 ׺ 2-612
ԭĳϿо
ԭ
ԭںš199901
ԭҳš1016
  šF11
  ۾ѧ
ӡںš199905
    ѧعչ
    ָ
߼顿ָϿѧѧϵ
    
    ĵһ֣19986 ڣѧ˵ʷǶȶҪ˱۵˼ԴĽǣ˹ܺ˼Ϊˣ
۾Ъִѧγ¹ŵͽṹֲͬо˼·Ϊĵڶ֣ǽ˼
·Ļչۣͨ˼·ıȽϣҪ˵ѧδչķԼµоıҪԡ
            һ¹ŵ崫ͳ
    ˹Ӱ֮£Ϊ20ɱ۵Ľ1933ͬʱŲصġ¢Ͼۡ
ޱѷġȫѧ¹ŵ΢۾ѧشչŲʵϷղɹ̶Ŀɵļ裬ҵԲƷ
ʽˮƽֹÿҵڱ߼ʳɱƽɱʽ½ܵṩƵͬһĲƷľϵͳ
ÿҵ֮´ﵽ⡣ǣŲصĲƷʵͻ˲Ʒͬʻһļٶǿ˲ƷԣǶ
ƷѧĿδԭرδԲƷļԴǨҵԽзΪ
ĻܻܿʹУԱͳͳ֮ڡȻ¢ϾһһʱޱѷĲȫ
ڵѧõø㷺80¹ŵ䱨۾ǰѲȫⲿԽģ͵ģڲȫĿ֮
ͨⲿõıһ̶Ͽ˷Ъȫ¿汨ȱݣʹΪܡ
    ⲿԣⲿãٲϣз˹˵Ǿѧ׽ĸ֮һעTibor Scitovsky,  "Two
 Concepts of External Economies," Journal of Political Economy, Vol.Lxzz,February,Number.1,1954.ۼҵŬ
ѱ塣һΪⲿԣϵⲿԺͽǮⲿԣϵⲿֱ֮ͨӵġг
ģƶȾѧҪĻΪȨڡµĸ߰׷úĲȷ
ԡǮⲿͨгƵ໥ɼ۸䶯𣬵һҵ󲻽ȡԼĻȡҵĻʱ
ǮⲿԾʹڡϵⲿַࣺһЪǿģҵ֪ʶⲿԣҵڷֹͨ߸ɱѧǡ
ڲá治ȫҵռУֻЧӦڶڸҵרҵҵֹĳҵ
ⲿԣгģĺⲿԻҵۼⲿԡⲿԵĵһĬ1986¬
˹1988ƵĺģڶͿеõ˸ǿǮⲿɭ˹̹޵1943ĵĺ۵֮
һһ˼뵽80ĩīƵȣ1989 ģͻעοMurphy, Kevin M., Andrei Shleifer, and Robert Vishny, "Industrial
ization and  the Big Push."Jaurnal of PoliticalEconomy,97,October 1989.˼ǣԼ۸ЧӦκβҵҵ
ͶʣгģܵƣȫҵıͲܵõã£ͨЭƶܸ
ܱߡ
    Ĭ1986¬˹1988ģһ̶ʹˣǰƽһ
ٶһⲿãͶʵᱨʸ˽˱ʣڶ㷺ʱȴͳиͶ
ݶҪго뿪ĽĬļҪ׷˱۵˼·ȷ˰ޣ1962
Ĺ֪ʶٶѧ֪ʶ䱾ǲģ ȨǿԲģ֪ʶСЧӦⲿԣ
Ұ֪ʶΪࣺһ֪ʶרҵ֪ʶרҵ֪ʶԲڲã̴¢¢γɸ
