 ׺ 2-702
ԭĳ
ԭ
ԭںš200003
ԭҳš6474
  šF13
  徭ʵ
ӡںš200012
    г徭Чϵͳ̽
Ӣı⡿A Systematic Analysis of the Economic Efficiency  Theory  ofWestern Market Socialism
    Jiang Hui
    (Chinese Academy of Social Science, Institute for  MarxismLeninism Study, Beijing 100732)
    
߼顿ԣйѧԺ  100732
    ԣ1969ꡪУ壬ˣʿоԱҪ¹ۺ˼о
ҪЧгĻݣΪ幫ƾñ绤֧һݵĲͳ̶Σ
г۽ĵλͼֵĵһ̽г߶202030ôսǱ̽
ĳм̣ҪǾüලҵ⣻ڶֽΪϸֺ̽ͷ˵гµʱ¶Գм
ĳԽ𣬸ֵģʽԵʾΪҹгƵȷṩ
ӢժҪEconomic Efficiency Theory is  the  fundamental  constituentof the western Market Socialism,and is the vital arg
ument  forthe public ownership of socialism.In the first  part  of  thispaper,it  explores  the  important  issues  inherite
d  by  thewestern market socialism from the economic calculation  debatein 1920s and 1930s of the 20th century,especially  t
he  issuesof  economic  incentives, supervision  and  the  role  of  theentrepreneur. In  the  second  part, it   will   ana
lyze   thetheoretical efforts of western market socialists to solve  theabove  issues  under  the  new  circumstances  and  
in  detailsummarize and evaluate the  four  typical  models  of  westernmarket  socialisrn. Finally, the  author  puts  forw
ard   someinspirational points for the Chinese socialist market economy.
  ʡг//Ч/ģʽ
    Market  Socialism / Public Ownership/Economic  Efficiency/Models
    
    ͼšD07F019ױʶ롿A ±š1001 5574200003006411
    г202030ʱѧ緢һԶĹ徭üĴս̽
ַΧ֮㣬֮Ҫ۳̶֮ңΪ׷ͷ˼ⳡսʱǨʱ淶Ժʵ
