ѧѧ
ACTASCIENTIAECIRCUMSTANTIAE
19986µ186ڿƼڿ
ߵȻרҵγ̽ṹͽѧʵʩȽо
½ǿ١ŸӾ
(Ͼѧѧ빤ϵȾԴоصʵңϾ210093)

ժҪ5ѧΪͷ价רҵĿγ̽ṹͽѧʵʩĻ״ҹ˱Ƚо.оγ̽ṹͽѧʵʩԲҪ9棺רҵĿꣻʽγ̵ãγϵṹѧƣĿγãʱӳ¹۵۵Ŀγ̣Ŀѧѧγã߿γ̣Դγ̺רҵѧʽ.ȽоΪ9Ϊҹ޶౾רҵͻѧҪĽ.ͬʱṩĳЩвοֵĿγʵ.
ؼʡߵȻγ̽ṹȽо.
COMPARATIVE STUDY OF THE COURSE STRUCTURE FOR ENVIRONMENTAL PROGRAMS (MAJORS) AND TEACHING PRACTICE IN HIGHER ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION BETWEEN CHINA AND USA

Lu Genfa, Yin Daqiang, Ding Shurong, Xu Ouyong
(State Key Laboratory of Pollution Control and Resource Reuse,Department of Environmental Science and Engineering,Nanjing University,Nanjing,210093)

ABSTRACTIn this paper,based on data from five universities and colleges which are chosen as representatives of USA,the system and structure of courses and teaching practice for undergraduate students majoring in environment between China and USA were studied and analysed comparatively.The multiphase analysis and comparative studies sholwed that there were many differences in system and structure of environmental courses adn teaching practices between China and USA.These differences mainly existed in the following aspects:the training objectives;setting up courses on quality education for students;the system and structure of courses and the practice of the credit system;setting up courses to foster student's ability to solve environmental problems;timely response to new viewpoints and theories on environmental sciences;setting up courese about environmental humanities and social science;developing courses concerning environmental policy;course of resource science;and the utilization of teaching methods.We can conclude that some experiences mentioned above in USA are used for reference when we make the national basic training speciifications and basic teaching requirements for undergraduate studnets majoring in environment.
Keywordshigher environmental educatioin,course structure,comparative study.
ѡߵѧУ౾רҵод5ѧԻרҵγ̽ṹͽѧʵʩϴ9ҹԶԱȣΪоƶҹУרҵͽѧҪԼߵȻչսṩо.

1רҵĿĲ
ҹԱĿǿרҡ͡ר˲šҪҵרҵܡԿڡѧΨרҵ֪ʶȲΪӹȣ±ҵӦС.רҵھ.һ棬ӶѧȫĻʵڡ֪ʶ͡ˡУ߽Ϊ.ѧԱĿ꣬Ƚע߼ˣ籱ɴѧĹѧԺıѧλרҵ(ѧרҵΪ4ѧλרҵ֮һ)ǽ㷺Ļ빫רҵϣ1.רҵйרҵְҵԱΪԺоѧϰṩһʵĻʹѧȫ淢չ.νȫ淢չʵָΪһдѧĻ.רҵѧڻýǿרҵͬʱҲЩѧڻеӦáǿӦ.

