 ׺ 2-938
ԭĳйѧ
ԭ
ԭںš200008
ԭҳš5356
  šF3
  ҵ
ӡںš200011
    ҵһ廯֯
Ӣı⡿Enterprise Group and Economic Orgnization of Intergration
    The Management School of Xi' an  Jiaotong  University, Xi'an 710049,China
    ΰ
߼顿ͨѧ  ѧԺ   710049
ҪþѧĻͨҵһ廯֯ҵ빦ܽгֱȽϷʾҵ뾭һ
廯֯ҵԴͬζҹʵеҵŹԼ߽顣
ӢժҪAfter being analysing comparatively the nature and  functionof enterprise group and economic orgnization  of  en
tergrationby economic mathods,the sames and  differences  of  enterprisegroup and economic orgnization of  entergration  in 
 resourcesallocation are analysed and put  forward  in  this  paper. Theproblems  and  the  policy  suggestions  of  disolvi
ng   theseproblems at presently in construction and operation  in  Chinaare also raised.
  ʡҵ/һ廯֯/ȽϷ/ʵ֤о
       enterprise  group/economic     orgnization     of intergration/comparative analysis/positive study
    
    ͼţF270  ױʶ룺B  ±ţ10029753 200008005304
            һ
    ھøĸ￪ǰҹᾭУҹͨ߶ȼƻļȨƣϰеҵΪطְ
ţҵķ˵λʵ̸Զ²ɾȨڶҵҵšҵ
γ뷢չڸĸ￪Ժ󣬴ʵ20ʷбľ飬Ҳ̵Ľѵϸ˵ҹ
ҵγ뷢չ׶Σرҹҵŵ齨гֵؽ淶˲Ҫ۹
ߴʵսѰҴ𰸣1999ĩɽŹ˾ʵҵԼԴŹ˾£Ҫɽ
ʵҵԴŹ˾Ӫ˽ΪϸĿ죬ͨο˽ҹǰҵű齨ĹУ뷢һг
еĹ淶ҵ齨ԶĽùҵ֮Żݣ䱾һҵ졣ͨҵһ廯
֯ҵ۵ļҪۼعˣҹʵеҵЧʽҹҵŵĹ淶չԼĽ

            ҵż
    ҵţEnterprise Group Business  Group IndustrialGroupCorporate Groupĸ͹֣ҵŽ
ָԽʱΪĵ¢ϲţҵŹģϴʵۺ٣ձ⡢סѡܽءһȰҵС͵
Ħ˷աŰСʿ١÷¡֥Ӹ硢ǡ¿˹ȣҵų˶⻹
ش͹˾ΪģͨعɡιɡԼγɵľ壨ͼ1ʾҵͨ»1෨ˡӷɵ
λϿҵŲǷ˶ɶɵҵ壬ûз˲ƲжʸڲԱҵиԶľ
棬ڹ֮ͬ϶һ𡣣2ϵŦҵŵĸԱҵ֮ҪɿعɡιʲŦ
ϵ⻹ԾоӪ¡Լȶ෽ϵŦȨϵҵиԱҵ֮ΪŦ3
ֹ֯γɵҵţҵֹγɵҵţӳֹɹϵ֣ɻֳĲ㡢ܲ㡢
ܲɢȲΡ4Ӫ ҵһ㶼ǴµһƷ뾭ӪΪ˳ԴɢӪգҵ
缸Ӫҵ5๦ܡҵŲӪܣнǿĿпܡóͨܡ6
 гùҵҵͨǿţ侭Ӫ򲻽ĸ˾ڹ
    ҵŵĲ뷢չгԼҵ˫չıȻгҵ֯ģĲţҵڲ֯ɱͻᳬ
Ľ׳ɱҵģã˺ҵʼԲ뼺صҵһ廯ǰĳЩҵΪⲿ֯
ͨʽ𡢼µŦǱеϵЩҵǶӪķˣҵеĺϵҵڽԼ
׷õͬʱһ̶һ廯֯ĹģΧͷɢյľԡһֽҵг֮ıΪ׼һ
