ѧѧ
ACTASCIENTIAECIRCUMSTANTIAE
19982µ182ڿƼڿ
෨Ķſ*.ߺͬʱƽ߳ˮBODŨ
顡ꡡӨ
(ѧѧԺ150008)

(Ⱥѧѧ蹤ѧƣͩ376ձ)

ժҪǰĵĻϣһо˸õߺͬʱƽ߳ˮлŨŷű׼Լ£ʹзʡڿ.ſƱQWDOı仯ɶʹԼͽʡзãǣˮɱ仯ȷǳʱκοҲʹˮˮʴ꣬зû.Զԣͬʱƽ߳ˮBODŨǸŷű׼ˮйЧرˮ.ʼ״̬S(0)ſƵӰ첻.X(0)ӰϴڱоУX(0)ֵ24002600mg/LΧ.
ؼʡ෨ſƣˮBODŨ.
MULTIVARIABLE OPTIMAL CONTROL OF ACTIVATED SLUDGE PROCESS
.THE COMPARISON OF LIMITING AVERAGE AND/OR MAXIMUM BOD EFFLUENT CONCENTRATION

Peng Yongzhen,Wang Baozhen, Wang Shuying
( Dept Of Environ and Municipal Eng, Harbin Univ of Achitec and Eng, Harbin 150008)
Masao Kuroda
(Dept of Civil Eng, Gunma Univ, Kiryu 376,JAPAN)

ABSTRACTOn the basis of previous papers, this paper further studies the optimal period controd for the least cost operation under two different discharge standardsm, i.e., limiting average and/or maximum effluent organic concentration. Calculatiion results showed that the variation of optimal variables Qw and DO are trying the best to satisfy its restrictive conditions and to save operation costs. However, when the influent load changes drastically, any control measure is not possible to reach the standard and the operation costs will be greatly ncreased. Comparatively, limiting the average and maximum BOD concentration of effluent simultaneously is a more reasonable discharge standard. It not only benefits the operation and management of the sewage plant, but also protects the receiving water body more effectively. The influence of initial value S(0) on the optimal control is little while the influence of X(0) is significant. In this study, the optimal value of X(0) should be in the range of 24002600 mg/L.
Keywordsactivated sludge, optimal control, effluent BOD concentration.


1
ǰģ12ѾҪؽ˻෨ſƵһЩ⡢㷽Ӧ⣬а״̬ʾзõָ귺ʽ.оܽŨ(DO)зõӰ죬ԼƳˮл(BOD)ŷԼµſƼ㷽.ͨµ״̬ͲԼΪԼſ.ŲĶ̬޸ĴͳݶȷſƵļ㣻ݼųʼ״̬ڿƵ¸.ǿ˸ſƱı仯ɣʵ׼ſƵʵ.
Ӧǰģ2олŷ⣬ԳˮˮҪز߳ˮлŨȣͬʱƽ߳ˮлŨȵŷű׼.оֳˮˮԼµſ.ȻоԽˮʵſʱʵ׼ſƶиҪ.
һΪһڣͬʱ״̬XSͿƱDOĳֵĩֵͬԱʵڿ.ڼʱ˺0֮⣬ϵͳ(ǰģ1ͼ1)Ķѧ԰ǰģ1ݵı1ȡֵ.˵⣬зŶͬ׸.

2߳ˮBODŨȵſ
ָƳˮл(BOD)Ũκʱ̶ĳһ涨ŷű׼.ҹڵҶһŷű׼.ɣŷű׼Լ˴ϵͳˮˮʵĲˮĳ.
2.1ſƵѧģ㷽
2.1.1òΪԼſ⡡һ߳ˮBODŨȿɱʾΪ״̬SвʽԼ̣
Sst-S(t)0, tʣ0,1
(1)
ʽУSstΪˮлŨ޶ֵŷű׼(mg/L).ΪϵͳÿŷŵBODZ(1)ܳˮSstĳ˻ZsٿڿƵҪǰģ2е״̬(ʽ(26))ͳʼ(ʽ(29))ֻ״̬ĩֵԼΪʽ(2).