֤Ե⣬ʮһֱôǵ˼άЩ侭̽δڹͻ𰸡80һЩѧҺ
ѧңµỷ£ݷչ˵κ;ѧۣʱ弸ʮʵչľѵָ˹г
ۣһµķչ׶Σע½׶βı־ӢѧŵľáμA.Nove
The Economics of Feasible Socialism,London 1983 ôʮǰ幫ƾЧʵıЩľ
أһгڻӦսĹЩ۽أǴ֮̽ӦЩʾǶг
ýʾͽأͼ⼸һЩԵֺ̽ͷ
            һгм̵̽ٵս
    Ĳٹʮǰ˫ݵĹ̺ҪＰ۵㣬ΪѾΪ֪ǿԽۺʵ
չΪ֪ĲϺʵ½⣬ҵгⳡ֮Լ͹ϵĲ֮ͬ
⵱г۷չҪǰᡣ
    һڶԾЧʺгõⷽ棬µѧɴսȫģ  ڼ㣨calculation ܡ  
motivationܺͷ֣discovery صķ˵гھûеۺáΪ֧
һ¹ŵ侭ѧڽΪɹػش˼⣬ڼͷϲδɹӦսΪг
һӵ̽ռ䡣
    2030ıҪΧܷкԴչģҲ˵ҪΧƾüеġ1920꣬µ
ѧ·άϣ롤˹ġ干ͬľü㡷һģˡ˹۾ݡMises's argumentüֻ
˽ΪгвǿܵģֻȷƷͷĽֵΪṩҪԼ۸ʽֳ
ϢǵľûȱҪгȫƵļƻ޷ͨƷĽϵγɼ۸
Ϣܽкľü㡣Ӧս¹ŵ߶ۺͱ߼Чüֵۣáѧ͡
֤ڼȶĸ˵£ƻȫͨʽʽη̣ȷϵľ
ͿԴﵽʱͬľԴЧʡʹġԴ
    Ϊ¹ŵŵѧʽ߼ƵΪɹػӦ˹ڼսҪֹҮ
ҲϣƻܹѼ󲿷ֱҪϢܹʱЧȷҪؼ۸£˵Ľǳ
ġִľ̬۷ʺʵ磺Ʒԡԣ۸ĳ仯ʹƻ
ʵи޷ȷ׼ȷļ۸ϢҪǣûҵг룬ûļ۸ҵҾȱ㹻Ķȥ
ԼɱҮ˾Ѿǿصϼ۸ĺ⣬תʵегþ֪ʶϢ
֯ϱ仯Ҫص⣬Ǳûܹشļͷ⡣עǲҲ漰˼⣬
ҵ׷ΪĿ꣬ƽɱСҪϽֻǱؽƻṩļٶ۸Ϣ
µѧгϵҵǲͬġδش⡣
    ʵϣ˹˾Ѿս⡢ĺͽȡ⣨⣩Ϣ⣨⣩ֻ
м̽˼⣨עϸMises   EconomicCalculation in the Socialist Commonwealth1920in   Hayek 
Collectivist Economic PlanningLondon,1935 Ƕгܵ⡣ҮǻͬӦģʽ
ʵǿơƺ;ЧʵĹϵܳɹػش⣬ûӦս
    ڵʱʱ崦ھΣʱڣʺܸߣߵĶԱʹµѧɴڲλҲûеõ
㹻ӡֱ80°µѧɲ⣬ͷתΪίСҵ⡣һгھЧ
ͼ⡣г峫P.K.͵ºͽڹŵгģʽУڼ۸źָ׷
󻯵Ĺҵܹġ¾геԴáûлشھߵļͳͷĹؼ⣬رǣ
µѧǿģڹڸΪЧ֪ʶṹڲϱ仯£ҵҵġֹ̡⡣[1] ĬҲϣ
ʱгΪҵҴҵṩˡͶʾмԼЩؼǸ߶ȼȨĹ
Ȳܲġ[2]
    ɼгҪشĲǼ⣬Ǽͷ⣬2030гǰû
й漰򵥿һʱڵ񻷾³ֵģԼгڻӦ°µѧս
ЩѺͻ
    ίС⣨the PrincipalAgent Problem
    ίСʽʼ2080һЩѧ¹ŵ侭ѧڶҵ⣨motivation incen
tive problem˼ ʱг°µѧɺսг߾ùίС
۷ͼҵӦս;Ĭʱִʶʾδһ;ҵһί
ϵŦᡣ[3] μҵľ׷ҵ󻯣ʹҵΪḷ̌Ϊг徭
ش⡣2030еļµ֡
    ֮ίСǣһˡagent 䡰ίˡprincipalйӪͬʱñꡣ 
һҵľԱί˿ǹɶңȻϸϽǡᡱίߵĴڲȫ
Ϣ£ί˲ӵд˿õȫϢί˲ܱ֤ЧشԼйӪ˿ϢĲ
ȷ׷Լ棬Ͳ˼ල⡣ԣг徭Ҳ⡣ڹһ벻ȫල
ҵӪ¾ҪǼ⡣ؼڹҺԼҵ֮ƶһ˵ԼϵΪҵһ
ҵ׷ͬʱҲ޶ȵΪᾭЧס
    °µѧɳϮǰĹ۵㣬Ϊȱʱȫ˽ƺȫ£Ƶ徭òܺܺõؽһ
ĹҮ˾֤һ⣬ѧҿƶɹȥгΪгߣ
Ϊ塰ԤԼ£ȫҵίС⡣ ע°µѧɺⷽĹ۵㣬 ɲμF.
