 ׺ 2-491
ԭĳϺƾѧѧ
ԭںš200002
ԭҳš311
  šF13
  徭ʵ
ӡںš200006
    ĸйģʽ뵽ѧ
Ӣı⡿China's Economic Patterns after the  Reform: from  Idealizedto Scientific Models
     School of  Economics, Shanghai  University  of  Finance  andEconomics,Shanghai,China,200433
ע͡ĵдõϺƾѧйʵ֤ѧϵͷо199810ڸÿֻ
ܵۡ߶ԸֻĲ챣Գʾлڵһд߸
    
߼顿Ϻƾѧ  ѧԺϺ200433
    1953УϾˣϺƾѧѧԺڣʿʦͬôѧеѧԺڡ
ҪΪ˴ӳڽǶйú;øĸбҪо1978꿪ʼıξøĸйģʽйѧԴ
о԰䷽۷ΪͺͿѧࡣǰ߽϶شض߸עĳЩܵơĲȡһо
йڱξøĸֵܳľģʽ֣̽ΪһģʽĻصʣͶũƶȺҵ
Ӫũƶȵ⡣
ӢժҪIn  order  to  understand  Chinese  economy   and   China'seconomic reform from a long run perspective, it  is  
necessaryto examine China's economic  pattern  after  the  end  of  thereform beginning in  1978. The  similar  research  by
  China'seconomists can  be  categorized into Ideal Kind and ScientificKind according to the methodologies adopted, with  th
e  former more dependent on particular     ideas,while the latter  morefocusing on  some  possible  trends. This  paper  app
lies  thelatter method,investigates the potential economic  pattern  inChina after this economic reform,and considers  the  
essentials of this pattern  as  labor  surplus, landowning  peasants, and autonomous enterprises,with more focus on the  iss
ue of land ownership  by peasants in China.
  ʡйģʽ/ѧ/г/ũ