²Ʒġо뿪ʽԴһ֪ʶԲⲿãʹȫᶼܻùģáڲúⲿý֯ãʹ
һƷҵʹҪͶò˱Դ˷ʽĬ˷ֹ֪ʶ۹̡¬˹
ⲿģģ60Ϊʱ۹˼Դ֮һĵʱͨĺͷĽ
γɣǲʱġڲЧӦޣ1962ġ߸ɱѧָͨڸѵʦͽഫڹл۾飬ɴγ
ʱʱγɹ̾СⲿЧӦ޵˼뵱Ȼ׷˹ܵķֹۡ¬˹ģͳ޵˼룬˵Ϊ
ʱĻԴʱⲿЧӦıġ
    ۵Ľģȴͳ¹ŵ۴ƽһС˼ߵľ룬ǻԼԭ
Ҫؽ;¹ŵ崫ͳͳ֮ڣһۣȱ΢ۻƵ˵صȱδ
ⲿڻ⡣ǿΪʩٸգ1951ƶȾѧΪṩһ̵ֳĻ΢ۻۡʩٸͼѳ
ۡҵۺгģܺṩƵ˵עοʩٸգҵ֯ơ22ҳ37ҳϺ
1989档۾ȱݣһ˹ܺ˼ڶ̬ƽɱʱƶ½Լ
໥˼벻һ£עMCorsi,Division of Labour, Technical Change and Economic Growth,PP:118123.Gower Publishingcomp
any,1991. ڶѷֹ֯ʽѡֻɱ˽׳ɱֻͣɱͷϣδ
ɱ½ļԣȻ¹ŵ䴫ͳ֮޷ɵģ֮ǽ⿪ԴһҪ;ķɭġ
ʲרԡһĳԣδγɶԱĽͣδġ䡱ڵڶ㲻㣬˹1937Ͱ
氲ķģ1972ṩ˽׳ɱĽͣ˹Ϊֹ֯ʽгҵȡڽ׳ɱıȽϡ氲͵
ķһͨΪΪʲôܻȡ棬ͨĽµĽȷֱܵбȽƵ
רҵԭעƲȨƶȱǨ63ҳϺ1991档ҪҵʵרҵǱƣⲿ
ǺҪҪ⣬ǿг͸׳ɱҵγɣӶɱ½áƶȾѧͨǿȨ
ʹⲿڻĹܣΪṩ΢ۻݴˣԿɵɱͽ׳ɱ½ƶȱ仯
ġǣԱ¹ŵ䴫ͳ֮еƶȾѧȱݣָܽƵνƶβģѧ˵
˵Խ˵ΪʲôܽƶȾѧ˵ƺõƶȻܱ
桱һΪ߻šʵžǲڵġһصȱǼǨƶȱǨʱ
ΪϵԾ۲ܽΪƶȾѧĿǣƶȽṹʱһƶȱ仯εһƶ
仯ġˣ¹ŵ崫ͳԱĶ̬޵ģ⡢ŵ˼άϻʲôأĽ
˼·Ϊ˿Եĳԡ
            ṹ˼·
    ó۵Ĵﱣޡ³ָ4050չѧгһ˼򣬼ǿԼ
гģЧӦĽǮⲿõҪԡעPaul  Krugman,"Toward a Counter- Counterrevoution  in  Development  Theory, 
"Proceedings  of  The  World  Bank,  Annual   Conference  onDevelopment Economics,1992.Ȼ³ָȫ棬
ΪڷչѧĴ󲿷ʶ˽ṹƶȲЩҪأȻ˵ڵķչѧǼִ֮ѧ
ͼһĿۼŬЩѧңѶɭ˹̹޵նϣɿ˹ȣԳΪ뾭ѵ
ߣͼһ¹ŵ侭ѧϵͬ¾ѧŵѧѶԷӳŬΰ
ľѵʱҵᾭѧڷҵľ˼УźġϣЩӴġ
