 ׺ 2-559
ԭĳѧо
ԭ
ԭںš200005
ԭҳš5056
  šF13
  徭ʵ
ӡںš200007
    ɾѧʽ
Ӣı⡿On the Model of Economics of Transition
    ZHANG Yu
    (School of  Economics ,Renmin  University of China,Beijing100872,China)
    
߼顿йѧ  ѧԺ  100872
    1964УˣйѧڣҪо徭ۡ
Ҫ2080ĩնҷľйʽĸ·ĳɹһڸĸ﷽ʽĴۣг塢
ȽϾѧ¹ŵ侭ѧ˹塢塢ƶȾѧĸ﷽ʽۺξѧʽ8ֹɾѧʽ 
ʵγһֱȽϿѧļֵ߼һµƶȱǨۣйѧչر˼徭۷չٵ޷رܵ⡣
ӢժҪThe social turmoil occurred in Soviet Union and East  Europeand the steady reform undergoing in China in  the  l
ate  1980shave aroused heated discussions on patterns  of  reform. Eightdifferent patterns of economics of transition are  g
eneralizedfrom the discussions.They  are: market  socialism, comparativeeconomics,new classical  economics, Keynesianism, ev
olutionaryrationalism,new systemic economics,special ways of reform  andpolitical economics as a  whole. To  develop  a  com
parativelyscientific  theory  with  conforming  values  and   logic   inpractice is  an  unavoidable  task  for  development
  of  bothChinese economics and Marxist economics.
  ʡƶȱǨ/ĸ﷽ʽ/ɾѧ
    change in  the system/ patterns  of  reform/ economics  oftransition
    
