 ׺ 2-137
ԭĳѧϢ
ԭɶ
ԭںš20000623
ԭҳš
  šF13
  徭ʵ
ӡںš200009
    軬뻵гáг뷨
    Ǯӱһ
    
    һԣζԾ÷չӰ
    Ρ(rule of law)һͨһ˵ġ뷨Ρѷһͬгһг
ΡִгмΪеĹǾѧûжԴоκһ־ƶһضй
ûϷ(rule of game)ִгΪһƵĸϷǻڷεĹڱнζԾ
չ;Чٽáڷִ÷չйϵβǷרҲӦǾѧңرƶȾѧңҪ
оͬʱҲӦܵйעʹ¾÷չ;øĸǵӡ
    ҹ1979ĸ￪øĸͷչȡ˾ϵľ޴ɾ͡ڽ2000Ľ죬ҹľƸĸͷչһ
̨׵ʱ򡣼ó֯ʾýӹһҪ衣ǽغķչչڵصһսԾٴ롣Ҫһÿ
ţҪѹڵƸĸһ½׶ΡҪȫгƵת죬2010Զ
滮δ10ڳɹ淶гơһ漰ҵ˰ڡóᱣϡгͨȶ෽棬Ҫҳһ
١ĻôٱǷΡǽִгƵƶȻ
    ʮĴˡгáΪתĿꡣʮֽһˡǹƾгõҪɲ֡
͡ιĿǰΪֹѧֻעгƵĹȴδог뷨εϵӹɣ
ǺҪģǣǸΪεƶ⡣ִгԶҵΪɽ׾ãǲᡰά
(self-sustained)ġҽִгΪһЧƵǷΣͨΪгṩ
ƶȱϵġεĵһԼԼԾûԤεĵڶԼΪаȨ綨
ͱͬͷɵִУƽУάгͨҪڲֱӸԤõǰԾýеĽɫ
ֺ֧гáûзεΪƶȱϣȨӸ˵ǲȫģҵг
γɾЧõķչҲǿɳġ
    ɺͷζԾ÷չ;תӰڳΪѧرƶȾѧоǰءȥƶȾѧ
ڷɺͷζԾõӰ졣ȻṩһЩܺõ뷨ȱ۷ܺϵͳľ֤(empirical evidence)
ѧӰޡЩ۷ھʵ֤окܴͻơ۷棬ѧòۡͬۡ
Ϣѧȷ߶ԷɺͷζԾ÷չ˱Ƚ׼ȷĲѧӹķھ֤ݷ棬ѧҲѾ
оͬϵͬ͵Ĺ˾֤ȯͶԽڼгĹ(regulation)Թ˾ʡ˾ṹ֤ȯгչ
СҵչԼ徭Ӱ졣۷;֤ݵĽ󶼱κʵĹھ÷չ෴ȱκ͡ȹ
ơ(excessive regulation)ϢûͷгҪԭ
    Щоȡչһ۷;֤ݶ廯ˣ˷ľɵоʽΪԼͬɹ
Ϊβͬȡ;˵ͼȵ漯ŵӰ죬ҲĻʷءеϵ
ѧеĹɴ˲Ҳϵͳͨѧķ顣ǷȥоĳЩƶ
иεķκͷءת쾭УȨĲȫʱгȱݶҵչ谭ֱûз
ıϱ£гѳڳ־õرɿšչЩоѧйסȤǣһ
Ǵת쾭ܵȻ굽չкͷҡΪת쾭йڷκͷɶҵ徭÷չӰͻ
Ҳܹע
    ĿǰҹȻгáһʿ˵ѾģǻԶ˵ѾȽ׼ȷȫΪһ־Ƶг
á෴ΪǧĴͳСũõʶڵļƻʵԼһЩѧҶгõķȫڹͣǶִг
ƻڲ⡣һ£ʶг뷨εĹϵǱȽ׼ȷȫ̵ִгƵĹؼһ
    ͳгִг
    гõǷɢľþ߸г۸ԴáгΪһƣ¶ʹڼƻ
֮ǰгֿɷΪ࣬ͳгúִгá෢չ൱ʱڣǴͳгã
гʷϵشͻơʹڱúν¾áƶԣִгõ
    ͳгõص㲻ǾӪģСƶȾѧĽǶȿƶص㡣һڴͳгУʵ֮
Ľ׶Ϊֻгס(spot market transaction)һֽǮһֻֽг׵ʵҪνͬ
(implicit contract)ִҪ˫(reputation)ǵҡִͳУ˽֮ĺ
ζԽ׳ɰҪûСУ֡˸񻯽ס(personalized transaction)ĳɱܵ͡һ˻