Hayek,The Fatal Conceit,London:Routledge and Kegan Paul,1990;J. Kornai, The Road to a Free Economy, New York: W. W.   Norton
& Company,1990
    սг߳ĴڣָʱҲͬ⡣͵ºΪ
߹ʱڵĹ˾ʱ壬Ϊǰȷʵڴ⣬ںߣߺ͹߷£ҵͬ
Ҳпܲ׷ߣɶ¶׷Լ棬Ϊί˵Ĵ󲿷ֹɶڼûҲûжලҵ
ߣμලҲͬڡҵһȻÿеʵϲκˣΪû˳еΣһɳǧ
ϰͶеʱҵҲѱ֤γеšȻԤۺ֢[4] ʱܹ
⣬гҲܹʱ徭УһܵĽͨнڻӻãලɶ
гΪг徭ҲԽӦĽнƽ⡣˶ַЧʵ
ֹҵļͼලٱͬʱһľЧʣڼּලģʽĵڶ֣
    Ϣּҵ⡣
    ʵϳ¹ŵѧɵķʽΪµѧսеʶۺͷ˵¹ŵ侭ѧɽϢ
ǿ͹۵ġȫġȶģѧоʹȶԴ󻯡µѧΪΪҪԲȡ
жġ֪ʶ۵ġصġɢĺͲȫģκ뵱ֶ޷ѼԴ֪ʶֻͨҵҵΪѼ
ЭЩȫĺ໥ì֪ܵʶҵΪ֪ʶķֺ̡ͲŻüпԴ⣬
Ż֪ʶ⣬ֶΡĿĹϵעģҪгĴΪµѧɵʶ˵
徭ⲢΪ⣬뻯߶˹ʵеļúŵѧʽ⣬ڸӵ
׼ȷػñҪϢԳõĶ̡̬
    2030ĴУµѧɲǿͼ⣬УϢҵĹעԶ׼ģ
עⷽݿԲF. Hayek, the  Uses  of   Knowledge   inSociety, 1945,in Hayek,Individualism and Economic Order,London
,1949ȻϢķֹģ 80ִµѧµıвġ羭ѧD.άһ
ֱ²˰µѧⷽĹ۵㡣Ϊгֹ֪̾ԶԻһڱ̡ҵ˽
˶ļ£Ŭȥÿܵ󣬵Ϊʵһ㣬Լķɢ֪ʶȥ»᣺òҪǼ
ȥȷ飬Ǽͨ໥ȥʲôӦȷ顣[5]˽ȨյҵҵŬ ΪҪ
ϢֵıҪг̵ķ֡ܲµѧɺ¹ŵѧִµѧɵ
ս¹ŵ侭ѧڵг壬ͬ¹ŵƻģʽһǲܵģҲǲģΪЧϢֺЭ
Ҫһ˽Ϊг̡
    տƶڵĹ۵㣬˽ȫصõţ˽Ȩҵҷõľǰᡣ
޶ҵҵĸҿҵҡһʵʹӦñϸơûһʹùʱùҸ߶ܹʤθ
ƺšҵЩֻЩԸðԼʱ֮յˡ[6]һ׼ Źƺгϵĵг
̸ҵҵķˡִµѧĳӮʤ
    µϾսг߻ܹҵֵͲȫ֮һֻ˽ҵԼʱ
ʱΪԼʱִµѧɵĹ۵塣ڵ˾ʱȨ͹Ȩ£ûʵֵʱ
ҲͬŽҵҵϢ⡣֪ʶĲȫԴ棺һԴ֪ʶԺԣгԭ
ʽġִµѧǿֺЭ֪ʶĹҪгжųЭĿԣ޷
ڶϢȫ⡣
    ɼִгһܺͳ˰µѧϢúҵҷ⣬һֽʾ˰µѧ۵Ĳ
ȫԣԴΪԼ۵ķչ㡣ͨǻҪһ⣬ִг߻볬ǰ¹ŵ䷽Χһ
Щִг峫Ŭ
            гµĻ¶ĳԽ
    ǴǰķпгҪȻشȻǡƾܷʵ־Чʡ⣬̽
ᱳʱۻ202030ǰȻͬˣĹȺҲͬնǵ
ľüܰݵġ2030ǰ徭õľʱΣγǿҶԱȣг
ĹƵλԹҮΪİµѧɴơ8090ǡǡתǰͶŷ徭÷չͣ
ͺͱƺгвͨġִµѧɺ崦ڹƣִгƺͱ绤ĵ
λ
    ۻʵ鷽濴ִ۵ķչȶгսͬʱΪṩ˽»
·ǽǰͶŷʧܵĽѵִʱ徭еʵϣŬѰԼ۷չͻӦսֶ
ǼҪ˷ǰ¹ŵ䷽۲㣬ҪڻӦսĻʹг۷չ½׶Ρ