    ͼţF121    ױʶA     ±ţ0257-2826200005-0050-07
    徭гƵ˼ѿ19ĩͳˣԴͳƻƽиĸʵҲ50˹̽
½ʼˣгĸʵ90ǰѾ൱Ľչ˵ɾѧĲѾá
90ǰг90гűʵĲͬ ȣ 90ǰмƻùҵĸĸﶼܷƶȵĿ
неģһֽʽĸĸΣĸȻгȡģгΪĸĿ겢ûлúϷĵλɾѧΪһ
ձϿɵȷľѧѧƣ80ĩŷϵľ;ȫгõĹΪ־ġ90Ժ󣬴Ӽƻ
гõĹɳ˸ƻùҾøĸĻúƽһӴͳƻгùɵתʱڡ
оӼƻгùɵĹ̺͹ΪĿľѧת;ѧɾѧ
    ɾѧĲչĸʵء1989꣬նҷʱͳѧ̴һֹʶг
õĹɱȡķʽǲԽһ蹵ʽĸԳɹġͨʻһ֯е֯Ĵ
㣬һֱ֮ΪݿƷ͡ըļʽĸ﷽ʽ㷺áΪֹʵȴеͳսй
ʽĸﲢûͣͣйľøǰͶŷľȴͣͺ˥ˣδ֮ȡǣ
ŽʽĸԼʽĸ࣬Ӷһڸĸ﷽ʽĴۣǶԾѧرƶȱǨ
۵̷˼ڲͬɵľѧҶгõĽṹԼת͵ʺ͹ɡáҵλߵ
Ŀһϵʶںܴɴγת;ѧĲͬʽ
            һг
    ҾƸĸʵʵгƵĽϣܷۺʵнгƵ⣬Ǿ
Ƹĸǰ;˵ĹؼءгʵгõĽΪĿһۺš۷ӳ
ҾƸĸʵʺͻĿ꣬ڸĸʵкܴӰ죬ڹɾѧرйĹɾѧУ
ʼմںĵλǰͶŷ֮󣬶ŷߺѧձΪг
ʧܣгˮݣʱгĸıȻŵʲƶڣͨɾ֮·̨̨Զ
ɷ޹˾1993ǣйƸĸľֹ֤۵ǲʵʵġƾе򾭼ážá
ú͸ʽķǹоÿֱгýһ𣬼ʹǹоڲҵ֮ҲŲƲϵ;ӪȨϵԲ
ҲҪͨгƷϵгƵĵڡйĿǰڽеĹдҵִҵƶȵĸĸ飬ʵֹ
гƵļݣг¸õطӹоõΪĿġ
    ̽ʵгʵ˾޴ķչۺƶѾ˴ӷгг
ת䣬гѾΪ˶ҾƸĸָ˼롣ǣӦѵؿʵ
Զûɡг۵ģʽ̩աģʽõ¹ŵ侭ѧķߡһۼٶ
гƽһԵĸ뿪ľúλڲáгȻ෽泬Խ
¹ŵķʽǣ۵ļٶȴеرˣЩ¹ŵ۵ȱݡ90ڹ
νĵгͼµʷάг룬ҲŹֵŨĿ뻯ɫʡ
ҾƸĸʵгõļһӵĳڵ񣬾һ͡
            ȽϾѧ
    ñȽϾѧʵĸĸ90ǰĸﾭѧɾѧ۴Ӳͬľгɻ
Ҫأܽɻԭγɻľģʽ缯еļƻģʽļƻģʽгƵļƻģʽ
ģʽӢгģʽ¹гģʽŷĸģʽԼֹھеģʽڴ˻϶Ը
־ƽбȽϷѡָĸʵ
    80һ棬ƸĸʵѾȫչĸʵƱǨ۵Ҫǿңһ棬ƶȾѧ
ڻδռͳѧʹͳ徭ûйгݻ̵ϵͳۣȽϾѧ80
ʢһʱ80йĸĸոտʼ𲽵ʱڶŷḻʵĸĸۺ͸ĸʵǰеۻңʴӡ
˹壬¾ûƣǸǷ˼άΪĿе롣90гù
رǶ˹ҵҷչгõľǵĸ߶ӡбȽϲмѧϰͽгģʽг·
ľѵйľøĸ;ת˻ƶáǣӦģʽй˵ֻΪο
ճհᡣ磬ڰйĸĸ·붫ģʽȣǿߵĹ֮ͬעشͳִȶɡ
г֮ƽ⣬ȶλƽгִĽ̡ǣģʽйʽ·֮䲻йԣ
