ѧѧ
ACTASCIENTIAECIRCUMSTANTIAE
19981µ181ڿƼڿ
෨Ķſ*
.л(BOD)ŷ
顡ꡡӨ
(ѧѧԺ150008)

ժҪолŷʱʹз͵ڿ.ͨµ״̬òԼ⻯ΪԼ⣬ŲĶ̬޸ĴͳݶȷӶƵؽ˶ڿƵļ.ол˲ͬʼſҪзҲͬųʼ״̬ڿƵ¸Ա֤ˮͬʱһˮɱ˵иҪ.Ļǿָв߱ʵſĴϵͳɸſƵоʵ־й㷺ʵüֵ׼ſ.
ؼʡ෨ڿƣBODŷ.
MULTIVARIABLE OPTIMAL CONTROL OF ACTIVATED SLUDGE PROCESS:.LIMITATION OF TOTAL SUBSTRATE(BOD) DISCHARGE MASS

Peng Yongzhen, Wang Baozhen, Wang Shuying
(Department Environment and Municipal Engineering,Harbin University of Architecture and Engineering,150008)

ABSTRACTOptimal periodic control with the lowest operational cost by limiting total substrate discharge mass was studied.Through adding new state variable and using supplement functions,the problem with restriction conditions was converted into nonrestriction problem.In addition,the dynamic searching method of optimal step coefficient was developed to modify the conventional gradient method,consequently the calculation problem of the multivariable optimal periodic control was able to be resolved better.It was found that the operational costs of optimal control under various initial states are distinctly different.A new concept of optimal control under optimal initial state was presented.It is pointed out emphatically that to the treatment system without optimal control condition,the suboptimal control with extensive practical value can be realized according to the results of optima control.
Keywordsactivated sludge process, optimal periodic control, BOD total discharge mass.

1ǰ
ǰģ1Ѿ֤ʵŷQwܽŨDOǻ෨еҪĿƱǼܿƳˮˮܸıз.ңĳһˮǰ£ڲͬĶQwDO£зҲͬԼDOΪ0.9mg/Lʱз.ǣⲢſƣоſл()ŷԼ£ѰʹзʡſƱQwDOı仯.ſƱҪȡأһǽˮˮˮı仯涨ĳˮˮʣָʽҪﵽĿ.
ڸľ÷չˮƽˮȾ״ԼˮĹܲͬȶ෽ԭ򣬸صˮŷű׼ˮˮˮҪͬ23.磬ˮˮлŷŵҪˮлŨȲĳһ׼ͬʱƳˮƽлŨȷֱ𲻳涨ָ.ƳˮлŷȾƣһֳõŷű׼ڹҵˮŷ.олŷſģ㷽ĻϣͨԸ⣬뱾йص.

2ſѧģ㷽
2.1ſѧģ
ӦָǱȽϸӵԼſ.ԼһҪлŷƣҪ״̬ÿյĩֵֵͬǿƱQwDOֻһΧȡֵDOС䱥ֵQwҲΪֵ.˵ڶԼڽˮˮˮڱ仯£״̬ÿҲڱ仯ʵڿ(Ҳſ).ȻоˮϵͳڿƸʵ壬ÿսˮˮˮڱ仯ÿյſƱȴ޹ɱ仯ſƼʵҲʵ.ͨ״̬òʹǰԼõ㣬ǽ(Pontryagin)ļֵԭ.
Ϊлŷ״̬һ״̬Z(t),Zʾÿڳˮųлʱtı仯
Z(t)=t0QSdt(1)
״̬ZʱĵΪ
(2)
ZĳֵZ(0)=0ĩֵZ(1)ͱʾÿŷŵл
Z(1)10QSdt(3)
ǰԼ״̬ĩֵԼɱʾΪ

(4)
ʽX0,S0ֱΪ״̬XSĳֵ֪
ZsÿŷŵлȡZs=150kg(BOD)/d൱ƽˮBODΪ15mg/L.
ſֵ㷽ݶȷֻԼ⣬ˣò4ݣڼȡʽ(4)ĩֵԼΪָʽ(ף1ʽ(18))һӳĩֵԼƻ̶ȵĺʹ֮ΪԼ⣬õһµָJ