    棬ǽΪطһµгνм̵⡪ƾõЧġ
    Ѿں̶ܴϲٰѾЧΪ̬ļͼȶԴãעض̬ļϢּ
ʽִѧίСҵΪ⡣ȣΪЩⲻǹƾõڵģ˽Ϊ
ִʱ徭ͬ⣬ʱ徭ܹǣ幫ƾͬԽԴΪǰᣬ
˹ƾýЩļģʽ
    ִгҪĬίСϣǰúִʱ徭˶ԱȡΪģʽļȨƻ
֮ʧܣΪûнίС⣺1 ҵ˹ϵĴ⣻2 ƻߡҵϵ
Ĵ⣻3ڡƻ߹ϵĴ⡣ Ȼִʱ徭Ҳͬ⣺1 Ҳҵ͹֮
Ĺϵ⣻2ΪɶϵĴ⣻3ΪڡɶϵĴ⡣[7]ĬΪ ʵ
˽Ʊܽ⣬ƾƵõǵġתΪǷܹһ־ûƣ
ܹʵ֣ʱ䲻ᷢأ˵ûҵڲ˽Ȩ£ܷҵ֮ľأ
[8]Ĭζţ ˽ƲǽЧʺͼΨһǰᡣôִгĳƹƾ
ļලģʽҵõأĽΪͣעֻ뾭Чʺͼصƣǵг
ģʽȫݡΪϸĲҡԵġ90г۰˴ģʽԭءоϡ19
9834ڡ
    һΪĵļලģʽ
    ģʽҪѧP.͵ºģõJ.ĬӦ֧֡ҪģձսγɵĴϵkeiretsu˽˹˾ͬ
عɡΪĵĹ˾Ⱥģʽ͵ºľ巽£עϸϿɲP.   Badhan,   On  Tackling  the  Soft
Budget  Constraint in Market Socialism,  in  Market  Socialism:the Current Debate, Oxford University Press,1993 ҵΪ
УÿҵȡϹɷݹ˾ʽ˾Χһγһأ򱾴ڵĹ˾ṩʽ𣻹Ҳֱӵһ
ҵһ˾ĹƱһԼڲĹ˳У󲿷Ⱥڵҵ乤ˣͶм֧
УҵӵйƱĹжֶΣͨ侭ٴȺҵ׷󻯣һЩƱɴ⹫˾ڻ
ݻ͵طȻС
    УеĻǡίеļලߡͨԴȺڸ˾Ͷߺͽ߷ϵͨ
ҵ˾ĹƱСĳһ˾ĹƱб˾۵ԼʱоҪȡʩٺԼù
˾ĹˣҪʱ̸дͬƶȲԣͨڳϢʩҵŴȺڵҵṩ
ֵ֧ȡͨԼĿعɣڱҪʱӹܾӪҵƲɱ£Ʋҵʲ
á
    ͵º˴ȺĹģ⡣ÿȺ̫ǻеļԼͽ״ĿǣһҲ
̫СΪʹշɢͶȺģСӦʹڲҵڼЧ໥ϵĳ̶ȡ
    ڴȺڵҵҪලߵĽɫ֮ǣ˭ලලأлṩʽ𣬹ȥһ
ֱ徭ЧʵĹԤԼǲǻ·أ͵ºΪȻȫһķƵ
ලƾкķʩоɣ1 ڹҲһҵ֮һ㣬ɳֹɵġ໥ϵ
ҵͬ𣩺һɵĽලҵγ˽ԼֱӵθԤ2 о
ҲǷֹѹءоƵԭЧĴӪѵҵͶгҲͷġ3 
ȶй߱꼤ơ4ʾţ ֹмලǵɳڣͬʱҲڱ֤Ͷʾߵķλ
5ҵƲԼ6ȻֱӵеĴ󲿷ֹɷݣһЩҪɷݽݻ𡢱չ˾г
ʹеĴ漰ܵרҵԿơ
    ֮ΪĵļලģʽƣʱҵʵΪݵģпɲԺԽ֮˹ٸ
ƱʾϿɣΪпԷӱȹɶծȨ˸ΪЧĿáΪձҪƶȽӵдɷݺͿعɹ
˾ҪãԵơеĸ߸ծΪʵʩලṩ˼ҲΪеĿṩһֶΡջشв
һЧĿֶΡ[9]͵ºΪ Ѿ߱һ׹ͶкͽڻķչйңΪĵļලƲʵ
ʩΪӦǵӡ
    ģ֤ȯгΪĵļලģʽ
    ģʽJĬP͵ºͬġעڸģʽϸƿɲP.BadhanJ.Roemer,Market Socialism:A  Case  for
Rejuvenation. Journal  of Economic Perspectives(Summer) 6: 101116.J.Roemer,A Future for Socialism, Cambridge  Mass:Harvard
