ѧѧ
ACTA SCIENTIAE CIRCUMSTANTIAE
1999 19 6 Vol.19 No.6 1999



ӦVOFˮդʧЧֵģⳢ
šʯ¡ϡ
ժҪͨԱVOFģʧЧΣճȵˮٶȳĳһٽֵʱ͵μдʧЧճȺܴˮٶȳٽֵʱٽۻʧЧ.ģڶеʵһ.ٽˮٶȻƫ⽫ԺĹͨһ̽.
ؼʡʧЧֵģ⣻VOF.
Preliminary numerical simulation of boom failure with VOF model
ZHANG Zheng,CHENG Shiyong,LI Han (College of Chemical Engineering,Beijing University of Chemical Technology,Beijing 100029)
An C.F. (Imperial Oil Inc.,Calgary, Canada)
AbstractFloating booms have been commonly used to contain spilled oil on water surface,while failure often occurs in currents with high velocity.In order to study boom failure mechanisms,Computational Fluid Dynamics methods have been used by now.As a preliminary application of volume of fluid (VOF) model in self-compiled SIMPLE program,two cases of oil failure were simulated:when critical current velocity is exceeded,droplet entrainment occurs for low-viscosity oil while critical accumulation occurs for high-viscosity oil.In the computation,fluid flow is simplified to be laminar.The simulation results are qualitatively identical with experiment and the simulation results obtained by Dr.C.-F An with Commercial software,Fluent.Quantitatively,however,our computed critical current velocities are a little higher.Turbulence model should be employed in further computation in order to get more acceptable results.
Keywordsboom failure,numerical simulation,multiphase flow,VOF model.
1
ʯй©ɺ󡢺ȾѳΪעĻ.ĿǰȾõķˮդ1ȻƲջֱӷ.դƯˮռϰƵ壩.դʯ͵ʾͼ1ʾ.ʵդʱڸԭ򳣻ᷢʹդ±ˮ߶ʧЧ.йʧЧʵоҪ3ʧЧʽ24ݣ͵μдʧЧͲʧٽۻʧЧ.Ͷѧоڼģ͵Ļϣ56ݣˮΪһά˶ճȦ<3.510-3m2/s࣬Що޷˵ʧЧĻ.


ͼ1դͲĵ״
Fig.1 Oil slick contained by oil boom
żķչӦֵģķоʧЧΪһЧֶ.E.J.ClavelleR.D.Rowe7ݲSOLA-VOF˶ճȦ=2.310-3m2/s͵ۻʧЧֵģ.ˮٶv=0.14m/sʱͲȫդߵνٽʧЧDelvigine[3]ʵ.
ô۹ʯ͹˾İC.-F.An ʿˣ810FLUENTɹģ˶άʧЧ3ʽ.VOFӦk-ģͼˮճ.ģһĵճͣˮٶȵٽֵʱͲջﵽ̬ܳɹˮٶȳٽֵʱ͵μдʧЧ.ģõǰͲȺٽˮٶȷֱWilkinson5,6 ֵDelvigine2ݵʵǺ.ڸճȵͣˮٶСٽֵʱͲҲܴﵽȶڵǰγɶ̶ġͶѡˮٶȳٽֵʱٽۻʧЧͲӵ¡ߡȫƹʧ.õٽֵDelvigineʵϣ3.
Anʿ˹Ļϣ̽VOFоʧЧӦóΪһоʧЧ».
2㷽
ųӰ죬դάĶ.ǵճԶСҺ壨ͺˮֵɺӰ죬оԼΪϽΪĦ-ˮ.ˮʱչդʻΣĴˮٶ.ˮٶʧЧҪƶģ⽫ԳƵդΪоĶ.԰һΪάʵоǶά-ˮǶ.
Ϊˮ಻ܣԵ棬ֵģĹؼǸ.һһЧ1112ݣVOF棬ͨͬһƷֲ̼.VOF˱ضĺF(i,j,t).ѳˮΪF=1.0ѳ͵ΪF=0FΪ01ֵ֮ʱΪ.
2.1Ʒ
ѹĶάNavier-Stokeṣ
(1)
Է̣
u=0(2)
Ϊˮ࣬F(i,j,t)F㣺
(3)
2.2VOFҪ
2.2.1̣1ͣ2ɢȶԷ̣1ʽʽɢɵn+1ʱ̵Ĺٶu*pnunĹϵʽٶԣ1ʽáʽʽɢ.УѹΪʽpn+1,ɢͶеٶΪʽunӶõn+1ʱٶun+1ѹpn+1nʱٶunĹϵʽ.ɢõ
(4)
Уѹp=pn+1-pn.ѣ4ʽԷ̣2Уõѹ̣
(5)
2.2.2 ɢ 趨ѹpn£ɷ̣1ʽʽɢu*ѹ̣5ţٵ⣬ѹp. pʽ4µٶȳǷԷ̣뷽̣5һֱ.u*=0.Ӷõn+1ʱ̵ٶȳ.ٶȳ뷽̣3УF.
2.2.3 F Ϊ˱֤̣ⷽ3ʱܵõнԾԵF,˸-巽DA12ݣκεFϢȷ״,Ȼݸ״Fͨ.
2.2.4߽Ĵϱ߽Ӵɱ棬ǰǳĦƽ壬߽yٶΪ㣻ײ߽Ϊ̶޻ѱ棬˱߽ٶΪ㣻߽룬ٶui;ұ߽ΪԱ߽磬u/x=0.yٶg=-9.81N.͡ˮУܶȺճȡƽֵ.
3 Ƚ
ķֱֲͬճȵģ㣬Delvigine˵ʵC.-F.AnģĽбȽ.вò񻮷֣ڵ帽ͼϲԱ֤-ˮ͵帽ļ㾫.
3.1 ճ͵ļģ
ճģDelvigineʵ2.Ϊһͨx 4.0m,y0.30m.ھ 2.0mΪ0.07my )x)0.01m.Ŀ14231Сߴȡx=0.02m,y=0.005m.͵ܶȦo1=888kg/m3˶ճȦo1=710-5m2/sˮܶȦw=998.2kg/m3˶ճȦw=1.00410-6m2/s.
δ֮ǰˮ߽u=0.09m/sٶȸ򣬾30.0sһ̬.ԴΪʼʹ߽Ϸ룬λϵﵽQ=0.01m\+3/mʱֹͣ.ֱˮٶΪ0.09m/s0.15m/s0.20m/s0.24m/s0.28m/sʱͲڵ帽ĶѧΪͼ2.
ˮu=0.09m/s£t=0sʱ̣Ϳʼ߽룬22.2sֹͣͣͼ2a˴ʱǰͲκٶȷֲʱͲǰѵﵲ岢ڵǰۣ򵲰ˮͲ㲻ϱ̣t=40.2sʱͼ2b Ͳڳ˸ٶȣ˺Ͳֱ䡱ȥ䳤䱡ֱt=85.0sʱ.֮Ͳﵽ̬.˽ʵJohnston֮ν.