(2)
Բòʽ(1)ʽ(2)ԼΪָʽ(18)2뷴ӳЩԼƻ̶ȵĺʹ֮ΪԼ⣬õµָJ:

(3)
ʽУG3G4ΪԾ

(4)

(5)
ʽУK3K4ֱΪ㹻3.ˣ߳ˮлŨȵſҲԼ.
2.1.2߳ˮлŨſƵѧģ㡡µָʽ(3)ıG4(Sst-S)2һʽ(3)еı״̬ʽ(26)23Ҷֱ԰123ĺͣµH

(6)
ſۣH3״̬XSZƫó淽

(7)
ָʽ(3)еǰ3ǰģ2ͬԣ淽(7)ĩֵǰʽ(30)2ͬ.ˣ״̬(26)2ݺͰ淽(7)6һ΢ַ̣ʽ(29)2ݺʽ(30)2ָ6˵ټһƣ΢ַн.µʹH(6)ȡСֵ(еԼͬʱʹָзJCҲȡСֵ)ſQwDOı仯.ΪHԿƱƫHQwͦH/DOǰģ2еʽ(32)ȫͬһһгˣǰģ2Ų̬ݶȷͨ.
2.2
ǵķˮŷű׼BODŷű׼SstȷΪ15mg/L.
2.2.1ųʼ״̬µſ
ڱУˮˮˮʽ(8)Ҳ仯

(8)
ʽУ0ֱΪ12000m3/d0.160kg (BOD)/m3.QS0ͬ仯仯.


ͼ1ˮBODŨŵ
15mg/LĶֵƽĹ
Fig.1 The effluent BOD concentration gradually approach
to the constant 15 mg/L with iteration carrying on
״̬ĳʼֵΪX(0)=2300mg/LS(0)=15mg/LQ0w=280m3/dDO0=0.9mg/LĶֵʼſ.580εĵ㣬óԼ;Ҫſƣ״̬SˮBODŨŵ򶨳ֵ15mg/LƽĹͼ1ʾ䲿ּ1.
ȻֱַX(0)Ϊ21002200240025002600mg/Lʱſ.ƪֻX(0)Ϊ2500mg/Lʱļͼ2Ҫ£
(1)ˮBODŨSSst(15mg/L)ҶSstƵĽԼ޶ȵؽʡз.
1X(0)=2300mg/LʱſƵĲּ
Table 1 Parts of calculation results of optimal control at X(0)=2300mg/L

X(t),mg/LS(t),mg/LQw(t),m3/dDO(t),mg/Lt,dZ(t),kg/d
2300.015.00147.3100.926600
2308.915.00151.1801.12820.0509.070
2318.015.00166.3501.37980.10018.274
2326.515.00198.5601.65160.15027.591
2333.315.00248.2101.84470.20036.990
2337.415.00308.0501.93080.25046.432
2338.915.00364.8501.79730.30055.875
2338.115.00405.1701.54420.35065.274
2335.515.00425.0901.26840.40074.591
2331.815.00430.8501.02980.45083.794
2327.515.00430.4600.84610.50092.864
2322.715.00425.1400.71330.550101.794
2317.915.00414.3900.62190.600110.591
2313.115.00400.2300.56350.650119.274
2308.815.00385.4600.53220.700127.874
2305.015.00370.7600.52500.750136.432
2302.015.00354.8500.54120.800144.989
2299.915.00337.7300.58290.850153.590
2298.815.00322.0700.65470.900162.273
2298.915.00310.5600.76510.950171.070
2300.015.00303.2100.92661.000180.000
J(N)=2133.2250(Ԫ/d)JC(N)=2133.0870(Ԫ/d)




ͼ2X(0)=2500mg/LʱſŹߵı仯(JC=2114.1Ԫ/d)
Fig.2 The variation of optimum control and optimal trajectories at X(0)=2500 mg/L (JC=2114.1yuan/d)
(2)״̬XSͿƱDOĳֵĩֵȣʵڿ.(3)ΪS(t)SstſDOˮBODɳͬҲ仯仯ȴֵͬX(0)=2100mg/LſDOߴ6.86mg/LʱΪ0.66mg/L.⣬ſQwʱı仯ҲڼS(t)SstֽʡзѣҪ֤X(0)=X(1).
2ͬʼ״̬X(0)ſʱз(JC)
Table 2 Operation costs of optimum control under various initial statesunder vrious initial states X(0)

X(0),mg/L210022002300240025002600
JCԪ/d2667.52183.52133.12117.92114.12122.6

(4)ͬʼ״̬X(0)ſʱзҲͬ2ʾɼзŵͿڳʼֵX(0)Ϊ2500mg/L.
2.2.2ˮBODɶſƵӰ졡Ҫ۵⣬ˮˮˮ仯ʱǷS(t)Sst
Ϊʹ򻯱ڷ״ֵ̬X(0)Ϊ2400mg/LS(0)Ϊ15mg/L䣬ˮBODı仯ʽ(8)ֻͬıˮı仯£

(9)
ʽУƽˮ仯ϵ(m3/d).ֱ˦Ϊ20004000m3/dʱſƣ3˲ּ.
3=4000m3/dʱſƵĲּ
Table 3 Parts of calculation results of optimum control at =4000m3/d