    china's  economic  patterns/research  methodology/Socialistmarket economy/land ownership system
    
    ͼţF041.2  ױʶ룺A  ±ţ10090150 200002000309
            һ±˵
    ھĵ֮ǰҪ˵һ±ĵı⡣Ӧ˵Ǳеġĸ󡱡1978꿪ʼйøĸѾ
߹20ͷⳡøĸйִʷһҪǲʷǸĸʷֹһ
ĿǰйøĸǴΪʵĳһضĿ԰յĿꡢڶչľҵ䶯ĽǶ⣬ôΪֹ
Ѿ˲ܶʱйøĸнʱˣ̸ܿۡĸ󡱵״̬һ棬оһҪ
ҪһﱾݺͷʽҲҪǱĿĺͽΪһϣﲻʵĳһĿĻĳ
һֶζѡ۸ĸĿĻǸĸĽǵָ򣬶ǸĸֻγɵƶȡģʽĸĿġָ
ⳡĸͼʵֵġĸ󡱵ƶȣĸζšĸ󡱳ֵ״̬ԣĵıˡĸ
йģʽʵϣйʼĸ20ǹйĸĿģʽĴо˵ĺϣڶԡĸ󡱵о
ΪĿָӦϣڸĸʵֵ״ԣԡĸ󡱵ойѧʵҴģֻ
һֱûʹñᷨˡ
    ԡĸоıҪԲڶԸĸﱾۣҲھѧ۽衣ӾѧǶȶйо
ҪйΪ鱳һоĳɹҪΪۣݵľ鱳гڵЧԣԽ˱θĸʱ
ȵЧԡעݹƣйȽ϶͵ƣԼҪ2020꣨׿Ԫ19979ҳζţ θĸԼ
20ꡣҪйصо߶ԡĸ󡱵й״̬򾭼ģʽĳֹ룬չԡĸ󡱵о
    ΣҪ˵Ǳıеġ롱͡ѧĸĿĺͽ͡ӸĸĿĵĽǶ
˵ĸ˵Ծ˰һͼΪʵԼﵽĳ֡ĸ󡱵״̬ĿչĻӸĸĽǶ
˵ĸ״̬״̬һּҵʽ͹̣˵ͼйأֲȫȡ˵ͼĹ̡Ϊ״̬
عͬġ˵ͼĿģֻһأһʮҪءĿͼﵽĶ
ʵʳֵĶˣ˵Ŀ۵ģǿ͹۵ġĿĸطӳ˵ܶԣطӳ
͹۹ԡ
    ǣĿĻĿǶȶԡĸ󡱵оһ̶Ϸӳ˸ĸĿ͹ʵ͸ĸֵ״̬Ͼض
ͼоǶԼϣֵδͼʽĳҪģ˵ĻһָͬʱЩо
طӳ˶δ룬˵ɻӰʷĽ̺δͼʽԣĿĺĿоļֵӷ۵ĽǶ
۲죬˵Ըһֵ۳ԸĸĿġĿоǶġĸ״̬о
ойڸĸܾеľģʽǱıָġ롱ľģʽ
    ӽĽǶȶԡĸ󡱵оӵǸĸ󡰿ܡֵ״̬ǸĸӦֵ״̬ĸֵܳ״̬
ȡأ˸Լԡĸ󡱵룬ԼڸĸбֳΪԼĸĸĿĶȡĸĸ﷽
ߣɷżҪáоĸʱ뿼ǵҪ֮һͬʱĸĽǰڵĶ
ֶعͬõĲ﷢չĳֱȻơ˵ԸĸоǶԵЩĿ͹
ɵоӷ۵ĽǶȿоȻܴضĶδԸܴӸĸĿӦڸĸз
ҪõĸӾúʵоЩʵĲԸ˵־ΪתƵġԸĸ״
žõĻơойڸĸܾеľģʽǡѧľģʽ
    ٴοĸоᷨıҪԣΪĸĿоֻ˸ĸоһ֣Ըĸо
ǸҪĻҲٹͬҪĲ֡ҪעģǹڸĸﾭģʽĿ꣬ܺ͸ĸĽв
ҲпĸʵǺϡͬԡĸ󡱵ĿѧоóĽۣȻǻϸĸʵġȷ
ģʽΪ۵Ĳ𣬲ܱ֤۵Ĳǽ۵ȷԡѧооԲǰһо
ˣоȻԸĸ״Լ룬о߼ȷ֮оУܱˡҲĸţҲ˵
ԸָĸĿ룬оԵġҪооеĿ͹ԡǣʹÿо߶һ㣬
ʹõо߲ͬ۲ĽǶȲͬĲβͬյϲͬóĸĸ󾭼ģʽҲвͬ
һЩģʽȫĸʵྶͥѧڲͬ۵㲻ͬģʽľзչġ֤αжһֹ۵Ƿڿѧ
ϡȷı׼֮һδûг֡Ե֤αܵʱ򣬿ѧогֵĲͬ۵㣬֤αĹ۵㣬
ڿѧУɿѧļ˵֮һ˵ǻڿѧΧڡ෴һĿĺоóδĿģʽ
Ҳܺͺʵһ£Ȼǻֵġ͡оˣоۺʵıȽϽǶȹ۲죬۵ġ
ĺ͡ѧģʽֵġԣǽӷ۵ĽǶǡ
    ĵַ˼崴ʼ˹ڿͿѧһ֮ݶ˹˵
Ϳѧٴ档һߵ۱ǲģ⡰Ǻ͵ʱʱ״
Ľ׼״Ӧġ˹18801972409 ҳڶߵ˼뷽Ψġ˵
ǾԺıֻ֣ҪֳԼ硱ͬϣ416ҳˣ ߸
