йѧ
CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE
1998 18 4 No.4 Vol.18 1998
Ƽڿ

ӡпӶ԰϶ʵ
١㡡١θӢӭйԤҽѧѧԺо 100050
ġժ϶ʵˮȾмΪҪΪо顢ӡпȾ϶ԣ԰Ϊʵָ϶ʵ顣,As3+Cd2+ԼAs3+Zn2+ʱ϶ԾΪ׿ãCd2+Zn2+϶ҪΪԾЭͬáAs3+Cd2+Zn2+ 3ֶʱ䶾Ϊ׿á
ؼʡ顡϶ԡӡп
Joint toxicity test of arsenic with cadmium and zinc ions to zebrafish,brachynanio rerio. Xiu RuiqinXu Yongxiang,Gao Shirong,Ren Gaiying,Fu Yingchun(Institute of Environmental Health and Engineering,Chinese Academy of Preventive MedicineBeijing 100050).China Environmental Science.1998,18(4):349352
AbstractThe joint toxicity is very important in environmental evaluation of water pollution. The joint toxicity of arsenic with cadmium and zinc to zebrafish, Brachydanio rerio was determined. Additive index method was used to evaluate the joint toxic effects.Results showed that the joint toxicities of As3+ with Cd2+ and As3+ with Zn2+ were antagonistic action;while the joint toxicity of Cd2+ with Zn2+ was synergistic. The joint toxicity was antagonistic action of As3+ with Cd2+ and Zn2+ .
Key words:arsenicjoint toxicitycadmiumzinczebrafish
ĿǰǶԴԻѧĵһ˽϶˽⣬ǣ໷ʵʴڵĶȾ϶üʶĻࡲ1ֻֻѧͬʱʱ뵥һȫͬĶԷӦǽʮǷǳע⡣Ȼ϶ʵоĸԣоչΪ˲ʵоֶ϶ԣǶ3϶临ӵЧӦڻδ2԰Ϊʵ鶯ӡпӹʱ϶ЧӦϵͳо
1Ϻͷ
1.1ҩƷ
As2O3 ΪCdSO*8HOпΪZnSO*7HOΪŨȷֱƳ1000mg/LĸҺ10ıϡΪϵʵŨȡ
1.2ʵ
ùʱ׼ʵ㣨Brachydanio rerioʵѱ10dϣƽ峤2.46cmƽ0.22g
1.3ʵ鷽
ʱ׼֯ISO׼ʵ鷨Ķʵ顲3۷Markingָ4顢ӡпһԻϣAsCdAsZnԼCdZnµ϶ԣ󰴶11Ũ11ĲͬŨ£ֱⶨ3ﹲµ϶ԡйʽֱSֵ

ʽУABCΪһԵLC50ֵAmBmCmΪ϶ԵLC50ֵSΪﶾ֮͡
Sָ(AI)S < 1ʱAI=(1)/(S)-1S > 1ʱAI=S(-1)+1.0AIж϶ԣAI=0ʱΪãAI < 0ʱΪ׿ãAI > 0ʱΪЭͬá
2
2.1As3Cd2 ԰϶
ڵһﶾʵϣ԰Ϊʵ㣬ͬʵ¶趾11Ũ11е϶ʵ1
ɱ1ɿAs /Cd Ϊ11£ӹ棬İŨLC50ֵ244896h£ֱΪ26.725.624.1mg/LõAIֱֵΪ-6.91(24h),-7.48(48h)-10.8(96h)AIֵС㣬϶ԾΪ׿áAs/CdΪŨ11£AIֵ24hΪ-4.2948hΪ-3.8696hΪ-5.32AIֵҲС㣬ҲΪ׿áɴ˿ɼӹ滥ཱུ˶ԡ
1As3+Cd2+ ԰϶
Table 1Joint toxicity of As3with Cd2 to zebrafish

 ʱ䣨h LC50ֵmg/LSAI 
As3+ Cd2+
As/Cd1:124 26.7(2627.4) 53.8(5254.6) 7.91 -6.91 ׿
48 25.6(24.226) 50.5(4952) 8.48 -7.48 ׿
9624.1(22.226) 51.0(4557) 11.8-10.8 ׿
As/CdŨ1:1 24 33.2(33.233.2) 33.2(33.233.2) 5.29 -4.29׿
4826.8(26.826.8)26.8(26.826.8) 4.86-3.86 ׿
9625.0(25.025.0) 25.0(25.025.0)6.32-5.32׿