(5)
ʽG1G2G3Ϊ㹻ʽҶ˵ǰΪ.ȻG1G2G3ֵԼʽ(4)ƻĳ̶ԽСͨʹµָJΪСֵſƣʹзJCʡͬʱʽ(4)ĩֵԼ.
״̬Zĵʽ(2)״̬(ף1ʽ(6))һ״̬̣

(6)
ſƵļ㷽4ݣ(Lagrange)Ӧ12ͦ3ʱδ֪Ҳư.ָʽ(5)еı״̬ʽ(6)3΢̵ַҶֱԦ12ͦ3֮ͣĹܶ(Hamilton)H.

(7)
ͨH3״̬ƫ-H/X,-H/S-H/Zóſİ淽ʽ(8)

(8)
ſָʹHȡСֵſQwDOҲʹָJȡСֵ.ƱQwDOȡֵΧԼſӦʽ(6)ʽ(8)ͪH/Qw=0H/DO=0()ɵ̵Ľ.״̬ʽ(6)ĳֵ״ֵ̬Ϊ֪
X(0)=X0, S(0)=S0, Z(0)=0(9)
淽ʽ(8)ĩֵָ(5)ҶǰĲֱ״̬ĩֵX(1)S(1)Z(1)ƫҲƺ

(10)
ɼ8ɣ2Լ6΢ַ̣6˵ɽ8XSZ123QwDOQwDOΪſ.Ͱſ΢̵ֵַ.ȻоĿƱQwDOȡֵԼԼ¿ЦH/Qw0H/DO0Դֻǽļֵԭ4.ֵԭָȻſƴʱH/Qw=0,H/DO=0ʹHȡüֵ.ˣоſͱΪڿƱԼ£Ѱ㷽ʽ(6)ʽ(8)˵ʽ(9)ʽ(10)ʹHΪСĿƱQw(t)DO(t).
2.2ŲĶ̬
ݶȷſƵĻ˼ǣȲ²һQ0wDO0ڳʼʽ(9)ĩֵʽ(10)£״̬ʽ(6)Ͱ淽ʽ(8).Ϊ²Q0wDO0ſƣÿHֵġ½ݶȷH/QwH/DO

(11)
ʽK1K2ǴĲ.ʽ(7)õHֵݶΪ

(12)
ͨQiwDOi΢ַ̣ʹӦHֵָJзJCԽϿٶȼСֱСֵõԼʹзʡſƱQw(t)DO(t)ı仯ɣӦ״̬X(t)S(t)ΪŹ.


ͼ1ŵ
DO(t)ſƱƽ̬
Fig.1 The trend of DO approaching to optimal 
control with increase of the teriteration times
ֵĹǷǳģ䵱K1K2ѡȡֵСʱҲܣK1K2ȡϴֵʱ̷ɢ޷.һ㿿ѡȡK1K2ֵ46.ΪˣоһŲĶ̬ƴͳݶȷÿQi+1w,DOi+1ʱɴ㣬Ȼȷһ龡ֲܴʹ̷ɢĲKi1Ki2.ּ㷽˼Чʣ˼ʹֵ΢ʵ.ͼ1ʾڰŲĶ̬УȲ²Ʊ֮һDO(t)Ϊֵ0.9mg/L£DO(t)ŵ(660μ㣬ÿμŲɴε)ſƱƽ̬.ͼֻʮεļÿֱʾôμDOļ.һ㷽ɹؽ˿äյѡȡ̶K1K2ֵļ㹤ɢ.

3
ڽмʱר˵⣬䶯ѧйزȡֵԲף1б1ֵˮŨȵı仯԰ף1ʽ(19)ף1ͼ2ʾϵͳÿųĵﲻ150kg(BOD)/d.
1X(0)=2000mg/LʱſƵĲּ
Table 1 Calculating results of optimal controls at X(0)=2000mg/L

