 ׺ 2-1255
ԭĳ硷
ԭ
ԭںš199906
  šF61
  ˰
ӡںš200004
    ľ÷
    /־
    
    ʱγһ÷չرǷչйҾҪս֮һʱγɵǰͶʻͶʻʽԴ
ԸԸͶǾıҪJhingan,198139ҳǴϻǴľ÷չ
ʱĹϵ֪ˣƹ״߹ʣǸ׷ľĿ֮һʵһĿĹ
УʵĸߵҪáرҹĸ￪20겻ϣծģţҹ
ģÿµֱ̬ӹϵ
    źǣǾѧеһҪ⣬Ҳʵ˹ע⣬ҹѧԴо޼
ͱĿǰܿһЩо塢㣬1991ܿأ1996˼Ⱥ1998Ľ綨һ£õĽ۴
ྶͥΪˣȴĽ綨ʼҹı仯̬ơʵǰǸƾ֧֮ܶ
Ĺϵֹϵǣ浽һϵҪ⣬ʱص⣺Ӧ˰ջ֧ϵ
ĲķӦµӣԤּ٣ӳ˵߹ӻ
˽˴İͶ
            һĽ綨
    ھѧ̿УͨΪҵͼ֮ͥ͡չʹھͳУָһ
ŵĴһ(general government sector)ҪʡݣطԼᱣϻԣ˵
һ֧Ҳ൱ҹ˵ĹҲ֧
    ָһŵľ(current revenues)ھ֧(current outlays)룭
֧У
    룽˰룫Ʋ루ҵϽɵ󣩣ͥ͹ת
    ֧֧繤ʺнƷͷĹ򣬼֧תãҵĲͥת
ȡ˵תãծϢ
    ҪָǣͬһżǴ̵ĲߣҲŴʹߡˣȿֵҲ
Ǹֵŵľһʱڴھ֧ʱֵֵһζŲֶȫ
Ͷˣһӹ෴ŵľһʱСھ֧ʱ
ֵ£ŽծԱΪ֧ʽνĸô(dissaving)
һֶܴĿ۳֮£ծΪ䲿ֻȫʱ֧ʱʵϴųԴʾ

    Ҫһ˵һֲֵķ޹ءȿ÷йծҲûҴ
ķֲ֣Ҳ˵ծֲֵֻʽԴʽԴȻҹЩѧߣܿأ1996
˼Ⱥ1998ծΪҪԴǼΪͬġڶڼʱ֧Ͷ֧֮
ǹؼΪ߲ĶУǰȴĶС۾ɻڣôһ
ܶͳΪëܶ(total gross national saving)򣬾ͳΪܶĲ۾ɻԣָ
Ǿ
    ڽͲͬʱڵ仯ʱǱ뿼ҪأЩʹǶķøӸӡ
    ȣǹԤһɲֵ֣ı仯ֱ֮ӹϵҲ˵
£ͻӲ֣ӽٲ֡ˣһʱڵķں̶ܴڶԲ
ֱ仯ķ
    Σһľ֧ܶ΢С仯ᵼͲֱȽϴı仯ˣЧؿƾ֧ܶ
乹ɣͱȱ䴢ˮƽʵı仯ͻܴ
    ٴΣģı仯ں̶ܴϷӳ˹ԤԾ÷չԶӦˣӦģ仯ԭ򣬼Զ
Ļԭ򣬻ԭ򡣼ڴ˰GDPͼ۸ˮƽĺˮƽھڹлᷢ仯ھ˥
ʱڣ֧˰ս٣֧Ͻʧҵȼýȣӡˣûᵼ١෴÷
ʱڣӣΪӣᱣϷ֧١ˣھڹı仯νԶĻ
ȶ־ţ1997Ĵء
    ģı仯أԣбҪΪʵʴ(actual saving rate)
ڲӰ죩ṹ(structural saving rate)߷ӳʩӰ졣뷽ĽṹȻ
ṹ߱仯Ӱ죬а˰ƶȺͷ˰Ľṹ仯Ӱ졣磬˰֧ӣ˰٣ͻ
ʹ٣ڷ˰ԴУӮӪҵ˽л˹ҵ(public domain)󣬾ͻή
ʣ˽˴ʣ֧֧ˮƽͽṹı仯ڳӰʡ磬ԹʵĽס
ḣӣ֧Ҫӡ磬ʵʩԲۻӴծģ˵ڵϢ֧
    ԭ򣬹ʽԤֺ͹ծı仯ôгڽǶǡһ½ʱ
رǵôڲʱؾšȻ൱һʱڳ½ʽֽṹԲƽ⣬Ҫ
˰գ֧ȻʵĲʩע⵽˽˴ʵӰ졣
            ҹ̬
    ǹһɲ֡ǣҹûйҵĸйͳҲûṩҵ
ͳϣˣֻ̬ܵơַΪǶȣһʱзĸ￪20ҹ
ʣܶռGDPʣı仯ǺҵȽϣҹʵĸߵ͡
    ǣҹĲͳҲûϣֻøͨе㷽ϡйͳ
ĹҲĿ֧ݽ㣺
    룽˰룫ҵϽ룫루תû
    ֧֧֧Ľ̿ѧҵ֧÷֧ḣȼ֧֧Ϣ֧֧
    룭֧
    㷽Ǽ19781996ҹʱ仯1Կһ19781996ҹһֱ