2.2As3+Zn2+԰϶
2As3 Zn2 ԰϶
Table 2Joint toxicity of As3 with Zn2 to zebrafish

 ʱ䣨h LC50ֵmg/LSAI 
As3 Zn2
As/Zn1:1 24 27(2628) 32(3134) 1.83-0.833׿
48 26(2628) 31(3131) 1.94-0.936 ׿
9625.6(24.226) 30(2931) 2.72-1.717 ׿
As/ZnŨ1:1 24 29.2(2236.4) 29.2(2236.4) 1.40-0.400 ׿
4823.4(2224.8) 23.4(2224.8) 1.31 -0.207 ׿
96 22.6(2223.2) 22.6(2223.2) 1.71 -0.707׿

ͬʵ£пӵ϶ʵ2As3Zn2ڶ11£As LC50ֱֵΪ27(24h)26(48h)25.6(96h)mg/LпӵLC50ֵ24h48h96hֱΪ323130mg/LõAIֵ24hΪ-0.83348hΪ-0.93696hΪ-1.717С㣬Ϊ׿áAs Zn Ũ11£AsZn LC50ֵ24hΪ29.2mg/L48hΪ23.4mg/L96hΪ22.6mg/L;AIֱֵΪ-0.40(24h)-0.207(48h)-0.707(96h)AIֵҲС㣬Ϊ׿á
2.3Cd3Zn2 ϶
ɱ3CdZnڶ1:1£24h LC50ֵCdΪ3.30mg/LZnΪ19mg/L;48h96h CdLC50ֵΪ3.11mg/LZnΪ18.5mg/LõAIֵ24hΪ0.21948hΪ0.076AIֵ㣬϶ΪЭͬã96hʱAIֵΪ-0.271Ϊ׿áCdZnŨ11ʱLC50ֱֵΪ2.30mg/L(24h)2.15mg/L(48h)2.05mg/L(96h)AIֵ24h48h96hֱΪ1.861.611.09㣬ΪЭͬáɴ˿ɼCdZnʱ˶11ʱ96hΪ׿ΪԾЭͬãӵĴпĶԣһspehar5Flagfishоп϶ʵһԣпʱĶԲпһԵӣԶԶпһԵĺ͡
2.4As3 Cd2 Zn2 ʱ϶
3ֶﵥһʵ鼰϶ʵϰ11£ֱAsCd Zn ʱ϶Խʵ飬4
3Cd2 Zn2 ԰϶
Table 3Joint toxicity of Cd2 with Zn2 to zebrafish

 ʱ䣨h LC50ֵmg/LSAI 
Cd2 Zn2
Cd/Zn11 24 3.30(3.303.4) 19.0(1820) 0.822 0.219 Эͬ
48 3.11(3.023.2) 18.5(1019)0.929 0.076 Эͬ
96 3.11(3.023.2) 18.5(1019) 1.271-0.27׿
Cd/ZnŨ11 24 2.30(1.82.7) 2.30(1.82.7) 0.350 1.86 Эͬ
48 2.15(1.82.3) 2.15(1.82.3) 0.383 1.61 Эͬ
962.05(1.82.3) 2.05(1.82.3) 0.478 1.09 ׿

4As3 Cd2 Zn2 ԰϶ 
Table 4Joint toxicity of As3 with Cd2 and Zn2 to zebrafish

 ʱ䣨h LC50ֵmg/LSAI
As3Zn2 Cd2
һ 24 36.3(34.638) 49(4850) 7.6(7.47.8)
4836.3(34.638) 41(3646) 6.5(6.07.0)
9623.7(2324.3) 30(2337) 4.8(3.95.6)
As/Zn/CdŨ111 24 19.1(1820.2) 19.1(1820) 19.1(1820) 2.23 -2.54
48 17.2(16.418) 17.2(16.418) 17.2(16.418) 3.54 -2.43
96 15.4(14.616.2) 15.4(14.616.2)15.4(14.616.2) 4.40 -3.40
As/Zn/Cd111 24 22.2(2024.4) 4.41(4.04.82) 26.5(2429) 1.73-0.73
48 20.0(17.522.5)3.96(3.524.4) 24.0(21.226.8) 1.68 -0.68
96 18.8(17.520) 3.76(3.524.0) 22.6(21.224) 2.34 -1.34

