йѧ
CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE
1999 195ڡVol.19 No.5 1999



ƵųΣоչ
Сš¿ڡ³
ժҪвѧʵоʾ˹Ƶų(PFEMF)¶Ѫ̥쳣ȷ,ͬʱҲ൱ʵδ۲쵽PFEMFЧӦ.Ϸ΢ųûƵ,ݷԷֲ۷,϶PFEMFǱΣ,һָΣһ.ع˽PFEMFΣƺģ,ΪоӦϸַ.
ؼʣųЧӦƵ֢
ͼţX123 ױʶ룺A ±ţ1000- 6923(1999)05- 0472- 05
A review on the study on power frequency electromagnetic field hazards to organisms.
GAO Xiao-rong1, CHEN Kui-fu2, LUO Zhi-cheng2 
(1.Department of Electronic,Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084,China2.School Basic Medical Sciences, Peking Union Medical College, Beijing 100005,China). China Environmental Science. 1999,19(5)472476
AbstractOn the power frequency electromagnetic field (PFEMF) bioeffects on organisms, there have been much epidemiological survey and laboratory study which confirm the relation of leukemia, tumor and embryo abnormality with PFEMF exposure;but at same time, there are also a few reports on the opposite side. After the controversy of weak electromagnetic field bioeffect mechanism was analyzed in ideology based on the nonlinear divergence theory, and the models and mechanisms of hazards proposed in recent year were reviewed, the potential hazards of PFEMF to organisms were affirmed; moreever, the hazards were random events and should be studied with various nonlinear theories. 
Key wordelectromagnetic fieldbioeffectpower frequencytumornonlinearity
ҵĹƵ50Hz,ֹҵĹƵΪ60Hz.1979Wertheimer˱ڵ߸סĶ֢ͯʳһͯ12֮,Ƶų(Power Frequency Electromagnetic Field PFEMF)ΣͳΪѧһȵ[1].ΪִܲҵִѧִҽƵĻ,ҲճֵҪ.رǹƵŲܳ(50HzĲΪ6000km),ûз,Դ͸κηǽ,޷ĳռ,Ҳ޷Ⱥθ.ĽعΣڵйоʵ,ݷԷֲָǱΣ¼.
1 
PFEMFΣо漰ĴųǿȺ,һڼm Tʮm T(شųĳǿԼ50m T),ϸԴųͼ.ȻųǿȺ,вѧо˷Ѫذй[2],ı¶ʵҲʾųȷʵлӰ.ͬʱ,ҲвоС෴Ĺ۵.ǱΣƵĲظԼ,һֱ۽[3]. 
Σ۵Ƚϵ͵Valberg-PA.[4]ΪPFEMF¶ͷǷ,һ̶ڻϸӵѹܷ⵽ⲿPFEMFշĵ硢ѧͻеźš.ΪųЧӦ¼:(1)Ӻʹ絰PFEMF¼ٻ,ӶıϸĤ嵰,ʵ,õԶϸӵĵ;(2)ڸӦ糡Եɺ͵ʩ, ȵ͵Сö;(3)΢Ĵžغɻų໥,δֶԴžϸ,ųıɻʵ˵Ҳкܴ;(4)ųгշ-Ӹ񶯴ݻת,Щɽܵѧì,ʵûеõԤڵЧ;(5)ʱƽռܸĽκ,ֻҪṹϵͳеųʱƽ,ھδ.֮,ΪPFEMF(<2m T)Ӱ.
޺۵,ôҪ֤ʵValberg-PA5ֻ΢PFEMF¶¾޷.
ڵ(5),ռϸļжԼ΢PFEMF,ڹ֯СӦļҲἰ[5]. Litovitz-TA[6]ΪPFEMFԴҪں߿ռʱֲ,ǰڿռʱ,ͬһϸĤϵĴЭͬ,ӶϸܲԵӰ.,ΪʱƻռЭͬЧӦ.ʵԭԼ̥쳣ļƵų(ELFEMF),ǿ൱(Լֻǿȵ1/1000)ŵųͬ,쳣ЧӦʧ.[7]ϸø(Ornithine decarboxylase:ODC)ӰʵҲ֤ʵһ.Lin-H[8]ʵҲһ.ǿռӦòЧӦ,αʱƵĶģֵ.
