 ׺ 2-1562
ԭĳƾо
ԭ
ԭںš200007
ԭҳš1117
  šF11
  ۾ѧ
ӡںš200009
    ƶȾѧ
Ӣı⡿On the Methodology of Institutional Economics
    HOU Rong-hua
    School of Management,Shanghai Maritime University,Shanghai, China, 200135
    ٻ
߼顿ٻϺѧԺ  ѧԺϺ  200135
    ٻ1963УϺˣϺѧԺѧԺڣϺƾѧѧԺʿ
ҪĶƶȾѧоһȫƶȾѧĹ۵㣬ϰߺ͹ƶȷʮҪָ
ȾѧֻǶԵط⣬ͬھ÷ʹö»ϸסâ˹ƶȾѧеĺķ롪
ϰߺƶȣָǰʮʱֵƶȾѧдĳЩ⣬ӦԾƶȾѧߵ˼߼ϡ˵ھ÷ϰ
ߺ͹ڣƶȾѧڴ֮ʱнϴͨԣ¹ŵ侭ѧȶΪƶȾѧ
ӢժҪThis paper gives a complete and detailed description of  theapproach of  institutional  economics. Habits  and  
rules  areessential   in    institutional    analyses    according    toinstitutional economics. Tt is pointed out that  ins
titutionaleconomics  analyses  qualitatively   and   uses   quantitativetechniques as well. The paper then defines the  core
  conceptsof habits  and  institutions  in  the  theory  of  Veblen  andCommon's old institutional economics,   shows  that 
 there arecertain defects in the new institutional economics, and arguesthat there should be some reconcilation between the 
two  underthe guidance of the old institutionalist' ideas.   Finally thepaper shows that habits and rules  are  ubiquitous  
whether ornot (bounded) optimization is possible and  further  indicatesthat at its foundations, institutional economics  ha
s  greatergenerality  and  encompasses  neoclassical  economics   as   aspecial case.
  ʡƶȾѧ//ϰ/ƶ
    institutional economics/methodology/habit/institution
    
    ͼţF019.349  ױʶ룺A  ±ţ1001 9952200007001107