½ƣ19781980ƽ14%½19960.6%13.4ٷֵ㣬ͽ0.8ٷֵ㣻ڶ1981198519781980
ʽ5.5ٷֵ㣬1986199019811985ʽ5.2ٷֵ㣬1991199519861990
ʽ2.4ٷֵ㣬199619911995ƽʽ0.3ٷֵ㣬ҹ½ٶǵݼģ1996
꿪ʼ߼ӸֵΪֵʿʼǾر˰1994˰ĺ״õ
ƵĽ
    ʵȫǶʶŲ̶ͬȵ½ơȣӲ־÷ң¹ձ
Ӣȣ6090ʳͣ60ƽΪ4%70ƽΪ2%8090˸
ʣֱΪ-0.9%-0.7%(Robson,1996,198203)ΣӲַչйңӡȡɱ̩ȣ70
ڵ80ƽ½3.2ٷֵ㣬ֱΪ4.6%1.4%(United Nations,1982)
    ͼ{ͼ}
    Դ19781985ݸݡйͳ(1998)67ҳ273ҳ275ҳԼ276ҳйݼã19861996
ݸС2020й144ҳ͵147ҳйݼá
    ӹʱȽϽǶҹ״̫80ڵʱȽϸߵľ÷60ˮƽ
չй70ˮƽӽȻǣҹʻûбΪֵǣǴǴռ
ܶı1½ǳġȵģҪȡʩֹ̬ơ
    ΪҵʵЧʩҪҳҹ½ԭ򡣶ԴˣǴӾ֧мҪӾ
ģ90%˰룬ʵ½˰״ֱӹϵ֪1996ǰ
ҹ˰ռGDPıʳ½½1ٷֵ㣬ͬ½0.8ٷֵǺϡɼǶ
ʵֱ;˰ռGDPıʡ
    Ӿ֧ģҹ֧½һҪԭоѧ˹(Please,1967,p.243
2)30ǰָŵ֧Ź߶ߵʸǰߵʣԤ㴢Լ
٣ǳ֮Ϊ˹ЧӦ(Please effect)ݱ߼㣨1ҹƽ߼ʴǣ19811985Ϊ0.261986
1990Ϊ-0.1619911995Ϊ-0.231996Ϊ0.07Կҹ80ƽ߼ʴֵָ״һ
ֱ1994ꡣ˵벻ûΪṩʽԴ֧Ҫ̬Ȼ1996
ת߼΢΢Ϊ0.07߼ߴ0.93Ҳ˵ľ󲿷ֱ֧
ĵ
    ɼҹĹҵУĹȥԶҪʡڵǣӦ
˰ջ֧ϵĲ߽ķӦ˵ʵʵǣǷضӹ
Ҫ۷
            Ĺϵ
    Ȼ˰պ빹©ѺͶ֧עˣԤ
ͶʹҪ(Heyns,1995)
    һĹʽ
    Ͷ˽˴ͶʡͶ֮ĹϵԴӿžõĹʽƵSoderstrom,1987
45ҳ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ʽУYֵCp˽ѣIp˽ͶʣGڹƷͷ֧XƷͷĳڣ
Ҫ룩MƷͷĽڣҪ֧˵ľתã
    Ѳ֧Ϊ֣֧Ͷ֧
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ʽУGc֧GiͶ֧˽˴Ķʽǣ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ʽУTľ루۳ת֧(2)ʽ(3)ʽ(1)ʽõ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ˣܶ(T-Gc)˽˴SpͺͶܶ˽ͶIpͶGiټϾͶ(X-M)
(4)ʽǵõʽĺʽ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    (5)ʽһ֮ĹϵһڿžУųԴԤ֣ºضҪ˽
˲ŻṩЩԴڶʽȱ£˽˲ҪṩԴͱ˽˴߼˽Ͷ