ڵ(3),ɻҲȡһչ.ǿȺܵ͵ľųʹ߶Իѧѳɵ߶Իѧ,һ䳡ʹɻߺ͵߻ѧı.,ųͨɻܶԻѧӦ޴Ӱ.һValberg-PA5,δƽȽ۵,ֻ㹻,ǿ㹻,ܷ.Զƽ̬ϵͳ.ϵͳ,ṩһʱۻ,ϵͳﵽֲٽ,ϵͳδչȡ,ϵͳѡȶ.ѡ˭,ɵʱСĸȷ,ֻҪĳѡĸԴһ,ѡͱΪȶ.¼һָ,һֱȻ,˲еű¶,ٽʱ,пĳָʷ,вѧ۲һ.
ϸĤ֬ӹ,ԼΪ40?.ڴϸ,˫ĤԼ0.1V, ݶ(100kV/m)ǳ,ʺ͵.ѧ,ݶ10-5~ 10-8V/mƵųյ.һ˵󲢷ƽܽ(ƽ,ʱƲֵӦ𽥼С,Զۻ,ǿ),һҲ˵ųȷʵи.
2 PFEMFЧӦʵ
ܶʵ鱨PFEMFЧӦ. Farrell-JM[9] Ϊ5ļ̥¶ų(60Hz,Լ1m T)о,еĸ屩¶,̥쳣Լ3.
Youbicier-Simo-BJ[10]̥ͳ¶ʾĵų.ͬʱ״򵰰׶׼3,ÿߺ, ѪƤ̴Ѫʺڼصˮƽ.,̥ʱȶ;ڵ2ߺ,Ƥ̴ʺڼ,¶ָ½.
Uscebrka-G[11]۲PFEMF(50Hz) ڱ¶ԴٹܵӰ.ֱ¶,پ,,¶ƤС,;ʡƤʿɼԳѪ,ϸѪܱ.
Zecca-L[12]Ƚڼٱ¶5m T1kV/m100m T5kV/m3ֵų(60Hz)¶״̬ʵ.¶ÿ5,ÿ8h.ֱ¶ϸ߳ǿɹٵȥˮƽ.
Ѿ֪L929ϸ¶60Hz,10m T (rms)ų,ODCǿ.Ϊ֤ϸĤЭͬ,Litovitz-TA[7]ƵΪ3090HzŴųԭų,ŵRMSֵ60Hz൱,ǿٱ¶ͬ;ӵĸǿȼС,ųĻǿЧӦ;ǿСԭų1/10,ԺЧӦӰ.
˹ϸ¶60 HzҴųԭ°c-myc ̬ת¼ˮƽ.Lin-H[8]ʹխ(3090 Hz,6.7 m T rms)60Hzų(6.7m T rms)ʵ.ʾ¶60Hzų,c-myc̬ת¼ˮƽ40%.60HzųӸŵı¶,c-myc̬ת¼ˮƽٱ¶Ĳͳ.Ҳ൱ʵδ۲쵽ЧӦ.
Miyakoshi-J[13]ԼƵϵͳ,0.4T120hPFEMF(50Hz)¶ӰѪߵHL60RGCCRF-CEMϸ.˺ëϸѪŲЭ˵GM0637TAT2SF ϸX߷ų¶2h,ҲıԷ.
[14]оPFEMF(50Hz)ѪǷЧӦ.,¶硢Żߵӵĳ, ܽøġβɡ2,3-ͺ͹׸ĵҪʵŨû.
Owen-RD[15]ΪųյHL60ϸMYCǿЧӦ׼ȷԺͿظ,HL 60ϸ¶6m T 60Hzų.ⷽͱ¶ǰЧӦоӽ.ҵԭʼоṩϸ,δԵֵ֤֧ű¶ܹյMYCʽ.
Cridland-NA[16]άϸѪһҹ¶Ƶ50Hzų.ڵCO2ıС0.2m T.50HzĴų¶30h,ǿ20m T20mT,DNAϳɾ޿ɼӰ.
3 ģ
ֻиݴʵݺвѧݽ¶ӦĶģ,ҵлõĻ,ѧѧ,ܶı¶淶.κͼͬоСųЧӦĽ,е൱.¶ȫ,оĵı¶ϸ,опܾûм¼,ΪԶʵеϸӲͬ.Ƚо,ظʵ,Ĺؼǽų¶ʵı׼[17].
Markov-MS[18]˹ƵӰһ,ռõĿܻƺһЩ֪.
[19]ⲿųл໥,̽漰Ŀܻ,رǵοƿϵͳͺɢṹ.
[20]йرṩ,о50Hzų¶ӦĹϵ,żͳǿϵԵñԹϵ.
Marino-AA[21]ָųʵƵЧӦһµԭԴϵ.0.5 kV /m-60 Hzų,һֱ,һ,һ.Ϊи,صӰԳʼʮ,֮,ʽģӦǷԵ.ͬʱҲѡʵָҪ.
