 ׺ 2-1175
ԭĳйѧѧ
ԭ
ԭںš200003
ԭҳš4247
  šF10
  񾭼ù
ӡںš200008
    ۺ۾ߵʱ䲻һ
Ӣı⡿Time Inconsistency in Macroeconomic Policies
    WANG Jian
    (Department of Economics Management , National  School  ofAdministration ,Beijing 100089)
    
߼顿ѧԺ  ùв  100089
    1951ϺˣѧʿѧԺڣҪоѧͺ۾ѧ
ҪĴӶ̬ӽǷҹĺ۾ߣ̽ҹͶߡߺͲߵʱ䲻һ⣬
ЭƸĸʩûߺǿְܵȶԲԽ飬Խ۾ʱ䲻һ⡣
ӢժҪThis  article  attempts  to  offer  a  dynamic  analysis  ofChina's macroeconomic policies implemented in recent
 years. Itexploits  the time  inconsistency  of  our  investment  policy,monetary policy,and  fiscal  policy. Possible  solu
tions  aresuggested  then to solve the  problem  of  time  inconsistency.They are : coordinate various  measures  of  econom
ic  reform, apply  monetary  policies  flexibly, and  reinforce   fiscalfunctions.
  ʡͶ///ʱ䲻һ
       investment  policy/monetary  policy/fiscal  policy/timeinconsistency
    
    ͼţF019.6   ױʶA    ±ţ10005420200003004206
    ۾ʱһԵĻʱ䲻һԵģǺ۾еĺ⡣۾ʱһԵģ۾
̬ŵģôʱƣ۾ʼŵģ۾ʱ䲻һԵģ۾߲Ƕ̬ŵģô
ԭŻĺ۾ʱžͳΪ߻Żߡʵ۾õĻлƵı仯º۾
ߵʱ䲻һԣˣ۾ߵʱһǺ۾оߺͺ۾ƶ׷Ŀꡣ
    Ľй۾õʵ۾еͶߡߺͲߵʱ䲻һ⣬һЩ۾
ߵʱ䲻һĶԲߡ
            һź۾ߺʱ䲻һ
