ѧѧ
ACTA SCIENTIAE CIRCUMSTANTIAE
1999 19 6 Vol.19 No.6 1999



㺺
졡ɡ¡
ժҪҪۣLCAĸԼʱ׼֯1997䲼ISO14040ϵ-ԭܡԳĲͬʽ˽ΪϵͳLCA.աۺϴĻӰǱֱΪ5.110-23.810-22.610-21.710-2ɱֱΪ39.2Ԫ/(.)21.3Ԫ/(.)27.8Ԫ/(.)8.5Ԫ/(.).ۺϷڻЧ;Ч淽涼3ַ.
ؼʡ.
Life cycle assessment of municipal solid waste in Guanghan city
XU Cheng YANG Jianxin WANG Rusong (Department of System Ecology,Research Center for Eco-Environmental Sciences,CAS)
AbstractAccording to the concept of life cycle assessment and environmental management-life cycle assessment and framework issued by International Standard Organization(ISO) in 1997,the LCA of municipal solid wastes in Guanghan city was accomplishad.The result shows that environmental effect of incineration,open-dump,sanitary landfill and the comprehensive treatment is 5.110-2,3.810-2,2.610-2 and 1.710-2 respectively,and the treatment cost is 39.2 RMB(capita.year),21.3RMB(capita.year),27.8RMB(capita.year) and 8.5RMB(capital.year) respectively.The comprehensive treatment method is better than others in environmental benefit and economic benefit.
Keywordslife cycleassessment;municipal solid wastes;Guanghan city.
ͳĻӰ۽ڶԵĿ򿪷Լչ滮ĻӰ,Ⱦڲͬת,ʹ۽Ƭ.ۣLCAΪһƷĻ,ͨһƷϵͳϵͳ(ԭϻȡƷ졢Ʒʹֱմ)ĻӰ,ڴͳӰ۵ľԶµƬۣ12.LCAӦѸҵ,漰ҵƷյơۼƶȸ,Ϊ෢ƶҵչսԵѡߣ3.ĸLCAĻоܣԹ㺺вͬ˽ΪϵͳLCA.
1LCAĻۿ
Դ60ĩ70չһϵ԰װƷеԴ.20ķչ90γ˱Ƚϵͳĸۿܣ4.1990ꡰʻѧ뻯ѧѧ(SETAC)״ν䶨ΪһֶԲƷռĻѹ۵Ŀ͹۹,ͨʡԼɴɻŷŽʶе,ĿʵԼŷŶԻӰ,ͬʱѰ󻷾ƵĻԼֻ5.ࣨP&G˾򽫷ڶΪյķ㿪ʼӹΪкõọ̈̄6.
۵оܷΪĿ뷶Χȷ嵥Inventory AnalysisӰ(Impact Assessment)ͽ4лϵĲ.1997,ʱ׼֯䲼ISO14040ϵ-ԭܡʽ4ۿܣ57.
2㺺LCA
2.1оĿͷΧ
Ĵʡ㺺Ϊͨ񡢼񡢷ջղܼۺϴ4ִеʡȾŷŵĻӰ.оĹܵλǸ˾ŷŵ.漰˴˾ŷĳɱԴġˮ͹ŷ.оķΧ˴ʼ,ռֱմ,ϵͳ߽ͼ1.ڱоۺϴУڿɻʵ٣ģδ.