University Press,1994Ϊ һȱַչ֤ȯгڻδṩҪԼľУԽ
Ϊĵļලģʽ֤ȯгܹӽΪҪãľʵԹΪг壬ý֤ȯ
гΪĵļලơȻ֤ȯгʽıˣӦһģԵ֤ȯг£һǽһƾϢ
Ʊƽг깫񣬸ÿ˻ƽȵÿһģϴҵҪȨΪʵģӦͬ
ÿһͬӵͬĹнϴģҵͶϣƾǶÿһ֮ͬƽȷȨ
ͬĹƱͬҵĹƱֻƾϢƱ򡣹ӵеƾϢƱֻڹƱܶһΪֽ
ƾϢΪ֮Դ֮һƾϢƱڹҪջع⣬ΪŲǻƽȷĿ
Ĳϸƽ⣩
    ƵĿľģʵĹƱгͬʱֲʹʱȨ뼯СƾϢƱΪý飬
йƱףǲܽƱһֽֽҲܹƱ͵ºΪԱ֮ΪǾáclamshell economy 
ζţǳڽ׷ĿǣƾϢƱʵҲø滻ġģʵƱгĸ֤ȯгҪã
ͬṩʱծȯгṩҵӪ״źţҵӪ״ѣƱĹͬͳЩƱҵƱ
۸񣨵Ȼǡǡ۸񣬲ֽ۸񣩾Ҫ½ҵҪԼľӪͻᱻӹܻ򵹱աɼƾΪʵģ
ƱгҵԼá
    ƵʵɲΣʵлûʵṩ֤ǲܲڼ˹ƾõƽȺЧʷ
еĴ⡣һ棬ڿġʱ徭е֤ȯгϣͬԼලЧҲܲ
ʵĹƱгǶԾõļҲ޵ġڿģʽʱҪ壬ҪעƱгڼ
ʵЧ˹ٸ˵һЩǿƱгṩеá͵ǾͨƱȨñ
꣬ǹƱгṩϢЧ۾ҵ [10]ָԭһǹƱ۸ܶصӰ죬ЩӰ
ֻһ뾭ΪֱйأǴ˾δڹƱгУû֤˵Щ˾ھƷ治ǹƱϢ
ֻ˾жλϵľԱıйأԱļֵͨƱгֳΪ
ģ֤ȯгලģʽҪĲοֵ
    ලģʽ
    ලҵһֱΪ徭ʿڸŷ뼯Ȩõʧܣƺ֤Чԡ
ȻһЩгȴΪҵڳֵгලƣ۱׼
ԾԼֶκҵļЧƾȻܹ֤Чʡ
        ѧҡ  ʵõг塱J. ˣJ.Yunker ضΪҪලĻƣע
Jˡʵõг塱ģʽϸݣ ĽԡһʱĽ˼о19981ڡ
УһΪо֣BPO ҪһǹͶϵͳNIBSǹ
ҵͶίԱᣨNEIBڹҵල棬оֳеҪִʱҵ»һĹܣע
˵ģʽУȻⲻǹоֵΨһܣչҵϽ󡢷ˡ侭üල
ܡǣоһ֮һռҵĸͳϢڹҵӪ
ĺûԴҵ⡣оֵĵڶһɣǷɢ200300طУÿһط
1015ɡ˴Ӿ57ḻҵԱѡÿ˸ලҵ˵Ҫְ
оͼලҵӪ״ĺûܶҵоҵָͨƣԴӺϵءලͼҵ
ԭоͨġɢĵطʹԼְܡҵȨֱɹо
ʹɢĵطʹҵĳ־ĹԤһطĴְڲ
طĴϵ˸ලҵһҲûϵҵְΪϸƹоֳԱھҵ֯
ͨıΪ⣬ƶʵʩĹ淶ල˵ΪԱ֤ϸִԼְܡ
    ˵УͶϵͳҵͶίԱǹоֵĲǳеҪְܡһ棬Ǹ
ͶԤҵһ棬رҵͶίԱᣬҵҾӪҵԱ֤ô»Ʒá
棬Ǵӱ֤ҵгͶʽͷҵõĽǶȣǹоõЧġ
    ɴ˿ɼģʽУͶʡලͼ涼Ҫãбǰģʽ˵ǰģʽǶʱ
мල֤ȯгලƼģ¸ĻôģʽԽǿһǶȣľùܷ棬˵
геӵõܹ˷߶ȼȨĹҼƻõı׶ˣӶ֤ҵЧʵġǣ˵ģʽ
оϸƽ϶࣬ʵԼɲҪ֤ͻڿ룬ͬʱ˵ģʽҪһ⣬
оα֤ɱΪȨĹŻֿԼľְܺ͹ֵĸԤΪα֤ԼͶʾߵȷ׼
ȷƶҵЧı׼ȵȡЩⶼʮָӵģ񵥴򵥡
    ģƺ͡ҵҵλģʽ
    ģʽɲѧW.³˹K.˹ġġ˼гԾƵУͨ
ģʽͶŷĸ̵ķ˼̽˼ʮгʵľѵʵҾøĸӦȫ