Ȧӣ͹ϵ׵ĳɱںཻܶ޷ʵ֣ҵгĹģ˸񻯵Ľ׷ʽк
ľԡ
    ͳгõĵڶصǶԾ˺ȨԣңƶȵԼ磬˰֣˰ʡֱ
Ԥûƽס͵¾ʵĲȨòƶȱϴӶַȻڴͳгУ
ΪȫԼġܵԼ磬ϢͽͨԼضڲ̶ͬԤõǵ
ֻǿάִ±ʱͻᶯҡȨȹ̡һƶԼԼĿǡر
ǵгִԤʱôǰԾõĿɿԻȡڵ档ڶЧޣΪִ޵Ĳ
ȷԺܴ󣬶ִ߲һˣ߲ߺ͵طԱڶϲȫһ¡
    ִг봫ͳг˵涼бϵĲ𡣵һȻֻ׺˸񻯽Ȼ൱ķΧڽУ
˸񻯽ס(impersonal transaction)ΪҪĽ׷ʽֽ˫һϤԷʶԷ˽˫
ζɽвͨġҪͨƽִкͬڶȻ뾭Ȼأ뾭˵
ϵش仯ʹ뾭˵Ĺϵˡ־͡(arm's length type)ྭʷѧңŵ˹(North)ɭ(R
osenberg)ڹڶԾ˵Ĺϵϴֵ־һת䡣֪һҪʷ¼1
688ӢٸʱӢʼҵĲ;ȨʼλᲢ˳ҵִгƵԴ
    ε㾭ú
    ִгƲͬڴͳгƵƶȻʲôأһǷΡȻεĺܹ㣬ԶԶ÷롣
編κйαҲжĵ¼ֵƽȡ͹ﲻЩ⣬Ǽ۷ִг
жԾ÷չ;ЧʵáΪԣ㾭ú塣εĵһԼԼԾû
ԤεĵڶԼΪаȨ綨ͱͬͷɵִУƽУάгͨҪ
ֱӸԤõԾýеĽɫ˵εĵһζŷɹ(deregulation)Ļôڶ
ζĳЩơͨεãִƶȷ뾭ˣҵˣ֮ı־
ϵִ÷չлд£ֿɳƶȻεĵһԼǡԷι(rule by law)롰
ι(rule oflaw)ĸڡھڣԷιͨʽҵ͸ˡԷιĸйͳĻ
ʹڡսĩڵķҾ÷գǲԼʵ۵ġڵιеҪһϰտͨԼ
ΪɿԼΪʱʵоȨԡ֮ΪܷԼҵƶȺɽ׾û
ıϣôִгõĻͲˡ
    þѧΪʲôԼԾ÷չҪһȨȻĴҵˣΪиϰûе
ֶΣ˰ʹþ;ӡڶһȨԾԤƣշֻһԵ
ԤΪûмͶʣŤͶʣ϶̡ƽĿȥ¸ԱԻȡԤļ١͹ɶ
÷չϰԴΪԼ£Ծ˵ĳŵ(commitment)ò(not credible)ͨ
ϰĵġ߶䡱ھѧ֮Ϊġųŵ⡱ʵϣһ֡˫䡱档Ϊ
½òչ˰˼ٶԼҲ档ͨԼ
ΪԴﵽġųŵ(credible commitment)ɡ˫Ӯ֡߼϶з෴һ
ܵԼܶԾԤ磬շѣҲƾûҲԳϦġڶԤڵ
ȶ߻ҵͻԵطͶʡھлԲɴ˲ľû棬ҲԴ
ȡ˰˫Ӯġе˰ʷ˰ܶﲢǼ򵥵˰⣬ĳŵ벻ŵ
߶Ծ˼ȸ߶ȶ˰Ҫصöࡣ
    ϵķǿһ֡ȨۡȨԽԽأʹŵòšϰղ
ŵʱǾûĻԣշʹ𡣷ͨȨԼΪ
ʹĳŵÿšϰջϰ棬Ҳ档ⲻ߼ƵĽҲʷ֤ݿѰ
ӢĹٸ˻ʼ˰ȨȨתᣬںӢսУӢͨйծѣΪĻծ
ŵǿˡ뼯Ȩķȴû㣬ΪͶ߲䲻Լŵ
    εĵڶԼΪҪշɷֺ֧гáΪ˴ﵽĿģھý˫Ӧ
䵱ƫĵĽɫþѧķǻ⵽εĵڶҪԡ˵ΪԼΪ˻һ
º󡰻塱뾡취ռ˵ıˡҲԵģ֪º󲻸Ǯ򲻽򽻴ƷȾͲͬ
ˣͬ⡣Ǿ֮ġųŵ⡣ǡ˫䡱档ھûУҵ͸׷Ч
ΪҪΪḣ;Чʣͱȷ涨ȨȨִкִͬзɣάֵعгòеȵ
ͨЩã˫ԼԼľΪﵽųŵ조˫Ӯƺһۣһɵ
Ҫ
    ڷεĵڶֺ֧гݺͳ̶ȣѧвͬĿΪܵԽԽãҲΪҪ
ÿһЩ۲û壬Ϊ˾廯Ұѧ۵ĹάгݷΪࡣһģ
оѧҹϵݡȨȨִкͬͨ˵ġҹˡáڶǽģ
