 ׺ 2-34
ԭĳо
ԭ
ԭںš200007
ԭҳš1623
  šF10
  񾭼ù
ӡںš200011
    ۹оñص
    ƽ
߼顿ƽ  ѧйо  100871
Ҫɱ״ҵĿ꺯ı仯ڹоûҵڲҵеıصӰ졣Ĺ
һḣĿҵеȨˮƽq׶ιŵʲĵĻϹͷģͣڵȱ߼ʳɱ
Եг󷴺£ҵĿ꺯ı仯˽ҵڹоԵλЧӦ֤¹оڹ
еıز㡣
  ʡҵ/Ϲͷ/ḣ/ת
    
    һ
    йøĸУҵľ÷չٶȴҵ˽ҵʶʵ˽ҵľ÷չٶȣйҵ
ҵĲֵڹҵֵܲеı½͹ʵȻ۹ߵĹעⷽ۾˵ࣺһ
ڹ淶ѧķΧҵʲôǱҪģдڵıҪôʲôĲҵбڣ
ʲôڶʵ֤ѧķΧ͹Ϲҵеģҵڹ񾭼лһʲôĵ
λҵĲֵĳһҵеıջһʲôľֵǷвҵйҵֵıض½½ή
һʲôľֵþֵǷΪ㣿ʲô£˽ҵʱҵֵԱػἱ½ʲô
£ҵĳҵеƻԱ֣󣬴Ŀ꣨Ϊ޶ȵȫԱĸڹ
о˽˾áʡ£Ϊ˱ֹҵĲֵԱʣоóɷݾռƱǺʵģоõġ
λӦȷǷһͬ"50%"ϣ
    ĵдͼϻش⡣ƲҴά徭õȶʵֿһ㿼ǣĽ
ǴӾõ˾ΪķϿ죬ҵһĿ꺯ѭԼŽʱоõԱ
ʲôľֵǴһϣ۵ĹҵоõԱأؾģоõԱֵǹ
ҵžǹҵžߵĻ̵һ⡣ͼ۵ǣڲͬɱгظ
ʱľܾʽֵǵҪʾǣҵоõԱʵҵ
Ŀ꺯йأ˵ڹҵĿ꺯ġ80ڿʼĽ10оԵλ½˽ҵй
Ҳ൱̶ҵıĿ꺯йϵ˵оõλ½ǹҵԼҵġ
    ۵Ķɹ漤ġ(2000)֤۷ǹоڿʼʱôСֻҪЧʼ
ȹвŸߣJ[,t]ΪоеıأʱtСtʱJ[,t]0ȻͬһƪУҲָ
J[,t]ʵвһ0һȽСľֵ⣺һJ[,t]Ƿһ㣿J[,t]
һľֵôδ̻ƣ
    ڹľѧ2080ڹоڻϾеԵλвۡĵ۳P.BeatoA.M
as-colell(1984)ģ͡һĹŵ˫ͷͷģͣڱ߼ʳɱMCΪΪһԺp=a-bxpΪ۸xΪ
a>0,b>0ļٶ£ѹҵΪһ˹˲(Stackelberg)쵼ߣָҵʲ㣬ǹҵ
ǻḣġ1989꣬G.DefrajaF.Delbonoڡţ򾭼Ļ㡷ϷģBeato-Mas-CollelĻ˶γɱ
Ƚ˹ҵл˽еĲͬгṹӰ졣ʵϸһڹҵǹҵ˫ͷ
ĵĻϹͷģ͡C.Fershtman(1990)һӪҵ򲿷ֹлҵһ˽ҵ˫ͷĵģͣģʵ
˹гɷΪһƱԡ۵ĻϣK.Basu(1993)˻Ϲͷģ͵Ҫ۵㡣1989-1991
˹ٴѧϵĽ˼һֱ˼ϡ
    ׵ĻϣȿҵĿ꺯ΪһƷǹҵֶζõġɴ˼
ҵĿ꺯˱䶯ʱ˷ǹҵĽģˣҵǷӦڣоǷӦƣ
ľѧ֤ӦǷӦ׷޶ȵȫһĿ֤ȥѰҡһĿ൱̶Ӧ֣
ڵȱ߼ʳɱ£ҵͲҵԵλأҲ㡣ΣչFershtmanģ֤ͣ
׷󼫴󻯵Ĺҵ˫ͷģʲǻعڴͳĹҵƵġˣֻ͹ҵڲ
ʽתĸǲг·ġǱĵһҪסĵĵǣͼҵĿ꺯ҵгݶ(S)
ϵ˫ͷģнsлĿеȨ֮ĺϵ
    Ļһ־̬ڼгǰ£һͬʱĹŵģ۹ҵ˽ҵ
ṹķڶ̬Ҳģָ˹оԵλĶ̬ģӦߵ˵ľ
̡
    ڶרŷ׷ḣҵɵһԣʵǶԹоñҪԵ֤