ʵĲ죬磺ģʽʵеʱƶȣйʵеƶȣйһ͵ĶԪṹĹңִĹҵ
Ĵͳũҵ棬һڶǸ͵һҪ⣬ȵȡģʽľ鲢һʺй
    ȽϾѧķȻͼֵҲŸȱݡһ棬һǾĶǹ淶ģֻʷлʵ
дڵľƶȽйɣûγɹƶȱǨһۣ޷γɾձָ⡣һ棬һ
ģʵģѲͬƶȺͲͬʷµľƼ򵥻ͼʽ޷ƶȱǨĸʵ ˣ 
90ԺƶȱǨľѧڹڵĹ㷺ǶƶȱǨоĲ룬ȽϾѧӰ쿪ʼ˥΢бƶ
ȡơ
            ¹ŵ侭ѧ
    ¹ŵ侭ѧǶǵ˹ܡ֡۵ϵͳ¹ŵ۵⣬гƲԴõĻ򹤾ߣһ
ߵĺǹͼ۸໥áˣгùɵĺľǡסңſ۸񡱣ʵȶ˽лɻΪĵ
ʽġݿƷйʽĸĳɹ¹ŵ侭ѧķӦǣһǰйĸĳɹһ⣬Ϊй
ĳɹҪһϵĳʼڲձ壻һǿйʽĸĳɹʮ޵ģйĸ
ûʵг׵ɻ·µġڡйŷǰøĸеĽṹءһ
ѧڽܸ˹ϵͳزһ۵㡣ΪǰͶŷͬǣйΪһũҵҿʼĸ
̵ģйٵǵ͵Ĺŵʽ÷չ⣬ͶߴӵЧũҵЧĹҵתƵ⣬ǰͶŷٵ
ýṹĵ⣬ĵЧʵĹҵŵľҵʹͶµЧʵĹҵͷҵתƣ׼ľ÷չͨ
һиĽеȺ嶼Ͷũҵҵŵ棬ýṹĵܿϵľ޴
ͻ÷չ뾭ýṹĵҪ׵öࡣˣйʽĸĳɹҪڲ˵Ǿá󡱵Ĳ˹
ΪŷĸĸʵˡݿƷڿ֮ȡйĸĸȴڹҵûʵ˽лĸ죬
ŲȨ壬ĸǰֹۡ
    ¹ŵ侭ѧ״̬гƵṩһ׾ȷּۺ͹ߣӳữге
һЩɣڷתег˵Ҫ塣ǣ¹ŵ侭ѧһ̬Ħг
漰ֻггɺͷչ⣬ʱ̵ĴڣּٶƶȲãѸӵľü򻯳ϡȱ
Դ⣬ԾͲܶƶȵıǨгõγ뷢չȷĽ͡Ӹ˵ĸﲻһ򵥵ĻҺͼ۸⣬
һ̵ƶȱḲ̌ƶȵıǨϵûϲ㽨ΡĻʷʵ
־͹֮໥ϵ໥Լ໥õ̵Ĳˣסңſ۸񡱲һµľ
ƣƵĳɳһȻʷ̣ṹĳڸӵĽ͸졣
            ġ˹
    ŵ¹ŵ侭ѧΪɵгÿʵֳ־ҵԴã˹ԴǿսΪɵг
ǲȶģԾõЧԤгЧתıҪ˹һ۵㣬ڴ˻ϼԷչ
һЩͬɡ󿭶˹¿˹ǵ˹Ҫɡ󿭶˹徭ѧ¹ŵ侭ѧĻ
ǰᣬг塢ԤȫսԾõĲȷԡʱĲԡҵԡɱӼ۵Ȼ
ΪϵһЩѧΪҵľתо˲ͬ¹ŵ侭ѧĿ
ˡζMark KnellΪʽĸгĳäĿģг˽лķҪأ1 
֮ľùϵһֵĽ׹ϵһϵ2ҵ֯гǽ׻ҵг໥ģ
໥ġ3۸ƲһֶֽΣͬʱнڹܡսԹܡܵȣЩԽǳɹ
ЧԴĹܾԽʵ֡4 ĲԼΪģΪ˽оҵѧϰ¡5 ˽лЧ
ʲǱҪģ˵Ļ£ҵҲԶгķӦ6ҹǽƶȵ ۾ߵƶ
ϸƣˣջ߻ԲȵԺǻΪ۸ȫɻһЩص⣬
ڼ۸ʼ۸Ľӹ۸γɾ޴Ʋѹڴͳƻγɵĸ߶ȼеĹҵṹδ֮ǰſ۸񣬻
ӹҵ¢ϵλõĴ½صʧҵ⣬ȵȡ ˣ ԾõĸԤʮҪġ Mark  Knell   andChri
stine Rider.Socialist Economies in  Transition: Appraisalsof Market Mechanism.Edward Elgar Press,1992