    ĿǰƶȾѧnew  institutional economicsʷǳʱ֡¡ʱݴʰѶսһ׹ƶȾ
ѧۡ뷲סâ˹ġƶȾѧ   oldinstitutional economics֣עУ ƶȾѧ
ӡ¡ָ֣סâ˹ͳµƶȾѧ
    ΪƶȾѧϽԵġ۵ġֹ۵㾭ϸáڷ׺Ϳâ˹зǳǿ
͡۷չҪԺԣǶоһЩҪ⡣磬ף18991919ǵһλôĽо
úƶݽ۵ѧҡƶȾѧҲչ˲ȫгеĶΪۡǻۼӦþѧ
֡ɡƶȾѧ۵Ӱ졣
    ϰ룬ɡƶȾѧΪṩһȫͬĹ۵㣬ϰߺ͹ΪΪ衣Ϊϰ
֧Ĺ۵ѧֵ֧֣þѧҽһоƶȾѧĹ۵㣬ϰƶȷмҪͨ÷ںۺ΢
еӦþ˵ΪϰߵҪԡ
            һƶȾѧľ÷
    ƶȾѧķǴйΪƶȼùݽʵձ۵㵽⾭ƶȻ򾭼͵ľ۵㼰ۣˣַ
вΡ𣬵ͬεķϰߺƶ루ڵڶж壩ձ֮˹ؼϵ
áƶȾѧƶΪϰΪĹ۵㱾γɿɲۻƶȾѧһҪ˵һضĹͬϰ
ԴضƶȲǿġˣƶȾѧоǴӳ󵽾塣û˵ı׼ģ͡ƶȾѧ
о˵ΪʱȡѧѧѧѧƵĳɹ˵ƶȾѧۣͨǾָζԾ
ۡ
        1.ʾ۸γ
    ̷׶ԾƶȾѧ߶Ъ¹ŵ۸۵Ŀһ¡һ㲻Ծ˵ļ裬
Ъ۸Ҳȫ̷񶨡ƶȾѧһΪҪоӳƶȼгṹľĶۣͨü۸۵Ľ
оԣΪʵм۸γɵƶȹ̲ͬƶȾѧΪ۸ᴫͳõϰߵǿǶضƶСִ
ͳƷࡢƶȡ㷽Ͷ۹̵Ĳͬͬ
    ۸ǴͳܹϰߵӰ졣۸۱ضֵһֹԤڡϰ߼ƶȵۣǶ۵ĳ漰̣û
۾޷μγɶδԤڡ20ͳ50ƶȾѧ߰һ˼·йؼ۸γɵĴԼ۹
Ӧʵгṹ˾֯͵ļ۸ۡ磬Թͷ¢гӳɡȫɱۡ
Ⱦѧ߷ǳǿоʵ۸۵ȣֻΪͨü۸ʵԡޡ
    ƶȾѧĶȷ۸γйصƶأɱ۸ĳ桢֪в˽Ϣ
Ϣȡʹ÷۸ķйؾԶ۵սԼгṹϵķ
    Ȼָһ󼰼򻯵Ḷ́ϸ飬ɳ۸γɵĳЩؼ̡׶˹ΤMeans and Ware
1936ַӦڡ۸񡱵һӡ
        2.ϰ֣۾ѧ
    ʹں۾òΣྭҲϰ߻ۡ磬ܷ׵Ӱ죬ղķ˹ɭ1949Ѻǳǿ
ΪϰߵãܺõԤ⡣һ趨ȶˮƽеķɵΪϰ߶ʽΪ
ģԺӦԣҲϰ߻
    һأƶȾѧо۾ϵͳʱȷ˵Ϊʽ͹ԣڷִģ¡ԡۻԭϵͳˮƽ
ϵĹԺȶ΢ˮƽĶԡƶȾѧֹ۵۾õɣɼӦ˵ƶȾѧ
һشף202030ҾоΪ׵һѧҶԷչҪã
Ϊĺ۾ġԵĺԡ۽ȻͬΪ˹˿ռ䡣
    ƶһĳ̶ֳȵĳڲ䣬ʱɳˣˣѡƶȶǸΪλƶȱ֮ص
ȴڡǶһƶȵУữмڴˣƶȾѧרעضƶȵľʣйظ˵
ʷͨģ͡
    ƶȾѧԸġƶӰĸΪ۷λ۵㣨»Ҫ׼΢ۻ
ζƶȾѧ޷ģͻԤ⡣෴ӵо֤йԣϰ߽ͣصģǺ۾
õԤģͣѧõļƷԺ۾״Ԥȸӵľģ͸ѡƶȾѧΪ֤ϰߡƶ
ǿ
    ƶȾѧӺ۾ϵͳĶʽʵstylized factsͼҳϵͳڽṹصԽЩҪ
ַ磬ҹٶȷһʵҲܽʾһʽʵйѶGNPĹױԽС ƶȾ
ѧ˵ܽͳطҪǽѺ;ٶȷƶԼ̡
    裬ԤĽͺԤ֧ѵԡĵһռδԤݣǶ
ϿľýƵıȽойر֮ͳص֤ݽҪģƶȾѧǿҪ̽ڵϵ
ˣҪҪԤѲٶȼƣͿɰأĻϵȵȡܵ˵
ȷѰϵʱĳۻ裬ǿȽƶȷҪԡ
        3.ƶȾѧ
    ˵⡣ΪһƶȾѧǿûеƶȺĻأڶн
ѧѧѧѧĹ۵㣻ûнԵġЧ󻯵ľģͣ԰̬ǿϰƣǿ
ĪĿԣģѧͳƷǾ۵ĹߣҪأ壬ǴӽѧģͿʼǴӶʽʵй
Ƶۼ迪ʼ㷺ʹйᾭƶȵʷĺͱȽϵľԲϡԿƶȾѧ뵱ĳ
Щ졣
    ȻⲢζƶȾѧռݡûۣͽ͡ݹɲۣоԷƶһ׸
ӶʽʵҪһܡƶȾѧͼһܵۺͷṩܡ
            ƶȾѧ۵һЩص
        1.¡ɡƶȾѧĶԱ
    Ҫָɡ¡ƶȵĻ첢ףΪ¡ƶȾѧЩݲ޶ۡˣƶȾѧ
ŵ˼1981˹ɣPosner1973˹أSchotter1981ķѷWilliamson1975йͬۺġ
