ѧѧ
ACTA SCIENTIAE CIRCUMSTANTIAE
1999 19 2VOL.19 NO.2 1999



ؽȾƻ׼о
.C-B-Tһ(Triad)
¡
ժҪۺݿCERP-DBMS֧£ˮһ(Triad)ְؽȾƻ׼(SQC).ͨѧ(C)Լ(T)͵Ⱥṹ仯(B)ԪΪһͼӦӦϢжϾ󣬻ֳӦĳ׼ܽΪָʾְؽȾԳ̶ȺͷֲģʽֵԳؽȾļ-ӦϵΪһƶ׼(SQS)չȾָṩ֤Ϳѧ.
ؼʡ׼(SQC)һ(Triad)ؽְ.
Sediment quality criteria for heavy metal pollution in the Lean River . Sediment quality triad approach

LIU Wenxin,TANG Hongxiao (SKLEAC,Research Center for Eco-Environmental Sciences,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100085)
AbstractBy the aid of a comprehensive database, regional sediment quality criteria(SQC) for heavy metal pollution along the Lean River were established with an integrative approach-triad. Chemical analysis(C) and toxic tests(T) were combined with benthic macro invertebrates community structure alternations(B). Based on tri-axial graphs together with relevant matrix of decision-making, the initial bio-responsive sediment quality criteria clearly indicated the situation of heavy metal pollution, and showed the dose-response relationships between heavy metal contamination and benthic biotics. Moreover, the SQC may provide some basic material for establishment of sediment quality standards(SQS) and for follow-up remediation engineering in the area.
Keywordssediment quality criteria,triad,Lean River,heavy metal.
1ǰ
ˮˮ̬ϵͳҪӰ죬Ӧĳ׼(SQC)Ҳܵӣ1.ĿǰSQC㷺̬Ⱦ״ŷŸɺƼ.ͬʱSQCҲƶְܺͷǿĳ׼(SQS)ľ߸ߣ2.ĿǰҼSQCԴڸģʽ׶Σضλ(site-specific)ض(situation-specific)SQCǰоȵ3.SQCıʽɴ廮Ϊ()ӦSQCҪɸѡˮƽŨȷ(SLC)ЧӦֵ(AET)һ(Triad)ȣ()ֵSQCƽ䷨(EqP)ˮʱ׼(WQC)13.УTriadжػ(ںϻѧԼ͵ȺṹԪ)͵֤ݸʽ(evidence-burden)ɻ.һ(SQT)ֳ(in situ)ЧӦڽһѧȾͻѧȾĿƻ׼ۺ״ˮӰ45.ΪֹйSQCרоڹڿչ٣1ݣSQTʵӦޱ.ԵͭȾְΪоۺݿһؽȾ-ӦϵӦSQCڸıĳ״Ⱦ̬о.

2뷽
2.1λ


ͼ1ְλʾͼ
Fig.1 Sampling sites along the Lean River

ڵְջ۶ڵͭ󣬿ᡢϿˮͬؽСС͹ҵұˮӲͬλŷŽְͭΪؽȾˮ̬˥.ͼ1ΪCERPƻְõĲվλ.
2.2TriadSQCĻ
2.2.1Ԫָ궨ۺݿCERP-DBMS֧£Ļѧ(C)ﶾ(T)͵Ⱥṹ(B)Ԫʵݽвοʼݱ任ͳһ淶Ϊٷֱȣ10.
(1) ѧŨȷ(C)SQCĿǱнȾĻѧ迼ǽֲ̬Ӱɻӷ(AVS)ԽЧӦУ.ְAVSˮƽܵͣͬȡŨ֮(SEM)AVSıֵͨ16ݣʿɺAVS.CERPƻǰоְнֲ̬ɸԻ֣̬е̬֮ռݾƣ7ݣƶSQCӦˮĽͻһӦ˱ѡֲ̬ΧΪﻯѧԭʼ.ְ(510 cm)Ʒʪɸѡ(<63 m)ºɺȡ󣬲AASICPͭǦпӡ顢Ԫؽвⶨ.ÿֽķŨ(Dij)Եر(A01)Ϊ(Drj)빫ʽ(1)RTRݰʽ(2)Ӻͺɹʽ(3)淶Ϊٷֱ.
Rij=Dij/Drj, i=1,2,,n j=1,2,,mֽ(1)

(2)

Rti=1+(100-1)*(Ri-Rmin)/(Rmax-Rmin), i=1,2,,n(3)
(2) ﶾԼ(T)ԼĿ(i) ϶ˮ.ѡ͵ˮQ-67(ຣVibrio Qinghaiensis sp.Nov.)8ݺMicrotox鷽ƼT3(Photobacterium phosphoreum)ձ׼ĳʵ鷽Ͷ۳(TIE)ְ϶ˮƷﶾԣ9ݣָΪԸ(Inhibition %)(ii) ô(D.magna)гȡҺ(ˮó=14ʱ48 h)ʪԳı¶(Ӵ)Բ(T=48 h)Ը(Lethality %)ʾ.аٷֱ÷Ǻ任Ϊ(Radian)ֵ5.ͬѡ񺣿A01αȣɹʽ(1)ԲԵRTRֵվλݷֱӺͺ󰴹ʽ(2)淶Ϊٷֱ.
(3) Ⱥṹ仯(B)ѡӦĵܴ޼׵ϵ(benthic macroinvertebrates)Ϊָʾ֣5ݣϢ۹ʽ(ʽ4)ȵͳƽתΪָʽ10.ͬεĺA01οѭʽ(1)ֱRTRֱֵùʽ(3)淶Ϊٷֱ.Ϊ뻯ѧ(C)ﶾ(T)İٷֱȵӦһ£ùʽ(5)ת.