X(t)mg/LS(t)mg/LQw(t),m3/dDO(t),mg/Lt,dZ(t),kg/d
2000.09.9602.856900
2011.713.2103.27750.0506.246
2027.316.7703.60610.10015.447
2046.620.2403.83080.150
2069.023.0303.94770.20043.682
2093.524.5203.96720.25061.513
2118.824.304.8193.89770.30079.831
2143.222.3510.4603.74140.35096.769
2165.219.1214.9603.49960.400110.859
2183.715.3218.2703.18070.450121.447
2194.811.65206.9402.81330.500128.718
2193.48.60356.4302.43620.550133.378
2183.06.31448.1602.09240.600136.253
2166.64.75505.3501.81850.650138.034
2146.33.82544.1501.64290.700139.215
2123.73.42575.2001.58410.750140.124
2099.83.53606.3201.64940.800140.998
2075.34.16645.4801.83560.850142.057
2050.75.39703.4302.12810.900143.593
2025.67.30792.8402.48770.950146.034
2000.09.96879.5402.85691.000150.000
J(N)(Ԫ/d)JC(N)(Ԫ/d)NSa(N)(mg/L)JD(N)(Ԫ/d)

2177.78402177.693058615.000.0002
2177.78402177.692058715.000.0002
2177.78402177.692058815.000.0000

3.1ųʼ״̬ſƵ¸
Ϊʵÿյڿƣ˱ʹÿյĳʼ״̬ĩ״̬ͬ⣬ʹƱ֮һDOĳֵDO(0)ĩֵDO(1)ȣ޷ʵִյڿ.1ʾ趨״ֵ̬X(0)Ϊ2000mg/LʱڿƵĲּ.NʾSaʾƽˮŨȣJDʾǰμJĲֵ.
ɼDO1.583.97mg/L֮䣬ÿųĵﲻ150kg(BOD)/d.ÿյǰ10h(t0.4d)ŷ࣬ԱڽˮBODŨȴڸ߷(ף1ͼ2)ԭеMLSSŨֲDOŨֽϸ£MLSSŨ.ĿǾܽʹʱDOŨȣԼٹҪķ.֮ڽˮBODɽϵDOϵʱŷ࣬ʹZ(1)ǡΪ150kg/d״ֵ̬ĩֵͬ.


ͼ2X(0)2400mg/LʱſŹߵ
仯(JC=1826Ԫ/d)
Fig.2 Optimal controls and optimal trajectories atX(0)=2400mg/L(JC=1826yuan/d)


ͼ3X(0)2800mg/LʱſŹߵ
仯(JC=1893Ԫ/d)
Fig.3 Optimal controls and optimal trajectories at
X(0)=2800mg/L(JC=1893yuan/d)
ͼ2ͼ3״ֵ̬X(0)ֱΪ24002800mg/LʱڿƵļ.ǶеԼ.X(0)Ϊ2800mg/LʱMLSSŨȽϸߣߵDOŨҲ0.96mg/L.ÿǰ6h(t025d)ڴŷ࣬ΪʱķѲɺӣͬʱDOܵͣʵDOܶĹãʵСMLSSDOܾܽз.ÿպڼСŷΪX(1)Ҳ2800mg/L.֮мͬʼ״̬µſŹߣԼǰʹз.
оУǷ֣ͬʼ״̬ſʱзҲͬ.Ϊһоһ⣬ֽ˳ʼ״̬X(0)Ϊ20003000mg/LڿʱӦз.2ʾ.X(0)Ϊ2400mg/LʱſµзͣΪ1826Ԫ/d.
2ͬʼ״̬X(0)ſʱз
Table 2 Operation costs of optimal controls under various initial states X(0)

X(0),mg/L20002100220023002400250026002700280029003000
JC,Ԫ/d21781914184618331826183218471868189319041936

