 ׺ 2-135
ԭĳо
ԭ
ԭںš199912
  šF101
  
ӡںš200004
    ƶȡ˾ṹϵ鼰йʾ
    ½
    
    ƶȶʱг˾ṹϵӰ죬ڹơü񼸸Լͬض߶ȵӡⷽ
оģ󾭼÷Robert VishnyAndrei ShleiferƵRay BallֶǸרҵĴʦɼⷽоִѧ
ҪԡйҵٸĸĹͷⷽоṩ˼ʱҼмֵĲοĵĿڻⷽоĳ
Եǰйʾ
            һߣƵ;
    гĲ(imperfect)ȫ(incomplete)Ļѧ缰ʵͷ˺ֻ۲ġ
ڻڡߡ롰ߡ;Beaver 1989ǰָ񱨱ܹ˾ⲿͶʼȵľߣ
ָƵݣΪ߼Լִеݣ㱨ꡢԱ͹ķ䣬Լ˰ĺ˶ȡ
עоԡԼ(contracting)ָԼ߷;й߶ԻƵӰʽԼƸúԼ
дԼȣö࣬Աԡߡָⷽ;
    ֲͬ;вͬϢҪھߵ;ϣͶʼ߶δֽԻϢܹԤ
δֽáڻƱӳȥĽףǹȥгԣһܰԤδ󡣻Ʊ
Ҫ¶󣬶ɲӪҵӪҵԼƷķֲϢ(segment information)¶ҲͬҪ
⣬Ʊ滹ǿ¶ԭ򣬾˵ֻҪԤδаҪ¶¶ķʽһҪڱͨ
ע¶ߵҪԣϢھߵĿʱָԪĿԤδ
    ߵ;Ͼʹͬˡ˰ͨȡͬһ֣Իرǿֵȷδ
Ԥⲻǿص㣬ɷֵԼڸעȫ¶ȻϹ˰ȱȡڹȥҵ
ǣ浽棬ܵѹŤϢߵ;ʱָһԪĿĲԤδҲһ
ӳȥ
    ָŤһǷֶΣǻʹȨƣȨʱ估۾ɡ˵ȷõȡԼɱм
ͷʹöжϡ۵жϣвٿصĿռ䡣ȡⲻΪءԻϵԣ
дʵ֤оʾѡԣpositive accounting theoryԼӯ(earnings management)󡣵һҲд
ʵ֤оʾԶֽܽ͹ɼ۵ı䶯ƵжϻкܴϢֵȨƴڣʾϢֵ
ԶӯıײҺл׼׻ԼȻȫžӯ󣬵ǿ԰ѱײڿ
ԽܵķΧڡ
    ˵ĻжϵϢֵǶԹ˾ⲿ˵ľ߶Եġ߷ҪϢļֵͲôҪˡ෴ģҪ
ϾߣԱġжϡܱ֡ԡҲ˵ϵϢƫĳЩ߷Ŀǻ档ֻھߵҪ
ǹ˾ⲿ˵ҪҪһĳ̶Ⱥ󣬲ſܶߵӰǣáⲿ˵Ҫʲô²ŻҪǣƵ
Ҫ֤ȯгչĳ̶ԼȨɢΡҪЩ󣬱Ӹķƶ̸
            ƶȶʱгȨṹӰ
    La Porta,Lopez-De-Silanes,Shleifer,and Vishny(1999)оķƶȶԹȨծȨıкܴĲ졣һ˵
ͨĹӢȹһĳķ¡յȣСɶıϸ걸Ʃǰߴ󶼲ۻͶƱƣСɶٿʱ
ɶż5%10%ԼɶĳЩСɶȨʱȨҪ˾չǵĹɷݡķһû
Щ涨
    ɶСɶıϳ̶ȣӰ쵽һĹȨṹ֤ȯгģ¡յȹڶСɶıϽϲȫԹɶֻ
еĹȨԼ棬γ˴ɶعɵLa Porta,Lopez-De-Silanes,and Shleifer(1999)֣Ӣ֮ĹңȨ
ɢй˾дɶعɡɶʽУաµȹǼ壨Ǵ󲿷ֵĹҺ͵Щ
ֱӲ빫˾ûӢձĹȨȨ⣬СɶûбϣLa Porta,Lopez-De-Sila
