 ׺ 2-355
ԭĳѧҡ
ԭںš200004
  šF63
  Ͷ֤ȯ
ӡںš200010
    ҵΪʵʩܵľѧ
    
߼顿  㽭ƾѧԺ̹Ժ㽭  310012
Ҫ֤ȯгй˾ҵΪ֤ಿŵг֮乹һ̬⡣ĴӾѧĽǶȷ̽ҵ
Ϊҹ֤ȯгձڵԭΣҵΪгЧԵĶԲ뽨顣
    
    һ
    ֤ȯгй˾ҵΪѳΪձеĲΪҹ֤ȯгƽȷչһ硰
Դɶ⡱¯ΥΥ¼粻й˾ڵһ꼨š꼨ƽкܶ
Ϊʱҵװȣաֽס𡱶¶ݣй˾Ϊɴ꣬й֤涨ʸ׼ʲ(ROE
)10%ĵǷ켫쳣ֲROE[10%,11%]ڵ󳬹䣬ϵ1996-1998ȴ5-7֮䣬Զ
Զֲ̬߷ϵ3Ϊǳ͵ļⶥߣ˵ϵͳزROEķֲעROE(10%,11%)1996-199
9ȷֱΪ19.1%28.8%22.4%ͬROE(6%,10%)ıֱΪ8.4%6.8%12.9%ݾԡй֤ȯο(1)(
2)ݶķϵ=ĽĶ׼Ĵη
    ͼ{ͼ}ЩΪͶ߶й˾ášͶƱ֤ಿԼĶ౧ԹǴ𣬶֤ȯгͶ
ֵڽϴʡȻ֤ȯܻһٲ鴦ͷ֤ȯƷ桢ߵԼнİѹأ
й˾Գ̶ȲͬشҵΪ1999깫ľС¯ꡱɷݡΥΥ
ΪССĲΪδ鴦
    Ϊ˷㣬İй˾¼ƹ˾ֻΪֻͣŹ˾ͼ˾˾ҵҲΪñ
ࡣֻҲǻҪģй֤Ѿʲ10%ΪʸΨһ׼10%ΪҵϺõĹ˾ʸ
10%ҵϲĹ˾ɡ۵ҵΪָ˾ͨװѶڱ걨бҵýϺã
˾ñҵʵҵϴ󡣼˾ҵΪҲǼŹ˾Ȼ
Ҳڣ繫ڱʱҵôͶԤڵʵҵԱϡׯҡݹɼۣ缨˾ñ
顣Ϊ˷򵥣ԷӰ졣
    ӾòĵĽǶȷ̽ҵΪҹ֤ȯгձڵԭΣгܶԲߵ⡣
    ҵгܲģ
    ģͼ£עģ˼·ˡɳгģ͡lemons modelҲԭο(3)(4)
    1.˾м(G)(B)ֻͣñ(H)(L)ǹ˾ѡĽ˾ſ϶ѡñ˾ѡ
ñļȵơ˾ñҵΪ
    2.˾ҵװ֤ಿ޷ӱʶα֤ಿ˽֤ȯгϼ뼨˾ܱһľ
Ϊֱ׼гͳƣƳñļŹ˾ĸ֤ಿӵе֪ʶ
    3.֤ಿѡܣ鴦T벻ܣ鴦NֻҪȥܣ鴦ҵΪ϶ܷ֡
    4.˾֤ಿţйؼܡȣ׷棨Expected payoffҲ֧󻯵ķԵ
Ծˣ·Ŀǡ
    5.ñ˾ļֵΪV[,1]ɡŻߡܽɵȣ˾ֵ˾ҵݵĳɱΪC[,1]
֤ಿһβ鴦ƽɱΪC[,2]鴦Ϊܵļֵ뾫赥λͬΪV[,2]ûв鴦ΪʹͶ
ƭº֣֤ಿĸЧΪ-V[,3]V[,1]V[,2]V[,3]C[,1]C[,2]0V[,1]-C[,1]>0V[,2]-C[,2]>0

    6.p1-p˾ŵĸʣq1-q˾ñĸʣf1-fΪ֤ಿŲ鴦벻鴦ҵΪ
ĸʡ
    裬ģһźŴݲġ(signalling games)ͼ1ʾȡȻ˾ͣȻ˾ѡñ
򻵱֤ಿڹ۲⵽˾źšûʹñҶ˹1-ppõʣp(G/H)p(B/H)p(