(4)
ʽУniĳiĸĿ,nͬһmֵĸܺ.

(5)
2.2.2Ⱦ״ĳжϼӦߡѡȡA01ΪȽϻ׼ȷվλԪӦָԳ̶(+/-űʶԪ/Ӧ)жϳ״;߹ʩľΣ5ݣ1.

1һϢӦ-жϾ
Table 1 Triad response matrix for primary decision-making and advice
CTBܵĽԺͳ*
+++ؽȾ˥˵֤ȷ˥˳̶ȺضѧȾ(1)
---û˥˼״̬Ҫ
+--ؽɸԺܵĿǰҪ
-+-δⶨĿɵǱ˥˵Ⱦ**нָоȷѧȾ(1)
--+Ⱥṹĸı䲢ԴжؽĿǰҪ
++-ڳЧԣֳЧ(2)ʵЧԴͳ̶ƶˮƽ(1)
-++ڵ˥˵δⶨжȾ(3)ЧӦԴͳ̶ƶˮƽ(1)
+-+ЧӦͻȺṹıͬ޹ؿܲҪиӵļȷо
*Դƺһʩеȫ򲿷֣**ºʵѧ(Թ̵QA&QCԼ޵)Ͷʵ(ʿQA&QC)ǽиӷ(1) ĳЩ軳ɰĶԣ(2) º˲Ⱥ(ͳƷȷϲδṹı)ǽԴƣ(3)º˲黯ѧԼʿQA&QCһǸӷﶾԺ͵ȺṹıԭԴ.
2.2.3C-B-TͼԪָİٷֱͳһƳʾͼָʾؽȾԳ̶ȺͿռֲģʽʾؽȾ֮ļ-Ӧϵ.УCBTֱѧŨЧӦȺṹ仯ﶾӰ.ԪϵİٷֱԽͣ㸽иûԪԽС.

3
3.1ԪָĶת
3.1.1ؽѧ(C)ؽվķԺA01Ϊ׼ÿֽԵĲοʣȻ󽫸վλмRTRӣɹʽ(2)תΪٷֱȣ2.

2ְؽŨȲοֵ㼰ת
Table 2 RTR transformation for contents of various heavy metals in surface sediments
Ri(Cu)Ri(Pb)Ri(Zn)Ri(Cd)Ri(As)Ri(Cr)ӺͰٷֱ
A011.01.01.01.01.01.06.01
A04109.41.70.81.01.82.4117.1100
A0569.31.00.61.01.51.775.263
A0737.85.33.22.08.41.858.548
ɽA0830.72.11.81.33.51.941.333
ӶA0913.81.51.21.02.31.721.515
̼A1328.41.62.21.32.31.837.629
A1410.91.51.01.01.92.118.412
A1610.41.41.20.31.91.616.911
ֵ109.45.33.22.08.42.4117.1100
Сֵ1.01.00.60.31.01.06.01
3.1.2ȾﶾԼ(T)3о˿϶ˮˮҺʪԳﶾԼݵķǺ任()RTR㼰ת.

3ְﶾݵķұ任οֵ㼰ת
Table 3 Arcsine and RTR transformation of toxic data(%) for heavy metals in surface sedments
վλ
ƿ϶ˮT3
%任϶ˮQ67
%任ʪӴ
D.magna%任ˮҺ
D.magna%任RTR
ӺͰٷ