ûġɵġʱȻǲʵĽṹ۷ͨоԼҪ˼롱עҮ˹ࣺ
÷չ۵ʮλʦ16ҳй˳磬1990档ڷչѧŬȻܴɣԺı
ۼҲǿӰ죬³óۺۿ˼·֣ӶٻԷչѧ70¹ŵ
ġлػڷչѧҵ˼ҲɪǿӰ죬ʹ֮ѧԾȷر˼ں
    ĸɭ˹̹޵ġŷͶŷĹҵ⡷1943ӡ˼ɭ˹̹޵
һ¹ŵۺתΪģ֯ĽṹǨ˶쵼ˡĹҪáɭ˹̹޵ڻд⾭
÷չĹؼⲻǾ̬ͳľۣǶԷǾ̵ķԿڷչѧϵĻڹ˼
ģʱɭ˹̹޵Ϊ4˵ǹؼģʧҵǮϵⲿãʱļϵⲿãв
ɷָԺⲿʱҪԡɭ˹̹޵ĵ˼Լ£ˮƽĹģúҪеԵĹ
޵ũʣͶò˾ʵʸĽǮⲿãˮƽĹģֽͨǮⲿ
ˮƽתΪͨ֡ۻḶ́ʹڲżսԵĻҪҵʵ໥Э
ƶ
    ȻۻϵԭѶȷģڷǷϵķ˼ľѱ
¶ţǷѶܵӰĿǰȻɿ˹ġҵʱγɡ1952ȴķΪƪչ
۵ġɿ˹ѶġƶĶѭʵǲɪѧģʽġ·汾ʹƶ
ҡڶѭ֮УΪɭ˹̹޵ͺնϣˡ˳״̬ĲͬսԹ򡣺նϣڡ÷չ
սԡ1958ʹõġϵЧӦʵǽǮⲿõͬʣڷչѧеõ˹㷺Ĵ˺ߺٱʹá
̬ⲿãϵЧӦ˵Ϊҵ̵Ĺҵ״˵ĹΧ֮ĹϵԼΧ
ҵ̵ƶۡͺնϣԽηԿһġڵĳԡ
    ȻӢѧҿ˼ķչ뷢չѧֱϵһ㻯ΪԷ֮
ķͳѧҪԱԼ60ڿʼԶӢ˥ԭоΪ־ѧ˼뷢˼ҵת
ȫڱ۵оͬʱʼԾ۽ϵͳС಻Ϊ󿭶˹徭ѧҪԱҶ
ۡҲԶӰ죬ڡ־רۿۡ
    ΪҪǣеԵͨ˵ΪǱ¾ۻı
Ҫͳǣ۴ӹһĳʼ仯Ӧյ˶ͶʣŹĴΪṩʣ
ΪյͶṩʵĻҽϵΪؼ໹֤ҵרҵڹ·ֹݽеáʵǴ
˼ƵƶȰŻҵ֯Ҫԡⷽıǣͼѿ˹ķʽʹ
˹۶̬Younghian dynamization of KeynesΪۻʱΪĿĵĲƻ
;òƻϣֲͬͬһ̵ͬ档˹ܡ뿭˹Чѧ˵
Ҫǣڱ£˹ڳ־ҵʧҵ״̬֮ϸʧˡڴĶϣܲӲ
ԴԼԼ˰ԤڵƶȰżǨڡάֵ˵һҪ
    һǣṩ˱ĽṹڷǷ֮ϵ͹ó׵ķŵ侭ѧҺЪһ
ΪũҵǱݼĲҵҵѭɡũҵ͵ȻԴΪؽԼͼǼ
ģũҵϡȱԼڸũҵó£ԹҵƷ󼰹ҵҵҲܵƣ˽ʧҵͶ
۸񣬴ʧҵľǲڵģг޷ġڱ겻£ͨʣͶʱתƵũҵﵽ⣬
겻䣩Ǿ߶ԴԼıҪʵһԵ磨ڱ겻䣩
ÿҵÿŻĳּڱ̶ϵĲ죬ʹϵͳƣһʱϣ״̬Ϊ
һϵ¼ĽǲԤģͱʷʱ뵽÷
    ɪ80һϵֱ̽ԾϵͳתҪ塣Ϊڱڵ£ϵͳʾ
ص㡣һĲԤԣܹ¶ֿܵĽЪġؾ⡱ֽܱѡǲԤ
ڶǱԣȥʷ¼ĿǰδӰ죬ϵͳǿҵͺЧӦǱڵķЧʣ̬ݽеĳ·
θԣǡӵȡģϵͳܱ̬֮СʷұޡԴֻQWERTYУʷʵ
˵˱ͨһϵżȻ¼ʹֻЧʲߵļ֮СżȻġ¼Ծ