[22]о˴׺,ָӿɴϸĸҪ,缤ͷ;ʵӶԵű¶,ǿƾ;ΪӸıϸˮƽķӦ,۲ЧӦ䲢ȷ.
ųʺڼ½˵ܵע[23].˵,ɹ弤ˮƽ½Ӱּع,Ƽض̬ƽ(ذ).
Shao-T[24]ΪǵųͰ֢ϵͨ,ʺϳɵҪ,ʻɼغcAMPźյ;о֤ʵųյϸεЧӦ,Ũȱ仯ϸĤı䡢ϸcAMP,ı䵰ʺϳ.,ųЧӦ׺ϳ(ҪغcAMP)ϵǺ,еų방֢.
ܾϸĻĿǰв,Hendee-WR[25]Ϊųǰ֢Ĵٷ,ǰ֢.[26]ΪӦռȷǿ(0.1m T)ELFMFǷȷʵдٷ֢Ŀ.
ӺϿ,л쳣()ɹϸƫ״̬.ϵͳչٽ,ϵͳڲַչ΢С,ϵͳֻѡγȶṹ,ΪȶṹʹγҲ߽,,漴ٽ֮ȶĽṹ.ϵͳﵽٽǰ뻷,һʱۻ.
ȻشŻн,лڽбشӦĽṹ͹,ڷؼѡΪĽṹ.һ, ˹ųصظı.ϸĳЩٽ,ܵPFEMFƻĵشŻǷѡĳЩᵼΪǻṹ,Ҫо.
΢ۻܴ,˻ۡɻۡ˴Ź񡢲񡢳ЧӦ뵼ЧӦѹЧӦЧӦȶ.
4 뽨
ܶвѧ鱨泤ڽӴPFEMFȺͰѪʽϷǽӴȺ.PFEMFΣʵ鱨ķ,˱¶ʱ䡢ǿȡʽоСв,ʵһµĹؼѡı¶󡢼ָͱ¶ʱĲͬ.
PFEMF໥õС,Σ,ƲЧӦ.PFEMFĴпܸıϵͳڷչٽѡ,ӶʹϵͳΪ쳣չ.̥͸֯൱ٽ,ʱ׹۲쵽PFEMFЧӦ,ԳϸӰͺѼ.
лһ֯ϵͳ,ܹ쳣ϸ.PFEMFӰǸ,ڷĸ,ϸٽĲȽϵ,ʹٲϸ쳣,пܽ,岻쳣.Ӥ׶и,ϸٽĲȺܴ,PFEMFշϸ쳣ܺܶ,ĸʽϸ.
ܴ,ĿǰΪֹ,κΰȫ޵Ĺʱ׼δȷ.Ŀǰвѧ顢ʵйĹ鿴,ԲPFEMFְΣ,ǴĽǶ,Ӥ׶иԶű¶.
ͼͨǿPFEMFΣģ޷е໥ìܵʵ.Ӧ֯Ӧɢۺͷֲ۵ȷԿѧģ.΢۵Ļƺܲ,ǸӲۻǼ,Ҫдʵ.ͬʱʵҲǽ¶ʵһ;.
¶ϵͳƺ켼ĿǰΪ.ʵӦעʵĹ淶,Աཻܹͽ.
ʵʳǿ󼰳ǿķֲӦо.ЧӦǴųûǵ糡,ͬõĽ,Ӧдʵ.ͬʱʵĳǿΧӦӴ,лӵķϵͳ,ͬбʵ.
߼飺С(1963-),,㽭ͩ,,ʿ,ҪҽѧźŴҽѧоͿ.20ƪ.
ߵλСš廪ѧϵ, 100084
¿ڡ³ϡЭҽƴѧҽѧԺ, 100005
οף
[1]Wertheimer-N,Leeper-E. Electrical wiring configurations and childhood cancer [J]. Am-J-Epidermiol., 1979,109:273- 384.
[2]Knave-B. Electric and magnetic fields and health outcomes-an overview [J]. Scand-J-Work-Environ-Health., 1994,20: 78- 89. 
[3]Markov-MS. Biophysical estimation of the environmental importance of electromagnetic fields [J]. Rev-Environ-Health, 1994,10(2): 75- 83.
[4]Valberg-PA,Kavet-R,Rafferty-C-N. Can low-level 50/60 Hz electric and magnetic fields cause biological effects [J]. Radiation Research. 1997 ,148(1): 2- 21.
[5]Һ.ѧ[M].:ѧ.1998.300- 316.
[6]Litovitz-TA,Montrose-CJ,Doinov-P, et al. Superimposing spatially coherent electromagnetic noise inhibits field-induced abnormalities in developing chick embryos [J]. Bioelectromagnetics, 1994,15(2): 105- 113.