    ڡδȥһУ¿˹Ĵ˹ٸĸ˵Ϣѧķʽ¹ŵ侭ѧΪת
ѧΪھѡгģʽʱһҪμסʵʵгеģȥסɵ
ȫʽͳǵ˹ܵġ֡Ϊ¹ŵ侭ѧת;úƶѡôСʹڽͷг
÷ҲŸľޣͳľ۶ණŷת͹ٵԾ渺вΡϵͳ¹ŵ侭ѧת
۵ĻϣҵľתһϵеĿ磬Ϊھת͹УԶ˽лҪö࣬
ΪֻҪȷ綨Ȩʵ˽лͿЧʵĿһΣյ񻰣ͷҪǾ¢ϵ𣬶˽ƺ͹Ƶ
ϢĲȫ˽ҵ͹ҵһּ⣬гʧ⣬ˣһּɢ
˽ϵĻƲִгõȷѡ񣬵ȵȡ
    ¹ŵȣ˹徭ѧгõй̺ڻʶִгõʵ󿭶˹徭ѧ
еһЩ۵㣬羭õĲȷԡʱĲԡгĲƺϢĲԳơҹӦԵȣת;þҪ
壬Ƕת;вȨĸ۾áתٶȺʹгĹϵһϵҪʶֵӡǣϿ
ִ˹徭ѧѧʽһչܳԽѧľޡ¹ŵһǹг
ľѧۣһֹгɷչƶȱǨۣܶת͹оáΡĻ֯Ἧ
ƶȱǨе໥õĹ̼ɸֵ˵
            塢
    Ү˵ŵν壬ͼΪɺԷĺṩǿ֤սĹ۵㣬֪ʶϢ
۵ģԷɢĸ˵״̬ڵģǸʶͿĽֻԷġġʶģ
ǶԾʹͳӦĽͨƶдģֻһаȻѡҮˣ
뾭򡷣ѧԺ磬1989Үˣԭ꣬1997գʷ۵ƶ
ĳ磬1987ֹ۵ΪʽĸڼʽĸӢѧ׺ŵΪƻ֮ȱ
Чʣڼƻ߲ܻóֶ׼ȷıҪϢгУҪϢг۸ˡڴӼƻ
гƵĹУһԤʱСһӡĸʱ˺ִͬϢ⡣гһԳ
Ĺߣһƶȡгͨһϵй͹ãֹ͹ҪƣҪɡ  McMillan
,J and B. Naughton.How to  Reform  a  Planned  Economy: Lessonfrom China.Oxford Review of Economic Policy,19921 
ѧոݽľѧͱۣԴӼƻгùɵָĸ﷽ʽķΪ
ĸ﷽ĸڣĸῴһԴֶΣһûƣϣһλĸ
ῴһϢӹֶΣΪϢһۻ̣κθĸ﷽Ծ»õϢΪģδĸ
ֻһһָĸ۵ָһЩ磺ĸǴԤڵյ涨Լļƻǿʵʩ
гãĸҪĿǰҪĸ⣬佨ĻǶĿǰʵۣǿƻɵģΪ
״̬к޼ִֵ֯ڳյϢ;ڳ໥յϢ׷
ȣʵмֲļȶ룬ǿϢ֪ʶԣʵпתߣĸСģġģȵȡ
ΪɹĸĸｫЩһϳʱﲻϽбĹңЩþսڹȥδ֮ͻȻѵĹҡ
áգۼøĸ뽥øĸ⾭ѧгáй뵳У磬1994
    ¹ŵּ򵥵ȽϣǨгҪ̵ö࣬Ψͼʽĸ
۵з˼һеһЩĸĸԡĲȷԡԵľԼǿͳͲ
Դеã̰йʽĸ߼Ҫ塣ǣڽԴΪı
ǽڳ׵ĸϵģܶĿ͹۹ȷĽ͡磬ǲ
ʶģ޷˵ƶȵķչݻ̣ԵĴںǶиԤĿԣҲ
Ϊĸĸƶȵѡṩһ͹۵Եı׼ǿĻͳľ壬ʵϾͷ˸ĸ͸Ŀ
ԺͱҪԣŽ˵ʷΪʲôҪô༤ҵΪʽĸ
ʽĸǣ˵ΪʲôǰͶŷ90ǰеĽʽĸûгɹʽĸΪһ
ΪʲôܱܡԷԭĸȱ붯ȫͬˣųκʽԡ
Ԥѡ
            ƶȾѧ