Ϊо˵ϵͳĶѧˮˮˮ仯ǳˮҪȷ뱾ĸͬʱз͵ſƶӦĳʼ״̬X(0)һ2400mg/L.ǣضµĴϵͳзʱӦX(0)ſƱ仯Ǵڲҵ.ڻ෨ſоУ״ġųʼ״̬ſơ¸.Ȼйſ۵רУ46ݶδ̸⣬ڱоԴڵģҲǿԽ͵.һ¸ĺǣԼX(0)=X(1)ʼ״̬X(0)ĴСеMLSSŨȵı仯ΧMLSSԽDOԽߣ֮Ȼ.ǰģ1ݵо֪άֹ߻͵DO(MLSS)Ũȶڽʡзã˴һʹзʡĳֵX(0)MLSSDOŨȵı仯Χ.ɣųʼ״̬ڿƵоڱ֤ˮʵͬʱ䴦ɱиҪ.
3.2ദſƵĹϵ
оı䴦ϵͳеĳóſƱ仯Ҳٵ֮ı.ЩĸıӰ첻еӰϴЩ仯Χ.磬ı䵥λҪĴAһֵſӰϴ󣬲ദķ̶Ȳͬһڲͬϵͳб仯ΧǺܴ.
Aֵ1.13.14.1Ԫ/kg(MLSS)(ֵ)ֵX(0)Ϊ2400mg/LſƼ.õߵз÷ֱΪ30493654Ԫ/d˺ߵȻظһЩ֮⣬ǵſƱı仯ɻһ£AֵΪ1.1Ԫ/kg(MLSS)ʱĴͬ.DOı仯A=1.1Ԫ/kgʱDOı仯ɼ෴ſDO״̬Sı仯ʸعϵ.ΪAֵദJ2ռзJCıҲ󣬶ڹ̿мСJCJ2Ҫ;ǼСŷͨڽˮл︺ŨSϵʱʵDOŨȣ΢˥(Դ)ʵ.˵ڵ͵ŨDOܸЧؼ.
3.3׼ſƲԵ
оˮϵͳſƲȾԽԣһʹȶɿˮˮʴﵽԤ׼ҿʹˮˮʸպҪӴɱڳˮˮʴǰ¾ܼзãԼʵڿƣųʼ״̬ſƸҪ.ſ˴ԽԣʵһԶشо.
ͨоԿϵͳеĸֲȡֵʼ״̬ԼȶſƱı仯ɲͬӰ죬ǣĳһضĴϵͳضܿųʼ״̬µſƱ仯.ɴǿԵõʾȻʵſҪϵͳ߿ƣǣв߱ʵſˮȫԸĸضϵͳųʼ״̬µſƱQwDOı仯ɣֶͨԶģſƣóŹXSı仯ɶԱƱQwDO.ֿƲִгΪ׼ſ.׼ſҲÿսˮˮˮ仯ϸѭĳһɵˮŽˮˮˮ״̬ı仯̬Ʊ.Ŀǰ׼ſƽи㷺ʵüֵ.

4
1.ȳֵزڿƵıҪ.ͨµ״̬Z(t)޸״ָ̬̺꣬òлŷƺ״̬ĩſ⻯ΪԼ⣬Ȼ󣬸ǽ𼫴ֵԭʺⱾڿѧģ.
2.оŲĶ̬޸ĴͳݶȷӦļ򣬴Ӷֻѡ񲽳µ񵴷ɢ⣬˼ٶȣʹ΢Ϊ.
3.о֣ĳһʼ´ʹзٵſƣңһʹзøٵĳʼɴˣųʼ״̬ڿƵ¸.ڱ֤ˮͬʱˮɱиҪ.
4.ı䴦ϵͳеĳЩſƱı仯ҲŸı䣬ǣõڿƽƲȣǾʹˮˮʸպôﵽԤҪԼͬʱʹзʡص.
5.ĻƼв߱ʵſˮϵͳʵʩ׼οƣĳضϵͳųʼ״̬µſƱQwDOı仯ɣֶԶ.
оڢ󲿷ֽоõƳˮлŨȺͬʱƽ߳ˮлŨȵڿ.
ο
1飬꣬Ө.෨Ķſƣ.DOŨȶзõӰ.ѧѧ199818(1)1119
2Benefield L D,Randall C W.Biological Process design for wastewater treatment.Prentice-Hall Inc,1980
3 Metcalf and Eddy.Inc.,Wastewater engineering:treatment,disposal,reuse,(2nd edition).McGraw Hall Book Company, 1979
4 ֵȱ.ִۻ.ҵ磬1981
5ѧ.ſӦ.廪ѧ磬1986
6.Żſ.廪ѧ磬1982
7ʤ.¬Ӣ.ִ.ѧ磬1976
8Կ.ִƹ.й磬1986