2ʽγ
ԱӦעʽ.ָ֪ʶټʹ֪ʶõطõĶ.ʾ԰4棺һ˼ʣĻ(뾫Ļ)ҵʣ.ʽ4ȫ.21Ҫ˲Ǹʵġȫ淢չ˲.ԴѧʵĽһʮָӵϵͳ̣һ桢һַʤΣͨЭЧ.ϵпγһҪķ.ʢѧСۺϽƻ(General Education Program)ȽϾϵͳԣᴩһ꼶꼶ϵпγ̣4ܹϰ40ѧ֣ΪġѧƺͿѧ(ʵΪȻѧ)3ϵУ2.ִеѧơѧۡѧѧĻеҪѧְҵ(Ethics and Professionalismľ̵ְҵ)ְҵдȵȿγ̣Լǿѧʽ.
ŦԼѧѧɭѧԺоϵоרҵڡϵͲ֡γ(൱ҹ)60ѧУĿѧ6ѧ֣γ̰ѧѧ֡ϲȣѧԼѡ3.ҹĿγ绷ѧרҵ޿дѧ˼Ʒ¡ѧۡѧ10ѧ֣һЩѧУ͡͵ѡ.Ȼ֮γòͬĿͬǿѧĻʽ.ȻְҵʽҹרҵгӣγԶԶ.ſ˴ѧѧԺְҵʽγУְҵд(Professional Writing)\,ְҵ(Professional Skill)\,Ӱ׼ͱ(Environmental Impact Analysis Preparing and Documenting)4.ŦԼѧѧɭѧԺоϵĿγУдͼо(Library Research)\,ѧְҵд(Writing for Science Professionals)\,ְҵд(Writing for Environmental Professionals)ȣ3.ҹУ軷רҵӢһţⲻ϶ѧȫҪҹڼǿ˼ʺĻʽͬʱǿְҵʽ.

3γϵͽṹѧʵʩϵĲ
ҹбѧеȱǹ涨ıѧֶ࣬ѡѧ٣רҵγ٣ѧѡ.౾רҵγеһصרҵڶ࣬漰㣬ѧѡɶȴرָѡ޿κͱ޿Ҳͬʱſιѧѡ.1гŦԼѧѧɭѧԺоרҵγ̽ṹ3ݣӱ1Կרҵ޿он϶ѡޣ޷רҵκ͡ϵͲ֡γ̱޿(൱ҹĹ)Ҳнϴѡɶ.ڿγ̽ṹϼȷָݣעⱣ֤ҪĲֵĲͬѡԱѧϰƻ.ЩԵصһ淴ӳ˻ѧƺͻĸԺۺѧԣһҲӳгõڼ˲ص㣬ӳѧҼֵԼѧĽ˼.

4ۺϷͽ
γӦۺѧԵģӦʵʻ.ѧУγӦڻõۻϣص⻷ʵ.ѧӦһԾ˼ߺ֪ʶĲߣӦԹߺ֪ʶ˼Ľߣѧ֪ʶͼӦڶԻߡʵ5.ĽӦǶѧƵۺԷˣҪѧۺϷͽʵ.ѧγбȽѧۺϵطսķ(2).2гЩγ̶ͨʵںͿֳУҹѧʮȱγ.
1ŦԼѧѧɭѧԺоϵĿγϵṹ
Table 1 The system and structure of course offerings at faculty of Environmental Studies,College ofEnvironmental Science and Forestry,State University of New York

ϵͲֿγ̽ϸֿ߲γ
A. Ȼѧ(Nature Sciences),1520ѧ
a. ̬ͨѧֲͨѧͨѧ68ѧ
b. ͨѧ/ѧ34ѧ
c. ͨѧͨѧ68ѧ
B. ѧ(Social Sciences),18ѧ
a. ѧ3ѧ
b. /οѧ3ѧ
c. ѧĻѧ3ѧ
d. ʷ3ѧ
e. ѧѧѧΣ6ѧ
C. Ŀѧ(Humanities),6ѧ
γ̰ѧѧ֡Ϸ
D. Ӣд6ѧ
E. ѧͼӦã6ѧ
F. γ̣49ѧ
ѧɽϵͿγ60ѧе54ѧ֣ͨѧγһűʵ飬ѧϰһͨѧͨѧ.b. ܺͷΣ9ѧ
ͳѧ3ѧ
6ѧѧпγָѡޣ(ۣۻ᣻ӰۣϢۣ߼ѧ)
ѧ3ѧ
ԭ3ѧ
ȻԴͻߣ3ѧ
ȻԴ3ѧ
C. Σ
꼶ʼоרҵ4ΪϢ뼼ʹù滮ѧӦúÿһ12ѧ.
a. Ϣ뼼
ͿռϢ3ѧ
ˮˮ3ѧ
ľģʽ3ѧ
Ϣϵͳۣ3ѧ
b. ʹù滮
滮еȻ̣3ѧ
ۺع滮3ѧ
ʹ÷չ̣3ѧ
طչ3ѧ
c. ѧӦ
ԴΣ6ѧ(ֲԴ3ѧ֣Դ3ѧ)
ѡ6ѧֵѧȿγ(򹤳)
d. 
D. רҵγ̣12ѧ
ⲿֿγѧԼѡ뱣֤оȺȵѧϰ.γУֹɭεصĹ滮ͷչҰ.
E. ߼ۺϿ(Senior Syntheis),3ѧ
꼶ѧ3ѧֵĻоۺϿΣγ̵ʽѧ͵ʦоѧϰС飬ۺѧƵķۻ.
ѧӦɽϸֿ߲6162ѧе51ѧ.
һоרҵѧ121122ѧֲܱҵӦֿγе105ѧ֣1617ѧֿѧѡ.
ϸֿ߲γ
A. оרҵΣ2122ѧ
a. ȻѧΣ1213ѧ
޿ţ
ѧ3ѧ
ˮѧˮ3ѧ
̬ͨѧ3ѧ
ѧпγѡһţ
(΢ѧֲԣľѧѧ޼׵ѧΪԭͲ鶯ѧлѧѧ)
b. ѧΣ9ѧ
ʶֵͻ3ѧ
ͻ3ѧ
̺ͻ3ѧ
׼ѧѡѧָѡ޿.
B. ܺͷΣ13ѧ
a. (The Technical Communications)4ѧ
ְҵд(Writing for Professionals)
ͼо(Library Research)

