ѧѧ
ACTA SCIENTIAE CIRCUMASTANTIAE
1999 19 3 Vol.19  No.3 1999



ؽȾƻ׼о
.ƽ䷽(EqP)*
¡
ժҪؽȾصĽְΪѧƽ䷨(EqP) ػݿ⣬о̽˸ؽȾֵƻ׼(SQC).ͭɿĳЩγͭʵȾ̶ԶӦSQCˮƽ.⣬ ؽССҵˮŷţͬɸǦпؽ̶ͬȵسԵĻ׼ֵ.SQCĽΪƶ׼(SQS)Ⱦʩṩѧ.
ؼʡ׼ƽ䷨ؽְ.
Sediment quality criteria for heavy metal pollution in the Lean River . Equil ibrium partitioning approach
LIU Wenxin,LUAN Zhaokun,TANG Hongxiao 
SKLEAC,Research Center for Eco-Environmental Sciences,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100085
AbstractBased on equilibrium partitioning approach (EqP) and CERP-DBMS database, the preliminary surface sediment quality criteria (SQC) for heavy metals in the Lean River were developed. The numerical SQC indicated that mining activities of Dexing Copper Mine caused the level of copper contamination much higher than the corresponding SQC value within the specific sections along the Lean River. In addition, release of wastewater from some factories anong the bank also led to increases in concentrations of lead, zinc and chrome, superior to their SQC to different extent. Therefore, it is urgent to link the SQC with the feedback from local economic conditions and social benefits, so that the sediment quality standards (SQS) can be established, and remediation program can be performed. 
Keywordssediments quality criteria,equilibrium partitioning,Le an River,heavy metal pollution.
1ǰ
׼(SQC)ˮ̬Ҫ׼֮һȿֲˮʻ׼(WQC) Ĳ㣬۳Ⱦ̬ЧӦĻ.ѧ̬ƽ䷨(EqP)ǽֵSQCĴԷ֮һ໯ѧȾ(chemi cal-by-chemical)12.Ҽ׼ĸӿɲʵýǶȿصȻǽض(ض)ƻ׼3.Ƚ϶ԣֵSQCֱۡȷǿԴ滮Ա.
ҹSQCдڳ̽׶Σؽ뿪չʵо.ְڽڵĴ͵ͭ󣬿ɷϿˮְɳؽȾ̬ϵͳƻ.ְػݿ֧£õǰеƽ䷨(EqP)ʵݵļ㹫ʽо̽˽ְƻ׼ָʾúؽȾ̶ȼֲ֣Ϊƶϵʵʳ׼춨ͬʱΪ߹Ⱦۺ͹ˮƽṩѧ.
2뷽
2.1λ
ĲCERPƻõվλְվλֲף4.
2.2ƽϵKP
EqPĹؼ㻯ѧȾƽϵKP.KPһϵصĸӺֵ漰ָ(Fingerprints)ͳ/ˮĸֻأ4ݣ㷽ʽ(1) ֱֳӼ5ݣ(2) ͨģʽģʵϵļ㣬ͳģͣ2ݺͽеıģʽ(SCM).SCMҪк㶨ģʽ(CCM)ɢģʽ(DLM)ģʽ(TLM)̰ͼƷӦFITEQLMINTEQ6.ģʽͨΪӣѡɽȶȷԣ7ݣģʵʵεķӳһ.ˣѡݿCERP-DBMSԭʼֱӼ㣬ʽ£
(1)
SQC=KP.WQC+[Me]AVS+[Me] RSQC* =K*P . WQC+[Me] AVS +[Me]R(2)
ʽCSCIWCWֱ(5-10.cm)϶ˮϸˮؽܽŨ(<0.45mŨȲⶨAASICP)K*PΪ϶ˮƷȱʱĲοWQCΪˮʻ׼[Me]AVSɻӷ(AVS)ϵĽ[Me]Rв̬.
1USEPAˮӲƶĲؽ ﶾԵˮˮʻ׼8
Table 1 Protective WQC of some heavy metals regulated 
by USEPA for aguatic life in freshwater