nes,and Shleifer(1997)ֵ·ŷ½֤ȯгԹģҪӢͨϵҵСԹͨɱֵռİٷ
ŷ½ң23%¹13%ͨң58%Ӣ100%൱⡣עLa Porta˵оҲ
⣬ձ̨嶼ķϵǰֵͨռı0.620.88Ҫԭѧ
ûĽͣShleifer and Vishny(1997)ЩƲԵ̽֡
            Ȩṹ˾ƶԻϵӰ
    ڹȨԲ걸ĹңͨдɶֱӲ빫˾ɶĴ߿ƶ»ᣬֱӳΪ㣬
˾ԣǡڲˡҪϢԵеĶ»߹˾ڲײ㣬ҪⲿͶһҪ
ˣ˾ı˽⹫˾״֮Щҵ֤ȯгģԽСⲿͶ˵ϢҪܵӡһ˵
ЩңƲؾ߶ƫߵ;
    ǿ;ʱߵĿǱƻƵԣʹܵŤһӰƵ˰ߣ֤ȯг
Ȩеŷ½Ҽձ׼˰񷨹һƶΪ˷ֻƶһ׻׼򣬲˰
Щңƺ˰ƻһ£˰񷨹档Ϊ˻ķ㣬˰ͨᾡٸ˾
жϵĿռ䣬绵׼ֵͨϸơͶʾߵ;ЩĴȴҪжϵĿռ䣬Ʊ
Ϣֵ˰ĿԽҪϢԾߵԾԽС
    ڶӰֵǹߡڹ˾ĹͿعɹ˾ֱֽأĶȡڵڵԿعɹ
˾иԤĶעڵ¹ԣù˰涨50%Ϊ͵ӯʣ50%Ҫɶͨ˾Ҫ
ͱӯɽϸߵ˰ʡ⣬ıԱĺҲȡͬһ֣͹ȻҲƵλʩѹ
Ϻ֡
    ֤ȯгȨеĹңƵĶԵͣÿϵĽ⼸һͬ㣬Ǵ
ҶƫȼƽȵĻΪ˰գعɹ˾Ĺ룬ԼԱĺ֮Ȼ
˷ӳ˾ҵãҲʹƱʧȥ˶ⲿ˵ľ߼ֵڳķңСɶĵλͷȨ΢ǵϢ
ҪԹ˾ĲǣƵá
    Ӣͨϵң֤ȯгԾ֮Ȩɢ˾ⲿˣͨɻȻͶľҪͳΪ
ƷҪⲿ˵Ҫ˰񡢹ͺЩ߷ѹǿԼʹߵ
Ҫ޷㣬߷ᰴԼҪҪ˾ṩһױӢͨңƺ˰ѹͱΪ
ȻЩңҲԱȽϸеԣһһЩҵĻƱȽܹӳ
˾ҵBall,Kathori and Robin(1998)ƪδʵ֤оʾӢȹŷ½ձȹй˾ܽ͹
۵ı䶯
            ġʼЭ
    ͹ҵĻƲ죬ֳЭơҪԭǸ֤ȯгྺУΪȡĹ˾ڱ
У󲿷ֹҶټʹñĻ׼򣬶Ĺ˾ʹսͨеġʻ׼򡷣Լ򻯲񱨸ĳɱ
    һ棬й˾ΪͶߣҲвáʻ׼򡷵ŷ޴½ŷԪöԡ
¡ȹ1998𣬳˾ڱ֮⣬Ҳ˾ùʻ׼򡣣עΪߵҪ˰
ȵľϻԭĹ׼򡣿ɼҪĻϢͬͬʱֵ𡣣ݹʻ׼ίԱı
¹30Ĺ˾һ⣬ѱʾ򼴽ùʻ׼
    ͬķƶȣȤĻϵҵ֤ȯгһյĹʻɫʣĻй˾Ļƣ
Э֮ơʼĻҵͬ棬ͬΣ긴һڸı䡣
            塢ϵйʾ
    1.ֵýĶ
    ȽĲϵȻΪ걸׼ίԱ(FASB)׼ԶϽע
ϽƻƶȲѵ͡λFASBίԱƣÿ껨ѵԤ㣬ȫԼʵĻ׼ƶؼҪ࣬
⻰ûпšĻѧҲ˵ȫ򡣵ӱĵķֻ֪ӣƵķɱϻ
ƣ˷֤ȯгԼɢĹȨⲿ˵ľҪϵķչעͨϵСͶߵıϻ
ƣ1929꾭ôֻŵĽѵǿй˾ϸලԶ֤ȯгķչȨķɢṩ˾˫
ûЩϽʽƻϵ
    ϽĲƻϵǲг÷չıҪأӵ·յȹҵľ鿴ȴδءЩҵĲƻϵȣʵ
ۣ조ԭʼ䡱ûϽĲƻϵս񣬲ľ÷չЩҵĴ˾ʹòͬĳʼ