    ƶȾѧΪģƶȣһҵĳ֣˵ĻЩĽһ
ȵĳʼȻ״̬͵ĹǴ˵ƶȣΪơ۸壨methodological individualism
    磬¡ƶȾѧΪΪһƶ˵ĽȻһУͷƶǿѭ
̣Ϊ˿˷ʵｻ׵ѣǷ˻ңҺܷ㣬Ϊѡ
    롰¡ƶȾѧͬӷסâ˹׵¶Ӷ˹ġɡƶȾѧΪھ÷˲Ϊ
ܹ㷺ʹøƫúˣ˵Ļγƶȣͬʱ˵ĿĻƫҲᾭ״Ӱ졣ͻҲ
ˡ
    ׼Ի֡¡ɡƶȾѧȻ¡ƶȾѧӪڲۡŲһ¡¡ƶȾѧ
ƶȡȻ״̬еĸġмƶȾѧλڡɡƶȾѧ֮Ľ
ġ
    ȵѧƺΪ˲ӦΪԼɪ˹ٸģStiglitz1994˵ԵĳЩԴϵ
ͳͳΪԲȻǴġ
        2.Ϊϰ
    ƶȾѧ߰ϰΪĻϰ߿ɶΪزǰΪʽϰڲظ³ֵһ
άֵΪʽྭѧҶϰߡȻѧһΪϰѡĽΪ޾
ֶΡˣǵһλġ෴ƶȾѧ͵ķǴϰߵѡѡϰ߽͡ңϰߺ֪ʶ
ʵϰߵĽеĹƫúԼ㷽ʽͨϰĻöǶԻӦ
    էһַУϰ߿ΪѡĻ˵ѡϰߡǣƶȾѧǺѡۼ
һ͡ѧ˵˵ϰƺԸѡȻΪ˵ɸݹ̶ƫú
׷ЧñҲԸѡƫ֧䣬ͳ˻Чúūһ̨ˣڲƳ
ƫãȷԻﲻѡ
        3.ϰߵƶ
    ףVeblen1919ƶµĶǣ˵˼ϰߡһΪƶһеġ־õ˼жʽֲ
һȺ˵ϰ߻ķСڡɡƶȾѧУϰߵĸƶȶ塢˵Ϊá
    ȶԣ¡ƶȾѧƶȵĶһ㲻ϰ߸ƶȱΪΪͨùSchotter1981ǡ
Ϸ򡭹淶˼ʹϵΪԼNorth1990
    ¡ɡƶȾѧƶȵĶں൱ḻ֯繫˾кѧУϵͳڣҡ
Ժͷɡ
    ڡɡƶȾѧУϰ߸ĵλǺ͡¡ƶȾѧһؼ𡣡ɡƶȾѧΪƶȵγɺ
ϰҪϰ߹ʶһ֣֪ƶȵĽṹѧá˱Ȼ֪ܣſܽ
ѡж
    ѧõ֪ʶֵ̲ϰСϰΪһȺлһĻʱͷչΪϰףâ˹1934ˣϰߺ
̲֪ʶƶʱ䳤֪ʶĴʹ
    ͨƶ˼Ϊϰߵƶȹ淶˵Ļ˻ȡйݵ̵֪Ĺؼ֡ԱҲƶ
֧֡
    ֪ͬߡ첻ܳһӰ쵽˵Ŀƫáˣ˲ΪƶǿҪԭΪ
ģϰߵɢƶȵĳֻǿƶΪϰߣǴ³Աǿϰ߼ά˵
ΪṩϢ֪ƶ;úǿʡ
    ƶȼеġۡҪԵġ͹ۡ졣ˣϰߺƶԸڿ˷ѧʵ
ѧۣȻͬ˺͹ϵһáѭС
            ƶȣƶع
    ݸƶȵԴʹȱݺͲһԣˣӦ÷ֹ۵㣬תƶȾѧߵĸӿŵġݽ
ķ
        1.Ը˽ƶȵ
    ƶȾѧݸƶġΪ˴Ӹ˽ƶȵԴƶȾѧòһͳϽ˵
õܣκμٶƶȷԴĳʼȻ״̬УһЩԭĻ淶δûκƶصġ
Ȼ״̬衣
    磬ķѷҵ׳ɱȡгΪʼȻ״̬гһʼСWilliamson1975ķص㡣
˿ʼҵ͵ȼǵĽ׳ɱϵͣͻȥ
    Ȼй50徭ƶȸĸݽʵȻƶȾѧһ˼ά·гһƶȡг
׼ϰסϵʱΪ֯Ϣ磬ЩҪ͡ر˽˲ƲҪ͡гƶȵĳʼ
ΪѰڲƲ    гԭʼƶȵȻ״̬  ķѷWilliamson1983Ϊ˽˲Ʋɲڡ˽򡱣ûй
ҷɻԤĸ˶Ը˵Ľס
    ǣΪʹûйң˻Ҫϰס׼ԽнҪԱһƶȡ˽˲ƲȷҪʹ
ĳֹͬĸ׼нʹЩвڣƶȴǱزٵġ
        2.ме
    ѾָƶȲܲڲκƶӰȺƶӰ첢ԼˡˣҪƶȣƶҪ漰Ŀĵˣ
˵ĿҪӦƶȵȵȡȻڡмеع飬ַûоͷȻһ
ѭƶȺвͬص㣺ǵĻƲͬĿĵģƶûУƶȺ˵ͬʱȥƶ
̴棻ؼǣÿһƶȵУӰ죬ʹЩƶ첢ɸı䡣
        3.ݽ۽ƶȱǨ
    2080ѧгݽ˼ƽģʽڼûд𰸣Ȿı䣬ⲻӦǡ
ʲôǡʲô̽ߵķչζŴԾ̬תһָӿšչķܡһЩġ¡ƶȾѧ
ĳ̶ֳת򡰾ɡƶȾѧݽġŵĹ۵㣬ڹҮˣHayek1988ŵ˼North1990Ľѷǳԡ
    ݽ۵ĽͺѰҴֹǨ̵ۡVeblen1919Ը˽ƶȵ