ؽ׼Ũȣmg/L
Cuexp(0.8545(ln(ˮCaCO3Ӳ)-1.465)/1000
Pbexp(1.2730(ln(ˮCaCO3Ӳ)-4.705)/1000
Zn0.047(24.h)
Cdexp(0.7852(ln(ˮCaCO3Ӳ)-3.490)/1000
As0.19
Cr0.011

עڵˮˮµͳԶԣpH=6.5-9.02.3ˮʻ׼WQCȷ
ҹĿǰûйغؽﶾˮʻ׼˱Ҫһ (USEPA)ˮؽԶˮƽ(FCV)ˮӲƶĵˮˮʻ׼8(μ1)Ϊȷְˮʻ׼(WQC)Ļͬʱйرˮ׼涨ˮʱ׼(GB3838-88)еؽΪο9 .
3
3.1ɻӷؽֲ̬SQCӰ
оﺬͽֲ̬ԽɸԾҪӰ1011ݣˣּڱˮSQCҪ.ͨɻӷ(AVS)ͬȡ(SEM)ıֵϵжϽЧӦУSQC12.нֲ̬ɸԴϵԭеĽ(̬)һ㲻ƽ.ݻѧȶԺ͸Ľȡѭ򻯷ԭְؽֲ̬ɻΪ̬(ˮ̬ӽ̬)е̬(̼ν̬Fe/Mn̬л/̬)Ͷ̬(̬)13.
ְ͵AVSձܵͣ(SEM/AVS)ͨ1Խϸߣ12ݣAVSУÿɺ.ְؽֲ̬̬е̬ΪĽһ£13.ְؽ̬(̬)ռıܵͣʱڽְ׼ʱҲԲ̬Ӱ죬¼򻯼㹫ʽ
SQC=KP*WQCSQC*=K*P*WQC(3)
2ְAVSSEM(SEM/AVS)pH13
Table 2 AVS,SEM,(SEM/AVS) and pH of surface sediments along the Lean R iver13
AVS,mol/gSEMmol/gSEM/AVSpH
A040.013.82382.3ud
A050.047.66191.45.66
A070.987.878.036.78
ӶA080.133.8629.6ud
̼A130.255.1320.56.64
A141.461.641.1ud

ud--δܲⶨ
3.2ְؽȾĳƻ׼(SQC)
USEPAˮʻ׼(1)ʵˮʲְϸˮˮʻ׼(WQC)3ʾɹʽ(2)ְؽȾƻ׼4.
3ְϸˮˮʻ׼WQC(USEPAӲȲԱ׼FCV)
Table 3 Water quality criteria for heavy metals in surface water of the Le an River(USEPA's FCV)
ˮӲ(CaCO3),mg/LCu,mg/LPb,mg/LZn,mg/LCd,mg/LAs,mg/LCr,mg/L
A01102.30.0120.0030.0470.0010.1900.011
A04317.30.0320.0140.0470.0030.1900.011
A05189.30.0200.0070.0470.0020.1900.011
A07143.30.0160.0050.0470.0020.1900.011
ɽA08179.10.0190.0070.0470.0020.1900.011
ӶA09163.70.0180.0060.0470.0020.1900.011
̼A13133.00.0150.0050.0470.0010.1900.011
A1497.20.0120.0030.0470.0010.1900.011
A1680.20.0100.0020.0470.0010.1900.011

4EqPְؽȾƻ׼SQC(USEPA's FCV)
Table 4 Initial EqP-based SQC for heavy metals in surface sediments deriv ed from USEPA-WQC