˾ṹںܶҵԺͥûνŵĻϵĻϵڸԲͬľϵ
ɸ滥Ľ
    Ż˵ȡϡйҪȡȽϽʽƻᣬȾײƻϵϲṹ֤ȯгϵͳȨ
ṹԼ˾ƵȡЩϲṹʺййУʦǺѧˡô˵йͲҪ
ҲǣҪй˾еĹֿۡ
    2.й˾
    й˾棬Ϊ˱ϼͶߣй˾ĻƱǿⲿ˵ľҪ1993꡶ҵ׼ʵʩ
ʽӹ족ѾΪĹʶ۵ֻʱĿѡһνġʡָǡʻ׼򡷡׼FASBĲ
׼һй˾ⲿͶ˵ľҪΪҪĿꡣӹ족Ĳ裬Ƿչ֤ȯгɻȱһ
    ӱķƶȶԸϵӰ쿴й˾ĻܲܳΪйƷչȴǸʡйķƶȣڶ
ȨծȨıϣдơڶСͶ൱֮ǰ֤ȯгܷչģǸʡڻеֵͨ
Լǹֵ8%עһ˳йֵѴ25%ݰеĹС˼ͨɣͨƽֻռ
1/3йռıֻԼ8%ǰӢıȻкܴĳɳռ䣬Ǻ͵¡ȹȣ
ݵĿռͲˡעעһᣬķϵҲձ̨ȣ֤ȯгĹģռ񾭼ҪλΡ⣬¡յ
Ӵҵϵȡ֤ȯгĹܣйޡй֤ȯгܷչģǸֵýһ۵⡣
ͺһ֤ȯгĹģޣôϵܷԷⲿͶΪҪĿľʹʡ
    ⣬й֤ȯгձ̨չռ񾭼õҪأй˾Ҳܺʹһǵɶչ
Ȩ档עߵƣй˾ľȨǹɣ߷ɣй˾ĹȨ᲻ɢڶСɶ
Ըķҵľ鿴Բй˹⣬ɶʲô̬Сšȣ֣һ
⡣ôϵ޷չԷⲿΪҪĿĵľ磬Ҳ˵ⲿ˵ҪܻǲǿԼ߶ԻƵӰ
עһԵָǣй˾Ĳƺ˰ʲôʱŻȫѹڴ£Ϣߣ֤
صǿලպǿ֤ȯгܵĴϡй˾Ϣ¶ĽҪ
󣬷ȷġֻûⲿͶ˵ĺӦ֤൥λҪľļȨܼضй˾ΪӰ졣⣬
¶ҪҲҪͶ˶ϢĽȻ֤ȯгĽȻԹΪǶԸӵϢû˽⵱Ȼɡ
ǶԣȽҪĵǻϢĿɿԡֽ׶εصӦǷй˾עʦĲΪڻ׼ƻ
ǿԽ£ûбҪǿһλﵽı׼
    ûǿͶ˵ϢҪһй˾мۿ޷ʵطӳ񱨱ʾĹ˾ҵɼ۵䣬Թ˾
˽͵Ч֤ȯгֻ˹ʵҪӲ͸ɼ۽ϵԴЧõĹܡҲǷƶȵ
£չ֤ȯг뿼ǵء
    3.йҵ
    ڷй˾ǹҵҪӵöࡣӵԭڷеĹҵûⲿͶˣҵʱƺ
ⲿ˵ϢҪҪֽ׶Σ޷ġ
    ʱͳ˾ƶġʱЧй򡷾ǺܺõӡûһĻָ꣬
ֵÿ϶ġǹĶԪָ꣬羻ʲʡʲʡʲתʡʲծʵȣȴһǹ˾ⲿ˳
õָꡣڹûⲿͶˣϵĶȻǸߵҪ˰ӯϽɡȡϼָ
ꡱĴɵȡĻϵҪأƩһɱмͷԴʼֵʹ
ʱ˾ΪԼǣвԱѹ¸ڵĶ˾ĻƵλѹάִֵԼ͹˾
ĿĻȻʹƵԲױ֣ҲʹҵĲ񱨱ʺҵĺʱͳ˾
ָ꣬ܲеĻƱ㣬ʵҪúо
    ĵļǣûⲿ˵Ҫ˾Ļϵɱػصĸšŷ½Һձ֮꣬
ǵĴҵڹгҲ˾ʹڲĵλйĹҵƺȽʺϲο¡յȹɴɶĴ
˵ݲ빫˾ģʽɶĴȻǹ˾ڲˣǵϢҪͲһĲ񱨱ģʽеͨδ
ĹҵƺûбҪǿⲿҪΪĹʻ׼
    ȻģʽǰҪһ׼ƣʹҹȨĴԸܹչҹȨȥලҵעյȹ
ɶֱ˾ģʽʲڹ󣬵Ȼһܺǵļ⣬ѧߣ󲿷ǾѧߣԴ൱㷺
֣̽άӭ(1999)ȡҹȨĴҲҪʹڲϢȥҵЩǰᶼڣҵ
ҵֻлصⲿ񱨱ģʽʱʹưߵĸţǱˡ֮һҵ
õĻƱй˾׼һ£ߵҪʹԭеƶȡǰ¡ȹѾй˾Լ
ҪʵУʵеΣԼйĿԣֵýһо