ܶࡣԣɪоһ¹ŵ侭ѧ磬ĸ¹ŵ侭ѧȻͬиǿ˵
ɪۼҺΪչѧЩѧؿһ鲻ͬʷ¼ȫ
ͬġɪŵܱ˵ġ޷һƬ硱ˡŽṹ˼·ɪȷʵѱƽ
һµĽ׶ΣȻѧйڸӵĽϵͳоıϣԴһЩ㣬дڷһĿ֮½˼ͽģ

            
    ۲ԴԨҾĿǰ˺ܴչرԱ¹ŵ䴫ͳ֮ڵۡƶȾѧ
Ϊѧɲ֣˵ӽʵ˿ϲһֵûӭġȻȽṹ˼·ھзḻ
ںδ۷չкܿǸǰ;ġʵϣڵټҵؼֵ¹ŵ崫ͳƺȱ˼봴ֻǶԽṹ
ߵ˼뱻ӦŻװΡĶ˼·ԼҪΪ¹ŵ崫ͳ
øġֽķھ֮󻯺ŷʽñ仯˰żȻųľѧִۣ
һʱ͵ص㶼õĹɣһַʷķṹ巽ΪֲĹӦϵͳͽṹ
ȥʶۻʹϵͳвȶñ仯͵ǷǾ̣ƶȶ̬ǾأһӵķԶ
̡̬ʼ¼໥õ·ķչ̣÷Ҫעʱ䡢صĲ죬õһʷķ
    ˼·ڲ⣬ǶڹͬȱݣȱھϵͳתʶرδֲѰȶľ
ڷǾ⶯Ĺϵṹ廹ȱһʵ΢ۡ˼·ȷԺϸڷ϶ȡ˳չ
ƺδܳչʾ˹ܺ˼۵ȫںʹǽṹ˼·Ҳ˼ۻֺ̣˵ָ
˵ܴ˼˼ոӪ˵ٴ֤Ъѧ񣬡
ѧҵĿھѧǾѧעЪѧԭϾ18ҳӡݣ1964档ľѧ
дڴ죬ṹ˼·ֻһǰࡣ޵¡ķ̸ƶȾѧʱָģȥʮ䣬ù
ķһθѧµע𽥼еͬеǰʹ֮ȫ󻯵ϣϢѧͽ׾ѧԼ
ڴƹ㵽԰ɺƶڵоע޵¡ķģľáɺάȡ14ҳϺ
꣬1992档ľѧ϶ֲ⣬Ŀǰ𽥵תΪѧоĺĿ⣬ĿǰоԵδ
ԶԱãƶȾѧһǶƶȵʶҲȱݣ˲ɪԾϵͳһ
Що⣬ǶԴ֪ĲࡣδķչЩдĹؼȡͻԽչеľ
ѧ֮£Ŀ꼸ǲܴﵽġѧѴڴչǰҹбҪؿҰµо
    ·̶ܴʶϵģܴӾѧڲѧμȻѧнʮ
ɢṹۡѧһЩ졣Ȼѧеķ󣬱뾭ѧеıһ
£ֻϵͳѧϵͳӡͳ¹ŵ侭ѧĵţŷߣţѧľۡԺͻеʱӽṹ
Ҳ¹ŵ侭ѧĻĿǰѧѧȻѧһЩԽչѶҡţѧΪۣ
ֱѧӰ΢ѧǰЩԵ˼ͷ뾭ѧýϵ㣬ľؽѧίԱ
һоָģȻѧչһЩнĸϵͳṩĸΪѧչһ
˼룬˼ѧĳЩѾõĹ۵ǷǳǺϵģھѧмָ۵ȡעע˹̹
ŵѧ68ҳ顤֪꣬1997档ɪԱоʹӺɢṹ۵Ȼѧ
ǳھеļ򱨳ɷãʷ¼ĿҲʹƽѧȻѧҴеõ
һľۣǱ2030ѧʦܱؾñǨ۵ĺ˼룬¡ѷᡤءñǨ
һۡ1982ĳ棬ʹѧѳΪѸٷչһоڸȷĽ֮дһд
ֵ̽⡣
α༭
У  ߡҼ
οס
    [1] Arthur, W. Brian. "Competing  Technologies, IncreasingReturns,and lock-in by Historical Events." Economic  Journal,M
arch 1989,99.PP.116131.