    ۾ߵʱ䲻һԣָķʱŲŵġķʹôﵽķ״̬
ߡķָƶḣ£ȫġЧʵгеľþ״̬
    ķУȣ߸ݸѡںķ漰ľûУܹʹά
ǰߡʵʱıߣڲԼľߡıߺʵʾþⲻͬķ
Ҳ˵ʼķߣʱŲŵģԼ£ѡߣһ󱻳Ϊ
ߵʱ䲻һ⡣
    ˵ƫƫһʱûбҪظıߣܹʵֺ۾ߵʱһԡƫƫ
òͬʱֺ۾ߵʱ䲻һ⡣׳⣺һĿĿгͻٶеĸ˶
ͬĿ꺯չҪƶĺ۾ߵĿ˵Ŀ겻һ£۾߳ʱ䲻һԡ
˽ĸ˺͹ȫֵḣ͵˵Чúͬ˵ЧŻḣ
ͬº۾߳ʱ䲻һԡ
    ƶ߲ԼƫƫòͬʱҪʵֺ۾ߵʱһԱһ߾ԣ
ÿ˶׷󻯵£ܹ֤ḣÿʱжﵽ󻯣ǸҪ󾭼ܹԤ
δ߶ŵġ㣬۾߻ʱ䲻һԡ
    ۾߾ʱһʱеԾ˵ľ׷ź۾ߣ۾߳Чԡ۾߾ʱ
һʱеԾ˲ݺ۾ߣԵѡľߣ£۾Ч΢

    ҹ19931996ĺ۾õ߾ʱһԵʹҹڸٷչͬʱЧͨͣóɹʵ
½1996ĩ1997𣬺۾߳ʱ䲻һԣΪɵĻòĲߴ̼
ķȵԤֵͶЧӦݼ·ֱֲ̽Ͷߵʱ䲻һԡߵʱ䲻һԺͲ
ʱ䲻һԵԭ
            Ͷߵʱ䲻һ
    1993꿪ʼĺ۾õУͶڿͶ󣬽ͨʱҪáȻڵ
ǰһ衢̼ĹУͶ߳ʱ䲻һԣΪһͶ½1998ĩ1999
ͶӷȽϴͶʲͶٶ½ǲͶʴЧӦʵлĲߺӴ˲
ͶʵȣҵͶʺ͹ص㽨ͶѸӣǣǹҵͶޣͶͶԴ
ͶʵӣͶݼ
    ͶʳЧӦݼͶ߳ʱ䲻һԵҪԭͶʳǹͶ֮ȣ˵ͶӴ̼񾭼
áͶʱҲӣͨͶͶʱţͶ
Ͷʴ̼ıͶʳͶʼʱͶʵļͶʼٵ¾ıҲ
Ͷʳ
    19931998꣬ҹͶʳֱΪ2.231.871.441.140.800.67עЩֵݡйͳ1999е
ֵݣͶʳʽͶʳ 1ʣáͶʳ½˵죬
ҴתΪͶʡͶʳ½Ҫԭǣ1Ըǿ߼ һ۳
ұֵͦֵĹǿ̼˴¸ڷԱ࣬ԤְҵǼٵǰ
ѣӴԤְҵ䶯Դ벨ı仯סƶȸĸҽƶȸĸͽƶȸĸıǵ
ͨյʶǿԽԽΪ򷿡ŮѺδҽƷѴ´ӹ졣2 תΪ
Ͷ൱ıͨ;Ϊ롣ڵõЩȺУߵ˵ı߼Ӷݼ
͵ı仯߼Ҳ½ͳ֡˲뻨Ǯ˲һǮ
 3۵ĹԡۻĴҲǵϢ룬ڱ߼ʴ£ϢҲϢ൱ı
ɴӾ˱߼ʴ
    ͶʳЧӦݼĶ̬Ͷʴ̼õݼ19931ԪͶʿ¾2ڶԪ19971998
ʱ1ԪͶľֻ0.80Ԫ0.67Ԫ Ͷ
    Ͷʳݼ˵ԽԽķݶڴѵķݶԽԽ١Ѽٵгƣ
ƣȻгг۸µг۸ȫµʹҵ½ͶʵҲӦؼ١Ͷʽӽ
ߵڴʱͶ߸еͶͼѰҲи߻رʵĺĿ֮ǰͶ߸Ը⽫ʽжͶʡ
    תΪͶʵĻƲȫʱȫתͶʣᵼͶʳ½ѭͶʳ½ӡѼ١
г۸µҵ½Ͷ١Ͷʼ١ӡͶʳһ½
    ͶʳݼͶߵЧԵͶ߲ܴ̼ѸٷչӣͶ߳Եʱ
䲻һԡ
            ߵʱ䲻һ
    1993꿪ʼĺ۵ãЧͨͺ;ùȡȻһ衢̼ȶ
ĹУɵĻڴٽÿȴԵЧ΢1996й8µʣ1998 