    ֮δйҵηչҪΰţڴĻƷ۵óġ
    δйҵĻƷչһδ۵أǹԼպڷչҵеϢ󡣵ҵ
лڵҵнʱЩȻҪҵʹϸĻ׼ƱʱҵĻпܰ߷
Ϊ߷Ļ̫ǿҲпҪײ񱨱Ӧ衣ҲзֲܲɿıֻѺ
߱Ȩİţڲ˵ֱӲ빫˾ʻҵΪҪⲿˣǵϢԹ
ҵϵķչشӰ졣һ棬ǵҵҲҪƷչζƵķչ
ҵҲϢӦĵеϢҪܷٽƵķչҲǱȻġ
οס
    Ball,R.,"Making accounting more international:why,how,and how far it will go?,"Journal of Applied Corporate Finance,1995
,pp.19-29.
    Ball,R.,S.P.Kothari,and A.Robin,"The effects ofinstitutional factors on properties of accounting earnings:international 
evidence."Working paper,(April 1998).
    Beaver,W.H.,Financial Reporting:An Accounting Revolution,second edition,Prentice Hall,1989.
    La Porta,R.,F.Lopez-De-Silanes,AShleifer,and R.Vishny,"Legal Determinants of External Finance,"Journal of Finance,vol.
52,1997,pp.1131-1150.
    La Porta,R.,F.Lopez-De-Silanes,and A.Shleifer,"Corporate Ownership Around the World,Journal of Finance,Vol."54,1999,pp.4
71-518.
    La Porta,R.,F.Lopez-De-Silanes,A Shleifer,and R.Vishny,"Law and Finance"Journal of Political Economy,vol.106,1998,pp.111
3-1155.
    Shleifer,A.and R.W.Vishny."A survey of corporate governance."Journal of Finance,vol.52,1997,pp.737-783.
    άӭҵҵѧ磬1999
 