X(t)mg/LS(t)mg/LQw(t)m3/dDO(t)mg/LtdZ(t)kg/d
2400.015.0000.756600
2416.514.9401.96610.0509.490
2434.814.9703.98530.10019.727
2454.515.8106.02240.15031.125
2475.616.5407.28890.20043.722
2497.716.8806.99740.25057.066
2520.016.7605.21430.30070.501
2541.716.1603.77230.35083.329
2559.015.251173.3002.27560.40094.970
2503.214.991153.7001.06810.450105.349
2470.915.00907.0500.62680.500114.815
2441.714.99841.2400.41200.550123.344
2415.714.99744.7400.29790.600130.985
2393.014.99646.2200.23560.650137.869
2375.214.99514.7400.20480.700144.203
2363.314.98370.9400.19710.750150.245
2358.814.98211.3700.21060.800156.286
2361.614.99102.1300.24920.850162.617
2369.814.9900.32540.900169.500
2382.514.9900.47120.950177.140
2397.015.0000.75661.000185.673
J(N)=7458.0560(Ԫ/d)JC(N)=3128.5160(Ԫ/d)

Լ.
(1)ǵĹͬصǣΪ˾ܵԼзãDOMLSSˮɳͬ仯DOı仯ԣΪڽˮɸ߷ʱάֽϸߵMLSSŨȣ0.25d֮ǰ(Qw0).
(2)ǵĲ֮ͬǣڦ=2000m3/dʱ˳ˮŷű׼S(t)15mg/Lڦ=4000mg/LʱȻˮ߷ʱDOߴ7.29mg/LˮBODԴ15mg/Lڽˮ͹ʱDO0.2mg/LңˮBODС15mg/L.
(3)Եóۣˮɱ仯(ֵ)ʱͨڿƱDOQwS(t)15mg/Lŷű׼.
4X(0)=2400mg/Lֵͬſʱз
Table 4 Operation costs of optimal control under various values at X(0)=2400mg/L

,m3/d300600100020004000
JCԪ/d2109.02117.92134.52232.43128.5

Ϊ˱ȽϦֵзõӰ죬4˲ֵͬſʱз.ԿŦֵзҲ֮ߣң4000m3/dʱS(t)15mg/Lŷű׼ÿսˮBODŨȼ仯Լÿսˮȫֵͬʱÿս봦ϵͳBODҲߣǣзֵʷԵعϵڦֵСʱJC֮󣬶2000m3/dʱJC.

ŷű׼ƣʵſ߳ˮлŨȵƣͬʱ޶ƽˮлŨȵŷű׼Ϊ.Ϊˣһŷű׼µſ.

3ͬʱƽ߳ˮлŨȵſ
Ŀǰŷ޵ʵʩͬʱƽ߳ˮBODŨȵˮŷű׼涨ÿաÿܻÿŷŵƽBODŨȣлŷַֹ˳ˮˮʲˮĲӰ죬һָѧˮʹ׼.
3.1ſƵѧģ㷽
οĿǰƶŷű׼ͳˮÿƽˮBODŨȲƽˮBODŨȪst,ȡst=15mg/L
st-0,15,tʣ0,1
(10)
ͬʱҪκʱt߳ˮBODŨS(t)Sstʽ(1)ȡSst=20mg/L.ſѧģƼ㷽߳ˮBODŨȵȫֻͬʽ(10)Լ.Ϊÿսˮһʱ״̬ĩֵÿˮŷŵBODZ(1)ÿƽˮBODŨǵȼ۵ģԣZs=stڼʽ(2)е״̵̬ĩֵԼZs-Z(1)0Ȼʽ(10)Լ.ʱԲŲ̬ݶȷ׸.
3.2
3.2.1ŷű׼ſƵıȽϡϽͬԭʼݣҲȡ=4000m3/dͬʱƽ߳ˮBODŨȵſƲֽͼ3ʾ.3Ľȣ²ͬ
(1)ڽˮɸ߷ʱDO1.33mg/LʹS20mg/L꣬Z(1)=180kg/dƽˮBODŨstǡõ15mg/L.
(2)DOûˮͬ仯󲿷ʱ䶼ʡõ0.95mg/Lң1.


ͼ3=4000m3/d Sst=20mg/L,st=15mg/Lʱ
ſŹ(JC=2192.6Ԫ/d)
Fig.3 Optimal control and optimal trajectories at =4000m3/dSst=20mg/L,st=15mg/L (JC=2192.6yuan/d)

(3)ÿŷCOD5.67kg/dһʡ935.9Ԫ/dз.
ɼڽˮɱ仯Ƚϴʱŷű׼޶BODŷͬͬʱƽ߳ˮBODŨȵŷű׼ȴϵͳй뽵ʹɱõֻǳˮˮʲϴ.
3.2.2ųʼ״̬µſơֻ߳ˮBODŨԼ£ſʱS(t)=15mg/Lԣųʼ״̬S(0).ڣоS(0)ſƵӰ.
5S(0)=9mg/LʱſƵĲּ
Table 5 Parts of calculation results of optimal control at S(0)=9mg/L