廯֯;֯ʽҵšڼȽҵ֯õͬʱֽԼг׷ãӶʹеķ
ҵڵҵԲչĸԭڡ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ͼ1  ձҵŵĵͽṹ
    һ廯Լصľ֯
    1.һ廯֯䷢չ  ǴϲͬķɭWilliamson, 19711985˹أGrossman & Hart,19
86͸úͰգKlein, Crawford &  Alchian, 1978ƶȾѧҵؼ裬һ廯ľ֯ҵ
Ϊһ廯ľ֯ҵ⣬áᡢȶ֯ʽΪ˱ķķֲᵼ£
ڴһ廯ľ֯ҵ⡣һ廯ľ֯򾭼֯һ廯ҵԼϾ
֯ҵģչ䶯໥ϵ޿ɡŵָBesanko, Dranove & Shanley,1995ҵ 
չԼı߽γ˽Ϊһ廯ۣ֯һ廯һ廯ͬʱһ廯֯ҵ
һ廯ǽʾҵ߽⡪ҵԼµĻԼгרҵ˾йĻΧǰһ廯һ廯
ǰһ廯ָҵԼǰҵйչԼı߽磬һ廯ָҵԼǰҵչ
Լı߽磻֯ҵĺһ廯ǽʾҵĺ߽⡪ҵĲƷгĹģӦж󣬺һ廯ҵ
Լǰҵо򻥲չԼı߽磻֯ҵͬʱһ廯ǽʾҵ߽⡪ҵ
Ӫеһϵвͬҵļϣͼ2ʾ
    ֯ҵһ廯Ҫõֶξչ沢һ廯ľ֯ʽ϶ִҵķչ
HͽṹHolding CompanyUͽṹUnitary StructureMͽṹMultidivisional StructureĶ˾ȣӷɱ
ϽȻǷ֯·ʸ뷨˲ƲȨȡ֯ҵ֮һ廯Ϊһ廯ľ֯ҵ
һԴֶΣWilliamson,1988 ͬ֯ҵһ廯Կ˷ͬ֯佻׵гʧ飨Williamson,1971
Ҳͬһ廯֯ҵַʽչԼĹģԻ¢Լģ뷶ΧòɢӪգBesanko,Dranove 
& Shanley, 1995; David, 1997; Johnson & Scholes,1993 ˷ͬ֯ҵ֮геĻ岢ͽ׷ãGro
ssman & Hart,1986;Klein, Crawford & Alchian, 1978ȡ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ͼ2  ֯ҵһ廯
    2.صľ֯  ;֯ʽԣгһ廯֯ҵ˵Դ÷ʽ˶м侭֯
ʽ¼֣1һ廯Tapered Integrationһ廯̼ԼĳЩƷҲгϹĳ
ЩƷĳЩǲԼӵ۵꣬ͬʱӪȨȡһ廯䱾ʶһ廯г׵Ļ
ԴõķʽĽڲ߶ɱ֧¿չ̵룯ƷڲĳɱӮϢЭ
ⲿĵԼ̸СͨԼڲƷ빩ӦԼӦ̵ҪЮвȡ2սˡ ս
ǳ̲ȡһֲԶԶͬ֯ҵ׵ķҲһ廯г׵Ļս˵ĳͬĳ
ЩĿϢԴϺķʽȿǺ漰ͬһҵҳ֮ĺҲ漰Ӧɹ֮
ĺǲս˵ĸ齨һʻӪҵȣҵͨս˵֯ʽòƷӪȶ
רҵԼƷԼǿƷӪͬרЭȡ3ˣOpportunistic Alliances
ָ̼ضҵĿγˣɻ˵ĳ֮ûʽ֯ԼʽԵҵ
Ŀϣûн壬Դ˸ӽгϵԼϵ4ְ磨Subcontractor Networks 
ڲƷӪһϵвƷ̻У̲ͨԼγɵġͨƷιϵɳڵġ
ʽĸ壬֮漰ǽϸˮƽкеһϵиӵΡ5ԼĻϵ ֻϵԳ֮
δʽĹͬʶɣδʽĹͬʶڷɷΧʵʩϹͬʶʵʩڴ
ͬʶ½ɻϵĳΥԼͻδϵľ޴ʧ
            ġҵһ廯֯۱ȽϼӦ÷
    1.۵ıȽϷ  ͨĽܣǲѷҵһ廯֯Լľ֮֯ڵĲ죺1 䱾
ʿҵһ廯֯Լ֯ԴֶΣһ廯֯ͨ֯ڲ߶ȼƻʵʩģ
׷ü͵һ廯Ʒüߣһ廯֯ĶԴгֶΣͨͬһ廯֮֯г
ɵģг׷üߵһ廯Ʒüͣҵֶεм״̬һԴֶΣ
ֶΡȱݵȡ2齨ʽ ҵٴӹģ뷶ΧϿ԰ͨ񡢽֧֡زƷҵ
һоòż侭ӪҵҸи߶ȵԶԣһ廯֯Ȼ侭Ӫģ뷶ΧխҲͬĲ
һһ廯ȱԼĶԡ3ṹ ҵǽҵΧҵ֮Ĺϵһ廯֯ǽ
ߡӪԼԱ֮Ĺϵȡ4ӷ˵λ ҵ޷˵λܶеΣһ廯֯
з˵λеΡ
    2.һʵ֤о  ϸľ֯빦ܽǶȽҵһ廯֯нϴģҹгøĸ
ƹ齨ҵţȴЩ첻עҵŵ齨оһ廯֯ԴӶʹøĸʩ