H/B)p(L/B)Ȼѡж鴦벻鴦ϢԳƱڣ˾֪Լһ֤ͣಿ۵ĸʷֲ
ƹ˾ҵ񡣲˫ĵͼϱʾе1ִ˾ĵ棬2ִ֤ಿŵĵ档ּ
ۣ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    һC[,1]<V[,1]P(v[,2]+v[,3])<c[,2]вжϹһҶ˹⣺
    1.˾ѡ(H,H)ܹ˾ûñ
    2.֤ಿѡ(N,N)ѡ鴦
    3.֤ಿжϣp(G/H)=1-p,p(B/H)=p
    ֤ಿѡ鴦U[,1]=-p(G/H)C[,2]+p(B/H)(V[,2]-C[,2])ѡ񲻲鴦U[,2]=-p(B/H)V[,3]U[,2
]>U[,1]֤ಿûв鴦ѡɼܲ鴦ֻҪC[,1]<V[,1]ʱ˾ʱҵݵ涯϶ѡñ
־֤ಿŵжϣp(B/H)=p,p(G/H)=1-pϡU[,2]>U[,1]ɵóp(V[,2]+V[,3])<C[,2]
p<C[,2]/(V[,2]+V[,3])Ϊ˾ıϵ͡ҵΪձ飬һĲΪڣ֤ಿǷ
鴦ĽͼȲ󣬴Ӷ֤ಿûв鴦涯òʧʱ֤ȯгвҵΪp˾
ڣҲܵ鴦ͷϿҵΪǳɹģгȱЧԵġ
    C[,1]<V[,1]p(V[,2]+V[,3])>C[,2]ǰһʹ˾ҵݵĶһΪ˾ıϸߣ
һΪ£֤ಿǷ鴦нϴĽͼȣӶʹ֤ಿſʼв鴦Ķ֤ಿжϣ
    p(G/H)=(1-p)/1-p+pq1-pp(B/H)=pq/1-p+pqpʱ˫ڴԣ֤ಿֻѡ鴦˾ʱ
ֻѡʱһ֤ಿŵϢڷǾ·ϵĴԾҶ˹⡣ӳڿҵг֮һϲ
Ծ⣬˾ʱñʱԸq[*]1-q[*]ѡñ֤ಿԸf[*]1-f[*]ѡ鴦벻
֤q[*](1-p)C[,2]/p(V[,2]+V[,3]-C[,2]f[*](V[,1]-C[,1])/V[,1]ʱлϲԾҶ˹⡣
    ڻϲϣ֤ȯгҵΪձ飬һֲΪ鴦ܵͷһֲݳɹϿΪǲ
ɹģгǲЧʵġ
    C[,1]>V[,1]вϺ͸жϹһҶ˹⣺
    1.˾ѡ(H,L)˾ʱñʱ
    2.֤ಿѡ(N,N)ܹ˾û鴦
    3.֤ಿжϣp(G/H)=1,p(B/H)=0
    C[,1]>V[,1]ʱ˾ʱݱҵĳɱܸߣ棬ΨһѡǲݣҵõĹ˾
ļŹ˾ҵȫӳ˾ʵҵ״ͶȫԸݹ˾ҵ˾Ʊֵ֤ಿſ϶ѡ鴦
гûвΪڣгȫɹЧġ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ҵгܵĲۣõòĵĽ⣬ͼ2ʾʾҵݵĳɱC[,1]ʾ֤ಿŲ鴦Ϊ
õĽû鴦ΪܵĴ֮뼨˾ĳ˻ֱۺΪǷ鴦˾ΪõĽ֮͵ֵC[,2
]C[,1]