    ʽ(government saving)ʽ(government financial saving)ĳһţͶʵ
֮Ϊòŵʽˣ(T-Gc)ͶGiʱʽֵҲ˵Ԥӯࡣ෴
ʽǸֵʱԤ֡
    ˹׷P˹׷(Musgrave R.A and P.B Musgrave,1989)ָԤ༴T-Gc-GiֵֵԴǶ
ȶߵĽǶʽֵԤӯࣩڽߡ෴ʽǸֵԤ
еע룬һߡʽֵʱڳծ񣬽˽˴Ϊ˽Ͷṩʽ
ǣʽǸֵʱ˽˴תΪʹáʵϵT-Gcʱγɵľס
    ǿԵõҪĽۡһþծʽʵԤȻǶԴһգⲢһ
ӳԭڣľծʽͶʡֻڳܶͶ֧£Żᷢ
þծʳֲһӳľƸ״ԭֻծΪ֧ʱŻᷢľƸ״½
    ۷
    ʽûнʾĳض仯ʱֵĸӵĶ̡̬磬ߵı仯ԾòӰ죿
֣֧򽵵˰գҪ˽ʽSp-IpΪֵϣҪ󾭳ĿX-MΪֵϣ
˽ʽϣôͨ˽˴ʵ֣ͨ˽Ͷʵ֣Ƕ߼֮෴Ԥӯࣨ
֧˰գ˽˴˽Ͷʻ֧Ӱ죿⣬˽˴֮ǷֱӵĹϵ
    źǣĿǰΪֹйز֣ʽ𸺴õĴ׶ЩⲢûȷĻش𣬶ңܶ
ȻкܴۡӦָԤ仯ָͨӵĺͼӵӰžã˽˴ͶʵȵӰ첻ȷңҪ
Щ׼ȷشӦĴ⣨Soderstrom,1987712ҳһԤֻԤӯηģ
ʵķʽڶӰýṹģй˽˲Ϊļٶ
    ˣ˽˴֮ϵҲǲȷġܶһдۺ;оӰĳ̶
Ȼ֮(Hutchinson,1992)۾ѧ̿̽ԾõӰʱ෽(Branson,1989;Wachtel,1989)
һͼȼ۶(Barro,1974)ٶ˽˴ֱ֮ӹϵ磬˽˲ŶԼ˰ĲɾծʵĲ֣
٣ķӦǵĴԱ˰ˮƽߡ֮ʽı仯Ԥӣᱻ˽˴ı
һһصˣ˰ʺ͹ծڶ˽֧Ӱǵȼ۵ģֵı仯Ծе֧ӰԵġڶ
۵Ȼ෴ͳ˹壩۵Ϊڹծʵ£˰ӿ֧룬Ӷ˽ѡGDP
ҹֲ䣬гϵѹһ̶Ͻż˽Ͷ֧ȻGDPľӰȻԵġ
ˣ˰ʺ͹ծʲǵȼۡ
    ˹(Heyns,1995)÷վµIS-LM˵ֶ۵㣬ּڷԤ״˽˴ʺ͹֮Ĺϵ
2ͱ3ʾ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    մͳ۵㣬ӱ2ǿһ֧ӿܾн͹ʵЧӦ˰ʵĻùծʵģ
ڶùծʵԤ֧ӶԹʾиЧӦ֧Ǿ֧ʱ֧˰ʵĶʱ֧
ԹʿܾǱڵЧӦ׼ȷЧӦǲȷġ
    ͼȼ۶˽˴ֹģء֧߽˰գ²ӣ⽫ʹǵĵڴ
ڽ˰յԤӶ֮ɭ(Hutchinson,1992)˵ٶͥ͸ɴĪ
(Modigliani and Miller,1958)Ĺ˾Զӱ3ǿGcGiùծʶ˰ʱͼ
ȼ۶ȴͳ۵ڹʡңͼȼ۶ֻҪùծʷʽGcGiЧӦǷǸģң
£ܱ˰ʸڹʡ
            ġĲ
    ķѡߣ˰ա֧Լı֧ṹ
    ȿһͨGc˰ִֵĲ߶Թˮƽ͹ʵӰ졣մͳۻ
׼ۣGcծ٣ʹIS-LMеISƶGDP˽˴١ǣֵֻܲӡ
ˣǹǹʶߣ2෴£˰ӽʹISƶ˽˴
½ԭƶGDP½Ȼӣߡ͹Ƿ񽵵ͣȡ
˽˴½ԴС
    ͼȼ۶ͨ˰Ԥ֣ӣ˽˴߻ӦһһؼĴ
ƶֹISƶGDPʶᱣֲ䡣ڿɴʽгϣԿɴʽ빩
ˣ͹ʽֲ䡣ͬأGc½ӣ˽˴ĵ½Ϊ˰˻Թծļ
ӦIS߲ƶGDPʲ䣬͹ʶֲ䡣
    Щ4ʾ߼Gc˰ʱͳ۵ͼȼ۹۵ڹʡ෴ϽڵĽ۱
֧ӵĹУرǵùծʱͼȼ۹۵ȴͳ۵ڹʡ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ʵУʵʽּ֮ܽ䣬ͼȼ۶δõձܣPosner,1987400ҳȷ
