҪǸĸߵȽѧ಻״̬ӿƾౡѧƵרҵչֲˡԵѧƳɳ.ҹߵȻרҵ80ԭ֮һ.ڡָ£ҹߵѧУƶȡѧȨȷȡ׿гЧĸĸ.Ϊ˺۵أרҵõԭҽί׼ɽί䲼רҵĻͽѧҪ󣬷ſרҵ򣻴⣬ҹ˲͹δȫ˲гĵأڹɽ׶.ҹУ౾רҵȻͳһҲ.ʵϣרҵͬС죬ֻƲͬרҵ࣬ҹ׼רҵǿԺϲ.רҵƶΪǿ˲гϵľ.
3.2ѧ͵רҵҹΪ
ͳϿԿѧ͵רҵרҵռнϴı49רҵռ37%о53רҵռ14%.绷ͼΪᡢԴ뻷оԴͷչξѧ໷ѧȵȣרҵʹҹߵȻ˵Ҳ൱ʺİ.ҹб11רҵУʵȻѧѧ͵Ļ滮רҵҲ࣬ռרҵ11%.ֲ֮ԣΪǣڵĻʶԻҵҪԼѧչڲͬҺ͵ˮƽߵ͵ķӳ.ҹĻҵչ70ڣȡ˽ϴɼ൱ľ룬ڻʶһЩµĽѧƺո𲽣ԻҪձӡǡϡĩƬΪһ̡δʶѧƺѧڻеҪãӳҹ˲ĸУרҵĿѧרҵС.ȻĿǰҹҵչʾһۺϵͳ̣ⲻȻ⣬Ұỷ⣬һҪɲ֣6.ر1992硰֮󣬿ɳչսԵȷȷ˻ҵķչĿսԣĽܼмרȺҪȫṫ.ͬʱԻ˲仯ڸߵȽרҵѸٵӦᷢչҪ󣬳רҵڻרҵռش.Ȼӵͳƽ53ѧоרҵѧרҵԶԶڱ(14%37%)ⷴӳоĿ죬ۺͺרżҲ.ˣҹչѧͻרҵ˲ҹĿǰչҵҪӦڻ౾зչѧרҵ.
3.3ԽԽӻռ
רҵͳƽ(1ͱ2)ûרҵУʦΪרҵָʦʺͻ˻ʵ鼼רҵͻԱרҵ.ɴ˿ɼԽԽӻռҹ޴רҵ.״ȻҹġǿǿʶǲӦ.֪ռԹڻʶߺ͹ڲشãռķչӦʸߵʦʶ.ˣǱռʦʶҹߵȽ֮.
3.4ҹרҵʮֱ
ߵȽרҵеõ൱ӣͳƽǱоǰ5ֻרҵУлרҵӦĻ̡ѧְҵ뻷ְ̡ҵҽѧȵרҵ49רҵ3֣о53רҵ9.ⲻӳ˻ѧҽѧ淢չĽҪͻҪĻ󡪡࣬ʾҶԻ߲εҪ.ִѧչо֤༲뻷仯أ磬Լ70%80%֢ķ뻷йأرǻеĻѧ.ҪŪ廷ղĳ򣬴ӸԤķĽ.ĻĿ겻עҪעEPAĹҼ뽡оԻӵһ֤.ҹбרҵĿ¼(1993)ԤҽѧлҽѧרҵרҵԺУ٣ҾΪҽѧԺУ.Ŀǰҹؼ簩֢ķڲв彡.ٴҽѧġĩȻܸвֻмǿҽѧչŪЩ򣬲ԤΪҪǿ߲κ͸߲Ļҽѧ˲.Ȼйع֮δЭӰҹҽѧרҵķչ.
3.5ۺ͡˲ߵȻ౾иΪͻ
ߵȽרҵ֧()ѧã绷ѧʡȣڱͳУ479û౾רҵԺУй27ռ5.7%ۺרҵ绷ѧ/ȻԴάоѧȣ306ռ64.8%3.

3ƻרҵ֧()ѧͳƱ
Table 3 The statistical table of third-crade discipline majors for environmental scienceundergraduate students at universities in USA

רҵרҵ
1ѧ붾ѧ1
1ѧ5
10ѧ1
лѧ1ѧ1
ѧ/ȻԴά256ѧ뼼1
о401
ѧ8


ߵȻ౾רҵУۺרҵԶԶѧרҵ.ߵѧУƽۺ͡˲ΪĿ꣬֡ۺ͡˲Ŀͬ淢չгӦģѧľҵڽܸһѵ.ִѧķչκһˮƽĸߵѧУʹѧУѧϰڼܵе֪ʶµļ˵רҵ֪ʶǣߵѧУͨǿ۽ʹѧһֳ־õġʹõĻۣԱʹѧܹ˳ʵ֪ʶת䣬Ͽѧϰµ֪ʶ.֡ۺ͡ڿγϵõֱ֤.
ѧһۺǿѧƣˣӦͻۺ͡ص㣬౾רҵеõ˳.ַչҹרҵϿѡ޵רҵ򣬵Ҫ󡰵רҵ򡱡ҪרҵרҵȾһµģϸߵȽķչ򣬼ۺ廯Ϊǿؿھ.ңĿǰҹߵȻרҵøĸѰѻѧͻѧȱרҵϲһѧרҵǷϡۺ͡˲Ŀ.ڳ˼γǿխ͡רıδܸת䣬ڸߵȻ౾ȻһЩԭרҵģʽ˱뾡תʺϹߵȻƣΪҹҵ͸ġۺ͡˲.
3.6ȻԴߵȻרҵеõ߶
ߵȻרҵԻѧ/ȻԴάרҵ࣬㣬ͳƵ472ñרҵУ256ԺУ˸רҵռ54%һЩרҵ.ʵġѧרҵֻռ1.7%(1).ⷴӳ˶ȻԴӣѧȻԴѧȫĻ.ֶ༴Ⱦ̬ƻȻԴϵɷָ.ᷢչȻԴúͻ֮໥໥ԼĹϵΪʶ.Ի˲߹ҪӦȾĽ׶ΣԻȾ̬ƻصĽ׶ΣĿǰȻԴרҵеõӣӳȫԻ˲չڻ뷢չĽ.ҹĿǰӦȾΪȻԴδõӦе.
ͨϱȽϷԿҹߵȻרҵòרҵȫڴͳ࣬ѧ뼼ʼδܳΪѧͣѰĺܶ໷רҵϿкŨĴͳѧƵɫ.ңҹרҵ໷ѧרҵչϿ죬漰ѧƵ֪ʶ٣ȱⷽĻרҵרҵ״ԶԶڵѧչƣҹ21ͶԻ˲ŵҪ.
ο
1Carol M Brower.Why Environmental Education?EPA Journal,1995,21(2):68
2College Entrain Examination Board.College Handbook,Thirty-Third Edition,New York,1996
3Peterson's Guide to Graduate & Professional Program:An Overview,1995,1996
4л񹲺͹ߵȽίԱ߽˾.ߵȽרҵĿ¼.1993
5Roy Radner,Leonard S.Miller,Douglas L.Aclkins,Demand and Supply in US Higher Education.New York:McGraw-Hill Book Company,1995:158247
6Ian Robottom.Environmental Education:Practice and Possible.Deakin University Press,Australia,1982:1534