Ϣٴµȳ4ٷֵ㣬 ǱȽϺġͬ꣬νϢ½ȽΪ0.75ٷֵ㡣ңҹ
˴׼ʣԭ138 ռ򵥵Ļҳʽ㣬ҹ1ࡣȻ ˿ɵĻ߶Ծ
Ĵ̼úޣ1998ϰ꾭ٶȱȽϻ°ʵлĲߣٶȺѴﵽԤĿ꣬ҹ
Ҳδ̼ѸɵĻߴ̼õԵʱ䲻һ
    1.ߵʱ䲻һԡʵԺͶʵԱСӰߵЧг£Ͷ
֮ȣͶʵĶоӰ졣ͶʸʱͶӡͶʵڻʱͶʼ١
ڳЧӦݼ£ѲϵݼѵĵݼʹͶʵ½Ͷ½ֵͶʵļٺʹӡͬʱͶ
ʳݼµʴ̼ѺͶʵԽԽСѺͶʶʵĵԶ֮½Դ̼ѺͶʡ
    ʵġ塱Ӱ˻ߵáˮƽ͡ͶܵʱǻֱѰͶĻᣬԸͶʡ֤
ȯгϽͶķձȽϴͶȽ٣ֻֽܽСʱ෢лҲܴ̼ͶӣֻӴ
ʵġ塱ʵġ塱˿ɵĻߴ̼ãˣŴµƶ
    2.Сϧʱ䲻һԡСϧԻ߶ԾõĴ̼áԹҵСϧ
ձ飬϶Դ΢ʡСϧָŴгڹʱвͨгŴ󣬶
ڵгʵˮƽϹһҵһҵͬʱг۵ԣͶЧ͡ҵ
деͶʣʵͣʽѣ½дռӴ󣬴ӡΪʽİȫá
ϧڴƴСϧԺ۾õӰ죺һǿ˽ߵЧӦ
ʵнʱеŴЧؿͶǿ˽ߵЧʵԻʱŴ
ȻͼͨлҵãӶŻߴ̼÷չá
    3.ʽڲ·ʱ䲻һԡʽڲ·൱̶ȵص˻ӻҹЧӦ
˿ɵĻߴ̼áʽԵشӡѭΪڶ·ҵǰо
ӪַţäĿģֶνгģ֮ҵӪ淶˴ʽϵ֮ʽ
ѭ
    Ͷʲߡҵ½дʱҵֳʽڶ·һڴʵС
ϧһдִӣл˴ʽЩʽȥΪһǹҵǰ黹
еٴϢǹծȽϰȫĽծȯȶػծȯϢڴϢǹҵ
д1998εϢ֮ǰҵеĴʸھʣҵпȻɿˣ൱һ
ʽûнͨ򡣴ȫⲿʽڲѭûнͨͺʽ˶
ϵڱ·һʽġڶ·˻ңҵļͨҳýһҵĹ
ʽԼ٣ƿɵĻžõá
            ġߵʱ䲻һ
    1993꿪ʼĺ۵УʶȴӽĲ߾ʱһԣ󡢿۵áȻּĻ
ȴԴ̼Ӻ;õʱ䲻һԣҪ棺һǲ֧ͲͶʴ̼Ч
ӦݼǹծԵͼȼۡ
    1.֧ͲͶЧӦݼԲߵʱ䲻һԣΪĲߴ̼ŵõݼ19931998
֧꣬ͲͶʵĳֱΪ 2.231.871.441. 140.800.67ע֧ͲͶʳļ㷽ݵ
ԴͶʳͬЩֵݡйͳ1999еֵݣͶʳʽͶ
ʳ1ʣá90ڣ ֧ͲͶʶԾô̼ñȽϴ󣬾֧Ͳ
Ͷʵ 2֧ͲͶʴ̼ЧӦݼ19971998֧꣬ͲͶʵӶԾĴ̼С
1֧ӺͲͶʳͨ1߲д̼áĿǰ֧ӺͲͶʲܴ̼
ͶҲһֲתΪͶ߾ʱ䲻һԡ
    2.ծԵͼȼۣעгùƶծʱͨҪǷйծĺ۾ЧӦ缷
ЧӦͼȼЧӦȡͼȼָծȯʽ˰յʽʣЧǵȼ۵ģծԵġ
ͼȼ۵ԭǣͨծȯֲ֣еծȯǿ˰ճģծԼٵǰ˰գᵼ½˰ա
геľ˻ʶծı˰ʱ䣬ûм˰Ǵ൱δ˰Ա˰ǰ
ǿ֧ĲƸ˰ճʵЧһծȯ˰նԸߵӰ˽˴еĴ岻
мͥഢĲǡõ֧󣬾Ȼԭľ״̬ˣûߣͶûӣԲ
ܴ̼š
    ҹծͼȼ۵ԭǴԤյʶǿǴΪ˽˰ƸĸͬʱƳסƶ
ĸҽƶȸĸͽƶȸĸЩĸʩȫظıǶԾõԤڣǵڱأ˷ʶǿ