A010.01/10.05/10.32/10.01/141
A040.20/200.32/61.22/41.06/10613659
A050.13/130.12/20.52/20.64/648135
A070.78/780.89/180.28/11.33/133229100
ɽA080.33/330.42/80.56/21.06/10614865
ӶA090.49/490.36/70.59/20.88/8814663
̼A130.41/410.37/70.19/11.06/10615567
A140.54/540.41/80.32/10.41/4110445
A160.46/460.42/80.16/10.49/4910345
ֵ0.78/780.89/181.22/41.33/133229100
Сֵ0.01/10.05/10.16/10.01/141
3.1.3ܴ޼׵Ⱥṹı(B)ְܴ޼׵ȺṹͳƵ11ݸShannon-Wienerʽ(ʽ3)վλĵ޼׵ָοʼת4ʾ.
4ְܴ޼׵ָοֵ㼰ת
Table 4 RTR calculation and transformation for species and abundences of benthic macroinvertebrate
վƵ޼׵ָHοRTR淶ٷֱУٷֱ
A012.641.001001
A040*01100
A051.500.575744
ɽA082.520.96965
̼A132.220.848417
A162.320.888813
ֵ2.641.00100100
Сֵ0011
*ֳδ⵽壬
3.2һٷֱȼȾԳ̶
ԺΪ㣬ۺԪ԰ٷֱȿɵõؽȾ(5).
5ְԪοʵĹ淶ٷֱȼӦ̶
Table 5 Percentage scale of RTR values for each components in surface sediments from the Lean River
ƻѧ(C)Լ(T)ܴ޼׵Ⱥṹı(B)ԪӦC/T/B
A01111-/-/-
A0410059100+/+/+
A05633544+/+/+
ɽA0833655+/+/-
̼A13296717+/+/+
A16114513-/+/-
A0748100us/ud+/+/?
ӶA091563us/ud+/+/?
A141245us/ud-/+/?
us/ud򵱵δܲδܲⶨ.?ȱȺṹ(B)Ӧݣ޷ȷ.
3.3Triadʾͼ
ݱ5ݣͼ2ΪְؽȾһӦʾͼ.



ͼ2ְؽȾһӦʾͼ
Fig.2 Triad graphs for heavy metal pollution in surface sediments from the Lean River
4
Ԫͼ(ͼ2)ڳؽȾڵռֲϵĲ죬ϳ״ж-߾(15)ְȾķֶоķְ״ֽ̬׶ӦǱȾԴĳ.޽ܵͭŷŷϿˮľ޴Ӱ죬иŨͭµܶﶾԵҪԴΪˣµˮдĸԱϸƴֱ֧ŷţͬʱԵг.ȱٵȺṹݣεĴضԿɻۺȾǿ.ͭǦпձϸߣЭͬԴﵽֵ.ʵؿ죬ȥͭȾɢְһ֧ˮذǦпұˮҲҪãӦǿԹССҵʵбҪĹͣתȴʩ.ӻɽӶһȾǨļˮԾʶȻָĻѧȾǿȿʼͣܶϵ.ĿǰвɽؽֳڶΪԭ(C+/T+/B-)˲ȷϵȺͳԱԴƣذԽͻΪӦ㹻.ˮĵ(֧롢ٱ仺)ʹڲ̼崦ؽĻѧԪӦǿﶾԺ͵ܶȺṹڶ.ˣбҪչȾʵ迣Ϳؾ򹤳.ڽӽ۶Ļڵȵأؽһ𽥽ͣ޼׵ָ(H)ֻʵⶾ(T)ԱȽϸߣܴǱڵȾԴΪֹȾһչڲֽ׶Ӧǿͱ.
ִָŶԣˮƽӦSQCȱֱۡȷֵ(Threshold)ֵ(Range)RTRָȱٱ׼ͳŶȣ12ݣֵSQCպʵ.ˣֽ׶ӦǿֵSQCлĽϣTriad߶ֵSQCļ.SQCƶSQSУӦЭᡢáΡȶ෽໥ϵԱŻͻ⣬ѡ˵۷ʽĺ.ӳԶȫ͹۵зЧı֤ϵֽ׶Ա˵ķͼպ㣬Ҳһϵͳ.
лĸлвCERPƻС⹤ԱĶЭ֧.
ߵλ¡(йѧԺ̬оĻˮѧصʵң100085)
ο
[1]滪.ˮ׼о.ѧ199312(5)334341
[2]Chapman P M.Current approaches to developing sediment quality criteria.Environ Tox Chem,1989,8:589599
[3]USEPA.An SAB Report:Review of the Agency's approach for developing sediment criteria for five metals.EPA\|SAB-EPEC-95-020,Washington D C.1995
[4]Canfield T J,Kemble N E,Brumbaugh W G.Use of benthic invertebrate community structure and the sediment quality triad to evaluate metal-contaminated sediment in the upper Clark Fork River,Montana.Environ Tox Chem,1994,13(12):19992012
[5] Chapman P M,Pine M D,Arthur A D.A triad study of sediment quality associated with a major,relatively untreated marine sewage discharge.Marine Pollution Bulletin,1996,32(1):4764
[6] 滪Allen H E.ְɻӷﺬܽؽͷԵӰĳо.ѧ199718(4)3234
[7]Mao M Z.Speciation of metals in sediments along the Lean River.Final Report of the CERP,UNESCO,Paris,1996.5557
[8] Ľܣܣŵ.һ֡ຣ.ӣ199425(3)273276
[9] Wang Z J, Ma M.Toxic assessment by Photobacterium phosphoreum.China Environ Sci,1994,5(2):159164
[10] Washington H G.Review:diversity,biotic and similarity indices.Water Res,1984,18(6):653694
[11] Zhu J, Ren S Z.Preliminary study on the benthic macroinvertegrate community relating to the metal pollution in Lean River.China Envrion Sci,1994,5(2):177181
[12] Alden III R W.Uncertainty and sediment quality assessments:() Confidence limits for the triad.Environ Tox Chem,1992,11:637644
1997-04-07յԭ塡1998-01-21յ޸ĸ