Ŭζŷ۽ͣǰ֯ƶȵԴͷչһݽĹ̡
            ġϰߺ͹ıҪ
    ѧ׷Ч󻯵˵Ĺ۵ʹõϰߺ͹򣬴ΪĽͣɫϰߣƺ
԰Ч󻯵ĿСƶȾѧΪϰߵĽְһеΪǻرϰߺ͹ظʹ
ϰߺ͹ʹõľ⡣ʹŻ⣬ҲҪչѧܺԵ⡣ضϰߺ
򣨰г˵׬ǮԣӦھѧĺġ
    ʶʶزõġĻ˼ΪʽһʽǣX£Yϰʲͬ
ѭܾ˼ǣϰΪصδ飻һԶãͨظӦãɳΪϰߣƻ򳣱ȸıϰ
ףΪǶԼϰߵʶǲȫģڴҼȻϰߺ͹ͬһʽX£Y
Ϊ֮
    ƶȾѧΪⲻøʻŻҪԺ͹򣻼ʹŵľ⣬Ҳй
        1.Ż͹
    ЩŽ⡣磬Թ滮΢ַϸŻŻǰ򣺼ŻĹ
˵ڶҪ⣺ǴӺζȻŽⱾܽ͹ԴŽڵغйˣ˵Ż
ΪеĹѭǴġǱŽ̽ѰԭʼԴ
    ҲƾֱŻˡЩҲܻͬʽϰߣX£YͬЩϰߵγɲܽŽ͡
    ϰ߻ŻķΧˣŻȫ˵Ϊƶȡ
    ԣ¹ŵ侭ѧɿǳϰߺ͹ڵġɡƶȾѧͽӵġ۵ġռݵ෴
Ⱦѧдﵽ۾ǱأWinter1971Ϊ¹ŵ侭ѧΪѧǿԽһ˵Ϊѧ
ŵ侭ѧƶȾѧƶȾѧ֮ʱнϴͨԡ
         2.ϰߺ͹
    ڷŻľ£ȷԾߣϰߺ͹øҪЩֻԼ򵥵Ĳ;߹
    ߹չҲϰߡҵŻʱҲϰߣ߼ЧԭҪϰ߲ʵ֡ƶȾѧԭϰ߱λ
ĽѡζƶȾѧͨԽǿ
    ʵе˲̿ҵU ͵ҵšʹϢȷӵŻҲвͼѡ
е˹ϵͳҲҪֲ빹ܳϢ
    ոڣ20000320
οס
    [1].н׼ۣM.ӡݣ1981.
    [2]â˹.ƶȾѧM.ӡݣ1987.
    [3]ŵ˼.ʷеĽṹǨM.ϺϺ꣬1994.
    [4]Hayek, Friedrich A. Von, The Fatal Conceit: The  Errorsof SocialismM.The  collected  works  of  Friedrich  August
Hayek, Routledge, London, 1988.
    [5]Hodgson, Geoffrey M. Economics and Evolution:  BringingLife Back into EconomicsM.Polity Press, Anbor, MI.1993.
    [6]North, Douglass C. Institutions,  Institutional  Changeand Economic PerformanceM.Cambridge  U. Press,   Cambridge
,1990.
    [7]Posmer, Richard A.  Economic  Analysis  of  Law M .Little, Brown, Boston, 1973.
    [8]Schotter,   Andrew.   The  Economic  Theory  of  SocialInstitutionsM.Cambridge U.Press, Cambridge and  New  York,
1981.
    [9]Stiglitz, Joseph E. Whither Socialism?M.MIT press,Cambridge, MA. 1994.
    [10]Veblen Thorstein B. The Place  of  Science  in  ModernCivilization and Other EssaysM.Huebsch, New York,1919.
    
    
    
 