ԼƳһƵƶȡͬϣ423ҳǣ˹ָҪһ
ĸƵƶȣͨʱͨʾǿᡣµƶһʼעҪΪģ
ƶ꾡ܣҪ봿Ļ롱ͬϣ409ҳ෴ѧ彨Ψʷ֮ϣǵ
˵ǵʶѧ񣬡һƵƶȣоȻ׼޲׼
׼ע໥ʷľõḶ́ɴɵľ״ҳͻֶΡЩֶβӦͷ
ӦͨͷԴֳʵзֳͬϣ423425ҳȻǴͷδģʽ
ۣǴӿ͹۵ʷ;ùֹ̳ɲֿۣͿѧı׼֮һİѶ˹
˵˼뷽ϵΨΨ𣬳֮Ϊ𣬲Ψһظ𣬰ѶԸĸ󾭼ģʽоΪĺͿѧ
󲿷֡ע˼ѧͬʱĶͺͿѧо֣淶ѧʵ֤ѧֲͬߵ
ִѧѾԣMoeller1982878ҳ 19969856ҳȻʹռ򵥵Ĺ淶ʵ֤ѧֱ׼
˼ѧҲԿɼǹ淶ʵ֤ģ˶ھÿѧУϵش֤ܵͷǣ˼Ͷ
˹Ϊۣûܹ߱ھÿѧڡ
            ͸ĸģʽ
    Ϊ˽һ˵һĻ֣ʱٳоóĸĸ󾭼ģʽģʽֱκκܲ
ġξѧָ̡̳йƸĸĿģʽгơ˵Ҫг
ƣҪʹгҺ۵¶ԴԵãʹûѭֵɵҪӦϵı仯ͨ
۸ƺ;ƵĹܣԴõЧϺõĻȥҵѹͶʵʤ̭ӦгԸ־źŷӦ
ŵ㣬ٽļʱЭͬʱҲҪг棬ǿ͸ƹҶԾú۵ءҪ
չȫͳһгһгãݿ͹۹ɵҪúþߡ÷桢ƻָͱҪ
չ1995293ҳ
    һģʽٲµƻûн֮ǰ˵޷ʵȽ֮ǰ˵Ǵġʹ
ƽˣǿҲΪָһĿ꣬һ롣ĿǰθĸֵľģʽܴܿﲻһĿ
룬Ҫµġ۷Χĸĸȥ𲽵ؽӽ
    κĸĸľģʽһЩ֮Ϊгá1997102ҳӵҪǺ۷⣬ 
˲ȫԺͳֺ۾ơ߱ɸĸĿģʽ199422ҳĿģʽڣڱгƶ
еĻϣгĵڡģʽľǣͬϣ24ҳ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ݴˣͨɿصĺ۱ͻұȣܹʹܹϵΪӰгƱ仯ĲӶʹ
гƶ΢۾õṩõĵãҵ;ѡڹ񾭼øЧ淢չκ͵г
áĳ̶ֳϣڼеִڣѧΪķ;ڡĸйҲˡˣ
϶˵ĿģʽǴģΪˣһĿģʽѱɫʡʵϣκܽľѧУ1994
Ǽܱϳ͵гáص㣬Ҳܱϳйõص㡣
    ϵУǿԿ͵ľģʽĹͬ
    1.ǶǴǶйĸֵܳľģʽϣ
    2.Ƕûиʵ;ΪȻԵĿϣָ̽ĸľģʽ
    3.Ƕȱ֤αԡ
    Щ;ģʽйõķôܺޡ÷ȷĿָʵ;оͨ
淶Ӧʵָ֤ǹ淶ȷĿʵָ֤δﵽŻشﵽĿꡣǣʵ֤
ҪԼ񣬱߱ǰ᣺һ淶Ŀǿ԰ղ֤αľĿ꣬ڶеĻѾ
ʩӴ̼ʵĿĴݻѾʡǰ᲻ڵĻ÷ȾҪЩǰᡣΪˣ÷
ͱֱԺоԵض˵ľʵ
            ѧ͸ĸģʽһ̽
    Ŀѧ͵ĸĸ󾭼ģʽͨԸĸгֵҪҪơҪķóĸĸĿܻ߼
ǱȻĽⷽоĿǰ̽׶Ρʵ;״20ľøĸйõĳЩѾ¶
гõķѾȷгõĸѾγɡעݳʤѧߵойõг̶Ѿﵽ6019
98110ҳ͹״ѾʼʾҪƺҪˣѾпܲٸֱӵоʵ
ҪƺҪȻĿǰĸĸﻹûнйеľûڼеıθĸзҪı仯ԣĸ
ģʽȫȷˣʹǿѧ͵ĶԸĸģʽ֣̽ҲȫطδʵʡǣЩԼ
ľԣҲԴĿǰľʵУҳɻ󣬲ɴָ̽ĸֵܳľ״һ˵ҪѰҵĻ
ص㣺
    1 ԸĸֵܳκξľģʽشӰ죻
    2ЩѾڣ ĻʽܼеıθĸӰ죻Ҳ˵йһξøĸﻹᷢʲô
ЩԭǲġЩûгΣôеĸĸֻʹǳζǡ
    صйвпֵܷģһֺܷܶࡣ磬йˮƽһ󣬾ͷ
ص㡣һԵ󣬵ȲΪĸҲ޶йԸĸ󾭼ģʽѡҵ
ȣҲҪǲΪĸĸԵı仯ͬʱ̵ӰŸĸ󾭼ģʽľʽ