עоרҵõĿγ̷Ϊ󲿷֣ϵͲֿγ̹һ꼶ѧѧϰϸֿ߲γ̹꼶ѧѧϰ.רҵѧ꣬軷оѧѧʿѧλ(Bachelor of Science in Environmental Studies)
24ѧרҵۺϷͽĲֿγ
Table 2 The courses of environmental majors (Programs) to foster students' abilityto do integrated
analysis and to solve environmental problems at 4 universities in USA

ɴѧ1ݶſ˴ѧ4
ѧ빤רҵѧרҵ
ķͽ(Analysis and Solution of Environmental problems)

(ÿ1СʱΣ2Сʱ)ۺϰо(Integrated Case Studies)
ѧао(Case Studies in Environmental)
Դͻߵľ÷(Economic Analysis of Resource and Environmental Policy)
ʡѧԺ(MIT)6ŦԼѧ3
滮רҵоרҵ
̬ѧ
(Ecologrical Approachs to Environmental Problem Solving)
߹滮ƺʵʩսԷ
(Strategic Analysis for Environmental Policy Planning,Desigin and Implementaion)оָ
(Introductory Research Problems)

(Creative Problem Solving)


5ʱӳ¹۵㡢۵Ŀγ
רҵγ̵صܼʱطӳǰߺ;ٴе¹۵㡢¶½չʧʱѧܣ᳹¿γУڿγе½ڳʵΪݣʹѧܸʱķչ.ⷽĿγ̺ܶ࣬磺ȾֹۣѧͿɳչ.ͷͿɳչ.ۺȽϻͿɳչ.3.
3ߵѧУרҵзӳ¹۵㡢۵Ŀγ̾
Table 3 The examples for environmental courses concerning new viewpoints and theories for environmentalmajors (Programs) at some universities and colleges in USA

ʢѧ2ݶſ˴ѧ4
Ϣϵͳ(Introducation to Geographic Information Systems)

ɸԴı(Conservation of Renewable Resource)Ϣϵͳмͼ
(Computer-Based Map Analysis with Geopgraphic Information Systems)
ʡѧԺ6ŦԼѧ3
еì(Controversies in Public Policy)
֯뻷(Organizations and Environment)
ʻЭ(International Environment Negotiation)ͻ(Government and the Environment)
ʶֵͻ(Attitude,Values and the Environment)
뻷(Social Processes and the Environment)
оϵ(Env.Studies Intership)
˵Э(Negotiating Env.Disputes)
(Env.Decisionmaking)
(Env.Institutions)
Ϣ(Env.Information Policy)
(Env.Communications)