    ƶȾѧķйƸĸƶȱǨǽҹѧȽеۣĸĳɱ
ӶƶȵĹƶȵʱƶȴھ״̬ĸԤڸĸĳɱʱƶȱǨͻᷢˣĸĹ
ʵ׷󻯵һԼѰĸɱСŸĸ·⡣ʢࣺйĹɾѧϺ
ϺꡢϺ磬1995ĸеĺǡȨ͡׵ɻƶȾѧӰ
ǽйѧչһֵӵĲһ淴ӳйĸĸﾭѧĲ죬һҲӳ˽
峱ھѧеĹ㷺Ӱ졣
    ƶȾѧڰ¹ŵ侭ѧƶҵƶȡȨƶȡгƶԼҵķƶȺʶ̬뾭ѧ
Ŀ֮ڣչ˾ѧҰƽƶ۵ķչоƶҪĲο塣ǣһʽҲ
صȱݣ磺ƶȾѧ¹ŵ侭ѧе˷ʽƶȷУᵱ˵ļ򵥼ܣ˵ĹϵΪ
׹ϵԼϵΪһĶԺͿ͹ԣеĻλ޷
⣬ֻܰƶȵıǨɸƫûĻ⡣磬ܽ׷ѾΪƶȾѧĺķ룬ڸֽ
УȻȱһ׼ȷطӳ׳ɱʲпɲԵĶ壬ֶĻַӳ˽׷̵ìܡ
׷ԸΪģǽ׷øȴѡһ͹۵ԵЧʱ׼޷˷ì֮
СΪոķֻиʵĴڣֻһãֻڸ˵ĳɱ棬ûĳɱ
棬߼ʹɱ棬ҲΪĿ꺯޷ܣʹֻܳΪ޷׽ġӰǣƶȴ
һֵ͵ġƷ
    ˣƶȾѧ۷ʽȱݵģرǶоĴӼƻгùһġشĺͳڵ
ʷ˵ƶȾѧķһǡĺͿѧķ
            ߡĸ﷽ʽ
    ൱ѧ߰ѶԾת͹̵оķ˶Բͬĸ﷽ʽͷıȽ档ΪøĸĺǾ÷չս
Եת죬ĸǰйչĸԭعҵȷչĸϳսԣĸйѸٷչĹؼڸĸλ
һ塱ĴͳƣʹйԴȽܷӳͬʱйĸɹһҪ֤ѡһССܼʱ
Ľʽĸ·ȣй漣չս뾭øĸϺϺꡢϺ磬1994ڡ˫
ơѧйľøĸ19781992һУžڴͳвŵľԹģʹʵϴ¢ϵλڸĸ
ʵȫļ۸ɻͿܸҵṩгͲݶȨĻᣬ²½ͼ۸ߣ½
õ˥ˡ෴ڼ۸˫£вŽȫļ۸ɻĲƷҶ۸͡Լ۸˫Ϊġ߽
ľڣвڼƻ߽ͨԼ۸źӦȥ׽ᣬҪͻȻ˽лĹвȥԾŤͶȱ
ķӦѸ١ѧΪʽĸʵھƸĲʱ򣬻ھԱ߷չƣͨƵĳɳΪ
ĸﴴӶ͸ĸĳɱʹ޽ȵǹоõķչΪ񾭼ṩһٸĸ
ΪоõĸĸﴴһгΪƵĸĸṩʾٸĸѧϰɱ٣֮·
йѧ磬1993
    ڽʽĸ﷽ʽصһ̶Ϸӳйʽĸʺ·ǶԹɾõʶƽ
˹ɾѧķչǣǶڸĸĿͬȷļٶǰΧŸĸ﷽ʽĲչ۵ģû뿼ĸ
ĸĿ֮ı֤ϵʵϣĸ﷽ʽӡĸߵĳɹʧܡĸʩĳɱȸ־⣬ֻȷ
ĿԼ¼Կгֵ塣
            ˡξѧʽ
    ӼƻгõĹǰᾭáΡĻȸ̱ǨԹ̣ˣֻġʷķ
ܵóȽϿѧĽۡġʷķ߳ɾͣ˼ʷΨξѧڡ֮·й
ʽĸξѧһУͼһ˼ξѧΪĹɾѧۿܡһ
ص㣺
    1.ĿǰеƶȾѧΪ¹ŵ䷶ʽΪĵĸǿ͹ۡʷ
ʵᡢĻͳһȥйʽĸ߼
    2.Ŀǰеİѽ뼤ĲΪĸٶȺͷʽй۵㣬йʽĸﶨΪҵ
ܷƶ˫ԼµгѹҵгܷƶߵĹϵ֧йʽĸ߼ʷ̵֮⡣
    Բͬľѧ˵ĳּһһսͬеĽԤܵϾ顣ʵ
γһֱȽϿѧļֵ߼һµƶȱǨۣйѧչر˼徭۷չٵ޷رܵ⣬
ӦΪŬ
    ոڣ19991120
α༭侩
    
    
    
 