SQCA(CS/C\{IW\})Cu,mg/kgPb,mg/kgZn,mg/kgCd,mg/kgAs,mg/kg Cr,mg/kg
A011925873910ud26
A04usususususus
A05887452513ud61
A07806258262730ud75
ɽA08983282322240ud72
ӶA0953017052815ud46
̼A1371815599220ud47
A143826552610ud41
A163331667565ud49
SQC*A(CS/C\{W\})Cu,mg/kgPb,mg/kgZn,mg/kgCd,mg/kgAs,mg /kgCr,mg/kg
A012619542640732
A04255741592128101
A0555551318343750
A0719391263288751
ɽA089346172541235122
ӶA095301702646133073
̼A131050233893492357
A144202585263551131
A163331664201110257

us/ud--򵱵δܲɼƷ/δܼԲⶨ
3.3
ͼ1ְвؽʵ벿ӦֵSQC׼ĶԱ.ͼSQCASQC*AֱʾUSEPA's FCVĳƻ׼(4)SQCBSQCBǻڹҵرˮˮʱ׼ϵĳƻ׼().ͼɼְضض£Ӧƽ䷨ؽֵSQCʵ仯ҲΪһ.


ͼ1ְвؽʵ⺬벿ӦSQCˮƽıȽʾͼ
Fig.1 Comparison between determinations and SQC for metals in surface sed iments from the Lean River
ȻҪָڸ÷ԱĻе(϶ʻɶ)ԵȡָԼˮ(pHӲȵ)൱Уˮѧˮּ(⣬)ʱձ仯Ӱ죬ѰٵпɱԺⶨKPֵ.⣬ȥصӰ죬Ľϴ˵EqPͬؽһĽ͹淶2.ˣͨƽ䷨ӦˮƱ׼תضƱ׼ǵǰ߷չǰ;ĳ۹֮һ14.
ͼɼUSEPA-WQCSQCGB3838-88()WQCSQCˮƽϱ˴˽ӽ˵ߴĳ̶ֳȵһ.ԶԣƫҪԴڿ϶ˮĲɼͷ̣ڳ϶ˮĲǰȼͳһ(QA)ʿ(QC)׼15ݣְ֮ɽͺ½󣬺ӴҪʯ֡ϸɰɣֳĳЩضεˮĵΪӣʹʵʲѶȺܴ󣬲׳ϵͳΪ޷ɼƷ().
ְؽؽȾͻķֶηֲ(ԹA04̼A13)ıؽȾ൱أͭǦпʵŨȾ̶ͬȵسԳSQCˮƽֱӸԴȻԵ˴ͭؽССҵɿӰ.εض纣ڣһڻ׼ڣֽ׶ӦǱȾԴ總̿пˮŷ.⣬ڵصı׺ϸ(㺣ھʹ3 mg/kg)һ.ܸȱٿ϶ˮݣ޽εĳȻڵ͵ͭȾصʵŨԶԶ׼˥أ16ݣȡʩϸƾŷŵĵͭϿˮˮЧʺ͸ɣͬʱβۺ(ʵʩˡԼõ).δ帽ĶۺȾͭǦпĺڻ׼ˮƽȾҪھ迣ͬʱˮذұˮŷţҪʱʵйͣתȴʩ.ڻɽӶһؽȾӰ˥ˮԾָȾǿȿʼͣس̵ԽͻΪԳиǦпӰԲݺ.β̼ضںӴȽϵ͵ĻˮټʹͭǦпȽڵԻصεȾҪ.ڽ۶ĻڵȵسһָⶾԱȽϸߣ17ݣӦǿǱ(δⶨ)ȾԴļ⣬ֹڲ.Ľְ׼ڳ׼ҪĲиӵĿ϶ˮⶨ⣬뿼Ǽ(ˮڡˮ)ͳȾŨȵĴֱֲSQCӰ죬ñģʽ(SCM)бҪĸУ.
һЩߺִʵùв̶ͬȵڽֵ׼Ϊĳ̶ֹ淶ʹˮ׼ֵSQCʵֻǷӡźš(Flag)ָʾãڼﲻͬȾ״̶ȣ18.⣬ֵSQC׼ĿרһԺǿ(Chemical-by-chemical)ûгֿǶȾ֮临ӵ໥ãֱEqPֵ׼ϵػƺΧ̶ǲʵ.ͬʱSQCӦݻϢۺϷڼԵȾŨȵڵǰ׼ˮƽûзգԭضضȾĻ׼޵ģǱڵ޻׼ĻѧҲܿв.ˣΪɿļ;Ӧֵͻ׼򹤾ߣƽ䷨(EqP)㲻ͬȾԻ׼ˮƽȻˮֳ(in situ)ȾķϢ(ɸԡ̬Ⱥṹ)һ(Triad)ֵͻ׼жָ飬ҪĸĽΪƶǿִĳƱ׼(SQS)춨.Ŀǰֵ׼ôۺݿ⽨ּӦֵ(RangeBand)洫ͳֵʽ(Threshold)Ӧӵ-Ӧϵ.
л--ĸлвCERPƻ⹤ԱĴֺ֧Ͱ.
* ȻѧصĿ(ţ29137010)
ߵλйѧԺ̬оĻˮѧصʵң 100085