[7]Litovitz-TA, Krause-D, Montrose-C-J. Temporally incoherent magnetic fields mitigate the response of biological systems to temporally coherent magnetic fields [J]. Bioelectrotics, 1994, 15(5):399- 409.
[8]Lin-H,Goodman-R. Electric and magnetic noise blocks the 60 Hz magnetic field enhancement of steady state c-myc transcript levels in human leukemia cells [J]. Bioelectrochemistry and Bioenergetics, 1995, 36(1): 33- 37.
[9]Farrell-JM,Litovitz-TL,Penafiel-M,et al. The effect of pulsed and sinusoidal magnetic fields on the morphology of developing chick embryos [J]. Bioelectromagnetics, 1997,18(6): 431- 438.
[10]Youbicier-Simo-BJ, Boudard-F, Cabaner-C,et al. Biological effects of continuous exposure of embryos and young chickens to electromagnetic fields emitted by video display units [J]. Bioelectromagnetics, 1997,18(7): 514- 523.
[11]Uscebrka-G,Zikic-D,Matavulj-M ,et al. Stereological analysis of the adrenal gland of female rats after exposure to an electromagnetic field [J]. Acta. Veterinaria (Belgrade),1996,46(5-6): 277- 284.
[12]Zecca-L,Mantegazza-C,Margonato-V,et al. Biological effects of prolonged exposure to ELF electromagnetic fields in rats: III. 50 Hz electromagnetic fields [J]. Bioelectromagnetics, 1998,19(1): 57- 66.
[13]Miyakoshi-J,Ohtsu-S,Tatsumi-Miyajima-J,et al. A newly designed experimental system for exposure of mammalian cells to extremely low frequency magnetic fields [J]. J-Radiat-Res-Tokyo, 1994,35(1): 26- 34.
[14]Dacha-M,Accorsi-A,Pierotti-C,et al. Studies on the possible biological effects of 50Hz electric and/or magnetic fields: evaluation of some glycolytic enzymes, glycolytic flux, energy and oxido-reductive potentials in human erythrocytes exposed in vitro to power frequency fields [J]. Bioelectromagnetics, 1993,14(4): 383- 391. 
[15]Owen-RD. MYC mRNA abundance is unchanged in subcultures of HL60 cells exposed to power-line frequency magnetic fields [J]. Radiat-Res., 1998,150(1): 23- 30.
[16]Cridland-NA,Cragg-TA,Haylock-RG. Effects of 50Hz magnetic field exposure on the rate of DNA synthesis by normal human fibroblasts [J]. Int-J-Radiat-Biol., 1996,69(4): 503- 511.
[17]Valberg-PA. Designing EMF experiments: what is required to characterize "exposure"? [J]. Bioelectromagnetics, 1995,16(6): 396- 406.
[18]Markov-MS Biophysical estimation of the environmental importance of electromagnetic fields [J]. Rev-Environ-Health, 1994,10(2): 75- 78.
[19]Fedorowski-A,Steciwko-A. Electrosmog as a health risk factor: sources of artificial electromagnetic fields, evaluation of health risk, prevention methods [J]. Med-Pr, 1997,48(5): 507- 519.
[20]Juutilainen-J,Hatfield-T,Laara-E. Evaluating alternative exposure indices in epidemiologic studies on extremely low-frequency magnetic fields [J]. Bioelectromagnetics, 1996,17(2): 138- 143.
[21]Marino-AA. Different outcomes in biological experiments involving weak EMFs: is chaos a possible explanation? [J]. Am-J-Physiol, 1995,268(4 Pt 2): R1013- 1018. 
[22]Nishimura-I. Review on the biological effects of magnetic field exposures: II. Intracellular calcium [J]. Denryoku Chuo Kenkyusho Hokoku, 1996,0 (U95031): 1- 41.
[23]Baldwin-WS,Barrett-JC. Melatonin: receptor-mediated events that may affect breast and other steroid hormone-dependent cancers [J]. Mol-Carcinog, 1998,21(3): 149- 155.
[24]Shao-T. EMF-cancer link: the ferritin hypothesis [J]. Med-Hypotheses, 1993,41(1): 28- 30.
[25]Hendee-WR,Boteler-JC.The question of health effects from exposure to electromagnetic fields [J]. Health-Phys., 1994, 66(2):127- 136.
[26]Nakagawa-M.Bioeffects of electromagnetic fields-safety limits of each frequency band, especially less than radio one [J]. Sangyo-Eiseigaku-Zasshi, 1996, 38(1): 1- 10.
ոڣ1999-01-25