ڸֲ׷Ĺҵ˫ͷͷĵģͣƵ߷зֵۣ⣩ڵĽڣܽ᱾Ĳ
ߺ塣
    ḣҵоãڵıҪ
    ǵ۴ӹҵĿ꺯ҵȻȨĿ꺯ȻҲӦĿ꺯Ŀ꺯Ƕ
άģֻܾÿһ۵ĳһάĿꡣµУڲϵĽɫ뾭õûʲô
ҵĿ꣬ҲڶλҵʱĿ꣬Ӧ˽ҵNiskanen(1975),Bos(1988)
,DelbonoDe  Fraja(1987),Rees(1988)ļٶΪҵ׷ḣ󻯵ģḣΪʣʣ
֮͡ѧ۵гйҵĿ꣬ڽйĹҵʵѴڷǹ˽ҵİΧ֮
У׷ḣʵǴͳ˵ĿһԣļٶԡȻⲢ˵
ԹҵĿ꺯Խиĸ෴һڵķ壬۹ҵĿ꺯ı仯ǱĵҪ֮㣬ң
ҵĵλҲĿ꺯ϵĸĸйصġ
    һȷҵĿ꺯Ϊ׷ḣ󻯣ͻۣһǣгΪԣ߼ʳɱΪҵ
¢ϵλ㲻ᶯҡǣڶγɱ£׷ḣ󻯵Ĺҵֹס˽ҵĽ룻
󻯵Ŀ꣬ҵڼжȸߵĲҵ㡣
    ȻڶۣȵһۣҪ΢öࡣ˵ɱ۹ҵλʱӦӵ
ۣǱ˵ķ֣ˣֻԵһҸ۵֤ͬʱͨھں
ҪйĹҵǷĳһҵ˳б
    1ĳҵı߼ʳɱһҵΪ¢ߡ
    һҵn˽ҵmҹҵгķΪ
    ͼ{ͼ}(4)ʽҵĿ꺯ΪҵĿ꺯
    £ֻӾ֤һҵھ״̬ʱȻȫn˽ҵ˳ùҵ100%ռ
гݶ
    Ĺؼ֮Ҫ֤Ϊʲôڵȱ߼ʳɱģ겻䣩£˽ҵᾺҵԭڣҪX[
*]ʹ(3)ʽ(4)ʽһ׵Ϊ㣬(3)ʽһ(4)ʽһֱΪ
    ͼ{ͼ}άг߼ۣһҵһֱӲ[,j]˽ҵĲx[,i]0˵(5)ʽʱҵб
ΪʹԳǷ(6)ʽx[*]ʹ۸ڱ߼ʳɱǹе˽ҵiֻΪ㣬ʱ
˽ҵ޷ͨıʹҵͷ˽ҵĲΨһܸıķֻǼ٣κμ˽ҵΪɹ
ҵͬȵĲǹҵP=Mͼȫˡx[,i]=0(iʣ1,2,,n)ʱ(5)ʽ(6)ʽ
ͬ˵ⶨ㡣Ӷ1
    2һҵɱΪʱʹ׷󻯣ڸҵ˽ҵ(n)ʱɶԹҵʵ
˽лҵ˽ҵ(n)Сҵдڵĺԡ
    Fraja-Delbona(1989)ļ
    ڳɱΪ
    ͼ{ͼ}
      De FrajaDelbono  1989ԭģ"Oxford Economic Papers"41(1989)306ҳ
    Ȼʵгɱ(n+1)cḣĽǶ˵һҵ˽ҵҲ󡣵ȽϽ
Ե˵ɱǶκK(>0)ôֵ۱߼ʳɱkxĵٶkΪ󣬵һҵе˽ҵѾ
ǳʱʹǴḣ󻯵Ŀֹоûҵʲôֵɣл˽лΪ
ḣǣĳҵ˽ҵĸ٣ҵĹвḣ󻯵ĿǻȫԱĸˮƽ

    ˵е⡣Ϊ˵һҵʼǹҵ¢ϣԽɹҵ¢ȥ˽ҵԽɽ룻һ
˽ҵ룬˽ҵnӣҵڵĺԾͻԽԽ㡣nwɹҵؽѡʱǻᷢ
ġǣһҵг޶ҵгģ޶ҵҵn+mܳNȻn<NN
СʱͲ֪ҵдڵıҪԡ
    ܽһһڵۣԵó½ۣ
    оûҵĳһҵĴڵĺԣڸòҵĳɱ״̬ġ߼ʳɱһģ겻䣩ҵ
ḣһĿ꺯ȫ˽ҵḣ󻯼Ŀģֳһǹҵо
Ρҵĺҵҵ(n+m)޹ءĳҵǹģݼģ߼ʳɱģҵڵĺԹƾ
׷ḣ󻯵ĿԵòˣӦһгģ޶ҵɵҵNkkΪ߼ʳɱٶȣ
NСڶγɱ£ҵھʱҲ㡣˽ҵnСʱҵǷҪḣ󻯺
ҲkֵnСNֵСľúǸҵļжȸߡ
    ˣͳ˵ҵҪӾԲҵ˳Ҫ¢Բҵﱣ֣ԵЩķ˵߼ʳɱΪ߱߼