ɱ4п3ֶΪŨ111ʱõSֱֵΪ2.23(24h)3.54(48h)4.40(96h)ȡõAIֵ24h,48h96hֱΪ-2.54-2.43-3.40С㣬϶ԽΪ׿áAs/Cd/Zn111£ȡõLC50ֵ24hʱAsΪ22.2mg/LZnΪ4.41mg/LCdΪ26.5mg/LAIֵΪ-0.73Ϊ׿ã48hʱLC50ֱֵΪ20.0mg/L(As)3.96mg/L(Zn)24.0mg/L(Cd)SֵΪ1.68AIֵΪ-0.68AIֵС㣬Ϊ׿ã96hʱAsZnCdLC50ֱֵΪ18.83.7622.6mg/LAIֵΪ-1.34ҲΪ׿áɴ˿ɼAsZnCdͬʱʱ䶾½׿ãΪãͨʵ3϶ﹲʱֲͬ϶ԽǲͬģAsCdAsZnʱ϶Ϊ׿ãZnCdʱΪЭͬãAsZnCdͬʱʱΪ½׿ã5ɴ˿ɼֶﹲͬȾˮʱ϶ԻǺܸӵġǣͨ϶ʵǿԸġEaton6úڿоCuCdZn϶ԣҲʾֶﹲʱӵ϶ԣΪܼ򵥵ɸһﶾж϶ۺ϶ԡ
5As3+/Cd2+/Zn2+԰϶ԱȽ 
Table 5Comparison of joint toxicity of As3+,Cd2+
and Zn2+ to zebrafish (mixtmes)

 AI(ָ)
24h 48h 96h
As/Cd
11 -6.91-7.48 -10.8 ׿
Ũ11 -4.29 -3.86 -5.32 ׿
As/Zn
11-0.833 -0.936 -1.72 ׿
Ũ11 -0.400-0.207 -0.707 ׿
Cd/Zn
11 0.219 0.076 -0.27 Эͬ׿
Ũ11 1.86 1.61 1.09 Эͬ
As/Cd/Zn
11-0.733 -0.681-3.40 ׿
Ũ11-2.54 -2.43-1.34 ׿

3
3.1Լпӹ棬԰϶ʵΪ׿ãпӹʱ԰㷢˶ԾЭͬã顢ӡп3ֶﹲʱ϶Ϊֵ׿á
3.23϶ﹲʱ˸ӵ϶ԡʵоֶﹲ϶Եʵ
3.3ֶﹲͬȾˮ󣬷˸ӵ϶ЧӦֻõһĺȥжˮȾĶΣǲʵʵģһֵע⣬ȻˮȾڲⶨ˵һﺬͬʱӦ϶ԵĽǶȲﶾ鼼ˮȾۺۣԼˮȾ۵ҪֶΣп٣ܷӦֶ︴ȾʵˮҪĿѧ塣
ο
1ͯӢѧ϶ãϺϺѧ׳磬1994.1
2٣٣ȣ϶Եойѧ199515(5):348350
3ISO 736/1-1984 Water Aguatic-Determination of The Acute Lethal ToxicityofSubstandes to a Freshwater FishBrachydanio rerio Hamiltion-Buchanan(Teleostei,Cyprinidae)-Partic method.1984
4٣㣬ӭȣˮЧӦָѧ199413(3):269271
5Spehar R LFiandt T.Chronic effects of cadmiun and zinc mixtures on flagfish (Jordanella floridae).Trans. Am. Fish. Soc., 1987, 107(2): 354358
6Eaton J G.Chronic toxicity of a copper,cadmium and zinc mixture to the fthead minnow(Pimcphales promelas rafinesque).Water Research Pergamon, 1973,17:17231736
߼
١Ů193812йԤҽѧѧԺ̬ʵΣоԱѧλоʦҪ»ѧ̬ѧоγеȻѧȿĿйȻѧĿˮԼо񲿼ɹΪҹƶˡˮԱ׼GB/T 16125-199578ƪ
ոڣ1997-10-09