ͼ1㺺гLCAϵͳ߽
Fig.1System boundary for LCA of solid waste in Guanghan city
2.2嵥
嵥ݵĻҪͨ3;㺺лּ㺺ۺϴֳ飻ȡݵĲⶨݵļ͹.
P.R.White ˿ۺϹ-嵥ģͣ9,óͨ񡢼񡢷աۺϴ4ַʽ,˾ŷĳɱԴļַˮ͹Ӧŷ1.񡢼񡢷պۺϴĳɱֱΪ27.8Ԫ/. ꣩21.3Ԫ/(.꣩39.2Ԫ/(.꣩8.5Ԫ/(.꣩.Ҫ˵ǣΪ˽ѷѵ⣬㺺ۺϴڶѷһЩлһĵסأл޻ϷʣʹۺϴУлѷʿɻ10.4Ԫ/(.꣩ľЧ.Դķ棬ͼȣǰ߶Լлãɻ92MJ/.꣩Դ.մȻ˲ܣڹ㺺ֵƫͣҪӸȼϣȻҪһľͶ.
ŷУŷŵҪԼͶ̼ΪļŷΪ8.04kg/(.)ļŷΪ13.4 kg/(.)ǰ߽Ϻ߽40%մۺϴŷŵҪԶ̼Ϊռ99%.ͼCODĺֱΪ1.9410-2kg/(.)6.4810-2kg/(.)ǰߵ3.⣬񷨽Ϸպۺϴռý϶أռΪ4.0810-2m3/(.)ֱǷպۺϴ914.
2.3Ӱ
嵥ĻӰͷֳȫůữ͸Ӫֱ֣CO2SO2NO-3ΪݵĸӰ֮ĵϵ10ݣ2ÿӰ͵ĻӰǱ.Ȼб׼͸Ȩ,õܻӰǱ.ȨȨشСȷEDIPͨáĿ롱ĳֻЧӦøЧӦǰˮƽĿˮƽ׼֮ľ.ȨصļͨʽãWFj=ERj90/ERjT2000ERj90Ϊ1990׼׼ERjT2000Ϊ2000׼׼.
1㺺嵥
Table 1 Life cycle inventory of solid wastes in Guanghan city


ռռ
ܳɱ,Ԫ/(.)20.27.620.218.40.57
Դ,MJ/(.)1.15102-9.21011.381022.091023.9010-1
CO, kg/(.)5.4210-28.210-35.4610-21.5910-12.3210-4
CO2, kg/(.)6.603.67.012.981022.6610-2
CH4, kg/(.)08.04000
NOx, kg/(.)7.2010-21.8010-57.5210-21.8310-12.9710-4
SO2, kg/(.)2.4310-22.8510-52.7110-25.1310-18.8310-5
HCl, kg/(.)8.8010-51.5010-31.0510-47.6610-23.3210-7
HF, kg/(.)7.7610-52.7010-47.8710-53.0710-23.3210-7
H2S, kg/(.)2.8410-64.1010-32.7910-600
NH3, kg/(.)1.3610-74.8510-92.6810-71.0510-50
COD, kg/(.)1.8910-41.9410-25.3610-41.1310-53.1010-4
ռأm3(.)02.910-2004.410-3
ۺϴ
ռռѷʷ
ܳɱԪ/(.)20.21.118.5-1.04102.5010-11.5010-1
ԴģMJ/(.)1.151021.2010-11.381027.51102.93106.7810-1
CO, kg/(.)5.4210-24.3110-45.4610-22.7610-32.2410-24.3210-4
CO2, kg/(.)6.603.01107.014.08104.47101.56
CH4, kg/(.)01.34100006.710-1
NOx, kg/(.)7.2010-21.6610-57.5210-29.7810-32.5810-25.2710-4
SO2, kg/(.)2.4310-23.3410-52.7110-21.9810-27.2410-21.5710-4
HCl, kg/(.)8.8010-52.2210-31.0510-401.0810-21.1110-4
HF, kg/(.)7.7610-54.4010-47.8710-57.9110-84.3210-32.2810-5
H2S, kg/(.)2.8410-66.8210-32.7910-6003.4110-4
NH3, kg/(.)1.3610-76.5610-92.6910-73.8810-61.4810-60
COD, kg/(.)1.8910-46.4810-25.3710-41.610-26.0210-73.2710-3
ռ,m3/(.)04.0810-20-02.910-3

2Ӱĵϵ
Table 2Classifying factors of environmental impact categories

ӰȫůữӪ
ӰCOCO2CH4NOxSO2HClHFH2SNH3NOxNH3COD
CO2SO2NO3-
ֵ21250.701.000.881.601.881.881.353.640.23

ȨصĴСӳ1990ı׼׼Ҫٲܴﵽ2000Ŀ.Ȩ˵.µȣ11ݲĿ뷨ҹȫůữ͸ӪȨӷֱΪ0.820.730.74.
Ӱ۵Ľ㺺񡢼񡢷պۺϴܵĻӰǱֱΪ2.610-23.810-25.110-21.710-2.ͼȣǰ߶񳡵ļ弰Һռãʹȫů͸ӪֻӰ͵Ĺ׽ϼֱ𽵵32.4%36.0%.ȣմо󲿷ȼպԶ̼ʽͷŵȫůһӰ.ͬʱջһЩ壬絪ữմữĹ׷ֱ񡢼񡢺ۺϴ1064.ۺϴзķաѷʺױ΢ֽлͨѷתɸֳʣӶķͷŷţ价ӰǱҲӦΪС3.
3㺺гLCAӰ
Table 3Life-cycle impact assessment for municipal solid waste in Guangha city 