    [2]Arthur,W.Brian. "Positive  Feedbacks  in  the Economy."Scientific American,February 1990,262(2),PP.9299.
    [3]W.Brian Arthur,Yuri M. Ermoliev, and  Yuri M. Kaniovski.  "Path-  Dependent   processes   and   the   Emergence    of
Macrostructure",European Journal of Operational  Reseach, Vol.30,1987.
    [4]Piero Sraffa. "The  laws  of  Returns under competitiveconditions",Economic Journal,December 1926.
    [5]Kaldor,      Nichloas,"The Irrelevance of   EquilibriumEconomics."Economic Journal,Vol.82,December 1972.
    [6]Kaldor,Nicholas,"What is Wrong  with  Economic  Theory",Quarterly Journal of Economics,August 1975.
    [7]Charles P.Blitch, "Ally  Young  on  Increasing returns",Journal of post keynesian Economics,Vol.v,No.3 Spring 1983.
    [8]M.Corsi,Division of Labour,Technical Change and EconomicGrowth,Gower publishing Company,1991.
    [9]Peter Skott and Paul Auerbach,"Cumulative Causation andthe 'New'  Theories  of  Economic  Growth", Journal  of   Post
Keynesian Economics,vol.17,No.3,Spring 1995.
    [10]G.B.     Richardson,"Adam smith on Competition     andIncreasing Returns",in Andrew S.Skinner et al.(eds),Essays onA
dam Smith, Clarendon Press,1975.
    [ 11] Prue  Kerr, "Adam  Smith's  Theory  of   Growth  and Technological Change Revisited".Contributions  to  Political 
Economy,12,1993.
    [12]Tibor Scitovsky,"Two  concepts  of External Economies",Journal of political Economy,Vol LXZZ,February 1954.
    [13] Lucas, Robert  E. Jr. "On  the  Mechanics of EconomicDevelopment."Journal of Monetary Economics,22,1988.
    [14]Romer, Paul"Increasing  Returns  and  long- Run Growth."Journal of Political Economy,94(5),1986.
    [15]Rosenstein-Rodan,Paul N."Problems of Industrializationin Eastern and Southeastern Europe" Economic Journal,53( June-
September),1943.
    [16]Paul Krugman, "Toward  a  Counter-Counterrevotution inDevelopment Theory." Proceedings of  the  world  Bandk, Annual
Conference on Development Economics,1992.
    [17]David,P.A."Clio and the Economics of QWERTY", Am.Econ.Rev. Proc. 75.1985.
    [18]˼ʱۡ1975档
    [19]ǵ˹ܣƸԭоӡݣ1972档
    [20]Ъѧԭӡݣ1964档
    [21]Ү˹ࣺ÷չ۵ʮλʦй˳磬1990档
    [22]ʩٸգгͶֹҵ֯ơϺ꣬1989档
    [23] Ųأ¢Ͼۡ 顤֪꣬1958档
    [24]֡񣺡뾭ýƱȽϡ19962ڡ
    [25]ָ뾭÷չۡƱȽϡ19962ڡ
    [26]ָ֮𣬿ԭԾѧζʲôƱȽϡ19986ڡ
    
    
    
 