ͼ2ͬˮµճͶѧΪ
Fig.2 Dynamic evolution of low viscosity oil at different water velocities
ˮٶu0.15m/sͲһ򵲰巽t=110sʱͼ2cﵽ̬Ͳβ뿪͵δ.ʱʧڵ֮ͳɹ.







ͼ3ͬˮ¸ճͶѧΪ
Fig.3 Dynamic evolution of high viscosity oil at different water velocities
ˮٶu=0.20m/sͼ2dͲø̸-ˮٶȽϴʹ屻Сγ͵Σ帽Ͳȶ˵͵طͲ壬ûзʧЧ.
ˮٶu0.24m/s,Ͳø̣δȶûг͵ʧͼ2e.һӴˮٶȴu0.28m/s,2.5sͲԵѽӽײ͵ѿʼʧΣt143sʱʧڵ֮ͼ2f.ʧͳʷɢ״СͲ屻ڵ֮ǰжϷ͵μдʧЧ.
3.2 ճ͵ļģ
ԸճļģJohnstonˣ4ݵʵ.򳤣x)4.3m,y0.23m. 2.0m0.07my )x)0.01m.Ŀ22027Сߴȡx0.01m,y=0.005m.͵ܶȦO2=915kg/m3˶ճȦ=3.610-3m2/sˮܶȡW=999.1kg/m3˶ճȦ=1.13810-6m2/s.
ˮٶΪu=0.1m/sˮ̬Ϊʼʹ߽Ϸ.ﵽQ0.005m3/mʱֹͣͣ㲻ͬˮٶʱͲڵ帽ĶѧΪͼ3.
t=0sʱͿʼ߽룬10.0sֹͣͣˮu=0.10m/sٶȽ.t20.0sʱ̣ͼ3aͲǰѵﵲ岢ڴ˼ۣͲٶΪ.ʱӣͲ㲻ϱ.ͼ3b3cֱt65.0s t70.0sʱ̵ǰͲ״ֲͲýϺҳ˸ٶ,Ͳڳѭ.Ƚͼ5sͲ״ֲûб仯Ͳ㵽̬ûзʧЧ.ճ಻ͬˮĦϴ󣬹ûгͲġ䡱.
t=70.0sʱ̣ˮٶu0.15m/s.11st=81sͲڵǰµƽ.ͼ3dԿt=81.0sʱͲ̱񣬶ѻڵǰ.ܴʱ-ˮʲΣͲϲȶнϴͲ룬ַͲ.ʱûԵͲʧԿΪǳɹ.
ˮٶu0.20m/s.ͼ3et83.5sʱͲüȶҺ񲢳˵壬Ͳ㿪ʼƹ岢ʼʧڵ֮.2.5sͲʧٶȼȶʻΪٽۻʧЧ.t86.0sʱˮٶu0.25m/s.ͼ3ft89.0sʱ̵Ͳκֲһŵʧڵ֮󣬵ǰֻбһͲ򵲰.ڵǰûдﵽƽ״̬ڵͲ㣬ڴˮٶ·ٽۻʧЧ.
3.3Ƚ
DelvigineJohnstonʵڵճ࣬͵μдʧЧٽˮٶΪu0.24m/sңճȵ࣬u>0.20m/sʱᷢٽۻʧЧ.AnʿFLUENTʧЧٽֱֵΪ0.24m/s0.20m/s.ݱģĽ͵μдʧЧˮΪ0.28m/sʱճˮΪ0.25m/sٽۻʧЧ ԸʵֵAnʿļ.ͼ4aͣbֱ˵ճͺ͸ճˮٶΪ0.15m/sʱAnʿFLUENTõͲαȽ.ͼAnʿļȣͬˮٶ£õͲۻ̶ȽϵͣԽϱϳ.
ڴˮٶȡγߴóŵRe>20000,δģ.˾ͶԣǱģСƫԭ.