˹ĳЩ徭ѧΪü˵൱ʵļ衣֮򵥵IS-LMģͱͨGcͨ˰ն
ֵߣԹʺܾܿһӰ졣ǣGc˰նԹʵӰ첢ȣͼȼ۶

    ѡǽGcͬʱGiҲ˵ıֵܹģGDPֲ䣬ʣǴͳ۵㻹
ͼȼ۹۵㣬Ϊ߻ʺ͹ʡˣǵļ򵥷ƺԿ֧ṹı仯
ʵЧ;
    嵽ҹĿǰʩǷʵ壿ǿ߲͹ʩҲҹ
Ŀǰڽ൱ʱڽвص㡣
    ȣӾ̬ҹĿǰ˰ռGNPıʮֵ£Ⱦ÷ҵƽֵ30ٷֵңȷչйҵƽֵ1
5ٷֵңӶ̬20ľƸĸñһֱ»ƣֱ1996Ʋתƽһ½1
ٷֵ㡣״Ӱ쵽ĺ۵ȡˣ˰ѲˡҲ
˰ջ᲻ټͥӶ͹ĿǰᡣΪ(1)йǧĻͳγ˺ǿԤ(2)ס
ҽơϵƶȸĸĽ̼ӿ죬ǿǵĴ(3)йˣˣǮƫһֱã(4)Ӱͥ
ģֱǸ˰ҹĿǰ˰ռ˰3%ңӸ˰Ծ֧ͼͥ
ҲжӰ졣дʲµȴĿǰ6Ԫһ֤ݡԤ
ʹϢ˰֮󣬾Ի޼ԣ˰ղʧΪһѡ
    Σ;֧19851996䣬֧ռGNPȻҲ½ƣȫ֧ʶ½·
ʶؽ;֧Ƿһ¾֧ٶȾͻῴ⡣ھ֧У֧ٶȷֱΪ
֧13%Ľ֧16%֧20%֧21%ر֧֧죬Ϊͨһ̶ȵ
֧ṩء
    󣬵ѡ񼴽GcͬʱGiʺҹĿǰشʵ塣(1)ҹĿǰĲͶ֧ռGNPʺ
ͣΪ3%ң19701990䣬չйҵһ8%(Country Economics Department,1992)֧(Gc)
Ͷ֧(Gi)߽ۣΪҹŤת90Ͷʵľ棬ӦGiṩݡ(2)رʺҹǰ
ľƣӲͶʼ裬Լٲ֡(3)ҹĿǰ˰ƱȽټϾת
Ҫ˰յڶҪ˰벻̫ʵΪҪǣ˰յߵǰ
˰յı߼С119955051ҳǣҹ˰յı߼ǳߣ19861995ƽΪ1.2ң
1ʾҹڽ10䣬˰ӲûΪṩʽԴ֧Եһʱ
롣ȻҲܽ͹ɼҹҪʣҪŻ˰Ҫǿ
֧Ĺ
    ҹΪȫͨ˰ա֧Ͷ֧ʵ֣رǺ߿ܸ
ЧߴʩҲԹиӰ죻ıҪٴ룬ҪҲҹ
ص㣻ĿǰʮֱҪҲпԻ˵кܴǱ
οס
    (1)Barro, R.J., 1974, Are Government Bonds Net Wealth,Journal of Political Economy 82.
    (2)Branson, W.H., 1989, Macroeconomic Theory and Policy,Harper and Row.
    (3)Country Economics Department, 1992, AdjustmentLending and Mobilization of Private and Public Resources forGrowth,The 
World Bank.
    (4)Heyns, J.V.D., 1995, The Dimension of GovernmentSaving in South African Fiscal Policy, The South AfricanJournal ofEco
nomics 63.
    (5)Hutchinson, M.M., 1992, Budget Policy and theDecline of National Saving Revisited, BIS Economic Papaers, No. 33,Bank 