Ѽ٣򷿣֧ŮѣΪҽƸĸҽƷôΪݺձԤδ֧
ӣյʶǿ±߼½߼ʴЧӦݼڳЧӦݼʱĹծ
ܹͶʣȴԴͶʣҲԴ̼˹ծ̼ãĲ߳ʱ䲻һ
ԡ
            塢˼ͶԲ
    ۾ʱ䲻һĹؼǸıǵԤڣЧѡͨЭƸĸĹϵö
Ļ߹ߺǿĺ۵عܣԴ̼Чӣӱ߼ͶʳЧӦַӿɵĻߺ
Ĳߵá
        һЭƸĸ֮Ĺϵ
    ۾ߵʱ䲻һͬƸĸﲻйءƸĸҪøĸȶ뷢չĹϵͬʱȡ׸ĸ
ʩıǵԤڣʹ˵Ԥں;Ϊĸٴһ£̼ʩΪ
    1.ֲƽסƶȸĸҽƶȸĸͽƶȸĸŸĸʩ̨ʱĸδ֧Ӱ
ޣʹǶԤ֧ʹĸĸʩǵԤЭǿǶԸĸģӶٻ
ĸ̨߳ĺ۾ߵʱ䲻һ⡣
    2.Ӹ˿֧룬ʵ߹ʣ˰׼߸ˮƽ
    3.ҽƱղյķΧݱձ׼ǵĺ֮ǣٽǰѡ
    4.ʩͻҵĹģҲҪ;÷չĹģӦĻʩͻҵͶҲγظ裬Խһڻ
ʩͻҵͶתгĲҵҵӾҵᣬߵߵ
        û߹
    û߹ߣһǳַӹгݻߵãƽ۵طʽת䡣Źծ󣬸
гҵṩҪӴ󹫿гȣݽڻԣϸĸ﹫гҵͲˮƽǼǿ
ʹдʽԽڻʽũƷչʽĺҪ֧֣ʵٴĶ
̽ѺٴʽȲչҵʵֶҵƱʲ֧ҵƱʡ
    ҵнһŻṹٽṹ̼һӶũҵŴٽũգũˮƽǷ
ͼ򻯸ŴŴģǵطʽĴڴ˻ϣлСҵŴ
СҵķչǴֿ֧Ƽºͼ죬ƶ¼չǶѾת侭Ӫơծ񸺵صĹҵ
пʱʵнϢͣϢϢڹҵӾҵ̼Ѻ;
        ǿĺ۵ع
    1.Ƹĸ𲽽ӦгҪĹܣƲ۵ơȡ
֧ƽǰ£Ӳýṹãٽȶ
    2.òϢķʽ֧ʣͶʡϢǲãϢʽԴԤʽ𣬿ԽĿʳ
ʵЧߡʹòϢ߿ԶԱʽʽĿַӲľøܸã
ʽͶӰͶľߣʵֵͶʵĹģṹͶЧȺ۵صĿꡣ
    3.˰գ˰Դ̼Ч󣬴ٽóڷչͨ˰̼÷չķҪУһշѡȡ
շѣ͹Ͽ𵽽˰áڶƽ˰ӶԷǹоҵ˰ܣӦδĲ
ڸҵڲա˰ʡ˰ڼʧҵӹپҵ˰ȣѰ˰©
ĳɱԸ˰ջ걨Լ룬Ӷ˰˰վͻӦӡ
    ոڣ19991103
α༭侩
οס
    [1]Martin Feldstein.American Economic Policy in 1980sM.Chicago:The University of Chicago Press,1994.
    [2]Robert W. Hahn.Policy  Watch Government Analysis ofthe Benefits and Costs of RegulationJ.Journal of  Economic
Perspectives,Volume 12,Number 4,Fall 1998,201210.
    [3]ߺҵ׷.ִѧM.ÿѧ磬1998.
    
    
    
 