ǸȤо˵һΪϵĴ״̬ĸйģʽһ̶ϣĸ

    1µˮƽǴʣͶĴڣ
    2ũҵǼռָصũ
    3ҵԼľӪлľȨ
    4㹻άгõĻ
    ĸУǰѾڣҲܻΪĸĸ仯γɹСֻҪйĸĸΪֹ
ķϽУͽǿﵽΪйýзĳ̶ȡʵϣֻҪǿһ̶ȣ
ϣгƾͿξøĸͿɡһ˵ֻҪѾ÷չҪλãֻҪ
֮ľȱΪʵľôйгھתͷչŻãǿֱӹ
ãǱθĸԱ󡣻̬չһֿԣѧ͵ĸĸоܹԸĸйģʽһ
Ҫ̽֡
            ġũҵṹڴڵĿ
    оٵĸ֮Žܵϵǹͬйڱθĸʱֳܳһֻ״ֻ̬
Ҫȱκһ󣬸ĸֵܳľģʽͽǱһòĲطĸ󡣴ѧоǰ
ĿǰѾڵĻУһΪѧϣ1997˹1997ᣬ1998۲
漰Ǹĸйũṹȹ۲ԾģʽеӰ졣Ȼũص
ʹߣ粻Ϊϲ㽨ĹңũͽԼȫߡũĹʣͿǵƽͶʾ
ܽϡߡͬʱڵһǰ£ʹϵ䣬ũĹҲһũ뿪ũҵ
۲ҵͶʵȾнϴȨעŲӵѧߵо20
90ڣйͶг̶ȴﵽ60˵λùɶΪ58.47ʾɶΪ88.76ҵͶʾ
ɶΪ701998156ҳҵͨͶʱܵѹ͹ʡҵĹʣֲܵũĹʣ
1998ǱԾ͸ĸľģʽڹʵľʽ͹ʷõķʽóһĽۡĽۣȻ
ڶԸĸֵĽоĸĿ꣬ûһϵ෴ǵĸĸĿʲôǿܶѸıĽ
ԣ˵ֻҪйڸĸʵϸļƻãйĸĽڹʾ棬ܾͱȻˡйĿǰڼıθ
ȻҪʵмƻã෴ǴӼƻת䵽гõĻԣ˵ǰġ
    йũҵĿǰƶȣΪصļƺ͸ʹơǣƶйĸĸнȶش
    ĶԴ˵ĻشǣؼҲйøĸȫл߱ξøĸ֮󡣵ǣйũҵĹʾ
ʽƲصļơܹǰũҵһ׼ṹũҵֻͬʱΪռߺ͸ߵ
һũ׼һṹĳضʽ缯ơʵϣֻҪйũҵʵеũҵ׼߶׼ṹĵ
ƻƣֻҪʵųгļƻƶȣóĹʻƾͿڸĸľģʽЧ19
98
    棬ǿйũҵṹıĿԡ
    1.йũҵʵмƻá
    ڼƻ£ֱӹũ룬ȷũĹʣˣʹйũҵ߻ũɵļ壬
йʻҲЧΪȻܰũĹʹ涨ǵƽƷϣǣһֿԲΪ̬
ڶڼƻ£ũִŵҵͶũҵ涨Źʵľ
õķչѾʧȥá
    ԣйءĸ󡱵оݵһزٵǰǣйũҵйòʵмƻƶȡûǰᣬ
оû塣Ϊֹıθĸǡǡڴǰᡣ
    2.йũҵʵ׼ṹ
    ׼ṹ£ũ徭û߽Ϊߣʹߣũ࣬زƷΪũʺ͵
֡йũҵŴʣͶũ֮Ϊ˽̶ũҵͶгչļҾʹ½ˮ
ƽұֲ䣬ֱʣͶʧΪֹ£ʻƽã˵Ĺʾʽƽʧ
ȥЧ
    йũҵȡ׼ṹĿԣҲ΢Сǵǣ
    1 йʷϳڳֵƶڸͳεʱڣܸԸһ׼Сũƶȡ
    2й2050ظĸǰ ũҵڵԸũؿҲ͡עⷽ״ѧûγɹʶ
ʵϣһ2030ĵйءУ߾˹й½ط״ܴĹָ֣
СóĽ۽Ȼ෴Tschang19343134ҳһЩʱ״оɼͣģ1
9964857ҳе룬19972285ҳϵйǰʽ֣2050ظ
ǰй½ũռũ˿ڵıΪ33.13 ռռܸصıΪ30.94йũͳ198931ҳ 
ĳϰũΪԸũôǰϦԸũռũ˿ڵ13ص30ҡ
    32050 йظĸȫũ׼ṹʹܼй½ָ1949ǰ;ƶȣйũ
ҵ»ص׼ṹĿҲãʵϣڴ½ƶȵǰ1949ʧ̨ܵʡԺҲ̨ʡȫ
ũ׼ṹעһλǰȥ̨ʡרң2060ġ½۵ʢʱڣڡ
½֮󣬡ũӦʾΪ޵˽ƣũԷָиԸ֮ũСɹ׼
ũ֮أת⡱ţ19621982׼ĵй½ҲٿС
    4ڽ˽вƲַԭ£20 50й½ũظĸ⣬ôа޳