6Ŀѧѧγ
ȻṹҾṹ.ͬҲʵͽṹ.ⱻΪһԴôĽͱڵһĿƼ֮Уµļɹʵ.ָǻ⣬Ǽ򵥵ļ.Ľ漰ʵΪʶ̬Դ;÷չģʽṹ;÷չĴֵۺ͵±׼͹ʶߺͲ.ˣ漰Ρɡ¡ֵߵȵһĿѧ֪ʶԽΪĿ֮һĻҪѧңһҪ˼ҡμҡѧңѯԼξߵĻߺߣ5.
4ߵѧУרҵĿѧѧĿγ̾
Table 4 The examples of environmental courses concerning humanities and 
social sciences of environmental majors (Programs) at some universities and colleges in USA

ŦԼѧ3ݶſ˴ѧ4
/ĻӰͻʽ

ѧе
Ȼѧ뵱ǰ
Ȼѧ
Ȼѧ
ͼо
ȻԴͻ
ԭ
ȻԴѧۺӦ
Դͻѧ
Դͻߵľ÷
Դͻ
Ϳɳչ.ͷ
Ϳɳչ.Ľ
ѧ
ȻԴľѧĸ߼
һ߷ʵʩ
ʡѧԺ6ݻʢѧ2
÷չ
ߺͷ

ѧоʵеӦ

ߺ
ȽϻͿɳչѧ
ѧѧ
ѧ
̬ѧ
ѧ
΢۾ѧ
۾ѧ

߷
뻷

һЩѧרҵγòרҵγ˴ѧγ̣ڹ޿Ҳǿѧγ̣ƺ͹ƶ.ӱ1ɿŦԼѧѧɭѧԺоרҵڽϵͲֿγ(൱ҹĹ)60ѧУ涨ѧ18ѧ֣Ŀѧ6ѧ.ҹ绷ѧרҵĹ޿γҪοΣѧξѧͿѧ壬ԼһЩѧѡ޿.УĿѧѧγ̺ܶ(4).Щγ̶ҹʦ˵Ҳ൱İȱ̲ĺͽѧο.
7ӺͿ軷߷Ŀγ
רҵû߷γ̵Ĳרҵ϶࣬Ҹרҵ˴漰ߵĿγ̣5.ⷴӳߵȻȽǿҪѧƻԱ.вѧУĸ߲λԱӰͶԱԶ׼.
Ϊ˶ƽŮȨ˶һһλ.ƶʵʩֱӰŻĲͽĿǰĻΡصĻûдﵽԷĻ׶Σ7.Ŀ֮һǰѧ̬ġεġõĺڻɸıķͱľߣѧΡеͷ̣ѧβĲͬʽڽǱõжսƶжϣ5ݣҹǿۻʵСͬ͡ͳһĻһµ.
5ִѧרҵ߿γ̾
Table 5 The examples of environmental courses concerning environmental policy for environmentalmajors (Programs) at some universities and colleges in USA

ſ˴ѧ4ʡѧԺ6
Դͻߵľ÷(Economic Analysis of Resource and Env.Policy)

Դͻ(Resource and Env.Policy)
ԭ(Land Use Principles and Policy)
һߵʵʩ(Implementation of the National Env.Policy)ߺ(Environmenta Policy and Regulation)
(Discuss on Social Policy)
ߺ(Env.Design Policy and Action)
лѧƷߺ͹(Chemicals in Env.:Policy and Management)
ŦԼѧ3ݱɴѧ1
(Env.Decisionmaking)
(Env.Law and Policy)(Env.Management and Policy)
߷(Env.Policy Analysis)
ȻԴ(Natural Resources Law and Policy)
ˮԴ滮߷(Water Resources Planning and Policy Analysis)
Ⱦµ(Air Pollution Regulatory Policy Issues)
ʢѧ2
(Environmental Policy)
ۻ(Env.Policy Seminar)ÿ2Сʱ