ѧϿɵݣԭϣĳЩɺ͹Ʊ練¢ϷһЩ彡ȫͻгڻ˾
ṹйصĹơȻȽϼ˵ɾѧҷЩĸԤѧΪЩʵĹƵ
ڸԤĳɱǺݡԼ۸񣨷⡢ʡɼۡʵȣĹƣó׵ƣбĲҵ
ȵȡ֮飬Ϊûгֵ֤֤ЩԤԾ÷չԵã为ãгŤѰ⡢ܣ
ʮԡˣΪԵһԷӻáڵ࣬ӦΪءκγ֮гƶӦ
Ϊȡ
    гϣʾֵǽطֱ𿴲ƷгʱгͶгڲƷг˵Ľ
ȫͻйصĹ⣬ĿǰĹǷɹơеķǽڹ˾ǼעᣬԽԽáֱܶԭƵĲ
ҵš񺽡ȵȶٱˡʱгܷͬҾʵʱĿ»ҿɶһǶԽڻ
Ĺȴ൱࣬Ϣ¶ծչƵȵȡڲƷʱгĹϣҴͬС죬Ͷг
ͬŷ޹йĹơҲΪʲôͶгͨԽϺãʹľýṹΪѸ٣ŷ޽Ϊ
Ͷгʧҵʽϸߣ侭ýṹҲ
    Ҫָǣεĵһ͵ڶ֮лϵεĵڶԵһΪǰġҲ˵ֻеΪ
ܵԼ뾭ñһʱſܳΪƫĵֺ֧гЧЩ˷ĸԤãΪ
ǾɷεгģΪΪڵεĵһòܱʱԼʱԤгʱ
ȨгЧʡȻгҪܵԼⶨʲôǲҲ
ָʲôûҪƣԷֹȹơȻεĵһãԼ͵ڶãԼˣֲһ
Ĺϵʵϣ֮䳣ìܣһ棬ȨȥԼȨһ棬Լ
ֺֿܻ֧гĻá¼˹(Weingast)ΪġƵĸ⡱(the fundamental dilemma
 of an economic system)
    ġ˫˾Ƶط
    һڣиӵһ档κһɱʵеطԷȨԷӵطĻԡˣβ
ҵ͸˵Ĺϵ⣬漰֮Ĺϵ⣬߶ԾõķչشӰ졣һͻǵط塣
ͨطִк˾Ϊطͨƫ򱾵ߺߡôνأһ
ƶȰ˫(two-tier)˾֯ơ
    ˫˾һͻӡڵطһϣݶԼһ˾ϵݲڸ˾
ϵ֮˾ϵ˾ϵϣԺ(District Court)߷Ժ(Court of Appeals)
ѲطԺ(Circuit Court)߷Ժ(the Supreme Court)Ժòȫغϣ50ݹԼ90Ժ
ѲطԺǿõģ13һʮһѲطԺ׶ʢٵѲطԺ߷Ժֻܷصİ
ͨѲطԺ͸߷ԺߵİپͳֱȫӰ졣
    ˫˾ƶԴƵطγͳһĹڴг൱áΪҪܷеһڰ˿йڹ
Ȩ¹涨ġȨҡݼ֮䣬Լӡذ񡱡һͨΪ(the
 Commerce Clause)ܷһȨʹȫȨ漰֮ϵ޴Ȩһ
߷ԺԹִ᳹УΪͳһĹгķɻ
    һ1824Ļ˹(Gibbons)԰¸(Ogden)ѷλŦԼ֮һӡŦԼ
λŦԼ˸(Fulton)˹(Levingston)¢Ȩ߷ԺþŦԼݵһΥܣΪ
ݣŦԼݵһ谭Сһþõľܷеһ˵úףֻ
Ȩ֮
    һ1827겼(Brown)(Maryland)ڱ۽ڻ50Ԫ֤ѡ߷Ժ
κöԽڵݵĻȡԵķѡһþܷͬе
    ˫˾ƺܷеԼ߷ԺԴڵĵطóױ˾áӴԺ
ݾӪĹ˾ҲᱻšʹκβƷʱͶȫΧڿԽݵı߽
ȷͳһĴгγɡһҲһ˵һִгǲȻγɺάֵģһҪ
ͳһĴг˾ƶȵ֯ʮҪ
    ǹȥʮľѵ˵͵طȨϵϣȫȨȫȨھõķչֻгֵ·һȨ
ͬʱֽĳЩרȨ룬ŻھõķչڷҲһġ˫˾֯ϵ侭ѧ߼Ȼ˾
Ӧط˾Χ漰ط֮ľʱطıԶڣġǲָط
˾ԼǵȻǱطľ档ÿطʵеط壬ôȫȻܵ
𺦡Ƶطֻܿڵطһ˾ǴƵط壬άͳһгһЧ
Ȱš
              δ
 