X(t),mg/LS(t),mg/LQw(t),m3/dDO(t),mg/Lt,dZ(t),kg/d
2410.09.000.4100.518800
2420.116.330.3900.59690.0506.932
2436.817.860.3600.70000.10017.269
2456.819.940.3301.23830.15030.170
2480.519.980.3002.56980.20044.588
2505.619.990.2503.70460.25059.493
2530.719.87.2901.71910.30074.386
2546.019.89465.3600.88860.35088.789
2543.019.63481.2400.44860.400102.241
2536.319.48468.4300.27990.450114.276
2528.417.80423.4600.27070.500124.572
2519.813.50407.0000.27180.550131.969
2509.38.57369.3800.52220.600136.282
2496.65.23351.1300.60970.650138.441
2482.13.90332.7100.75480.700139.692
2467.23.21314.3500.92290.750140.580
2452.73.28306.1400.92500.800141.393
2439.43.94288.2300.82410.850142.382
2428.35.21306.8800.75570.900143.851
2418.37.25316.6100.69840.950146.246
2410.09.00402.7900.51881.000150.000
J(N)=1915.1550(Ԫ/d)JC(N)=1915.1280(Ԫ/d)

ڽˮˮʱ仯Ƚϴʱͬʱƽ߳ˮBODŨȵſҲˮˮҪˣǰģ1ʽ(19)ʾĽˮˮʵˮı仯оſ.ˮл︺ɸ߷壬͹ʱ6.
5S(0)Ϊ9mg/L,X(0)Ϊ2410mg/LʱſƵĲּ.ɼԼõ㣬S(t)20mg/L,15mg/Lˮɸ߷ʱDOΪ3.70mg/LͿʹSΪ19.99mg/LDOʱ0.3mg/L.ڲûиDOŨȵԼԵ.룬DOĳһŨȣſƽеƽˮBODŨȿ϶15mg/LзԵ.ʼ״̬S(0)ֱΪ1011121518mg/LX(0)Ϊ2410mg/LʱſƼS(0)Ĳ֮⣬XSQwDOı仯ɼΪƣзҲ޼ֱΪ1915.11910.51907.41908.81909.01910.6Ԫ/d.ɼʼ״̬S(0)ſƽӰС.
6ͬʼ״̬X(0)ſʱз
Table 6 Operation costs of optimal control of various initial states X(0)

X(0),mg/L235024002450260027002800
JCԪ/d2101.01917.51888.81874.31876.31877.4

S(0)Ϊ11mg/LX(0)ȡֵͬſʱз6ʾ.ɼX(0)ֵļСзԽ.УX(0)Ϊ2600mg/LʱзС.ǰģ2ݺͱĵڶڵоʹſʱзøʡųʼ״̬X(0)ңڲͬĽˮˮˮ仯ˮˮˮԼ£ųʼ״̬X(0)ֵҲͬ.

4
1.Ƚŷű׼µſѧģͣŲ̬ݶȷȻǿټݵ.
2.һ£ֻ߳ˮBODŨȵſƲʹˮˮŷű׼ʹˮBODŨȶƵ߳ˮBODŨȣзʡ.ǣˮɱ仯ȺܴʱκοҲʹˮˮʴ꣬зûѸ.
3.ͬʱƽ߳ˮBODŨȵŷű׼£ƵBODŨȽϸߣڽˮɱ仯ȺܴʱſQwDOҲʹˮ.ŷű׼ˮйͽʹɱṩõ˳ˮBODŨƣڱˮ壬һָеŷű׼.
4.ˣǰģ12ݺͱͨõĽڿƱQwDOı仯ɶǾʹԼõзʡ.
5.ʼ״̬S(0)ſӰ첻󣬶ʼ״̬X(0)ĴСеŨȣˣʹſʱзøʡųʼ״̬ҪָX(0)ңڲͬŷű׼ͽˮˮˮ仯£ųʼ״̬X(0)ֵҲͬڱоض£X(0)24002600mg/LΧ.
ɼзõ;ܶ.ʵĳһضˮˮˮ仯ڹʱѡȡͬƲ乤۲ͬųʼ״̬µſҲͬ.ˣѰʹƾ̬ŻʱĻ붯̬ſʱз֮ΪС⣬һոµĸо.

μӱоĻ㡢ܡ塢޺ƽ͸ߴ淵ͬ־.
ο
1飬.෨Ķſ I.DOŨȶзõӰ.ѧѧ199818(1)11
2飬.෨Ķſ.л(BOD)ŷ.ѧѧ199818(1)20
3ֵȱ.ִۻ.ҵ,1981