ο
1ݡAdams W J,Kimerle R ABarnett J W.Sediment quality and aq uatic life assessment.Environ Sci and Technol,1992,26(10):1865-1875
2ݡ¾Խ.ˮ׼.ѧ199211(3)60 -70
3ݡUSEPA.An SAB report:review of the Agency's approach for developing se diment criteria for five metals.EPA-SAB-EPEC-95-020.Washington DC,1995
4ݡ£.ؽȾ׼о.C-B-T һ(Triad).ѧѧ199919(2)120-126
5ݡWebster J Ridgway I.The application for the equilibrium partitio ning approach for establishing sediment quality criteria at the two UK sea dispo sal and outfall sites.Marine Pollution Bulletin,1994,28(11):653-661
6ݡ滪š࣬.ְؽģʽо.ѧ ѧ199616(1)13-22
7ݡCoates J A,Delfino J J.Sources of uncertainty in the application of t he equilibrium partitioning approach to sediment quality assessment.Water Sci Te chnol,1993,28(8-9):317-328
8 USEPA.Research and Development,A Geochemical Assessment of Potential Po rewat er to EPA-Regulated Metal and Ionizable Organic Contaminants for Use in Develop ing Equilibrium-Partitioning Sediment Quality Criteria.1990.18-20
9ݡһֱί.ˮͷˮ().йѧ .1989.576-577
10 Allen H E.The significance of trace metal speciation for water sediment and soil quality criteria and standard.The Sci of Total Environ,1993,Supplement:23 -44
11 滪Allen H E.ְɻӷﺬܽؽͷԵ Ӱĳо.ѧ199718(4)32-34
12 Allen H E,Fu G M,Deng B L.Analysis of acid-volatile sulfide(AVS) and simult aneously extracted metals(SEM) for the estimation of potential toxicity in aquat ic sediments.Environ Tox Chem,1993,12:1441-1453
13ݡMao M Z.Speciation of metals in sediments along the Lean River.Final Report of the CERP,UNESCO,Paris,1996.55-57
14 Ankley G T,Berry W J,Di Toro,Use of equilibrium partitioning to establish se diment quality criteria for nonionic chemicals:a reply to Iannuzzi et al.Env iron Tox Chem,1996,15(7):1019-1024
15 Bufflap S E,Allen H E.Sediment pore water collection methods for trace m etal analysis:a review.Water Res,1996,29(1):165-177
16 Zhu J,Ren S Z.Preliminary study on the benthic macroinvertebrate community r elating to the metal pollution in the Lean River.China Environ Sci,1994,5(2):1 77-181
17 Wang Z J,Ma M.Toxic assessment of water and sediment in the Lean River.Fina l Report of the CERP,UNESCO,Paris,1996.59-62
18 Landrum P F.How should numerical sediment quality criteria be used.Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,1995,1(1):13-17
1997-04-07յԭ塡1998-01-21յ޸ĸ