ĵع黹ԭ˵ĿԡȻʹ£ΪܵҲǣصԭ˽õʽĲòԭе
ءȨڸصũС
    5йĿǰԺҪչľøĸ ҲũҵõصȨöɸũ񣬶ôũȥءһ
ϼȫûпԡͬʱٵĿǰΪֹѧĹйũҵһĸĸ룬ƺûŰũҵ
ĸ׼ṹصƵġ
    3.йũҵʵйơ
    йĽһĸʵũҵõصĹƣҹʼմȫ幫־ôȻȫͨгũ
ṩأũҵʣͶڣʹũҵʽˮƽڱֲ䡣ͬʱһĵͬھϣ
ŻḺбϹȻһ״̬£һͨгʵֵ湤ʺݡ£г
ԳΪũõõĻֶΣʹصг۸Ҳ԰ũĹѹ͵ˮ׼ˣߡũҵ⣬
Խ
    4.йũҵʵԸũƶȡ
    йڼеıθĸȡũҵõصļƣ֮ũ˽ƣʵԸũƶȣô
ʻƽȻЧΪԸũƶ£ũȻܹȫũҵƷǵĹȻǵƽͶʾ
תƵҵľʱҵʲũҵʣȻһҪ
    ǣһȫԸũڣÿũӵһأôھУЩ˿ʧȥأЩ˿
ԶԶֵܸءǰ߽ҪӺظ֡ʣͶǰ£ǰߵĹʽ͵ˮƽµ
زƷáһʱԺԸũƶȿݱΪƵƶȡ˵Ըũƶȴһֲ
ƶȡǵһ㣬ԸũƶȵһֳأҲǲǡġ
    Ҳȫ룬ԸũƶȻתΪƶȣһڵĻ̡ڣһйũʹ
ƶȣֻҪԸũƶȻռĵλйʻƣҪܵĳ̶ֳȵЧģڶ
ԸũƶƶȵȻתҪʱ䣬ҲҪıθĸҪʱԼĸһضʱ䳤öࡣĻ
ôԸũƶȻȶǿĸĸ󾭼ģʽ˵Լٶ㹻ȶġ
    ΪеĸıйũҵṹѡУԼǷ񱣳нṹѡУĹͬã
ʹüеıθĸܷõغС1997113ҳйũһ׼ṹĿԼڡ 
ϣ˵ũǸߣһϲܽĸӰ졢ҷӰĸ
ģʽĻ󡣶йдоƶԸĸйģʽۡ
    ոڣ20000111
οס
    [1].йũҾоM.磬1996.
    [2]ʤ.йгоJ.йѧ1998ļ.
    [3]˹.ӿ뵽ѧķչM.й˼˹˹֣ࣩ.˼˹ѡ.
磬1972.376433.
    [4].19621982⸴½شM.ͬһ.ѡ̨֣19827295.
    [5].йóڷչһֿܻƣJ.о1998.
    [6].һũͶģͼйʣͶʵ֤оJ.йũ徭ã1997.
    [7]˹׵.йũҵͶ֮оJ.йũ۲죬1997.
    [8]  Moeller,    Hans.          Volkswirtschaftslehre [J].Handwoerterbuch  der Wirtschaftswissenschaften,1982(9).
    [9]ͣ.԰ʫģʽǰʶM.磬1996.
    [10]Σࣩ.ξѧ̳̣M. йѧ磬1995.
    [11]Tschang.Wen-Tsi.Die chinesische Pacht[ M]. Wuerzburg:Konrad Triltsch,1934.
    [12]˹̹.ʵ֤ѧM.׷򾭼ѧǵ䣬198719963.
    [13].ũҵʣͶĹƷʵ֤J.о1998.
    [14].йȨоM.йѧ磬1997.
    [15]κ.гۣͨM. йѧ磬19931997.
    [16]κܣࣩ.۾÷M.йѧ磬1994.
    [17]Ųӵ.йͶг̲ȣJ.øĸ뷢չ1998.
    [18]׿Ԫ.ĸ￪ҹоĻعչJ.о19976.
    
    
    
 