ãȫг塱гģʽڣģʽųʱгȫг塱
ʱгͬƷͶгڵġĸĸơ[11]гϹƺȫҵԼҵ
ҵĽϡ̽˹ҵȫг롰ҵҵλܷϵ⣬ҪΧҵ۹
ƾõЧʡ
    ġҵҡ°µѧɴһ£ҵҲǾӪҵˣΪҪǾץס»ᡢ
еյˣռЭϢˡΪȥươԱҵݺ϶Ϊһ˴û
̸ҵҡҵڹأԱûλֻоӪҲƲˣ߱ҵҵĹܡ
    ʹһؼԵ⣬°µѧɵġҵҡ˽˲ȨΪģҵȫƻκйص
ƶǲݵġϹơرǹ£ҵҡδأΪ˽ìܣ³˹
˹ΪΩһֵÿǵľǷȨһԽĿ⡱ôҺҵܹȨأǸ
Ĵһǹְܵķ룬ҵ֮ķ롣
    ְܵķǡҪΪߵĹͬΪȨءԼҵŹߵĹҷ뿪[12]
ģеĸְָһֱΪǲɷָġгҪǼ뿪Ҳ˵
ΪߵĽɫҪͬΪĽɫֿΪߣΪһ־壬䷢ӵľ
úһҪѭй򣬳ʲʲ⣬ҪҵеκͲ롣ΪȨ
ҵάгҪľûȨֹЩȨá³˹Ϊַ벻ӦΪκ¶
ֹҽֱӸԤΪִУԤǲɻȱģԤѭ
    ҵζţҵи㷺õĹҷ뿪໥֮Ҳ룬ҵΪľʵת
ⲻȫҵͶʾߣ涨ҵĻΧҵΪʵ壬ںϺ֯ϵԭ
򡣶г£ҵĳǾϵԭҵ֮ĹϵǾԵģҪݾǶֻ
ˣǺϲǽӹܡҪҵ飬Ա㽨ҵƶȣҵӪʲ⣬ҪʹҵΪҵ
ҪڴڷǹеĻ
    ³˹ϣڹ½ҵƶȵĻźܴѡΪ£ǲƲռߣ
νҵң޷ԼʲȥѰһðաڹҵУԹԱĶƣҵ
ԼжеΡʧͬҹĻҵݵȻòȫг
ֽϷԼĶעðռ޷ȥ[13]ȫгƵ߼ǰѷǹҵгҵиȻĳɷ
ҵҲ伣ӹĻáú۵ءͲƸĹƽȷ濼ǣҵдڵıҪԡг
ܲҪƣһҪκʽƽ塣ûģʽġ[14]
    ³˹˹ƣʵڰµѧɵо⣬Ȼơڹƺ͡
ȫг塱żĳͻԹƵıѾǻھԭĿǣҪκ᷽ԭ򣬷ǹгɷֲ
Ȼгõ߼ǵģʽУϸϽƺ͡ҵҡ֮ĽֻЭϵйĸ
˼·߼ȫͬȻǹҵݵȷҵľõ֡ҵλ໥侺ϵ
ȷһϵ˼֣̽ǵĸĸвοֵټǵķǶǰͶŷҾøĸѵܽᣬ
һЩǸֱӵʵ塣
            ۺʾ
    ǰ202030ôս漰ʵ⡢г߶ĳм̼»ٵսչг
۵Ļ䳫Ƶļֵ͵ļͼලģʽȣϸ̽֡ͷӶչ˵г߳Խ
ƾʵЧ۹롣ΪСȷ߶һЩнԺʾԵܽ£
    һڵʱ徭УͬίС⣬ɼ˽ȨǽЧĳṩ˽
лӦҩ
    ƱԭնҾʧܵĸԭ򣬹ؼǰѹƣرǹƣñ˸߶ȼȨĹ
ãӶЧʵ£
    幫ƾҪ֤Чʣüලҵ⣬ⷽԲοִʱ徭ýЩķ
ͳɹ顣
    ġִгṩļҪģʽסʵʵľУַᵥڡгУ
ල֤ȯгලһලҵұõķҪлϡ
    塢ʵʾԶκۺģʽҪۺģʽֻṩһЩʶͷϵʾʵʵľսԺߣ
øĸӱʵʾýṹ
οס
    [1]P.K.Bardhan,On Tackling the Soft Budget  Constraint  inMarket Socialism,in Market Socialism,the Current Debate,ed. by
P.K.Bardhan and J.Roemer,Oxford University Press,1993,p.145
    [2]P.K.Bardhan,and J.Roemer,Market Socialism, the  CurrentDebate,Oxford University Press,1993,p.16.