ͼ4ģͲαȽ
This paper Dr.An's
Fig.4 Oil slick profile comparison (numerical results)
4
ģĽϵˮٶ£դǳɹ.ڽϸˮٶ£u=0.28m/sճ෢͵μдʧЧͲ屻ڵ֮ǰ͵εʽʧڵ֮󣻶ڸճȵ࣬ˮٵӣͲڵǰۻú̺ܶܺ񣬵ˮٶȳٽֵu=0.25m/sʱͲ㶼ʧ֮󣬷ٽۻʧЧ.
Delvigine˵ʵȣģĽ֮úܺãģ͵μдʧЧٽۻʧЧʧЧҲڵճ෢ġ䡱󣻵ڶϣģóˮٶٽֵԸʵֵ.Anʿļȣͬˮٶ£Ͳۻ̶Ƚϵ.ڼδģ£бҪڽĹģͣһо.
ߵλšʯ¡:ѧѧѧԺ100029
:ô۹ʯ͹˾
ο
1 Hoult David P. Containment and collection devices for oil slicks.Oil in Water,1965,6579
2 Delvigine G A L. Laboratory experiments on oil spill protection of a water intake. Monograph: Oil in Freshwater,1985,446458
3 Delvigine G A L. Barrier failure by critical accumulation of viscous oil. Proceedings of Oil Spill Conference, San Antonio,TX,USA.1989.143148
4Johnston A J. Fitzmaurice M RWatt R G M, Oil spill containment: viscous oils. Proceedings of 1993 International Oil Spill Conference. Tampa,FL,USA.1993.8994
5Wilkinson D.Dynamics of contained oil slicks. Journal of the Hydraulics Division. ASCE,1972,98:10141030
6Wikinson D.Limitations to the length of contained oil slicks. Journal of the Hydraulics Division. ASCE,1973,99:701712
7Clavelle E JRowe R D. A numerical study of oil boom failure by critical accumulation. Proceedings of 9th Conference on Numerical Methods in Laminar and Turbulent Flow. Atlanta, USA.1995
8An C-F, Clavelle E J, Brown H M, Barron R M. CFD simulation of oil boom failure. Proceedings of 4th Annual Conference of the CFD Society of Canada,Ottawa,ON,Canada.1996.401408
9Brown H M, Goodman R H, An C-F,Bittner J.Boom failure mechanisms: comparison of channel experiments with computer modeling results. Proceedings of 20th Arctic & Marine Oilspill Program (AMOP) Technical Seminar, Vancouver,BC,Canada.1997,1:457467
10An C-F, Brown H M, Goodman RG et al.In:Zhou L X,Li X F (eds).Numerical modeling of the dynamics of an oil slick spill on flowing water.Multiphase Fluid, Nonnewtonian Fluid and Physico-Chemical Fluid Flows, Beijing:Int Academic Publishers,1997.3.453.52
11Hirt C WNiichols B D. Volume of fluid (VOF) method for the dynamics of free boundaries. Journal of Computational Physics, 1981,39:201225 
12άΣԾ.ȼյģ.Ϸʣйѧѧ.1992.341349
1998-01-09յԭ
1999-06-14յ޸ĸ