Ӱ
ͻ
Ӳ
ŷ
(kg/.)Ӱ
Ǳ׼ֵ
kg()
/(.)׼ȨظȨ
Ӱ
Ǳܻ
ӰǱ
   ȫ 
 ůCO
CO2
CH4CO21.310-1
4.3101
2.01022.41028.71032.810-20.822.310-22.610-2
 NOx
SO2
HCl
HF
H2S
NH3SO25.010-2
2.410-2
1.310-3
5.610-4
7.710-3
2.610-78.410-23.61012.310-30.731.710-3
 Ӫ
 NOx
NH3
CODNO3-6.810-2
5.010-7
4.510-37.310-25.51011.310-30.749.610-4
   ȫ 
 ůCO
CO2
CH4CO21.110-1
3.7101
3.31023.71028.71034.210-20.823.410-23.810-2
 NOx
SO2
HCl
HF
H2S
NH3SO25.010-2
7.210-2
2.010-3
8.310-4
1.310-2
2.710-71.410-13.61013.910-30.732.810-3
 Ӫ
 NOx
NH3
CODNO3-9.710-2
5.210-7
1.510-21.110-15.51012.010-30.741.510-3
   ȫ 
 ůCO
CO2
CH4CO21.610-1
9.4101
1.71011.11028.71031.310-20.821.110-21.710-2
 NOx
SO2
HCl
HF
H2S
NH3SO27.810-2
1.210-2
9.710-3
7.110-3
1.110-5
6.510-42.110-13.61015.810-30.734.310-3
 Ӫ
 NOx
NH3
CODNO3-1.510-1
2.110-5
4.510-31.510-15.51012.710-30.742.010-3
١ȫ 
 ůCO
CO2
CH4CO24.3
3.1102
03.11028.71033.610-20.823.010-25.110-2
 NOx
SO2
HCl
HF
H2S
NH3SO21.810-1
5.410-1
6.710-2
4.910-2
5.210-6
2.010-58.210-13.61012.310-20.731.710-2
 Ӫ
 NOx
NH3
CODNO3-3.510-1
3.910-5
2.010-43.510-15.51016.410-30.744.710-3

*ȫůữӪĻӰǱĵλkg(CO2)/(.)kg(SO2)/(.)kg(NO3-)/(.)
3
(1) ͷȣۺϷŵڽ޺ԴлؽպȽȾֽԼ˴ɱ.
(2) 񷨴ĹؼڶҺռֹԵˮȾԲļռãڿеŨȴﵽ5%10%ը.㺺ǰҪüķд޼ռҺĴʩ.嵥Ľּȣ񷨿ʹ)л.
(3) չвоǷշɹĹؼرĶfһ־綾°彡Σ.չвĴCO2弰NOxSOxӰ쵽ȫůữŷǰӦʵľ.
ߵλ:йѧԺ̬оϵͳ̬ң100080
ο
1Mary Ann Curran.Environmental life cycle assessment.Cincinnati:The McGraw-Hill Companies.1996.13
2Mary Ann Curran.Broad-based environmental life cycle assessment.Environmental Sciences Technology,1993,27(3):1827
3 Thmos D Foust.Environmental life cycle assessment.Cincinnati:The McGraw-Hill Commpanies.1996.515
4 .۵Ļعչ.ѧչ19986(2)6673
5 SETAC.Guidelines for life-cycle assessment:a `code of practice. Brussel: SETAC. 1993.9
6 White PR,Frnk M,Hindle P.Integrated solid waste management a Life cycle inventory.London:Chapman&Hall.1996
7 ISO 14040.Environmental Management-life cycle assessment-principles and framework.1997
8 Graedal T E,Allenby B R.Industrial ecology.NewJersey:Prentice Hall,Englewood Cliffs.1995
9 White P R.Integrated Waste Management:LCA and its practical use sustainable waste management through life cycle assessment.Environment Agency Seminar.1998
10 Wenzel H,Hauschild M Alting L.Environmental assessment of products. London: Chapman & Hall.1997
11 Yang Jianxin.Nielsen Per H.Chines normalization reference and weighting factors-according to the EDIP method,proceeding of the third international conference on EcoBanance.Tsukuba.1998.8184
1998-09-24յԭ
1999-04-30յ޸ĸ