    (1)C[,1]<V[,1]p(V[,2]+V[,3])<C[,2]ʱܹ˾ûѡñҲܵ鴦ҵΪɹгȱ
Чԡ
    (2)C[,1]<V[,1]p(V[,2]+V[,3])>C[,2]ʱ˾ʱԸq[*]ѡñ֤ಿԸf[*]ѡ鴦Բ鴦ֲ
Ϊ(pq[*]f[*])вֲݳɹpq[*](1-f[*])鴦ޣ˾нңҵΪȻڣг
ֳܲɹЧʲ롣q[*]f[*]
    q[*](1-p)C[,2]/P(V[,2]+V[,3]-C[,2])f[*](V[,1]-C[,1])/V[,1]
    (3)C[,1]>V[,1]ʱ˾ʱñ˾ʱҵʵӳ˾Ӫҵ֤ಿŲ鴦гȫ
Ч
    ϼֲľԿҪҵΪʹгܸӳɹЧӦʹC[,1]߻V[,1]ֱͣC[,1]>V[
,1]ӦV[,2]V[,3]򽵵C[,2]Ӧp
    V[,1]£C[,1]Ӷ˷ΪĶǿȣӳҲ֤ಿŲ鴦Ϊĳ̶ȡC[,1
]й˾ʵľгߣͶߣгߵʶԽǿ߷ԽʱC[,
1]ͻԽߡҵΪĴҲʹC[,1]ߣʧЧͬĲݳɱͨ˾ŵƵʹC[,1]
߱ÿţӶͲݶǿȣֱC[,1]>V[,1]ʱгȫЧV[,1]ζСŹ˾뼨˾
࣬Ҳ𵽽Ͳݶǿȵá
    Σй˾һļ뼨ı£V[,2]V[,3]ζżӴǷ鴦ΪĽȣӶ֤
ܵĻԣ˹˾ҵΪĳ̶ȣq[*]ֻǾֲĽгܵЧʣȴ޷ʹ
ȫɹЧģ;ֲ޸ΪΪձʱʹ֤ಿǴ𴦷иЧã֤ಿûܣ
Ϊδܵע⣬֤ಿϾְܣ޵ҲʧɴӦɵóӦ߶֤ಿŵĴϾ
ۡˣΪV[,2]V[,3]Ŀа취ӦҪV[,2]ͬʱV[,3]һˮƽ֧֡
    ֤ಿŵƽ鴦ٹܳɱC[,2]ĽҲV[,2]V[,3]ͬЧǽC[,2]C[,1]ߵ½ΪѣΪģ
Ϊ޷ӱʶͬʱϸ봦вʹ˾ݵļɴߣӶӼܲ鴦ѶɱӰ鴦Ļ
ԡΪкۼѭֻҪܣ϶ܷҪ֤ಿгܵҵ빤ġ
    Ӧй˾ҵˮƽpʹ䣬Ϊ˾ı٣ҵΪҲͲԣг
ܵȱЧҲǿԱܵġ
    뽨
    ϷԿҪҵΪʵʵܵЧԣ£ʵ֤ߴʩʵ
    1.ֻҪһļ˾ڣҵΪڶдڣڳҲܴڶҾȶԡ֤ȯгҲͬ
ˣ̶ֻȲͬѡ֤ಿнصԶ볤ʵкüְ
    2.֤ಿżйػҪмְ𣬼ǿһ߼ְܺͶ߽гʶ߷棬
鴦ͷΪϸ¡ͬʱʹɡƶȡִ⳥ŵʵšУȡЧҵΪ
ǿ֤ȯгСͶߵͶġ
    3.ǿй˾нɣй˾Ϣ¶͸ȣɿǽɶ⳥ƶȺͳŵƶȣ˾¶Ϣ
δʱ¶ҪϢ¹ɶģӦɸù˾䶭³е⳥ΣעʦΥйطٱ¹ɶ
ģӦɸûʦʦе⳥Ρ
    4.ڳʹҵΪʱֻӶй˾ĳͷӶ֤ಿżйػʧְΪĴЧޡֻҪϳҵ
ദܲšԼʧְߡִͨߣͬʱмְԱҪĽ
;֧֣ʹ֤ಿĺȥ鴦ܣҵΪŻ
    5.й˾ҵˮƽ֤ȯгڡƽȡչĸֻܴϳڽҵΪ
̶ȡͬʱֽ׶й˾ҵǺ롢Ź˾Ǻܸߵ£ԼŹ˾뼨˾ֲ߽Ҫ־
Ի󻯣ҪӦгֵֽŷӡ
α༭
 