ɱⱾ¢ϵҵڵĺȴͬӦøһӷɱ״ḣ
ԭȷҵǷչ˳ҵߵ
    ҵĿ꺯ĸıҵԵλ½ϵ
    ǰһҼٶҵĿ꺯Ϊ׷ḣ󻯡һۣҵһĿ˸ĸڹоñ
λʲôӰ죿
    ۵ʷݵġǵĹҵĸ1979ɡȨġҵٲֵ׷
󣬶ȨֻҵٲֵذгƶԷǹе˽ҵĲӦҵͻᰴݽʽ
ؽ˽ҵлϹͷĵĸ֡
    ֤ûָĸҵȻ׷׷ܸ󻯣ǹҵڵȱ߼ʳɱ±㲻

    ĳһҵֻҵڶڸгȱ߼ʳɱ(C[,i]=mx[,i],i=1,2)֪ʲʱ׷
󻯵˽ҵľΪ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    [,1]ΪҵĿ׷ḣˮƽ󻯵Ȩء
    ѹʽ(13)빫ʽ(10)ڸĸеĹҵ1һ˽ҵ2ڻϾеĲ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    [,1]=1Ͽ֪q[*,2]=0˵ҵ׷ڵȱ߼ʳɱ£ǹҵ㲻롣ǣж
3
    3ڵȱ߼ʳɱԷ£ǹҵĽһҪǣҵʼ׷
    ΪҪǣǵõз֣
    4ڵȱ߼ʳɱԷ£ҵֵ׷󼫴󻯣0<[,i]<1,i=1,2)ʲǷئ[,1]
=[,2]=1عڴͳоơ
    ҽ֤˼·ÿһҵѡ(q[,i],[,i])(i=1,2)һ׶ιŵʲģq[,i]
[,i]ľڵһ׶Σÿһҵȷ[,i](i=1,2)ֵԼڶ̶ϸݹҼƻḣ󻯵Ŀ
ƻڵڶ׶ΣȷԼŲq[,i](i=1,2)
    շɷۣ[,i]ڵһ׶ȷҵѡʲôŲһ߹лΪ([
,i],[,j])ĺ
    ͼ{ͼ}ÿҵڵһ׶εѡֵʱ跨ҳ
    ͼ{ͼ}֮ŹϵӶǿԴӦ[,i]
    ͼ{ͼ}ŵһڦ[,1][,2]֮ķӦ̣
    ͼ{ͼ}             (16)
    ӹʽ(16)پһ׶ҵڸĸУڦ[,1][,2]ĹŵʲֵȻ[*,1]=[*,2]=1Ψһ
Ĺŵʲֵ
    4ľúǷḻģÿһҵԼѡ[,i]ôһҹҵĦ[,j]ֵʱԼĦֵԽԼԽ
Ϊ[,j]ʱ[,j]Խߣζq[*,1]ֵԽҵгеķݶԽͬˣ[,i]ʵ൱˹˲е
쵼ָ꣺[,i]ֵԽ˵ҵiԽǷḣĿ꣬ĹϵԽǿ[,i]Խߣ˵ҵiԽǲں
󼫴Ŀ꣬ƺӰ졣ǣ[,i]([,i])ڸĸʵǹҵļ붯׷[*,i]Ȼ
ҵĿ֮һɿԸҵǣ׷[,i]ζгϸǿƣߦ[,i]ζĿľ룬
Ӷø֧֡Ȼ[,i]Ŀ֮ìܵģҵʵ֮ѡ񣬶״
Ҫô[,i]=0ҵ˽ҵһ׷󼫴󻯣Ҫ֧ȫѹΪۣҪôǦ[,i]=1([,j]>0)ζ
ҵiΪ㣬[,i]=1ζҵܴʽϵ֧֣[,i]=1ʾҵȻһġ˵
ÿһڸĸеĹҵ˵гԵģڵȱ߼ʳɱ״̬ôѡĿ׷
Ŀ֮ٵʧȨ(trade-off)ġ4û˽ҵ룬ûƶҵıҵĿ
ֲ꣬׷ƣв˽оãĸǲʹҵıԭģʽģʲĽط[,1]=[,2]=
1״̬˻صĸǰģʽȥҵ΢۲ϲںҲҵԡ
    5ڹҵ1ֲ׷(0<[,1]<1)ʱڵȱ߼ʳɱԵг£У(1)ǹе˽ҵ2