    [3]J.Roemer,Equal Shares,London:Verso,1996,p.910.
    [4]P.K.Bardhan,On Tackling the Soft  Budget  Constraint inMarket Socialism,in Market Socialism,the Current Debate,ed. by
P.K.Bardhan and J.Roemer,Oxford University Press,1993,p.146.
    [5]D. Lavoie, Computation, Incentives, and  Discovery: TheCognitive Function of Markets in  Market  SocialismתNew
Left Review199778ºţ60ҳ
    [6]J.Kornai,The Road to a Free Economy,New York:W.W.Norton,1990,p.49.
    [7]J.Roemer,Equal Shares,London:Verso,1996,p.1518.
    [8]J.Roemer,Equal Shares,London:Verso,1996,p.18.
    [9]J.˹ٸģδȥWhither Socialism1998꣬219ҳ
    [10]J.˹ٸģδȥWhither Socialism1998꣬91ҳ
    [11]W.Brus and K.Laski,From Marx to the  Market: Socialismin Search of an Economic System,Clarendon Press,1989,p.105.
    [12]W.Brus and K.Laski,From Marx to the  Market: Socialismin Search of an Economic System,Clarendon Press,1989,p.138.
    [13]W.Brus and K.Laski,From Marx to the  Market: Socialismin Search of an Economic System,Clarendon Press,1989,p.142.
    [14]W.Brus and K.Laski,From Marx to the  Market: Socialismin Search of an Economic System,Clarendon Press,1989,p.149.
    
    
    
 