for International Settlements, Monetary andEconomic Department.
    (6)Jhingan, M.L., 1981, The Economics of Developmentand Planning, Vikas Publishing House.
    (7)Modigliani, F. and M.Miller, 1958, The Lost of Capital,Corporation Finance, and the Theory of Investment,AmericanEcon
omic Review 48.
    (8)Musgrave, R.A. and P.B. Musgrave, 1989, PublicFinance in Theory and Practice, Mc-GrawHill.
    (9)Please, S., 1967, Saving with Taxation: Reality orMirage? Finance and Development, No.1.
    (10)Posner, M.V., 1987, A Survey of the Debate, in M.J.Boskin, J.S.Flemming and S.Gorini, eds., Private Saving andPublic
 Debt, Basil Blackwell.
    (11)Robson, M., 1996, Deficits, Tax Policy, and Saving,in C.E.Steuerle and M.Kawai. eds., The New World Fiscal Order, Th
e Urban Institute Press.
    (12)Soderstrom, H.T., 1987, Sectoral Saving andInvestmentPatterns in 16 OECD Countries, 1965-82,in M.J.Boskin, J.S.Flemm
ing and S.Gorini, eds., Private Saving andPublic Debt,Basil Blackwell.
    (13)United Nations, National Accounts Statistics:MainAggregates and Detailed Tables, 1982.
    (14)Wachtel, P., 1989, Macroeconomics, Mc-GrawHillInternational Editions.
    (15)塢㣺йGNPķʹáйѧ磬1991ꡣ
    (16)ܿ˪йʵѧҡ1996꣬1ڡ
    (17)˼Ⱥʱʱγɡѧ׳磬1998ꡣ
    (18)У2020ййó磬棬1997ꡣ
    (19)־ţ۲ȶо1997꣬5ڡ
    (20)˰뾭÷չйó磬1995ꡣ
 