                            1
룻(2)ҵŦֵΪ(3)ҵڹ񾭼е
                            3
                                   q[,1]
Եλҵгݶs(=)Ǧ[,1]
                                 q[,1]+q[,2]
[,1]½ʱҵԱʣгݶԦ[,1]½ٶȵһٶ½
    
    ڶ5۵Ƿǳ򵥵ģ
    (1)ӹʽ(15)пԷ֣0<[,1]<1ʱq[,2]>0ҵ2׷󼫴󻯵˽ҵҵ1ǲ׷ֲַ
ƻĿĹҵ
(2)ڹʽ(16)Уi=1,j=2[,2]=0˽ҵֻ׷
                       1
󻯣ʱȣ[*,1]=
                       3
                1
(3)[*,1]=(14)ʽ(15)ʽгݶ
                3
      q[*,1]                            1+[,1]
s(=)Ķ壬Եõ  s=          (17)
   q[*,1]+q[*,2]                            2
         ds      1
Ȼ=ҵгݶҵıĿ꺯
      d[,1]    2
ٶһٶȶ½
    
    Ȼ[,1]ֻҵḣĿȨؿ̻¦[,1]=0ҵгݶԻ1/2ǣ[
,1]Ϊһпعҵ1Ȩеıأ߽ĳһҵеĺгɷݵҵΪһ壬òҵед˽о
óɷΪһ壬ôòҵĻϹͷľͿΪʵ֮Ĳģô[*,1]=1/3ͿԽΪںӪʵ
вȨűʣӦأS[*]=2/3൱˵Сֺڹ񾭼еԱΪ2/3ֱϵУ
ҵгݶΪ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    򵥵ļǴͳõĹйоá徭ֺڹ񾭼еԱʵӡ
һǲѷĳ֮˵ʲôǷ˵ȱ߼ʳɱļٶԵгļٶֽ׶εй
Ƿ˵оòŵĿ꺯ֵϣǷ˵оõԱʵɸ΢۾õλΪؾ
ˣ߲ҶԴ½ֻۣΪĿѰҾоԱʵľֵ
    ġ
    ҵоҹ徭еĵλҪϡʶ̬ϼ֤ҲӦӾѧϼ֤
ггģȷظ󣬹ҵ׷ʲôĿꣿҵΪԼŻ⣿
ʵǾҵλơеľνоԵλ
    Եгȱ߼ʳɱ£ҵȫ׷ḣ󻯵Ŀ[,1]=1ҵõԱز
㣬Ҹᶯҡоõ¢ϵλڶγɱ£оõıҪԽḣ󻯵Ŀ֤
Եò㡣ʱоǷҪȡгģ޶ҵļжȡҵгжѾܸߣn
Сḣ󻯳ҵдڵĺԡڵȱ߼ʳɱģ겻䣩£ḣĿڹ
ҵеȨʵϻΪǹҵĽż[,1]=1ס˽ҵ롣ǣ̫Ҳиáڷ
е˽оõĽѹƾоڲĿĲ룬0<[,i]<1ǰ60ʽĸĸ߲
оԭļƻƵģҵĸĳЩɹʹоǹоڴڸĸгиԶչһ
Ǵ0<[,1]<1Ĺҵ=0˽ҵ빲ͬõĽǡĸַ׷ḣ󻯡Ŀ꣩
šǹе˽ҵ룩ͬõĽ