8Դγ̳뻷γ
ĲԴĿǲɷָģǶԻʶҲǴԴ⿪ʼһʶش󻷾˿ʳ⣬֮ʶϵԴ޵ģԴûڶĻƻȾ.Ҫ֮һԴ.ɳչµԴҪԱ㱣ȵ.
ȻԴвɷ֣ڱרҵγúͽѧҲӦַӳ.ҹȴٽϺͷӳϵ.ߵȻרҵϰԴ뻷ϵһ𣬶ڿγҲ(6).
6רҵԴγ̾
Table 6 The examples of environmental courses concerning natural resource for environmental majors (programs) at some universities and colleges in USA

ſ˴ѧ4ŦԼѧ3
Դ(Soil Resource)

Դ뻷ѧ(Resource and Env.Economics)
Դ뻷(Resource and Env.Policy)
ȻԴ۵ľѧ
(Economics of Natural Resource Damage Assessment)
ȻԴľѧĸ߼
(Advanced Theory of Env.and Natural Resource Economics)
Դͻۻ(Seminar in Resource and Env.Policy)̬ѧԴͷչ
(Ecology,Resource and Development)
ˮԴ
(Water Resources Management)
Դо
(Research in Environmental and Resource Engineering)



9רҵѧп۷ʽ
¶˿*ȶΪС۽ѧã8ݣ(1) չǼܡa. ٽ⣺һС۵ĻҪӦʹѧ֪ĳһѧĸԭȵȣʹѧѧѧи֪ʶ֮ϵb. ͨѧġƻʵչǱ.(2) ѧν⣬жϣչ˼ά.(3) иݵĳһ.(4) ѧͷļ.(5) ıѧ̬.
ѧγ̵ĽѧʽԽʦڵĹ䷽ʽΪڽʦκ󣬹涨϶ѧʱڿ(Seminar)Щγ̿۵ѧʱڽʦѧʱ籱ɴѧġķͽÿܹ3ѧʱнʦ1ѧʱ2ѧʱ1.
ѧĿγдۻ(Seminar)ͽ(Advanced Topic of Special Topics)Լо(Independent Study),һ12ѧ֣ۻͽʽнʦ֯ѧԼ֯ĳһĳһѧѧ֪ʶοϣѧݽԼĹ۵㣬ڵԲĽ.оһڽʦָ£35ѧһ飬ĳһչڡодС.Щۻ᲻ѧ˼⣬оʵʼܣѧڻѧԵʮҪ.Ŀ֮һڻĽѧչͽļܣҪṩѧлˮƽϵĻڻĽ5.ȻҹרҵĽѧʽԿùĽѧʽΪֽѧʽȲϸߵȽĽѧ˼ͷչƣҲϻѧӦеĽѧص.

10С
ͨ9ĵ顢ԱȺͷԿСߵȽרҵγϵṹѧʵʩϴںܴҹߵȻںܶ෽.ĿҪıְֻҵרҪȫʽһǿרҵھרҵƿھһӦоרҵƣڿγϵͽṹҪ֯.ȫʽᴩרҵѧϰọ̈̄ӿγúͽѧݼϣŬǿۺϷʵʻγݶҪʱӳִѧе½չҪӴγϵĿѧѧγ̵ıأũҽĸרҵҪˣ軷߷Ŀγ̺йؿγлߵݣ跨ıĿǰγϵԴ뻷ѽڵ״нϵĿγ̣ͻܷγ̵ãڽѧʵʩʵıԽʦΪĹʽѧʽÿۡĶȸõĽѧʽѧѧϰԺͽʵʻ.
ο
1The University of North Carlina at Chapel Hill,Record of the School of Public Health,Department of Environmental Science and Engineering,19951997
2Washington State University,Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering,The Undergraduate Program,1995
3State University of New York.College of Environmental Sicience and Forestry,19941995
4Duke University,School of the Environment,19961997
5Ian Robottom,Environmental education:Practice and Possible,Deakin University Press,Austalia,1987
6Massachusetts Institute of Technology,Department of Urban Studies and Planning,19951996
7Julie Jubeir.Education of Environmental Managers for Tomorrow,EPA Journal,Spring,1995:3133
8¶˿*ȶ..ߵѧУ.磬1989