üЧԷӳ1999ĩɽʵҵּԴŹ˾֮ԴŹ˾Ӫϸʵز
ۿ죬ԴŹ˾ΪҹгҵŵĵʽǷһ塣ԴŹ˾Ϊʵҵ
ҵŹ˾Ϊģ£ҵʵ壬ܲйɶᡢӻᡢ»ᡢܣԼۺ
ӪơҵĻѵĸְܲţΧƵҵóΡҵز20£ҵЩ20ҵ
ҵλУжûԶķʸ񲢲Ӧ20ҵλֻ漰óεļҵλ
Ӫ䡢ȻȨ󲿷ֵλûԶӪ䡢ȻȨеӪ
䡢ȾмżƻʵʩʵֻǸüΪһҵеһְܲŶѡŵľЧȻģǵĵ
УеĵһԱв쵼ȣӳǵĹûм붯ҵӪͼ²㡢гȣ
еľӪҪôҵ¢ϾӪתƶҪôҵصҵг¢ϾӪ
    3.۷ʵָ  ֵرָǣɽʵҵԴŹ˾󲢷Ǹ󣬶ҹгУҵĸ
ץСߵֱΪڵ󣬡ץ¡ҵĸߵµطԼΧҵͬʵʩץС
ڻڶԭƣӪƣбڸҵŻݻ̼طҵ
ԸΪʩ齨͵ġҵšҵглùɣǽԡҵš֮е
ŻݣҵҵԼгı빦ܺ;ùɣսҲֻԶҹгĸԵáƹѡ
Ľ֡رָǵķڷ񶨡ץСҵĸߣҪƴץСпܲ
Ѿһв߾Чʵ⡣
            塢
    ҵźҵԼгᾭ֯һԴֶеһҪֶΣҵϺõطԴõ
ܣҪָҵŵı빦ܼγɵѡмɡǻ϶һرǶҹľƸĸﾭ
ΪҪͻ벻бäĿհĴ֮С
    ոڣ20000225
    ĿȻѧ𡰾塱صĿҵ֯չЭۡģʽо׼79830010Ľ׶
ɹ
οס
    [1]David. Besanko, David. Dranove & Mark. Shanley,1995˾սԾѧ뱾[M].ѧ磬19999³.
    [2]Fred R. David, 1997: Concepts of Strategic Management.սԹ뱾[M].ÿѧ磬19986³.
    [3]Sanford J. Grossman & Oliver D.Hart,  1986: "The  Costs and Benefits of  Ownership: A  Theory  of  Vertical  and Late
ral Integration."J.P.E.Vol,94.Aug:691719.
    [4]ǿΰ.1999ҵγɵľѧ̽Դ[J].ѧѧ棩4.
    [5]Gerry. Johnson &  Kevan.   Scholes,   1993:   Exploring Corporate Strategy.˾սԽ̳̣뱾[M].ĳ
19984³.
    [6]Benjamin. Klein, Robert  G.   Crawford  &  Armen  A.Alchian, 1978:"Vertical Integration,  Appropriable  Rents, and th
e Competitive Process."J.Law and Econ. Vol,21.Oct:297326.
    [7] Oliver  E. Williamson, 1971: "The  Tertical IntegrationProduction:Market Failure Considerations."A.E.R.   Vol, 61.Ma
y:11223.
    [8]Oliver E. Williamson,1985:The Economic Institutions  ofCapitalism. New York: Free Press.
    [9]Oliver E.   Williamson, 1988: "The  Logic  of  EconomicInstitutions". Journal of Law, Economics, and Orgnization.Vol,
4.Spring:6593.
    
    
    
 