    ڴڸĸеĹҵ˵ѡʲôĦֵڲ߱ĿռжȨأʵҵ
ĿΪһͷҵ֮Ϊһ֮Ȩ⣬ʵ϶ǹҵļԴȪ[,1]Ŀ꣬
Դ϶ҵֵ֧ǹҵг϶˽ҵŵһҵѡ=0ʵϱʧȥԴ
֧֣ȫ׷󼫴󻯡ҵѡ=0ʵϾͲѹҲͲȫ׷󼫴Ŀꡣھ
ĦŲq׶εĹŵʲУҵȾԼ֮Ĺϵ[*]ȻȷŵĲˮƽq[*]ɷ
ɽĦ[*]ֵڵȱ߼ʳɱ˽ҵǰ£ӦΪ[*]=0ɴѾ׷󼫴󻯵˽ҵʱ
ҵʹҪ׷漫󻯣ҲӦȫЧ˽ҵΪ>0ڹҵгݶġڵȱ߼ʳɱԵг
󷴺£˽ҵԽǰ£ƲϹҵǹеҵĲϵЧʲ첻ۣҵ
оõԱز㣬һֵ
    Ȼȫ˹оǹоڼ֯ϵĲ죬ʵйоñص½ԭ˵
ǼȫġҪҵĿĸıԹоԵλӰ죬Ҳֻھ̬ȽϾֻ̬һ֮
οס
    1 ٣2000תĶ̡̬о1ڡ
    2 Basu,K,1993,"Lectures In lndustrial Organization Theory",Blackwell.
    3 Beato,P and Mas-collel,A,1984,"The Marginal Cost Pricing as a Regulation Mechanism in Mixed Markets",in M.Marchand,P.P
estieau,and H.Tulkens(eds),"The Performance of Public Enterprises",Amsterdam:North-Holland.
    4 Bos,D.1988,"Recent Theories of Public Enterprise Economics",European Economic Review,(32)409-14.
    5 De Fraja,G.and Delbono,F,1989,"Alternative Strategies of a Public Enterprise in Oligopoly",Oxford Economic Paper,(41),
302-311.
    6 Fershtman,C.1990,"The Interdependence between Ownership Status and  Market Structurethe Case of Privatization",Econo
mica,(57),319-328.
    7 Niskanen,W.A.,1975:"Bureau Crats and Politicians",Journal of Law and Economics,(18),617-693.
    8 Rees,R.1988,"Inefficieny,Public Enterprise and Privatization",European Economic Review,(32),422-31.
 
